Jump to content

axel

Members
  • Posts

    389
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by axel

  1. Not a bad idea after all. This would help isolate obnoxious individuals that are a nuisance to their surrounding environment. Provided their cave or rather "oubliette" (to stick to the Louis XIV context) is not internet-enabled, that is. I sent you a PM for the reason I wasn't supposed to post in the thread anymore as I had promised to. Otherwise I would have said it out in the open, without hesitation. I may be wrong but sometimes I have this impression that the way you act does not correspond to what you are in reality. Maybe is it that you don't like yourself. I do not dislike you.
  2. So your solution to this problem is taking the child out of the hands of his neglectful parents and giving him to gay "parents"? Is that the actual problem gay adoption is trying to address or will this problem remain after gays are granted this "right"? "Good parents being scarce, we should also look into gay "parents", who knows, we might find good ones there". Is that your argument for gays adopting children? PS: This is my last post in this sickening thread.
  3. I'd rather write Stormig a poem so she can brag about it on HyeForum.
  4. Only truth hurts and I am afraid you are well off target. Maybe I should fake anger in order to alleviate your pain but I regret this is beyond my abilities.
  5. What a laugh! You definitely have no clue about my background & personality. But I wouldn't want to disappoint you so here's one bible quote that complements my previous post "And why beholdest thou the mote that is in thy brother's eye, but considerest not the beam that is in thine own eye?" (Mat 7:3) L'hiver, c'est moi.
  6. About your "ideas", well nothing worth debating really. I am not trying to defeat your "arguments" with ad hominem attacks so your remark is pointless. You made one remark about the supposed irrelevance of mental-illness that was quite telling of your actual potential for reasoning. I picked it up, you chose to ignore it and concentrated on the observation that there is no room for understanding between the two of us (for the reasons I outlined above), a simple statement of fact. As to your scorning Solzhenitsyn with this irony-filled question, it is revealing of how mediocre an individual you are. And yes the latter is ad hominem, I couldn't care less.
  7. Strong argument. Extrapolate to pedophiles, rapists... No it is not if we are considering their ability to raise children. My remark on legalism was directed to you. I realize now it is quite beyond your comprehension as a libertarian saturated with enlightenment thought and "spirit".
  8. Irrelevant propaganda. Most psychiatrists study psychiatry in the hope of curing their own illness. Moreover, most psychologists/psychiatrists are gays themselves. Their deciding that homosexuality is not mental illness is a bit like the Vatican stating twenty centuries later that Jews bear no responsibility in Christ' passion.
  9. Legalistic arguments on such issues are sheer nonsense. Solzhenitsyn pointed out the inanity of "legalistic life" in his Harvard address. source :http://www.columbia.edu/cu/augustine/arch/...harvard1978.htm
  10. I don't see how being raised in an orphanage is actually worse than being raised by two mentally ill individuals.
  11. There is a somewhat related idea expressed in one of Tarkovsky's movie something in the vein of "shame will save humanity". The problem is that in order to feel ashamed, one has to have the notion of what honor is.
  12. axel

    Iraqi Abuse

    http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/politics/3701351.stm Too bad for iraqi civilians, they were hoping for "democracy". Now they learn "human rights" are geographically based in Europe. Nice try.
  13. axel

    Iraqi Abuse

    Well yes. But as Sip pointed out, this is what "freedom and democracy" is all about.
  14. axel

    Masonic Society

    I did not make a statement. I asked the question.
  15. axel

    Khent-the Fool

    What prompted me to ask the question is the heavy influence of enlightenment/masonic ideas Raffi was subject to as demonstrated by his novel "Khent". Modernism, secularism, chiliastic socialism, strong hostility towards christianity (obviously Raffi has an extremely superficial understanding of the latter)... all of these are indisputable characteristics of movements inspired (if not directed) by atheistic judaism. Instrumentalization of national identities by freemasonry is a common trend in the late nineteenth century as freemasonry attempts to break down the remaining empires through a divide & conquer strategy. Manipulation is commonplace, and Armenian intellectuals are not immune to it. That said, I will not interfere further in this thread I do not have much interest in this novel which, in my view, is just a piece of naive revolutionary propaganda. PS: You often attack christianism on the grounds that it was brought to us by the Jews. But you fail to see that most of the intellectuals you revere (Varoujan, Siamanto...) were under the spiritual influence of foreign philosophers such as Jean-Jacques Rousseau, himself, incidentally, of jewish ascent.
  16. axel

    Khent-the Fool

    Raffi the freemason?
  17. The fact that someone acts in a potentially reprehensible manner, morally speaking, is no justification for you to behave immorally. As far as the gender issue is concerned, well I don't think it is a gender issue but a rather a moral one. Women may be more often confronted with the kind of situation you described but in the end the choice to be made follows from the individual's moral nature rather than his/her gender. That said, I leave it to you to decide whether all women behave as whores, practically speaking. I am mainly concerned with theoretical issues.
  18. Glad to hear that from you :D You made my day. I usually do not like to quote Julius Evola for I do not share his overall outlook but I think he makes a few valid points in his "Revolt against the modern world". The text is not available on the web so I resort to quoting articles about the ideas he expresses in chapter 9 of the first part ("life and death of civilization"). http://pages.prodigy.net/aesir/ramw6.htm http://english.pravda.ru/columnists/2002/05/30/29541.html
  19. Dear TB, I understand your reasoning pretty well. Our positions are in fact closer than you may think. Note that, in my view, the core is not necessarily made of what you call "preservationists". While some degree of "preservationism" is needed (esp. at this point!) we do agree it is not a sufficient basis to serve as a definitive solution. A driving force or rather a common goal is necessary for energies to converge, in the long run. And Culture is a living entity, not a corpse to be mummified. Moreover, I do agree that the odds are against us, that is why I used the term "heroism" for heroism consists precisely in going against the odds. That said, the single thing that dominates this discussion is TAP's faith which is demonstrated by his lengthy selfless posts. And this is what I will retain from this thread. It would be wrong to discard this as simply belonging to the "emotional" sphere. There may be flaws in his actual argumentation, there may be some misconceptions... but these are of secondary importance. PS: The following text was written at the turn of the twentieth century. It is somehow related to this idea of "driving force" you mention. I figured it might be of interest to you. I give a litteral (and approximate) translation. "This kind of society may be recognized by this trait that one never mentions society. Truth, spirit, life, this is what we see and search - union is given as bonus - and the most certain sign of its decadence is that one feels and betrays the need for it : like those barbaric warriors who enchained themselves with one another when they felt their courage weakening. In every living and superior society, the social body appears dominated, vitalized, by a sovereign reality, a common goal where all the spirits and wills converge. Faith in this reality is its soul and place. Society endures and grows through faith only, while all commune with it and each subjects his logic, ego and immediate comfort to it. But this reality is not given or immediatley grasped. It is felt by the interior intuition and revealed through the works by which it is embodied and expressed, both of them imperfect means. The term of convergence is beyond any intuition or actual implementation. Faith is cognition, it is also confidence. Shall we say it is a mere social symbol, that there is nothing more to it than union itself, that the secret of this truth is its lie, of this reality, its void ? Such is the tenet of the new sociology which amounts to metaphysical nihilism. We will not discuss this here, maybe is it not possible. Idealism, from Kant to Durkheim, distinguishes between the social role of faith and its actual value, and pretends that it may keep the first while negating the other. I do not know whether the view is right but the calculation is definitely wrong. The day faith is convicted of illusion, whatever praise one may give to its social utility, it dies, and the social body, deprived of its sap, dries out on its soil. It may be a symbol but this symbol serves as a foundation for its reality. Take off the illusion of truth _ the reality of union disappears. It might be that the human spirit, in its greater work, edification of society, pursue a ghost: It is necessary that it ignore it. For if it is disabused, it will shy away from its effort, from life itself, as dying Don Quixotte."
  20. I was considering doing so. This last post of yours demonstrates beyond doubt that you are far too brilliant an intellectual for me to challenge. (I apologize to everyone for disrupting this thread with my childish comments and behaviour)
  21. I never said I was against mixed-marriages. But I am not particularly in favor of them either. You seem not to be able to cope with nuances. That said, there is no contradiction in being half-armenian and against mixed marriages. If you do see one, then you are the one deprived of the "most elementary logic". I am actually in a much better position to criticize the potential harm of mixed marriages than you are, aren't I? As for the second paragraph contradicting the first... ??? you mean "emotional" and "reason"? Well, one can "reason" under the empire of emotion... That is illustrated by your post being completely off-topic yet appearing to be structured. What knowledge? You equate me with some kind of naive rousseauist adventurer, "dashnakoid", admirative reader of Raffi's Khent... And then you bring in ASALA in the picture. That takes the cake! You're the one with narrow perspectives.
  22. I believe you do not understand what I say. In fact, you reason in terms of limited categories I happen to be totally foreign to. You picked one sentence and wrote three mostly irrelevant (and emotional) paragraphs. PS: I am not very good in english but I believe rationality and rationalism are two separate things.
  23. The numbers are somewhat misleading. Looking at the entire diaspora population is not a correct way of evaluating demographical dynamics and tendencies. One should only look at the reduced subset of self-conscious Armenians instead of considering all people of armenian descent. The former are the one who will sustain the armenian identity in the long run. While we may see decline and assimilation eating away "peripheral" armenians, there is no fatality for the core group not to grow. It is just a question of faith, and will. So I believe TAP is justified in most of his views (I have no time to elaborate on the minor points of disagreement we may have, the main one has already been pointed out by gurgen, actually). I prefer passionate faith and heroic willpower to dry rationalistic pessimism. The former is life, the latter is death. I believe in resurrection.
×
×
  • Create New...