Jump to content

Armenians Of Iran


Zartonk

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 64
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

Posted Images

let's see, they were invaders and occupiers just like anybody else. They forcefully moved the Armenian population of Caucusus to Iran. Again this was a FORCED move, thousands drowned in river Arax, these people were treated like cattle. All I am saying is that there are no angels amongst Armenian neighbors. If 1915 did not happen, I would somehow choose the Ottomans over the Safavids.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Compared to Turks and Arabs yes, only because they are absolutely unrelated to us.

 

Arabs? What did the Arabs do to us? If it had not been for the Arabs who protected fleeing Armenians, and who gave freedom to Armenians to establish communities, the Diaspora might not have been...

 

A assume that the aggressive ones in Iran were Azeri Turks.

Edited by Dave
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Arabs? What did the Arabs do to us? If it had not been for the Arabs who protected fleeing Armenians, and who gave freedom to Armenians to establish communities, the Diaspora might not have been...

 

A assume that the aggressive ones in Iran were Azeri Turks.

style_images/master/snapback.png

 

First of all I only said they are completely unrelated to us, being semites and all. Second of all if you want to talk about it in that context you're still wrong.

 

Arabs did far worse things than turks when they occupied Armenia. In general they damaged Armenia more than Turks. For severeal centuries Armenians were fihting for their very own survival against Arabs. Armenian culture was devastated. Hell if it wasn't for Arabs weakening and destroying the region the nomadic turks would have no chance and would have been defeated.

 

The fact that some Arab speaking people(I can't stress this enough) in Syria and Lebanon helped Armenians is irrelevant. Many Armenians were also sold as slaves by Arabs during the genocide. That famous picture of the tattooed girl is an Arab slave.

 

Arabs are very much like turks. Turks occupy Armenia, Anatolia, Thrace etc. Arabs occupy Syria, Lebanon, Egypt, so called "Iraq" etc.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

let's see, they were invaders and occupiers just like anybody else.

 

Big deal. So were we.

 

They forcefully moved the Armenian population of Caucusus to Iran. Again this was a FORCED move, thousands drowned in river Arax, these people were treated like cattle. All I am saying is that there are no angels amongst Armenian neighbors. If 1915 did not happen, I would somehow choose the Ottomans over the Safavids.

style_images/master/snapback.png

 

I agree. Blame the Arabs for destroying the glory of Persia. We're left with these towelheads today who have very little relation to ancient Iranians. Still geopolitically Iran is probably the number two ally of Armenia in the world today.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Artaxias,

 

true about Arabs, they destroyed Armenia REALLY BAD. I mean, we had to come up with a mythological figure of Sasuntsi David to get rid of the Arab yoke in our minds. That did not happen with Turks. I understand it's extremely hard for the Armenian ears to hear that Turks throughout centuries were not as bad as some of the other invaders, again 1915 changed things drastically.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Artaxias,

 

true about Arabs, they destroyed Armenia REALLY BAD. I mean, we had to come up with a mythological figure of Sasuntsi David to get rid of the Arab yoke in our minds. That did not happen with Turks. I understand it's extremely hard for the Armenian ears to hear that Turks throughout centuries were not as bad as some of the other invaders, again 1915 changed things drastically.

style_images/master/snapback.png

 

 

Ditto.

 

The epos existed long before granted with different names and locations but the devastation raised by the Arab invaders was so enormous that the legend was modified. It's a miracle that we were able to drive them out. Thank God for Theodore Rshtuni!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

First of all I only said they are completely unrelated to us, being semites and all. Second of all if you want to talk about it in that context you're still wrong.

 

A lot of Diasporan Armenians who come from Cilicia or around Urfa probably have some Assyrian (semitic) ancestry, but those who beleive in races call us Aryans (like Iranians or other Europeans).

 

Arabs did far worse things than turks when they occupied Armenia. In general they damaged Armenia more than Turks. For severeal centuries Armenians were fihting for their very own survival against Arabs. Armenian culture was devastated. Hell if it wasn't for Arabs weakening and destroying the region the nomadic turks would have no chance and would have been defeated.

 

That's how empires were. You expect them to distribute flowers to Armenians?

 

Byzantines weren't any different. They persecuted Armenians just because they weren't Orthodox Christians. Many Armenians were relocated to areas such as Sepastia, or even to distant places like Bulgaria. If they had not put their efforts into conquering Armenia in 1045, both Armenia and the Byzantine Empire would have had more power to confrount Turks.

 

 

When the Europeans were still in the Dark Ages, Arabs were the masters of the most flourishing culture in the world. They weren't simple nomads anymore. Cities like Baghdad had a population surpassing a million. Arts, science, and education were encouraged, etc. They were generally treating the Christians good, until the Crusades...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

A lot of Diasporan Armenians who come from Cilicia or around Urfa probably have some Assyrian (semitic) ancestry,

 

That makes them non-Armenians!

 

but those who beleive in races call us Aryans (like Iranians or other Europeans).

 

That's an old archaic term with way too many definitions;therefore, it's useless.

European within the continent and White overseas is preferable.

Iranians only speak the langauge today, a very istorted form. Culturally and racially they are very far from the ancient glorious Persians or Parthians.

 

That's how empires were. You expect them to distribute flowers to Armenians?

 

Your point being what? Turks didn't distribute flowers either. We're supposed to hail them for destroying our country and almost extinguishing our culture?

 

It was hardly an Empire in the sense of Roman, Assyrian or Parthian ones. Ummajads in Cordoba, Fatimids in Cairo and Abbasids in Bagdad warred for the Caliphate constantly.

 

Byzantines weren't any different. They persecuted Armenians just because they weren't Orthodox Christians.

 

A large number of those so-called "Byzantines"(they called themselves Roman-Romanoi) were Armenians, the Empire was ruled by Armenian Emperors for several centuries! A civil war within a family cannot be compared to a foreign invasion by totally alien cultures and races.

 

Many Armenians were relocated to areas such as Sepastia, or even to distant places like Bulgaria. If they had not put their efforts into conquering Armenia in 1045, both Armenia and the Byzantine Empire would have had more power to confrount Turks.

 

Most of the chaos was caused by Arabs. The country was broken up into feudal states that were constantly fighting eachother as well as the Graeco-Armenian Roman Empire. The firestarter were the savage Arabs.

 

 

When the Europeans were still in the Dark Ages, Arabs were the masters of the most flourishing culture in the world.

 

Hogwash. Arabs never came up with anything on their own. Their "culture" was stolen through various invasions from actual civilizations, including Europeans.

Most of their "scientists" merely translated books from Greek, Latin, Syriac, Armenian etc. They got the numbers from Indians etc.

 

 

They weren't simple nomads anymore. Cities like Baghdad had a population surpassing a million. Arts, science, and education were encouraged, etc. They were generally treating the Christians good, until the Crusades...

style_images/master/snapback.png

 

It's irrelevant how they were treating Christians on Christian land. They had no right to be there in the first place. The Crusades were a retaliatory response to Arab and Turkic expansionism.

 

To further debunk your misleading statements, a dhimmi could be slaughtered on the spot by a Muslim, the tax on dhimmitude could often be onerous, and Muslims were often simply disregarding the the Qu'ran and the Hadith and would abuse the Christians in their midst. The dhimmi-system was a system of extreme suppresion of all non-moslims. Worse--dhimmitude was supposed to END if one opted to convert to Islam; since dhimmi were virtually slaves to their Muslim conquerors, conversion to Islam was often made illegal.

 

Robert Spencer has made a valiant effort to demonstrate that Islam, from it's outset, was brutal and expansionist, notwithstanding the occasional virtuous Saladin (who was a Kurd) or a similar warrior. Western civilization did indeed face a relentless enemy in Islam, and the Crusades--albeit often vicious in their own right--were indeed a defensive war and not merely a 'distraction' from other matters. I heartily commend Spencer's books to you for further discussion of this matter.

 

Unfortunately the Crusaders became too fixated on the Holy Land. The Popes might have to take the blame for this improper focus. The focus should have been against the Turks, so as to save our lands.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

If you don't mind, where are you from and where were you raised?

 

 

That makes them non-Armenians!

That's an old archaic term with way too many definitions;therefore, it's useless.

European within the continent and White overseas is preferable.

Iranians only speak the langauge today, a very istorted form. Culturally and racially they are very far from the ancient glorious Persians or Parthians.

Your point being what? Turks didn't distribute flowers either. We're supposed to hail them for destroying our country and almost extinguishing our culture?

 

It was hardly an Empire in the sense of Roman, Assyrian or Parthian ones. Ummajads in Cordoba, Fatimids in Cairo and Abbasids in Bagdad warred for the Caliphate constantly.

A large number of those so-called "Byzantines"(they called themselves Roman-Romanoi) were Armenians, the Empire was ruled by Armenian Emperors for several centuries! A civil war within a family cannot be compared to a foreign invasion by totally alien cultures and races.

Most of the chaos was caused by Arabs. The country was broken up into feudal states that were constantly fighting eachother as well as the Graeco-Armenian Roman Empire. The firestarter were the savage Arabs.

Hogwash. Arabs never came up with anything on their own. Their "culture" was stolen through various invasions from actual civilizations, including Europeans.

Most of their "scientists" merely translated books from Greek, Latin, Syriac, Armenian etc. They got the numbers from Indians etc.

It's irrelevant how they were treating Christians on Christian land. They had no right to be there in the first place. The Crusades were a retaliatory response to Arab and Turkic expansionism.

 

To further debunk your misleading statements, a dhimmi could be slaughtered on the spot by a Muslim, the tax on dhimmitude could often be onerous, and Muslims were often simply disregarding the the Qu'ran and the Hadith and would abuse the Christians in their midst. The dhimmi-system was a system of extreme suppresion of all non-moslims. Worse--dhimmitude was supposed to END if one opted to convert to Islam; since dhimmi were virtually slaves to their Muslim conquerors, conversion to Islam was often made illegal.

 

Robert Spencer has made a valiant effort to demonstrate that Islam, from it's outset, was brutal and expansionist, notwithstanding the occasional virtuous Saladin (who was a Kurd) or a similar warrior. Western civilization did indeed face a relentless enemy in Islam, and the Crusades--albeit often vicious in their own right--were indeed a defensive war and not merely a 'distraction' from other matters. I heartily commend Spencer's books to you for further discussion of this matter.

 

Unfortunately the Crusaders became too fixated on the Holy Land. The Popes might have to take the blame for this improper focus. The focus should have been against the Turks, so as to save our lands.

style_images/master/snapback.png

Link to comment
Share on other sites

another good book is

 

The Sword of the Prophet: History, Theology, Impact on the World

by Srdja Trifkovic, Serge Trifkovic

 

 

 

musulmanutyune hetamnats ev vayreni kron e ev MANAVAND hayerin voch mi musulman asg voch mi lavutyun yerbek chi berel batsi kandukarutyunits, kani million der petka kotorvenk vor haskanank es hasarak gaghaphare.

Edited by kakachik77
Link to comment
Share on other sites

musulmanutyune hetamnats ev vayreni kron e ev MANAVAND hayerin voch mi musulman asg voch mi lavutyun yerbek chi berel batsi kandukarutyunits, kani million der petka kotorvenk vor haskanank es hasarak gaghaphare.

style_images/master/snapback.png

 

Kakachik jan, isk inch eq arajarkum anel? Hayastann teghapokhel urish mayrtsamaq? Te bnajnjel bolor harevan petutyunnere?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hey nice map! (But its still a far far way away)

 

Anyway, the bottom line is that the only time Armenia "had it good" in any way or form was when it was free of anybody's yoke. Im not saying under Rome or Russia culture didn't prosper, but it also became less and less our own.

 

There is really no such thing as a helpful and beneficial invader and occupier.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

de lav etqan dajan chi kareli Artaxias, jamanakner@ urish en sxal khaskanan, hamel ov haves uni mi 300-500 million musulman morti aper, mexkenq che axr :)

 

ha chmoranam hartsnel vor, ba Hamshetsi musulman Hayerin inch es voroshel anell? drants elenq mortum?

 

ehhhhh lats u tsitsaxs xarnvele irar.....hima estex en asel

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...

×
×
  • Create New...