Jump to content

sen_Vahan

Members
  • Posts

    439
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by sen_Vahan

  1. Arpa jan, Here we face the problem of linguistics. As you said (and I agree with)"The reason why while we lost the roots of many of our native words and terms and we had to eventually look in the laguages of our neighbors. One of the reasons when we read about the roots of our words we often go the Persian and Pahlavi, who may have borrowed them from us originally." When we open Acharyan's famous dictionary we see that a lot of Armenian words have (according to Acharyan) Persian, Greek, Turkish origin.But mainly Persian. So,it really becomes hard to define who borrowed we or Persians. Probably all we have today was a result of long-term cultural exchange(in both directions). Pavel Florenski showed that the word "anun"(name) has almost the same form in many old languages - Armenian, Persian, Arabic, Aramean, Dichar,...(anun, anuan,anum,...) Well, I think it is possible to find the origin but that's really a hard stuff. But what is interesting is that we meet the "ar" or "ara" mostly in Armenian and Persian. Another thing is that (as far as I know)Aramazd and Ahuramazda have different "theologies". I think that's something that one should pay attention to. Arpa, that was very informative and interesting to read! Shnorhakalutyun, huys unem, der ays teman ksharunakenk: Vahan
  2. Rozanov once said:"Ya vsegda slushal,nabludal,molchal i beskonechno dumal.Molchal i dumal." That was his style of responding to ideas - not telling anything but just keeping thinking. Poeple however are different, some just analyze others in addition respond strongly. Everything is valuable. "V spore rogdaetsya istina" Vahan
  3. sen_Vahan

    Ashtanak

    Hey guys, Actually, Biblical motives were widespread in all the Christian world.(One can meet them in architecture as well as in other arts) For example, if you take the pictures of Van's Church you will see a lot epizodes presented from Bible - Adam and Eva, Apostoles,... Of course, David's star is one of them and may be found also in/on Ortodox and Catholic Churches. Bayz ays depk@ mikich urish e: Inch vor mek@ berel drel e momakal@, ev harz e zagum, te inchu(@st Movsesi asaz hodvazi)? Vahan
  4. sen_Vahan

    Ashtanak

    Movses jan, what was the point in that article - why the Jewish symbol is on Sevak's Grave or whether or not that stuff is Jewish? These are 2 different questions might be asked. It seems to me that what was on the Grave was Jewish. Vahan
  5. Critics may be pretty different. Agayan and Raffi were always critisizing each other like enemies. Maybe it is not my business but in my opinion Twilight Bark is very intellectual critic.It is interesting for me to read Ara as well as T.B.'s ideas about Ara's thoughts. T.B., critisizm as you know is the best inspiration source for the writer as well as for the philosopher. My respect, Vahan
  6. sen_Vahan

    Ashtanak

    Arpa, Do you know something about Aramazd and Ahuramazd origins? I thought Aramazd's origin was Persian. Do you know some specific books or investigations about that? Vahan
  7. To highflyer/ That's right.But it is also important how these people think of themselves. Don't you think so? Vahan
  8. sen_Vahan

    Ashtanak

    Arpa jan, I guess I know what you mean.But on the other hand Christian Greek continuaton was Buzantium - with the richest Christian heritage. In Russia, for example, Greece is mainly associated with Buzantium, e.g. with Christianity. Roman Catholic Culture also prospered much. Almost all the artists of Renneisance payed attention to Bible and Evangelion, Christ. And for the literature Christianity was the source of inspiration. As for Armenians, Vardavar is a hetanos holiday,for instance. And there are some celebrated among people but not considered as national holidays. Another thing is that Armenia was always a province."Oskolok Vizantii". Vahan
  9. Dear Ara Baliozian, If it was not a joke then what a Jew does when he wants to become a King? Or a philosopher? Comparing Jews and Armenians in that sense doesn't seem to be reasonable - Armenians is a nation, Jews a superethnos(see the differences by Gumilev L.N.). It is hard to define who is the Jew today. If a Russian Jew wants to become a Flamenko dancer he/she will look like.... He/she can be a opera singer because of some Russian origin. Oh, some people in this page again will think I am making differences between peoples. But what can you do, they ARE different. Thank you, Vahan
  10. sen_Vahan

    Ashtanak

    Arpa jan, I am absolutely sure you know that Vahakn, Astgik, Anahit also had their "ancestors" in Greek and Persian Culture although they were created by Armenians. So, it is hard to say that we just threw our traditional Gods and took one from Christianity. 1700 years passed and now Armenians are old Christians - traditions are always changing, what can one do? Persian people also forgot their Achuramazd,their Avesta; Greeks forgot about Dionisius,Zevs,...; Christianty won the world, at least the part of the world despite the fact that modern people are(as one Russian auther said) "Neandertal'zi Duxa". Maybe some day a new religion will come... These candle holders were used in Christian world (especially Eastern), but in that case of Sevak I guess Movses' question is reasonable. But should we worry about that? Vahan
  11. Avetik Isahakyan@, karzem. Vahan
  12. sen_Vahan

    Paruyr Sevak

    Well, Movses jan, I think if it was not Sevak's Grave but of some common guy, nobody would pay attention.Lets not consider Sevak as a Saint, he was a human being and that's it. If it is allowed to bring things to the Graves then why cannot his girlfriend bring that Jewish Symbol? Armenians in Armenia were always tolerant to other people, so why not to continue that now? Vahan Hazar ut haryur vatsun in@ tvin, Hayoz ayginern inch ptug tvin, Hayoz arterum inch berk er hasel, Dgvar e asel: Sakayn ayd tvin Mayr Hayastani argand@ egav srboren begun, Mi manuk znvez Lorva dsegum, Na heto piti darna patani, ev eritasard,ev ayr imastun, Anbagt Maroin lazov spani, Mer harachank@ haszni astzun: Sakayn nuyn tvin, Loruz shat heru, Anatolui havar horkerum, Mek urish manuk lus ashcharh ekav,....
  13. sen_Vahan

    Paruyr Sevak

    The white line on the picture I guess is a deffect.
  14. sen_Vahan

    Paruyr Sevak

    the Jewish symbol. I have not seen that before. That's what you mean? Not abnormal but pretty strange.
  15. my uncle's best friend in Russia is Turkish.Actually, it is strange for me to hear or read that Armenians consider Turks to be killers. As for me, that is something not real. Armenians like Turkish music,the kitchen,....Moreover, Armenians in Russia work a lot with Azeri people in commerce, business. Armenia needs good relations with Turkey, but the problem of Genocide should also be solved anyhow. The problem is not only in Armenians. Vahan
  16. Dear highflyer, Do all Armenians outside Armenina know their own language (read,write,speak)? Maybe 50 % know or 30 % ? So, it turns out not to be so simple as you think to survive. As Russians say: "Pobegdaet seredina i posredstvennost'." (about your model Armenians) Vahan
  17. Dear highflyer, you say that Armenians teach their children to think in categories like "otar". Do you know any other way to survive out of homeland? Second, people are different, they DO belong to different categories, and so do the nations. One of the nations that think suffered much from inhumanity, in fact, think in categories such as "We are the chosen nation, we are the best of the best". I don't mean Armenians, don't worry. Vahan
  18. Dear Ara Baliozian, I think you are very important for today's Armenian youth. In my opinion,it is sometimes better to read a new writer that a well known old one. So, your ideas are more fresh than those of Hakob Paronyan.And I would like to thank you, Vahan
  19. Eeeeeehhh,nobody wants to talk about Parajanov. But his films are so full with love - "Ashik Kerib", "Teni zabitich predkov"..... Vahan
  20. Dear Ara Baliozian, Don't you think that "dreaming about better days" is too trivial? No wars means too many people on the Earth.How can you imagine that?Wild people fight wildly, civilized ones - in a civilized manner, without any jatagans, knifes, just by bombing... Maybe you are dreaming about friendship between Armenians and Turks?If you think we are not ready for that,then I want to ask you whether you know about Turks.Do they want that? Vahan ------------------------------------------- Despite the fact that Armenians face the problem of assimilation, they still remain very poor. Who are the Europeans today? Overall peace in the world will even increase the assimilation.
  21. Harut, So, is that all right that people take different folk and represent it as Armenian? The propblem is that Armenians themselves do that and loooots of other compatriots listen to that mixture.I will not be surprised if I some day an Armenian listening to Turkish will say:"Hey, this is cheating!!! They took our music!" Vahan
  22. The basis of RABIZ - so respected among Armenians-is mainly Turkish music(and sometimes Iranian). That's interesting why Armenians do not like Turks? I respect German music, Russian, Georgian,..., so, I respect these nations too. As it is usually said the music is the spirit of people. So, Armenians like that Turkish spirit but do not like Turkish people. That's strange... Vahan
  23. Dear Twilight Bark, Actually, Armeninans do not show any fundamental superiority but the thing is that almost every Armenian seems to be "Napoleon of his culture".At the same time knowing only a little bit about own history, culture in the best case. In the worst case he/she does not know even the language! Armenians brag too much about their old culture but ,for example, in Moscow (!!!), where you can find lots of Armenians, one cannot find a place to learn the language.Many children born each year in Russia,for example, but they go to Russian schools and don't learn how to read and write in native language. So, what is that? I would call it simply assimilation. The same story in many other countries.That's a typical tribalism. Critisizing our people and country does not mean something negative.I would say the very critisizing is the way for the progress. Vahan
  24. Dear Ara Baliozian, You say:"I am all for peace,coexistence, and cooperation with our enemies.I don't see blockade and the occasional massacre (whether we are the victims or vicrimizers makes no difference)as a desirable,or even viable,option" Why then you call them "enemies" if you want to live in peace with them? I also think that "some day,if Armenians,Turks,and Azeris step forward and identify themselves as supporters of peace...we may be surprised to discover that they are - and they have always been - in the majority". But if a serious problem arise between these peace supporters (for example, territories) it will again turn out that all of them are old enemies. Doesn't the history show that? Maybe the problem is that "war is the alfa and omega of life"? Vahan -------------------------------------------- ONE SAD TRUTH: WE REMAIN HOPELESSLY DIVIDED AND FRAGMENTED TODAY BECAUSE WE BEHAVE NOT AS A NATION BUT AS A COLLECTION OF TRIBES./by Ara Baliozian
  25. Dear Ara Baliozian, I agree that armenians brag too much about being the first Christians. An armenian:"We are the first Christians!" French, Russian or any other representative:"Oooooooo! That's great!" People no matter to which nation they belong to react very emotionally to such kind of things, that's why I guess armenians like repearting that. For example, an armenian:"Erevan is older than Roma!" The other representative:"Wow, it is so old!!" I think all the nations like exaggerating. I started reading your books and I realize that I do not agree with many things you are saying although I red just a little bit. I want to ask you questions and I can do that either in this topic or I can open a new one and ask my questions there. Whichever is more convenient for you. My first question is: Why I have NEVER heard about Ara Baliozian? I grew up in Armenia. Vahan
×
×
  • Create New...