Boghos
Members-
Posts
1,746 -
Joined
-
Last visited
-
Days Won
4
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Events
Gallery
Everything posted by Boghos
-
Hello Anka, I am sometimes surprised by how Armenians cannot face the obvious and sometime hard reality that surrounds them. It is not just Armenians in the diaspora that are more caricaturesque Armenians, even half-Armenians when their nationalistic feeling "blossom" they tend to be even more chauvinistic than pure bloods. Of course that it is not an Armenian only phenomenon, as most aren´t in any case. What seems to be even more diffcult for many is to accept what reality is and believe that in such a world it is possible to live happily.
-
Some people have a certain difficulty in comprehending what i am saying: Simply that over time it is diffcult to maintain something that in any case is not easy to define. In muslim countries or in places here inter-marriage is not accepted by tradition this process takes longer. Even in Lebanon there are several Arab Christian-Armenian couples, same thing for less cosmopolitan Syria, in a smaller scale. Old Armenian-Russian families such as Orbelyan have very few Armenian speaking members, and the list goes on. I am not saying anything new. Just look at Armenian and world history.
-
I must say it is very amusing to see self-described hardcore nationalists accusing me of neglecting the fate of the Armenian people and other similarly ridiculous and childish "crimes agaisnt race". Of course I will not publish here my "Armenian" CV but I might eventually forward it to Armenian Pirate to see if I have a chance to be admitted in his compound... Meeting 3 Armenian nationalists seems to be a great achivement for one whereas the other brings the example of the Jews as proof rather than perhaps one of the very few exceptions at the most. Such is the fate of many of our communities in the diaspora, or at least of some of our institutions. To be ruled by such minded people that obviously have not been able to achieve success in the real world and hence create a make believe fanatsyland where they become the Knights of Armenianhood that go around with their banners held high proclaiming to be the saviours of the race. Nothing more quixotesque. These are the very people that through their ignorance and xenophobia have driven out many good people. It doesn´t take long for people that are independently minded and strong willed, as many Armenians are, to forsake "community" living for the more ventilated and open minded world of odars. As for the example of the Jews: I will just say that the Jews are not a race but essentially a religion which membership is gained mostly through matriarcal lines. But where are the Swedes that immigrated to the Midwest, the Italians, even the Koreans, the Japanese, they have to different degrees been assimilated into American society; there are other countless examples, the Germans in the Alsace just to point to another relatively recent and European example. It just happens to be like that, nothing that Mickey Mouse or Armenian Pirate or whomever can really do about it short of immigrating to Armenia.
-
Hello Armenian Pirate, Thanks for your kind and enlightened words. Just one final point: you seem to imply, by constantly coming back to this point, that there is a contradiction between maintaining an Armenian identity and "making money", that those that devote themselves to the Armenian cause in its widest sense do not have the time to become rich. Is that so ?
-
I am glad that you have met at least 3 nationalist Armenians. You also have won the debate. Thank God there are Armenians like you or else what would be of our people. Maybe you should post the address of your Armenian-only compound. I knew of Aryan Nations but had never heard of Armenian Nation. How does it work there ? What kind of test do you administer to see if someone is really Armenian ?
-
Hello Armenian Pirate, I do believe that Armenians outside the diaspora will disappear, it is just a matter of time. Common sense and history are on my side. That doesn´t mean that one cannot act in different ways trying to delay the inevitable, after all this is not a scientific experiment that can be controlled, measured, replicated. Armenian schools exist and are very important and strong in many places mostly because there are newcomers that have similar needs as the survivors of the AG. The important issue at hand is if there is really an Armenian way of living, an Armenian culture when it comes to existence in the diaspora. More often than not our so-called nationalists are often maladjusted in the society they chose to live in and hence the appeal to some sort of saintly or superior way of life, which just happens to be called "Armenian". Most Armenians that are serious about Armenia do not bother with this whole discussion about who is or who isn´t Armenian or what one should do or not do to be Armenian. They just live their lives, travel to Armenia, read books from and about Armenia, forums and so on. More often than not people rally behind a flag of an apparently beautiful cause but do not even bother to take out the trash of their own houses...
-
I am an optimist, I think Armenia will thrive. The Republic is still very young and things have looked rather grimmy in the past but have been improving noticeably even if "not enough". Armenians have a healthy tendency to self-deprecation but that sometimes verges on excessive pessimism and sometimes even a sort of melancholical somewhat destructive outlook. That doesn´t mean that Armenians will exist two, three or four centuries down the line, but it is perhaps an indication that excessive pessimism as to the continued existence of Armenians on earth is just that and is likely to be wrong in light of our historical trackrecord. If Armenians disappear from the face of the earth, which I most adamantly believe will simply not happen, what would be the problem ?
-
First of all, good bye Sev Mard and good luck. Armenian Pirate´s stand is similar to some of my deceased´s grandfather friends and are perfectly understandable were we in the 1950´s or earlier. Right after the Genocide Armenians scattered around were concerned with physical survival and the preservation of a sense of community. Armenian xenophobia or whatever you may choose to call it has existed from time immemorial, undergoing cycles of more or less miscigenation according to historical circumstances, so for example in early history when rape was a prevalent method of rewarding troops, the gene pool from Hayk started to get mixed up. Fast forwarding to this century we see places where there is very little mixed marriage, such as Syria and less so Iran, but in most oher places this is a non-issue, Armenians in the diaspora are condemned to disappear, as the Hungarians and Polish Armenians have, and as the French Armenians, one of the largest communities in the diaspora are moving very rapidly towards. Is that bad ? Well, it is as bad as the sun rising and setting everyday, it is inevitable. Armenians in the diaspora will have little bearing as to whether Armenians continue to exist on the face of the earth, for that one has to move to a country called the Republic of Armenia, as many have done. We can naturally try to help Armenia in many different ways, and we can also as we have done create a number of institutions that congregate Armenians in different ways. But that doesn´t even make a small dent in the inevitable assimilation that in five or six generations will have swept most. We should not confuse our current existence as "Armenians" in the diaspora, a relatively recent phenomenon, at least in the dimension that it exists, to the fairy tale of maintaining Armenianess outside the lands of Armenia proper. Some people feel threatened or saddened by these thoughts, which I would rather call reality. But the choices are very clearly in front of us and we can make them based on economic, religious, national, sexual or whatever interest. Last but not least I will not throw myself into a discussion of Monte´s role in Karabagh´s defense, suffices to say that every people needs a martyr and that Armenians from Armenia were by far the relevant actors in that war. But why not think of Kirk Kerkorian, who doesn´t speak a single word of Armenian (ok maybe he knows parev) and who hasn´t done a single thing to make sure that his kids remain Armenian, is he a traitor ?
-
Armenia and Georgia are just another example of so many other neighbouring countries not so friendly attitude towards each other. It is true that in this particular case rivalry and mutual dislike are probably at a higher level than most but it is still the same phenomenon. Maybe it has to do with size. Georgia is an interesting case: a country that had the "privilege" of being run by one of the most senior cabinet members in the SU, no serious contentions with neighbours, friendly with the US and the EU and still a major mess where parts of the country continue to be outside central goverment control, the economy is in shambles and crime has not come under control. Nothing to be envied. Armenia ousted its second class Shevardnadze, for right or wrong, earlier. But its second "choice" was probably not the best, but still installing any semblance of democracy is not an overnight process and in my book Armenia is not doing that badly. Armenia and Georgia will always be client states of Russia. Georgia has attempted to stray away from it with friendly relations with the US during Shevardnadze, but it is inevitable that sooner or later it will come back to where it really belongs. I think as a result of Putin´s ever strengthening position and some re-ordering of Russia´s economy (still a long way to go, for sure) the country will re-assert itslef in its traditional areas of influence. Furthermore a Russia-EU rapprochement of a higher degree should not be discounted. We are still watching the sad remnants of the disintegration of the SU and the different attempts to create states. While the real power, Russia, doesn´get its act together it is less likely that the periphery will see any real stability.
-
Congratulations.
-
Just came back from a two week vacation in Europe. We spent four nights in Venice where we visited the island of St Lazar where the Mekhitarists have their church, monastery, library and so on. There were Armenians from many places visiting, including from Armenia itself. Very good tour given by a very funny priest. Also passed by Moorat Raphaelyan and was saddened by the state of abandon...literally... In Rome we were walking along Via Giulia and my wife points to a small church, I look up and what do I see: armenian writing.
-
Dear Stormig, I think you are oversimplifying many issue. Just one of them: Europe, or most of it, believes that all the so called social benefits are an integral part of their lives and cannot possible be taken away. I am afraid that is the wrong way of looking at things and the price to pay as time goes by will simply be lower standards of living for everyone. As to diet, I think you have a point. In Europe people tend to have a healthier relationship with food than in America. But obesity is exploding everywhere, so it is not just quality.
-
Of course the Balian´s built mosques, palaces and so on. It was not out of compassion to the Ottomans, or Turks if you prefer. They had a business. Armenians were always second class citizens in the OE and often took ation in order to better fit into the upper echelons of the empire. Nothing new in that.
-
It is tough to take sides in the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. There is plenty of evidence to show that non-Jews have been always treated as second class citizens (even Armenians, remember the story of the small village that has been posted here somewhere, and also the Armenian quarter...). Dynamiting houses and making sure that crops do not get the necessary irrigation cannot be seen as friendly acts by Israel, among other things. However that is not to say that the Palestinian side is just a victim. Naturally many tend to side with the "weakest", the "oppressed" and so on. I also sympathize with the "needy" but often enough we are trapped in our own moral dilemmas and forget how complex and difficult certain situations are. I find very little use in looking at these issues if not for learning, taking sides is not a particularly interesting exercise. Time and again I have seen people "fighting" for the rain forest, for the giant ants of Papua-New Guinea, for the rights of horizontally challenged people and so on, if people were to focus on more "local" issues I am sure that the outcome would be a much better one.
-
From Don Quijote: "And the good gentleman was so far gone in his fantasy that neither the touch, the smell, nor anything else about the good damsel -- which would have made anyone but a muledriver vomit -- disillusioned him in the slightest." Volume 1, Chapter 16, pg. 89 Some of our own seem to have been one of the source of inspiration for Saavedra.
-
True but revisionism is for me the re-reading of history that is done for PC reasons. Revisionism is a simple term and if people use it in the exact opposite sense, so be it.
-
Just another thing: it is certainly a plus as a student not having to swallow all the PC garbage and revisionist history thrown at you in most schools.
-
The "enlightenment" brought about by mass schooling of children is regarded as a modernizing institution by many so-called liberals. Weber, the "thinker" that among other things proposed the inherent falacy that economics should be under the influence of politics and "not the other way around" is a proponent of these semi-dictatorial models. I have no doubt that schools in general train people rather than make them think, but I am not sure whether mass schooling is a necessary step in order to allow for home schooling. It might sound paradoxical but without some minimum standards even the Hayekian weakest may not fulfill their role adequately. It comes down to how much freedom is really desired, necessary and useful.
-
This week´s Economist has interesting articles about "home schooling". My major concern on this issue was whether social skills would be severely affected by the lack of a school environment. Apparently lack minded parents across the US have created support networks that make possible for labs, sports practice, school trips and the like.
-
Interesting discussion. What is not clear, among other things, is whether Hayek´s concept of human nature in the broadest sense leads necessarily to the conclusion that anarco-capitalism would be a better functionning system everyhwhere . I am familiar with Rothbard´s writings and quite sympathetic to many of his views but I have to agree with Axel that the "State against the individual" stand is often simplistic and taken to extremes. Rothbard wrote that to defend his viewpoint he would ally himself with whomever he saw fit and sound more extremist than he really was just because the "other side" was too strong not to be attacked that vehemently. Even Austrian economists accept that certain goods had to be provided by the state up to the point where there was enough capital in the hands of the private sector in order to replace it. It then it starts to becomes clear that the issue of whether anarco-capitalism is a better system is not unrelated to where societies are in the process of capital accumulation and/or capital markets development. Doesn´t it sound paradoxical that within the more succesful period of growth in the history of mankind that was brought about by Capitalism, the State also took on powers of a dimension far larger than ever before ? And where it went to extremes societies basicaly failed, disintegrated or were severely impoverished such as in the USSR ? For the USSR was never a socialist country given that this is a theoretical and pratical impossibility over any decent period of time. Running out of time. Sorry for just jolting without much elaboration.
-
Hello sevmard, I think an MBA is a necessity today in spite of the fact that: - the present value of this degree has been falling and in some cases it has even become negative (that is in the case that you stop working to study and thus have to compute the cost of missing wages and tuition, and add the additional that you make by having the degree), of course these are averages and may not apply to your case, if you can do it part-time I think it is a great degree to have. - you don´t necessarily learn much of interest when compared to a MA in History, or Poli Sci, Econ and so on. But as it has become a sort of "must have" to anyone contemplating a career in the corporate world it seems that it would be a wise choice to go for it, especially if it is company funded. As to the GMAT I also took it a long time ago but my wife took it recently and the sheer number of CD ROMs and manuals on it is astounding. There are also the courses and so on. I think it is mostly a matter of concentration. As I recall it it was a not much more difficult than SAT.
-
http://www.mond.at/opus.dei/opus.dei.uo.faq.html
-
Armenia following Georgia seems to be mostly wishful thinking...
-
Opus Dei is an interesting organization, if this adjective is the right one. There are several sites with testimonies by ex-members which might be enlightening if biased. Focus in recruiting is quality not quantity. Very pervasive in Latin America.
-
Armenia bidding for these contracts ? Which of the mob families would bid ? those that ran the gas scheme, the cement monopoly, customs Which ones ? Please move this to the humor section.
