Jump to content

Boghos

Members
  • Posts

    1,746
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    4

Everything posted by Boghos

  1. The Lebanese "diaspora" of 16 million is just a figment of imagination. Most of these people don´t know a word of Arabic, have never been to Lebanon. They carry a Lebanese surname and that´s about it, especially those that immigrated before WW2 to pla.es like Argentina, Brazil, Mexico and the US. Your example just helps proving my point.
  2. Boghos

    Stocks!

    Yes, and RIMM, MACE, MAMA...but I would be extremely careful, this is the second bubble in "story" stocks...if history is a good guide you´ll eventually be in for a nasty surprise.
  3. http://www.hayastan.com/entones.html
  4. In Iran I saw shops where you could rent a number of devices for self-flagellation in homage of Hussein. I think that these types of rituals are not familiar to Armenians, which of course doesn´t make it impossible for some to adopt. So, some do .
  5. Boghos

    Sharagan

    I am reserving a more detailed opinion for when the CD arrives, but I have to say that it sounded crisp but not with so much soul as you put it.
  6. Boghos

    Sharagan

    Thank you very much. I just listened to a few samples of her voice on Amazon. Incredibly crisp. I am ordering the CD, of course .
  7. Boghos

    Sharagan

    I have been listening to two different recordings, one by Anna Mailian and the other by Lucine Zakarian. Horzham and Tiramayr by Zakarian are extremely beautiful. Together with Gomidas it is interesting how from time to time they touch very deep feelings of sadness and happiness at the same time. I recommed Armenian Medieval Spiritual Music by Lucine Zakarian to everybody, as to Gomidas my opinion is that one should hear any and everything he has to "say".
  8. Hello Pirate, I sense so much anger in your words. Your caricaturesque nationalism is just an expression of that. There is no contradiction between being an intellectual and being an activist. Unless of course you believe that the way of a stormtrooper is the best way. Denying our intellectual heritage is just another expression of self-destruction. Your assertion that you have not insulted anybody directly or indirectly simply does not stand under the most flimsy scrutiny. But I have had it with your rather obtuse and obscure ways. I on the other hand will say that I ironized and made a series of sarcastic remarks, some less others more obvious. Every time you read my posts you may find a new one that you had not previously seen. Have fun.
  9. "Words of an intellectual will always be crushed under the heel of the couragous action taker." I only now noticed Pirate´s motto. Interesting. I wonder if the words of an intellectual would also be crushed under the heel (is that some S&M fantasy or stormtrooper delirium ?) of a coward action taker (of which many are known to exist) ? Good job Pirate, Armenia really needs people like you: cannon fodder.
  10. Boghos

    Atheism

    The issue is banalizing religion not whether Santa Claus or the Easter Bunny exist. I haven´t read most of the posts here but I happen to agree with your statement, joke or not, that we have very limited and imprecise knowledge of what exists around us. Is that proof that God exists ? Obviously not. But it at least should be enough to leave a doubt out there. Mind you not that I find it that relevant, as God can be defined in countless ways.
  11. Boghos

    Atheism

    If you concede that we as humans are very far from understanding what "reality" is and have very few and poor explanations for almost everything, wouldn´t that be a tacit acknowledgment that affirming that God doesn´t exist would amount to extreme arrogance ? As someone whom I don´t remember said: the issue is not if I believe in God, but if he believes in me.
  12. I think "volunteer army" means that soldiers are not compulsory drafted into military service. Ends up being one of the employment opportunities for "upper lower middle class" (H. Simpson´s definiton) minorities that instead of being paid low wages in services are willing to "fight for freedom".
  13. Exactly. It is not yet 100% but almost there. Please let me know if you are going.
  14. I think the correct way to put this is that we have mostly one religion. One national church but two catholicosates with the clear understanding that Etchmiadzin has primacy over Antelias. Unlike some believe, there have been two cathlicoi since the XV century, hence this is unrelated to the deep schism that appeared in the Armenian diaspora right after the AG and that has persisted in some form until these days. I think many are aware of the assassination of Archbishop Tourian in New York, 1933 over political issues. This happened inside a church just to show how daring some fanatics can be. It is widely regarded, even though I am not quite sure if this is correct or meaningful, as the key event in the so-called split. I think it is more appropriate to call it the hijacking of part of the church for political reasons. After this period it was very common to be called "garmir" (Red) by people from the splinter group even if you just minded your business, maintained your Armenian identity but otherwise refused to take part in violence and other fanatical acts.
  15. Of course, I should immediately apologize. How stupid of me...poor pozer...
  16. Hello dear Arpa, In certain places and with certain people you can offer them money and they will provide you with a service. Two words come to mind: "bornig", whose ethymology seems to have been discussed here somewhere and the other is the common "poz".
  17. Dashnakoids indeed. I am sorry my reference to the carpet weaving orphans was too cryptic. There is a certain type of carpet which shows Armenia as a lady weeping looking at all the Armenian provinces around her on fire. This is the lady that has to be made to smile.
  18. Dear TB, Thank you once again for your comments. There might be some small differences in the way we express our thoughts but in essence they are the same. I think another of our strengths as a people is that our nationalism does not arise from any feeling of superiority. It is true that once in a while it doesn´t appear to be so but these are the exceptions. Not the rule. Moreover, I am afraid that certain stereotypes of a demeaning nature have become widespread in the diaspora and that combined with the non-Baltification of post Soviet Armenia has led to an all time low in our morale. It has challenged the self esteem of the established diaspora and at the same time made life for the newcomers more difficult. The new diaspora, or new diasporas are a product of very different circumstances than the post Genocide one, but I would be very hard pressed to believe that there is an essential difference between all of these different elements. As you have very appropriately put an Armenian should not be defined on what he does but rather the contrary. Please correct me if I am wrong but I understood that as a belief that we have certain values that are usually not challenged, at least in not any meaningful way. I understood also that these are not just a moral code, it goes much beyond that. Reading your statement and commenting on it I am immediately asking myself if that doesn´t smell of chauvinism or some sense of superiority. It doesn´t if it is to be taken in a purely contemplative manner, it should just help reinforce what we carry for some reason. Hence (?) my viewpoint that by force we´ll never get there, but neither by the pen. What we need is that Armenia represented in the carpets woven by orphans in Aleppo to seduce people. I can´t tell you how, but I sense it will happen.
  19. It was not my experience nor my parents. It was quick and painless. Evidence is that it has even improved in the recent past.
  20. Most fascinating. Is a book version of your extensive wanderings in historical Armenia in the plans ?
  21. I think that there are a few characteristics that define us as a people. Among others: resilience, practicality and peacefulness. They are obviously interlinked. Perhaps this varies from person to person but at least my experience and that of many around me is that unlike many other peoples, we are not waiting for the Messiah. We rally around the feeling, the belief if you will, of Armenianess not based on an ethereal or unreachable being, or some thought of redemption. That might be one of the explanations for our peacefulness (which should not be confused with the instinct of self preservation, they go together as paradoxical as it may sound). In that sense Armenia will always be preserved in the diaspora but by people that might no longer call themselves Armenian, nor obviously speak the language etc. If we are orphans than we have always been orphans. But I don´t believe this to be the case. We are not orphans, we are just struggling in a battle of unknown consequences but that we´ll win in a way or another, as we always have. In much worse circumstances in the past. Preaching pessimism is a not unheard of Armenian habit, and many have made the mistake of reading a few of my words and accusing me of that or worse. Nothing is further from the truth...I am as much sure of the inevitability of the diaspora weakening position over time as I am of the potential that our own country offer. A short termist view would argue the opposite but would be no moe than a contradiction in terms. Finally since my verbal and philosophical ability is much below some posters here and I have the habit of finishing my posts not always very coherently: if you are planning to be in Bulgaria in July come and say hello to someone in the Brazil team, it will be most likely me =D .
  22. Hello Pirate, Armenians in Ethoipia, in any meaningful scale are a post Genocide phenomenon. The emperor at that time decided to give refuge to two hundred orphans if I recall it properly. After Haile Selassie was unseated by the Socialists Armenians started to leave the place and what you have left is a very small community, not exactly a thriving one. Same apllies to Sudan for example.
  23. Boghos

    Dual Citizenship

    This issue was discussed in the past with views similar to those that have been expressed here. My romantic point of view is that Armenian citizenship should be given automatically to any Armenian that survived AG in a special cerimony in every single country. Nice way to rally the respective families. ROA should be seen as caring for the fate of the country and the diaspora, this would be a simple and meaningful way of doing it, and of course very fair. The rest: citizenship but no voting rights unless established in Armenia.
  24. Dear TB, As usual your comments are straight to the point. My ideas come out much more clearly through your words. The only small divergence is when it comes to the old communities, I have, as mentioned before a special interest in those and they do arise a sort of melancholy in me. Hope you are well and as Azat said come by more often.
  25. Hello Pirate, I feel that you have a certain difficulty in comprehending simple texts. But given the fact that you seem to be a good boy, in spite of calling other people´s opinion garbage and making a number of ridiculous assumptions and deriving even more ridiculous conclusions from them, I will bother to answer you again. I write once again mostly for two reasons: I have met many people like you and I used to be what one could consider a hard core nationalist. I start by saying that there is a very different view from those that struggle to be Armenian and those that are Armenian. I am not much older than you, 10 years or so, but it has been enough time to allow for a good understanding of my ethnic identity. You see, one cannot be Armenian by force. As much as I believe that inevitably most of the diaspora will blend into their respective host countries, and that is supported by the most overwhelming historical evidence one can dream of and pure and simple common sense, I also believe that I am an Armenian and will inevitably be so until the end of my days. Something that I am not proud or ashamed of, but something that I feel very comfortable about and that I like. Just to give you a simple example: In the past I have cold called many Armenians in different parts of the world and the great majority has led to very pleasant moments, I could tell you many stories of this nature and others of great moments I experienced in what is defined an Armenian environment. Have no fear though, I no longer cold call Armenians anywhere in the world as I have passed the age where that would be deemed somewhat acceptable but I still try to discover the footprints that our people have left in many different places. I have been to most of the "obvious"communities, the only exception being the Little Armenian one in LA. So I am for example interested in the history of old Armenian communities that have disappeared or almost disappeared such as those that thrived in the British Empire in Asia and also the little known Armenian community of China. When I say that one can live a happy existence accepting the absolutely inescapable reality that the diaspora will disappear, I mean a happy existence as an Armenian. That much I hoped was obvious. So before you go around in your still adolescent ways accusing people of being fools and the like think twice or maybe even three times before you do that. Hopefully age and experience will help ypu understand what ethinicity and being Armenian is all about, for your own sake and not to save the Armenian diaspora from extinction, because that is as certain as my belief that Armenians will continue to exist for as long as there are human beings in this planet and that our Armenia will see much better days in the future.
×
×
  • Create New...