Jump to content

aurguplu

Members
  • Posts

    623
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by aurguplu

  1. dear thoth, i forgot to thank you for the beer offer. is it stout, by the way (i can't resist stout, especially guiness). take care,
  2. dear thoth, thanks. i agree with pretty much everything you say. just a few comments. 1. re postponing the armenian issues until after the iraq (kurdish) and cyprus issue. this is not an attempt at postponing the issue indefinitely (although i don't doubt for a moment that many establishment guys would jump at the opportunity to procrastinate it even further by using these as a pretext) but a realisation of facts and, in a sense, limitations of both sides. both of us being parties to a fairly recent and still unresloved conflict, we can see - as we just have - the top of our more capable representatives (i don't wanna sound presumptious but i am the only turk here) blow off in a rage. i think we have to focus on ag recognition and once this gets done (which is no mean thing) let it sink in, and then probe the ground again to see if it is ripe for a discussion of that sort of thing. i can understand that some countries are discussing these issues peacefully, and the examples of czechoslovakia and even in a sense russia (partly) is before us, but so is the example of former yugoslavia. unfortunately with the present state of one past conflict (ag) and one present conflict (nkr) far from solved, we are i am afraid more likely to end up in a yugoslavia-like picture than a czechoslovakia-like picture i am afraid. after all, the czechs and slovaks didn't have a past legacy as we do, and as the serbs, croats and bosnians had. i still have the example of europe in my mind, especially since i lived in two ethnically divided parts of it (trieste/italy and belgium) and visited another. given the past that we have, it is pretty far off as far as i can see to live "like brothers" again (if we ever did), though none of us can be predict the mutual attitudes of both nations once the ag is recognised and its criminal nature and our collective responsibility have sunk in with the turks. but we can live together. after all, the europeans who slaughtered one another in such numbers that you could build another europe with them in the first half of the 20th century - and twice -, started work on a common european state immediately after the war and created one in stages starting in 1954, just nine years after the war. they still have their mutual hatreds and prejudices - germans, who practically run the place, still avoid speaking german outside germany, and you still cannot get a reply in holland if you speak in german - but they manage to keep the whole thing together in peace because the pie that peace brings is greater than any that the pursuit of past conflicts can bring. still - the borders of europe are not perfect, at least some europeans think so. i lived in a half italian-half slovene village in italy for two years, and have seen how the italians and slovenes are barely able to disguise their mutual antipathy (and later on, in the army, translated nato reports on how nato had carried out undercover operations there to prevent any slavic uprising before it even began (in the 1950s and early 60s): they managed to do it without bloodshed, or so the report claimed). of course the italian/slovene case is different from ours in that the slovenes had voted to stay with italy for fear of communism in yugoslavia, but there is some parallel there in the cohabitation of two different peoples not particularly fond of eachother for quite some time. belgium is also a case in point, most belgians gleefully pointing out that french fries are the only things that keep the nation together, and they don't have that old a common history, either. another one is alsace, where the local german population still has "a broken heart" that they are on the "wrong" side of the border (but can of course not do a damn thing about it because of hitler's legacy). these are of course civilised states (at least now, after two world wars, you really don't have much of another choice), a feature which is a bit wanting in our part of the world. if we can ge the ag recognition sorted out, that will - i hope - pave the way for the development of an atmposphere where such things can be discussed. but we must be prepared: people can - and will - blow up, as i have (and very probably on both sides). i still think that the days of the idea of nation-states are numbered, and that's not at all a bad thing. in our part of the world, the concept of nation is stil based on ethnicity, and therefore keeps clashing with the realities of the "nations" created after the dissolution of the ottoman empire, and my country is not the only one where it does. either the borders are going to change or the states in them. i keep advocating the latter as it can be achieved with far less bloodshed and as far as i can see in my country, states can be made to change in that direction by a mixture of pressure, assistance, promises and threats (and patience). much can be achieved without actually resorting to border changes, and i think it worthwhile to explore that possibility. cheers,
  3. Please - get real. If you truly believe this then you understand nothing. I and most Armenians care nothing/think nothing about this or any land issue - Our hearts bleed for our people and what was done to them. This statement of yours is quite insensitive IMO - and combined with your constant referencing to this (non-issue) of land...and your seeming attempts to rationalize the genocide (Armenian gangs etc) leads me to wonder if it has been a waste of time with you - and I can only conclude aparently. I truly hope that this is not so - but it is clear that you have misundersttod MJs points entirely. And believe me - if I coveted your lands I would not be talking to you begging for them and such - I would be finding a way to take them. And if us Armenians really felt this way now - as a Turk I would be afraid.[/QB] thoth, i have this feeling it has only been you who really understood me throughout this conflict (and various others). i really wish what you say above is true and what i say is wrong. i also see that my blood has boiled a bit too much and resulted in the last string of postings, but i think here the problem has been mj's attitude (first push land claims and then deny them) that really blew the top off my head. i think that may be it is a bit too early for us to discuss the land claims, and after my blood cooled down (it took a while) i saw the sense in some of the last postings re various countries having land claims concerning one another. i do realise armenians have land claims, and from a purely "justice" point of view, i can see the moral ground to it (now that my blood is back to 36.6 degrees celsius). but i still think that it is too early to discuss these, as i can see that even someone like me who has no problems recognising the ag (even publicly over here) has his blood on fire when he hears about the land claims. we do not have a history of peaceful settlement to such problems, and we are surrounded by countries who don't, either. i think before seriously resuming that sort of discussion we have to wait for the iraq thing to clear up and the cyprus problem to be sorted out. i see the emergence of a kurdish state from there as a near-certainty and haven't got a clue as to what on earth turkey will do. i think what it does there and the results it gets will determine how it will approach the land claims issues elsewhere. i still think that instead of focusing on changing the borders, we have to focus the natures of the states in them. turkey at any rate has to change radically and has taken some serious steps (at least on paper) in that direction. i am not much of a friend of the concept of nation-state, and more and more people in turkey realise that you cannot have a country composed of at least two nations (turks and kurds) that has a state geared toward the "interests" of one at the expense of the other. this thought is gaining ground. let's see what it gets to. i am as axiously awaiting as everyone else. i am sorry for the tone of my last few postings, especially if i came out as if "justifying" genocide (i hate that charge). but mj's attitude really drew me mad. take care,
  4. mj, 1. good to see you own up to them. 2. 7) was referring to you and not to me. and if you read carefully you will see that it's you who calls himself an idiot and not me (i don't claim to call you an idiot by the way). you first make a case for land claims, and then call any person who does so an idiot. it's your own quotes. the aim of your side is clear as far as i can see. YOU WANT LAND, and the genocide is a side issue FOR YOU. the turkish hardliners that i had met kept reiterating this line and i kept refusing it. when i had joined this forum i was hoping to see it proven wrong. instead i see myself proven wrong. what a waste of time it has been.
  5. Not only don’t I remember asking lands from you, but I don’t believe you. Let me refresh your memory: Dear Ali, I sort of disagree with the premise of your resentment. There are two totally different issues as far as the Armeno-Turkish issues are concerned. One os the Genocide, and the other one is the land. They are not related to each other whatsoever. I think conditioning the issue of the recognition of the Genocide to the giving up of the land aspirations of Armenians is a faulty attempt if we are discussing the iisue as a principle, however as a matter of “realpolitk” I can understand it. The recognition and the condemnation of the Genocide has to be Turkey’s internal problem, first of all - for the sake of the self-cleansing of the Turkish society and the Turkish people from the hideous crime. Let’s assume for a moment that the fact of the recognition may imply certain undesirable for Turkey consequences. I think the people of Turkey would shine under a better light if they first recognize the fact of the Genocide and express their remorse, and than they fight against the consequences, whatever they may be. I think making the recognition and the condemnation contingent upon the elimination of the consequences in advance is equivalent of denial. It is also understandable that the statements originating from the Armenian side about Turks’ migration to Mongolia are under the best scenario manifestation of some pathological hysteria and lack of common sense judgment. I would also like to add that if from the Armenian side the aspirations tied to the Sevres treaty are just a testimony of incompetence by in large, and perhaps criminal misleading propaganda by some marginal Armenian “political” organizations, the dissipation of which in my view would be in Armenia’s best interests. From the Turkish side, however, these are testimony of well thought-out policy of denial and justification of the Genocide. I am claiming this not because I find deficit of emotions in my heart for what might’ve justifiably (with some exceptions) belonged to the Armenian nation, but because of the absence of an iota of reality. Even in 1919, right after Turkey’s acceptance of the Sevres Treaty, there has been zero reality for its implementation – there were no adequate numbers of Armenians left on the territory of what once could call Western part of historic Armenia, to enforce Armenian sovereignty on such territory. The prime-minister of the Republic of Armenia at the time has claimed that even if we bring the entire Armenian nation together, line up them on the proposed borders, we cannot even cover the border. In a way, the Sevres Treaty without te subsequent support of its enforcers (Europeans have abandoned us as always, and the American Senate has rejected an American Mandate to Armenia despite the request from the President Wilson), hasserved as a pretext for the subsequent slaughter of the remaining Armenians of Eastern Anatolia and Cilicia. While I don’t think that in the real political context history has much to do, and who has lived on which lands for what period of time is of much relevance, I fail to understand from the scientific point of view the basis of your statements on Armenians having invaded the whatever lands from somebody else. What is the basis of such argument? I also would like to bring to your attention that the era 1200-700 BC is considered to be the last stage of formation of the Armenian nation as a national entity. This doesn’t imply that prior to that Armenians have resided somewhere else, but the complicated national evolutionary processes have finally shaped out this nation in that era. The only party which can advance territorial claims to Turkey is the Republic of Armenia, which has not done it. I don’t see any real basis for anything associated with Sevres. Even if it would become a reality by some magic, there would be a lot of sober Aremenian which would oppose to it by any means available to them with the understanding that the enforcement of Sevres would be a disaster for Armenia. Let me make this claim more explicitly – the annexation of the territories of Western Armenia to the Republic of Armenia is not in Armenia’s interests, but in Armenia’s enemies’ interests. However, as an Armenian individual, I would like to stand up and claim that yes, the Republic of Armenia has, or better to say, should have (maybe not as a matter of fact but as a matter of legitimacy) territorial claims to the Republic of Turkey. This has nothing to do with the Genocide nor with Severs. I would also like to emphasize that I am speaking here according to my own logic, and I have no indications nor information that the Government of the Republic of Armenia indeed has a decision to pursue such claims. With all this, my claim doesn’t imply that I see a reality of materialization of the claims that I have emphasized above, but I have an expectations of the Turkish side recognizing the legitimacy of these claims and searching with us for acceptable to both sides solutions. I would also like to get your feedback as why shouldn’t we have territorial or other claims from the Republic of Turkey. Thanks for your understanding. Dear Ali, To be honest, I am a little puzzled at some of your statements, though understand some others. Your statements can be compared to the ones of a “big guy,” who has been caught with his hands in somebody else’ pocket, and then when being asked to take his hand off, or return what he has stolen, he says “if you can, come and take it.” As a matter of “realpolitiks” we all know that your description is what rules the reality. However, I wouldn’t feel proud of it and wouldn’t feel “macho” about it. I couldn’t quite follow your arguments about embassies, the UK, etc. Please elaborate. As far as Balkans, Greece, etc are concerned, and as far as your premise the way I suspect is concerned, I think Armenia has done its share, too. From al I gather from our Turkish friends in this forum is that they don’t teach in Turkish schools about Sardarabad, Bash Abaran, Karakilise – the only instance in the history when the Turkish army has gone against the Armenian Army. Therefore, I suspect your premise, unless I understand it incorrectly, is wrong. If you really are open for dialog, I think you should recognize the legitimacy of the Armenian claims, have them put on the table, and then try to address them. But what you are saying here sounds like “don’t even put them on the table, and I don’t even want to hear about it.” Therefore, it makes an impression that you are not longing neither to a dialog nor searching a solution. In few hours I have to leave out of town for the rest of the week. If I don’t hear from you by then, I will respond over the weekend. Dear Ali, If there is an impression that I think that we are going to advance territorial claims and Turkey is going to satisfy them, or there is any reality to expect satisfaction of such claims despite Turkey’s opposition, I have to say that it would be a very naïve impression. However, I don’t understand what means a “dialog,” if you are not even ready to discuss the existing issues. Pretty much what you are saying is what we have heard Turkey say at least since 1993. However, there are issues between us, which require some resolution, and unless we are ready to put all the issues on the table, the illusion of the dialog wouldn’t serve any other reason but PR, which I personally wouldn’t care about. As far as Karabagh is concerned, I would appreciate if you could explain me in greater details the crux of your position and statement. I have to leave in about an hour and a half, myself. So we can discuss it on the weekend, unless I find time during the week to snick into the forum, which is not much likely. I have to add that the return of the Armenians into Anatolia is a (using Edward Demian’s terminology) a primitive bluff from both sides, and it should be called off for the sake of not wasting precious time in our discussions. No Armenian is going to return to Anatolia even if by some crazy magic it becomes part of Armenia. Cheers, Martin There they are. These are from the thread "US ambassador says genocide rather a spiritual problem but not political" under Genocide. I have first quoted them in their entirety to avoid the accusation of quoting out of context, and give what I consider to be the relevant parts (land claims) below (the last line is from your last posting in this thread): There are two totally different issues as far as the Armeno-Turkish issues are concerned. One os the Genocide, and the other one is the land. However, as an Armenian individual, I would like to stand up and claim that yes, the Republic of Armenia has, or better to say, should have (maybe not as a matter of fact but as a matter of legitimacy) territorial claims to the Republic of Turkey. I would also like to get your feedback as why shouldn’t we have territorial or other claims from the Republic of Turkey. If you really are open for dialog, I think you should recognize the legitimacy of the Armenian claims, have them put on the table, and then try to address them. If there is an impression that I think that we are going to advance territorial claims and Turkey is going to satisfy them, or there is any reality to expect satisfaction of such claims despite Turkey’s opposition, I have to say that it would be a very naïve impression. However, I don’t understand what means a “dialog,” if you are not even ready to discuss the existing issues. However, there are issues between us, which require some resolution, and unless we are ready to put all the issues on the table, the illusion of the dialog wouldn’t serve any other reason but PR, which I personally wouldn’t care about. I have to add that the return of the Armenians into Anatolia is a (using Edward Demian’s terminology) a primitive bluff from both sides, and it should be called off for the sake of not wasting precious time in our discussions. No Armenian is going to return to Anatolia even if by some crazy magic it becomes part of Armenia. If you thing that everyone here is such an idiot that will ask lands from you, you are residing in a world of fantasies. I understand the following from the above and am open to corrections, preferably in the same format (1,2, 3, etc): 1. There are two issues, not one: AG and the land. 2. There are/should be Armenian land claims from Turkey and they are legitimate. 3. Even though they are there and are legitimate, Armenians recognise they are not realisable. 4. Even though they are not realisable, they should still be discussed. 5. There is no point in recognising the AG if no land is given with it. It's all or nothing. 6. Even if the lands are returned, no Armenian is ever going to live on them again. 7. You are an idiot. Answers to your questions will come in a separate posting. Cheers,
  6. Not only don’t I remember asking lands from you, but I don’t believe you. Let me refresh your memory: Dear Ali, I sort of disagree with the premise of your resentment. There are two totally different issues as far as the Armeno-Turkish issues are concerned. One os the Genocide, and the other one is the land. They are not related to each other whatsoever. I think conditioning the issue of the recognition of the Genocide to the giving up of the land aspirations of Armenians is a faulty attempt if we are discussing the iisue as a principle, however as a matter of “realpolitk” I can understand it. The recognition and the condemnation of the Genocide has to be Turkey’s internal problem, first of all - for the sake of the self-cleansing of the Turkish society and the Turkish people from the hideous crime. Let’s assume for a moment that the fact of the recognition may imply certain undesirable for Turkey consequences. I think the people of Turkey would shine under a better light if they first recognize the fact of the Genocide and express their remorse, and than they fight against the consequences, whatever they may be. I think making the recognition and the condemnation contingent upon the elimination of the consequences in advance is equivalent of denial. It is also understandable that the statements originating from the Armenian side about Turks’ migration to Mongolia are under the best scenario manifestation of some pathological hysteria and lack of common sense judgment. I would also like to add that if from the Armenian side the aspirations tied to the Sevres treaty are just a testimony of incompetence by in large, and perhaps criminal misleading propaganda by some marginal Armenian “political” organizations, the dissipation of which in my view would be in Armenia’s best interests. From the Turkish side, however, these are testimony of well thought-out policy of denial and justification of the Genocide. I am claiming this not because I find deficit of emotions in my heart for what might’ve justifiably (with some exceptions) belonged to the Armenian nation, but because of the absence of an iota of reality. Even in 1919, right after Turkey’s acceptance of the Sevres Treaty, there has been zero reality for its implementation – there were no adequate numbers of Armenians left on the territory of what once could call Western part of historic Armenia, to enforce Armenian sovereignty on such territory. The prime-minister of the Republic of Armenia at the time has claimed that even if we bring the entire Armenian nation together, line up them on the proposed borders, we cannot even cover the border. In a way, the Sevres Treaty without te subsequent support of its enforcers (Europeans have abandoned us as always, and the American Senate has rejected an American Mandate to Armenia despite the request from the President Wilson), hasserved as a pretext for the subsequent slaughter of the remaining Armenians of Eastern Anatolia and Cilicia. While I don’t think that in the real political context history has much to do, and who has lived on which lands for what period of time is of much relevance, I fail to understand from the scientific point of view the basis of your statements on Armenians having invaded the whatever lands from somebody else. What is the basis of such argument? I also would like to bring to your attention that the era 1200-700 BC is considered to be the last stage of formation of the Armenian nation as a national entity. This doesn’t imply that prior to that Armenians have resided somewhere else, but the complicated national evolutionary processes have finally shaped out this nation in that era. The only party which can advance territorial claims to Turkey is the Republic of Armenia, which has not done it. I don’t see any real basis for anything associated with Sevres. Even if it would become a reality by some magic, there would be a lot of sober Aremenian which would oppose to it by any means available to them with the understanding that the enforcement of Sevres would be a disaster for Armenia. Let me make this claim more explicitly – the annexation of the territories of Western Armenia to the Republic of Armenia is not in Armenia’s interests, but in Armenia’s enemies’ interests. However, as an Armenian individual, I would like to stand up and claim that yes, the Republic of Armenia has, or better to say, should have (maybe not as a matter of fact but as a matter of legitimacy) territorial claims to the Republic of Turkey. This has nothing to do with the Genocide nor with Severs. I would also like to emphasize that I am speaking here according to my own logic, and I have no indications nor information that the Government of the Republic of Armenia indeed has a decision to pursue such claims. With all this, my claim doesn’t imply that I see a reality of materialization of the claims that I have emphasized above, but I have an expectations of the Turkish side recognizing the legitimacy of these claims and searching with us for acceptable to both sides solutions. I would also like to get your feedback as why shouldn’t we have territorial or other claims from the Republic of Turkey. Thanks for your understanding. Dear Ali, To be honest, I am a little puzzled at some of your statements, though understand some others. Your statements can be compared to the ones of a “big guy,” who has been caught with his hands in somebody else’ pocket, and then when being asked to take his hand off, or return what he has stolen, he says “if you can, come and take it.” As a matter of “realpolitiks” we all know that your description is what rules the reality. However, I wouldn’t feel proud of it and wouldn’t feel “macho” about it. I couldn’t quite follow your arguments about embassies, the UK, etc. Please elaborate. As far as Balkans, Greece, etc are concerned, and as far as your premise the way I suspect is concerned, I think Armenia has done its share, too. From al I gather from our Turkish friends in this forum is that they don’t teach in Turkish schools about Sardarabad, Bash Abaran, Karakilise – the only instance in the history when the Turkish army has gone against the Armenian Army. Therefore, I suspect your premise, unless I understand it incorrectly, is wrong. If you really are open for dialog, I think you should recognize the legitimacy of the Armenian claims, have them put on the table, and then try to address them. But what you are saying here sounds like “don’t even put them on the table, and I don’t even want to hear about it.” Therefore, it makes an impression that you are not longing neither to a dialog nor searching a solution. In few hours I have to leave out of town for the rest of the week. If I don’t hear from you by then, I will respond over the weekend. Dear Ali, If there is an impression that I think that we are going to advance territorial claims and Turkey is going to satisfy them, or there is any reality to expect satisfaction of such claims despite Turkey’s opposition, I have to say that it would be a very naïve impression. However, I don’t understand what means a “dialog,” if you are not even ready to discuss the existing issues. Pretty much what you are saying is what we have heard Turkey say at least since 1993. However, there are issues between us, which require some resolution, and unless we are ready to put all the issues on the table, the illusion of the dialog wouldn’t serve any other reason but PR, which I personally wouldn’t care about. As far as Karabagh is concerned, I would appreciate if you could explain me in greater details the crux of your position and statement. I have to leave in about an hour and a half, myself. So we can discuss it on the weekend, unless I find time during the week to snick into the forum, which is not much likely. I have to add that the return of the Armenians into Anatolia is a (using Edward Demian’s terminology) a primitive bluff from both sides, and it should be called off for the sake of not wasting precious time in our discussions. No Armenian is going to return to Anatolia even if by some crazy magic it becomes part of Armenia. Cheers, Martin There they are. These are from the thread "US ambassador says genocide rather a spiritual problem but not political" under Genocide. I have first quoted them in their entirety to avoid the accusation of quoting out of context, and give what I consider to be the relevant parts (land claims) below (the last line is from your last posting in this thread): There are two totally different issues as far as the Armeno-Turkish issues are concerned. One os the Genocide, and the other one is the land. However, as an Armenian individual, I would like to stand up and claim that yes, the Republic of Armenia has, or better to say, should have (maybe not as a matter of fact but as a matter of legitimacy) territorial claims to the Republic of Turkey. I would also like to get your feedback as why shouldn’t we have territorial or other claims from the Republic of Turkey. If you really are open for dialog, I think you should recognize the legitimacy of the Armenian claims, have them put on the table, and then try to address them. If there is an impression that I think that we are going to advance territorial claims and Turkey is going to satisfy them, or there is any reality to expect satisfaction of such claims despite Turkey’s opposition, I have to say that it would be a very naïve impression. However, I don’t understand what means a “dialog,” if you are not even ready to discuss the existing issues. However, there are issues between us, which require some resolution, and unless we are ready to put all the issues on the table, the illusion of the dialog wouldn’t serve any other reason but PR, which I personally wouldn’t care about. I have to add that the return of the Armenians into Anatolia is a (using Edward Demian’s terminology) a primitive bluff from both sides, and it should be called off for the sake of not wasting precious time in our discussions. No Armenian is going to return to Anatolia even if by some crazy magic it becomes part of Armenia. If you thing that everyone here is such an idiot that will ask lands from you, you are residing in a world of fantasies. I understand the following from the above and am open to corrections, preferably in the same format (1,2, 3, etc): 1. There are two issues, not one: AG and the land. 2. There are/should be Armenian land claims from Turkey and they are legitimate. 3. Even though they are there and are legitimate, Armenians recognise they are not realisable. 4. Even though they are not realisable, they should still be discussed. 5. There is no point in recognising the AG if no land is given with it. It's all or nothing. 6. Even if the lands are returned, no Armenian is ever going to live on them again. 7. You (MJ) are a self-contradictory idiot. Answers to your questions will come in a separate posting. Cheers,
  7. to everyone i am starting to doubt my powers of expression or your powers of comprehension, or both. the sky is not as clear as my position is as far as i am concerned. i am sick and tired of repeating it, but here it is in a nutshell: 1. ag has to be recognised. 2. borders have to stay the same. 3. for ag to be recognised, land claims must be dropped, because i) denialists will use it as a pretext to put off recognition, and ii) they will cause yet another armed conflict if they persist after recognition and somebody on your side decides to implement the claims. what you guys are basically saying is "recognise the ag and give us the land, and then we can make peace" what i say is "i recognise the ag (for myself as well as for you) but the land stays in our borders. you are welcome to live on it as a first class citizen if you want, and i will do everything in my power to this end. but no border change." we will not give a chunk of our country to be "nice" to you. and of course, supporting armenian rebels in azerbaijan (which is turkish as you know) who have occupied territory OUTSIDE NKR and then expecting to normalise relations with turkey or at least expecting turkey not to do anything about it is also very, very clever and far-sighted of you. it is a bit like our guys refusing to recognise ag and still expecting you not to hate us. i shall post no more on whether there was armenian separatist action or not, not because i am "chickening out" or anything, but i have had enough of repeating the same stuff all over again. for those so inclined, there is plenty of stuff around, starting with the boghos noubar letter, and not ending there. as to whether we are right in maintaining that you still have aims to get half of eastern anatolia and throw us out, you can do no better than start with your own postings in this forum under various threads. we have come full circle in this issue. when i had joined two years ago i was first greeted with suspicion, then commended for my stance on ag, then land claims started to pop up, and my refusal to accept them brought us back to square one. since this discussion took so long and so many different people posted (even though i was the only turk who did) i think i have a fairly clear idea of what a sizeable percentage of armenians think re the issue: "get the turk out of there at the first opportunity, and play the game until the opportunity arises." if any doubt, please refer to your own postings under various threads, not all of which i had replied to. i hope to be proven wrong in time, but by events and not by words. there has been enough suffering for both sides and there must be an end to it. i repeat that i shall not answer postings unless i see something radically different or new, not because i am chickening out, but because both you and i have said everything there is to say about it. it's all in the postings, you can refer to them if you like. i shall post to other threads on other things.
  8. mj, i wasn't going to post, but it looks like i have to. YOU have asked lands from me in a past thread, remember? and it wasn't a slip of the pen, it lasted for a pretty long time, and deteriorated into what we are in now. plus i do not think they are idiots. they have valid and respectable reasons to ask for land, and i have equally valid and respectable reasons to refuse it. 2. If you think that by recognizing the Genocide you or Turkey, for that matter, are doing some kind of favor to us, you are playing a very "junior" game. i recall a posting of yours that was diametrically opposite this one in feeling. chronologically speaking, it was the one just before your first post where you had asked for lands. plus i don't think giving someone (or their descendants) their due is a favour. favour is when you give someone something that he doesn't necessarily deserve to be "nice". i think i have to do it, as a human being. what do you expect me to say, "one million people died, o.k. so what?" or what? also, i do not play games about things that cost a million lives. 3. if boghos noubar delivered the speech he did deliver, i am perfectly entitled to use it. the fact that he wasn't any armenian but the international representative of armenians immediately after the events makes it ever more relevant and strong. there is only one quote by hitler re the ag as far as i know, and armenians use it over and over again, which doesn't make it any less real or relevant, and the same principle applies to the boghos noubar quote, whether you like it or not. it is there. besides it is not the only such thing that i know of. there are loads more, some of them in turkish sites too (like the map used in ottoman armenian schools) etc. i just do not have a scanner and couldn't be bothered to get one just to post that sort of stuff which exists in many other sites anyway. Additionally, what you are demonstrating here over and over again is that you have no remorse, which makes you no different from the perpetrators of the Genocide. so i have no remorse, and that's why i am here recognising the genocide and sticking my neck out over here to get a few more people to recognise it as a fact and a crime (well, once you recognise it as genocide, i don't know how you can escape the conclusion of it being a crime). so what's my agenda, mj? to come here and persuade you, descendant of survivors of genocide that there wasn't one? or to tell you that "don't mind me saying that, but we were right in killing your ancestors, you see, some of you sided with the russians, so we had to kill all to avert danger, o.k? no hard feelings, o.k? past is past. you drop that genocide line and let's live like brothers like we did for centuries. how's that?" is that what you think i am trying to say? you give me such an impression that you think that this is what i am implying. i am especially disappointed that i am still being accused of using this and other stuff as justification (so i understand). i had made my point clear on this in view of the nature of genocide (an entire population killed without regard to guilt or innocence) as opposed to punishing the guilty (those who took part in separatist activity). there are two kinds of dishonesty. one is refusing to admit a fact, and the other is putting words (or implications) into someone else's mouth. i am going to use the strongest language i have ever used in this forum re you, and that is that i suspect you understand what you want to understand in my postings, and this is not honest. there is plenty of stuff you can criticise me for: in the heat of the moment i forget my references, occasionally i type in things that i forget to check in my library (and turn out wrong), in a few occasions i ventured into areas where i didn't have enough knowledge and quickly found out at my cost, etc etc. but i have never had any stance like "so there was a genocide. so what?" or worse, "o.k. we did it. but frankly speaking, we had to do it: it was us or them." these belong to the grey wolf/establishment/fossil CUP mouths and minds. not me. accuse me to your heart's content of things i am guilty of, but don't accuse me of things that i am not guilty of. what kind of person you think i am, if, as you say, i accept the ag but fail/refuse to show remorse for it (we had disagreed on the use of this word in english, bt let me adopt your usage). what do you think that i could ever be gaining by coming to this forum and "playing games" with you as you say? do i have too much time in my hands to waste? let's wrap this thing up, for god's sake.
  9. mj and you are right we have exhausted this topic ad nauseam and it is coming out of everyone's ears including mine. your position is clear to me, and my position is clear to you. i shall post no more on this unless & until i see something radically different than already posted. i leave this topic with a strong sense of disappointment as i see that certain differences are irreconcilable, at least in this forum. i will continue to do my bit to contribute to any dialogue that may exist between the two nations, though, as i will continue to defend my country's territorial integrity. i do not expect an answer to this posting of mine, and i shall not reply to it unless it is radically different from anything that was posted until now. yours,
  10. hello, i think i have a few things to say re the above topic that might be of use: 1. i do not think that it is or will be unimportant for the armenians whether turkey recognises the ag or not. imagine a germany in the middle of europe not recognising the holocaust. would it be acceptable? 2. unfortunately, both sides have shown reluctance in accepting certain facts: i) turks show reluctance to accept that their treatment of the armenians, especially in the last quarter of the 19th century (i.e. before 1890s and the ag in 1915) was nothing they could be proud of, and they base their arguments of armenians rebelling upon russian instigation largely on that: if they were so wonderfully treated, it could only be some external factor that made them rebel, as there were no internal reasons, nothing they could complain about, that could cause discontent and rebellion. ii) turks - and as far as i can see armenians - tend to overlook one crucial piece of evidence from the turkish side, namely the memoirs and other literary works of people who had served in wwi and the independence war. there is ample evidence in them that the thing was planned. armenians often quote the records of the 1919 trials in istanbul, but since these were conducted in a city occupied by the british and run by a government that was largely seen as a bunch of traitors, turks find it quite easy to dismiss. it would be a good deal harder to dismiss evidence from the authors i am referring to. maybe a compilation of such quotes would be very useful to convince turks with their own sources. iii) armenians show reluctance to accept the fact that the genocide did not arrive from nowhere and the famous boghos noubar quote and others in the same vein, though perhaps slightly exaggerated for propaganda purposes, are not that far from the truth as they were delivered soon after the events by and to people who had participated in them. denial of this fact plays into the hands of turkish denialists and keeps the issue in a rut. 3. it is important to realise that turks and armenians were by no means the only people directy or indirectly involved with the ag or more significantly, the events leading to it. the germans, the russians, the british and the french all had something to do with it (especially the germans and the russians), and material relating to that are found in their archives. as you know the german archives relating to 1915 were recenty (2000 if i am not mistaken) opened, and evidence to german complicity in ag became public. what i wonder is why they were closed until that time, and as far as i can see no-one asked that question (correct me if i am wrong, please). turkish "researchers" on the issue claim i) that relevant portions of russian, british and french archives are still not opened, and maintain that the totality of existing documents re the events should be made available (this is, of course, being used as a pretext to keep the turkish archives closed, but they have a point: if we are expected to let the beans spill, everyone should be expected to do the same). this is important becuase it plays into the denialists' hands. 4. those defending the armenian version have very frequently overlooked/downplayed/attempted to justify turkish suffering and armenian excesses (including those predating the ag), which some armenians themselves do not deny, and this keeps playing into the denialists' hands. 5. one thing serves as a great eye-opener for the turks, and that is their version of the events, armenian version of the events minus the label genocide, and the definition of genocide put side by side. many turks discover that turkish accounts of individual events compared to their armenian accounts are shockingly similar, and put into a chronological order, do give the impression of the genocide. this is especially important as both sides are given "summarised" versions of events, but details are available and not particularly hard to get. 6. turks use genocide denial as a shield against the perceived threat of land recognition, and the attitude of many armenians has shown time and again that this threat is not a figment of turks' imagination. turkey cannot be made to accept the ag in the foreseeable future as long as it feels that the day after it recognises ag, there will be a demand from the armenian side - backed by the russians at least - "now give the six provinces". turks feel that in such an issue the western world - which is almost ntirely christian - will naturally support christian armenia rather than muslim turkey, or at least turn a blind eye if there is armed conflict, the way they did in bosnia. this christian-muslim factor is still very relevant in world affairs, and we fear it is becoming even more valid after 9/11. turkey realises that ag denial cannot go on forever (unless we and azerbaijan are prepared to remain the only two countries that still deny it), and the recent opening up of turkey in this respect (which so far manifested itself mainly in not preventing alternative opinions of the subject to circulate freely in turkey) is pretty obviously a move by turkey to prepare the public opinion to an eventual acceptance of genocide bu first turning it into an open secret and then accepting something that everyone knew about anyway. this is pretty much what they did with the kurdish issue. turkey also, most logically, prefers to accept it when it is strong enough to weather the consequences. if i were an armenian with the power to do something about genocide recognition, i would i) divorce the ag issue from the land claims issue and state clearly and officially that roa has no land claims from turkey, ii) accept armenian actions prior to the genocide (a la petrossian), iii) present evidence from turkish sources re the ag, iv) show the turks the parallels between armenian and turkish arguments rather than the differences, v) open up relevant roa archives (there are portions of it that are closed) and push - and push through - for the opening up of the relevant portions of russian, french, british and other archives. if these were done, turkey would have no means of denying the genocide further. i would also be wary of something else: libaridian apparently has stated in a conference where a turkish scholar (halil berktay) was also present, that there are armenians who "love the problem". a turkish (turkish jew) businessman discussing the issue with an armenian scholar in paris reported that the scholar said at the end "-but please understand, sir, this is my bread!". ag appears to have turned into an industry, especially among the diaspora, and turkish recognition will no doubt weaken that industry as the "struggle factor" would have been largely eliminated. this might result in cut funds for ag research and other troubles for the members of the sector, and they would paradoxically but understandably might push for ag recognition on the one hand and do their bit to delay it on the other to keep the sector going. this has been a bit disjointed, bt i hope it helps. after all, we all want to see this denial business come to an end. cheers,
  11. quote:Originally posted by HOVSEP KASHISHIAN:Mayebe future generetions will be luckier.Ali Efendy,do you think waiting another fifty years will be enough so we might have more "open minded" turks pop out and then we will be luckier.Can you please tell the Azaries to wait like we did now for more than 80 years,you know we might have in Negorno Artsax more open minded people. hovsep efendi no i don't think waiting for another fifty years will be enough, in fact i am doing my little bit to shorten that time span. i can tell what i like to the azeris, but whether they will listen to me is another matter. but interesting, do you think that you might perhaps have made a bit of a mistake in nagorno-karabagh, or at least painted a picture of yourselves that doesn't quite fit with what you hold yourselves to be? i don't want to get into yet another polemic, so you don't have to answer that one, at least to me. just think about it. when i had first encountered the fact of ag, i didn't - and didn't have to - answer anyone about it, i first thought about it myself. this aside, i think the sooner the region's problems are solved, the better. we in our little quibbles overlook the crucial fact that practically none of the decisions concerning our destinies in the region has been taken by us or with our concerns in mind for the past fifty years. and right now it is yet another era of decision-taking, and unless we get our act together and sort out our differences real quick we may soon find that the place has been rearranged and we are given new roles and degrees of importance that we were not consulted about and had forgotten to agree with. i am especially uneasy about this taliban+el kaida+iraq thing. this won't stop there. these guys (the usa) has to sell arms to make its economy pick up, especially after the accounting scandals, and for arms to be sold, new markets are needed. and we have always been good markets. brrr...
  12. dear thoth, i don't know whether there will be a coup in turkey in the next two years (i hope there won't), if there will be one it will be a bloodless one like 28th feb 1997. but we all know the situation is very precarious. i also would be very careful before investing in turkey, not because you are an armenian, but because turkey is not yet as far as i see an investment grade country. it is just too volatile. but of course the aegean coast is wonderful. dear nairi, o.k. i'll see you in the other forums. i used to post in language/arts/famous amenians, and especially in arts, i could make use of some info, especially re armenian architecture (esp. aghtamar) and some crafts, like the armenian red in iznik tiles. dear hagarag, i understand that at this day and age the burden of the past was weighing on both of you too heavily. we have to get rid of that, and time will heal. maybe future generations willl be luckier. see you under other threads, cheers,
  13. quote:Originally posted by THOTH:Ali - I do hope some of our Armenian friends here take the time to read and digest what you have written here. I'm not so sure I would call all the Armenians here who have taken issue with you as hardliners though. I think that they have chosen to concentrate on a portion of your position and disagreeing with it they have made argument. And I am sure that there is a certain amount of misunderstanding due to the imperfections of communications/language etc. For the most part - the vast most part - I cannot find any significant fault with your position (and I don't see any need to quibble at the moment - as you have said - we are repeating ourselves). What I wish to adress is your (earlier made) contention of Turkey moving toward openess with the Armenain question with the ultimate idea of admitting...etc. First, while I see the liberalization - I don't see that Turkey has abandoned the fight against recognition - not at all. But as you do - can I ask what might be and when might we see the next step? (Would allowing the film Ararat to be shown in Turkey be a step and then open diologue? Is this at all likely?) I for one and still (unfortunatly) pessimistic for the time being. You make a good point about the ability of Armenians to visit Turkey. I certainly have never encountered any offical obstacles - nor any harrassment or noticible hostility (outside a very few individuals when I mention that I am Armenian). I wonder though if purchasing property and such is a viable option... dear thoth, thanks. wow, we can move to a next step! that's a relief. anyway here it is: 1. i don't think that turkey will openly move its official position in the very near future. the reasons for this do not stem from any perceived/real threat from the armenian side, but i) the political shambles turkey is in right now. i don't know whether you guys care, but the imminent elections (3rd november) are only going to give rise to yet another round of elections, and this time (hopefully) a two-tier, narrow-area system since the present system is so unrepresentative of public opinion. also, we have 23 parties at the moment, and as far as i can judge, the electorate is about 50% centre-right, 20-30% centre left, and 20-30% extremists (extreme right and the mullahs). so you really need about five parties: one centre right (anap+dyp), one centre-left (dsp+chp+ytp), one fascist (mhp+bbp), one fanatic (akp+sp), and one separatist (hadep+ödp etc). and this has not been happening for years. our political life got fragmented after the 1980 coup, when the soldiers first banned the old parties (there was no such profusion then), then allowed new parties to be formed, which quickly proved themselves to be continuations of the old ones), and then finally allowed the old guys (demirel, ecevit, erbakan, türkeş) to come back. we had a leader with great vision (albeit with not-so-great principles and morals), turgut özal, who could handle the situation, but after he died in 1993 we went back to the old days, this time in a different fashion. it is no coincidence that turkey ahs had a ramshackle economy domestically and made so little progress internationally in the 1990s, no wonder with that sort of political spectrum. so at the present moment (for about two three years) i wouldn't expect much from turkey in any area, let alone the ag. let's first see how the implementation of the lifting of the restrictions on kurdish and minority foundations actually run "on the ground". but there is much openness re the armenian question, unthtinkable in my teens (and i am not that old after all, only 35 (ok i's half the road, as we say)). i think the first thing that has to be done is to reinstate the armenians in the turkish psyche as people like everyone else, especially as people with whom we have lived for centuries and who contributed to us so very much. after that, with perhaps timid steps, we can tackle the fact that armenians existed here way before us and have left their mark there. at the same time (and actually right now) cultural exchanges between the two peoples must take momentum. you see, our problem is not only to solve differences over ag. our problem is to show both sides that they are both regular people. the vast majority of armenians still see the turks as savages bent on destroying them, and the vast majority of turks still see the armenians as traitors or separatists who want to throw us out of anatolia. we both have to prepare the ground for them to discover that they are just people like anyone else - and what is far more important - very much like one another. i think these are the first steps to be taken. i wouldn't start by showing ararat or anything like it, because i) the contents (the message) are known, and ii) it will play into the hands of the denialists and hardliners if it is shown before the people have done some discovering themselves and are receptive to the message. some soul-searching along these lines has been going on for a few years by now and if you are here you can see the results (positive). of course, until the govt officially admits it, it will go on by attempting to provide more intelligent arguments re the denial, but as we say in turkish, you cannot smear the sun with mud. as far as i can see such official attempts only serve to get people more curious to learn what really happened, and since turks are almost genetically suspicious of any tune the govt plays (so many of their lies have been exposed), it will backfire. i think the govt is also well aware of that and don't underestimate the importance of the fact that with each passing year, some younger people come to prominence and they don't buy lies that date from the one-party times (1940s). it was a minister of state and a very prominent man (from the centre right) who wrote "the beads of salkım hanım" (the book about the property tax period with flashbacks to the hamidian massacres), which was then turned into a movie where the ag was explicitly referred to, by the armenian director of the movie, etyen mahçupyan. the fact that nothing whatsoever happened to him and the film was on show for weeks on end is a very strong indication to me at least that some very serious changes are now taking place. so i do not think that you have to pay that much heed that the govt is going on with ag denial. after all, it is what they are expected to do. what they are doing is to allow alternative opinions to be voiced and that is far more significant. as i have said before, the govt being a political structure and essentially populist (all democratic govts are to some extent) they have to carefully prepare the public opinion before the say something revolutionary likethe ag being a fact to avoid political suicide. re visiting turkey. you are in a better position of course to judge than i am. after all, i am not armenian, and even in discussions re ag, it is taken for granted by both sides that both of us are turks. i know of unpleasant experiences armenians had and are probably still having in turkey, i cannot judge to what extent these reflect the general stance of the public. as a general rule, the public is against violence and discrimination, but there is one element that has been a major - and destructive - power in any society, and that is the mob. i am an optimistic, idealist guy, but by the time you are 35, you are no dreamer anymore: ugly facts exist. as far as buying property is concerned, as i had said, there has been this armenian from california who bought a hotel in van and had called it vartan upon which it was closed down, only to be opened three years later when the court ruled in favour. we still have our xenophobic urges but things are improving. but i would of course be wary of attempting to buy large tracts of land because right now the whisper times in turkey reports that the armenian lobby of america is planning to buy large tracts in eastern anatolia adjacent to armenia with a view to driving the turks out and settling the place with armenians. i had heard that during özal they had tried it, and özal was not averse, but the army had stepped in and it was the end of the story. when dealing with turkey , never forget that the real ruler of the country is the military. they don't interfere with everything, but they do when they perceie something as a potential threat to turkey. cheers,
  14. quote:Originally posted by nairi:Ali, there's no point in trying to solve problems in this forum. You are very well-aware of the fact that the largest majority of Armenians who speak up in this forum is anti-land claims. If you want to sort out the land-claim problem, I suggest you start chatting to prominent Armenians who do support land claims. As far as I'm concerned, your job's done here. There's nothing left to discuss. Nairi nairi i am surprised that this is coming from you (given one of your postings in the very recent past). most of the recent postings re the land claims had convinced me otherwise (you can check them if you want and see why). however, if this is the case, then fine. i discussed the land claims issue (in fact it think it was mj who had started it long ago) as it came about and as it is an important issue, at least for us. since this forum is pretty much my only access to armenian opinion outside turkey, and since i don't know any prominent armenians, i discussed it with you. (also because i hold the opinions of the not-so prominent armenian masses as important as that of the prominent few). but i agree that there's nothing left to discuss re this issue. i shall hang on in the forum if "your job's done here" doesn't mean "get the hell out of here".
  15. quote:Originally posted by THOTH:Ali - super post. It may have been possibly I who talked of your progress (though in some cases maybe I would say lack therof...LOL). But first let me say - you are obviously not a genocide denier - and that should be clear. Secondly - I find your core positions as entirely reasonable - commendable even. Three - I basically agree with your land position - particualrly as stated here - though I would like to think that this is not an entirely settled issue. But back to progress - In the past you have raised the issue of Armenian violence against Turks prior to the Genocide/WWI as some rrational for the Turksih action and seemed to me that you were attempting to blame the Armenians. It seems that you have largely backed away from this - for the most part distasteful stance (and part of this is the claim of any significant Ottoman Armenian cooperation with the Russians). This is "progress that I see". Perhaps you will claim progress that Armenians even acknolwedge the presence of such bands...etc. I I think your perspective is valuable for us - agree 100% or not - it is educational - and we need this exposure - we need to learn how to talk together - IMO. Anyway - I hope you don't leave. Losing Filiz from this forum was bad enough...so don't despair...and don't get too frustrated. dear thoth, thanks. i agree with most of what you say except my position that i had stated re the issue of Armenian violence against Turks prior to the Genocide/WWI as some rational for the Turkish action. there was armenian violence, and there was turkish reaction. one is as much justified as the other (=neither is justified). a turk by a far fetched argument could attempt to find some justification for the massacres of 1890s (and even then he would have a hard time explaining an incident in istanbul one day and several thousand armenian dead in adana the next, and still harder to justify the murder of thousands of innocent citizens on the pretext of the violence of some activists: if someone's guilty, go punish him, why do you kill babies and women?). no turk by any argument could explain or justify ag (1915), however. this was pretty obviously an attempt to substantially eliminate the armenian element in anatolia. the "justification" was that as long as they stayed in anatolia they would constitute a threat whenever we got weak. this is akin to murdering someone who has reason not to like you on the suspicion that since he doesn't like you, he might attempt to kill you one day, the absurdity of which is obvious. my attempt was not to "justify" the genocide by citing preceding armenian violence (i had stated at the beginning - when the issue arose - that nothing in my opinion could justify a genocide, and i stick to it) but to remind that i) armenian violence and separatist demands way before the genocide and even before the 1890s massacres did exist, and they are cited in third party sources (i have some english ones in my library, they are not difficult to find in europe), ii) they were used as a pretext by the CUP and it worked, and iii) denying them would only play into the hands of the ag denialists, since that sort of material really abounds all over the place (you can apparently still find that sort of material in turkey in the booksellers' bazaars). in approaching an issue such as the ag we have to do our best to be calm (and given the fact that we both are parties to it and that we both cherish long-held positions with equal passion, our best will very frequently not be good enough, that's why i strive to be as patient as i can in the face of the torrent of insults that i receive whenever i log in) and accept from the outset that facts may emerge which will not suit us a bit. i recall a mhp member whom i had once known who knew that his grandfather was in one of the chetes (ostensibly to defend the muslims) but who learned only in his adult life (and long after he had joined the mhp) that his grandmother was originally an armenian orphan saved by his village when her village was wiped out. now what is this guy going to do? what is his identity? in such an issue where sides are so sharply defined, whose side is he going to be on? there are people, and not a few of them, who keep having to answer such questions every day. and no wonder they swing from one extreme to the next since they themselves are insecure as to where to be, as to who they are. we at least - at least as far as i can understand - on this forum have clear identities as to who we are: you rae armenians and i am a turk, no doubt about that. cards open on the table. now what we have to do is to bridge our our differences. maybe this has been so hard because of one thing that i observe: i understand - from what i read - that many armenians here are hardliners (you are an exception) re the turkish-armenian conflict, whereas i am not a hardliner myself. the issue resembling a tug-of-war, each side is trying to pull the other side towards itself as much as he can. now this would be an even match if both sides grabbed the cord at equal distance from the centre and with equal strength, but in my case i grab it at a point closer to the general armenian opinion than most turks are (and hence near the centre), and am pulled by the armenian hardliners here as far as they can pull toward their side. if i were a denier, maybe the discussion would be about convincing me about the fact of the ag. since i accept that and you (not you personally, thoth) don't have to lose time on that with me, you concentrate on getting me as close to your side as possible and making me accept all of your positions. now the reason why i am closer to your stance than the regular turkish stance re the ag and other related issues (excl. the land claims) is not because i had previously been forcibly pulled toward that direction by some armenian, but because i think yours is closer to the truth than ours. you got it right, we got it wrong (sort of). and i stick to my opinion on that, and defend my position re the ag over here as adamantly as i defend my position re the land in the forum. i hold the two opinions equally close to my heart: 1. there was an ag and it was a crime. it has to be acknowledged, apologised and compensated for. 2. turkey in its national boundaries is my country and i want it to stay in one piece. some members here may ask "don't you see a discrepancy between the two? how can you accept the ag and its criminality and then defend turkish territorial integrity?" good question. apart from the "we shall never surrender (quoted from Churchill)" line, on which i am not basing an argument, our moral right rests on the fact that i) we have been here for so long, ii) we are an outcome of the mingling of central asians and local anatolians, so there is no question of our nativity and hence "moral" right to be here (in sharp contrast to the americans, for instance, who have so little native american blood). this point is especially pertinent since so many of the turks whom some armenians here in this forum would like to see out of turkey are actually genetically at least partly armenian, and iii) my country does not owe its existence to the genocide. it was there, called turkey from the 13th century onwards (and then by marco polo and not us), and we had been a numerical majority on this land by the 18th century, long before there was even a hint of massacre. mind you, i don't know if anyone has checked, but it may very well be that the numbers of both the greeks and the armenians in the 19th century might have been very close to (and in some districts, larger than ) their numbers under the byzantine empire at the time of our arrival in the 11th century. this might surprise (or even anger) some of you, but if you look at the (admittedly not the most reliable) evidence, there were some 3.5 million greeks and up to 2 million armenian in turkey in 1914, concentrated in the aegean, istanbul, the black sea coast and cappadocia (the greeks) and northeastern anatolia and adana (the armenians), almost a third of the entire population of anatolia. this is half of the population of the byzantine empire in the 11th century (roughly 10 million), and the byzantine empire had a non-greek, non-armenian central and southeastern anatolia. (o.k. this has been a bit of a digression again, back to the topic). so in brief my two positions and the bases they rest on are clear, and as far as i can see they do not clash. as i have stated several times, i am all for armenians returning to anatolia, and in fact many turks deplore the loss of the multiethnic cosmopolitan life of pre-republican turkey since it was so rich. and as i have stated, if the problems were solved and you would have no obstacles in visiting & living in ani, van, aghtamar, mush, bitlis etc., would you really be so adamant about getting them away from the turks and including them in armenia? i think it's time to conclude as we keep repeating ourselves now. cheers,
  16. eduard, the info that you put is actually pretty old (at least over here). i don't follow azeri stuff much but it appears to be just a rehash of stuff to indict s.o. or defend s.o. indicted. and, for god's sake, what is secret about turkish-azeri military alliance? you can watch it both on turkish tv and azeri tv.
  17. i'm still there there are several points that i feel the need to address as i find it shocking thatasome misunderstandings prevail after so much discussion: 1. i as a person have never said that i drop the ag denial on condition that you drop the land claims. if you recall, i had accepted the ag from the outset, way before this particular thread got started. whether ag did happen or not - and it did - will not depend on anyone's acceptance and denial of it, nor will it depend on our differing positions re the lands. 2. as i had said before, i am not here for idle talk but with a view to eventually participating in something that will contribute to the ending of the blood feud between us. in order to achieve this, one must concentrate on realisable goals and projects. in my opinion it is eventually realisable to get turkey as a nation and state to recognise the ag, apologise, pay compensation for, allow for resettlement, but it is not realisable - and therefore realistic - to ask it to cede land. i prefer to concentrate my efforts on what is realisable. and i see that my nation cannot be made to accept the ag unless and until the land claims drop first. this is the underlying reason of my proposal that you drop the land claims if you want to see turkey accept the ag. and to maintain that i am a denier in this forum of all places is an insult to my intelligence. what am i here to do? tell all of you guys, descendants of victims of genocide that there was no genocide, it was all you imagination? 3. it is stated here many times that turks took the land from the armenians. wrong. turks took it from the byzantine greeks (remember romanos diogenes?). to te best of my knowledge there was precious little fighting with the armenians, and there was more than one occasion when the two nations cooperated in warfare. mj had at some point commented that not at any time in history were armenians defeated by turks in battle, this, although perhaps not totally accurate, is not that far from the truth, as there were not all that many battles between us to begin with. 4. to say that the land is yours and not ours is inaccurate on at least one account other than the right of the sword: we came into anatolia almost 1,000 years ago, and mixed with the local population to such an extent that we are really turkish-speaking anatolians with some (few) central asian genes, not unlike you being armenian-speaking anatolians with some (even fewer) balkan genes). an enormous amount of our culture covering all aspects of human life are anatolian native. our houses, our dress (well, that's changed now), our music, our visual arts, our food, our popular religion (as opposed to "high" religion) are all predominantly anatolian. recent genetic research in practically all cases show that we, the anatolian turks of today, are lineal descendants of the people who inhabited chatalhuyuk and hacilar and similar neolithic settlements. in fact, you don't have to go as far as lab experiments, all you have to do is look at our faces. so who is kicking out whom, and on what moral grounds? 5. i understand armenian indignation at seeing their historical sites such as ani, ararat and aghtamar off-limits. we lived the same when central asia was under soviet rule. well, the issue is being relaxed now (even with ani as far as i can see) and if one day all these troubles are over and borders are removed you will be able to visit all these places and maybe even buy houses there (a californian armenian has already bought a hotel in van and called it hotel vartan after his son). 6. somebody (sorry forgot who) commented on how nice it was to converse with filiz (if i paraphrase correctly), well, it was you who kicked her out. does this not say more about you than it does about filiz? 7. some people here have posted stuff that i am out here to really deny the genocide, that i am a typical denier, that i am no different from the rest, that i hate you all, that i see the armenians with contempt, that i am aggressive and threatening, that i am just a barbarian like all the others of my ilk, etc. etc. to these all i have to say is the following: i) if you think i am a denier, then you either do not know what denial means, or have never talked to a denier. ii) if you really think i am no different from the rest, i suggest you to take a poll, and if it turns out that the majority thinks that way, then i'll quit the forum. i don't like being in places where i am not wanted. iii) i am not aggressive and threatening. but what on earth do you expect me to say to someone who says to me "get the hell out of there where you have been living for almost a millennium, and give it to me"? being nonaggressive does not mean being meek and doing whatever you want me to do. i have my own, and will hold on to it. iv) i see a disturbing parallel between the attitude of some people here commenting on my "progress" and that of the colonial europeans in africa, asia, australia and the americas. please don't forget that i) we are descendants of a nation that built an empire and kept it going for over six centuries, and an empire is not built solely by the sword, ii) i am not "retarded", so there is no question of talking about "progress". we have very serious and explosive issues at hand about which we both have passionately held positions, and it is not "progress" if i move in your direction or you in mine. i hvae never referred to anyone's acceptance of any of my positions as "progress" and i shall have none of it comingfrom the other side. plus, there is no universally accepted and APPLIED criteria on issues such as land claims, so what progress are you talking about? v) you seem to overlook one crucial prerequisite of negotiation: when you accept to negotiate you automatically accept that you cannot make the other side accept ALL of your positions, just as you cannot be expected to accept ALL of his positions. you accept NONE of my positions (other than those that are the same as yours) and you expect me to accept ALL of your positions. do you think you will get anywhere with this? 8) just out of curiosity: suppose you get eastern anatolia. what are you going to do with the 10 million + turks and an even larger number of kurds? don't forget: it takes two to tango, and we have to tango, whether we like it or not. and we don't like it any more than you do.
  18. nairi our differences are irreconcilable. no deal. if you so much want the lands, come 'n' get them if you can.
  19. hello i have decided to stop replying to each posting separately because it costs too much time and most of the posts have many points in common, and we have really exhausted the issue anyway. here is what i have to say: we have a blood feud that needs to be solved if our children are to live in peace. that needs intelligent discussion and civilised negotiation. i have seen no negotiation come to a fruitful end without either side ready to make such concessions. there is no sitting at the table and getting ALL of what you want, and that applies to both of us, not just you. as far as i can see our starting point is as follows: hardline armenians would want turkey to recognise the ag, apologise for it, pay compensation for it, allow armenians to return to anatolia and give half of eastern anatolia to roa, and get the hell out of there or accept armenian rule, open up the borders and keep silent about the armenian-azeri conflict. hardliners in the turkish establishment would want the ag claims dropped dead, avoid apology, compensation, no return of armenians and certainly not an inch of territory given to anyone, and armenians either to get out of karabagh or accept azeri rule. the two points of view are irreconcilable and there is no point in attempting to get these people to the negotiation table. softline turks would want the armenians to drop land claims and get out of the territories OUTSIDE nagorno-karabagh that NKR is currently occupying. that's all we want from you. in return, we offer pushing for ag recognition, apology, compensation, return of armenians to live as armenians live in france or usa (well the place is a bit poorer but still), opening up the border, normalising relations with you and helping you and the azeris to normalise relations. we can reach an agreement with those armenians who want everything except actual secession of territory by turkey and continued occupation of lands OUTSIDE NKR in azerbaijan. that is the only way that i can see to solve this problem. once this is thus solved, we can have peace flourishing and maybe our grandchildren will have different thoughts about territorial integrity and what should belong to whom. in europe, you can have a country (denmark) opting for eu membership while a part of it (greenland) stays out of it. this sort of thing would have been unthinkable fifty years ago even in europe. (or maybe especially in europe, given what it was like fifty years ago). there is no border between europeans now, the very same people who slaughtered eachother by the tens of millions just fifty years ago. but eu was not built in a day. and it would never have made it if the founders pushed for everything that is taking place now at the beginning. deep down to me the concept of this land belongs to me/to you is an unrealistic and arrogant statement. it is not the land that belongs to us, it is the other way round. we belong to it. we come and go and the land stays. all our wars about this or that territory is ultimately meaningless because in fighting for it we are destroying it, and when we destroy it beyond a certain point the land becomes unlivable and we have to leave it. countless wars have been fought over anatolia and its resources depleted by each successive civilisation in a most wasteful manner. did you know that anatolia was covered in trees from one end to the other just 8,000 years ago? it's a bit hard to believe that now, isn't it? well, these trees all became the fleets of the egyptians, phoenicians, greeks, romans, byzantines, and ottomans. now most of anatolia is a steppe, and the population it supports in its central and eastern parts is barely 30 million, less than half of what it could support if it were not destroyed so extensively. we fought over it, so what? you are out of eastern anatolia but are we in it? no. the provinces that armenians demanded - and died for - barely support a few million people today, and those few who are left there are all looking for a better life elsewhere. we have to change our bases of thought fundamentally. i find it exceptionally arrogant on the part the human being to maintain that land belongs to him rather than he really belongs to land. if we adopt that line of thought, maybe we will look at this territory business in a completely different manner. when we quarrel about this land belonging to us or to you, what we really mean is which STATE it belongs to. to me a state is an institution that serves the needs of a people, and the more respect it shows to the land, the better it does the job. as far as i can see the only states that qualify by this criterion are the scandinavian ones. maybe we both should step aside and invite the swedes, danes, norwegians and the finns to rule us . maybe i should have typed this ages ago, when this discussion first started. cheers,
  20. quote:Originally posted by nairi: quote:Originally posted by aurguplu:agree to hand you on a plate half of eastern anatolia and persuade my people to get the hell out of there? Why do you keep assuming that Armenians want Turks out of Anatolia? Armenians are a civilized people Ali. The Armenians who say they want lands back are saying: "Those lands should be ruled by Armenians. Thus, if a Turk lives in that territory he should abide by Armenian law as an Armenian living in Turkey would abide by Turkish law." I hope this fact was interesting enough for you to read and use as the basis of your arguments next time. Nairi this is exactly what's happening with artsakh and the territories outside nagorno-karabagh that you invaded, isn't it? all the azeris are there living happily under armenian rule, aren't they? all this stuff about one million internally displaced azeris that even the un does not deny is just a propaganda and all these people dying off in the slums of baku and elsewhere are really con-artists paid by aliyev to play the part of the oppressed azeris, aren't they?
  21. quote:Originally posted by nairi: quote:Originally posted by aurguplu:agree to hand you on a plate half of eastern anatolia and persuade my people to get the hell out of there? Why do you keep assuming that Armenians want Turks out of Anatolia? Nairi "Well I've got news for you: Turks knew Armenians were a civilized people from the beginning. They were also well-aware of the fact that the lands we lived on belonged to our ancestors. Turks decided to wipe out a civilized nation. Hence, they will have to deal with that civilized nation. And if that means losing a quarter or even half of their lands and belongings, they should accept that. What goes around, comes around." see why?
  22. quote:Originally posted by sen_vahan:Hi, Ali, 1. the land claims are not there because of ag denial. various armenian groups were demanding land from the turks since well before 1915 or even the hamidian massacres in 1891-95. They had the right to do so. Show that they didn't and cannot now. they had the right to do so, and the turks had the right to do something about it (and before you jump on it, no, they had no "right" to commit genocide, nor was it necessary) 2. we are in a vicious circle here. turkey is not going to officially recognise ag unless and until land claims are dropped, and land claims are going to persists unless and until turkey recognises ag. to break it, there has to be an agreement that the land claims will be dropped prior to ag recognition, upon condition that the dropping of these claims will be immediately followed by ag recognition (=you drop the land claims today, we recognise the ag tomorrow kind of thing). Present-day Turkey does not seem to be ready for such an agreement, Ali, because I said before what we see in the world is the denial of the fact. And I guess the propaganda of denial still goes on in your country and people are still being brainwashed. How do you want us to deal with a state with such an attitude among people? Sorry, but it does not seem to be a civilized manner to solve a problem. turkey was not ready to recognise the kurdish identity until 1991, it has now. it wasn't ready to allow public use of kurdish, it just has. it wasn't ready to abolish the death penalty, it just has. it isn't ready to reach such an agreement now, it will be. don't underestimate turkey. you miss a point here: from the turkish side, you cannot START by asking them to drop the denial, because they are concerned about the land claims. if you start by dropping the land claims, then turkey will have no reason to be concerned about, and getting the recognition will be much easier. the recognition is not the BEGINNING of the process, it is the intended CULMINATION (unless the armenian agenda is ultimately about getting the lands back, with ag recognition being an intermediate step, as turkey suspects). 3. the yataghan is out of date. The principle is the same. i had meant the principle. "these days it is the buttons. and before actual warfare, there are a host of economic/political measures such as trade sanctions, embargoes, freezing of assets, denial/postponement of eu membership etc." Exactly, and that's what you are probably doing? nope. i had meant the west. we don't have the buttons (which i am happy about, actually), and we are the ones on the receiving end of the sanctions, not the producing end. "and do not forget that while you tend to see just us when you look at us, we tend to see the russians, eu and, to some extent, the usa in addition to you when we look at you. after all, the turkish armenian border was (is it still ) patrolled by russian troops and not armenian ones. " Sounds like you consider us to be very important. yes we do consider you more important than you consider yourselves to be. at least on this point you cannot blame us with arrogance. By the way, there are russian as well as armenian soldiers,troops in the border. we have no american troops on our borders (iraq may be excepted now). Whereas you see russians , eu, and us (?), we see you dealing with this problem. precisely my point. you are not alone. we are. "plus, if the armenians get stronger, they will want to "solve" the problem the way all strong nations solve. you have a problem with the azeris and you are solving it by the sword, not negotiations, because you have a sword strong enough and they don't (and we are not helping them much, because we don't want to get into yet another quagmire)." 1.you mean economic sunctions or buttons? Neither one will work with turkey because neither is possible. You probably think a small country will bother you (a powerful one) with its sword when it gets stronger? Come on, this game does not make any sense, sorry. i had meant both. sanctions, yes (for instance, ag recognition is a prerequisite for us to get into the eu. while i agree with it fully, i also see it has little to do with economics. what if we recognise ag to get into eu, and then the eu comes up with a prerequisite that we give up eastern anatolia? they had said similar things until very recently re the kurds in the southeast. yes a small country can bother us with its sword when it gets stronger. israel is a tiny country with barely two million people in it, and kicks the xxxx out of 150 million arabs from the pacific shore to the atlantic. it is in the same region, which was until 80 years ago part of the same empire, and was craeted by the very same great powers that had carved up the ottoman empire and had supported you. "the example is right before our eyes. artshakh opted out of attempting to achieve peaceful coexistence with the azeris already when azerbaijan was not even ruled by the azeris. and the issue there has always been more about getting ancestral lands back than working out a solution for peaceful coexistence. what guarantee do we have that you will even contemplate peaceful coexistence with us the moment you have the power to get rid of us?" Yeah, in the near 1000 years Armenia may probably get that strong "to get rid of you". Isn't that rediculous, Ali? it hasn't taken 1,000 years to get strong enough to get rid of the azeris, twice your size, has it? "4. no exaggaration, merely a statement of observable facts. all you have to do is look at the postings in this forum." Postings are different but you mainly deal with people that are polite and intelligent enough, right? Ali, unfortunately, one cannot find any turkish forum as civilized as this one. In all the turkish forums I attended armenians/armenia are insulted in an awfull manner. i am no contributor to any turkish forum and hence not responsible for whatever goes on there. i am here. i do not represent anyone but myself. i talk to the people here. i am responsible for what i type here and respond to what is typed about me here. Anyway, we talk to you personally, to a person who is really appreciated in this forum (I think you know that) but sometimes you are insulted because people are very different here, and the topic is about extermination of the nation, so, don't be surprised, please. thanks. could i be forgiven for doubting that after the posts of nairi, gamavor, tb, and recently boghos? 5. if the phrases have been utterred, then why not bring them up? whatever i (and even those turks in other forums) utter is brought before me, and not infrequently in a distorted interpretation, then why shouldn't i? besides, i see it very relevant. after all "i hate the turks biologically. i wish they simply didn't exist" sounds very much like hitler on the jews, does it not? what if we have someone like gamavor as the president of roa one day, and what if that roa is strong, and say, in possession of nuclear power?" Please, don't go too far in this issue, we are discussing the AG recognition and probable land claims. I think if turkey has nuclear power the world will face more problems. heaven forbid. the first people who are going to face the problem are probably us, since we are very probably goingto store it in a bunker on an earthquake zone, and then when an earthquake hits, we'll all glow in the dark. Moreover, stop this game, please, the genocide of armenians were made in your country and how do you expect that there will be no armenian hating you? i play no games about issues that cost human lives. i do not expect armenians not to hate turks, but i haven't killed anyone, nor has any member of my family, and in this case the hate is misdirected. Sorry, but dealing with armenians in this problem you need to be very CAREFUL (I would do that if I were a turk,yes) because the emotions of people play an important role here. if i haven't been careful enough i apologise most sincerely. And if today you think that "somebody like gamavor" may become a president of roa then you either laugh on us or you are really far to be able to solve this problem. no, in fact. the last thing i do is laugh about it. and if he - or someone like him - one day indeed gets to be your president, you will not be able to laugh, either, will you? "can this not happen? do we not have the right to take preemptive measures to prevent this from happening? " You know your right better i guess. And we also may think that somebody like talaat or enver (lets not talk about hitler, please, we have other examples) becomes a president in your country god knows what will happen. yes you are perfectly entitled to think so - and regrettably not necessarily that inaccurate, after all the mhp is still a coalition member - and we are asking the same question slightly differently: what is happening with our country now? does god know? if he does, then why isn't he doing anything about it? Again, do not go too far, both sides have the same problem and both have something to lose. i agree. but staying where we are we are not going to solve the issues. "after all, hitler did exist, as the ruler of an ostensibly civilised nation like germany, and nukes have been used, twice, one week apart, by another ostensibly civilised nation, the usa, against two non-military targets in japan, and that civilised nation still refuses to apologise for them. and all this was not that long ago, was it?" I would not mix all these issues. Japan was an agressor (I don't say US did a right thing though) and was very powerful. The problem of jews in germany is also very different(I don't want to start this because the topic may be changed as it usually happens). armenians in the empire were peaceful people (as they usually are unfortunately) and were one of the most cultural and they did not owe all the banking system in your country having a huge pressure on the politics and economy. Turks were solving problems they might face later - the land problems, and armenians were important who might have land claims. i agree to a very large extent (to my regret). Today the situation is not very different as i understand because a very intelligent person in this forum says "what if land claims,..., what if gamavor as a president...., etc, etc". today the situation is slightly different. in 1915, they only had the 1890s as an inherited nightmare. today we have both. but then, the ottoman empire was on the verge of collapse, and behaved like a cornered animal. it attacked savagely. today turkey is not on the verge of collapse (i hope) and can behave in a civilised manner. the most savage animal is not dangerous when it is not hungry or threatened. we are not hungry (not land-hungry, i mean), we only feel threatened. if the threat is removed, we will not be dangerous to you or anyone. "do you know on what grounds the decision was taken to use nukes against japan and not germany? "the japanese do not belong to the same branch of humanity that we do (the germans did)." Sorry, I am not sure about that - it would not make sense to do against germany which lost the war with Soviets. the nukes were developed before german capitulation if i remember correctly. i had heard that quote at oxford from a dissident who was busy condemning the usa for the use of the bombs. it has the risk of being inaccurate, and i can abandon it if proved so. it is not cetral to my argument. "well, we don't belong to the same branch of humanity that you do. you are christians, and we muslims. and especially after 9/11 (whose effects will last very, very long), you can find enough people in christendom (especially in your part of the world) to justify such an act, and less than enough people to oppose it effectively. and you are so buddy-buddy with russia, full of (mostly stray) nukes, and not a nation known either for civilised behaviour nor any standards of morality." Does turkey take into account all this to whether or not recognise the AG?? yes it does. we do not see neither ag nor its recognition in a vacuum. there is a context to it. and we have to watch the context. it is no coincidence that a good part of the conflicts of the world emanate from the regions which are former ottoman territories (iraq, syria, bosnia). in most cases the conflicting parties are muslims versus someone else. i am not a conspiracy theorist, but the facts are there. "the bosnian genocide was allowed to go on for years in the middle of europe before any serious action was taken (by the usa, not europe) because i) the russians didn't allow any action against it, ii) europeans didn't want to risk life and limb, iii) europeans saw the serbs doing a dirty job for them (cleaning a part of europe of ottoman muslims), and iv) there was no oil. some 200,000 muslims were killed, there is an independent slovenia, serbia, croatia, macedonia now (and as far as i know montenegro is on its way to independence), but no independent bosnia: there is a bosnian croat federation." Right, and christians there have the opposite point of view. but there was no serbian genocide by the bosnians, was there (any more than there was a turkish genocide by the armenians)? if muslims can be wrong, then christians can be wrong, too. besides, it appears that not all that many christians have the opposite point of view, otherwise serbia would not have been bombed by the christian usa, and milosevic would not be in the hague, in christian europe, accused of a genocide. after all, izetbegovic is not there, nor is there anyone accusing him of genocide as far as i can see. " no independent muslim state in europe. chechnya is being raped by the russians and there is no action (i don't mean words) in sight." Why do you bring all these examples? because they are relevant, and they are the ones that denialists in turkey push forward. we may not like them, but we must address them. "wouldn't you be at least careful if you were a turk?" As I said I would. then you understand me. regards, Vahan regards,
  23. quote:Originally posted by nairi:Thoth jan, though in many ways I agree with you, I don't see why Armenians should cooperate with the Alis in the world when we have the members of the "Union Against Genocide" to cooperate with. Don't you think cooperating with the latter is more effective than continuing the same old monologues with (pseudo/brainwashed)-deniers? Ali has hardly responded to any of our substantial posts. He only selectively picks out posts to which he can respond "drop the land claims first" with. I don't care whether he has a diploma, is an A-level student, or a trained denier. The fact is, I haven't seen the slighest bit of progress in him in the last month alone. If you have, please point it out, because I'm having trouble seeing it. ali may have different criteria in judging which posts are substantial and which not. and since he is the only turk here he has to respond to a large number of posts, in his spare time, and this involves selection. posts by some people (mj, thoth, and a few others) i consider much more substantial - even though i may disagree strongly with some of their contents - and more persuasively argued, and in a far more civilised style than others (guess who), so i concentrate on them. if you will read carefully you will realise that i have responded to every post by them and to every point raised in them. we still do not agree on a number of issues, and there are some on which i cannot see we will ever agree, but there are enough vital points on which we agree that makes - in my opinion - it worthwhile to continue with the discussion. by the way, what would "progress" on my part mean to you? agree to hand you on a plate half of eastern anatolia and persuade my people to get the hell out of there? and who are you to make statements about my "progress"? are you holier than me? do you see me talking about anyone having to align his position with mine in order to "progress"?
  24. dear thoth, thanks. i just have to correct one serious misunderstanding on your part. i am not, have never, and will never attempt to justify a genocide, ANY genocide, for the simple reason that there is no justification for it. i think my point that was misunderstood re the genocide was (as far as i understand from the quotes) my linking it with armenian revolutionary activity and cooperation witht the russians. i have stated numerous times that such an act would justify killing of those involved in it as an act of treason, but could not be carried further to encompass the whole population, at the very least since by definition an entire people could not be involved in it (babies, women etc). allow me to give an analogy that i often give when discussing the kurdish issue or any other such issue (including 9/11 these days) and get people see red (but they cannot deny the logic behind it): you have a friend who smokes two packs a day. you like many others are concerned about his health and warn him of the dangers of smoking, especially at this rate. he ignores them all, and one day is diagnosed with lung cancer. some tactless friends tell him something to the effect "see, we had told you" at which point he loses his temper and accuses them of conspiring to make him cancer, or at the very least justifying his cancer. no. the friends were not doing either. they are not friends to cancer, but they know that it exists, and that smoking causes cancer. they are not the ones to blame for his cancer merely because they had predicted he could develop cancer by smoking so hard. they haven't caused it by pointing out the danger, nor did they "justify" it (it would have been a justification if they had said something like "serves you right", but they didn't, remember?). justification is the exercise of finding a moral cause for something done. if i had said something like "they did the genocide because they had to, and that was right" then that would be a justification. talat himself is reported to have said such things. that is justification. many turkish hardliners say that if he hadn't done it, turks would have been history in anatolia, and that we owe our existence partly to it. that is justification, too. the germans said comparable things to justify the holocaust. that was justification, too. justification is explanation PLUS a moral judgement in favour of the act. without that moral judgement, there is no justification. looking at european and especially german history, for instance, it is a no-brainer that some such act was imminent. there are plenty of precedents of it in european history, plus there was a terrible economic situation in germany (the inflation rate in germany in the two years preceding the war was about one trillion per cent). it is obvious in retrospect that something terrible was going to happen. this is explanation, and it can be found in most history books on wwii history, none of which can be accused of being tainted with anti-semitism. this is not justification. it would have been if they said something like "well, the germans had to do it to save their country". i understand fully that in an emotionally charged topic such as the holocaust or the ag, participants in a discussion can lose their temper and overlook this very fine but very significant difference between "explanation" on the one hand and "justification" on the other. suppose that we turn down all explanations regarding the ag and its subsequent denial as justifications and hence untenable. what then? how are we going to address the questions of why on earth turks killed the armenians after having lived side by side with them relatively peacefully until the 1890s, and why the are still denying it? and what is more pertinent, if we cannot explain, then how on earth are we going to tackle the problem of getting the turkish government recognise ag, since neither us (the turks who want to see it recognised) nor the armenians have the power to force it into such a recognition? if the armenian side is sincere in its desire to get ag recognised and relations with turkey normalised (as many of them, at least most of those in the roa claim to do) it cannot avoid paying attention to turkish sensitivities. there are two sides to this conflict, and a solution is impossible without negotiation and reaching common ground. you have to put on the table all the things, the things you cannot do without as well as the things you can do without, and we have to do the same. when we can develop a common list of sine qua nons that we can agree upon, a solution is possible. otherwise, this war of words and the blood feud keeps going on and on, and the greatest danger is that it can reconflagrate into yet another bloody conflict if the conditions in our part of the world give rise to a regional war (and that thing with iraq now gives me cold sweats). i have always striven to carefully weigh my words when addressing the issue (i do concede that in retrospect i can see that i have sometimes failed) because i am not here for idle talk, but actually do want to participate in any such reconciliation effort if a realisable one emerges. but i am alone (or one of the very few here), and even if there are more of us, we cannot achieve anything in turkey unless and until we find like-minded people on the armenian side with whom we can reach common ground. my recent experience here has made me very disappointed, as i now see that quite a few armenians do really have an agenda to claim land from turkey and get it, and will not stop at having the ag recognised, apologised and compensated for. people with this attitude are of course not the ones that either i can have a dialogue with, or can expect members of my nation to have. i do not know how much clearer our position could be stated. regards, [ September 12, 2002, 09:41 AM: Message edited by: aurguplu ]
  25. it has proved to be a futile exercise to attempt to establish a dialogue with you and find common ground. you are like arafat who kicked the table with peres when he was so close to getting most of what he wanted, and look what state he is in now.
×
×
  • Create New...