Jump to content

Twilight Bark

Members
  • Posts

    1,010
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Twilight Bark

  1. quote:Originally posted by bellthecat:If this message-board really was a place for genuine discussion and exploration of subjects like this, don't you think those academics that know or profess to know the field would visit here occasionally. But such names never appear. Are they all computer illiterate or do they just look down at us with embarassed scorn. Don't overestimate the genuine depth or value of the academics. Academia is first and foremost about careerism. If new insight comes out as a byproduct of their activity (which it does, but with a pitiful relative yield), it's a bonus. The academics would not "lower" themselves to internet forums because they are almost invariably snobs, and they perceive the marginal return (for their careers) of their interaction with the "proletariat" to be zero or negative (i.e. waste of their valuable time). These operating reasons for the academics' absence have little to do with the quality of discussions conducted or the quality of the arguments expressed in this Forum. I have seen too many academics with the intellectual life of a cow, or "famous" academics that are inexcusably dumb in their own field (let alone subjects outside their field) to crave for their input. Besides, in the anonymity of the internet you never know who is an academic and who is not with certainty. So I advise you focus on the ideas rather than the academic pedigree of their source. Twilight Bark
  2. Below is an exerpt from an invited article by Bjorn Lomborg (the author of the book “ The Skeptical Environmentalist ”) , which appeared in The Economist. The passage refers to a table in which the cost of saving a life by different "preventive measures" is documented; it ranges from 'Passing laws to make seat-belt use mandatory' at $69/life to 'Installing benzene emission control at rubber-tyre manufacturing plants' at $20,000,000,000/life. The moral of the exerpt is that man-made global warming does exist, and is poised to have serious consequences, but it is simply too expensive to slow it down in a meaningful way. He may be right. quote:Ignorance matters only when it leads to faulty judgments. But fear of largely imaginary environmental problems can divert political energy from dealing with real ones. The table above, showing the cost in the United States of various measures to save a year of a person's life, illustrates the danger. Some environmental policies, such as reducing lead in petrol and sulphur-dioxide emissions from fuel oil, are very cost-effective. But many of these are already in place. Most environmental measures are less cost-effective than interventions aimed at improving safety (such as installing air-bags in cars) and those involving medical screening and vaccination. Some are absurdly expensive. Yet a false perception of risk may be about to lead to errors more expensive even than controlling the emission of benzene at tyre plants. Carbon-dioxide emissions are causing the planet to warm. The best estimates are that the temperature will rise by some 2°-3°C in this century, causing considerable problems, almost exclusively in the developing world, at a total cost of $5,000 billion. Getting rid of global warming would thus seem to be a good idea. The question is whether the cure will actually be more costly than the ailment. Despite the intuition that something drastic needs to be done about such a costly problem, economic analyses clearly show that it will be far more expensive to cut carbon-dioxide emissions radically than to pay the costs of adaptation to the increased temperatures. The effect of the Kyoto Protocol on the climate would be minuscule, even if it were implemented in full. A model by Tom Wigley, one of the main authors of the reports of the UN Climate Change Panel, shows how an expected temperature increase of 2.1°C in 2100 would be diminished by the treaty to an increase of 1.9°C instead. Or, to put it another way, the temperature increase that the planet would have experienced in 2094 would be postponed to 2100. So the Kyoto agreement does not prevent global warming, but merely buys the world six years. Yet, the cost of Kyoto, for the United States alone, will be higher than the cost of solving the world's single most pressing health problem: providing universal access to clean drinking water and sanitation. Such measures would avoid 2m deaths every year, and prevent half a billion people from becoming seriously ill. And that is the best case. If the treaty were implemented inefficiently, the cost of Kyoto could approach $1 trillion, or more than five times the cost of worldwide water and sanitation coverage. For comparison, the total global-aid budget today is about $50 billion a year. To replace the litany with facts is crucial if people want to make the best possible decisions for the future. Of course, rational environmental management and environmental investment are good ideas—but the costs and benefits of such investments should be compared to those of similar investments in all the other important areas of human endeavour. It may be costly to be overly optimistic—but more costly still to be too pessimistic. [ October 02, 2002, 11:49 AM: Message edited by: Twilight Bark ]
  3. quote:Originally posted by MJ:I wonder what has changed in the human behavior over the last one year… It may be the higher temperatures due to global warming. Eskimos (a.k.a. Innuit, etc.) have been observing (and starting to make noises about) habitat destruction due to increased temperatures in the Arctic lately. Assuming the same phenomenon is occuring over the Antarctic, the shrinking of the ozone hole might perhaps be explained by the "human behavior" represented by global warming. Disclaimer: This is only a speculation, and not a religious statement.
  4. quote:ISTANBUL (Reuters) - Turkish scientists said on Tuesday the substance at the center of a nuclear weapons scare was not uranium and that the material seized in the south of the country posed no threat. ... Either that, or the material is sitting safely in a government facility, waiting to be assembled into the first Turkish atomic bomb. I thought I would start a nice little conspiracy theory for those with excess disposable time.
  5. I am no expert, so I'll try not to exceed my bounds. And my apologies to those who know more, and who know better. Of those, there are doubtless many. I agree with the theory that the mutual intelligibility depends strongly on one's command of any flavor of Armenian. Eastern Armenian speakers usually have no trouble understanding Western Armenian speakers, since they have grown up immersed in the language, exposed to it in all possible contexts, 24 hours a day. The difficulty is experienced mostly by Western Armenian speakers with a limited competence even in their own flavor of Armenian. I agree that the differentiation of sounds, competently stated by Arpa as usual, is a feature of Eastern Armenian that Western Armenian speakers should be envious of. I also agree that the ortography must be unified, and that much of Soviet-induced changes were unnecessary. On having many words for the same concepts, I say "the more the merrier". Instead of expunging the language of what we personally might think are "weird" words, structures, or grammatical rules, I say let's start merging the two flavors. Over time, "redundant" words and grammatical usages can take on subtly different meanings, enriching the language. Witness the remarkable expressive power of the hopelessly messy English language. I doubt that a Shakespeare would be produced with a tidy, economical language. Twilight Bark
  6. quote:Originally posted by THOTH:TB - no I have always thought your comments were pretty much on the mark Thanks Thoth. And thanks for the clarification. quote:- but I think you (and the others) have rejected Ali and branded him an extremist/denierSpeaking only for myself, I have called him neither an extremist nor a denier. After his recent crisis I called him a hardliner, because his far-out paranoid perceptions of what is being said here, and his obsession with territory puts him squarely in that category, regardless of his self-image. This does not make him an extremist, however, as it is the standard-issue mindset in the Turkish elite; i.e. he is not any more "extreme" than the "mainstream" Turkish political thought. Sad but true. And he certainly is not a denier. But how long can we keep congratulating him for seeing the obvious (admittedly not a mean feat in Turkey)?. What Armenians need is not an academic admission of the obvious, or a sterile and insincere "apology". What Armenians need is a truly reformed mindset in their gigantic neighbor. While you perhaps would like to take credit for "turning around" the "opponents" with your beer talk, I maintain that reasoned and honest arguments, despite being hurtful to the ego of the "opponent", do much more in creating progress. The point of having a discussion by definition involves a difference of opinion. And we cannot have much of a discussion by congratulating each other on how enlightened and reasonable we are. quote:I don't agree with the recent characterization of him as some hard-liner - even if I think he is clinging to some of the usual Turkish defensiveness type of postions.Since "the usual Turkish defensiveness" is a perfect specimen of hardliner attitudes, your statement is a contradiction in terms. Not all hardliners are deniers. I hope Ali Suat has begun to discover the hardliner in himself (assuming his apparent confusion and re-evaluation is sincere), and is working on bringing his thought system in line with his professed self-image. On another note, needless to say, I don't think any of the participants qualify as a "bad guy". I am sure we all are reasonably nice people. I also do not see much utility in periodically congratulating each other on how nice we all are.
  7. quote:Originally posted by THOTH: I understand your recent frustration (though not so much with MJ - as I think you have misinterpreted him) - but with some others who have focused on their points of disagreement with you (and were a bit nasty) I am curious Thoth. Do you include me in those who were "a bit nasty"? If so, could you expand on the points that you found unfairly "nasty"? Thanks.TB
  8. quote:Originally posted by aurguplu:the aim of your side is clear as far as i can see. You can see? Since you apparently cannot read, I thought you were perhaps "eyesight challenged". Ali Suat, you cannot see anything. quote:YOU WANT LAND, and the genocide is a side issue FOR YOU. What we want is a truly repentant, truly civilized neighbor. Too much to ask I know. Yes, yes, it obviously means we are hell-bent to destroy you. quote:the turkish hardliners that i had met ...Oh dearest Ali Suat, you are a hardliner. Maybe because you have been meeting those hardliners too often. quote:... instead i see myself proven wrong. You have indeed been proven wrong countless times. Just not in the way you are fantasizing it to be. Your entire understanding of the Armenian issue appears to be false. quote:what a waste of time it has been.If you exemplify the best and the brightest Turkey can offer right now, it has not been all a waste of time for us. It served as a good lesson for us, so we might come to our senses and stop having these futile discussions and focus on improving Armenian condition in Armenia and the diaspora. And no, our welfare does not depend on Turkey, as long as it doesn't decide to complete its "unfinished business".
  9. quote:Originally posted by Boghos:Hello TB, I just wished that Ali had the sort of reasoning you allude to. The poor chap is lost in so many contradictions and factual mistakes that it is not clear what he thinks or proposes all the time. I really don´t think he has any agenda, he just seems to find entertainment here. You see, people get a kick out of the most incredible things. It is just a pity that many of us, including myself, ever took him seriously. Poor soul. While I agree that it is sad to see Ali Suat break down like that, I still maintain that he does have an agenda of the sort I have been describing since I started reading his posts. However, I do sympathize with his frustration due to his unavoidable inability to reconcile his "enlightened" self-image, nationalistic views, and a desire to live up to his family name by accomplishing what he misguidedly felt was a win-win outcome. Going back to the drawing board is no fun. Just as Ali Suat hoped to find a microcosm of Armenian thought and attitudes in this particular forum, we can regard him, with all the expected flaws and unavoidable contradictions, as a representative example of the part of Turkish elite that is willing to talk (down) to Armenians.
  10. quote:Originally posted by Azat:There are ALWAYS exceptions to every rule. Is there an exception to that rule?
  11. quote:Originally posted by Boghos:It is beyond any reasonable doubt that the ROA would be entitled to claim land from Turkey. It is not reasonable to assume at present that such claims would have any practical consequences. Hi Boghos,You see, the "practical consequence" Ali and his "contacts" would like to see are of a different kind. They know full well that "land claims" issue has no practical consequence in terms of actual land changing hands. They also know that, some time far into the future, if Armenia is in a position to take historical Armenia by force, any piece of paper they signed (a long, long time ago) would be as constraining to them as Sevres is to Turkey now. The "practical consequence" they are after is to pull a fast one on Armenians so that they can appear oh-so-civilized and reformed to Europe and America, while having an excuse to weasel out of a true reckoning within their own populace. They want to be able to say: "See, we had a good reason to have the attitude we had; now that those intransigent Armenians promised that they are not going to send us to Central Asia, we admit that we did what we had to do in self-defence. Now let's move on with better things. Case closed." Very practical, indeed. Turkey has to do better than that. Not for Armenians, but for its own people.
  12. Hmm. Things are getting heated, even explosive. The trial balloons appear to be filled with hydrogen instead of helium. We know how that ends I know that my approach often lacks the machismo of realpolitik, swords, and dares. But let me repeat for our friend Ali, who is enchanted with "practical" considerations, out of the goodness of his heart. I said earlier, with no apparent registration in Ali's neural network: One consistent theme in Ali's drone is that "Armenians started it", so "only Armenians can end it". By accepting unjustifiable, unneeded, and uncalled-for preconditions for what is an intensely "private" act of Turks' collective self-introspection, Armenians would implicitly have acknowledged that they were indeed the stumbling block for the resolution of the "Armenian Question". This means, Ali, that Armenians are not going to accept such a silly and paranoid precondition because it would validate the incorrect contention that Armenians presented a real danger to Turks and Turkey then and now, and that both the creation and the solution of the "Armenian Problem" rested on something Armenians should have (or should not have, as the case may be) done. I think you should put the gun to our heads, as usual, to get us to do that. If that would look, er , uhm, too undiplomatic, then perhaps you should drop the issue.
  13. quote:Originally posted by aurguplu:to everyone, ... not because i am "chickening out" or anything ... It is clear that you are. To be exact, you are playing a deaf chicken. Indeed, take your own advice and read what I wrote if you disagree with that assessment. We say we don't have land claims, but we find it unacceptable, unjustified, and undignified to be shoved preconditions to our faces, you retort that this stance means we want to eradicate the Turks out of Anatolia. If this is the level of comprehension and logic you utilized to get your precious degrees, all I can say is "vah" for those institutions. And you never touch the issue of meaningful repatriation (even symbolically), cultural and administrative autonomy, and the "unitary" dogma of your country. Barely "tolerating" the existence of non-Turkish identities in Anatolia until they are bulldosed, bribed, and brainwashed out of existence is the fundamental ideology of your government (and I am not talking about the Ottoman Empire now), and your stance differs only in its poor attempt at sugar-coating it. Again, I want to repeat that you are not hated here, Ali. But it would be good if you took a break and do some soul-searching and reflection, and try to understand what I am saying. That is, of course, if you are sincere about a true reconciliation between Turks and Armenians. Assuming that you are sincere about wanting a true reconciliation but are simply confused, and that you do eventually understand what I am (and am not) saying, you would have to agree with me. But then, there is a good chance that you will stay silent, because your new stance would be too dangerous in Turkey, even for a well-connected aristocrat like you. Of course, there is also a good chance that you never cared for a true reconciliation, but for a quick fix to get those pesky Armenians off Turks' back, and exorcise those pesky Armenian ghosts flying around (a feat that would elevate you from a lesser Urguplu to a hall-of-fame Urguplu; nice thought). In that case, never mind; just wait a couple of months and come back with the same old arguments with the hope that the little crowd that coldly dissects and analyzes your posts into the trash can labelled "Defective" (also called "peer review" in some circles) will have moved somewhere else. [ September 24, 2002, 10:49 AM: Message edited by: Twilight Bark ]
  14. quote: ... corruption always infests and procreates amongst less developed and financially poor countries. I am not going to bring examples of third world countries but let’s look at Italy. Italy is a truly divided country. The northern part is well developed and financially affluent and less corrupt but on the other hand in the south corruption and mafia is still prevalent due mostly for lock of opportunities and less development. Hi Rubo,I agree with the spirit of what you wrote. But I'll chime in with my take. There is a strong correlation between economic development and lack of corruption. However, it is a "chicken or egg" sort of problem. Is the economy stagnant because of corruption, or is it corrupt because of a lack of legitimate opportunities presented by a vibrant economy? This is a question that even the best economists have not been able to answer satisfactorily, let alone find a solution to the problem. It is a vicious cycle that can be broken either by an external factor, or a cultural shift. In my view, a quick exit from the cycle of corruption and economic stagnation will almost certainly rely on a few "extraordinary" individuals that do not conform to the "norms of behavior" of the society caught up in the loop and have sufficient political and financial clout. So, if you want to make a big difference, focus on making a ton of money, and start your strong-willed NGO (non-governmental organization). Make your huge investments conditional upon the fulfillment of the needed "structural reforms", and allow the political leadership to take credit for the positive outcomes. Anyone here with the money? TB [ September 23, 2002, 11:32 AM: Message edited by: Twilight Bark ]
  15. It is no surprise that the usual contributors wound down their "contributions" to the subject. There is little point in repeating the same arguments. What would be useful is a compilation of the arguments in a concise, to-the-point form, for the benefit of "newcomers". We have an unwieldy collection of posts all over the forum, with high redundancy, sometimes hiding under irrelevant topics. Of course, any attempt to summarize the arguments into a single document will launch a fresh wave of verbal diarrhea, but that is life. In any case, the quality of the thoughts unfortunately has a roughly inverse relationship with the amount of disposable time the contributors have. Therefore, I don't expect a competent summary to show up anytime soon. I certainly am not volunteering. One consistent theme in Ali's drone is that "Armenians started it", so "only Armenians can end it". By accepting unjustifiable, unneeded, and uncalled-for preconditions for what is an intensely "private" act of Turks' collective self-introspection, Armenians would implicitly have acknowledged that they were indeed the stumbling block for the resolution of the "Armenian Question". Armenians are no longer the naive bunch that you take them for, our dear aristocratic Ali Suat. I hope you have gathered as much by now. Although Ali has chickened out of addressing my responses, I do have one message for him, which has been repeated countless times in different forms, by me, as well as MJ and others: Turks' reconciling honestly with their own history and genesis is vastly more beneficial for Turks than it is for Armenians. As such, Turkey has no right or reason to set preconditions for what is a fundamental and badly needed act of self-evaluation. Just as a genocide recognition shoved down Turks' throats is meaningless at best and probably counterproductive, shoving an arrogant ultimatum based on realpolitik, paranoia and falsified "history" down the victims' throats is both morally repugnant and devoid of pragmatic utility. Turks don't need Armenians' help to do what they need to do. Gather up your courage and do it. Or do nothing and suffer the smell of cultural rot around you silently. [ September 23, 2002, 10:37 AM: Message edited by: Twilight Bark ]
  16. I discarded my yet another long-winded reply to Ali, after seeing how the tone of the discussion deteriorated and that we don't seem to have an actual dialogue. I want to state once again that I do not harbor even a particle of hate towards Ali. I do think Ali's thought system is inconsistent and in need of serious repair. If my analyses of what he writes sounds harsh, it is only because of my annoyance at an intellectual level. Ali may be an intelligent man, but he does say many things that are simply not intelligent at all. I would find the idea that the Turks are oh-so-afraid of the big, bad Armenians funny if it were not so annoyingly misguided and misplaced. Turks are afraid of the Armenian ghosts, and are demanding our help in exorcising them. And the price Ali is hypothetically offering is (perhaps) some pocket money and a promise (of dubious credibility at best) that they will allow the remaining Armenians of the planet to pretend to have dignity. Again, I am not discarding the offer, but simply stating what it actually is. And if you care to follow the evolution of Ali's arguments, now the culprit is no longer the big, bad Turkish population threatening to revolt at the face of recognition, but the state that is acting according to its own agenda. Ali has to understand that some Armenians get infuriated by his comments because he is shoving "realpolitik" on their faces, and is expecting gratitude in return. Forget about "recognition", "apology" and the rest of the insincere nonsense Ali is peddling. If Turkey started treating Armenians as normal human beings, they will "discover" that their paranoia is baseless, and that things can start moving along just fine. There are many, many holes, in Ali's system of thoughts, but I will stop addressing them, as he avoids any real argument and either comes back in a "victim" mode, or starts peddling the same old insensitive, arrogant positions. The fact that Ali comes here and talks to Armenians does not mean as much as some might think it does. I would like to remind the forum that the first prominent Turkish politician to visit Armenia was none other than Turkesh, the head of the ultrachauvinist party MHP. Speaking of MHP, their pre-1980 vote percentages were at times in the teens, and not in the mid single digits as Ali would have us believe. Ali, if you start working on your government's attitude towards Armenians, you would be expending your efforts more fruitfully. Be nice to the Armenians for a change. If Armenians do not respond in kind, and start building weapons, you can always go back to your traditional attitude before they become this big, bad monster you are so afraid of. Now I will stop addressing this issue. All that can possibly be said has been said. It is the responsibility of the reader to arrive at a self-consistent and practical view of reality, using what has been said on this forum as a guide. One last word. I agree with Thoth that we are all guilty of some form of arrogance by virtue of the fact that we think we have something worthwhile to say that others need to listen to and learn from. I intend to be quiet for a while, and focus on being a good person, and hopefully a good Armenian as well. Regards to all, Twilight Bark [ September 12, 2002, 02:34 PM: Message edited by: Twilight Bark ]
  17. quote:Originally posted by aurguplu:the major problem is the lands. turks will not accept any claims for obvious reasons plus the fact that before the genocide there was no independent armenia. the turkish conquests of the 11th-13th centuries were like any oter conquests and you cannot realistically extend the genocide issue that far back. if you did, and succeded, then it would set a precedent for similar such claims re the americas, australia etc, indeed, much of the world. First of all, the absence of presence of independent Armenia at the time of the Genocide is irrelevant. Instead of embracing Armenians as part of its population, Turkey chose to exterminate them. If a country cannot be trusted to provide a section of its population with a reasonable level of human rights (such as the right to live, to begin with), it loses its right to govern them. Can you do it the second time around? You don't seem to think so. In fact, you don't think it is a necessary skill for Turkey to acquire. Second, there are no official land claims. Nonexistent official claims are impossible to retract officially. And nonofficial "demands" cannot be retracted, as they simply reflct the private thoughts and wishes of private individuals. Who has the power to lobotomize Armenian brains, or tell them how to feel? And is it a desirable power to have, if it existed? You want the Armenian Government to sign a piece of paper saying that they will never, ever demand anything from Turkey, in return for Turkey becoming semi-civilized and "normal" in its attitude towards them. Strange attitude from someone who is convinced that borders are soon to be abolished and become irrelevant. Even stranger for the party who has a lot of apologizing to do. I have a better suggestion. Turkey starts being really nice to Armenia and Armenians, without silly preconditions to tell the future generations what to want or not want. I bet those future generations of Armenians will not want to break a friend's heart. Especially a friend that repents sincerely and tries everything possible to mend its past wrongs. Right. quote:the problem is that turks have a genuine fear that you guys are up to kicking our asses back to central asia, after all, the sevres treaty was very much in that spirit. so they block every move on your part that they perceive as an attempt on their country's integrity. to get any headway in arguments with the bulk of the turkish population, you first have to realise and accept it as the basis of of your position toward us that no part of turkey will be ceded to anyone else peacefully. assuming that you are not envisaging a military confrontation with turkey, this basically means that you have to accept turkish teritorial integrity. Obsessed about Territory, are we? Turkey's territories are safe, and you bloody well know it. You just want Armenians to acknowledge that they have no rights on these lands. Sort of an international version of "declaring it kosher". It somehow maddens you that it is not "helal" (muslim version of kosher). What does Turkey offer to make it kosher, Ali? The promise that they will not commit another genocide? How generous. Oh, I forgot. Of course the IMF and World Bank dollars, courtesy of the American taxpayers. Perhaps you can approach individual Armenians and bribe them into signing away their individual moral right to live on those lands autonomously as Armenians. If it is a good deal, I am sure you will have many takers. Consider it a sort of rent. Since Turkey does not wish to regard Armenia as representing all Armenians, that would be the only logical alternative. Of course, there is the status quo that Turkey seems to like. quote:now about getting back to the land and living on it with those bloodthirsty bastards (us): i think that if turks are genuinely convinced that you do are not going to use your return to turkey as a step to eventual secession, they can be brought to accept it. note that many turks could be made to agree that you have a moral right to live in anatolia (it is kind of obvious), the same way that many americans can NOW (not forty years ago)can be made to accept the moral right of a native american to live on his ancestors' soil. the problem is that they fear that you will once again attempt to take the land away. I think "you guys" are not afraid of the real, living Armenians, as you know that we are not a serious threat. What you are afraid of are the Armenian ghosts floating above and inside your heads. It looks more and more like you are trying buy some sort of an exorcism. quote:that is why i had said about 100 years for your return. i do not think it is a geological time scale. 100 years ago you were armenians, today you still are, and 100 years on you will still be (and the ability of the diaspora to retain its identity is really its own responsibility). Since you did not offer a sincere repentance, and view the whole thing as some sort of a "trade", you made the absurd claim that Turks would "acknowledge", "apologize", and "pay reparations", and yet would not tolerate Armenians on "their" soil. A fake apology and a little bribe with other people's money to get the Armenians' off your back. I am not necessarily saying that it is a bad deal for Armenians. But I am saying that it has nothing to do with true repentance and reconciliation. I have also observed that you consistently avoided any discussion of a federal structure in Turkey that would allow different cultures (Turkish, Armenian, Kurdish) and identities to exist with their head equally high. Right boss? quote:now of course what turks would fear here (and rightly) is a version of the israeli-palestinian problem. this is a very pertinent example and how it could be addressed, in case what i have outlined above actually takes place, i do not know. Israeli-Palestinian conflict (after the Oslo accords) is not complicated. Neither is the resolution of Turkish-Armenian problems. Both problems are fed by a toxic combination of arrogance and paranoia by one of the sides. Inept leadership on the "weaker" side (surprise, surprise!) has always made it worse, but was never at the root of the problem. If the strong side dropped the arrogance and the paranoia, the solution would be easy. But then, this would be like saying "stupid people should wise up" or "bad people should become good". Now I deserve a "duh" from the audience. quote:armenia on its own of course does not worry us, but armenia plus russia plus europe plus the usa does.This is pretty ludicrous. A martian listening in would think that Turkey was under some sort of a terrible siege. Why on earth would all the powers-that-be of the planet come together in support of Armenians, and against an "ally", against all their political instincts at all levels? You really need to live outside of Turkey for a while, Ali. The paranoia appears to have infested your mind thoroughly. And it is not our duty to snap you out of your paranoia. You are asking us to confirm that your paranoia has a credible basis in fact. Well, I will not do that. quote:clear? Sure. In fact very transparent. One day it may even be clear to you too.
  18. quote:Originally posted by Rubo:Listen Eduard, I am not here wasting time fighting…but your comment, the implication that TB might be a Turk is unrealistic and unfounded. Please read recent genocide thread and his responses to Ali and you will have no doubt furthermore it might teach you about patriotism which has many shades from borderline suicidal to contemplative productive.Please don’t expect everyone to be carbon copy of yourself. Thanks a bunch Rubo.
  19. quote:Originally posted by aurguplu:1. i reasoned that hagarag did not mean to get all the land by and for himself, and that he was referring to a desire common to many armenians. i am of course aware enough of the fact that armenians are as diverse on this subject as any nation would be to make a detailed point of the matter unnecessary. The point is, dear Ali, what Armenians wish in their hearts is their own business. It has nothing to do with what they would actually attempt to do. It is not even obvious that Armenians would attempt to grab land (populated by other people) if they had the chance (which they won't, as the time required for the prerequisite power-shift in the region is longer than the likely time-scale of EU-type integration.) You can safely let Armenians feel as they wish, without losing a square inch of your oh-so-sacred Territory (may peace be upon It). quote:2. the "empire builders" of ours (who are they?) you refer to have cosy relations with the army, just as everyone else in the country, simply because the alternative has proved too dangerous. i am not a bit proud of that fact, but wouldn't blame our civilians for it. moreover, what "empire building" activity have we engaged in after the fall of the last one (and don't cite me cyprus, you know it wasn't one)?Oh this is simple. Three letters: MHP. I hoped it was apparent that I used the term "empire builder" somewhat sarcastically to refer to their wet dreams. quote:3. i am a bit disappointed that after two years of my presence in this forum (gosh, it has been long) some people still do not dig it that i do not for a moment question/challenge armenian moral right to live in anatolia. in fact, i propose solutions that involve resettlement of armenians in turkey that are derided/refuted/taken as dishonest by many. and then you talk about getting the lands back, fully realising at the same time that you don't and won't have the power in the foreseeable future to remove the turks from there by force. don't you see a contradiction there? "I" am not talking about getting any lands back. Others might, over shish-kebab and pilaf in a backyard somewhere in Los Angeles. So what? I only suspect your dishonesty when you say it would take another 100 years (after the recognition and possible reparations) or so to safely invite Armenians back to their ancestral lands. I won't repeat why it is absurd and disingenuous, but I will say that Armenians are not the dangerous animals you appear to imagine them to be (I know you don't think that; which leaves the only rational alternative of your being less than sincere). quote:4. i think i had stated clearly that what at least i am against is not armenians coming back to turkey, but a part of turkey being ceded to armenia or any other country. it is a basic desire to keep your territory intact. I know that you are not against their return on a geological time scale. Preferably after the diaspora completely disappeared, Armenia got depopulated further, Turkey reached a population of 250 million, and started running the EU. quote:5. i agree with your czechoslovakia example, but do not forget that these people were until relatively recently under austro-hungarian empire, and czechoslovakia came into being after the wwi, and then it was run over by the germans in wwii, and by the russians in 1967. besides, the czechs were quite happy to see slovaks go because they were a bit of a burden, and it was that ex-commie former boxer meciar who wanted his own little turf closer to russia who engineered the whole thing. i should very much ask the slovaks now whether they are so happy with it now. Whatever. Civilized countries handle self-determination in a manner radically different from (and superior to) the uncivilized ones. End of story. quote:6. our right to be in anatolia does not only derive from our sword. we have mixed with the indigenous population to such and extent and took over so many aspects of their culture that in practical terms we are turkish-speaking anatolians. if it weren't for our different language and a few items in our arts & crafts & music, and a few other cultural things, how would you be able to tell us from the rest? we are almost as anatolian as you are, and central asia is as strange place to us today as it is to you. In fact, your moral rights are compromised by your sword. But it is irrelevant now. So is your "indigenous" genes, when you reject the identity of the bearers of those genes. The genes are relevant only in the laboratory. So, what is relevant? Just the fact that people that call themselves Turks or Kurds live on the land now, and they themselves are not invaders. That is where their right comes from. End of story. I don't care if their parents were Martian invaders. quote:7. if i didn't feel that the land belonged as much to the armenians, greeks and kurds and others who lived on it for ages as it did to turks, then what in the hell do you think i am doing here talking to you? You are marketing a vision that is orders of magnitude better than the sophomoric silliness cooked up by your government. I am simply saying that you still need to revise your product before a serious introduction into the market. Then again, I am not the person that you need to talk to. If Turkey bothered to allow diplomatic relations, you could visit the Armenian embassy and perhaps talk to someone relevant. quote:sorry this has not been in very clear sequence, but i hope it is clear.In the time we can spare for this dialogue, this is the best we can be expected to do. quote:regards,Likewise
  20. quote:Originally posted by aurguplu:hagarag, was it you who had told me in a previous discussion under a different thread that you guys were not trying to carve up my country, or was it someone else, and if it was someone else, could i please get a coment from him about your posting? Hi Ali, I do not know if I am the “someone else” you had in mind, but I'll use the break I granted myself to pitch in anyway. First, "you guys" and "hagarag" are not synonymous, to say the least. "Us guys" (and there is really no such coherent entity as far as the issue is concerned) includes people who want nothing more than an acknowledgement (not even an apology) of history, and move on with their lives toward full assimilation into cultural oblivion, feeling good that their grandparents did not hallucinate the whole genocide thing. In fact, "us guys" includes those who want to drop the whole issue and move on, and pretend that Armenians are a "normal" nation, hoping that it could become one by declaring itself so. “Us guys" includes those who enjoy dreaming that a few of the provinces containing the most "significant" Armenian totems like Mt. Ararat and Aghtamar can become Armenian again. And of course "us guys" includes those whose wet dreams involve a "sea to sea" Armenian Empire. And then of course there is the "mainstream" Armenians, who are too busy with life to think much on such silly subjects one way or the other. I am sure you can make a similar categorization about "you guys", except that your "empire builders" are a lot more numerous, are on the ground (rather than in some faraway place a continent or two away, fully submerged in the safety and comfort of the eventual graveyard of their culture and identity), and have afrighteningly cosy relationship with the army, which happens to be the most powerful one in the region by far. As far as “carving up my country”, how melodramatic of you. You think hagarag will draw his sword made of celery, and throw bean-powered bombs to carve up “your” country? Even if the territory in question were granted to Armenians, it wouldn’t qualify as “carving up”. And in some unlikely scenario where Armenians re-populate their ancestral lands and proceed to demand independence, why do you think it would be such a tragedy? And do you think there are ways in which Turkey could prevent such a “tragedy”? If you don’t, then I suggest you think harder. And in case Turkey couldn’t prevent oh-such-a-melodramatic tragedy, you can take comfort from the fact that Czechoslovakia split into two pieces, and produced two stable and healthy countries, without the Czechs feeling the urge to wipe the Slovaks out of existence, or refusing to deal with Slovakia. And Canada has no immediate plans to punish Quebec into submission or send its residents to France. There is no question that Armenians have the moral right to live on their ancestral lands of many millennia, especially considering the circumstances of their “removal”. Now if you cannot make them happy after they come back, perhaps the land in question does not and should not belong to you. If Armenians do not bother to come back in significant numbers, then they forfeit their moral right to live on it except as tourists or “ordinary” Turkish citizens. In any event, I suspect that a country with the vision to invite back the few Armenians that would bother to come would also have the level of intellectual development that ensures a harmonious coexistence, with all the cultural freedoms and local governance. But don’t worry Ali, the paranoia and territorial obsession displayed by “the best and the brightest” of your society makes a true reconciliation seem like a distant dream that it probably is. Finally, it seems that it is not enough for us to say “we can’t imagine demanding lands from you, because you are too powerful” (paraphrasing Kocharian). You want to censor our thoughts and emotions, so we cannot even wish to live on those lands as Armenians without being accused of complicity in land-grabbing. You want us to tear away from our hearts the places that formed the main body of our nation. As an avid proponent of realpolitik thinking, you surely understand the polite position of “We don’t demand it because we know we cannot get it”. Leave it at that. When discussing matters related to genocide and ethnic cleansing, there is one overriding factor above all else: morality. It is morally hollow (to say the least) to “repent” and yet forbid the descendants from coming back to those lands. Once you fulfill your unavoidable and morally required task, it is then your responsibility to ensure that those that come back have no reason to ask for outright independence. If Turkey can’t imagine doing that, it need not bother the Armenians with silly displays of “Oh I am so sorry”. Here is one censorship (or perhaps self-restraint) homework for you Ali: until you feel in your heart and know in your mind that the land in question belongs as much to Armenians as to Turks and Kurds that now live on it, refrain from trying to sound so enlightened. Once you and the rest of the “best and the brightest” internalize that notion, the two nations can “play it again”, hopefully with much happier results this time for all involved. This may be news to you, but the ball is in your court. Regards, Twilight Bark
  21. Hi people, Just dropping by. Nice story, but I doubt that the kid in the story is Armenian. I don't recognize the first or the last name as Armenian, and -ian ending is not uncommon among Iranians. Take care all, TB
  22. quote:Originally posted by THOTH: I do think you are being (overly) harsh on Ali Dear Thoth,If a reasoned response to his statements sounds harsh, there is not much for the conveyor of the respose to do about it. quote:I'm not sure I understand the relevance of the issue of Turks being 2500 years junior to Armenians in Anatolia. It is not relevant to the "right to the land", as I indicated in earlier posts many times. You should know by now that I do not think in those terms. However, Ali is taking a "take no prisoners" approach and is trying to prove (to no useful end) that Turks are as "native" as Armenians (even though that is of no consequence, as you would agree). I am addressing his assertions on that subject in isolation from any discussion of population movements or exchanges. Self-consistency is the first test that a thought system must pass. Then would come morality. And then of course would come practicality. Ali often falls into the usual trap of bypassing the first two tests and starts celebrating the superficial appearance of "practicality" of his thoughts. quote:What I am trying to say is that we cannot just wish the Turks away. Neither can we make the claim that the Turks of today are not Anatolians and that they do not (as well) have rights to the land.I hope you are not implying that such nonsense can be concluded from what I wrote. Regards, Twilight Bark [ August 23, 2002, 10:43 AM: Message edited by: Twilight Bark ]
  23. Dear Ali Suat, Here is a partial analysis of and responses to the points you raised earlier. quote:1. subconscious: if i were that sort of guy, then what am i doing here trying to establish a dialogue with you?I am not sure. I already expressed my take on your motivations. No inconsistency there. quote:2. what i said earlier: it wasn't an exercise in wishful thinking, it was (i believe) a coldly realistic position: suppose we admit to the genocide tomorrow, before it has sunk into the population, and armenians come back (assuming that you will actually find any armenians who would want to return to live side by side with the turks, and in eastern anatolia of all places). there will inevitably be brushes between the two peoples. as i have stated numerous times in this forum, the overwhelming majority of the turkish (and kurdish) population enuinely believes that there was no genocide, and that the armenians behaved just as atrociously as the turks and kurds (meanwhile again most do not deny the killings themselves). the armenians believe the diametrical opposite with equal passion. and since this is not an intellectual exercise but a tragedy that affected every turk and armenian directly or indirectly, it is extremely likely that eruptions here and there will occur. therefore i would frankly speaking be wary of any large scale settlement of the places concerned before both peoples (as opposed to states) actually reached common ground. Your response fails by lacking logical self-consistency and moral integrity, as well as being based on an unrealistic assessment of how the dynamics of “recognition” would play out. Other than that, it is a fine response. First of all, you contradict your own thesis by implying (correctly) that there would not be a huge influx of Armenians willing to face the hardships of such a relocation, which conflicts your assertion that a genuine desire to invite the Armenians back would somehow be dangerous. Then, you wish us to believe that a public recognition and (by your admission huge) reparations by the state would not be accompanied by a wide and deep public discourse and awakening of the Turkish public, and that ordinary citizens would doggedly continue to believe the fairy tales they had been fed earlier. And yet they would go along with the “humiliation” of accepting and paying for a crime they still believe was not in fact committed. Gee Ali, are you sure you don’t want a nice bridge? It seems you are in the bridge-marketing business up to your ears. quote:3. my intelligently nationalistic position. well, i am nationalistic (but not the kind that says we are the best and destined to rule everyone else). and i take "intelligently" as a compliment, thank you. i am sure you understand that i am a turk after all and my position will always be a turkish one (as you are an armenian after all and yours will be an armenian one). we have to accept that there is no suc thing as "objective truth" in these matters, and i am afraid the same thing goes for "justice". i do genuinely think that armenians have been wronged and something must be done to right it, but that something will have to stop short of actually ceding territory or any other steps that will eventually lead to it. look at the middle east now and tell mre whether it is at all realistic in that poitical environment to allow any large-scale armenian resettlement in anatolia and not expect a separatist warfare in a few decades' time at best. i have people whose interests have to be defended, and if we don't, then who will?The old realpolitik argument. And as usual it simply means “I really have to act like a bully and a thief; it is my nature. Sorry, it cannot be helped. So buzz off.” It wouldn’t work because the Turkish elite (not the people as you would have us believe) wouldn’t let it. Not because it cannot work for some fundamental reason. You share the same obsession with territory (and place it above all other human considerations) as the rest of the Turkish elite. Exactly what are you offering Ali? Clearing your own conscience (good for you), and some hush-money (speaking only for myself, I don’t want the money)? Is it somehow the Armenians’ duty to help you become better people (the advantages of having a less insane neighbor notwithstanding)? We have our own inept and corrupt to keep us busy for quite some time. Talk to the EU for the lessons. As for “steps that lead to ceding territory”, how much assurance do you need? After all, tolerating an independent Armenia right next to the Territories (capitalized, since it appears to be sacred in your particular brand of secular religion) is a “step” that may lead to losing those Territories one day, when Turkey is weak and preoccupied, and Armenia is strong and armed to the teeth, say in 217 years. Perhaps it is better to dissolve the source of this “risk” now? Where do you stop? As MJ repeatedly says, we are not trading territories here. We can only discuss the moral and intellectual aspects of history and cultural interactions. Let us stop pretending to be representatives of states. You are not defending “your people” here. You are defending a certain way of looking at the world; a way that I find profoundly and increasingly lacking in aesthetics, logical integrity and morality. Leave the “negotiations” to those that are authorized to do it. Or, if you want pretend negotiations, come to the table with something that Armenians would be interested in. quote:4. accept the crime but not the consequences: no. but don't forget that no-one who took part in the crime is alive today (unless they are past 100). so we are not the criminals ourselves. you might argue that we are their descendants. true, and so are the americans, the australians and anyone else who is in a country that was invaded by his ancestors. and so are you, after all, you (or rather your language) came here from somewhere else (the balkans). the fact that it was three thousand years ago does not make it any different: imagine we hold on for another two thousand years: we'll be just as native as you guys are now. ). I did not say “your” crime. I said “the crime”, whose sole beneficiary is “you” (plural). You accept the crime, but do not wish to even discuss any rights whatsoever of the heirs to the stolen “property”, which you only bother remember having when someone else talks about it. Your “comparison” (and implied equating) of letting Armenians into their ancestral lands to cleansing the continents of Australia and the Americas of non-indigenous settlers is silly and disingenuous. Even if you did actually sent the small population of the relevant part of Eastern Anatola to Western Turkey, which nobody (that matters) is proposing, and gave it to Armenia as a present, which nobody (that matters) is suggesting, the country of Turkey would still be alive and well. The discussion here on this forum has never taken the tone of “you Mongols go back home”, so please stop attacking that straw-man. And the “slippery-slope” argument that you might have up your sleeve does not apply either. Greeks of Ionia were not subjected to genocide, but were rudely sent to Greece as part of a population exchange agreed by the two states. And the rest of Anatolia is largely a bunch of chameleons that have changed their identity half a dozen times; the Turkish one being the latest. Who knows, in another 1000 years they may think they are regular Vikings. Your attempt to compare Armenians to the natives of Australia and the Americas exposes more disingenuousness on your part. You do not hesitate to model your “proper” response after the behavior of aggressor peoples and states, and yet you urge us to model our response after peoples that have been solidly dumped into the “loser” category by the winners. By the time they developed enough organization, coherence and a collective “identity” the said groups had lost everything, and were at the mercy of the “winners”. That is not the case with Armenians. For all their faults, they are at a qualitatively different level of cultural development and organization (after all, they have a state that exists to represent their interests), and under no obligation to roll over and play dead. I am sure you know the Turkish proverb: “Babies that don’t cry don’t get fed”. And even the pathetic remnants of the surviving tribes in the US now have considerable sovereign rights on their tribal lands, without cleansing the whites out of the continent; not that I am advocating a “reservation” type of disgrace. As for being as native as us, you are again on shaky ground. This is like devout Christians saying “We are as pagan as any pagan today; after all, all of our ancestors were pagans”. Especially for someone that defines (and is in fact obliged to define) ethnicity not by ancestry but by declaration, you appear to assign undue importance to the identity of the ancestors; an identity that you by definition betrayed and rejected. No Ali, you are not native even if your genes are 100% Anatolian. And I will not address the “Armenians are from Balkans” nonsense yet again; I already explained why it makes no sense. It is too convenient a fiction for you to listen to logic on the subject. Just stop talking from both sides of your mouth; and that will be sufficient. The Turkish identity in Anatolia antedates the Armenian one by 2500 years. That will always remain the same. In the year 100,000 AD the fractional difference will indeed be small and insignificant. Until then, resign to the significance of the 2500 years. quote:no, i am not saying acknowledge the crime but not the consequences: the consequences, such as compensation, should eventually be paid and will amount to a hefty bill. Keep your (non-existent) money, and give us the rights. The most important thing you stole from the Armenians is not their assets and properties; it is their unalienable right to live on their ancestral lands. Start with that one, and then go from there. If you cannot change your constitution, state structure, and attitudes to allow an autonomous Armenian existence in Eastern Anatolia, what exactly are you offering? Some pocket-change courtesy of the American taxpayers? quote:5. re regarding the return of the armenians as "cultural enlightenment": i checked the genocide posting "turkish misinformation" today (2 august 2002) and saw hagarag's and other guys' postings there. and you want me to trust those returning armenians? would you if you were me? This is in fact a continuation and repetition of point 2 among others. Now let's assume that significant numbers of Armenians did come to Eastern Anatolia. They would certainly demand (and deserve) cultural and administrative autonomy. The current, heavy-handed, centralized Turkish state is incompatible with such needs. This is of course largely irrelevant to the utopia we are discussing, since an enlightened Turkey that wants Armenians back would in all likelihood be a decentralized state that instinctively provides plenty of local autonomy, and great cultural freedom. The point at which we actually diverge is the mechanism and timing of genocide recognition and cultural enlightenment. You seem to imply that the ruling elite would like to acknowledge the historical truth but is somehow intimidated by popular backlash. The Turkish population is quite malleable (the word “sheep” comes to mind), and it would be a matter of months for the establishment to re-educate the population, which will certainly not stage an uprising because of it. There will be a lot of shock and subsequent yelling and screaming, but that is all. After a couple of years, people would look back to the earlier state propaganda as the post-Soviet population looks at Soviet propaganda. But you in fact do not seem to wish for that to happen. The recognition and the associated awakening in Turkey are not uncoupled events, with the latter lagging behind the former by 100 years, your apparent wishes notwithstanding. As MJ tells you, Armenians will not come back to be ordinary Turkish citizens. Without cultural and administrative autonomy, the "invitation" is not sincere. And if such a state offends your "unitary" sensibilities, so be it. And if the Armenians are not treated satisfactorily on their ancestral lands, and their pleas are ignored, they might indeed express a desire for greater freedom, eventually approaching independence. You are essentially saying "We'll accept and repent for the crime, but we'll repeat it if you piss us off; so let's not get into such a situation again. Know your place, and know who's the boss." Do you really have such a dim view of your people? Do you really think they are so incorrigible? How many centuries do you need to get rid of the very arrogance that is the ultimate cause of the Genocide? As I said, if the “recognition” is not a result of a sincere and fundamental Turkish enlightenment, and is a superficial, forced gesture, it offers no benefits to Armenians. So spare yourselves the trouble, and spare the rest of the world from the deception. quote:i am still an optimist, and i think in 100 years' time there will hardly be any borders left in the region, as is the case with europe.Taking your statements at face value, you are in fact a pessimist. One that does not believe a bully state can change its ways, that the population cannot possibly be enlightened despite huge changes around them and a complete change in the ideology of their state, and only their great-grandchildren could have a hope of being tolerant of other cultures, due to being bribed and brainwashed by the new EU order. Gosh, I wonder what your thoughts are when you are actually in a pessimistic mood, Ali. quote: but our descendants will be very different from us and will have acquired other notions of morality, humanity, courage, patriotism etc., mind you. they will persist as turks and armenians, but these will mean very different things to them than they do to us now. think about it.I certainly hope that the new Turkish generation is already capable of such evolution, given the right guidance. And with all due respect, you really do not know or understand my notions about the said concepts. However, expect them to pop into the ears of your descendants. They may even come from their own parents. Twilight Bark
  24. quote:Originally posted by Rubo:I am glad to be part of this forum and I am looking forward to "meet" you all.Some of you already know me as Argishti from other forums.TB I hope you are doing fine. Regards to all Hi Ruben, Nice to see you here. Life is too hectic right now (and will remain so for about a month or so) for me to contribute much to the discussions. No, it's not "bait and switch" , just life. This is a good forum to feel at home for a decent, mentally active Armenian. At the end of the day, one doesn't leave depressed, with a bad taste in one's virtual mouth. And that despite much self-critique, self-evaluation, soul-searching and little self-flattery. Again, welcome. Best, TB
  25. quote:Let me start claiming that that there has been not a slightest desire or attempt from my side to subject you (of all the people) to sarcasm. If, against my will, I have come across as sarcastic - I apologize.And I apologize for being hypersensitive . That's what you get from two men who are either sleepless or tired or both. quote:Also, in an attempt to tackle over the Internet such a huge issue, our discussion becoming prolonged and extended, has somewhat lost its axis and focus. Maybe. But we covered more in two days, in a fairly logical fashion, than some forums cover during their miserable lifetimes. quote:There may be a mountain of evidence to condemn Australia for its past actions against its aborigines, but I am not exposed to it. Therefore, I will refrain from making comments on a subject where I don't have strong backgroundWe also have not personally lived among the Armenians of 100-600 years ago. Just as the European settlers might not have intended a straightforward genocide, even if the result looks as if they did, we may be then be excused for refraining from being too hard on the Armenians of the period, among which we did not live, and whose constraints we do not have. quote:Continuity, tradition, structure, wealth, stability, power, influence, etc, are advantages in the continuation of the "familial chain." Additionally, their absence leads to the break of the "familial chain," since the "familial chain" has strong merits only if it is based on the continuation of private ownership. When the chain of ownership is broken, the "familial chain&" also gets broken. Needless to say that the broken chain of ownership is a perennial Armenian attribute; I am not sure that characterization applies to the Armenian peasant much more than it does to the medieval European peasant, the Roman provincial peoples, or the muslim peasants in Anatolia. Maybe it does; I am just not at all sure. quote:I also do not consider the declarations of our peaceful nature as valid arguments. That's too bad; because they are largely true. The Kurds tried and failed. Armenians for the most part never tried aggressive methods on an appreciable scale. If they could get away with some sort of "arrangement", "understanding", and "negotiation", they consistently preferred it, even when they were the clear losers most of the time. Was it "cowardly"? To be fair, yes. Was it "wise"? Probably. Was it "peaceful"? Yes. quote:We have not been "peaceful."Yes we have. To an extent most other nations consider absurd and spineless. If we hadn't been peaceful, we would either be a big regional power (say 20% chance), or extinct (say 80% chance). "Live free or die" has not been our slogan; that's for sure. Whatever you may think of such behavior, it was definitely one thing: peaceful. quote: I can call peaceful the Chinese ... and you would be very wrong. quote:or the Indians.That's probably fair. Armenian and Indian cultures have similarities in some positive and negative ways. In any case, there can be more than one nation on the planet that can call itself peaceful. In fact, the similarity between two cultures allows a direct comparison, from which the political history of Indians emerge even more "pathetic" than of Armenians, considering India's huge population, area, and resources. They have been ruled by Mongols, Muslims, and the British, all with much smaller numbers, and they had a horribly oppressive and divisive caste system. One can trivialize their peacefulness as a result of their lack of success much more easily than Armenians'. Anyway, Armenians have been peaceful throughout their history. Whether it was a good or bad idea to be so is irrelevant to the validity of that simple fact. quote:The week are not peaceful but helpless;Or maybe the "weak" are weak because they have been too peaceful. quote: Like Boghos has mentioned above, and which has been a clear cut position of some in this forum for a couple of years, now, Diaspora is steadily headed towards its extinction quite naturally as an entity with no purpose.Count me in the camp that has that position. quote: By being "subservient" to the Republic, or better to say by making itself an extant ion of the Republic, Diaspora may only save itself. It will also serve the homeland; Let me make another analogy (I know, I know). The diaspora is the almost severed hand of the body (the Republic), dangling from the side. It is unreasonable to expect the severed hand to drive itself to the emergency room with the body in tow, in order to have itself reattached to the body. Maybe the republic has to hold the steering wheel with its teeth, and drive very clumsily. But only it can take itself and its hand to the surgeon. Because no ambulance is on the way. It is not self-consistent to recognize that most diasporans feel alienated from the motherland, lack vision, organization, and often motivation on the one hand, and then expect them to magically become a natural extension of the republic, no questions asked, on the other. "Stupid should become smart", "bad should become good", "fools should become wise" are all correct statements. They are also completely useless. Without guidance the diaspora will disappear; and that's a shame. Millions of Armenians, no more. Gone. No longer Armenian. But the lack of vision, lack of creativity, lack of resourcefulness, and the lack of caring on the part of the republic that would let that happen is the really bad news. Because such a "motherland" runs the risk of heading into (or rather staying forever in) utter obscurity if not oblivion. That's a disaster. In fact, the problems are pan-Armenian. Our goofiness is universal. And shifting the blame accomplishes nothing. Every Armenian that knows better, in the disappearing diaspora, or the stagnant republic, should do what he or she can. quote: The expression of "Disporan communities" has to be put in perspective. The absolute majority of Diaspora has nothing to do with communities. Armenians steadily dissipate in the host cultures for a millennium, now. If not for the Genocide and the hardships in the Republic, we would've not had Diaspora in the 21st century;Well, we would have a much tinier one, that's for sure. And as logic and reason dictates, whatever its size, it is bound to shrink to nothing without fresh additions. Some families may prolong the process, but the end result would be the same. quote:Maybe the motherland has not done much mothering. There are several reasons. First, Diaspora has not been interestedAgain, circularly, the alienated and the assimilated cannot be expected to show interest at this point. As for the unassimilated, I wouldn't be so sure about their lack of interest. In fact you seem irritated by their being too interested. In any case, TV shows are also cancelled due to lack of interest. Usually nobody blames the audience. quote:....Unlike many other DiasporasIt is clearly not like other diaporas. For a good reason. Reality can be a bummer, but that's how it is. It is not a "normal" diaspora. quote: Additionally, the Diasporan establishment has entered the political arena of the homeland with a clear intend to take over its political process and has appealed to all dirty tactics along the lines of the accomplishment of such a role;Normally, the diasporan participation in the homeland politics is a very positive thing, as long as those participating actually start living there, exposed to its problems and dangers. The key is to make sure that the votes and the "political money" does not come from sources that reside comfortably outside Armenia, or can easily relocate (read double-citizenship) if their adventures with the republic fails miserably. The criterion must be tough, but should not discriminate between the "Western" Armenians and "Eastern" expatriates. I don't know what specific ill effects the diasporans have caused so far. Can you elaborate a little?As far as "dirty tactics", it may not be limited to the diasporans. quote:I would also like to add that I have not questioned your thinking. To the contrary, I am much impressed with your chain of thought. My comments in the last post where unequivocally directed at your "liking and being interested" but not at your "thinking."That's true. And thanks for the compliment. So I hereby delist my "liking and interests" from the Free Market of Ideas, and list it on another stock exchange called Free Market of Likings, Interests, and World Outlooks. I am not expecting a huge stock price, but you never know. Thanks for the discussion. I appreciate your intelligent and stimulating comments. In case the readers have a different impression, we agree on a lot more than we disagree on. Best, Twilight Bark [ July 07, 2002, 01:04 AM: Message edited by: Twilight Bark ]
×
×
  • Create New...