Twilight Bark
Members-
Posts
1,010 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Events
Gallery
Everything posted by Twilight Bark
-
Dear Rubo, Please don't underestimate MJ. He is not infallible, and contrary to some supporting evidence , I don't think he has any such pretense. But you will not achieve anything positive by a confrontational style. Try to start with a clean slate, and stick to the issues that you care about rather than the personalities you find disagreeable. Please give MJ a chance (and perhaps some motivation) to be civil to you. I guess I am assuming Thoth's usual role today. Hey Thoth, how am I doing?
-
Dear Rubo, I do think MJ has completely misread you. There are indeed cliques of people on the forum that resonate with one another at some level, and are therefore more lenient on one another; and that's alright. This "personal chemistry" can be manifest beautifully, and conversely its lack often causes an ugly mess, as in between you and MJ. I would like to implore you two to start afresh, with a clean slate to the best of your abilities. One can attach various adjectives to some of MJ's attitudes, but he can (and to some extent should) get away with it by virtue of his other, more valuable "cerebral" contributions. On the other hand, I do miss his earlier, more sober contributions and style. Then again, who I am to talk; I haven't contributed much weighty myself lately. And, Dear MJ, Please reconsider your attitude towards Rubo. He seems to be a sensitive, open-minded, and thoughtful individual. From what he writes, he is a good father, which, in my opinion, measures a man's intellectual value better than many other "traditional" measures. He is sometimes hot-headed perhaps; but then that isn't far outside of our norm, is it? Again, please try to start with a clean slate, and give him the benefit of the doubt. And when you think he is flat wrong, please try to debate it cerebrally, rather than falling prey to the obvious lack of personal chemistry. One day you may even like him. And, To others, I am disappointed that you participated in this tar-and-feather virtual lynching of Rubo by the apparently unjustified implication that he is some sort of A.R.-style conspiracy-theorist. Perhaps I am too thick and missed something, but he doesn't seem to be the type. Please get a grip on your mob-instincts. I apologize for the preaching; but somebody had to say it.
-
quote:Originally posted by MJ:I am sure it wouldn't take long for some idiots in this forum to come up with other interpretations about the "peacefulness" of our nature. I am not sure if it took me long or not, but having previously made an argument along those lines about our collective behavior, I confess to being one of those idiots. So be it. I am unaware of many instances where Armenians attempted to take other people's wealth or land, while many "imperial" cultures saw it as their right to plunder, massacre and oppress. If we are no different from the aggressive nations in our "peacefulness", then it must mean we are particularly lousy at implementing our lust for dominion and other nations' wealth. Any evidence showing that we tried (alas failed) nearly as often as the aggressors would go a long way in curing me out of my idiocy. Until then, I will remain so ... Oh well.
-
Dear Domino, Thanks. and Dear Sip, Thanks for stating the self-evident truth about my being the best Twilight Bark in the whole universe of Twilight Barks. In case the population of that universe exceeds one, and anyone doubts my superiority, I will refer them to your elegant proof on the more general case.
-
quote:Originally posted by THOTH:I don't think it is only the Genocide that defines Armenians - but of course it must be the single most defining issue - as nearly all of us have been tremendously affected in a very similar manner. I for one am not willing to give up the memory of my slain kin though I admit it is difficult to know what would constitute an acceptable rekoning. And I don't quite understand what you are getting at when you state that Armenians of today fail to fully recognize that their ancestors did not hallucinate the Genocide. Just the opposite I should think. (please elaborate?) Read more carefully, Thoth. That's not what I said. I said there are many "Armenians" whose main connection with Armenian identity is their psychological need for the world to know that their ancestors did not imagine the whole thing. Absent that, they are ready to move on to cultural oblivion. quote:I think that you are underestimating and discounting the very real pain that we (at least most of us) feel - I'm not sure why you seem to not feel this nor understand why this is of paramount importance to most Armenians...just as the Holocaust largely defines (pulls together) and sometimes pre-occupies Jews - as can certainly be expected under the circumstances I think. But this is not the only issue that makes one an Armenian or a Jew - even one who is largely assimilated as I am. I am not discounting the pain of thinking about and re-living the horror. I dread reading books about the genocide (in fact, any genocide); I find it traumatizing. However, my pain has little to do with whether the Turkish government made an empty, insincere declaration or not. quote:And I'm not so sure that most Armenians would be satisfied with a symbolic apology I didn't say anything about the "majority", as I don't know what the "majority" wants, especially when it is hard to define the relevant "whole". I made a factual statement about "many" Armenians. So dear Thoth, I am afraid you misunderstood what I wrote.
-
quote:Originally posted by aurguplu:... secret poll in 1991 .... .. one fourth to one third of our population is Kurdish. ... Whatever. While I think half of that figure is probably in the "I have a grandma that spoke Kurdish" category, the real point is that the state managed to invent a Turkish identity, when very little of it existed in 1920. Those that would describe themselves as first and foremost as "Turkish" probably formed a minority not larger than 25% (and perhaps much less) in the rump Ottoman Empire of that time. The transformation to today's synthesized Turkish identity was accomplished by an extremely aggressive, chauvinistic brainwashing campaign, whose main tool was the educational system (after the extermination or wholesale exile of the unassimilable, of course). Naturally, having limited resources, the success was not 100%. The rest is meaningless detail. quote:What I mean by realpolitik is that I approach the subject as a problem that needs to be solved,Well, your approach is indeed that of realpolitik. But your description of your approach is not. You have not touched what needs to be solved. And in fact you have shown outright hostility to what would constitute a real reconciliation and resolution. quote: and its solution will be possible by ... what? quote:I have to look at the issue on the one hand and my powers on the other. Quite. And if you drop your pretense of being a negotiator, and focus your energy on educating your fellow citizens in non-chauvinistic thinking, you would be doing something that is indeed within your powers. Trying to accomplish a fake "result" by "negotiating" with people who don't have the power to change anything isn't exactly productive. Your desired "result" would be empty and fake, even if it occurred in real life. But much more so if it happens on this forum. I am suggesting you to do what is possible and immediately productive. Your proper audience is your fellow citizens, not Armenians. quote: quote:I am personally not wounded a bit by the lack of recognition by Turkey, or apology. Many Armenians are by their own declaration, and I can only agree with and symphatise with that. Please bear in mind that I am interested in finding a solution that is acceptabe to the majority on both sides of the divide, and not specific individuals. While a contemporary "Turk" is a fairly well-defined creature, a contemporary "Armenian" is not. There are legions of "Armenians", whose sole connection to being an Armenian is the lack of full recognition that their ancestors did not hallucinate the genocide. In other words, a part of their psyche is still slavishly dependent on what the Turks may or may not do. And after a "recognition" and perhaps an "apology" (and it does not matter to them if it is uttered through clenched teeth, and is without substance), their "tie" to Armenianness is severed, as there is no longer a point to their "Armenianness". To think that satisfying that psychological need of the assimilated (and for all practical purposes, lost) "Armenians" by Machiavellian means is more important than resolving a fundamentally moral issue the right way is absurd. The issue is not about facilitating the transition of ex-Armenians into full assimilation into the western societies. In fact the issue has noting to do with what is acceptable to Armenians, or "Armenians". Do what you need to do in order to become a better people. And if you don't care to become a better people, don't. quote:If you are going to wait for Turkey to evolve to that level naturally, you will probably have to wait until the Turkish GNP reaches 10,000 USD in terms of purchasing power parity, until much of the country is online, until the Turks shed their old fears that everyone is trying to dismember them, until the Cyprus and Kurdish problems are solved one way or the other, and the results have sunk in and accepted by the Turkish population, i.e. for about another quarter of a century. If you have a way of changing the nature of your government ideology, go ahead. But do not expect to achieve anything worthwhile within the constraints imposed by that ideology, as it is today. quote:TB, are you sure we ae talking about the same thing? States are not moral creatures, people are. Your arguments are fully valid when it comes to people's approach to the question, but states just don't function like that. And it is not a question of enlightenment as far as the state is concerned, for the state knew and knows about the true nature of the question and its moral implications, anyway.The disconnect of the "state" from the "people" is a holdover prom imperial and royal times, when the state's formal, "legitimate" function was to further the interest of an emperor or a small group of the "elite". The modern state, however, is supposed to represent the will and the character of the people behind it. When there is a significant disconnect, you brew trouble in democratic societies. And in less evolved societies, you have supposedly educated people defending the disconnect as if it must be a fact of life. Probably because they are not as "evolved" as they would like to believe. In which case, more time and effort need to be invested. quote: quote:I won't bite that bait.And what are you going to do? Deny it?Because it is a silly generalization. And is in fact information-free when the perpetrator of the crimes are not defined. Was the state a result of a struggle in which those heinous crimes were committed by its founders, or by its enemies? Anyway, it is a silly argument. quote:It's time to speak out. Also, I am not good at sneaky things. I am blunt. What you are suggesting is also called "putting the cart in front of the horse". quote:... I may not be one of these as my area of expertise is historical linguistics and not sociology.I am referring to the conceptual "vocabulary" (or building blocks), and not the words or the terminology. quote: However, if you are referring to basic civilized social thinking and commentary, I do not think I am particularly deficient there You have the concepts. However, you have fatal flaws in your application of them. But, I agree that you are not "particularly deficient". quote:(and cannot say the same thing for all the members who post in this forum). Indeed. quote:I don't pretend to become a "teacher" in any field where I do not have the requisite formation.If you are contemplating an academic career of any sort, then it is all you need. quote: The Armenian issue is on my agenda because I see it as shackles on the feet of my nation that it needs to get rid of, which will not happen with the attitude that has prevailed until now. Indeed, as I diagnosed before. But do not see it as Armenians' obligation to make unwarranted sacrifices and accept blatant inaccuracies in order to help your people achieve that. And the rest of your post is basically irrelevant, so I'll conclude my post here. [ November 18, 2002, 12:50 PM: Message edited by: Twilight Bark ]
-
quote:Originally posted by Eduard Markosyan:T-Bark, i remember you from AR's forum. You now sound so polite, so nice and well educated. One only needs to go back and read your posts in the other forums in order to see your true face. p.s. you also used to post in the Serbian site, right? Eduard,What are you talking about? I certainly did not post anything on AR's forum, or any other mental-health related forums. Armenian Cafe is the only forum on which I posted anything (and unlikely to happen again). And the "worst" of my postings on Armenian Cafe were my ill-considered attempts at bringing some semblance of reason and civility to that forum when it was being razed by the likes of AR and "Steve" (certainly nothing to do with Bellthecat of this forum). However, if you would be kind enough to post the links to these postings, I would have a chance to see what the potential impostor has been up to. And why on earth would I post on a Serbian forum? I assure you, I am not some idle net-warrior with time to kill. In fact, I have to justify to myself the time it takes to type each posting. Again, thanks in advance if you could post a link to the posts you had in mind. Not that there is much I can do about it. I don't have the copyright to any of the monikers. Come to think of it, I don't even have a copyright to my real name! TB
-
quote:Originally posted by aurguplu:i shall address all of the points you have raised in time Good luck. quote:1. the kurds are not 10% but about 25-30%. so if this was a successful assimilation campaign, what would it be like if it weren't? for your info: there are probably 21 million kurds in turkey today, more than at any time in history (in fact, the entire population of anatolia was never much above 24 million in preindustrial times). so much for your "successful" assimilation campaign. I was of course not referring to genes or ancestry, which cannot be change by assimilation or brainwashing. If you want me to believe that 30% of the population see themselves as Kurdish in any way that matters (other than saying "I had a grandmother that spoke Kurdish"), perhaps you will have better luck with selling bridges. In any case, whatever the percentages, the Republic has been very succesful in synthesizing a Turkish identity out of almost noting through brainwashing. Where the central "education" could not reach because of lack of resources, it of course failed to do that. That is beside the point. quote:2. realpolitik versus morality: why do i stick to realpolitik rather than morality? simple: i am interested in positive results for both sides of the conflict.Realpolitik and "the art of the possible" are two very different things. I am beginning to believe that you are sincere in your disingenuousness. How was that Sip? quote: the genocide is many things: it is a crime, it is a tragedy, it is an example of man's inhumanity to man, it is a bitter lesson, etc. etc., it is also a practical problem to be solved. i cannot undo the crime. i cannot bring back the dead. i cannot uncry the tears, i cannot erase the memories, etc. etc., You are saying it as if I have asked you to do these things. If that is the kind of straw-man you had to come up with, my positions must have been quite valid. quote:but if i can find enough people on both sides i can contribute to the eventual recognition of the genocide and thus, partial healing of the wound. as many armenians have expressed, genocide recognition and apology are key to the healing of the armenian psyche. we opened the wound, we have to help heal it. here is a bit of the morality you were asking, if you know what i mean.I am personally not wounded a bit by the lack of recognition by Turkey, or apology. However, I would very much love to see Turkey evolve to a level where those things would come naturally, not only for Armenians, but for the Turks as well. I have zero interest in achieving those superficial results by realpolitik. And I would expect sensible Armenians as well as sensible Turks would think along the same lines. quote: but to get both sides to find common ground - for there will be no recognition unless and until there is common ground - you have to do some practical work, and that involves realpolitik, tb, not morality.The common ground that is worthwhile to find will be found when the Turkish population slowly but surely evolves sufficiently. If Turkey were under a quasi-colonial rule as Germany and Japan were at the end of WWII, some "acceleration" of the process would be practical, desirable, and welcome. But it is not. The prerequisite enlightenment for a true resolution simnply cannot be achieved by Machiavellian negotiations. quote: states have always been products of heinous crimes,I won't bite that bait. quote: and the turkish one is neither the first nor the last in that respect. the winners of this world, the bosses, have not been bosses by following moral codes. and i am not a boss in my country. i have to play by the rules and flex them as much as i can without breaking them. if i break them, they can break me back. you see? i am walking a very tight rope. I have previously acknowledged the difficulty of expressing truly relevant and truly enlightened viewpoints from your position. And I said I would understand it if you became silent because of it. However, there is much "sneaky" education one can do without breaking the rules. Less glamorous perhaps, but the only thing that can be done. Turks need to learn the basic vocabulary of enlightened social thinking and commentary before arriving at the "common ground". After some reflection, you may become one of those "teachers", without getting entangled in the Armenian issue per se. quote:it's easy to post your stuff from wherever you are, but i am posting mine from here, and with my real name and not my nickname. My anonymity has nothing to do with the subject. I am not pretending to be a hero. And when I am a coward, I am so for the benefit of others, not mine. In any case, who I am is irrelevant. quote:come post from turkey with your real name if you dare and then we'll be talking, man.I am not suggesting you to endanger your life or well-being. However, I am suggesting the "art of the possible".
-
quote:Originally posted by Domino:Why are you telling this ? I mean, you talked about order, and I have commented about the "order" thing. This is the conception I had for years, if you are not interested to discuss about this, just tell it TB. Well, it's just that I expected you not to stumble in the ways you seem to be. For example, you ask me how come we end up in the one universe that allows the evolution of life. Come on now, Domino, we are not inter-universe travellers. We are the life you are talking about. Also, we cannot pick and choose what we mean by order. It is statistically defined, and is best represented by the concept of entropy. I was not referring to pre-bigbang. The violent explosion of the big bang must not have been an order producing event. I know, a singularity or a soup of a universe stuffed into a pinhead are not the most appealing examples of "order", but they do nevertheless represent an extremely "ordered" state. As for the local increases in order, such as life, there is nothing thermodynamically mysterious about it. And yes, I am tired of discussing the subject. It was fun though. Best, TB
-
Domino, Are you pulling my leg?
-
quote:Originally posted by aurguplu:1. i stick to realpolitik because it is real, not necessarily because i like it so much. Realpolitik involves divorcing morality and all the enlightened values (which make humans profound creatures) from the interaction of states or entities. It is repugnant, and it is no more real than moral principles and self-respect. Need for much evolution here on your part. quote:2. i don't want to get into yet another row about my sincerity, but it must have been obvious by now. of course, having opinions that differ from yours and arriving at different conclusions from the same set of data are not to be interpreted as insincerity, i hope. I am not talking about differing opinions. I am talking about inconsistency between declarations and crystal-clear intentions and priorities. quote:3. no, tb, your past postings and the present one are not entirely consistent with one another.Then please be kind enough to demonstrate it so that I can fix the alleged incosistencies in my thought system. If you cannot, please do not make such a declaration. quote:4. to quote the trash that passes for press in turkey, especially the sports and magazine pages to fathom the turkish psyche on the eu, well, really, tb, you can do better than that, can't you?Those "newspapers" are infinitely more representative of popular culture than your quoting yourself in response to my saying that Turks are indignant at being snubbed by the EU. In fact, they are the "best" anyone can do to sum up the state of the culture at large. quote: quote:And the inclination to absorb, assimilate and grow bigger as a desirable end in itself is very much alive in the Turkish culture. i think that is very much alive in many cultures. britain and (especially usa) certainly have it, as do russia and in a different fashion, germany. all nations that were once big and mighty tend to dream of the "good old days" and might have some ideas in the back of their minds to get big and mighty again. the thing is, most people are aware of practical and impractical ideas, as are we. do you really think that turks are so stupid as to seriously contemplate any "conquest" in the military fashion in europe?I don't recall talking about Turkish armies marching across Europe. Perhaps I was not clear enough; I was talking about "conquest" in metaphorical sense, culturally and identitywise. Turkey has had a huge success in transforming a hodge-podge of muslim remnants (after killing off or exiling the Christians) into "Turks". As a glaring example, the huge number of Balkan refugees did not view themselves as "Turks" at the time, but their descendants certainly do. And the same story is repeated for all the muslim ethnic groups that were left in the rump Ottoman Empire that became Turkey. The 10-12% Kurdish minority is simply a remnant of a very succesful but imperfect assimilation campaign. As you would agree, the Turkish nationalism is largely non-racist. It essentially views non-Turkish ethnic identity within its borders as some sort of a temporary ailment that needs to be fixed with a proper dose of brainwashing and assimilation. That's what I am talking about. And I never claimed that Turks were the only ones with such instincts. However, they represent one of the best practical implementations of such mentality. quote:In fact, that facet has been emphasized and nurtured by the Republic since its foundation. quote:you are grieviously wrong there. that facet has been crushed, erased, polished to extinction and generally made to disappear. See my response above. quote:you flunked that one, tb.Balderdash.
-
Artifact May Be Earliest Relating to Existence of Jesus
Twilight Bark replied to Azat's topic in Religion
quote:Originally posted by Boghos:Hello TB, I thought we had only one resident "guru" that goes by the name of Ara Baliozian. But in any case I agree with you that every Armenian has a little bit of Baliozian in his blood. Hi Boghos,What can I say; you read me like a book. quote:Armenians are very competitive, especially against each other. But often enough they are not as competitive when it comes to non-Armenians ("odar" is a word outside my vocabulary).Competing against non-Armenians is such a drag. One can satisfy the need for uniqueness by declaring oneself better than any Armenian in sight. It has the added bonus of providing a handy explanation for lack of success. Ahh, if I weren't held back by those Armenians, who knows what glories I would have. Aahh, ahh. -
Artifact May Be Earliest Relating to Existence of Jesus
Twilight Bark replied to Azat's topic in Religion
No no no, you guys got it all wrong. Of course, that is not surprising (see explanation below). You see, the glue that holds us together is that each one of us is clearly superior to the rest of our fellow Armenians. What other group provides such a wonderful opportunity to be the best of a group? Of course the rest of you couldn't see this as clearly as I can, because by definition you are inferior to my superior "guru" status. I must admit that the same superiority is true for all of you, but I don't want to hear about it. Ahh, it is good to be among Armenians. It makes me feel so clever. I think I will post this in the "Culture" section. After all, this piece of wisdom should be distinguished from other riffraff. Hmph! ... -
quote:Originally posted by aurguplu:a turkish jaw drops in amazement... Why?The fact that I am often irritated by your realpolitik talk and (perhaps unintended) lack of sincerity does not mean that I wish the Turks ill. To the contrary, my position on this issue is entirely consistent with the rest of my positions. quote:turks have neither the power nor the inclination to conquer anything anymore, besides, europeans are not weak, either. it's over. I was referring to something like a "forced marriage". As for the desire to conquer, I have to disagree. Just read the colorful sheets of cellulose that pass as "newspaper" in Turkey. A soccer team doesn't just win a game in a european city, they "conquer" it. A succesful concert by a Turkish singer in a foreign city is nothing short of a "conquest". The culture of conquest is still very much embedded right under the surface.And the inclination to absorb, assimilate and grow bigger as a desirable end in itself is very much alive in the Turkish culture. In fact, that facet has been emphasized and nurtured by the Republic since its foundation.
-
quote:Originally posted by Arpa:Why do Armenians talk 999 times more about Turks and Turkey, Because they are important to us, regardless of how much we may dislike that fact. quote: 1000 times more about Jews and Israel?Probably because many Armenians are indignant at the lack of Jewish friendship, to put it mildly. The whole thing is silly, but then we do seem to have more than our share of the silly, don't we? quote:Is it too embarassing to talk about ourselves? Sure! Yes. It appears so. Thanks for expressing a suspicion that I have had for some time.
-
It would be wonderful if Turkey changes enough to qualify for entry into the EU. I wholeheartedly support the idea without any facetiousness. However, I am disgusted by the idea that forceful penetration into the EU would do good to anyone. Instead of becoming a catalyst for positive cultural change, a premature entry would "prove" (for the benefit of the Orwellian elite in Turkey) that Turkey has been alright, they were right, and now they are taking their rightful place, and a bright new future awaits, and history must now be buried and left to history buffs. And I would agree with the last sentiment only after Turkish culture changes sufficiently. It clearly has not. Yet. As for the "muslim" excuse. While it is certainly in the minds of many a conservative folk in the EU, it is definitely not a determining factor. The real reasons are twofold: Culture and Size. The relevant issue is not the religious difference per se, but the cultural incompatibility. If Turkish society were to become a liberal-minded, enlightened one with a culture of governance that matches it, EU would simply not be able to say "No", even if it wanted to. Let's think about why they would want to say no. Perhaps a significant minority of the reluctant would like to say no on religious grounds, but Christianity has been in a sharp decline all over Europe. Poland is the only major Euopean country that rivals the US in religious fervor. The rest of the reluctant would like to say no simply on the grounds that Turks are ethnically too different (looks and acts too differently) from the western and northern Europeans, and (this is important, and brings us to the second factor, namely size) is too populuous. The "innocent" cultural idiosyncracies would be easily overlooked if the associated population were not so huge. The "native" population of EU is poised to shrink significantly in the course of this century, possibly to something less than 200 million, while Turkish population would probably not stabilize before hitting the 100 million mark. Turkey would easily be the largest country in the union, essentially starting to run the show. Don't expect its premature entry to be acceptable. Europeans have their faults, but they are not imbeciles. Turkey needs to be significantly more "europeanized" before it hopes to be welcomed into the Union. And that has little to do with religion per se, although such a process would inevitably and fundamentally change both the face of the (already somewhat distinct) Turkish variety of Islam, as well as its significance in Turkish society. In any case, it is a process that should not be forced, but allowed to take its course. As a sidenote, the absurdity of an Albanian entry into the EU stems from the endemic crime, corruption, and incompetence; not the majority religion. It is small enough not to change the face of the EU by composition, but has way too many crooks. Again, letting them loose on the EU population without the prerequisite evolution in the Albanian society would take a complete suspension of rationality on the part of EU. Before being so indignant, Turks should perhaps ask themselves this: who would want to join a union of naive imbeciles that are devoid of an instinct for self-preservation?
-
Artifact May Be Earliest Relating to Existence of Jesus
Twilight Bark replied to Azat's topic in Religion
The lack of awareness about the brother has probably been due to the Church's reluctance to advertise that "Virgin" Mary did not stay virgin forever, even if Immaculate Conception is accepted literally at face value. -
quote:Originally posted by Domino:... just after the big bang, a very big amount of energy was injected, and that time there was no order ... To the contrary. Even though it does not conform to our usual sense of "order", the universe right after the big bang was very "ordered" simply by virtue of being confined to an infinitesimally small space. The kind of order you are talking about are small islands of increased order (of a different sort) in a background of increasing disorder. Incidentally, almost all of the heavier elements necessary for life are produced as a result of Supernova explosions; not exactly "order producing" events. The atoms in our bodies started their existence as dust and gas blown away from a supernova. It seems that the "hot gas" left an imprint that shows itself in some of the posters on the internet (such as those that pollute cilica.com ). quote:And I do not believe life being an accident at all. How do you explain that a connection of matter could give birth to conscience(another definition, as those commonly believed) ?Lego pieces and a lot of monkeys playing with them. quote: In order that that happens, laws should permit it,But I explained that in my first post in this thread, didn't I? It is quite plausible that this universe is one of an infinite number of possible (and existing in parallel) universes, and happens to have the right conditions for the evolution of life. quote:now you know of what I think about in my bed. And I thought you dreamed about veelas in your bed. TB
-
quote:Originally posted by Domino:About Hidden variable, in mathematic, it exists, all the series , like those of fourier are based on that, you have an adding that goes to the infinit, each parts of this sommation, could be considered as variables, we may decide to cut pieces, untill we have a reasonably accurate numbers. No no no. The "hidden variable" I was talking about has nothing to do with fourier series and the like. It is about the speculation by Dirac regarding the nature of the randomness dictated by quantum theory. quote:The analogy could be made with super computers used for meteorology,Clearly that was what you had in mind. However, it takes a "deterministic" view of te universe, which is at odds with quantum theory. In other words, you can obtain apparent randomness and chaos in a classical, deterministic system, which still allows for a super-intelligent-omnipowerful-control-freak sort of creature to actually know and predict the trajectory of the system. However, fundamentally, there is also quantum uncertainy under it all, making it impossible for even the super creature to predict the future of the system. Unless, of course, the quantum randomness was not random at all, and it appeared so to the lowly humans who could not look into (or control) the values of those hidden variables.Anyway, I think we are beginning to put the poets among us into a deep sleep. TB
-
quote:Originally posted by Domino:I said the most complex in that Universe, the Universe here is excluded, of course the universe is the most complex and ordered o all, because it contains any order it creates, but the point here, is about what the laws of the Universe have created as the most complex, what they have created is life, that’s the most complex thing that we know of. The universe is getting less and less orderly according to the 2nd law. Among other things, the highly "ordered" form of energy, also known as "matter", is turning into photons and and such, emitted into space. This destruction of order is occasionally used to create local increases in order, much like using electricity to create a colder region of space at the expense of increasing overall entropy of the universe (e.g. your fridge). For every planet that supports mechanisms for this phenomenon (i.e. life), there are surely countless other planets that simply absorb high energy (i.e. more "ordered") photons and emit back "low-quality" infrared photons throughout their existence. In fact, "life" appears to be an exceedingly rare phenomenon. It's just that the universe has enough stars and planets, and sufficient variability of conditions (in addition to physical laws that permit them), such that there is at least one planet that the freak accident of life had an opportunity to occur. I see no obvious "purpose" in the universe. If there is purpose, we created it. I "believe" in humans. Meaning and sense can only exist in the fictional world created by the self-aware "intelligent" creatures, accidents though they may be. They are the accidents that create profundity. Thus, I completely reject the infantile philosophy of "who cares about those rotten humans, the important thing is the planet". The planet (or the universe) is meaningless without self-aware, intelligent beings. It might just as well not exist. quote:... but for the Universe, its not by chance, its not chaos, because if you were all the Universe, you would know every parameters, if you beat your right . . . so "chaos" could only be define by ones ignorance of parameters. This is also known as the "hidden variable" view of "fundamental" randomness (championed by Dirac) such as the one coming from the Heisenberg uncertainty principle. To the best of my knowledge, we have not yet found even a hint that those "hidden variables" exist (i.e. unknowable by lowly humans but existent nevertheless). Therefore, your belief is currently not supported by what we know about how the universe works. Perhaps you will change that. As Azat's cartoon implies, the randomness may be coming from interference with other universes (that would also explain the violation of the conservation laws when quantum mechanical uncertainty is operative as a temporary exchange of energy or matter between universes). quote:Now, I guess, you are questioning, what this has to do with what you posted... Actually, I was starting to question what this has to do with Armenians. But there is a link in my mind. In the back of my mind. Waaay back in mind. In the Department of Meaning. I'll cut it short here. Good luck with your research. TB P.S. My post above has some passing references to what was discussed in another thread /cgi-bin/forum/ultim...ic;f=1;t=000526 [ November 12, 2002, 04:08 PM: Message edited by: Twilight Bark ]
-
quote:Originally posted by Domino: OK, a little correction then, the most complex thing we know of that nature build is not human, but humanity. You know where this is going, don't you Domino? The most complex thing we know of is the universe itself. Too obvious, I know. And speaking of the universe. It is entirely plausible that there exists an infinite number of universes, with all the possible values for those fundamental constants that do not fall out of fundamental equations, even if we assume that the governing laws are the same in all universes (and they need not be, I suppose). Then we are in this universe, simply because the particular values for the fundamental constant(s) happen to be conducive for the eventual development of life. In that case, there is nothing purposeful about the universe. Sigh... Humbug. TB
-
quote:Originally posted by nairi:Can YOU prove that Armenians were among the first to speak PIE? I don't need to. We are considering an ethnos that always spoke an indoeuropean language to the best of our knowledge, the big Urartuan infusion notwithstanding (but Hayasa predates Urartu, making Urartuan component an "assimilated" one, rather than the "nucleus" of the ethnos). The present language is IE, the linguistic environment in which the "Hay" nation originated was IE. As I said too many times, with no apparent registration on your side, it is meaningless to talk about who adopted what concerning times when an Armenian nation did not exist. I do not understand why you fail to understand a simple concept like that. You are dragging the discussion into an anthropological one, which is not fruitful. We can be fairly certain that the anthropological composition of today's Armenians is significantly different from the nuclear group that first crystallized as the people of Hayasa, not the least because of the later Urartuan component. By such an anthropological definition of "Armenian", there are very few native words in Armenian, because the "other" ancestors probably outnumber those from the original Hayasa-Azzi province. That definition, although somewhat silly, is fine with me, as long as we all know what we are talking about. As an aside, by the same definition, the Turkish spoken in Turkey has very few "native" words, because they are anthropologically almost entirely Anatolian/Near Eastern/Mediterranean, and whose ancestors did not "invent" Turkish. Compared with their case, Armenians have a lot sounder claim to define IE words as native, even with the silly definition we are considering right now. quote:Like I said, if you can, then I am willing to agree with you that PIE/IE lexicon and syntax is purely Armenian. Being "purely Armenian" and "exclusively Armenian" are two very different things. Perhaps you should mull over that a bit. quote:I didn't mean to say that Germans are better than Armenians or v.v.I didn't say you claimed that. I said you seem to be under the impression that Germanic languages are somehow the gold standard with which to compare. In any case, whether those languages have more or less non-IE words than Armenian has nothing to do with whether IE words in Armenian are "native" or not. quote:In fact, most linguists are more interested in Armenian than they are in German, simply because it took such a different path from all the other PIE/IE languages.It had a "linguistically rich" environment, and it reflects that. But I don't know if I would be so ethnocentric and claim that Armenian is so much more special than all the other IE languages, although it would be nice if that were the case. quote: That's what I meant by "breaking away from the standard". This automatically means that there are plenty of other words and grammatical structures in Armenian that are uniquely Armenian and in no way related to IE or any other language. All IE languages have their "unique" characteristics that set them apart from other IE languages. But that has no bearing on whether IE words in Armenian should be defined as "native" or not. quote:If you have trouble understanding what I wrote, please don't hesitate to ask. What I have trouble with is why you chose to be so patronizing with so little understanding. But you'll grow out of it I am sure. quote: quote:The two cases are entirely different.Not if Armenians borrowed PIE.Armenians did not "borrow" PIE, and they did not borrow IE. That is becasue they did not "borrow" the Armenian they spoke at the time of Hayasa. They happened to be speaking whatever they were speaking at the time when the formation of a group called Hayasa-Azzi was precipitated by the political environment. There is no single group that can claim that their ancestors alone were the "inventors" of indoeuropean. It was most likely a lingua-franca used by a variety of ethnic groups, probably all around the perimeter of the Black Sea, when it was a lake, before it got flooded via the Bosporus strait. Such an origin would also explain why there is no credible evidence for the "arrival" of the Armenians or even the Hittites into Anatolia (from east or west anyway). quote:Thoth jan, if it is true that I can learn something from other people, then it should also be true that other people could learn something from me.Other people's learning from you can happen at unexpected times, rather than exactly when you think or wish it should happen. And it is more likely to happen when you have something correct to teach. Otherwise it is not "learning" but "misguiding". the time will come for it; let it happen by itself.
-
quote:Originally posted by THOTH:TB - OK fine - a misperception on my part - I can buy that - so I am wrong...no problem. Dear Thoth, It pains me to bicker like this, especially when it is thoroughly unwarranted. And it is not a matter of you being "wrong" or I being "right", or whatever. I am treating Nairi as a peer, rather than a fragile little flower. That isn't so terrible is it? And what's with this MJ, Boghos stuff? How did they get dragged into this? If you have a bone with MJ, you can deal with it through e-mail, or perhaps a public virtual duel of some sort . But I was surprised to see you vent those hidden frustrations like that. And could you be kind enough to let me know whom I treated snottily, and why you judged it so? Granted, I don't usually act buddy-buddy, and say such things as "let's go get drunk and sing together", and often have a formal way of writing, I don't snob anyone. While I would be in good company being grouped with MJ and Boghos, I still dislike being lumped with others, especially when it is apparently done to associate me with actions that are not mine. Whatever was crossing your mind when you raised your objection, I want you to know that I still like you and most of your expressed thoughts. TB
-
quote:Originally posted by nairi:Actually, what hasn't helped me, is TB's elementary level of teaching. As they say, I cannot learn it for you. You have to help yourself. You may yet do that some day. quote:If he has anything more advanced, Dear, dear. One little step at a time. Let's first get the logic part down. quote:I will be all ears.And hopefully you won't neglect to use what's between those ears properly . I am confident you can.
-
quote:Originally posted by Domino:I think that TB non-friendly approch in explaining you, has not helped a lot.(specifically because of the unfriendly approch and not the explaination itself). Dear Domino,You are a technically literate person, so you'll appreciate this. Suppose you are solving a nonlinear equation by an iteration method called Friendly Iteration (FI). And after a few iterations your algorithm FI is coming back with the exact same number that you started with. You may reasonably decide that your FI approach has failed, and that perhaps a different approach is warranted. Or, depending on how much time you have available, you may simply utter something "unfriendly" about the problem and walk away. My walking away from the "stuck iteration" problem was disapproved by Thoth. Since he is a nice guy, I gave it another go. I am not sure I achieved "convergence" yet, but I surely depleted my emergency supply of patience. And what is this hooplah about "friendly" and "unfriendly"? The most drastic thing I told Nairi was to take a brief break from "thinking", implying that I didn't think she was thinking straight. Gosh, what a horrendous thing to say! Poor, little, fragile Nairi; she can't take such gross abuse. Come on, what you and Thoth are doing is much more insulting to Nairi than anything I have said so far. Are you going to treat her as a peer or not? Let it go. And re-evaluate. TB
