Jump to content

Twilight Bark

Members
  • Posts

    1,010
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Twilight Bark

  1. The following is my hasty take on the subject, and is submitted without waiting for my irritation by the subject to die down. Any perceived hostility should not be interpreted as directed to any individuals. First of all, we should consider the subject in the proper context, and in relative, not absolute, terms. Even the Turks, the "dominant" element in the empire had very little coherent idea of ethnic identity by the end of the empire. By far the most predominant element of one's identity was religion. The modern idea of "Turk" actually antedates the modern idea of Armenian. The Turks of today are overwhelmingly the product of heavy-handed (not necessarily bloody) assimilation policies, and a big majority have no Turkish lineage. It is largely a state-synthesized identity. Armenians on the other hand have had an uninterrupted and "natural" lineage both in terms of ancestry and identity. What that identity meant has constantly changed since the time of Hayasa, the Ottoman period being no exception. This is expected. Indeed I think the only "ethnic groups" that had the meaning of their identity unchanged over millenia are the ones that somehow avoided cultural evolution, e.g. isolated hunter-gatherer groups. So I would say it is time to get over the fact that Armenians adapted to their environment. Much more important to remember is the fact that they preserved enough of their "cultural DNA" to re-emerge as a proudly distinct group. Yes, we adapted. Yes we changed over time. The adaptation was necessary. So is the re-adaptation that we are still going through. None of this is cause to feel bad. In fact, it is remarkable, considering that they have no "world-class accomplishments" to rally around, military, intellectual, or otherwise. So once again, get over it people: we adapt. And that is why we survived. While survival is not an intellectual accomplishment of high caliber, it is nevertheless the only criterion that the slow but unstoppably powerful process known as "evolution" cares about. I regard it as poor taste to single out Armenians that descended from a particular region and question whether they are true Armenians or mere "cousins". Nonsense. The Soviet period is infinitesimal in any nation's history, particularly one that is as ancient and borderless as Armenians. Regardless of where they lived, Armenians lived under somebody else's empire, and had no "proud" national identity until now. Period. That includes the territories of the Republic of Armenia. Do we regard the Armenian Republic as "formed by Christian Turkish and Christian Persian refugees adhering to a particular sect"? We can, you know. To no useful end, of course. Do we really have time and energy to devote to this sterile subject of "Armenian from here" versus "Armenian from there"? Let us regard our historically consistent reluctance and "inability" to gang up and rape other cultures as a huge moral positive, resolve to become strong and tall, and consign such divisive talk to the smelly old coffee-houses of the old. Armenia is not a corporation that we can downsize. It is not a conglomerate that can focus on its "core competence" depending on the economic climate of the current quarter. It is not a firm that can go into a hiring spree when the times are good. It is a family. Yes, "cousins" and all. Overly "rational" approaches to cultural and national identity is bound to end up in a sterile, meaningless cul-de-sac. My humble advice to those going that way is to remember to brake when they reach the wall.
  2. Twilight Bark

    MaSis- Nkarner

    quote:Originally posted by sen_vahan:Hey, TB! Nice to see you! Thanks. Likewise. quote:The legend in Gigamish was about Babeli King Family or Sumeri King? As I remember, the Sumerian legend was adopted by the Babylonians, who kept a working knowledge of Sumerian, which was already a dead language at the time. quote:When I was a high school student for some reason I thought Sumerians were Armenians Well, they did have an "Armenoid" component "anthropologically", implying that we probably share some ancestry with them. Way back, I also posted some Armenian words with apparent Sumerian connections. Some of them, such as "oror" and "gat" are unlikely to be borrowed, and I feel imply a direct ancestral link. What percentage of our ancestry is common with that of ancient Sumerians will probably never be known. However, every time I say "oror", I can't help think that I am using a word that survived more than 5000 years from parent to child.
  3. quote:Originally posted by Accelerated:To a small extent owning a BMW is power . The power to get from point A to B in privacy, luxury and some class etc. (or whatever the resident society might percieve the ownership of a BMW may bring) I was not talking about the power to be a snob . I was talking about real, serious "movers and shakers" kind of power. Also, to address what you said earlier, success does not come from money. Money comes from success. However, whether you chase money or success has profound importance in determining where you end up at the end. Note that this is not to say that money-chasers don't find some of what they are looking for. Nevertheless, the previous statement applies.
  4. Twilight Bark

    MaSis- Nkarner

    quote:Originally posted by Arpa:... by Assyrians, see the Epic of Gilgamish, ... Sumerians. As for the charges of later "plagiarism", it's virtually certain that they are true. The story of Genesis seems to have the marks of clumsy translation from Sumerian. As for the "flood", it is worthwhile to investigate its interpretation as the flooding of the Black Sea basin.
  5. quote:Originally posted by Accelerated: quote:Too many of us value money above sucess, let alone intellectual pursuits.Money is power, and with enough of it comes success and fame.Pursuing money for attaining power is not the same as pursuing money to buy a BMW and crow to your equally banal Armenian neighbor. I would, with some equivocation, include "lust for power" in the "intellectual activity" category for the purposes of this discussion. It has to do with how banal your goals in life are.
  6. quote:Originally posted by nairi: quote:Originally posted by Twilight Bark:I am wishing that "western media" had many more Armenian contributors. Why? So we can proudly say that we are contributing to that propaganda? So we can moderate and modify what comes out of it. My usual refrain about "just bypass them" (about outdated institutions) does not apply here, because Armenia or Armenians are not about to come up with their own BBC (ABC?) anytime soon. The only way to penetrate the mainstream is to join it and change it from inside. quote: quote:Too many of us value money above sucess, let alone intellectual pursuits."Too many", thus not "most". So where's the problem? "Too many" can and I think in our case does mean "most". And that is a problem. quote:First of all, I think we are all people who happen to have a certain ethnic background.We also all have lungs and kidneys in addition to "happening to be of one ethnicity or another". That does not increase our contribution to the Armenian collective. When one views oneself as "a successful person that happens to be Armenian", it is not fundamentally different from viewing oneself as "a successful person that happens to have brown hair". On the other hand, feeling like "a successful Armenian" has a whole different connotation. quote:Secondly, I think it's unrealistic, if not sadistic, to ask of one person to do a thousand things at the same time. As if concentrating on one thing and becoming successful in that isn't enough... One common trait of successful people is that they are not overwhelmed by multitasking. It is very common to see them do many things. The two traits almost always go hand in hand. They also know when and what to delegate. You wouldn't expect Kasparov to read over the legal minutiae of setting up a chess software company. quote:As for feeling like a freak-mutant, that is a personal feeling.Feelings are always personal. And they all ultimately result from our social context. quote: Not every "isolated" successful Armenian (or person of any ethnic background for that matter) feels that way, as far as I know.As always, when talking about humans (even many other animal species), we are not talking about 100% applicability, or absolute certainty. We are talking about likelihoods. Just because my chain-smoking uncle lived to be 100 years old does not make smoking harmless. quote:Way past bed time for me. Weltrusten, as the Dutchies would say. I hope you had a good rest.
  7. quote:Originally posted by hagarag:The key word for us should be tolerance. Tolerance is very desirable. However, tolerance is also produced by indifference. We need much more than tolerance. We need compassion. We need unconditional affinity, akin to one in an extended family, which we actually are. quote:As for your comment that homosexuality or bisexuality has to do with genitals, that is not correct. It has to do with the mind. The genitals are just a machine which is controlled by the mind. . . . Sure. But the genital manifestation of what's in the mind is irrelevant to the discussion. That is all.
  8. quote:I think we already have this inspiration. It's what you do with it. If leaders is not the right word, then how about Armenians who have made it? I somehow doubt we would have the position in world-chess if it wasn't for that one Armenian who showed the rest of us that it is possible for us to become champions. Role models are good. But we need more than role models for the collective progress. There is a subtle but significant difference between a successful person that happens to be Armenian and a successful Armenian. The former is Gary Kasparov. The transformation of him to the latter is a fictional Gary Kasparov that pulls Armenia into his personal sphere, establishes a Software Company in Armenia bearing his name, markets his hand-made brandname Chess Sets made by Armenian artisans ("from the land of Chess"), and does high-profile charity work around the world from his base in Armenia. But these things don't happen in a vacuum. Such things are more likely to happen when the successful Armenians don't feel like freak-mutant Armenians due to the absence of other equally successful Armenians "near" them. The "isolated" Armenian is much more likely to become simply a person that happens to be Armenian. So the "networking" I was talking about can be as "passive" as simply providing the successful Armenian a sense that he/she is not a mutant Armenian. So that is one way in which the "critical mass" operates.
  9. quote:Originally posted by nairi: quote:Originally posted by Twilight Bark:However, I would be ecstatic with an occasional and steady "presence" other than things that involve death, calamities, and conflicts. You shouldn't be looking to (Western) media for that. I am not. I am wishing that "western media" had many more Armenian contributors. Too many of us value money above sucess, let alone intellectual pursuits. quote: quote:We need unconditional affinity, akin to one in an extended family, which we actually are.Even if that person holds ideas that are "inhuman", such as extermination of a race? I think "unconditional" is a little far-fetched, if not unrealistic. But that's a personal opinion. I said "unconditional affinity", not unconditional surrender or unconditional agreement. You argue with them, fight them, or even "jail" the nutcases if necessary, but you feel bothered by it the way you are forever uncomfortable about the row you had with that mental-case aunt that won't make peace with you. As opposed to saying "good riddance". Your "empirical" behavior regarding the hatemonger does not reflect that inner conflict. But the inner discomfort is indicative of how you view your nation. It also means that, even if you give up hope on the nutcase, you still accept or make his offspring as part of your "extended family". I am in effect talking about a primal, and profound, concept of a "tribe". Unabashedly.
  10. quote:Originally posted by nairi:We have quite an array of different Armenian books and CD-Roms for children with plenty of games in them, and they continue to multiply. I have checked some of the software, and the best was at the very low end level of the low end children's software titles in "dominant" languages. I am refraining from calling them "pathetic" because I am sure a lot of labor of love had gone into making them, and I do appreciate whatever is available. It's just that we have to do a lot better. It is very damaging (indeed toxic) to have (much) lower expectations from things Armenian. quote:We have a growing number of famous Armenians who openly speak about their heritage to foreign papers and magazines.I am thinking of the evening news or the mainstream newspaper. We do not need to be more obscure than the Fiji islands in the world's consciousness. How many Armenian columnists are there in mainstream media? How about radio? TV? There is no reason for us to be not grossly over-represented in intellectual pursuits. What values are we transmitting to our kids? Make a buck and have a comfortable life? Is that "new" or "old"? quote:We even have Hye Forum!Yes. And when we get quoted by CNN or The Economist we have arrived. quote:I don't think you can expect the word "Armenian" to ever become relevant outside of Armenian communities.I can expect the world. However, I would be ecstatic with an occasional and steady "presence" other than things that involve death, calamities, and conflicts. quote:This may be a sociological factor, I'm not too sure, but please don't think that American kids growing up in Holland know much about the country of their parents. In fact, many of these children hardly speak English. The only children who do are those whose parents either drill, send to English-speaking schools, or travel to English-sepaking countries on a regular basis. Moreover, many of these children/teenagers are as reluctant about getting to know their roots as Armenians are growing up isolated from Armenian communities. All this in a country where Hollywood movies, McDonald's, and Coca-Cola are more widespread than Dutch-made products and ideologies.When a culture is everywhere, it is almost the same as being absent. Similar to one's inability to smell one's own perfume after a while, while it can still be noticed by someone that walks by. By the way, I thought everyone in Holland could speak English. quote:As long as they are able to find each other, form their own groups, feel comfortable in them, or feel comfortable on their own for that matter, I personally don't see the necessity for "leadership". But again, if there are those who do find this necessary, it is up to them to take that initiative. By "leadership" I mean "inspiration". And those that are in need of leadership are almost by definition not the ones that are going to lead. While I in fact dislike the "leader" type character, and find many of its manifestations plainly annoying, I grudgingly accept that it is a very useful quality, especially when a culture lacks it so painfully. The difference between what you are "supposed" to achieve (and often a lot less) and exceeding yourself by a lot is that funny quality called "initiative" or "leadership". quote:I'm not too sure if I understand what you mean by "critical" mass, and what exactly you are expecting from them, however. I am not really talking about a yet another "locale" where young Armenians engage in chitchat. I mean a concentration of intelligent, modern (and proud) Armenians in the university departments, government offices, media editorial staff and the like at a level that allows them to network and be much more than the sum of the individuals. A brain does its wonder because its neurons are networked and interact. Take the same number of neurons and separate them, and you have a bunch of rather useless cells. I guess I am talking about expecting things that we are somehow not "supposed" to expect. Anyway, right now I am expecting myself to get back to work and make a buck.
  11. quote:Originally posted by nairi:I think there are enough "New Armenians" who care. I hope you are right. However, there is a disturbing lack of observational evidence for their abundant existence. In other words, if there is a critical mass of "New Armenians", I do not see the results of it. I hope that is because I am not informed enough. quote:In fact, I think many of these "alternative" institutions already exist, and are quite successful from what I hear. Think of AGLU (for gays and lesbians), or all the student organizations in universities where there are substantial amounts of Armenians. We have differing definitions of "alternative" institutions. While it is definitely a good thing for Armenians with an "alternative lifestyle" to have a cultural home, that was not what I had in mind when I used the term "alternative". As for the student organizations, how many of them are hitting the parents of the students for a good chunk of money for the computer literate students or alumni to write rich, modern, and professional computer games with Armenian themes? A few gameboy or playstation games that at least have an Armenian option would be a much greater breakthrough than most anything our genocide-obsessed institutions would regard as a "great achievement". How "alternative" are these "alternative" institutions? How many of them are making it possible to make the word "Armenian" relevant to an Armenian kid that is growing up outside the ghetto? Do they care? The relevant "new" alternative is not in the use of genitals, or in the age of the body. It's in the head. quote:Moreover, I'm not quite sure if "New Armenians" is a right term. I would simply call them "Armenians": they have been around ever since the beginning of our existence, and will continue to exist as long as we exist.A rational mindset that is different from an instinctive and failing one deserves to have the adjective "new" attached to it. Again, the question is not whether "New Armenians" have ever existed or not. The question is, do they exist now in numbers that form a "critical mass"? If they do, they are not led by anyone anywhere. Again, I hope my impressions are due to my ignorance.
  12. quote:Originally posted by nairi:If you feel the need for an institution/club/cultural center etc. that promotes or supports your ideology, try and find people with the same idea and start one. Exactly. Instead of saying "they" should not be the way they are, institutions that are meant to represent the unrepresented must be formed. Who gives the right to anyone to define the borders of "Armenian community"? No one. It is a right that is taken, not given. On the other hand, if our "famous" Mr. Baliozian could lament that he has not been supported and lavishly paid by those he criticizes (often rightly, though pointlessly, vulgarly, and with a clumsy and broad brush that covers the whole Armenian nation as well as its neighbors far and near to form a shapeless mess) for his public "service", perhaps we can forgive wh00t to demand mere acceptance by the "establishment". But let us remember: Republicans don't complain about not being invited to the social functions of the Democrats. Green party voters don't expect to be invited to Bible reading classes or Young Republicans meetings. Socialists don't mind being snubbed by the Conservatives. In any case, the best source of dynamism and progress is a healthy competition. If a free market is a good idea for the economy, it is much more so in the area of ideas and outlooks. The question is, are there enough "New Armenians" that actually care about their Armenian identity for the "alternative" institutions to take hold, flourish, and act as magnets for the "alienated"? That is the "critical mass" we should be thinking about, not the one that is supposed to be left after we gleefully cut off the "undesirable" Armenians. Compassion, love, and a positive attitude are not to be confused with a naive world view. In fact, they form a combination much more potent than a dour, exclusivist, and overly intellectual interpretation of Armenianness. TB the radical moderate
  13. quote:Originally posted by wh00t:Why is it that the most successful Armenians are the ones that have rejected their Armenian heritage? Cher wants nothing to do with us. Ditto Garry Kasparov. I would have thought the same of Andre Agassi had he not briefly acknowledged his heritage on "The Armenian-Americans". Furthermore, why is it that the biggest champions of the Armenian cause are those who rejected their Armenian heritage in the past? Atom Egoyan wanted nothing more than to distance himself from being Armenian when he was a teenager growing up in Vancouver, and now has done immeasurable good for Armenian awareness. I know nothing of Kirk Kirkorian being a card-carrying AYF member during his youth, but now the billionaire is pumping millions of dollars into the economy of the ROA. Where I live, in order to be seen as a "true Armenian", you must fulfill the following criteria: 1. Speak fluent Armenian. The level of fluency in Armenian must be equal to, if not greater than, the level of fluency in the official languages of the country. 2. 95% of friends must be Armenian. 100% is preferable. 3. Do not challenge the fundamentals of Armenian culture and church. I do not meet these standards. I have greater devotion to the Cause than most in the area but am rejected nonetheless. Those on this Forum with the best ideas are those who have little or nothing to do with the community at large. Armenians need to stick together to ensure the survival of the nation, but this can be done without sheltering ourselves from the rest of society. Nor must this be achieved by shunning those who do not fit into the idealistic image of an Armenian: half-Armenians, Armenians who do not speak perfect Armenian, etc. It is no wonder that the disenchanted are moving on to achieve great things. Dear wh00t,What you say resonates with many Armenians. However, I think lamenting on the behavior of the "traditionalist" Armenians is akin to lamenting the foolishness of the fools, the zealotry of the fanatics, or the old age and failing health of our parents. The fools are almost never converted to wisdom; they are bypassed. Parents are not changed or discarded; they are loved; and politely ignored when necessary. How is our lamentation on the lack of vision of the "old guard" any better than the "amot e" that we are all sick of? We are saying our version of "amot e", aren't we? It seems we still carry, in our cultural genetic code, the propensity to prefer "negative" solutions to problems. Similarly, the exclusivist attitudes displayed in this forum are woven from the same thread as the attitudes in the "ghetto" that they are supposedly protesting. I think the key to progress is creating new venues for expressing the will of the "New Armenians", and not the condemnation or destruction of the "Old Armenian" way. The arrow of time will take care of the rest. "New Armenians" feel "rejected from the community" because they have failed to form their own sense of community. In my haste I can point out two reasons for this: 1. The "New Armenian" is still mostly raised by the "Old Armenian", and carries the cultural genetic code of being a lousy leader. We still are not good leaders. By the time an Armenian is born into a family that encourages leadership, he is already removed several generations from the "Old Armenian"; too late. He is not even a "New Armenian". He is in fact not an Armenian at all. One or more of his grandparents are. 2. The answer to the question "What is the point of keeping the Armenian identity" has not been formulated well. Keeping and nurturing an Armenian identity in an "alien" society takes a significant amount of precious resources from an individual. Joe Schmoe next door doesn't have that burden while you do. For example, I am taking the time to gather my thoughts and type this post, while my competitor Mr. Schmoe does not. Without a compelling justification (i.e. a good answer to the above question), a modern "New Armenian" will be loth to do anything for the propagation of the Armenian identity. The first reason will be eliminated when the question in the second reason is satisfactorily answered. So I guess there is only one reason. By the way, this being discussed under the general category of "Famous Armenians" (why?) compels me to declare that anyone who disagrees with me or criticizes my views is either a charlatan or an ignorant fool, and is surely against human rights, democracy and all the good stuff we all love and cherish.
  14. Twilight Bark

    Bizarre

    quote:Originally posted by MJ:TB, I don't know what you are saying and have very little time for nonsense. You were saying...? Alright MJ, alright, don't get testy on me now. I see you are not in the mood for subtlety today. But "no time for nonsense"? I don't know. Anyway, I want you to know that the pointy side of my comments were not directed at you at all. I share your loathing for the trivialization of the essense of being Armenian. Where I disagree with you is the importance of the silly symbols and unthinking reciting of the cliches. Those things are called "national myths". The silliness is not particular to Armenians or "loser" nations. The "great" nations have them aplenty but are doing just fine. The fact that Armenia, of all places, was put on that list, rather than some other "unimportant" nation has little to do with the silliness of our cliches. More could be said about such matters in another thread. But that'll have to wait. This is going to be my last post for some time. Sorry to rattle your nerves. That was not my intention. Take care all, TB
  15. Twilight Bark

    Bizarre

    quote:Originally posted by MJ:Dear TB, I don't know what you were saying above, but whoever is interested in whatever debates, I may propose you holding their hand and taking them to their high school debate club. Oh no. I avoid like the plague people who would say things like: "whatever it is, it is just someone else’s fault. They just don't like us because we are too smart." or "these Americans may be too stupid to understand how important we are. They may not even know that we are the first Christian nation in history and they don't understand that they owe us big time for it. They haven't even sent us their payments, yet, for quite some time." Just like you would.
  16. quote:Originally posted by EZ: quote:Originally posted by Azat:Harut jan, another way to say donkey is ass. Now I'm getting confused. What does "esh" mean? I looked up the english "donkey", but it doesn't exist in my EA dictionary. Which word in E Armenian should I use for "ass" and what for "donkey"?Dear EZ,"Esh" means donkey, the animal. It has nothing to do with human body parts. Our dictionary writers are often too well-mannered for their own good and leave out some of the "words that proper people should not use". So I wouldn't be surprised to see such omissions. At the risk of using an improper word, , the other "ass" is "vor" (i.e. used in equally vulgar contexts). On another note, the vocabularies of Eastern and Western Armenian are largely identical (i.e. little need to stress "eastern" or "western"). The difference between the two flavors is mainly in some grammatical rules and pronunciation. Hopefully the soviet-induced differences in orthography will eventually disappear (but no big deal).
  17. Twilight Bark

    Bizarre

    quote:Originally posted by MJ:I beg Well, if you put it that way. We disagree much less than you think we do. quote:"Anti-Armenianism" is a non-existent category in the US policy towards Armenia. Armenia(ns) is nothing for America to be "anti." Armenia is a half-breathing country with a Diaspora in agony. The issue is not Armenia, but Armenians. And the reason why anti-Armenian attitudes are tolerable is precisely because the Armenian profile is nearly non-existent in the mainstream culture. I was not talking about Joe Sixpack having any opinion on the matter, other than grouping Armenians in the "collateral damage material" category. And that is precisely the problem. There certainly exists, where it matters (let's euphemistically call it the "State Department"), an anti-Armenian bias. It exists in the heads of a tiny number of people that matter. Not because Armenians are too powerful in absolute terms, or that they are of relevance to much of anything. But because of two main reasons. First, they are a perennial nuiscance, buying their way into the political process, when their collective importance does not justify it. This is the "negative" motivator of the anti-Armenianism. Second, and this is perhaps more important, they are expendable (i.e. can be "sacrificed", not that it is much of sacrifice for "them") for reasons to which you alluded. They can be used as a punching bag to show lack of religious bias in foreign policy, with little consequence. They can be used as a punching bag to complain about "ethnic lobbies", without the writer being exiled to Alaska as a result. I am sure I missed a few of our multipurpose qualities, but you get the idea. quote:I would rather think this incident has to be qualified as "message to Armenia." I still have a question: are there any active/inactive terrorist organizations functioning/registered in Armenia? You give a ridiculous amount of credit and benefit of the doubt to the urban peasants at the "State Department". quote:Question 2: Does Armenia stand for something other then "preservation?"Armenia, in an ideal world, stands for the opportunity for Armenians to realize their biggest dreams without having to sacrifice their or their descendants' identity and heritage. It stands for having our cake and eat it too. In the real world, it stands for little more than a symbol for the diasporans. I don't know if it represents anything more than "what is familiar" to its residents. I think eveyone on the forum agrees that things must change for the better. We are real geniuses to see that, aren't we? quote:Finally, I think this incident, again, is characteristic of our mass psychology - "whatever it is, it is just someone else’s fault. They just don't like us because we are too smart." But I may be wrong - "these Americans may be too stupid to understand how important we are. They may not even know that we are the first Christian nation in history and they don't understand that they owe us big time for it. They haven't even sent us their payments, yet, for quite some time." You were doing alright until you constructed this caricature of a straw-man argument. I am sure you can find suitably stupid Armenians and tie them to a chair in front of you so that you can have a lopsided debate. Unfortunately such an activity is affably called by another name, and you know what that is.
  18. Twilight Bark

    Bizarre

    quote:Originally posted by hagarag:Twilight Bark, I personally was thrilled when ANCA endorsed Clinton. For all of Dole's advocacy for Armenians what influence does he have, if any, among his colleagues inthe Republican Party? Just remember that Clinton allowed the Genocide Resolution to come to the floor of the US House and only when he got an urgent call from Peres in the middle of the night, after Sharon had walked on a Moslem Holy place in Jerusalem (done specifically to agitate the Palestinians, to help his candidacy)did Clinton use his influence to quelch the Resolution. The Bush Administration, on the other hand, overtly insulted us. This was not a reaction but an overt action. As such, this was much more malevolent than Clinton's actions. Dear Hagarag, Please stick to the issue at hand. Loyalty to sincere friends is sacrosanct even for the slickest of the smnooth operators, if they want to ensure success beyond the shortest of terms. It has to do with credibility. The kind of stupidity displayed by ANCA in that election is a regular, and amusing, practice in American voting habits: "Vote for the sure winner; don't let your vote go to waste." Really now.
  19. Twilight Bark

    Bizarre

    This was so absurd that one should think it was not intended to stick as law. However, it probably was intended to stick to average newspaper reader's mind: "Armenia? Oh yeah, wasn't it on the pariah-state list?". I doubt that the "correction" will get any press. Anti-Armenianism is still a very tolerable concept in America; nobody gets red-faced about it. While ANCA should be congratulated in this instance, some of their past actions only encouraged the antiarmenians. Who could take them seriously when they decided to "support" Clinton against Bob Dole, when they thought that the latter was sure to lose. If a huge Armenian organization shows so little loyalty to its greatest ally, it might as well say "Hey guys, we are the punching bag you are looking for". I was tempted to write this in an earlier thread concerning "clash of civilizations" and how Armenia might benefit (!!!) from it. I can't quite remember who it was that said it could be a good thing for Armenia. What folly! The clash of civilizations is already underway, except that the US is never going to call it that. And what better way to demonstrate its "religion-neutral" credentials than using a few expendable "Christian states" (the other obvious candidate is naturally off-limits) as punching bags, and boast of its close friendship with a "muslim" ally, Turkey. If there still are naive souls out there hoping to milk our "status" as "the first Christian nation", I desperately hope that they have woken up. I somehow doubt it though. My tentative explanation is that this was cooked up as a no-lose (for the antiarmenians) prank. If it stuck, great. If it didn't stick as law, it will as memory and impression; again pretty good. And the bonus is that it acted as a probe to gauge the readiness, resolve, and resources of the Armenian lobby, so they know what to expect next time. We lost something at the end of the day.
  20. Twilight Bark

    Light-bulb

    There aren't enough HyeForumers to change the bulb. MosJan puts a newsflash on the bulletin board of the HyeForum house, informing that there is a burnt light bulb and needs to be changed. He doesn't change it though. Sip starts wondering why people bother with light bulbs, when they can enjoy the sunlight during the day, and at night their computer monitor doesn't need the lamp, and its light provides sufficient illumination not to trip over something on the way to the fridge and back. He then demands that HyeForumers provide an explanation for their light bulb fetish. As Sip suspects, Thoth comes to the scene and chides the HyeForumers for their prejudice against the burnt light bulb. He says the burnt light is just different, and not necessarily worse than the new bulb that the HyeForumers want. Sip scratches his head wondering why he agrees with Thoth. Domino starts digging through his references on the history of light bulbs, and starts searching for HyeForumers that can appreciate the finer points of light bulb design. Arpa starts passing out leaflets on the etymology of the light bulb in 37 languages, and makes angry remarks that HyeForum lacks a proper light bulb factory and needs to buy bulbs made by somebody else. He also suggests that HyeForum should stop using whimpy regular lamps, and says "What we really need is a gigawatt power laser cannon. That's the kind of light we need". He starts wondering if the local community school teaches people how to build one. Hagarag smirks knowingly, pointing out that the only reason the light bulb is burnt is because of HyeForumers' incompetence and non-vegetarian diet, and refuses to change the bulb, asking who would want to see their faces when they eat meat, have reckless sex or indeed sex at all, and clearly show their ages when he doesn't look a day over thirty. He suggests that, as a promising solution to the problem, they must change their diet and religion, and try to upgrade to a cooler ethnicity whose light bulbs never get burnt. MJ gives an existential account of the relevance of the bulb, and proceeds to say that there aren't any qualified HyeForumers to change the bulb, and that he is not about to do it alone for the rest to have a free ride, especially when the house is full of so many unworthy people. Boghos agrees, but starts a discussion about MJ's bulb theory. Rubo gets upset at the whole thing, saying he knew this mess would happen all along. He starts reading "On Changing Light Bulbs - Armenians can't do it" written by Ara Baliozian. He then impatiently jumps from his chair and storms out. Nairi commends Rubo on his course of action, and starts collecting opinions on forming an organization to change light bulbs, preferably formed by people who never changed a light bulb before. Gamavor blames the Turks for the burnt bulb, and suggests that HyeForumers should not take his name literally. Twilight Bark drops by to say hello, says he really has no time to change the bulb, and rushes out the door. He hears something that sounds like "He's not much use is he?", but couldn't be bothered to double check. A new immigrant from Gyumri sees the sorry shape HyeForumers are in, and finds a wealthy merchant to help them out. Upon hearing the need for charity, the merchant decides to have a church built at the point of need, with a big plaque at its entrance displaying his generosity and spirituality. The illegal-immigrant workers building the church take pity on the poor slobs at the HyeForum house next to their site, and change the bulb for them using one of their spare bulbs. [ December 13, 2002, 05:57 PM: Message edited by: Twilight Bark ]
  21. As for the title topic, yes, Armenians could be described as xenophobic, provided that one clarifies the term for this particular case. "Phobia" means fear, but in cultural contexts it is usually taken to mean "hate". That is wrong in the case of Armenian xenophobia. Armenians actually do fear other nations, partly for good reason, and partly for lack of self-confidence when there is no good reason. Fearful of other cultures, yes. Hateful of other cultures, no. Getting rid of the Armenian xenophobia requires the gaining of self-confidence. In the meantime, implying that Armenian xenophobia is hateful is wrong and unfair. We may be goofballs. But we are harmless goofballs.
  22. quote:Originally posted by Sip: quote:Originally posted by MJ:Actually, you are wrong Sip. ... It was discovered by academician Piatrovsky about 60 years ago during the explorations of the ruins of Erebuni.... I stand corrected Boghos and MJ. No no no. You all stand (or you can sit if you like) corrected. The prototype of the Internet was invented by the canines of London, and was called ... the Twilight Bark! For the documentary evidence, consult Disney's 101 Dalmatians.
  23. quote:Originally posted by THOTH:At worst I may have indicated that I would adopt similar behavior...but have I? Yes, I know you are regularly teased. But I was surprised to see you drag in a tasteless innuendo about his private life (in another thread). That's when you lost your license. However, I am not "so upset" at you, and simply wanted to remind you that you are not spotless. Relax. You are well-liked. TB
  24. quote:Originally posted by THOTH:TB - you have done well - (lets see how long it lasts). Ahem. I was asking about my fleeting role as the peace-maker of the forum. However, I am sensing that you were affirming my general well-behavior. For that, I thank you. However, I assure you that I was not seeking such affirmation, for I think I have always stayed well within the limits of civilized discourse. In case I wanted such affirmation, I would probably go to someone else. You see, you recently lost the chance of being the dispenser of wisdom on good manners during your exchange with Boghos. Therefore, I kindly request that you not be observer of "how long it lasts".
  25. quote:Originally posted by Rubo:Cheers and yes lets do start afresh. Wonderful. Just as a note, the name "Khodja" was Hagarag's previous moniker on this forum. That is, he wrote under the name "Khodja" himself. He says people back in Ottoman Istanbul called his grandfather by that title. So it's not really name-calling. But of course we have had real intances of that too.
×
×
  • Create New...