axel
Members-
Posts
389 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Events
Gallery
Everything posted by axel
-
Some contend christianism is an emasculating religion. While this may be true of christianism in its modern (I would say modernist) and degenerate forms (evangelism, mormonism...), it is not of Orthodoxy. Orthodox Christianism is virile in its essence, it is a religion of sacrifice.
-
First I have to say I personally discard the state vs individual worldview which I find overly restrictive in that it is merely based on a materialistic/individualistic faith derived from ideas of the "enlightenement" (I find it ironic btw that you espouse such a view while accusing "nationalism" of this very wrong). Worldviews are based on value judgements, there are not mere rational constructions. Spengler values Culture, Solzhenitsyn, Ethics, others, Tradition vs Modernity... I just want to point out that I don't see the world through the prism of the State vs the individual so that I be not accused of standing in defence of what you call "The State" (which is a gross oversimplification btw that allows all possible amalgams to be made) or Coercion in the largest possible sense, by the following "critique" (the word critique is a bit presumptuous I guess ) for I reject the hidden assumptions that subtend the angle of analysis. Government subjects are not victims in the absolute (there might be victims in specific instances, under specific regimes). As much as I hate do so, I have to refer to the idea of social contract in which the individual forgoes some of his freedom in return for a certain amount of protection (be it physical, social...). This is also valid in early societies, in what Giambattista Vico characterizes as the heroic age. Are you making a case for monarchy? who says appointed caretakers make the actual decisions? that there does not exist ruling circles holding an "inheritable monopoly" on public affairs and exerting power through various means of pressure? in fact things are much more complex but I don't have time to develop a theory on this subject in fact, this is not my area of interest. This is a statement of belief, one which considers that this world is entirely driven by material greed and reduces man to a mere socio-economical animal. Nothing in the absolute justifies this assumption although I have to agree it has often been justified in practise (but not always). A private owner of government? So you believe some form of government or authority/hierarchy should be maintained?? I don't see where anarchy stands here if authority is to be maintained. Actually, authority/hierarchy exists in all forms of society. (And in the same way some see in the "invisible hand" an absolute law of God, others such as Maistre see in hierarchy and authority a divine manifestation according to the belief that "all power comes from God"). It is either hidden or apparent. The miracle of so-called democracy is to have made hierarchy almost invisible to the profane. slave? slave owner? interesting comparison... -Who are you? -The new Number Two -Who is Number One? -You are Number Six -I am not a number . . . I'm a free man! http://www.the-prisoner-6.freeserve.co.uk/...ner_updates.htm the above doesn't stand as an argument but the words you use denote some hidden assumptions that contradict the idea of freedom you seem to be defending Thanks for the advice. As for material progress (you refered to the improvement of living standards in order to make a case for capitalism thereby making a value judgement which I do not agree with. you may find some ethical arguments against the idea of progress here), it surely doesn't eclipse spiritual decay which I find to be the most worrying aspect of the modern world. But as Heidegger (among others) points out, spiritual decay has reached such a stage of advancement that most people no longer have the possibility of realizing it.
-
You must have read my post too quickly as I wrote: I will try to look at your post in detail later on to see if there is something new in your reasoning but at first sight, there doesn't seem to be.
-
a few quick thoughts. if we consider early societies as anarchic and if anarchy is a viable system, why is it that the "state" appeared? anarchists merely advocate another system (that which is defined as no system) as though systems held the key to mankind's problems. How naive a belief. Anarchy is based on the rousseauist premise that man is good in nature which is obviously not true of all men, or that every men following their own interests is the way to harmony and ultimate good which is an erroneous belief. one should at least learn that from history. if ethics are not the criteria for judging a society what is? efficiency? progress? these abstract notions that alienate man? the free market? there is nothing to be loved in all this, nothing transcendent. just the mechanics of offer and demand. mechanics, that is the word. machinery. man is lost into machinery. But man's endeavor on this earth should be a nobler one than that of submitting to the forces of the "market". Otherwise life is just meaningless. It has no purpose. man is a mere puppet enslaved by the "laws" of the material world. But Man is FREE. Some people having discovered these "higher" laws or principles saw in them the hand of God. I am afraid this god, in christian terminology we refer to as satan.
-
I suggest you read Igor Shafarevich's "socialist phenomenon" (if you haven't done so already ) As for America becoming socialist in the strict sense of the term, I have some doubts. The abolition of private property doesn't seem to be likely in a near future.
-
Reminds me of a Tolstoï short story I read a few years ago, "the death of Ivan Illitch". the last days of a dying man who contemplates the emptiness and futility of his life and realizes he has done everything wrong.
-
In your dreams, ma chérie. The french republic doesn't give a damn about the armenians and the Genocide. Gilles Veinstein, well known for his negationist views, wouldn't have been named professor at prestigious Collège de France otherwise. Actually there has been a recent proposal for the law you made a reference to to be extended so as to make the denial of the armenian genocide penally sanctionable. The amendment was rejected. One deputy, Pascal Clément observed that putting the armenian genocide on the same level as the Shoah would amount to insulting the jewish people. http://www.cdca.asso.fr/cdca/cdca-affaire_...t_reactions.htm
-
not true.
-
While magnanimity stands as a mark of superiority, bitterness and animosity often betray a hidden inferiority complex.
-
I am quite flattered to be the exception that confirms the rule. Nous sommes, de toute évidence, deux êtres d'exception. I have trouble, though, picturing how I might absorb you
-
Like you know something we don't. Here is some reading for you: L'esprit du jacobinisme, especially chapter one and seven, the latter makes the distinction between modern (artificial/ideological) nationalism and traditional patriotism quite clear. Jacobin "nationalism" was never an end in itself. It espoused the boundaries of France at a time where the boundaries of France coincided with that of the revolution. La révolution et la libre pensée
-
I reject the theory of superiority as fundamentally flawed: its enunciation by someone other than myself makes me feel inferior.
-
Yet another "The more I love you the more I hate you" (or vice versa) relationship. I think anileve and anonymouse would make a wonderful couple. They have so much in common.
-
Claiming that all members of the nation were consciouly serving the "higher interest of the nation" (which is an abstraction) is a romantic myth. But that is not only true before but AFTER the enlightenment too. The "higher interest of the nation" is always defined by a small elite. The democratic idea of the will of the people expressing the higher interest of the nation is pure propaganda. That said, one should distinguish between abstract/political national awareness (as expressed above) which is reserved to a small elite and "natural" national awareness or national identification. It seems to me this distinction has not been made sufficiently clear. It is true that before the enlightenment and the late formalization of the concept of nation (by the likes of Ernest Renan) and propaganda that followed, europeans shared different affinities and expressed differente allegiances so that there were not clearly-delimited self-conscious national groups but interpenetrating and overlapping sets. Identity was split up between language, religious conscience (the first crusade regrouped men of vary diverse ethnicities), fidelity to a given lord, and "class" who shared the same code of conduct and ethics (as demonstrated by intermarriage between noblemen accross Europe) among others. The preponderance of the Catholic Church and the existence of powerful orders that spanned much of Europe (notably the Templars) are good illustrations of supranational bodies that defined transnational identities. But history is full of conflicts between such entities and actual kingdoms (basically national entities!), occurring well before the enlightenment. One only has to look at Philippe Le Bel's reign. The french kingdom was the embodiment of the national idea. The subjects' loyalty to their kings defined the "national" sentiment (and one cannot underestimate this sentiment). The superior interest of the nation was defined by the king. So even in Europe one cannot claim that actual national awareness (even in its political form) was inexistent prior to the nineteenth century. This might have been true of Germany and Italy who were split up into multiple political entities before their unification (et encore!) but certainly not of France. => One should not oversimplify and extrapolate european's own historical development which, moreover, is not uniform as is suggested! More generally, one should be careful when trying to apply the same historical model onto different historical objects. Armenia's identity has long been shaped up by its Church. The early split of the latter from mainstream christianity following the concile of Chalcedon made it an auto-cephalous and national entity. This early specificity alone distinguishes it from the european nations. The widespread sense of belonging to the Church was clearly a determinant of national awareness in addition to ethnico-linguistical considerations. That this identification might not have translated into a political reality (unity) is another question. But exhibiting the lack of political unity in order to discredit the idea of national awareness prior to the "enlightenment" is plainly wrong.
-
Sure, passeism leads to fossilization but the opposite attitude (negating one's roots) is the surest path to decadence and cultural/national death.
-
Ara Baliozian has found his master in sophistry.
-
This is no problem if the racial criterion is replaced by a spiritual one. thus we might consider Armenians to be spiritual descendants of Hayk. Racial or biological nationalism is the post-enlightenment ("modern") form of nationalism, an absurd constuct, that is opposed to the traditionalist worldview that seems to be that of hagopn (correct me if I'm wrong). hagopn, the term "nationalism" refers to the modern ideology and therefore lends itself to confusion. It might be more appropriate to speak of the "armenian national idea".
-
Well this conversation reminds me of the movie Andrei Rublev which is a reflection on evil, faith and art. It is a succession of episodes in the life of a reknowned fifteenth century russian icon painter showing his inner struggle, his hopes and his deceptions. Among the numerous characters emerges the trinity Kiril, Andrei and Danila all three, monks, who may symbolically be related to the Father, the Son and the Holy Spirit. Kiril's God is a vengeful God, a God of fear reminiscent of the one of the old testament whereas Andrei's is one of Love and redemption. In the scene 'the passion according to Andrei" Rublev engages into a dialogue with another painter, Theophanes the Greek. Theophanes argues he believes in God and not in man, that Good may only exist within oneself. Andrei agrees to the fact that Man does evil yet he affirms his faith in the reconciliation between man and God arguing it was precisely for that purpose that God sent his Son. In another scene, Andrei refuses to paint the scene of the Last Judgment precisely for the reason he doesn't want to scare people. Andrei Rublev by Andrei Tarkovsky Faith in Man and Faith in God are interleaved. When I say Faith in Man, I don't mean humanism!! (which divinises man) but faith in man's ability to elevate himself towards God. The following text I already mentionned a number of times is extremely relevant in this regard: The Grand Inquisitor (from the Brothers Karamazov) PS: This is my last message. Gevo jan, keep cool and don't pay much attention to THOTH's provocations. He has great spiritual problems. He would not be a militant atheist otherwise. Faith is Life. What does he have to offer in replacement? Not much, perhaps something called absurdity.
-
Anoushik, I guess you didn't look at this one then You cannot separate God from Christianism for Christianism is the religion of God-Man and the religion of Faith not a humanistic philosophy or a set of moral principles. Morality or rather moralism is degenerate spirituality. In one of my readings, I came upon the following quote by Lao-Tseu, I paraphrase: when Meaning is lost then so is Life, When Life is lost then so is Love, when Love is lost then so is Justice when Justice is lost then so is custom. (here custom/tradition is equivalent to moralism, that is dead spirituality fossilized into a moral code) Custom is lack of fidelity and lack of faith and the beginning of confusion. Of course from a materialistic perspective, the distinction between morality and spirituality is not understandable. Spirituality and Faith are beyond the reach of utilitarian minds. And what characterizes american minds is precisely that: utilitarism, productivism, narrow rationalism... so it is no wonder that this land has not seen the blossom of the Spirit, that christianism has degenerated on its soil into such legalistic forms as "biblical christianism" with its emphasis on the bible and the law. The truth is american civilization will not give birth to a Bach or a Brueghel and the reason why is because it is soulless. Understanding the true nature of Art that is selfless in essence and is the reflection of the transcendental and the sacred is a way to apprehend God as Armat rightfully suggests. There is another one and that is the confrontation with evil. In any circumstance, Faith is a matter of personal experience. From a christian standpoint, it has to do with the idea of Grace. www.stgregoryofnarek.am
-
People praying to God for material rewards (including temporal life) don't have a clue about Christianism. Their mindset is paganistic. Have you taken a look at the links I provided or did I post in vain? The worth of Christianity and the unworthiness of Christians
-
Well this is entirely different. You (rightly) accuse some self-proclaimed christians of being unchristian and irreligious and you use this argument to discredit faith and support atheism? this doesn't make sense really. And again with the twin towers example, you're not rejecting God but some misconceptions people have about God. The following essay is worth reading for it addresses all the questions that have been raised in this thread: http://www.chebucto.ns.ca/Philosophy/Sui-G...ssays/worth.htm there are a number of threads on theism/atheism/agnosticism on this board btw: here is one I initiated a year ago: http://64.21.83.54/forum/index.php?showtopic=3240
-
"This means that the mistake must be at the root, at the very basis of human thinking in the past centuries. I refer to the prevailing Western view of the world which was first born during the Renaissance and found its political expression from the period of the Enlightenment. It became the basis for government and social science and could be defined as rationalistic humanism or humanistic autonomy: the proclaimed and enforced autonomy of man from any higher force above him. It could also be called anthropocentricity, with man seen as the center of everything that exists. The turn introduced by the Renaissance evidently was inevitable historically. The Middle Ages had come to a natural end by exhaustion, becoming an intolerable despotic repression of man's physical nature in favor of the spiritual one. Then, however, we turned our backs upon the Spirit and embraced all that is material with excessive and unwarranted zeal. This new way of thinking, which had imposed on us its guidance, did not admit the existence of intrinsic evil in man nor did it see any higher task than the attainment of happiness on earth. It based modern Western civilization on the dangerous trend to worship man and his material needs. Everything beyond physical well-being and accumulation of material goods, all other human requirements and characteristics of a subtler and higher nature, were left outside the area of attention of state and social systems, as if human life did not have any superior sense. That provided access for evil, of which in our days there is a free and constant flow. Merely freedom does not in the least solve all the problems of human life and it even adds a number of new ones. (...) One does see the same stones in the foundations of a despiritualized humanism and of any type of socialism: endless materialism; freedom from religion and religious responsibility, which under communist regimes reach the stage of anti-religious dictatorship; concentration on social structures with a seemingly scientific approach. (This is typical of the Enlightenment in the Eighteenth Century and of Marxism). Not by coincidence all of communism's meaningless pledges and oaths are about Man, with a capital M, and his earthly happiness. At first glance it seems an ugly parallel: common traits in the thinking and way of life of today's West and today's East? But such is the logic of materialistic development. (...) I am not examining here the case of a world war disaster and the changes which it would produce in society. As long as we wake up every morning under a peaceful sun, we have to lead an everyday life. There is a disaster, however, which has already been under way for quite some time. I am referring to the calamity of a despiritualized and irreligious humanistic consciousness. To such consciousness, man is the touchstone in judging and evaluating everything on earth. Imperfect man, who is never free of pride, self-interest, envy, vanity, and dozens of other defects. We are now experiencing the consequences of mistakes which had not been noticed at the beginning of the journey. On the way from the Renaissance to our days we have enriched our experience, but we have lost the concept of a Supreme Complete Entity which used to restrain our passions and our irresponsibility. We have placed too much hope in political and social reforms, only to find out that we were being deprived of our most precious possession: our spiritual life. In the East, it is destroyed by the dealings and machinations of the ruling party. In the West, commercial interests tend to suffocate it. This is the real crisis. The split in the world is less terrible than the similarity of the disease plaguing its main sections. If humanism were right in declaring that man is born to be happy, he would not be born to die. Since his body is doomed to die, his task on earth evidently must be of a more spiritual nature. It cannot be unrestrained enjoyment of everyday life. It cannot be the search for the best ways to obtain material goods and then cheerfully get the most out of them. It has to be the fulfillment of a permanent, earnest duty so that one's life journey may become an experience of moral growth, so that one may leave life a better human being than one started it. It is imperative to review the table of widespread human values. Its present incorrectness is astounding. It is not possible that assessment of the President's performance be reduced to the question of how much money one makes or of unlimited availability of gasoline. Only voluntary, inspired self-restraint can raise man above the world stream of materialism. It would be retrogression to attach oneself today to the ossified formulas of the Enlightenment. Social dogmatism leaves us completely helpless in front of the trials of our times. " excerpt from Alexander Solzhenitsyn's Harvard address
-
Any follower of any given religion considers his "religion" to be the absolute Truth. Certainly not. Think as you wish. Err as you wish too. Who am I to make statements? is that your point? well who are you to express a single opinion? Defending absolute relativism is no more acceptable than defending absolute truth. do you expect everyone to think exactly like you???? You should shut up right away. I will. Well clearly you do not understand the spirit of christianism. This is my last message on this board (some may breathe a sigh of relief). I feel like I am repeating the same stuff over and over again and always getting the same reactions. Not very encouraging to say the least. ANS DO AS YOU PLEASE. YOU KNOW BETTER THAN ALL THE APOSTLES, THE PATRIARCHS, THE FATHERS, THE SAINTS, THE ASCETS, THE MARTYRS... AND GOD HIMSELF.
-
Well to the follower, this is a tautology. One does not think in terms of "religion" or "organized religion". That is a secular view. The Orthodox Christians share a common Faith and consider the Church to be the Body of Christ.
