Em Posted August 31, 2009 Report Share Posted August 31, 2009 (edited) http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20090831/ap_on_...urkey_armenia_4 Turkey, Armenia agree to establish diplomatic ties By SUZAN FRASER, Associated Press Writer – Mon Aug 31, 3:30 pm ETANKARA, Turkey Armenia and Turkey agreed Monday to establish diplomat relations, overcoming a seemingly intractable rift that dates to the early 20th century and was marked by massacres of Armeniansunder Ottoman rule. The neighboring countries would be setting up and developing relations for the first time, Turkish Foreign Ministry spokesman Burak Ozugergin said. It is unclear, however, if the talks will touch on the dispute over theWorld War I-era killings. The issue is a major stumbling block to Turkey's aspirations to join the European Union and has strained ties with the United States. Historians estimate that, in the last days of the Ottoman Empire, up to 1.5 million Armenians were killed by Ottoman Turks in what is widely regarded as the first genocide of the 20th Century. Turkey denies that the deaths constituted genocide, contending the toll has been inflated and that the casualties were victims of civil war. It says Turks also suffered losses in the hands of Armenian gangs. Turkey and Armenia also disagree about Armenian forces' control of the Arzerbaijani region of Nagorno-Karabakh. Turkey is a close ally of Azerbaijan and back Baku's claims to the region, which has a high number of ethnic Armenian residents but is located within Azerbaijan's borders. Turkey was one of the first countries to recognize Armenia's independence in 1991, but the two countries never established diplomatic relations and their joint border has been closed since 1993. Ties began to improve after a so-called soccer diplomacy campaign last year, when Turkish PresidentAbdullah Gul attended a World Cup qualifier in Armenia. Armenia's President Serge Sarkisian has said he wants significant diplomatic progress on the reopening of their shared border before he will agree to attend a World Cup qualifying match in Turkey on Oct. 14. The Turkish Foreign Ministry said the upcoming talks, agreed to after mediation by Switzerland, should last about six weeks. Armenian political commentator Artyom Yerkanian, speaking during a special broadcast on Armenian television, suggested the agreement to establish ties could be signed at the October match in Turkey. Edited August 31, 2009 by Em Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Em Posted August 31, 2009 Author Report Share Posted August 31, 2009 As a friend pointed out, now we wait to see if Azerbaijan makes a stink over it. If not, we are doomed over NK issue. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Arpa Posted August 31, 2009 Report Share Posted August 31, 2009 (edited) Yes!!! Chalk up another "goal" to the team from ankara, just as they scored one day before that fateful date of April 24, 2009, just as we are at the eve of the "football match" (diplomacy). When will we ever learn ""diplomacy"? Note that, regardless what the dictionaries may say, to me "diplomacy" still means "double talk", speaking from both sides of the mouth. We will see who has the bigger "ball" between their legs. Can I say it one more time? "You fool me once, shame on you. You fool me twice, SHAME ON ME!!! We should send real diplomats to those talks, who can speak in a language that the whole world can understand. No, no. Not rusky, turksky or armiansky. How about angliansky? Edited September 1, 2009 by Arpa Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
MosJan Posted September 1, 2009 Report Share Posted September 1, 2009 As a friend pointed out, now we wait to see if Azerbaijan makes a stink over it. If not, we are doomed over NK issue. Em jan Qaghaqakanutyun@ qez el ir JAnker@ q@tsets kartses / yerb 92in mer Artsaxyan azatagrakan payqarin miyatsav MAryami Gund@ ( Kanants Gud@ ) azeriner@ ausm eyin te irents verj@ yekav yerb Hye Kananyq zenq en vertsrel dzerqin, hima mer Em'na Qaghaqakanutyamb hetaqrqrvum Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
MosJan Posted September 1, 2009 Report Share Posted September 1, 2009 iys amen@ hamarya te parz er rus turqakan verjin axperakan handipumnerits heto .... sa hima iysor.. isk inchpes LTP'i 10 tary araj sa giter ?? yev asum er te iyn inch mez en arajarkum iysor ( 1997~98 tvakannerin ) el chen arajarkelu ? lav iverjo mi or irakanutyuN@ haytni linelu e te inch eyin iarakanum arajarkum mez iyn jamanak ? xndrum em yete gushakelu eq mi greq. qanzi 10001 angam arden menq gushakel yev paxxarakel enq LTP yev ir andznakazm@.. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Yervant1 Posted September 1, 2009 Report Share Posted September 1, 2009 Just another delay tactic. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Em Posted September 1, 2009 Author Report Share Posted September 1, 2009 iys amen@ hamarya te parz er rus turqakan verjin axperakan handipumnerits heto .... sa hima iysor.. isk inchpes LTP'i 10 tary araj sa giter ?? yev asum er te iyn inch mez en arajarkum iysor ( 1997~98 tvakannerin ) el chen arajarkelu ? lav iverjo mi or irakanutyuN@ haytni linelu e te inch eyin iarakanum arajarkum mez iyn jamanak ? xndrum em yete gushakelu eq mi greq. qanzi 10001 angam arden menq gushakel yev paxxarakel enq LTP yev ir andznakazm@.. Before I get shot for suggesting such a thing, please take it with a grain of salt. Maybe what LTP planted will bear fruit through intelligent maneuvering on the part of current administration. Lots of people would like to see open relations between our two countries. I don't live in Armenia and do not bear the direct brunt of the hostility and hardship our people endure on a daily basis. MAYBE some good can come out of some REAL dialogue- symbolically presented for the benefit of both countries citizens. Maybe our country can be proactive and change the course of it's future. At some point, you have to pick yourself up, shake off the "victim" title, roll up your sleeves and get to work. Not forget or be trusting, but forgive to heal thyself first. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Em Posted September 1, 2009 Author Report Share Posted September 1, 2009 Em jan Qaghaqakanutyun@ qez el ir JAnker@ q@tsets kartses / yerb 92in mer Artsaxyan azatagrakan payqarin miyatsav MAryami Gund@ ( Kanants Gud@ ) azeriner@ ausm eyin te irents verj@ yekav yerb Hye Kananyq zenq en vertsrel dzerqin, hima mer Em'na Qaghaqakanutyamb hetaqrqrvum I have deeply imbedded romantic sensibilities, Movses jan. I would go and volunteer my services if war broke out again. Or at least help out in any way I could. I really want to live in Yerevan again in my lifetime. Bayc lava giten vor zinvats knoj mot "xax" chka. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
MosJan Posted September 1, 2009 Report Share Posted September 1, 2009 I have deeply imbedded romantic sensibilities, Movses jan. I would go and volunteer my services if war broke out again. Or at least help out in any way I could. I really want to live in Yerevan again in my lifetime. Bayc lava giten vor zinvats knoj mot "xax" chka. knoj mot espes te enpes xagh ch@ka Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
gamavor Posted September 1, 2009 Report Share Posted September 1, 2009 It doesn't matter basically.... The Armenian side should take more relaxed approach. It is in Turkish and American favor afterall... Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Boghos Posted September 1, 2009 Report Share Posted September 1, 2009 Just another delay tactic. It may very well be. In spite of the fact that the trilateral relations Armenia-Azerbaijan-Turkey are of limited importance and interest for those outside the region there is pressure from the United States to establish diplomatic relations and reopen the border. However unlike the pathetic announcements of important breakthroughs made before April 24th, we now have something a bit more concrete: on one side Armenia has reaffirmed what it has been saying for quite some time, that it is willing to establish diplomatic relations with Turkey without any preconditions. However the communique apparently tries to resurrect the historical commission that had been proposed by Turkey, essentially to determine whether the Armenian Genocide took place (2...Implement a dialogue on the historical dimension with the aim to restore mutual confidence between the two nations, including an impartial and scientific examination of the historical records and archives to define existing problems and formulate recommendations;). 1. accepting this clause is an incredible and humiliating loss to the Armenian side, perhaps a moral loss more than anything else (interestingly enough Switzerland recognizes the Genocide in spite of a few recalcitrant deniers in government), but a loss nevertheless. It does make the whole thing a much easier sell to the Turkish public and government but it also indicates how the balance of power works in this case. 2. such dialogue, commission or whatever else might be imagined will never take place. I doubt Turkey has any interest in that and Armenia should not play such games. 3. in spite of everything, opening the border and establishing diplomatic relationships is not just desirable but unavoidable, we can debate the circumstances but not its need. Some have argued that Turkey's admittance to the EU would be in the best interest of Armenia, I agree even though I don't think it will happen in my lifetime (I am 40 and expect to live a long time: thanks for the cognac, Azat!) but in order for EU talks to have a chance of progress Turkey's relationship with all is neighbours have to improve. Economic benefits are beyond discussion. Yes, it is better to go through Turkey than Georgia! 4. all in all, the best outcome for Armenia is to open the borders and have the Turks build an embassy in Yerevan, all the rest is the usual fluff that has no bearing in realpolitik. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
gamavor Posted September 1, 2009 Report Share Posted September 1, 2009 3. in spite of everything, opening the border and establishing diplomatic relationships is not just desirable but unavoidable, we can debate the circumstances but not its need. Some have argued that Turkey's admittance to the EU would be in the best interest of Armenia, I agree even though I don't think it will happen in my lifetime (I am 40 and expect to live a long time: thanks for the cognac, Azat!) but in order for EU talks to have a chance of progress Turkey's relationship with all is neighbours have to improve. Economic benefits are beyond discussion. Yes, it is better to go through Turkey than Georgia! 4. all in all, the best outcome for Armenia is to open the borders and have the Turks build an embassy in Yerevan, all the rest is the usual fluff that has no bearing in realpolitik. Turkish membership in the EU could happen much faster, Boghos. That would be the real benefit for Armenia. EU must make some concessions to Turkey, just as they did to Romania and Bulgaria which were not prepared at all to join the Union. Armenia should stay out, if she wants to survive. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
ArmenainPatriot Posted September 1, 2009 Report Share Posted September 1, 2009 Screw Switzerland, they don't know what's good for Armenia. 20 million stinking Kurds live in Western Armenia you think turkey won't like to send them over the open border thereby killing two birds with one stone? Putting an end to the Armenian state and solving their kurdish problem is on top of their seljuk agenda. The Armenian government is full of shit. And Yerevantsis are happy like the seljuk is honest about what they say, most Armenians are complete IDIOTS, there's a little minority who knows what the central asian seljuk shit is all about. Stupid naive people, nature doesn't tolerate stupidity that's why Armenia is only 42 thousand square kilometers, 20 times smaller than turkey because we have and always had stupid moronic asinine leadership and people. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Armat Posted September 3, 2009 Report Share Posted September 3, 2009 Before I get shot for suggesting such a thing, please take it with a grain of salt. Maybe what LTP planted will bear fruit through intelligent maneuvering on the part of current administration. Lots of people would like to see open relations between our two countries. I don't live in Armenia and do not bear the direct brunt of the hostility and hardship our people endure on a daily basis. MAYBE some good can come out of some REAL dialogue- symbolically presented for the benefit of both countries citizens. Maybe our country can be proactive and change the course of it's future. At some point, you have to pick yourself up, shake off the "victim" title, roll up your sleeves and get to work. Not forget or be trusting, but forgive to heal thyself first. good post.Agree 100% It seems here in Diaspora all we care is AG recognition which begs the question if Turkey recognizes then what.Are we on revenge mode? after 90 yrs or something else. Here is my true feeling.My pain is my pain and I don't need anyones sympathy,pity or anything resembling "victims or victim families etc." Don't want Turkish money either.That's just me and I am sure plenty of people will disagree. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Harut Posted September 16, 2009 Report Share Posted September 16, 2009 is the actual text of the complete protocol available on the internet? Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Arpa Posted September 16, 2009 Report Share Posted September 16, 2009 is the actual text of the complete protocol available on the internet? http://hyeforum.com/index.php?showtopic=22717 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Z'areh Posted September 17, 2009 Report Share Posted September 17, 2009 (edited) Serje Sarkissian, the Chess lover, thought he was so smart he alone single-handedly could check-mate the Turkish diplomacy. But what has happened so far indicates that he has lost his Queen, both Rooks, both Bishops, a very battered single Knight trying to keep the King safe in a corner, with some Pawns (Nalbandian) moving around aimlessly. Perhaps today, after the meeting with other party representatives, our brave and manly leader will realize that it is just a matter of time that the opponent will check-mate the game. On October 13th what Armenia will be allowed to do is simply smile, extend a hand and say "good game". Then Sarkissian will go and watch a soccer game. What an imbecile!! Reading the following one gets a real essence of Sarkissian's (Armenia's) defeat. Interview with David L. Phillips, a senior fellow at the US-based Atlantic Council and of TARC fame. published today in "Today's Zaman". I have all reasons to believe what Phillips says is true and it underscores Sarkissian's political miscalculations even more. -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- ‘Turkish and Armenian parliaments will ultimately ratify the agreement’ Even before the report “Disarming, Demobilizing and Reintegrating the PKK,” you prepared a report on Turkish-Armenian rapprochement. Most Turks support this rapprochement, hoping that “this will end our nightmares on genocide resolutions.” Do you think Armenians will give up their genocide recognition demands? Adopting a treaty on normalization and recognition is an event that occurs on a specific date. Reconciliation between Turks and Armenians is a process that is going to require a long time and a lot of interaction. Opening the border, Turks and Armenians will be able to come together. That will deepen mutual understanding and promote reconciliation between these two peoples. But that doesn't mean that Armenians will stop seeking recognition of the genocide. What if the new historians' commission comes out with a report that what happened amounts not to a “genocide” but to a “massacre”? My experience with historians is that they come to the table with piles of books and papers justifying their conclusions. I suspect that this commission will not reach a definitive conclusion that is satisfactory to either side. (one would think that a President of a country that is dealing with a genocide-denying country, therefore still Armenia's enemy, would have at least "suspected" this much as well) Do you think the Nagorno-Karabakh issue has the potential to block the rapprochement? Through the Minsk Process, efforts will intensify to reach an accord that returns most of the war-affected territories to Azerbaijan. But there is no linkage in the current agreement on normalization and recognition between Armenia and Turkey and the territories in Azerbaijan. My own view is that normalization and recognition between Turkey and Armenia will provide a big boost to the negotiations on Nagorno-Karabakh. (this I read as saying Turkey will gain more leverage in forcing more concessions on Armenia) There is also the “Armenian Ergenekon,” the Karabakh clique, which can do things including the occupation of Parliament. I am not aware of the Ergenekon clique in Armenia, but there will surely be resistance to reconciliation on both sides. There are people who have an interest in keeping the border closed. Fortunately those parties are in the minority. There is an initialed agreement that describes the way forward. There will clearly be heated debate on both sides, but I'm confident that both the Turkish and Armenian parliaments will ultimately ratify the agreement. I think the issue is ripe, and both sides are ready for reconciliation. The era of closed borders has come to an end, and it is time for open borders, open minds and open hearts. (As if borders being closed are the fault of both Turkey AND Armenia, how did we loose this PR over the fact that it is Turkey and only Turkey that closed the border and imposed a blockade on Armenia) What did the poet write? Ayskan tcharik... Edited September 18, 2009 by Z'areh Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Harut Posted September 18, 2009 Report Share Posted September 18, 2009 http://hyeforum.com/index.php?showtopic=22717 thanks... this is a really sad text... this casts such a big shadow on armenia's reputation... all the facts that we've been presenting to the world community (AND TO OUR OWN PEOPLE) for the last 18 years are put in doubt by this paper... Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Yervant1 Posted September 18, 2009 Report Share Posted September 18, 2009 I personally don't see what's happenning only as doom and gloom. Keep in mind that there are lots of powerful players at this game which leaves Turkey and Armenia as little fish in a big pond, even more so for Armenia. I have no doubt that eventually Genocide will be recognized by Turkey, when in time the Genocide subject is discussed freely through democratic process. You can politisize Genocide but you can't hide it forever. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
yergatuni1 Posted September 18, 2009 Report Share Posted September 18, 2009 I personally don't see what's happenning only as doom and gloom. Keep in mind that there are lots of powerful players at this game which leaves Turkey and Armenia as little fish in a big pond, even more so for Armenia. I have no doubt that eventually Genocide will be recognized by Turkey, when in time the Genocide subject is discussed freely through democratic process. You can politisize Genocide but you can't hide it forever. why should they? when the historical commission comes out with an inconclusive outcome on the genocide disscussion?, why should any country recognize it after that outcome what the armenian government is doing is playing politics with the genocide, they've joined the club and are their doing the same thing the US/israel have been doing... Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Harut Posted September 18, 2009 Report Share Posted September 18, 2009 http://www.anca.org/assets/pdf/misc/protocols_explained.pdf Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Harut Posted September 18, 2009 Report Share Posted September 18, 2009 I personally don't see what's happenning only as doom and gloom. Keep in mind that there are lots of powerful players at this game which leaves Turkey and Armenia as little fish in a big pond, even more so for Armenia. I have no doubt that eventually Genocide will be recognized by Turkey, when in time the Genocide subject is discussed freely through democratic process. You can politisize Genocide but you can't hide it forever. i never cared for turkey's recognition per se... nor do i think it should be a precondition for normalizing relationships... but this protocol effectively puts genocide's factuality in doubt... Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Z'areh Posted September 18, 2009 Report Share Posted September 18, 2009 i never cared for turkey's recognition per se... nor do i think it should be a precondition for normalizing relationships... but this protocol effectively puts genocide's factuality in doubt... I will go even further, once the "genocide nightmare" is over the Turks will not stop there. It is more than conceivable that they will attempt to turn the tables and start a campaign of "rehabilitation", so to speak, of the Turkish name. One should not be so naive as to think that after neutralizing the Armenian threat the Turks not only will not take responsibility and recognize the Armenian genocide, but the opposite will happen, they will start to push for recognition of their own twisted version of history where the Turk will be portrayed as the victim in this version of the "nightmare". Who is going to stop them from embarking on such international campaign? What a demeaning fiasco we have put ourselves in. Shame on us. To blame our misfortunes on being "small" and "part of a larger game" is unacceptable, we have seen what "small" nations can and have achieved, we have seen what we have achieved ourselves. To espouse such defeatist mentality is to say "come and take everything you wish", that would eventually include Artsakh...Zangezure...why not? Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Yervant1 Posted September 18, 2009 Report Share Posted September 18, 2009 Over twenty countries accepted the AG, even if twenty more accepts it nothing will happen as long no one forces Turkey to accept or pay reparations. AG is being used by other countries as a tool to blackmail Turkey and they don't want that tool to disappear. The outcome of commisions are all political decisions and it's not based on facts, everybody knows this. During TARC times the outcome of that justice decision was in our favour, what did we get because of it's positive outcome? Nothing! We can't live in fear of outcomes, if the conclusion is inconclusive than the battle continues. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Yervant1 Posted September 18, 2009 Report Share Posted September 18, 2009 (edited) Armenia-Turkey protocols: What is on the scales of the balance? The Noyan Tapan Highligts, September 14 2009 By Haroutiun Khachatrian The political figures and parties of Armenia have been divided into two groups, and some of them say that the published Armenia-Turkey draft protocols contain preconditions (by Turkey), whereas the others claim there are no preconditions and recall a calf under an ox (the Armenian proverb used by foreign minister Edward Nalbandian during his press conference). They are engaged in mutual recrimination. The argument is on a wrong subject. There are preconditions by both sides and preconditions could not but exist. The point is what risks the two sides are to take and what their goals are. Are the risks worth the goals? EACH SIDE PURSUES ITS INTERESTS Turkey has expressed desire to open the border with Armenia (closed 16 years ago) of its own free will, so it is interested in opening the border. It would be surprising if Turkey did not strive to satisfy its interests in this affair - just like any other state does. No one can claim that by providing credit to Armenia or occupying a borderline territory, Russia and Georgia, respectively, do not pursue first of all their own interests. Well, does Turkey believe that the international recognition of the Armenian Genocide is contrary to its interests? It certainly does. Does it believe that the deterioration of its relations with Azerbaijan contradicts its interests? No doubt it does. Therefore, Turkey will continue taking actions aimed at protecting its interests (that is, to hinder recognition of the Genocide and to help Azerbaijan) also after the above-mentioned protocols are signed and ratified. Turkey would have continued to protect Azerbaijan's interests, even if the protocols had contained, according to much respected by me Mr. Vartan Oskanian, the following sentence: `The normalization of Armenia-Turkey relations shall take place irrespective of the Nagorno Karabakh problem resolution process'. Similarly, does Armenia think that the international recognition of the Genocide is in line with its interests? Certainly. Does it believe that protecting Nagorno Karabakh from Azerbaijan's ambitions suits its interests? It does. Therefore, it will seek achieving these goals also after signing and ratifying the indicated protocols. Let us fix these obvious facts and go ahead. ARMENIA'S INTERESTS A), B ), AND C) Now, I want to consider the most important factor. Armenia is very much interested in reopening the borders and having diplomatic relations with Turkey. It is interested to such a degree that many people do not even realize the importance of that. Indeed, if the Armenian-Turkish border is open, then a) Armenia will gain a serious victory in the fight for Karabakh. Azerbaijan's power will at least halve. Now, we have two physical fronts in the war against Azerbaijan, and only one will remain after opening the border. Let's not forget that we have not yet won the struggle for Karabakh. b ) Armenia will get rid of its unilateral dependence on Georgia. Usually, only the economic aspect of this dependence is indicated, namely, that we will have an alternative railway, a reliable and cheap supply, etc. The political price of this dependence is never mentioned. I mean, after all, it is for this reason that we turn the blind eye to (let's call things by their proper names) anti-Armenian actions of Georgia's government. We are forced to do so. And we will get rid of it. c) The economic result is determined not so much by, and even not by the very fact of opening of communications. Rather, it is determined by the fact that Turkey's MARKET will open to Armenia. We forget that we are in a unique situation: goods of 200 million dollars come to Armenia from Turkey annually, whereas movement in the opposite direction is CLOSED due to a de facto embargo of Turkey. Some express fear that our market will open before Turks, even though it has never been closed. And almost nobody speaks about what will happen if Armenia's commodity market will have 70 million consumers instead of 3 million now, especially as this market is next to it, rather than being located thousands of kilometers away as Russia, for example. It will be a COMPLETELY DIFFERENT ARMENIA. It is impossible to forecast what investors and investments will flow into Armenia. But we can recall the considerable number of investors who refused to come to Armenia due to the small size of its market. I would like to emphasize once again that Turkey is also interested in the border's opening: it has its own reasons for that, but I will not dwell upon them now. THE OTHER SCALE OF THE BALANCE After stating all this, let's consider the `unacceptable preconditions' indicated by the critics of the protocols. The first `precondition' is the commission on historical dimension. It is said that its existence (according to Vartan Oskanian, the very fact of the protocols' initiation) will give Turkey a pretext for declaring at every turn that there is no need for other countries to recognize the Armenian Genocide because the Turks and Armenians are clarifying this issue themselves. Suppose Turkey will do so. Armenia in the person of Serzh Sargsyan has stated that the Genocide is not a subject for bargaining, but Turkey will undoubtedly say (just as it has said so far) that the problem of the Genocide should be left to historians for discussion. Whom will Turkey persuade and whom will Armenia convince? As ever, those who want to be persuaded will be `persuaded'. By the way, are there many people today who `want to be persuaded' that genocide did take place in 1915? In other words, are there many parliaments, where the recognition of the Armenian Genocide has been put on the agenda? As far as I know, currently there is only one such parliament, that is, the Congress of the United States. Over the past five years, no other country has had incentives `to be persuaded' in our favor. And this only parliament, the U.S. Congress, will `be persuaded' that the genocide was committed only in case when it proceeds from its interests. No sooner, and no later. And the protocols on the establishment of relations between Armenia and Turkey will not play any role in it. Well, suppose they will play some role. But let's put the indicated points a), b ) and c) on one scale of the balance and the recognition of the Genocide by the U.S. Congress on the other. What the present-day Republic of Armenia needs more? We should remember that such an advocate of the Genocide's recognition as the famous Armenian American editor Harut Sassounian has repeatedly said that the recognition of the Genocide by the Congress is of no importance because the United States recognized it long ago: President Reagan issued a Presidential Proclamation in 1981, recognizing the Armenian Genocide. Finally, let's simplify our problem by reminding that the international recognition of the Genocide is part of the National Security Doctrine of the Republic of Armenia. Now, what is more important for our national security? The uncertain prospect of the Genocide's recognition by a foreign parliament (even by five parliaments) is on one scale and on the other are the above mentioned points a), b ), and c) when a real chance has emerged to achieve them? The second `unacceptable precondition' is that Turkish parliament may drag out the ratification of the protocols, demanding concessions from Armenia in the Karabakh problem, even though this problem is not mentioned in the protocols. This is quite possible, indeed. In addition to the Karabakh issue, the Turkish parliament may also make other demands we cannot think of at the present time. So what? Today too, Turkey is trying to force us to meet Azerbaijan's demands. Today too, the OSCE Minsk Group Co-Chairs are pressuring. What will change if we sign the protocols, if we make an attempt to reach the above indicated goals a), b ), and c)? Nothing will change. We will just get a chance to reach these a), b ), and c) goals. A chance, which may be fulfilled, and may be not. That is, things may remain as they are now when we have no relations with Turkey. Things may remain the same, but it seems they will not because Turkey appears to be really interested in changing the situation (otherwise it would not have initiated these documents). So, we have a chance to achieve the goals a), , and c). So it is worth trying. Vartan Oskanian wrote in this connection: `... if the ratification of these protocols takes place ... before the date of President Obama's April 24 message ... it is safe to say that Turkey and Azerbaijan have received sufficient guarantees regarding the return of the territories around Karabakh and the status of the NKR'. (168 Zham, September 10). Well, what are these guarantees, which cannot be received from Armenia (Armenia's leadership) now, but can be received after the ratification of the protocols? It is incomprehensible. What will change after the ratification? Why should the Armenian authorities be inclined to give the territories in return for ratification? Will foreigners try to benefit from Serzh Sargsyan's legitimacy problem, as is hinted at some foreign instances? But this problem exists today as well. It is difficult to understand the respected former foreign minister. And the final point is the issue of borders. No doubt, it is the most painful issue, I will permit myself to say it is even more painful than the problem of the Genocide for the simple reason that the victims of the Genocide cannot be brought back to life, but the hope of changing the border drawn by the Communists and Moustafa Kemal, in other words, the hope of recovering (at least partially) our historical lands has been and will always be alive. Do the protocols establish these borders or not? Diplomats say that the issue of disputed territories can be raised at any moment, and the establishment of relations does not necessarily mean the final recognition of borders. After all, after the ratification of the protocols, Armenia will always be free to declare this or that provision invalid (can anybody guarantee that after opening the border Turkey will not close it some time later?) I don't know. One thing is obvious: in order to protect our lands, we should not retire into our shell; at least we should have an open border and normal diplomatic relations with Turkey. Can those holding the opposite view say what the Republic of Armenia has done to get back its historical lands? And what can it do before opening the border: to raise a placard `Give Our Lands!' at the border; or move the army towards Western Armenia? If there is a strong desire to act according to the latter version, the protocols are unlikely to hinder it. I must respond again to an opinion expressed by Vartan Oskanian. He wrote about the clause on the borders: `The emphasis on territorial integrity is an internationally accepted wording that solves the problem of concern related to borders, at the same time not depriving us of the right to obtain historical justice. Meanwhile, we should have avoided at any cost the wording `mutual recognition of the existing common border between the two countries' which was set down in the document.' Obviously, he is right. But how realistic was it to avoid the wording `mutual recognition of the common border' in these protocols? After all, those representing the Turkish side were not inexperienced youths, and they knew what the Armenians want from them. The negotiating countries have quite different `weight classes,' suffice it to mention the difference in their populations. To all appearance, this is the precondition which adoption the Armenian side could not avoid to accept if it wanted to have the above mentioned points a), b ), and ). TO TRY OR NOT TO TRY? There is yet another reason that raises a doubt as to these affairs, and it is related to those who carry out them. It is not for the first time that I say that the current ruling political elite, to put it mildly, does not inspire trust. Its definitions are: irresolute, small-minded, revengeful, and amoral, and the elite infect the society with these negative characteristics at every turn. With respect to such a political elite (not to mention the problem of the president's legitimacy), there are always fears that it may prove insufficiently reliable. As regards the protocols, as the above-mentioned analysis shows, up to now the current political leadership of the country has done its best. There is a hope that it will be so in the future as well. Especially, as the approaches of the political elite and its most powerful opponent Levon Ter-Petrosian to Armenian-Turkish relations are quite similar, and in future Ter-Petrosian will continue trying to assist Serzh Sargsyan in this issue. An opportunity should be given so that we will make an attempt to open the border. If we miss this opportunity, a new one may take long to arise. Edited September 18, 2009 by Yervant1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.