Jump to content

Turkey Suspends French Military Contacts


Lev7

Recommended Posts

ANKARA, Turkey - Turkey has suspended military relations with France in a dispute over whether the mass killings of Armenians early in the last century amounted to genocide, a top army commander said Wednesday.

 

The move was the latest backlash against French legislation that, if approved by the Senate and president, would criminalize denial that the killings of Armenians in Turkey were genocide.

 

"Relations with France in the military field have been suspended," Gen. Ilker Basbug said in Ankara, according to state-owned Anatolia news agency.

 

France's Foreign Ministry and Defense Ministry had no immediate comment.

 

France and Turkey are both

NATO members, and Turkey has been a buyer of French-made weaponry. The two countries also have participated in military exercises together, and have sent troops to serve in the international peacekeeping force in Lebanon.

 

But the Turkish military also has blacklisted several French firms in the past in similar disputes over the mass killings of Armenians.

 

Basbug, commander of land forces, disclosed the suspension of military ties with France in comments to reporters at a reception in Ankara, the Anatolia news agency reported. The French bill still needs approval from the Senate and

President Jacques Chirac to become law.

 

Asked whether any military missions between the two nations had been canceled, Basbug said: "There are no high-level visits between the two countries."

 

Turkey sees the French bill as a hostile, anti-Turkish move, and has warned that the lawmakers' vote has already damaged Turkish-French relations.

 

Turkey vehemently denies that it committed genocide against Armenians, though many nations have classified the killings as such.

 

The United Nation's 1948 Genocide Convention makes genocide a crime, and defines it as killing or injuring people "with intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnical, racial or religious group."

 

Turkey acknowledges that large numbers of Armenians died in mass expulsions and fighting, but says the number of dead is exaggerated and that most were killed in interethnic violence that erupted as the Ottoman Empire collapsed.

 

Armenians and many nations say some 1.5 million Armenians were killed in a genocidal campaign devised and executed by Turkish leaders.

 

The

European Union and European media have criticized the French bill, saying it does not respect the principle of free expression and does not promote dialogue with Turkey, a hopeful EU candidate.

 

The United States also criticized the French bill, saying that it gets in the way of reconciling the Turks and Armenians.

 

The Armenian issue is one of the most divisive and emotional in Turkey. Those who classify the killings as genocide are often accused of treason.

 

http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20061116/ap_on_...france_military

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I agree with you Yervant. The actions of the government only amplify the public's paranoid reaction. On the other hand, the army's suspencion doesn't really achieve anything by NATO'S terms, and they know they can't afford to boycott France, so al is in vain and to our gain.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I think Turkey helped Genocide recognition by their behaviour more than any other nation would ever be able to.

 

I could not disagree more. Look around, Turkey is verry successful in what it is doing, given the undeniable nature of the genocide, its behavior has given considerable results. A country economically crumbelling, a third world-like, is still able to dictate various countries on this issue. I can't view otherwise than calling it a success.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I could not disagree more. Look around, Turkey is verry successful in what it is doing, given the undeniable nature of the genocide, its behavior has given considerable results. A country economically crumbelling, a third world-like, is still able to dictate various countries on this issue. I can't view otherwise than calling it a success.

I'm not talking about Turkey or it's succeses. If you read my post again it says Genocide recognition by others. Since their denial the amount of reports be it on TV, newspapers, editorials and by political people have been in the hundreds.

Foreigners that did not know about AG, one way or another heard about it now, more and more papers and reporters are qouthing as Genocide.

Probably if you ask an average Joe as to who is an Armenian, he will say I don't know.

But if you ask about the Armenian Genocide, he might say yeah I heard about that.

IMO Turkey is not succesful at all on the contrary they are in a quicksand and they are sinking as we speak. It's the politics and interests of other countries that is giving them that outcome and not what Turks are doing.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Yeah I agree with you Yervant. Wherever or whenever I come across to people about Armenia or Armenians; Americans don't know where it's at but usually they heard about the Genocide. And they say oh yeah I heard about the Armenian Genocide.

 

I think Turkey is losing credibility more and more by denying the Genocide in the face of the earth.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I don't see how an American Joe's not knowing about Armenians but knowing about the Armenian genocide because the media quotes it or Turkey's denial actually says anything about Turkey's credibility. The more American Joe's know about it, the less credibility Turkey has? Doesn't make sense.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Take a good look and see that Turky's losing credibility was another subject matter as was the paragraphs.

 

I think Turkey is losing credibility with the sophisticated class of people in the world. People who know history; even though the hard core politicians in this country and elsewhere are being bought.

Edited by Anahid Takouhi
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I don't see how an American Joe's not knowing about Armenians but knowing about the Armenian genocide because the media quotes it or Turkey's denial actually says anything about Turkey's credibility. The more American Joe's know about it, the less credibility Turkey has? Doesn't make sense.

 

I do agree that talking about it could be a good thing, but on the other hand, given that Turkey is in a position that any threats or any such actions could only be a win-win situation, I don't see how Turkey is not effective, it actually is very effective. Americans in general could not place any other nation than theirs and maybe Canada on a map, and that is because we're on north of them, an 'Armenian Genocide' is the last of their interest, what matters for them is if Turkey is an ally of the US or not.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I think Turkey is losing credibility with the sophisticated class of people in the world. People who know history; even though the hard core politicians in this country and elsewhere are being bought.

Sophisticated? Class? Sounds elitist to me. Moreover, I find the "sophisticated class" equally unrealiable as any other. Additionally, the Rwandan Tutsi who was subjected to genocide in his own country need not know history to condemn denial of the Armenian genocide once he has the basic facts.

Turkey loses credibility in the face of morals, which is what this is all about, not history, not even politics.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

If I understand correctly, yes, Turkey is sawing away the branch it is sitting on by so vehemently denying the Armenian genocide. Still, I do think that the average American Joe's knowing about the genocide is a result of Armenian campaigning and not Turkish denial, at least not remotely directly, unless one counts the "firing up" owing to denial as an impact. At any rate, such "Oh yeah, now that I have heard about" on the part of the average Joe, who is otherwise more interested in mundane things, ought not to be an indicator of effectiveness or success.

 

I do agree that talking about it could be a good thing, but on the other hand, given that Turkey is in a position that any threats or any such actions could only be a win-win situation, I don't see how Turkey is not effective, it actually is very effective. Americans in general could not place any other nation than theirs and maybe Canada on a map, and that is because we're on north of them, an 'Armenian Genocide' is the last of their interest, what matters for them is if Turkey is an ally of the US or not.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Sophisticated? Class? Sounds elitist to me. Moreover, I find the "sophisticated class" equally unrealiable as any other. Additionally, the Rwandan Tutsi who was subjected to genocide in his own country need not know history to condemn denial of the Armenian genocide once he has the basic facts.

Turkey loses credibility in the face of morals, which is what this is all about, not history, not even politics.

You didn't get it again. When I said sophisticated class of people. You took the class word apart and you didn't understand what the word sophisticated mean? It had nothing to do with the elite. for your information sophisticated means a person, any person of any given class of people that is knowledgeable. Understands and knows the truth and is able to judge and judge it well.

 

You're talking about Turkey losing credibility because of her immoral conduct. Although this statement is true; however the Armenian Genocide and turkey's denial is all about history. How can anyone condemns turkey for her irresponsible conduct if one doesn't know the history behind it?

 

And about my mentioning about polititions, it was said as a disgust against the damn politicians that most of them have no morals to accept great deals of money to pocket it for themselves from turkey and play around with our cause that happends to be sacred for us.

Edited by Anahid Takouhi
Link to comment
Share on other sites

for your information sophisticated means a person, any person of any given class of people that is knowledgeable. Understands and knows the truth and is able to judge and judge it well.

 

what they know is equal to what you teach.

You're talking about Turkey losing credibility because of her immoral conduct. Although this statement is true; however the Armenian Genocide and turkey's denial is all about history.

 

Yeah some people who have no idea about both armenians and turks decided about a war(genocide) between turks and armenians.

 

I am sure all canada people, france or others, have great interest with armenian and turkish history. ;)

 

I am happy we are so famous.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Stormig; Please do not carry your small dissapointments with me in regards from other topics about nose piercing or whatever else; because this site and this topic is very sacred to me.

 

I am the daughter of a Genocide survivor. My father was a little child when the Genocide happened and he is the only one who survived in his family. He obviously went through a great deal of agonising hardships, not to mention he used to wake up abruptly night after night from his sleep crying in agony for the loss of his mother and his whole family for many years. My poor father was finally taken away by the American orphanage, that's how he survived and that's how I was born to write to you now.

 

Before I have joined this Forum, my grandmother was constantly in my mind for a few months. She has walked through the deserts in the most harsh and the most dreadful walks until hear agonising death.

 

Not to mention my grandmother on my mother's side, her whole family were annihilated. 145 members just on her mother's side and many more on her father's side were all killed by the turks.

 

That's why Stormig, this site and this topic is utterly sacred to me. If I have to say anything here, I speak it with my deepest grief and with complete seriousness of the subject matter.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...