The bible talks about subjects that affect us today (money, sex, faith, forgiveness, love, etc). Does LOTR do that? As far as I can see, it's only about a ring.
I've only seen historians admit the Biblical stories to be true on TV and video, I'm not sure if you can find it on the net. I know you don't read the Bible, so please don't propose empty accusations.
No, people know Jesus was not born on the 25th, but they set it on that date because it was around that time period he was born. It is an educated guess.
But hey, you can pray to the "Elven" gods all you want.