I have questioned my beliefs a lot. But to be honest, I feel right from wrong, it's not a saying or writing or book that proves a religion correct. Science only has books and theories.
The statement >"You say we are sinners.. You say God created us from his own image.. You say God gave us free will"< whoa, hold on a second. You've rearranged the order buddy. God created us from his own image and then we became sinners.
And who is having a miserable life here? You?
As much as we'd like, there won't be such thing as a perfect planet with perfect people that have perfect lives. Enough blaming God for that. It's reality.
You have already gained his love, Jesus died on the cross for that. By the way, I'm not narrow minded, and I also like to question things. But I'm guessing you were a good Christian until a few questions were thrown your way about Christianity, which you could not answer and saw it as a flaw in the religion and decided to leave. I'm sure it's the very same questions you are asking me now that led you astray.