aurguplu
Members-
Posts
623 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Events
Gallery
Everything posted by aurguplu
-
quote:Originally posted by Boghos:Ali, it was you who wrote: "...and then your involvement with the russians and the genocide". It is part of a larger text of yours reproduced above. I will not comment much further except for saying that this is the usual accusation against Armenians: sedition. Not counting the overtone. So give up your righteous nonsense. I will not bother anymore. Good bye. boghos i cannot make you see what i want to say as long as you see just what you want to see. i wont bother anymore either. goodbye.
-
quote:Originally posted by sen_vahan:Ali, "you (some of you) say that it is absurd to hide behind land claims to avoid recognising ag, because the armenians either don't have land claims, or know that it is not a perceivable goal, and claim the only reason why i stick to that line is to avoid having the ag recognised, and then you state these claims here and elsewhere on this forum and start making plans as to how to pressure turkey from all sides with other nations' help." Right, and that's the result of the blockade, long-term AG denial and the absense of the desire among turks to "meet and solve the problem". "and what we have here is a question of feasibility (practicality), not morality. the ag is a criminal issue, recognising it personally is a moral issue, and getting it recognised by the state and the public is a practical issue. the state is not going to recognise it as long as it sees such a recognition as a potential threat to its territorial integrity. and the state does, whether you agree with it or not." Recognition is in some sense a diplomatic act (lets put aside the moral side). When two sides solve some problem and sign agreements each of them has own points,positions,etc. Probably, we are too far from such an agreement yet because even the historical fact is still denied! "some of you say (if i understand you correctly) that turkey has nothing to fear because the armenians are so weak. what then if one day you get stronger? or get a stronger ally? the reason why roa - and the more tactful of you - do not vociferously push the land issue NOW is because you realise that you don't have the power to carry it out to the desired conclusion NOW. simply put, you don't try NOW because you know you can't get, NOT YET." Ali, we are all aware that turks have the ability to solve a problem once and forever, but you will need to do that one more time in your history - the only difference is that you will need to do that in a correct diplomatic way this time and without a yatagan, that no other problems arise later even if armenians get stronger. "in addition, i see an attitude on your part as you sitting on a higher pedestal than us, that you are intrinsically right and we intrinsically wrong, an attitude that i do not cultivate toward you. so a turk who accepts your line is "civilised, improving, hopeful etc.", the more of it he accepts, the more so he is. he is a less bad turk who symphatises with your sufferings, a goodish one if he accepts the ag, a good one if he accepts the ag, apologies, and compensation, and an excellent one if he agreed to pack his stuff and go wherever he came from." Come on , Ali, what an exaggeration! "taking it further, he'd be best if he dropped dead! ("i hate the turks biologically. i wish they simply didn't exist" - gamavor)." Ali, lets not try to bring such phrases, i can also bring a lot from turkish forums about armenians and you will see the same and even much worse. Anyway, I agree that this is the most civilized forum and you expect more... Regards, Vahan vahan 1. the land claims are not there because of ag denial. various armenian groups were demanding land from the turks since well before 1915 or even the hamidian massacres in 1891-95. 2. we are in a vicious circle here. turkey is not going to officially recognise ag unless and until land claims are dropped, and land claims are going to persists unless and until turkey recognises ag. to break it, there has to be an agreement that the land claims will be dropped prior to ag recognition, upon condition that the dropping of these claims will be immediately followed by ag recognition (=you drop the land claims today, we recognise the ag tomorrow kind of thing). 3. the yataghan is out of date. these days it is the buttons. and before actual warfare, there are a host of economic/political measures such as trade sanctions, embargoes, freezing of assets, denial/postponement of eu membership etc. and do not forget that while you tend to see just us when you look at us, we tend to see the russians, eu and, to some extent, the usa in addition to you when we look at you. after all, the turkish armenian border was (is it still ) patrolled by russian troops and not armenian ones. plus, if the armenians get stronger, they will want to "solve" the problem the way all strong nations solve. you have a problem with the azeris and you are solving it by the sword, not negotiations, because you have a sword strong enough and they don't (and we are not helping them much, because we don't want to get into yet another quagmire). the example is right before our eyes. artshakh opted out of attempting to achieve peaceful coexistence with the azeris already when azerbaijan was not even ruled by the azeris. and the issue there has always been more about getting ancestral lands back than working out a solution for peaceful coexistence. what guarantee do we have that you will even contemplate peaceful coexistence with us the moment you have the power to get rid of us? 4. no exaggaration, merely a statement of observable facts. all you have to do is look at the postings in this forum. 5. if the phrases have been utterred, then why not bring them up? whatever i (and even those turks in other forums) utter is brought before me, and not infrequently in a distorted interpretation, then why shouldn't i? besides, i see it very relevant. after all "i hate the turks biologically. i wish they simply didn't exist" sounds very much like hitler on the jews, does it not? what if we have someone like gamavor as the president of roa one day, and what if that roa is strong, and say, in possession of nuclear power? can this not happen? do we not have the right to take preemptive measures to prevent this from happening? after all, hitler did exist, as the ruler of an ostensibly civilised nation like germany, and nukes have been used, twice, one week apart, by another ostensibly civilised nation, the usa, against two non-military targets in japan, and that civilised nation still refuses to apologise for them. and all this was not that long ago, was it? do you know on what grounds the decision was taken to use nukes against japan and not germany? "the japanese do not belong to the same branch of humanity that we do (the germans did)." well, we don't belong to the same branch of humanity that you do. you are christians, and we muslims. and especially after 9/11 (whose effects will last very, very long), you can find enough people in christendom (especially in your part of the world) to justify such an act, and less than enough people to oppose it effectively. and you are so buddy-buddy with russia, full of (mostly stray) nukes, and not a nation known either for civilised behaviour nor any standards of morality. the bosnian genocide was allowed to go on for years in the middle of europe before any serious action was taken (by the usa, not europe) because i) the russians didn't allow any action against it, ii) europeans didn't want to risk life and limb, iii) europeans saw the serbs doing a dirty job for them (cleaning a part of europe of ottoman muslims), and iv) there was no oil. some 200,000 muslims were killed, there is an independent slovenia, serbia, croatia, macedonia now (and as far as i know montenegro is on its way to independence), but no independent bosnia: there is a bosnian croat federation. no independent muslim state in europe. chechnya is being raped by the russians and there is no action (i don't mean words) in sight. china is raping both sinkiang (muslim uighur turks) and tibet (tibetan buddhists), and again, no action. the list can go on. wouldn't you be at least careful if you were a turk?
-
quote:Originally posted by Boghos:Ali, There is hardly anybody in this forum that has been proven wrong so many times as you, trying to show knowledge that you clearly do not possess. But this is not an issue of knowledge, it is a moral issue. As you have written: "a millennium ago, you endured the sword (a sword is not gobbledygook, it is always very clear what it is), then you endured the rule (that was also very clear, i guess), then in the 19th century you endured a sharply deteriorating condition (that was also very clear, i guess), hamidian massacres (i won't ask whether these were clear or not), a brief partnership in the young turk regime in which you preferred to keep an ambiguous position), and then your involvement with the russians and the genocide" You are an angry young man...I can even have sympathy for the sad state that you find yourself in. But this is not a place for online therapy. 1. other people have been proved wrong just as many times as i did, even more, and i have defended my positions with arguments and facts wherever i could and i could in most of the cases. i make a point of not commenting on issues i know nothing/enough about, there have been several such issues, and i am on record for having abstained from commenting on them for lack of knowledge. 2. the passage that you have quoted was a statement of facts and not a justification/display of pride/arrogance etc. i am disappointed that you cannot see the difference. when i post in this forum, i do so with the assumption that i) my stance re certain issues are obvious by know, and ii) certain basic facts under discussion are known by all participants in the forum. i am disappointed over and over again to see that both my assumptions are sometimes wrong. 3. i am not angry, nor particularly young (35). as far as i know you are not that older than me, either. so i would appreciate if you tried to stop sounding like a grandfather and instead concentrate on answering certain points that i make. i see an attitude very much prevailing in this forum that armenians just cannot be wrong, especially in a discussion with a turk re the roots of conflict. it is a prerequisite of civilised and fruitful discussion to accept the fact that being human we all can be wrong. there have been several instances in this forum where i was factually wrong/stated my position in an inadequate manner/drew the wrong conclusions out of facts etc. and when these were pointed out and persuasively argued, i abandoned my former position and admitted i was wrong. i do not see this very often (hardly ever) on your part. don't you think that it is time to have a look at yourselves?
-
quote:Originally posted by nairi:So you agree that they deserve to be "punished" (in my book that's to feel deep regret for at least a year and be on probation for at least a generation)? Hagarag jan, yes, the Turkish government plays a big role in brainwashing its people, but are Turks that primitive that they can't learn to think for themselves? Especially those Turks who grew up in the West? In countries where slogans like "think for yourself" are still very popular? No offence, but ignorance is no longer a valid excuse for me. On another note, please don't forget that European Armenian activists have close bonds with the Germany based "Union/Committee Against Genocide", a committee that fights against genocide denial and assists Armenians in healing from the genocide. Both the chairman and vice-chairman have attended Tsitsernakaberd April 24 commemorations for several years in row now and were warmly welcomed by the Armenian people and authorities each time. Though it is true that their members are growing by the year, we also can't ignore the significant growth in MHP members in Europe. What Ali says about MHP being innocent and powerless is utter and complete nonsense. But I'm sure you were already aware of that yourself. My sincere apologies for overestimating your safety in the US. Nairi nairi read my postings before you refer to them. mhp INNOCENT? really...
-
quote:Originally posted by hagarag:Ali, Please notice that YOU are not the only one being insulted here. I have received similar treatment. This behavior is based in the Armenian psyche, of professing to be "HOLIER THAN THOU." It is a bunch of hogwash and has gotten Armenians into trouble throughout the centuries. I ask again, why did an Italian doctor in the employ of the Ittihadists get so much pleasure in torturing Armenian priests? His family had lived in Istambul for centuries, and his family were Christians. What was it about the Armenian priests approach that had enraged him so? In the absence of any government or other institutions for centuries, the clergy formed the Armenian psyche. The warp in the Armenia psyche emanates from this. hagarag, i know i am not the only one insulted, but as far as i can see i am the only turk who contributes regularly to the forum. so i think that makes a bit of a difference. this conflict has two sides, and here in this forum the other side is represented only by one person, and i think it is significant how he is addressed. as far as the italian doctor is concerned, i don't know a thing about him, so i am not in a postion to judge. but of course, armenians are neither angels nor devils, nor was the italian doctor, and no-one deserves the treatment that armenians as a whole were accorded by the ittihadists.
-
dear arpa, i must confess i didn't quite understand what your point was, so i am afraid i cannot furnish a reply (if there's anyone out there who understood, could you please explain?) cheers,
-
quote:Originally posted by Rubo:Let us raise ourselves to higher ground where the air is purer and the vision is larger. From this vintage point of view Ali’s views or ours are totally irrelevant. What is really relevant is the wall street and its powerful bulldog jaw crashing politics in the name of “new world order” or better yet “globalization”. Who really cares about our little feuds, but us, thinking somehow the world revolves around us. Lades and gentleman we are nothing more then “new markets” to be exploited soon or later and the best Turks and Armenians can do is how best to play the game so as not to become slave to bankers. If the Turks had any intelligence (does not apply all) then they would solve the cypress problem, open borders with Armenia and become a EU member as soon as possible but wait “you guys” actually believe you can bully Greece, Armenia crap on international law and be accepted as a civilized European member country? This does not seem probable every time I see Turkish politicians punching each other in parliament. Strangely as an Armenian, Turkish politicians punching each other reminds me of the genocide. Go figure! rubo, you made a point. i am sure half of the power brokers in wall street confuse armenia with romania and think turkey is the bird they eat for thanksgiving. and they matter, we don't. which is the more reason we have to solve this problem. we are in a deadlock and our accumulated hatred/mistrust/fears/arrogance/superiority-inferiority complexes blind us to the big picture and our place in it, which gives others (the big guys) to determine our places for us. it is a sobering fact that neither one of us has the power to push our respective positions regarding our conflict without the help of some big outsider, and that outsider is usually the usa. you lobby in the us congress against us, we lobby in the very same congress to counter you. who wins? us lobby companies! (just to give one example). apart from the morality side, this issue has a practical side to it that kept dogging both of us for so long. this is at least one of the reasons i for one to see it solved. cheers [ September 11, 2002, 11:14 AM: Message edited by: aurguplu ]
-
ok everyone 1. the reason why i said i didn't understand arpa's statement is not because there was something that i didn't like, but simply because i found his last posting garbled, disconnected, not laeding to a specific conclusion, and not answering my previous posting(s). i also had a bit of trouble following the way he uses english, frankly. 2. but there is a bigger problem when trying to communicate with you, and it is a bloody big one. none so deaf as he who wouldn't hear, none so blind as he who wouldn't see. until now i carried my conversations with you guys thinking that as civilised individuals, we can carry out an intelligent, informed and reasonably balanced discussion despite the flagrant nature of the subjects without calling eachother names. this thought, or rather hope, is diminishing. i am as strongly opposed to some of the positions you hold as you are to some of the positions that i hold. but i have never called any one of you, or - heaven forbid - your nation, the names that you have called mine. your style in replying to me and in referring to my nation approaches mhp's style in referring to your nation. you can check if you care by comparing the style and vocabulary that i use in my postings to the one that you use. i state the fact of the role that the sword played in history - and not only in ours - whether we like it or not, and you twist it to interpret as if i am praising it. i make a statement about a given fact (that there was no independent armenian state prior to ag) and you claim that i quote kamuran gürün. if kamuran gürün didn't exist, and if i had still made that statement, which is a fact, whom would i be quoting then? couldn't it be that i am stating that fact because it is a fact, with or without gürün's comments on it? i say that ag did happen, that it was a foul crime, and that we must recognise it, apologise for it, pay compensation for it, etc., but that it would be difficult to achieve this without first seeing the land claims dropped because of the concerns on the part of turkey regarding the safety of its territorial integrity, and you again twist this as saying that this is yet another trick by a turk to sideline the ag issue. you (some of you) say that it is absurd to hide behind land claims to avoid recognising ag, because the armenians either don't have land claims, or know that it is not a perceivable goal, and claim the only reason why i stick to that line is to avoid having the ag recognised, and then you state these claims here and elsewhere on this forum and start making plans as to how to pressure turkey from all sides with other nations' help. if i am for avoiding the ag issue then what in the hell am i doing in the first place? why am i typing this instead of going out with my friends and doing something more exciting? after all, i am not going to accept land claims on the forum and send the concerned land by e-mail, as mj had wisely pointed out. you also claim that i do not recognise your right to even contemplate the subject. i am nobody to recognise or not to recognise anyone's right to think anything, besides i don't know on on earth i could do to this effect. it is the most absurd thing i have heard recently. of course i can understand that you as armenians want these lands back, and that you see that it is your moral right to want them back. after all, you had been there for three thousand years, and your mark on the land is there, as is so much of your history. but that's the moral side of the question. the american indians and the australians have exactly the same moral rights that you do, but that is not going to make the whites move off their land. the question is not whether it is moral or not, the question is whether it is feasible. and what we have here is a question of feasibility (practicality), not morality. the ag is a criminal issue, recognising it personally is a moral issue, and getting it recognised by the state and the public is a practical issue. the state is not going to recognise it as long as it sees such a recognition as a potential threat to its territorial integrity. and the state does, whether you agree with it or not. some of you say (if i understand you correctly) that turkey has nothing to fear because the armenians are so weak. what then if one day you get stronger? or get a stronger ally? the reason why roa - and the more tactful of you - do not vociferously push the land issue NOW is because you realise that you don't have the power to carry it out to the desired conclusion NOW. simply put, you don't try NOW because you know you can't get, NOT YET. but you fail to - or refuse to - understand that it is precisely your insistence on that unrealisable goal that plays into the hands of genocide deniers. they deny the thing ever happened in public by using establishment propaganda prepared for public consumption, economic, political and military bribes etc, and justify their denial in private conversations by pointing out the land claims. i reply that i) we have nothing to fear from them, since most armenians realise it is not a feasible goal because we are so strong and they are so weak, and ii) that most of them want the recognition more than the lands. the guy i) asks me what if we get weaker and they stronger, like in artsakh, and ii) shows me some comments made by a few individuals in the media including those on the hye forum. i turn into a nightingale that has eaten mulberry (if you know that expression, it is from turkish). in addition, i see an attitude on your part as you sitting on a higher pedestal than us, that you are intrinsically right and we intrinsically wrong, an attitude that i do not cultivate toward you. so a turk who accepts your line is "civilised, improving, hopeful etc.", the more of it he accepts, the more so he is. he is a less bad turk who symphatises with your sufferings, a goodish one if he accepts the ag, a good one if he accepts the ag, apologies, and compensation, and an excellent one if he agreed to pack his stuff and go wherever he came from. taking it further, he'd be best if he dropped dead! ("i hate the turks biologically. i wish they simply didn't exist" - gamavor). i find in this a very disturbing parallel to the attitude of the 19th century natives who resisted white encroachment on their lands and refused to give up their languages, cultures, and identity and adopt white man's ways. my position is clear. the ag took place, it was a crime that has to be recognised, apologised for and compensated. anatolian armenians must also be allowed to return to their land and live unmolested lives with no second-class status, if they so choose. this is justice, and it must be done, for the armenians have a right to receive justice, and the turks have an obligation to give justice, and have a right to live without the moral burden of carrying on an injustice. turkey must stay in one peace and the return of the armenians to eastern anatolia must not mean the turks getting out of it. this is also justice, for the turks on this land are natives by dint of time, culture and genes, just as you do. for this to be possible, land claims must be dropped, because i) they are not feasible, ii) they are not just (see above), and iii) they obstruct ag recognition. this is pragmatism.
-
quote:Originally posted by nairi: quote:Originally posted by aurguplu:dear arpa, i must confess i didn't quite understand what your point was, so i am afraid i cannot furnish a reply (if there's anyone out there who understood, could you please explain?) cheers, You can't furnish a reply because you're a coward, just like your fellow 80 million Turks. Nairi nairi you are slipping back into the style which had caused me to suspend comunication with you. besides, the question was addressed to arpa and not you. let's see his answer.
-
quote:Originally posted by nairi: quote:Originally posted by aurguplu:by the way guys don't take mhp that seriously. they couldn't swing öcalan, and now the death sentence is off the turkish penal code. i doubt they will make it to the parliament in the next elections. do not forget that before 1980 they were what 4%, 5% of the electorate? Then how come they are HIGHLY active and supported in Holland? After Turkey won their first match this World Cup, there were more MHP flags in the streets of The Hague and Rotterdam than Turkish ones. Could you please explain this? yes i think i could 1. turks in europe are like blacks in the usa. their situation is bitter, which makes them bitter, which makes them to support bitter parties. 2. the kurd:turk and shia:sunni ratios in europe are much higher than in turkey itself, and these conflicts are carried into europe. since europe is more liberal in terms of dissent, these groups (and their opponents) flourish more easily in europe. 3. mhp is one of the few turkish parties (the others are the religious guys) that took a genuine interest in turkish expats, and got itself organised there real well. 4. mhp is (o at least was until bahçeli) deeply embedded in all sorts of violent crime, chiefly extortion, drug smuggling, contract killing, illegal human trafficking etc, all also pkk areas of interest and they naturally come into conflict and this is reflected back on the populations that support them. hope this helps. cheers,
-
boghos, thanks for the summary. allow me to give my version: aurguplu (personal): ag recognition & compensation & resettlement. will deal with land claims separately. turkey: denial until land claims drop (or until we together with azerbaijan are the only two states left to deny it). ostrich mentality. roa: ag recognition, compensation, opening up the borders, normalisation of relations. unclear position re land claims. diaspora: diverse. ag recognition (all), compensation (almost all), land claims (may be not the majority, but enough to block the issue), resettlement (almost none). proposed solution (to be discussed behind closed doors): sequence of events: 1. roa makes clear statement that i) it does not and will not harbour land claims, and ii) will not support diaspora claims to this effect. 2. representative diaspora organisations drop land claims from agenda of political goals to be pursued. 3. turkey recognises ag, apologises, agrees to pay compensation germany-style, and returns property to individuals (not roa) wherever feasible, allows resettlement. 4. relations between roa and tr normalised, trade booms. question: who thinks the russians will just watch this, and how come? thanks,
-
by the way guys don't take mhp that seriously. they couldn't swing öcalan, and now the death sentence is off the turkish penal code. i doubt they will make it to the parliament in the next elections. do not forget that before 1980 they were what 4%, 5% of the electorate?
-
ok everyone this will be a partial reply, 'cos i don't have much time. 1. ag will eventually (and as far as i can see, sooner than we might think/fear/hope) be recognised with or without turkey. whether turkey will join this recognition or plod along denying it time will tell. i very much hope for the first option. 2. several issues will surface (or resurface) when this happens, these are 1) compensation for the dead, 2) return of or compensation for lost property. since movables being movable and moved off, these will most probably be settled to some extent by compensations. i can envisage a civilised turkish government not having nightmares about that. after all, they can vaporise enough money to run a small state in a series of bank scandals and then grin to the imf and world bank and get the money. so this is a relatively minor problem. the major problem is the lands. turks will not accept any claims for obvious reasons plus the fact that before the genocide there was no independent armenia. the turkish conquests of the 11th-13th centuries were like any oter conquests and you cannot realistically extend the genocide issue that far back. if you did, and succeded, then it would set a precedent for similar such claims re the americas, australia etc, indeed, much of the world. and do not forget that this includes your national symbol ararat as well. i do not know enough of the history of the armenian republic 1918-1922, so i cannot comment on the legality issues there. the problem is that turks have a genuine fear that you guys are up to kicking our asses back to central asia, after all, the sevres treaty was very much in that spirit. so they block every move on your part that they perceive as an attempt on their country's integrity. to get any headway in arguments with the bulk of the turkish population, you first have to realise and accept it as the basis of of your position toward us that no part of turkey will be ceded to anyone else peacefully. assuming that you are not envisaging a military confrontation with turkey, this basically means that you have to accept turkish teritorial integrity. now about getting back to the land and living on it with those bloodthirsty bastards (us): i think that if turks are genuinely convinced that you do are not going to use your return to turkey as a step to eventual secession, they can be brought to accept it. note that many turks could be made to agree that you have a moral right to live in anatolia (it is kind of obvious), the same way that many americans can NOW (not forty years ago)can be made to accept the moral right of a native american to live on his ancestors' soil. the problem is that they fear that you will once again attempt to take the land away. that is why i had said about 100 years for your return. i do not think it is a geological time scale. 100 years ago you were armenians, today you still are, and 100 years on you will still be (and the ability of the diaspora to retain its identity is really its own responsibility). now of course what turks would fear here (and rightly) is a version of the israeli-palestinian problem. this is a very pertinent example and how it could be addressed, in case what i have outlined above actually takes place, i do not know. one more thing: the position "you drop land claims, we recognise the genocide" is not my moral position. it is my pragmatic position. i for one do recognise the genocide whether you drop your claims or not. the problem is that i am in a tiny minority in turkey and hence not significant. i want more people to recognise it, but the thing is i see that it won't happen unless and until you drop the land claims, and frankly speaking, i can see why. the genocide did happen whether we recongise it or not. everyone else is agreed on that whether we recognise it or not. many turks can, in private conversations with armenians, accept it and offer their regrets over it. but these are private, personal expressions of opinion that have no bearing on the state and do not put it under any kind of responsibility. and there's the crux of the matter. the state does not recognise it officially simply because it will open up pandora's box, and all sorts of issues, the most important of them being the land issue, will come out, and they will have their hands full with a serious problem. because when a state recognises something as a fact, then the responsibility to do somethng about it automatically follows. what that something is has not yet been agreed upon by both sides. and one of the sides - judging by its present position - can very well say "now that you have recognised it, get out of the land". armenia on its own of course does not worry us, but armenia plus russia plus europe plus the usa does. and we know full well that russia at least is behind you (admittedly not always the way you would like it to be ). we want that issue to be sorted out first before we recognise the genocide. clear?
-
quote:Originally posted by hagarag:Ali, It was not me who stated that there were no designs upon present Turkish territory. YOU are WELL aware that most Armenian organizations AND the ROA consider varying parts of eastern Anatolia to be rightfully part of Armenia. Please do not feign ignorance in this matter. I take a more moderate approach than most, because I feel that the majority of this territory would be more of a burden upon Armenia than it is worth and believe that Armenia has enough problems at present without having additional territory that few Armenians would wish to return to. BUT the border is not locked in cement. As you have stated, as Europe is becoming borderless perhaps the region of Turkey/Armenia will one day become borderless. Once bitter enemies in western Europe are peacefully co-existing. hagarag, 1. you say ROA rightly considers parts of eastern anatolia as rightfully part of armenia. i remember having said things to that effect under various past threads, and almost uniformly got replies like this was sheer nonsense, that it all was turkish government propaganda to justify the denial of genocide etc. so it turns out it wasn't after all. it isn't me who feigns ignorance of it, it's some on the armenian side, and in fact i was trying to prove my point, you've done it for me, thank you. 2. i am relieved to see that you can see the third option, namely a borderless turkey-armenia. but don't you realise that asking for removal of borders and uninhibited settlement is one thing, asking for change in borders is another.
-
quote:Originally posted by Twilight Bark: quote:Originally posted by aurguplu:hagarag, was it you who had told me in a previous discussion under a different thread that you guys were not trying to carve up my country, or was it someone else, and if it was someone else, could i please get a coment from him about your posting? Hi Ali, I do not know if I am the “someone else” you had in mind, but I'll use the break I granted myself to pitch in anyway. First, "you guys" and "hagarag" are not synonymous, to say the least. "Us guys" (and there is really no such coherent entity as far as the issue is concerned) includes people who want nothing more than an acknowledgement (not even an apology) of history, and move on with their lives toward full assimilation into cultural oblivion, feeling good that their grandparents did not hallucinate the whole genocide thing. In fact, "us guys" includes those who want to drop the whole issue and move on, and pretend that Armenians are a "normal" nation, hoping that it could become one by declaring itself so. “Us guys" includes those who enjoy dreaming that a few of the provinces containing the most "significant" Armenian totems like Mt. Ararat and Aghtamar can become Armenian again. And of course "us guys" includes those whose wet dreams involve a "sea to sea" Armenian Empire. And then of course there is the "mainstream" Armenians, who are too busy with life to think much on such silly subjects one way or the other. I am sure you can make a similar categorization about "you guys", except that your "empire builders" are a lot more numerous, are on the ground (rather than in some faraway place a continent or two away, fully submerged in the safety and comfort of the eventual graveyard of their culture and identity), and have afrighteningly cosy relationship with the army, which happens to be the most powerful one in the region by far. As far as “carving up my country”, how melodramatic of you. You think hagarag will draw his sword made of celery, and throw bean-powered bombs to carve up “your” country? Even if the territory in question were granted to Armenians, it wouldn’t qualify as “carving up”. And in some unlikely scenario where Armenians re-populate their ancestral lands and proceed to demand independence, why do you think it would be such a tragedy? And do you think there are ways in which Turkey could prevent such a “tragedy”? If you don’t, then I suggest you think harder. And in case Turkey couldn’t prevent oh-such-a-melodramatic tragedy, you can take comfort from the fact that Czechoslovakia split into two pieces, and produced two stable and healthy countries, without the Czechs feeling the urge to wipe the Slovaks out of existence, or refusing to deal with Slovakia. And Canada has no immediate plans to punish Quebec into submission or send its residents to France. There is no question that Armenians have the moral right to live on their ancestral lands of many millennia, especially considering the circumstances of their “removal”. Now if you cannot make them happy after they come back, perhaps the land in question does not and should not belong to you. If Armenians do not bother to come back in significant numbers, then they forfeit their moral right to live on it except as tourists or “ordinary” Turkish citizens. In any event, I suspect that a country with the vision to invite back the few Armenians that would bother to come would also have the level of intellectual development that ensures a harmonious coexistence, with all the cultural freedoms and local governance. But don’t worry Ali, the paranoia and territorial obsession displayed by “the best and the brightest” of your society makes a true reconciliation seem like a distant dream that it probably is. Finally, it seems that it is not enough for us to say “we can’t imagine demanding lands from you, because you are too powerful” (paraphrasing Kocharian). You want to censor our thoughts and emotions, so we cannot even wish to live on those lands as Armenians without being accused of complicity in land-grabbing. You want us to tear away from our hearts the places that formed the main body of our nation. As an avid proponent of realpolitik thinking, you surely understand the polite position of “We don’t demand it because we know we cannot get it”. Leave it at that. When discussing matters related to genocide and ethnic cleansing, there is one overriding factor above all else: morality. It is morally hollow (to say the least) to “repent” and yet forbid the descendants from coming back to those lands. Once you fulfill your unavoidable and morally required task, it is then your responsibility to ensure that those that come back have no reason to ask for outright independence. If Turkey can’t imagine doing that, it need not bother the Armenians with silly displays of “Oh I am so sorry”. Here is one censorship (or perhaps self-restraint) homework for you Ali: until you feel in your heart and know in your mind that the land in question belongs as much to Armenians as to Turks and Kurds that now live on it, refrain from trying to sound so enlightened. Once you and the rest of the “best and the brightest” internalize that notion, the two nations can “play it again”, hopefully with much happier results this time for all involved. This may be news to you, but the ball is in your court. Regards, Twilight Bark hi tb, 1. i reasoned that hagarag did not mean to get all the land by and for himself, and that he was referring to a desire common to many armenians. i am of course aware enough of the fact that armenians are as diverse on this subject as any nation would be to make a detailed point of the matter unnecessary. 2. the "empire builders" of ours (who are they?) you refer to have cosy relations with the army, just as everyone else in the country, simply because the alternative has proved too dangerous. i am not a bit proud of that fact, but wouldn't blame our civilians for it. moreover, what "empire building" activity have we engaged in after the fall of the last one (and don't cite me cyprus, you know it wasn't one)? 3. i am a bit disappointed that after two years of my presence in this forum (gosh, it has been long) some people still do not dig it that i do not for a moment question/challenge armenian moral right to live in anatolia. in fact, i propose solutions that involve resettlement of armenians in turkey that are derided/refuted/taken as dishonest by many. and then you talk about getting the lands back, fully realising at the same time that you don't and won't have the power in the foreseeable future to remove the turks from there by force. don't you see a contradiction there? 4. i think i had stated clearly that what at least i am against is not armenians coming back to turkey, but a part of turkey being ceded to armenia or any other country. it is a basic desire to keep your territory intact. 5. i agree with your czechoslovakia example, but do not forget that these people were until relatively recently under austro-hungarian empire, and czechoslovakia came into being after the wwi, and then it was run over by the germans in wwii, and by the russians in 1967. besides, the czechs were quite happy to see slovaks go because they were a bit of a burden, and it was that ex-commie former boxer meciar who wanted his own little turf closer to russia who engineered the whole thing. i should very much ask the slovaks now whether they are so happy with it now. 6. our right to be in anatolia does not only derive from our sword. we have mixed with the indigenous population to such and extent and took over so many aspects of their culture that in practical terms we are turkish-speaking anatolians. if it weren't for our different language and a few items in our arts & crafts & music, and a few other cultural things, how would you be able to tell us from the rest? we are almost as anatolian as you are, and central asia is as strange place to us today as it is to you. 7. if i didn't feel that the land belonged as much to the armenians, greeks and kurds and others who lived on it for ages as it did to turks, then what in the hell do you think i am doing here talking to you? sorry this has not been in very clear sequence, but i hope it is clear. regards,
-
quote:Originally posted by hagarag:This propogandizing is nothing new. Dadrian's works have brilliantly neutralized every one of the Turkish government's discussion points. It is all about money and power. Until the Turkish military finds themselves losing ground due to the Genocide issue, nothing will change. Just like the Mullahs in Iran hold the real power, it is the military in Turkey. As long as Turkey has geographic leverage they will play it to the max. We should strengthen our alliance with Greece and Iran and improve it with Bulgaria. Every one of Turkey's neighbors should jointly demand a return of territory confiscated by the Turks, including Kurdish lands. The issue should be raised on the floor of the U.N. hagarag, was it you who had told me in a previous discussion under a different thread that you guys were not trying to carve up my country, or was it someone else, and if it was someone else, could i please get a coment from him about your posting?
-
quote:Originally posted by Boghos:Dear Ali, You have repeated several times in this forum that the Turkish government is preparing the population for AG recognition. Nevertheless all we, poor mortals, have been able to see points to the opposite. Turkey´s line is: let´s repeat the lie over and over again. And even give it a varnish of respectability by funding "academics" in Turkey and abroad. Turks in their vast majority not only deny that the AG took place but also have ill fellings towards Armenians. It is hard to believe that it would be in any Turkish politician interest to put forward this kind of proposition. Much less the military, for obvious reasons. This sounds exceedingly like some sort of conspiracy theory. It simply does not exist. Now, if you could present some concrete evidence of what you have been defending things would change dramatically. Who knows, we, the very organized, rich, powerful, influential, omniscient and omnipresent diaspora, could give you a hand. This whole discussion is not moving forward because you fail to understand what Armenian wants and that the diaspora is mostly irrelevant when it comes to important decisions. Turkey´s line that the Armenian diaspora is all powerful and magnificent, that you swallow so easily, is simply borrowing from the same arguments that is made about the jews almost everywhere. It is just a more comical and farcical version of it. Issues in Armeno-Turkish relations are not that complex. Actually they are quite simple. The solution, however is rather difficult because Turkey is very far from feeling secure about itself in almost all matters. dear boghos, 1. i have lately been talking to some People Who Would Know re turkey's evolving stance over the ag issue, and they said the observed the same thing. let me tell you the concrete pieces of evidence that i can think of: i) i have been to this forum for the past two years, which i do not doubt for a second that the turkish security checks in on and off, and have survived so far, and neither me nor anyone i know have been molested/made life difficult for or anything like that. ii) there are an increasing number of turks who are having similar experiences, iii) for the past few years, genocide-related material giving the armenian version of events has been freely entering turkey and even translated into turkish and has not been removed from circulation iv) some turkish armenians have referred in public to "a tragedy" that their nation had experienced that the turkish state has not yet addressed properly (e.g. hrant dink of agos): these same individuals are still alive and well and functioning as they did before v) a turkish minister from a very senior family wrote a book called "the beads of salkım hanım" narrating the story of the infamous property tax of the wwii period, where a main character, a jewish person, was changed to an armenian one (leon to levon) by the (armenian) director of the movie (etyen mahçupyan) and references were made to 1915, although it created great hype, no-one had a brush with the law, vi) roald grigor-souny gave a few lectures at turkish universities giving the armenian version of events. he wasn't shouted out, but after the lecture some from the turkish audience gave their accouns they had heard from their grandparents about how the armenians in their district were killed. nobody got to meet the police after that, vii) halil berktay gave an interview to a high circulation newspaper in which he described the CUP guys as the ancestors of our modern susurluk guys (you know what i mean if you follow turkish affairs). the article appeared as a centrefold double-page spread (or was it single page?) and halil berktay, the interviewer and the newspaper are still alive and kicking. viii) zülfü livaneli, a popular ex-communist singer, political activist and columnist, published an article where he asked the question of "for how long more are we to pay for the crimes of the ittihadists" ix) atlas, the turkish version of the national geographic, produced an issue mainly devoted to 1915 (with that title) where a glimpse of a highly unofficial version of the story can be read between, and sometimes directly on, the lines, and finally x) a senior politician, one of Those Who Know (forgot his name) had characterised the change from leon to levon in the salkım hanım movie (see v) as "a part of a greater plan to psychologically prepare the nation to the fact that what had happened to the armenians was a genocide". i think these are enough to show that some very serious changes are taking place in this country. the fact that almost all of the above took place in the last two years is a point that strenghtens my argument. as far as the still lingering turkish official position is concerned, i derscibe it as controlled retreat: it would be a very foolhardy state to acknowledge such a thing before having properly prepared the nation's psyche for it. as far as the diaspora is concerned, we are first and foremost busy with the american and french diasporas. i had never heard of the brazilian or dutch diaspora, for instance. it may be because these two countries, especially the usa, are of paramount importance to turkish interests, and the diaspora there is the largest, most vocal, richest, most powerful, and most dedicated. we are especially uneasy with the fact that some diaspora members have big stakes in the american media and entertainment industry (kirk kirkorian for instance). we see this as a weapon that can be used in propaganda warfare. you may of course point out here that until ararat, not a single movie (or am i wrong) was actually made on the subject, and i may agree that we are perhaps exaggerating this threat. but still, it is there. as far as the comparison with the jewish diaspora is concerned, i stick to my argument. do you honestly believe that israel could survive for one day in the middle east without american support, and that there would be that much american support for it in view of the most blatant excesses they have comitted against the palestinians, especially recently, if there were not a very rich and powerful jewish lobby in america dedicated to the cause of aliyah? cheers,
-
dear thoth, thanks for your refreshing posting. we three (actually, initially mj and i) were involved in an online war about the land claims and frankly speaking, it wasn't getting anywhere. i think we have to realise that we are not going to be able on every single issue: i realise that i just cannot make some armenians drop the land claims, and those same armenians have to realise that they just cannot make us take any steps that has the slightest risk of resulting in a smaller turkey and us herding sheep in kazakhstan. what we have so far agreed upon, though, is the fact of genocide and its implications (i think we have reached broad consensus here, even though differences may remain). this is something we can buil upon and more significantly, something that we on this part of the world can eventually carry on to a larger audience here. i don't like wasting time, and my efforts here are at least partly fuelled by the desire to see this genocide business sorted out so that it doesn't dog my - and your - children anymore. as far as the land claims, though, the most i can agree to - and i think this is already quite a lot - is that the anatolian armenians be eventually allowed to resettle in their original homeland. some of the members in this forum - especially mj - totally reject this option as far as i can see, but quite a few armenians (not necessarily those in this forum) differ: some armenians have moved in to buy land in eastern anatolia, which, although creating some hype, was allowed legally as far as i know, and there is a hotel in van (van?) which was closed down on the grounds that the californian armenian who had bought it three years ago had named it "vartan" after his son (which i understand means "victory" in armenian, is this correct?). the hotel got reopened after a court ruling and got its name back. there is a town in central anatolia near kayseri, originally called germir, whose name was changed to something turkish in the republican period, the name of the town was given back after the inhabitants protested for several decades! incidentally, it is the hometown of ilya kazancıoğlu (elia kazan), by the way. so things are happening. may be i am too much of an optimist, but the kurdish example is there. i am thinking about your proposal re other forums, let me think about it a bit more. i take risks, but not stupid ones. cheers,
-
quote:Originally posted by Boghos: quote:Originally posted by aurguplu: quote:Originally posted by Boghos:Dear Ali, You have repeated several times in this forum that the Turkish government is preparing the population for AG recognition. Nevertheless all we, poor mortals, have been able to see points to the opposite. Turkey´s line is: let´s repeat the lie over and over again. And even give it a varnish of respectability by funding "academics" in Turkey and abroad. Turks in their vast majority not only deny that the AG took place but also have ill fellings towards Armenians. It is hard to believe that it would be in any Turkish politician interest to put forward this kind of proposition. Much less the military, for obvious reasons. This sounds exceedingly like some sort of conspiracy theory. It simply does not exist. Now, if you could present some concrete evidence of what you have been defending things would change dramatically. Who knows, we, the very organized, rich, powerful, influential, omniscient and omnipresent diaspora, could give you a hand. This whole discussion is not moving forward because you fail to understand what Armenian wants and that the diaspora is mostly irrelevant when it comes to important decisions. Turkey´s line that the Armenian diaspora is all powerful and magnificent, that you swallow so easily, is simply borrowing from the same arguments that is made about the jews almost everywhere. It is just a more comical and farcical version of it. Issues in Armeno-Turkish relations are not that complex. Actually they are quite simple. The solution, however is rather difficult because Turkey is very far from feeling secure about itself in almost all matters. dear boghos, 1. i have lately been talking to some People Who Would Know re turkey's evolving stance over the ag issue, and they said the observed the same thing. let me tell you the concrete pieces of evidence that i can think of: i) i have been to this forum for the past two years, which i do not doubt for a second that the turkish security checks in on and off, and have survived so far, and neither me nor anyone i know have been molested/made life difficult for or anything like that. ii) there are an increasing number of turks who are having similar experiences, iii) for the past few years, genocide-related material giving the armenian version of events has been freely entering turkey and even translated into turkish and has not been removed from circulation iv) some turkish armenians have referred in public to "a tragedy" that their nation had experienced that the turkish state has not yet addressed properly (e.g. hrant dink of agos): these same individuals are still alive and well and functioning as they did before v) a turkish minister from a very senior family wrote a book called "the beads of salkım hanım" narrating the story of the infamous property tax of the wwii period, where a main character, a jewish person, was changed to an armenian one (leon to levon) by the (armenian) director of the movie (etyen mahçupyan) and references were made to 1915, although it created great hype, no-one had a brush with the law, vi) roald grigor-souny gave a few lectures at turkish universities giving the armenian version of events. he wasn't shouted out, but after the lecture some from the turkish audience gave their accouns they had heard from their grandparents about how the armenians in their district were killed. nobody got to meet the police after that, vii) halil berktay gave an interview to a high circulation newspaper in which he described the CUP guys as the ancestors of our modern susurluk guys (you know what i mean if you follow turkish affairs). the article appeared as a centrefold double-page spread (or was it single page?) and halil berktay, the interviewer and the newspaper are still alive and kicking. viii) zülfü livaneli, a popular ex-communist singer, political activist and columnist, published an article where he asked the question of "for how long more are we to pay for the crimes of the ittihadists" ix) atlas, the turkish version of the national geographic, produced an issue mainly devoted to 1915 (with that title) where a glimpse of a highly unofficial version of the story can be read between, and sometimes directly on, the lines, and finally x) a senior politician, one of Those Who Know (forgot his name) had characterised the change from leon to levon in the salkım hanım movie (see v) as "a part of a greater plan to psychologically prepare the nation to the fact that what had happened to the armenians was a genocide". i think these are enough to show that some very serious changes are taking place in this country. the fact that almost all of the above took place in the last two years is a point that strenghtens my argument. as far as the still lingering turkish official position is concerned, i derscibe it as controlled retreat: it would be a very foolhardy state to acknowledge such a thing before having properly prepared the nation's psyche for it. as far as the diaspora is concerned, we are first and foremost busy with the american and french diasporas. i had never heard of the brazilian or dutch diaspora, for instance. it may be because these two countries, especially the usa, are of paramount importance to turkish interests, and the diaspora there is the largest, most vocal, richest, most powerful, and most dedicated. we are especially uneasy with the fact that some diaspora members have big stakes in the american media and entertainment industry (kirk kirkorian for instance). we see this as a weapon that can be used in propaganda warfare. you may of course point out here that until ararat, not a single movie (or am i wrong) was actually made on the subject, and i may agree that we are perhaps exaggerating this threat. but still, it is there. as far as the comparison with the jewish diaspora is concerned, i stick to my argument. do you honestly believe that israel could survive for one day in the middle east without american support, and that there would be that much american support for it in view of the most blatant excesses they have comitted against the palestinians, especially recently, if there were not a very rich and powerful jewish lobby in america dedicated to the cause of aliyah? cheers, The fact that people are not being murdered by stating the historical truth is probably an improvement. But not exactly proof that the state is preparing the population for AG recognition. Or is it not Turkey the country that recently created an "institute" of Armenian studies, and whose embassies protest all over the world against the AG ? Morevoer books such as "Jenosit" by Dadrian were not published in the last two years, but before. Similarly, Kurdish revolutionary groups such as Kizilirmak and Yorum have had their CDs sold openly for years, but that does not mean that the Kurdish question was about to be resolved. You see there is a big difference between given access to a few irrelevant intellectuals to material on AG and "preparing the population for AG recognition". That is just tokenism. On the diaspora: first of all I never said that the Brazilian or Dutch or Singaporean diasporas were relevant or irrelevant. If by saying that you were trying to disqualify me as a source, by saying that the American and French diasporas are what really matters, implying that I shouldn't know, well, welcome to your "scholar" world. In any case, I am just saying that the role of the diaspora is overplayed by Turkey for obvious reasons and you swallow the bait. I think you have acknowledged that yourself to a certain extent. I do agree that the diaspora has been important for Israel. It has also been important for Armenia. But that does not mean that it dictates foreign policy. I can cite several instances where Israel acted without the knowledge of the US and sometimes even against it. Yes, the diaspora has helped lobbying in Washington and Paris. But it is much weaker than you seem to think. It is helped in Europe by the uneasy feelings animosity that most European countries have for Turkey. I can however understand where you are coming from: a product of Kemalist brainwashing and the longstanding paranoia of a still dying empire surrounded by unfriendly neighbours. I don't mean in a bad or insulting way, it is simply how things are. Just a few words on the Susurluk vs CUP analogy: I admit I don't know the context this was said but more often than not these comments have the underlying theme of "how great, tolerant and peaceful the OE was" and was spoiled by those mafiosi. The myth of the OE is another sickness that doesn't seem to go away. Dear Ali, I realize you are a good person, but believeing on what you want to believe, through some fallacy of composition, and being privy to information from "people in the know" are signs that a rest is merited and perhaps a bit more. dear boghos, 1. the fact that non-official versions of the ag story are freely available in turkey today means far more than you think. i am saying this because i experienced pretty much the same thing re the kurdish question. when i was a teenager (1980s) kurds simply didn't exist. they were mountain kurds who spoke a bastardised mixture of turkish, arabic and persian, and were called kurds because their boots made the sound "kart, kurt" when they were walking on snow (this is not a joke but serious government "theory" re the origin of the name "kurd"). i saw in the intervening years how the issue was gradually thawed (mainly thanks to the very courageous efforts of our late özal), and the military was forced to take a bit of a back seat thanks to the growing civilian opposition to their policies by the turkish (not kurdish) population. true, there have been a very large number of people - if not the numerical majority - who were opposed to that etc., and there are still publications around that portray the kurds as mountain turks etc., but so much of the opposite view has hit the bookstores, the newspapers, the media, the songs, the movies etc. that by the mid-nineties the fact that there were kurds (there weren't ten years ago), that they were not turks (they were mountain turks ten years ago), that they fought to get their cultural rights recognised etc. (they had all fought with us in the dardanelles according to the story ten years ago), was an open secret. and then, in the last five-ten years, the ban on kurdish got gradually lifted, culminating in the official removal of all the legal obstacles recently, and today there are no restrictions (officially at least) to express your kurdish identity. it all took less than fifteen years. there still are some odd academics here and there that publish stuff like "kurds are turks", they are met with respect, but the same kind of respect that you show to your neighbour who says that his wife is pretty and his kids smart. that is what i mean by preparing the public for the regognition of the ag. and all these things like the institute for armenian studies etc will not be able to survive in an environment when the government finally pulls off its support. 2. i may have overexaggerated the importance of the jewish diaspora a bit, not because i am brainwashed or anything but because i am physically over here and get most of my news second hand. but it is clear that israel could not do what it is doing without serious diaspora backing. mind you, the usa is still the only country that is offering serious support to israel. europe doesn't and hasn't been for a while, even if germans are still having their pangs of conscience over the holocaust. 3. i hadn't realised i had to give you a corrective to notions about me being a product of kemalist brainwashing. i came from two families who were active in turkey long before mustafa kemal, and i have a sense of perspective reading history. i am fully aware that much of kemalist-written history is pure fiction, this is indeed one of the reasons why i had stopped my academic carrer in turkey. the bulk of my references when referring to "sensitive" topics are european, as the turkish sources can simply not be trusted on their own: you need a corrective. so please, no more calling me a "kemalist" turk. if you are going to call me anything, call me something that i am: a turk. 4. i am aware of the dangers of "believing what i want to believe", and strive - and hope - not to fall into that trap. plus, i think the charge is unjustified: no turk would want to believe that ag is a fact, but it unfortunately is, and we are the ones to blame. now this is just so bad that if you can stomach that, you can stomach pretty much anything else. so if i were a person who would believe what he wanted to believe, i wouldn't be here in the first place. but i agree with your suggestion that we perhaps have to take a little break. i am busy and tired, and so seem you and mj. i might be away for some time, will check in again when i am in the right mood. till then, take care you all, cheers,
-
quote:Originally posted by Boghos:There is an interesting article about "gavur" at the very end of this page: http://www.ozgurpolitika.org/1999/12/15/allkosb.html I just don´t know if it is legal for Ali to read it... dear boghos, of course it is, and i have. there is quite a lot of stuff in the same vein in turkey freely available. cheers,
-
quote:Originally posted by Arpa: quote:Originally posted by aurguplu:arpa, the word "gavur", though sounding like "kafir" actually comes from old persian "gabr" which meant a zoroastrian priest (or something zoroastrian). i am not for calling people "infidel" or anything, especially seriously in a derogatory sense, and i don't condone such usage. cheers, Of course you wouldn't, and neither would I repeat some of the dictionary definitions of a Turk.Truth will be heard "from the mouth of babes". My cousin went on a "pilgrimage" to Anatolia, they travelled all the way from Marsah to Ani, her mother being of Zeituntsi heritage she mad e a point to also visit there. She spoke to some people, none of them would respond to her questions except for a 10 year old boy. I have this on video tape. Standing in front of a steep precipice when asked if he knew anything about Ermenis and what had happened there the boy responds; "Burda savash oldu, turkler ve 'gavurlarin' arasinda. Turkler uttu, 'gavurlarin anasini s....k, gebertdik, bu daghdan ashaghi attik". (There was a war here between the Turks and the "gavurs". We won, we f....'d their mothers, we killed them[as if an animal] and we threw them down this pricipce". Dear Ali, if you don't condone and utter such words where does a 10 year old learn it from? dear arpa, you can have many such experiences in many parts of turkey. the place was like the former yugoslavia at the point of breaking up. it exploded like a powderkeg, and some rather sombre aspects of human nature became prevalent. in western parts of the country, there are a very large number of greek churches (i saw some in mudanya) in the most pitiful state: the lead of the roof being removed, the structure starts to leak, and the columns begin to crack. the places were used for decades for "good nights out" (=rakı içip karı oynatmak) and a group of guy i know who undertook to restore one of them spent a week removing the bottles out of the church! of course when you ask people why they do it and whether they would enjoy seeing a mosque in such a state, they promptly reply that they already have (their own mosque back in the old country, which is either greece or the balkans). what can you say there? i say things like we should not answer wrong with wrong, but as we say in turkish "öfke baldan tatlıdır" and it is unleashed. (mind you, it is only recently (since özal) that we have been able to discuss such issues and drum differently relatively freely.) but of course, many turks, including those who say such things as the one you related above, feel very much ashamed when they are told that the person they are talking to is a "gavur". there is a perception that what was done was wrong. this is why i maintain that it is always better to bring the conflicting parties physically together, because it is when the other party to the conflict is not around that the harshest things are said behind them. when they are around, it inevitably has a civilising effect. cheers,
-
arpa, acemi in turkish means someone who is either a novice at something, or not very good at whatever it does. like "acemi doktor hastayı öldürür" (i made that up). this is the only current usage that i can think of, and it is a great injustice to a nation that is expert at so many arts! cheers,
-
mj, ok. go on, put forth all the issues on the table. as far as i see them they are: 1. ag and its ramifications: i say we open up all our relevant archives, recognise it, apologise for it, pay reparations german style, and allow you to resettle; and you open up all your relevant archives, make the russians, the french, the british, the germans, the usa and anyone else relevant do the same, and then face the picture that will come out. i also say that all guilty parties be pronounced as such. everybody knows turks are guilty. it's no news. news will be the part played by these guys and even some armenian factions in the ag. 2. land claims: o.k., you bring the issue on the table, we recognise your right to ask that question, at the same time retaining our right to answer in the negative: no. our reasons to say no are: i) we look at our own nation and do not see one that could be persuaded to give land, especially one it is living on, other than by military means. ii) we are just as native as you by dint of our anatolian heritage. the picture of anatolian turks as central asian mongols is totalyy inaccurate as can be observed by anyone who visits the place. we are anatolian in every sense of the word. turkish-speaking anatolians. this gives ud the very same moral title to the land as it does to you, the anatolian greeks, the kurds and everyone else. iii) looking around, we do not see other conquerors give land to the conquered and pack their stuff and go. why should we, then? because it is going to be more civilised? if this is the case, then perhaps those who preach civilisation and righteousness to the rest of the world (the americans, for instance), should pack, get back into nina/pinta/santa maria (and mayflower) and sail back to wherever they came from in europe. you get them to do that, then you will have a serious hand in asking us to do the same. iv) we are not prepared to discuss the land issue because as i have stated your claims are your first line of attack and our refusal to discuss them is our first line of defence. and if the first line of defence is pierced through, the second line of defence is exposed to attack. and if that goes on, we or our offspring may eventually find themselves either imprisoned in anatolian ghettoes palestinian style, or herding sheep in kazakhstan. neither of these is the future we envisage. this is our position. let's hear yours. cheers,
-
re turkey the bird was originally called "turkey cock" in english and did have something to do with us by some extension: i think the story was something like a muslim corsair ship getting caught in the mediterranean and having a cargo of these birds which were originally imported from the americas or something like that. in turkish the bird is called "hindi", and that either means that it came from india (which we know it didn't) or more probably has something to do with the confusion arising from the misidentification of the americas as india.
-
arpa, the word "gavur", though sounding like "kafir" actually comes from old persian "gabr" which meant a zoroastrian priest (or something zoroastrian). i am not for calling people "infidel" or anything, especially seriously in a derogatory sense, and i don't condone such usage. re "boklu da çamurluya gülüyor": it's wonderful! i had never neard that one. it must be one of those eastern anatolian dialects that use it. we in istanbul are more refined and say "tencere dibin kara seninki benden kara". you would agree, wouldn't you, that you cannot pronounce yours in polite society. cheers,
