aurguplu
Members-
Posts
623 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Events
Gallery
Everything posted by aurguplu
-
khodja, turkey (we the people) does not really claim to be a free, democratic nation. turkey (we the people) claims to be on the way to becoming a free, democratic nation. it is turkey (they the state) that claims that turkey (we the people) are enjoying freedom and democracy in turkey (they the state), whereas turkey (we the people) know better. clear? regards,
-
juggernaut, thanx for your comments on my english. i happen to have a b.a. and m.a. from oxford, england, and a degree of familiarity with english is required to get them. i also happen to be a language enthusiast, and would have become a professional linguistic historian if the academic world in turkey were anything like an academic world. sadly, (sob) i am doing research on stocks now, and also buying and selling some on my own. you are right in your diagnosis that a good majority of the people who are cultured and have the guts to come up with the human rights record of turkey have usually been from among the marxists' ranks. but this monopoly ceased to exist with ozal, who, despite his (numerous) faults in other spheres of statecraft, did breathe some freedom into turkey and allowed dissent to flourish. if he lived longer, we would perhaps have progressed more in turco-armenian relations and the recognition of a dark past. today, a good few people from all political inclinations are apt to admit (privately) that there has indeed been a genocide, and a good many more at least question the official verison of the story (in fact the official version of the story had also evolved in the past 20 years or so, so when you read the armenian and turkish versions of the event, and exclude the qualitative vocabulary such as "genocide", you do come up with pretty much the same picture. of course, the armenian side stresses the intent, which is the essence of the crime, whereas the turkish side tries to accuse only the actual butchers of the crimes, without analysing who masterminded the whole thing, but at the end of the day, when the official turkish version itself reveals that some 80% of the armenian population disappeared from the face of anatolia, it becomes obvious to everyone save those who wouldn't see that it could not have been "accidental" or "sporadic". as i have stated earlier, i think that the turkish state is currently preparing the people psychologically for an eventual recognition of the genocide. they are not doing anything actively, rather, they are removing the obstacles in front of those who already know about it and would like their countrymen to learn it, too. so you can give a conference or a t.v. interview in turkey today about the genocide, and not be touched. i think it is a good development, and it is starting to bear fruit. regards, [ October 09, 2001: Message edited by: aurguplu ]
-
thoth, i dont find it funny that you were not picked up as an armenian in turkey. what i had meant was that we can pick up armenians from a crowd of western europeans, americans, and even in some cases other middle easterners. i have known numerous armenians in the west, and in almost all cases i had guessed that they were armenian at the first sight, without previous knowledge about them or a single word exchanged. as i had said, i know of having "missed out" on some armenians, and a few "very few" people whom i thought were armenians turned out to belong to other ethnicities, i sometimes erred as grossly as mistaking a pakistani as an armenian! but all this said, i do observe that there is a recognisable physical type to which a good part, if not the majority, of armenians belong. this type appears to be predominant in eastern and central anatolia, and consequently many turks and kurds and arabs and assyrians etc. belong to it, too. funnily, the georgians seem to belong to it, too (though they are usually much whiter) while their cousins the circassians are somewhat different. of course, these are based on personal observations and not on any scientific study or anything, and it should also be clear from my earlier postings that i am not the type of guy who attempts to infer things from physical types (i felt the need to add this, because usually comments about racial appearance tend to get extended to other "characteristics" of the "races" in question, a brush with which i am not to be tarred). so you have been to turkey and had some good, and a few bad experiences if i understand correctly. i would like to hear more about your experiences with my countrymen. regards,
-
dear thoth, you are right. now the thing is that the turks are by far the most mixed of them all, that's why there is greater variety amongst the turks than there are amongst the armenians, for instance. i have no racial position regarding any race or nation or ethnic group, but i can assert with confidence that i - like many turks - can tell an armenian from a mile away, and although i sometimes miss some armenians, very few people whom i guess to be armenian turn out not to be armenian. it has got something to do with the eyebrows, the eyes, and the nose (well, that's most of the face, come to think of it). on the other hand, one would be pretty hopeless to detect a turk, except these anatolian dark, black-haired, thick eyebrowed hairy types with a gargantuan moustache running across their faces. shave them, and they will look in place from mexico to afghanistan. now turks appear to have been mixed very early on (central asia lies at the boundar between the natural distribution of the caucasian and sinitic races), they mingled with everyone from the inuits in siberia to the sudanese in africa, plus they were exogamous (meaning they married from outside the group, an assimilation policy), they left the indigenous races intact and mingled with them, and a significant proportion of present-day turks are descendants of the balkan migrants. so you end up with a country a bit like america in terms of racial makeup. i do not know whether to laugh or to cry when i hear of people speaking of the "racial" attributes of turks. to ascribe any racial characteristic (if there is such a thing, which i doubt) to turks flies in the face of observable facts. regards,
-
khodja, there are enough turks who had witnessed the massacres and lived to tell that you cannot really say that they have convinced themselves that it was a only war between combatants (and, yes, there were combatants, and many people actually died in internecine warfare of the yugoslav style rather than all-out genocide. many students of the genocide seem to miss this point). there are thousands of place names in anatolia that are still in use (although understandably unofficial) like red hill, bloody creek, etc., and if you ask the locals about the origin of the name, they will tell you that the name dates back to the "kıyım" ("massacre") when the chetes rounded up the armenians and killed them there. no, many people know what happened. it is just that they are too afraid to tell it in public because you can still end up in jail for saying that there was a genocide. recently a set of laws were passed to bring the constitution more into alignment with those of europe, and we hope now that this will make speaking out a good deal easier. also, as stated earlier in this forum, some 11% of the population does in fact recognise the genocide, in factt this should read that some 11% are vocal enough to say that openly in public even if they know that they are running a serious security risk. if you had talked to turks in private, you would be surprised at how many are actually aware of it and feel regret for it. our governments have always been lagging far behind our people, don't judge us by them. regards,
-
juggernaut, no, i am not, have never been. why, is there anything that smacks of it in my posting? you say although you see my logic, your views obviously differ. can you be more explicit, please?
-
1. agca (the one who shot the pope): he had killed a prominent turkish journalist (abdi ipekçi) before he shot the pope, and was given asylum by bulgaria and later by western europe. the pope later forgave him and learned from him ho was behind the attack. it is rumoured to have been the kgb and brezhnev. to take the actions of a solitary madman who acted as a hired gun to the communists as reprsentative of an entire nation is like concluding that the actions of, say, timothy mc veigh, are representative of the usa. 2. at the time of the turkish invasion of anatolia, the anatolian population was about 12-15 million (exact figures unknown). a total of some 3 million turks appear to have come from central asia throughout the ensuing centuries, with 1.5-2 million immediately after the conquest. the anatolian turks of most regions are physically and culturally (yes, culturally, too) indistinguishable from the non-turkic ethnicities who are their neighbours. this is partly because they mingled with them, and partly because the indigenous population of anatolia assimilated into them (or rather assimilated them) the way it happened with the romans, the slavs, the vikings, the celts, the armenians, the greeks, the hittites and what not throughout the centuries. the bulk of the cultural traits common to all of them date back to almost the tenth millennium bc. and the pronounced asiatic features that are sometimes (infrequently) encountered in turkey can for the most part be ascribed to the mongol invasion of the late 12th-early 15th centuries, and later, to the immigraton of central asian turks who fled czarist and soviet massacres in the 19th and early 20th centuries. we may have a history that makes us hereditary enemies, but that should not blind us to some very important facts about ourselves simply because it is easier & makes us feel better to spew forth hatred.
-
guys, i'll be away for a while. i am currently a head of research without a body (dept staff: 1) and i am expected to do four people's job (2 fired, 1 resigned, 1 (me) still there) at one fourth the pay, plus they are kickingus out of our room onto some open space. i hope i'll be back when i get my life back. meanwhile take care,
-
we are trying. in fact, mother nature is helping us (ecevit should have been dead a long time ago, but god wants us to agonise before he delivers us from pain).
-
dear harut, you are right, i seem to have missed that. sorry. anyway, a future posting of mine will contain my views on borders and stste sovereignty in general, i hope that will address it much better. dear edawrd, i fully agree with you on your views about the criminals. crime is crime is crime, and i will shed no tears after them just because they are turkish (as i had stated in an earlier posting, your criminal is no better than mine and mine no better than yours). as far as the return of the people, i suggest we look at a very similar region of the world with very similar problems, namely former yugoslavia, and see how they proceed (if they proceed) and draw lessons from that. i agree that people should be able to live side by side in peace, but if they show a clear inability to do so, perhaps it is wiser to apply there the principle you apply to silver and china and arguing children: separate them. anyway, in brief, i agree with the criminals, and i agree about people returning, but i fear it will be a long time coming. by the way, i am not a turkish protagonist, and was not attempting to suggest "give us this, so that we give you that" in an attempt to get things off you. i was merely trying to come up with a solution that would make everybody equally unhappy (look above) and that would work in the long-term. the worst solution is the one that causes bigger problems than it solves. dear mj, i am preparing my reply, it will take some time. pls be patient. regards,
-
to everyone out there, now it is becoming a criminal offense in many countries to deny the armenian genocide , but in turkey it still remains a criminal offence to affirm it (there is no law that says that, probably, but all such stuff is dealt with under "subversive actions aimed at overthrowing the turkish state, the unity and indivisibilty of the fatherland, insulting the turkish nation etc.). and that law includes actions done outside turkish jurisdiction. you are a turk abroad. faced with such a question, what do you do (if you really know what had happened). does the law give you to remain silent in switzerland, france, etc.?).
-
Dear MJ, “However, as an Armenian individual, I would like to stand up and claim that yes, the Republic of Armenia has, or better to say, should have (maybe not as a matter of fact but as a matter of legitimacy) territorial claims to the Republic of Turkey.” “If there is an impression that I think that we are going to advance territorial claims and Turkey is going to satisfy them, or there is any reality to expect satisfaction of such claims despite Turkey’s opposition, I have to say that it would be a very naïve impression.” If I can still read English, the first paragraph says that the Republic of Armenia should advance territorial claims to Turkey, and the second paragraph says that it would be naïve to expect the Armenians to do so or expect satisfaction of them. Now are these two paragraphs contradicting one another (which seems to me to be the case), or have you (or I) omitted some sentence that would have clarified the issue and made sense out of them? How can the Republic of Armenia both advance territorial claims on Turkey and expect to establish diplomatic relations with it, or even expect Turkey consider Armenia as anything other than an enemy? “This has nothing to do with the Genocide nor with Sevres.” It also has nothing to do with the generally accepted principles of interstate diplomacy or dialogue. “I would also like to emphasize that I am speaking here according to my own logic, and I have no indications nor information that the Government of the Republic of Armenia indeed has a decision to pursue such claims.” I take your word for it, in fact, we in Turkey are getting conflicting reports on the stance of the Armenian Republic on this issue, and it appears to me more a case of the position of several different individuals and/or organisations expressing their various – and often conflicting – opinions than a conspiracy attempt on the part of the Armenian Republic. “With all this, my claim doesn’t imply that I see a reality of materialization of the claims that I have emphasized above, but I have an expectations of the Turkish side recognizing the legitimacy of these claims and searching with us for acceptable to both sides solutions.” Show me a single state on earth that has recognised the legitimacy of claims on its own universally recognised territory (including the state that advances these claims, for the Republic of Armenian recognises the territorial integrity of the Turkish Republic, as stated by President Robert Kocharian himself) and agreed to search with the advancer of these claims solutions acceptable to both sides. “I would also like to get your feedback as why shouldn’t we have territorial or other claims from the Republic of Turkey.” 1. I would separate “territorial” from “other” and discuss them separately. I have made my position on the territorial claims clear. They do not call for a discussion or dialogue as far as I am concerned. Other items may. 2. I think the above made it sufficiently clear. If it didn’t, the answer is simple: by advancing territorial claims on Turkey, you would at best cause Turkey to ignore you as a state (which as we both know it has the power to afford), and at worst draw Turkey into a war that you imposed on it in the first place. No state that I know of allows, or participates in, any discussion of its territorial integrity, for it is the number one duty of the state to defend its territories. If it didn’t do that, it would be de facto defunct. “However, I don’t understand what means a “dialog,” if you are not even ready to discuss the existing issues.” I thought the existing issue was the recognition of the Genocide and the reparations to be made along the lines of the reparations Germany made after the Holocaust, which we discussed and – to my impression – were in full agreement with one another. This was my impression from my former dialogues with the Armenians, and from a good number of postings I read here in the forum, and these included yours. If I have given the impression that I would be prepared to accept Turkey’s territorial integrity as an issue that can be discussed, then I gave the wrong impression, for which I can only apologise. “Pretty much what you are saying is what we have heard Turkey say at least since 1993.” I did not know that the Turkish Republic had recognised the Genocide, condemned it, repented for it, and moved on to make the necessary reparations along the lines of the Holocaust reparations made by Germany, including the recognition of the right of the Armenians to return to their ancestral lands. Did I miss something? “However, there are issues between us, which require some resolution, and unless we are ready to put all the issues on the table, the illusion of the dialog wouldn’t serve any other reason but PR, which I personally wouldn’t care about.” As I had said, there was one main (Genocide & implications) and one smaller (Nagorno-Karabagh) issue between us, at least in my opinion, which was reinforced by some postings I saw here (or did I misinterpret them?). If you feel there is a third one, please state it. I also fully agree that there is no point in dialogue simply for the sake of PR, and we Turks are not very good at it (PR) anyway, are we, whether we care about it or not. “As far as Karabagh is concerned, I would appreciate if you could explain me in greater details the crux of your position and statement.” I think in Karabagh the following has to be done if we want the problem to be solved for good: Azerbaijan should understand that it has to say good-bye to it. Nagorno-Karabagh is almost 100% Armenian, there is no real hope for these guys living peacefully side-by-side, and as far as I can understand even before the conflicts started the Turks there were less than 10% of the population. They have no future together. A parallel may be drawn with the loss of the Arab peninsula by the Ottomans in ww1, which did not bother the republican turks a bit, in fact they were quite happy with it since we saw the Arabs as an untrustworthy element that would also hold us back if they were included in our new state. And history seems to have proven that we were right. The Nagorno-Karabagh Armenians and the Azeri Turks are like us in this respect, both would benefit from a border between them, and harmed if they are forced to coexist in the future on the same piece of land. Now Nagorno-Karabagh is buried deep in Azerbaijan with no land corridor that Armenia could claim legally, they “claimed” it militarily and there is one now. Frankly, I think if the Armenians got that and gave off the southern tip of Armenia so that Turkey-Nakhichevan and Azerbaijan are physically connected, and if all three parties agreed on that being the final solution to that problem, it would not recur. I understand Khodja’s suggestion was along these lines (he also added a sea passage through Turkey for Armenia, which I rejected: you cannot have everything). Such a solution would have the great advantage of actually working once it were put into place, for the way both Azerbaijan and Armenia look today calls for a future war for the borders to be redrawn just for geopolitical reasons. Armenians would have their Nagorno-Karabagh (Artzakh), and we would have our physical connection to Azerbaijan and safety for Nakhichevan. In this way, everybody would be equally unhappy (the successful statesman makes everybody equally unhappy to make sure things work, if one party is noticeably more unhappy than the other, that spells disaster). “I have to add that the return of the Armenians into Anatolia is a (using Edward Demian’s terminology) a primitive bluff from both sides, and it should be called off for the sake of not wasting precious time in our discussions. No Armenian is going to return to Anatolia even if by some crazy magic it becomes part of Armenia.” As I had stated earlier, I recognise the right of Armenians to return to their ancestral lands if they so wish, and if they do not so wish, have access to the financial wealth it produces. For me it is not a bluff, but their right. Having recognised that, I would leave the question of whether they would or would not return to Anatolia to the Armenians themselves. By the way, it is not true that no Armenian is ever going to return there, some already have: there has been at least one well-publicised marriage between a Turkish guy and an Armenian lady from Yerevan, they now live in Van, if I am not mistaken (the guy was Kurdish if I remember correctly). Also, the Armenian population of Turkey has shifted back and forth in the last three decades, many people who lived in Turkey long after the Genocide left the country during the Cyprus crisis and the coup of 1980, some of whom later returned. And several years ago Diaspora Armenians were trying to buy back their ancestral lands (houses etc.) from their present-day owners, upon which the state interfered and put an end to it (to my grief). Therefore, I would not exclude the possibility that some Armenians may choose to return to their ancestral lands. I can understand that most Armenians would choose not to, at least not in the foreseeable future, but if one day the region were the way Europe is now, then why not? There are many American Jews living and working in Germany now. But I agree with you that the “bluff” part of it is a waste of time and agree not to discuss it further. “Thanks for your understanding.” I understand, but reserve my right to disagree. Thanks for your understanding, too. I do not know of a single case where a state has ever accepted “the legitimacy” of claims on its territorial integrity on any grounds whatsoever. If there is one, please let me know, and with adequate detail, please. MJ, with all due respect, I have to point out a vital shortcoming that the Armenians on the whole (I allow for exceptions) appear to have, which was discussed by a very prominent and open-minded Turkish historian named Ýlber Ortaylý. I paraphrase with my own additions that I do not distinguish in print, so these comments are inspired by him rather than quoted verbatim: The Armenians have amassed, throughout their long history, a wealth of experience in many aspects of human life, such as arts & crafts, literature, music, and what not, but diplomacy, politics and statecraft are not amongst them, for obvious reasons. They had many prominent figures, but no statesman, politician, or diplomat on a world scale in a very long while, perhaps long before the Turkish conquest of Anatolia, since they were already largely partitioned between the Byzantine Empire to the West and the Persian Empire to the East. Statecraft, politics and diplomacy are human faculties like science, arts and technology, and the value of long-time uninterrupted experience in these areas is obvious, just as are the shortcomings in these areas that appear when a previously dependent nation suddenly finds itself in possession of a state. You could not expect the informed citizen of any nation seasoned in such matters to ask his neighbour to accept the legitimacy of any territorial claims that his country may advance on his, and expect to have any relations left, much less improve the existing ones. I have seen a number of comments by Armenians on the shortsightedness and low caliber of their politicians and statesmen in the last two centuries (the new one is too recent to comment upon), and at least partly blamed the disasters that befell the Armenian nation on them. In short, what they said was “they led us to disaster”, that is, if I understood them correctly. I had heard very similar comments from Cypriot Greeks about the fate of Cyprus in 1974, and I agree with them (I am also painfully aware of the way our low-caliber politicians led us to disaster in Cyprus, and not only in Cyprus). Do not forget that the worst enemies of the any nation can only be found amongst the members of that nation itself, for they alone have the capacity to guide their own nation into adventures and disaster. The Armenian nation has suffered so much more than its fair share of disasters that it should by now be able to distinguish between wise statecraft and foolish politicking. You have enormous tasks and problems facing you: Nagorno-Karabagh, your relations with Azerbaijan, with Turkey, with Russia, with Europe, with the USA, and the rest of the world, your infrastructure, economy, corruption, the exodus of Armenians from Armenia, the nuclear stations, environmental safety, and what not. You have just come into existence as a state after a millennium-long spell and a brief moment early in the last century. Throughout your postings I have got the impression that you are perhaps one of the most intelligent persons that contribute to the Hye Forum. In your previous contributions you have accurately shown the conflict areas, the causes for the polarity of positions and remedies therefore, but in this particular one you appear to have 1) contradicted yourself (look at your own two paragraphs that I have quoted and commented on above) and 2) (I must regretfully add) disappointed me as to your grasp of generally accepted basic principles of international politics and statecraft. I hope I have been clear enough. As stated before, I am ready to continue any dialogue on any topic other than my country’s territorial integrity, as I reckon we found ourselves in broad agreement on a number of really vital issues and principles. I am currently drafting another posting on my views on the future development of states, especially in our region. I shall expect your comments on it as I think it will answer a number of your questions, including the issue of territorial integrity. Regards,
-
thorny, it was perhaps only a "muslim" shepherd, but the version i had read said turkish, if i remember correctly. there was a very old turkish population in van, as there were some kurds outside. by the way, one should not forget (or at least try to learn) that a good part of the modern-day kurds of the region are not native to the place at all: there were large-scale voluntary or forced migrations during ottoman rule and before, and also, many turkish tribes became kurdish, peserving in some cases the language (some tribes have always been bilingual), some cases the original name in a corrupted form (like the "badýllý" of eastern anatolia - avery large tribe - were originally the "beg-dili", and part of the grey arrows (bozoklar) who were the avshar, the kýzýk, the beg dili, and the karkýn (or yarkýn). i don't have their ancestor's name in my mind, but this should be enough info. regards,
-
dear harut "alaverdi" means "god gave" in turkish. the most correct form would be "allahverdi", but some dialects from the eastern provinces and azebaijan pronounce "allah" as "ala" (so do little children in turkey). this is a very common name, and exists in numerous varieties in many languages. the name "baghdad" (iraqi capital) also means the same. so do the slavonic name "bogdan", the greek name "theodoros", and a good few others. i hope this helps. regards,
-
this is in reply to steve's (and perhaps others') remarks that the taliban practice true islam: at the time of the prophet muhammad (pbuh), women routinely participated in everyday life, including politics. later on, tere were some women who also participated in warfare (in addition to everthing else). like every religion, islam is also susceptible to be corrupted or interpreted in fashions by demagogues/fanatics/bloodthirsty murdereres and other assorted mental cases that clot the blood of the rest of humanity, solely to suit their own needs. islam did give rise to a great civilisation that was active and productive up to the sixteenth century. western civilisation owes a ton to islam, in areas as diverse as mathematics, medicine, the sciences, etc., even some religious practices (churchbells were introduced to christendom upon the inspiration of some saint (forgot his name) who was impressed with the five-times-a-day call to prayer in islamic countries while he was travelling through them. if true islam had been anything like that, it would not have been able to make such contributions, because it wouldn't have much of a following in the first place. tyranny does not survive long. look at the soviet union. regards,
-
edward we seem to find some points of convergence. i had thought it would have been obvious by my earlier postings that i was of course against there being second-class citizens of any race, creed, language or culture, not just armenians. and if some such thing ever happened (which as a world citizen is not utopia as many of us would think) then what problems would there be left with the armenians that many parts of the world, where such civility is already by and large reached don't have? of course it goes without saying that for this to ever happen the genocide issue must be resolved and the necessary reparations made (including the right to return to ancestral lands). i am pleased to hear that you have been in contact with turks, although not anatolian turks, and it was a peaceful coexistence. so you are perhaps not totally opposed to the idea that in some distant future, when both your descendants and mine will have changed a lot in their world view, there could be a peaceful coexistence. i took your posting to mean something like that, or not too distant from that, and if i was right, then i am happy. regards,
-
steve the distortion was not intended, and i myself was aware there was something funny about a member of clergy having a daughter. anyway, do the armenians originally from vann know anything about it? regards,
-
dear moderators today (18 sept 2001) the "on this day in history" section, which greets us when we come to the forum, referred to herodotus' book "anabassis". in fact, herodotus wrote "the histories" where he talked abou the armenians, too. "anabasis" (the correct spelling) was written by xenophon, a pupil of socrates and a friend of plato, relating the march of the greeks throughout anatolia into iran to sort out differences between them and the persians. regards,
-
i had heard in turkey - and read in at least one enhglish publication - the origin of the name "akhtamar". there was an armenian colony or convent on the island, and the daughter of the head of the convent was called tamara (tamar). she fell in love with a turkish shepherd from one of the villages on the shore. the shepherd used to visit her at nighttime for fear of the father by swimming across lake van, while she would hold a lantern to guide him to the shore. then the father discovered what was going on... he locked up the girl in the cloister, and went to the shore at night with a handful of men with lanterns in their hands. they lit the lanterns now here, then there, causing the poor shepherd to swim in every conceivable direction before he finally got exhausted and drowned. his last words were "akh tamara, akh tamara" as he was drowning. now i would believe this to be a fabrication by the turkish government, had i not heard it from the locals and read it in at least one english publication by an english lady called diana darke: guide to eastern turkey. perhaps steve could shed some light on it. regards,
-
mj, i cannot think of any muslim (including myself) who could make a better presentation of islam. congratulations. may we only wish that those unfortunates who are cheering at the grief of the world know half as much as you do on the religion they pretend to submit to. they should read "he who kills one innocent person kills the whole of humanity" over and over again, until they get the message. may i also add (i did not notice it in the texts above) that the one english translation that does justice to the message of the Qur'an is one by Mohammad Marmaduke Pickthall, an Englishman who became a Muslim. ıt is free of any sectarian differences of opinion, a thing that cannot be said of some of the other translations. many muslims (especially those with a working knowledge of judaism and christianity) tend to see the three religions as one and the same, that islam is essentially a universalised version of judaism (i.e. proselytising), and the only serious difference between islam and christianity being the doctrine of the Oneness of God versus the Trinity. i had heard that some sects of christianity do not recognise jesus as the son of god, and/or that they question/reject its divine nature. is this true, and if it is, could you give more info, please? regards,
-
harut, urartian (and its relation hurrian) are neither indo-european nor semitic. they are not that well understood, in fact, but what has been understood tells us that if they had any relatives, these must be the present day caucasian languages like georgian, cherkess, laz, mingrel, chechen, etc. they are a problem temselves when sorting out family ties. regards,
-
gamavor, my nation is currently going to war against these bastards together with you lot. and if you guys ever attempt to throw the anatolian turks out of the usa and western europe, they are far more likely to go to places like afghanistan than back to anatolia, where they will be a permanent problem for all of you. and judging by your past experience in vietnam, iran, iraq, palestine, and the russians' past experience in chechnya and afghanistan, they are more likely to prevail and you are more likely to fail. you want a war, we'll give you a war.
-
dear mj, i will have to respond in greater detail soetime this week since i hve to prepare it but the gist of it will be as follows: there is no way to get in the armeno-turkish impasse without dropping the land claims. guys like me are people you can talk to and reach common ground on genocide recognition, condemnation and reparation issues, as well as future turkish-armenian cooperation in the area (which is a necessity whether we like it or not, especially in the face of the recent attacks). but that does not mean that we are going to allow our country to be carved up simply because we want to improve realtions with the armenians. we recognise the armenian republic as it is today, territorially speaking (excl. the nagorno karabagh issue, which in any case is not settled yet). and we expect the same from the armenians. i am all for the return of the anatolian armenians back to their ancestral homelands and living in a multicultural society with vastly improved intercommunity relations. but i am not for saying goodbye to any part of my country. frankly speaking, i cannot understand how armenians are puzzled over it. how do you explain that more clearly than this? wait for my future posts. regards, ali suat
-
dear mj, let me tell you the one reason armenia and armenians should not have any land claims on turkey, "matter of factly", "legitimately", or otherwise: there is only one way to get between a turk and his land, and that is over his dead body. we will stop at nothing to defend what we consider to be ours. and we consider it to be ours not because we have been living there for so long or we are the majority or whatever, but simply because we give a blank cheque to anyone who questions it: if you can make the sacrifices we are prepared to make, and then still prevail, then the land is obviously yours for we are simply not there anymore. and of course, this is not impossible: other nations did it with what they had considered to be theirs, notably greece and the balkan countries. if you can, too, go ahead. this is why there is no point in discussing land claims. if you have a claim, then go get it. if you can't, then don't claim it. ask any citizen of a sovereign state and you will get the same answer. seriously, go pose as an american indian and tell the americans to get out of your ancestral lands (i don't mean patches of reservations, but huge chunks of the country that the americans took by ignoring treaties they themselves had drafted). go see what answer you get. and don't forget that the reservations (the so-called states) are not states but jokes. whic one is a viable entity, which one is sovereign, with its own standing army, flag, international boundaries, territorial waters, place in the united nations, embassies, etc? which one? the united kingdom is composed of england, scotland, wales (and northern ireland, which appears to be on the way to go) and the dependencies. has anyone ever head of a scottish or welsh embassy? army? currency? i am still open for dialogue as long as there are no land claims attached to it. regards,
-
edward demian, i see in parts of your last posting traces of a mind that is not entirely opposed to the idea that the two nations have an infinitesimal chance of not going into yet another war, and that the possibility of some sort of de-abnormalisation (i coined this term myself, i had to in view of your previous postings) of relations is a wee bit higher than the entire pig population of this planet taking to the skies in a day. if i am correct, please let me know, and if you are open to dialogue, let me know that, too. as for armenian origins: i have not intended to use the non-anatolian origin of the armenians to question their rights to live in the country they lived in for almost three thousand years. if we had used such criteria, there would be very few people left in the same place, and probablyno states (for instance, did you know that with the exception of basque, all extant european languages are not native to europe? there was probably not a single germanic-speaker in germany prior to 2000 BC.) but i have as much right to live in this country as everyone else. in all probability i have vastly more anatolian blood in my veins than central asian, my culture is anatolian, the name of my town, from which my surname, my vey identity, comes, is hittite (from ur-kup, which became procopius in greek and then ürgüp), and if a genetic mapping of anatolia were made, all these guys who had been at eachother's throats would turn out to be cousins. "deine zauber binden wieder was die mode streng geteilt" this is an excerpt from the official anthem of the european union, the civilisation that you say you belong. think about it. regards,
