-
Posts
1,641 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Events
Gallery
Everything posted by bellthecat
-
Thanks. It seems to have just the sort of content that I was hoping for. If other can add to or improve on the translation then please try (no disrespect to Teutonic Knight intended - the more people that work on a translation the more accurate it will be). Would Karin really be Erzurum I wonder, since that was in Turkish territory (and Ani was in Russian territory at that time)?
-
Is this Armenian writing readable, and if it is would someone like to have a go at translating it into English? It is a piece of tourist graffiti from 1903 written on a wall of a church at Ani, and it might be interesting if it gives an insight into what people 100 years ago were thinking when they visited the ruins of Ani. There are lots of other similar examples inside the same church (I'll post some more of them later maybe), but this is the one with the clearest writing. http://mysite.wanadoo-members.co.uk/virtualani/inscription1b.jpg
-
In the end I didn't have any problems. I used the "maxblast" software from Maxtor's website to copy everything on the old C:drive (a tiny 4GB thing) onto the now empty D: drive - then took out the C and replaced it with the D, and then put the new 160GB drive in as D.
-
The above is a review of an article in Armenian Forum, Volume 2 Number 4. Does anyone here has a copy of that issue? Also on their website: From the Editors (Volume 2, Number 4) A group of academics and polemicists in Yerevan are trying to enforce orthodoxy in Armenian history writing by branding as traitors and foreign agents historians with whose published findings they disagree. They advocate the proposition that scholars of Armenian descent have an obligation to reach conclusions that would make Armenians proud. In December 2001 the Armenian history department at the Yerevan State University Faculty of History adopted this group’s position by voting in favor of a Soviet-style resolution that goes so far as to name names (see pp. 36–37 n. 97 of this issue for excerpts). The resolution stands as an unequivocal announcement that the work of scholars from Yerevan State cannot be credible, for they would suppress any evidence that did not lead to certain preordained conclusions. At a meeting with Armenian Forum editor Vincent Lima in February 2002, the dean of the Faculty of History, Babken Harutiunian, disavowed the resolution, adding that it was adopted without his knowledge while he was abroad. It seems especially important to recognize that the people who pushed the resolution through do not speak for all their colleagues, and to continue to seek out and engage serious scholars trained and based in Yerevan—of which there are many. Indeed, we are pleased to include in this issue the work of two such scholars. At the center of this movement to enforce orthodoxy is a 1998 book by Armen Ayvazian, billed as a scholarly critique of the United States "school" of Armenian studies. Sebouh Aslanian, an advanced graduate student at Columbia University, examines the book in great detail. Aslanian agrees with Ayvazian that the work product of the Armenian-studies establishment in the United States requires a thorough scholarly critique. He finds, however, that Ayvazian has failed to produce anything more than a crude polemic.
-
About Armen Aivazian: Historians Clash on Scholars' Role Essay in Armenian Forum Reviews the Debate www.gomidas.org/forum/af8clash.htm Princeton, NJ (28 February 2003)—The Armenian history department of Yerevan State University shocked public opinion in the Armenian diaspora with a proclamation issued in December 2001. It claimed that Armenian-American historians “openly distorted and falsified many important issues” in Armenian history, and that many of them were in the service of Turkish-Azerbaijani revisionism. The proclamation endorsed a 1998 book in which the Yerevan-based scholar Armen Ayvazian charges his Armenian-American colleagues with treason. In an important new essay, Sebouh Aslanian of Columbia University engages in a careful and detailed critique of Ayvazian’s book. Aslanian’s 38-page essay, “‘The Treason of the Intellectuals’: Reflections on the Uses of Revisionism and Nationalism in Armenian Historiography,” appears in the current issue of Armenian Forum: A Journal of Contemporary Affairs. Aslanian reports that Ayvazian’s book consists of two sections. The first assails Ronald Suny’s Looking toward Ararat: Armenia in Modern History, which is “one of the most widely read works on Armenian history published in the West.” The second section explores Western scholarship on the origins of the Armenian people and the status of classical Armenian texts. The targets of this section include Robert Thomson, Nina Garsoïan, James Russell, Levon Avdoyan, George Bournoutian, Robert Hewsen, Peter Cowe, and John Greppin. Aslanian considers Ayvazian’s book “a symptomatic text of a new ethos surrounding nationalist history in Armenia.” The role of historians in this ethos is “to generate and maintain national identity” and “to defend the security interests of the state.” Ethnogenesis In this ethos, historians are expected to give only politically acceptable answers to scholarly questions. One’s view on the origins of the Armenian people, for example, is “the ultimate litmus test of loyalties. Scholarly considerations (such as truth) are blithely shunted aside,” Aslanian writes. According to Aslanian, most historians who deal with this question in the West agree that the origins of Armenians are “clouded in obscurity.” They say the best evidence, however, indicates that Armenians probably emerged from the convergence of native and immigrant populations in the Armenian Plateau between the twelfth and sixth centuries B.C. Ayvazian’s book, on the other hand, insists that Armenians are racially pure descendants of natives of Armenia. He goes so far as to cite craniological evidence in support of his position. Ayvazian is not content, however, to treat this matter as a question of evidence and scholarship. For him, the so-called immigrationist position weakens Armenian claims to Armenia. Armenian historians who take the position must be doing the bidding of “Turkey’s NATO ally, the United States,” or else they are dupes. Aslanian, in his review, characterizes this approach as the “blackmail of revisionism”—an attempt to intimidate historians with whose findings one disagrees. Nonetheless, Aslanian carefully considers the evidence offered in Ayvazian’s book. Overall, Aslanian agrees with Ayvazian that the work product of the Armenian-studies establishment in the United States requires a thorough scholarly critique. He is thus disappointed that Ayvazian’s book “consistently misrepresents the views of the author’s adversaries, often by deliberately distorting passages out of their context. Its inflammatory rhetoric and sweeping denunciation, based not so much on scholarly criteria as on political ones, actually prevents the author from critically engaging with some of the real academic shortcomings of Armenian studies in the West.” The Faculty Weighs In Ayvazian’s book would be readily dismissed as a crude polemic, were it not for the reception it has received in Armenia. Even the venerable journal of the Academy of Sciences, Patma-Banasirakan Handes, has given the book a glowing review. The proclamation of the Armenian history faculty at Yerevan State University, mentioned above, takes the matter a step further. It attacks scholars who do not speak out in favor of Ayvazian’s views for their “neutral stance.” Referring to the Yerevan State University proclamation, an editors’ introduction in Armenian Forum observes: “The resolution stands as an unequivocal announcement that the work of scholars from Yerevan State cannot be credible, for they would suppress any evidence that did not lead to certain preordained conclusions. “At a meeting with Armenian Forum editor Vincent Lima in February 2002, the dean of the Faculty of History, Babken Harutiunian, disavowed the resolution, adding that it was adopted without his knowledge while he was abroad. It seems especially important to recognize that the people who pushed the resolution through do not speak for all their colleagues, and to continue to seek out and engage serious scholars trained and based in Yerevan—of which there are many. Indeed, we are pleased to include in this issue the work of two such scholars.”
-
They are Armenian Catholics, I think. Don't know if they sold - but I have not seen them again so they probably did! They were not too expensive, if I remember rightly, about 20 dollars each. But their condition is not that great - they have lots of mouldy rust marks - so maybe even 20 dollars each was too much.
-
Its more like the thread lost its relevance as the postings went on. The Church says that it has the right, and the sole right. By "Church" I mean an organised community of believers who have sat down and given some deep thought about what they actually believe and why. Follow that thinking and actually you are no better than our own self-proclaimed little god Thoth. You leave the door open to every fanatic, charlatan, or weirdo to invent his own religion or parasitically leech off a pre-existing one.
-
Exactly. This silly "theory" has almost certainly arose out of the neo-fascistic regime and ethos that exists in Croatia today. It's similar to the sort of nonsence we see coming out of societies like Azerbaijan.
-
Hmmmm, actually, it is his wife who should be asking that question to Thoth. But I don't see the point in any such questions in this thread. Nor do I see a point to the whole thread. Christian Churches from almost year zero have been trying to define exactly what it is to be a Christian, and who is and is not a Christian, and have in most cases come up with a quite specific set of conditions and beliefs that must be followed.
-
If the disks were formatted on another disk drive, and that drive was slightly out of the standard alignment then you may not be able to read your disks on a different disk drive. The same might happen if the drive you are trying to use is out of the standard alignment. Or if the drive head is all clogged up with a layer of dust or smoke deposit (how grubby is your keyboard - the floppy drive could be equally as grubby inside!). Also, the magnetic patterns that are laid down on the surface of the disk will decay over time, so if you are not using those disks for years then you might find any data on them is unreadable.
-
Hmmm, if only it were true.
-
Windows98 - haven't seen the need to upgrade yet. But the new hard disk I have, 160gb, is only useable as a 138gb disk because of this (though I think that only the very latest version of windows XP can use disks bigger than 138). So maybe the time has come. Vava, what with all the drivers and programs I'd have to to re-install (and dig out all the paswords and installation keys), it would probably have taken hours more!
-
In the end copied everything from the D: drive onto cd-roms, then erased it all so I could just make a mirror copy of everything on the old C: drive. But the new udma66 ide cable is shorter than the old slow version of the cable - so, to reach the drive, I had to use a 3.5 inch bay that was previously occupied by the floppy drive, and so will have to get an adaptor to fit the floppy drive in a 5 1/4 bay (if they still make such things). You think fitting an upgrade will take an hour at most, but it ends up taking all evening.
-
Yes ... the technical term for those stairs is "two planks of wood"
-
I don't really know. You tell me. Apart from a sort of obsesion with "hygene" that has no real validity you haven't really explained yourself. I suppose yet another camp could be one of those that get some sort of of sexual fetish out of it (but I'm not saying that you are in that camp!). I've just thought of a cast-iron way of forever excluding Turkey from the EU. Europe simply has to ban all childhood circumcision. (Those mullahs in Turkey like messing around with boys penises so much that they would probably put your average Catholic priest to shame! )
-
I've got a program called "Ghost" that came with my motherboard (sorry, mainboard for you PC obsessed Americans ). But I've never used it and thought it was just to make backups and clones. I can't just clone the C: disk because I already have lots of stuff on my D: disk. Disk D: is going to be the new C: since I have a new disk to replace the D: disk.
-
Or maybe it was because he, and his work, get exactly the "respect" they deserve? Perhaps he should try studying in Turkey. There, their "professor-doctors" all look favourably on careers dedicated to churning out history as propaganda.
-
There is no defense, and I suspect that those that condone this practice will fall into one or more of three camps. 1. Those that have inflicted it on their children, and cannot admit to themselves that what they did was wrong because admitting it would amount to them admitting to child abuse. 2. Those that have had it inflicted on themselves as a child, but still support the practice because they do not wish to think of themselves (or be thought of) as "less" than those who are still "intact". 3. Those who, sheep-like, always unquestioningly accept and follow the traditional opinions and practices of their family or society, and have learned all their beliefs and actions from that family or society.
-
I once knew how to do this, but have forgotten since it has been ages since I've done it. How do you copy all the operating system, including hidden files, etc, from one hard disk (my current c: drive) onto another bigger hard disk (my current D: drive, which I wish to make my new C: drive)? When I just copy the files the process stops when it reaches a file named win386, which a dialog box then says is in use and can't be copied. And I've got a strange file named ffastunT.ffx, 107mb in size, in my root directory. Any idea what it is. Steve
-
Who? Me? What? Why? The only "galaxies" book title I know of is Douglas Adams's "Hitchhikers guide to ..." books. But that was from the 1980s, so isn't "last decade" (and is only one galaxy! )
-
Ahhh .. but she would make up for that by moaning 3 thousand times a day about how they never put the toilet seat back down. But houses do not have that many "corners" (attics, basements, garden sheds, etc) for men to individually retire to. With women, they can all be stuffed together out of the way in the kitchen!
-
"Archivate" ?? Translate Translativate
-
And in his few spare moments, as well as making rose-tinted spectacles for his fans, he likes to walk on water.
-
Domino has scanned the original issue of it into a Word file (at least I think he has - well, someone has, since I have a copy of the scan!). NB, ignore the silly gomitas-speak blurb. Nogales was not anti-Armenian, he was pro-Nogales.
-
I'm sure that Ara would be rather disapointed if everyone agreed with him! In fact, I think getting disagreement is his main source of satisfaction.
