-
Posts
1,641 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Events
Gallery
Everything posted by bellthecat
-
quote:Originally posted by Domino: Steve and, and, and ? I am waiting that you write about it. Give me time, it is not exactly something I am going to read for pleasure Steve
-
quote:Originally posted by Hmayk: Mostly I liked your 2nd tukish proverb. What a shot! Very strategic! The correct translation of the proverb is more like "a house is only finished being built when its owner dies" ...a rather different meaning from the one Hmayk seems to think.
-
There was a CD on sale in Ankara (ministry of culture shop) for 12 dollars, I wonder if this is the same one? (I had better things to do with 12 dollars than buy it). The on-line stuff looks like the same old regurgitated rubbish.
-
MosJan - go and read at least one accurate history book! MJ - sorry, I have no idea of which issue of agos is referred to. I found the article I quoted from on (shudder, as I say the words) AOL's Armenia message board (yeuch ...a glass of water please), so you cannot expect things like accurate references! The film was posted to the developers today - back by the weekend, I hope. Steve
-
"If you were to ask me why I go on writing, my answer would be..." - LOL. What is the point of asking Ara anything, given that he never replies to anyones comments or makes any contribution to the forum other than here? Steve
-
quote:Originally posted by Kazza: Well Steve, I hope you didn't think I was contradicting what you said.. I suppose in a way I was because I read somewhere that her feet were NOT nailed together. From a paltry web-page! But I suppose It's always best to have first hand information because you know how full of it the Internet can be. I don't know if you ever did go to that exhibition in lOndon you were telling me of a few months back. If so, what did you see? But why would someone comment on a grave and say the feet were not nailed together! (unless there was an historical tradition that she was buried that way - and the excavation of the grave proved she was not). In a day or so it just happens that I am meeting with the Americans who produced the notes in which I got the info from - so I will ask them where they got their facts from. Queen Katranideh does seem to have been an interesting and powerful person in her own right - although most of the inscriptions mention her in association with her husband, she was actually from a family that was older and had greater historical status than the Bagratids. I suppose that commenting on her dedication to God was the highest praise a medieval writer could bestow on someone - but that is not a reason why modern writers should just continue with the stereotyping! Re: the London "Treasures from the Ark" exhibition, I found the exhibits fascinating, but the exhibition full of descriptive and historical errors - I was going to write about it, but thought that it would just annoy people (people I might want assistance from at some time!), and the exhibition was finishing soon anyway. So I kept my mouth shut (which, if you knew me, you would know is a really hard thing for me to do ) Steve
-
quote:Originally posted by Kazza: hhm..that's unusual.. I never heard of that.. I guess you learn something new each day. I guess they want/need to do this because of the political movement through the net.. Banning whole sections of the net, LOL! I wonder how they manage it? Is it almost like a firewall? [ July 08, 2001: Message edited by: Kazza ] Germany has banned, and continues to ban, access to 1000s of sites. And only a couple of months ago France banned all auction sites, and search engines like yahoo, because of their new fascistic "anti-Fascist" laws. In the US - access is often restricted in public access internet places (like libraries) by the authorities insisting that you pay for a supervisor to watch you. How true is the observation that those who shout most about being oppressed, are the most likely to become oppressors when they get the chance. Steve
-
It is surprising how often this subject comes up, and how nothing seems to been learned from all the stuff that is said on all the previous ooccasions that it has come up! No, there are not 2 million, there are about 50,000 - maybe less. No, there are none in Armenia, or Georgia (probably - but maybe some in Abkazia). No, they did not convert to Islam to avoid the massacres - they did it many centuries before that. And I bet the last thing they want is to have contact with Armenians who want to "to reach out to them and show them back to the way of God and Hayastan". Steve
-
quote:Originally posted by Mesrob: Thorny in all sincerity - Are you a wannabe? If you want to respond in inuendos, than just forget it. What's he on about? I will probably have some new photos of the quarry by the end of the week. Steve
-
quote:Originally posted by Kazza: Steve, just a q..is this Marr's account the ONLY account of the excavations? If any event wasn't included in there, does that mean it did not happen? Also, where did you hear this from? The book by Marr summarising his excavations is the only accessible account - he also published yearly accounts in Russian archaeological periodicals of the time - but these are not accessible unless you live in Russia, have access to a big library, and speak Russian! (I loose on all three). I got the Queen Katranide info from notes on a US photo exhibition on Armenian architecture - but I think the info originally came from the Armenian Queens book I mentioned. Steve
-
I just saw this, it is part of a story on the Agos magazine, by Tatoul Hagopian, Istanbul. It starts: "It is already seven years that Turkish-language (with two pages in Armenian) Agos weekly is being published in Istanbul. In contrary to two Armenian-language dailies published in Istanbul- Jamanak and Marmara, Agos pursues a goal to somehow tie Istanbul-Armenians with those Armenians who don't speak Armenian. We met Agos editor-in-chief Hrant Dink in the editorial office of the newspaper". At the very end of the story is the following: Q: People say that Turkey also carried out a cultural genocide, hundreds of Armenian cultural monuments were destroyed in Turkey. Does Agos write about it? A: Here is the last issue of our paper, where I wrote how Ani's walls were destroyed when quarries were being exploded in Armenia. Turkish press wrote about it. I wrote that "do Turks have a right to speak, did they make any effort for preserving any Armenian Church in their territory, didn't they close their eyes when the churches were turning into ruins?" Steve
-
ARMENIANS OF AKHALKALAKI PROTEST AGAINST LIQUIDATION OF THE
bellthecat replied to MosJan's topic in National
quote:Originally posted by MJ: Who is the author of that book, Steve? I don't know the author's name, but it is a publication by "Research on Armenian Architecture" I don't own a copy - but have looked at one. It is a big, hardback book, about 200 pages long. Steve -
ARMENIANS OF AKHALKALAKI PROTEST AGAINST LIQUIDATION OF THE
bellthecat replied to MosJan's topic in National
quote:Originally posted by Aaron: MJ I don't agree, as you said, that the bad conditions armenians are living in are the result only of Georgia's difficult present day situation, I believe that there is a certain carelessness towards armenians (perhaps intentional) in Georgian politicians in general. I said that this could be arguable, and if we had argued i would have expressed my opinion clearly. I'm not saying georgians (not the politicians) have evil intentions towards armenians but it is a fact that armenians live in worse conditions than the ordinary georgians. To help you change the word "careless" to something stronger, perhaps you should try and get hold of the book "The State Policy of Georgia and Monuments of Armenian Culture", published in 1998. It illustrates, with hundreds of shocking photos, the Georgian policy since the 1980s to destroy Armenian buildings, especially churches, or remove their Armenian identity by removing Armenian inscriptions, khatchkars, etc. Steve -
quote:Originally posted by Aghmug: Paul, Have you seen the Simpson's episode where Homer joins a Mason-esque group? Awesome. There's another thread on the Masons around here somewhere. Check that one out, too. Mike Yes - "the stone-cutters" episode, it is absolutely hilarious, especially the song they sing. On a more serious note, all the CUP "Young Turk" leaders during WW1 were Masons, and it is believed that the 1908 revolution in Turkey was esentially a Masonic plot. Steve
-
I did not actually say they were bullshit, I said that they are nothing special, and never really were anything special. (Kazza, or anyone else in Britain, do you remember a hilarious send up of them in some comedy show - I think it went something along the lines of their manager, who was also their former school teacher in real life, treating them all like spoilt little kids). As for "popularity" - so what, that is not the point. And "the twat with the hat" Bono may well amuse himself by getting involved in commercially safe humanitarian causes (I don't think we will ever see him rip up a photo of the Pope, for example), but again that is irrelevant to his musical creativity (or absence of). And about them being insufferable show-offs - remember the laughable "zoo TV". That shut you up! Steve
-
It is really nice to see you are back, Kazza. I have read that there is a book called "Queens of Armenia" by Haig Khachatrian. Published in Yerevan, in 1998. All the pictures of Vartan I have seen are invented (and rather silly) 19th century ones, dressed in the armour of medieval Europe. Aparently Queen Katranide of Ani, the woman responsible for the completion of the Ani cathedral, was buried with her feet nailed together to show that even after death she was dedicated to Christ. But maybe the story is fiction, because there is no mention of this discovery in Marr's account of the Ani excavations. Steve
-
quote:Originally posted by ara baliozian: the palestinians have been victimized by jews? and the jews have been victimized by the world for thousands of years. why be selective in our sympathies? Note the "?" after "the palestinians have been victimized by jews" Now that Ara's pockets seem to be full of Israeli shekels, he will soom be saying Armenian "genocide" rather than Armenian genocide, and perhaps at this moment is practicing to spell the word alleged. Steve
-
Sounds like you may have a buggy version of internet explorer, some of the early version 5s were like this, they did not release the memory when a new window was opened and then closed, so after a while you would run out of memory and your computer would freeze up. Try getting hold of another version and installing that. Steve
-
I received this recently - some of it is a bit of a distortion, but it is mostly all true. Steve Did you know that, now, Palestinian refugees make up the largest portion of the refugee population in the world? Did you know that the United States awards Israel $5 billion in aid each year, from the American tax dollars? Did you know that Israel blew up an American diplomatic facility in Egypt and attacked a U.S. ship in international waters, killing 33 and wounding 177 American sailors? Did you know that over 600 Palestinians have been killed within a nine month period? 76% were shot with live ammunition to the heads and upper body? Did you know that of this figure 34% were under the age of 18? An incomprehensible figure of 110 children have been killed? Did you know that the children shot to death had nothing to do with protests or throwing stones? Did you know that 45 Palestinian students were killed on their way home from school? Did you know that yearly US aid to Israel exceeds the aid the US grants to the whole African continent? Did you know that the Israeli Foreign Ministry pays two American public relations firms to promote Israel in America? Did you know that the second most powerful lobby in the United States, according to a recent Fortune magazine survey of Washington insiders, is the Israeli AIPAC (American Israeli Public Affairs Committee)? Did you know that four prime ministers of Israel (Begin, Shamir, Rabin, and Sharon) have taken part in either bomb attacks on civilians, massacres of civilians, or forced expulsions of civilians from their villages? Did you know that Palestinian Christians are considered the "living stones" of Christianity because they are the direct descendants of the disciples of Jesus Christ? Did you know that Palestinian license plates in Israel are color coded to distinguish Jews from non-Jews? Did you know that Jerusalem, both East and West, is considered by the entire world community, including the United States, to be occupied territory and NOT part of Israel? Did you know that Israel currently occupies territories of three sovereign nations (Lebanon, Syria, and Palestine) in defiance of United Nations Security Council resolutions? Did you know that Israel allots 85% of the water resources for Jews and the remaining 15% is divided among all Palestinian Christians and Muslims in the territories? For example in Hebron, 85% of the water is given to about 400 settlers, while 15% must be divided among Hebron's 120,000 Palestinians. Did you know that Israel is the only country in the Middle East that has nuclear weapons? Did you know that Israel is the only country in the Middle East that refuses to sign the nuclear non-proliferation treaty and bars international inspections from its sites? Did you know that Israel has for decades routinely sent assassins into other countries to kill its political enemies? Did you know that high-ranking military officers in the Israeli Defense Forces have admitted publicly that unarmed prisoners of war were executed? Did you know that IDF's web site is hosted by AT&T? Did you know that Israel refuses to prosecute its soldiers who have acknowledged executing prisoners of war? Did you know that 41 schools have been closed and unable to operate affected over 20,0000 students? Did you know that There has been damage to over 2700 buildings, 700 homes (180 completely demolished), 29 Mosques, 12 Churches, and 44 Water Wells? Did you know that over 25,000 olive and fruit trees have been uprooted, along with over 3,000 acres of land bulldozed? Did you know that daily losses of income have been estimated at over $12 Million a day? Did you know that Sharon's coalition government includes a party Molodet - which advocates expelling all Palestinians from the occupied territories? Did you know that Israel's settlement-building increased in the eight years since Oslo? Did you know that Israel once dedicated a postage stamp to a man who attacked a civilian bus and killed several people? We often hear of Ehud Barak's generosity about an alleged return of 95% of the Palestinian Occupied Territories. When Palestinians refused, they were blamed for "missing an opportunity." Did you know that the Palestinians have already accepted Israel's existence on 78% of what was Palestine? WELL, NOW YOU DO! WHAT WILL YOU DO ABOUT IT!? THE LEAST YOU CAN DO IS LET OTHERS KNOW
-
quote:Originally posted by MJ: Steve, I am far from implying that the explosions are not taking place and are rumors, and I am very concerned about them. However, I don't think that writing to a President that per testimony of Steve Bellthecat explosions are taking place around Ani ads a lot of weight in his eyes. At least the ellmentary professionalsim requires some supporting materials. I understand what you mean, MJ, but all the usual Armenian sources have been deliberately silent over the quarry because the situation does not fit with their stereotypical "Turkey and Ani - bad; Armenia and Ani - good" viewpoint. And because the study of Armenian culture is mainly in the hands of Armenians we will be hard pressed to find any other sources. But as I said before elsewhere - I don't think anything positive can be done anyway. However, getting hold of the original UNESCO complaint about the quarry is probably the only route to go for documentation - on how to get it I have no idea. Steve
-
Ara, it seems that everytime you get together something intelligent to say, to make amends you have to put together something of total rubbish like this offering! Lets rename the "culture forum" the "Ara`s soapbox forum" because it is getting to the stage that whenever I see the word culture I reach for the delete button. quote:Originally posted by ara baliozian:[QB]SPECULATION ************************ If we make the safe assumption that no one in his right mind would declare a war in order to lose it, we must also agree that when the Arabs declared war against the Jews shortly after World War II, they had every intention to win it; Start to understand more of history, Ara. Countries often declare war because they are put in untainable positions politically, morally, or ideologically. Considerations of defeat or victory have little or nothing to do with their decisions. quote:and one reason they entertained no doubt on that subject is that they were sure the Jews, unlike the Arabs (with their glorious imperial past and alliance with the Almighty Allah) were born losers –a bunch of Shylocks, Fagins, and skeletal survivors of Nazi concentration camps. You seem to want to attack one set of racist views held (according to you - and you alone I think) by Arabs by dishing out your own load of anti-arab racisim. quote:As for killer-Jews, like Cain (who slew Abel) David (who slew Goliath) and Samson (who slew Philistines with the jawbone of an ass) they were, literally as well as metaphorically, ancient history. There is no such thing as "metaphorical ancient history" Ara! The above persons are architypal characters, common to all cultures and specific to none. quote:I doubt very much if there was a single Arab in 1948 who said: "Gentlemen, let us not underestimate these Jews." So you personally asked everyone involved, have you? quote:And I suspect what drives the Palestinians to irrational extremes today is not their resentment of Jewish military victories but their rage with their own colossal blunder. What irrational extremes are you refering to? The desire to be like any other country perhaps? Steve
-
quote:Originally posted by MJ: I think at least having precise references on the reports on explosions would be good. Imagine how stupid our appeal would look, if it would turn out that it is based on rumors rather than facts. Since I have seen and heard the explosions and seen the damage caused over the last year, don`t worry about it just being rumours (worry about it being all true ). Steve
-
I hope for a nice 100% fatal plane crash that will rid the world and the airwaves of these geriatric show-offs that ran out of what little talent they had over a decade ago. Steve
-
quote:Originally posted by Thorny Rose: Speaking of magazines... National Geographic comes to mind. Wouldn't it be a hot story for them? I don't know how the wheels of the system turn, though, so I might be going wild at the moment. I can almost gurantee National Geographic will NOT be interested. They are a very Nationalistic American publication and thus will not do anything to upset an ally of America (Turkey)/ Although the quarry is not a Turkish creation they will look on anything with the words Turkey and Armenia in the same sentence as a taboo subject. Im sure there is a way of aproaching those people in Ankara whose url I gave you, perhaps just say you are planning a visit to Ani and want some information - Architects love to talk about their work! Steve
-
I have just bought a copy in Ankara of the first issue of the journal of the official Turkish backed "Institute For Armenian Research". It is in Turkish and English. I`ll have a read and tell you what is in it. Seems to be produced by some of the usual names - McCarthy / Simsir / etc. Steve
