-
Posts
1,641 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Events
Gallery
Everything posted by bellthecat
-
True Martin, but it IS a painting - and since Aivazovski could turn little waves into big stormy ones, I'm sure he could just as easily turn a small welcoming commitees into a big, ceremonial, red-carpeteted one :-) Actually, given that Byron went to Venice to escape attention, it is unlikely that he was well known enough there to have merited such a grand reception. Byron later wrote why his studies of Armenian didn't get quite as far advanced as he had hoped. To paraphrase, he wrote that although his Armenian tutors had stresed to him that Armenia was the original location of Paradise, he was more interested in finding that Paradise in the arms of the women of Venice! Steve
-
Get it right Edward! Correct lyrics are: The greatest thing You'll ever learn Is just to love And be loved in return. Travis Flowers In The Window When I first held you I was cold a melting snowman I was told but there was no one there to hold before I swore that I would be alone for ever more Wow look at you now flowers in the window it's such a lovely day and I'm glad you feel the same cos to stand up out in the crowd you are one in a million and i love you so let's watch the flowers grow there is no reason to feel bad but there are many seasons to feel sad glad mad it's just a bunch of feelings that we have to hold but I am here to help you with the load wow look at you now flowers in the window it's such a lovely day and I'm glad you feel the same cos to stand up out in the crowd you are one in a million and I love you so let's watch the flowers grow so now we're here and now is fine so far away from there and there is time time time to plant new seeds and watch them grow so there'll be flowers in the window when we go wow look at us now flowers in the window it's such a lovely day and i'm glad you feel the same cos to stand up out out in the crowd you are one in a million and I love you so let's watch the flowers grow oh wow look at you now flowers in the window it's such a lovely day and I'm glad you feel the same cos to stand up out in the crowd you are one in a million and I love you so let's watch the flowers grow let's watch the flowers grow
-
Here is Byron pictured arriving at St. Lazare monastery and getting the red carpet treatment from the monks there. It's from a painting by Ayvanovski, done in 1898 - long after the actual event, so I wonder if he was welcomed to the island in quite so grand a way. http://mysite.freeserve.com/virtualani/byron_venice.jpg
-
This was about 5 years ago, but I still remember it. In the dream I was walking down a street in Kars (town in eastern Turkey) and passed by a large, two floor, stone-built house from the Russian period. Built against the gable of the house was a big conservatory with a semicircular plan and a facade of tall windows set between thin, fluted columns. The conservatory was almost derelict, but the owner was busy re-roofing it and replacing all the old windows with new ones. "That will cost a lot" I comment. "Yes", he replies, "but it's OK because I've just won a lot of money in the lottery". "Which numbers did you use?" I ask him. He tells me 4 numbers, which I remembered when I woke up. The following week those 4 numbers were 4 of the 5 winning numbers in Britain's national lottery. But I didn't act on the dream and buy some tickets. :-( Even getting only the 4 numbers right would have won about 1500 dollars. Steve
-
Theoretically yes, since the children would die anyway if their parents died.
-
Uh!! - you started a single line of a song running through my head, but I couldn't remember anything else of it except "everybody wants somebody sometime". To get it out I had a look at www.lyricmania.com to try and find the song - but nothing is listed under that title. But, nearby, I did notice Leonard Cohen's "Everybody knows" Everybody knows that the dice are loaded Everybody rolls with their fingers crossed Everybody knows that the war is over Everybody knows the good guys lost Everybody knows the fight was fixed The poor stay poor, the rich get rich That's how it goes Everybody knows Everybody knows that the boat is leaking Everybody knows that the captain lied Everybody got this broken feeling Like their father or their dog just died Which lead me to the page for Leonard Cohen... And there are no letters in the mailbox and there are no grapes upon the vine, and there are no chocolates in the boxes anymore, and there are no diamonds in the mine. Now see what you have done, I hope you're happy! Coz I won't be if this prompts me to blow the dust off all my copies of LC's old albums and play them for the first time in about a decade! PS None of this helped find the song I was originally looking for. Then I realised that the line I was remembering wasn't "everybody wants somebody sometime" but "everybody's got to learn sometime". It's by a 1980s band named The Korgis EVERYBODY'S GOT TO LEARN SOMETIME Change your heart Look around you Change your heart It will astound you I need your loving like the sunshine And everybody's got to learn sometime Everybody's got to learn sometime Everybody's got to learn sometime Change your heart Look around you Change your heart It will astound you
-
The U.S. is already making a good job of dissolving boundaries - making the whole world united (against America) http://www.theonion.com/images/241/article1731.jpg
-
It's a silly, amateurish book, like something that would have been written 150 years ago by a third rate history student - OK, not a very academic critique I agree, but it does accurately sum up the book! And as soon as you read it you will agree. I got mine new from Barnes & Nobel for 8 dollars I think, about 6 or 7 years ago.
-
Ah, what would Thoth do to pass his idle hours if he were not able to dish out his large portions of advice so liberally! "In matters of matrimony or religion I never give any advice; because I would not have anybody's torments in this world or the next blamed on me." - Earl of Chesterfield, 1765
-
If people are in relationships only until they think it is time to trade in their partner for next years model then its not surprising that nothing lasts. People that are important to your life at one moment should not be disposed of like last years fashion accessory or like a novel once it has been read. OK, most relationships are not for ever, and maybe for most relationships that is a very good thing, but I think that to start off without thinking somewhere in your head that "this is it, this is the one" is a sad and rather limiting outlook to take. That said, I think most people still do go into relationships thinking that it is something that will last. The trouble arises when one or both of them doesn't put enough effort into actually making it last, and the thing dies not because of boredom but because of sheer neglect.
-
This "sleep paralysis" is the origin of the medieval sucubus / incubus legends that later developed into the vampire literature of the 19th century.
-
It's one of those books that should have gone straight from the printers to the shredders! I hope you didn't pay more than 5 dollars for it, you can buy a new copy for about 8.
-
Peple do not sing songs about the things they have plenty of, or about the things they do not value. I suspect that in Australia it is the former reason. Though I have not been to Australia, I have always got the impression that friendship was extremely important there. Anyone in Britain who hears the word "mate" will always think "Australia". And every Australian I have ever met I have found to be very charming and friendly. Maybe the money-grubbing, dog-eat-dog, personal-satisfaction-is-everything Australia you talk of is formed from the post 1970s imigrant influx that has more or less destroyed the more relaxed and friendly Australia created by the English/Scottish/Irish imigrants from earlier generations. Maybe the concept of having "mates" only survives in smaller towns now.
-
You are making statements that are based on some serious misunderstandings. You can make no certain assumptions about the actual identity of "Urartians" and "Armenians" based solely on language. Nobody knows what the bulk of the Urartian population spoke. Most of the known inscriptions deal with religious things, and say what little they say in a rather curt way. It is perfectly possble that the language used by the ordinary people was completely different from the written language used by the priests and rulling elite in their cuniform inscriptions. Urartuan society does seem to have been very stratified and its elite overly concerned with showy presentation. It may even be the case that those rulers were not actually of the same race as the bulk of the people they ruled over (rather like the Ptolemaic dynasty in Egypt were Greek, not Egyptian). Nor does anyone know what the "Armenians" mentioned by the Persians actually spoke. No examples of their language survives in written form. In fact, I've been told that no examples of Armenian survives in written form until the invention of the Armenian alphabet. Before that it was the Greek language (and not simply Armenian written using Greek letters) that was used in all literary correspondance within Armenia - i.e the language used for written communication was completely different from that spoken by the bulk of the Armenian population. The evidence that the Urartians were Armenians is simply one of common sense. I might have written this before in another post. Even after almost 1000 years of massacres and invasions the Armenians in Van region were still the majority population until 1915. In that light, the few hundred years between the end of Urartu and the first mention of Armenia is simply not enough time for the entire Urartian population to have vanished (going to who knows where) and to have been replaced by an entirely different population known as Armenians (coming for who knows where). Steve
-
Also, draught Effes is not any better than the canned variety, in my opinion. (though draught beer in Turkey is hard to find outside of magor cities - anywhere else pubs / bars (or whatever the Turks call then) are generally hidden away up alleys or in the upper floors of buildings. I did once read a review of a beer that was described as a "German smoked beer" - the reviewer said it was the worst beer he had ever tasted! Couldn't have been the beer I had!
-
I agree. The inconsistancy about the killing and eating of the children when there would be so many dead lying around is puzzling. Unless they had a taboo on eating human flesh that did not apply to their own children. But children are easily replaced, so I do not think that what you said about killing adults in preference to killing children is correct. Also confusing is the sequence of events, lack of specific dates. And I think there would have been more female survivors than she says. In fact, I would have though that women would have been more likely to have survived than men. But all that indicates to me that the thing does not seem to have been written for publication - if it were then these problem parts would have been tidied up. Though probably there has been some tidying up - since the author will not have been the person who typed the piece, and the English seems too perfect for it to have been a direct setting down of her words. So maybe the inconsistancies have resulted from an incomplete setting down of her story by someone who did not know about the events in detail.
-
Canned Efes is pi**water, but bottled Efes is very, very good. Does anyone know about "smoked beer" - I had a bottle of such stuff in Germany, don't know the particular brand. Must have been at least 10 years ago, but I still remember how amazing it tasted. But have never been able to find it or similar again. Steve
-
Hmmm, I think I would prefer to think that nobody is running the show! If that is not the case then what are the alternatives - that those in charge are so useless that they have created this mess by accident. Or worse - that those in charge (or those pulling the strings of those "in charge") have created this mess deliberately, according to some sort of master-plan. Steve
-
Yes I did, I think. Their progress beyond England in last year's world cup was far more to do with the luck of the draw that them having a greater skill at football than England. So the Turks are now way too overconfident, always a dangerous thing.
-
Rest will follow in a day or so (the actual travelling to Kaput part). Then maybe my Varagavank visit (though some judicial pruning may be needed there).
-
Huh - I was going to vote - but got message that I had already voted! It'll either be a nil-nil draw or (more likely) a win for England.
-
The Lost City of Handut (Part 1) Back in 1878, after the annexation of the district of Kars to the Russian Empire, the Armenian Church commissioned a report that would comprise an inventory of all the ruined Armenian churches, monasteries and other antiquities that were within the region. It was produced partly as a "wish-list" of properties the Church wanted to be returned to them. The actual report was not published until 1970, and a summary of it appeared in English in the 1980s, in the RAA microfiche collection of Armenian monuments. The report lists hundreds of sites, the vast majority of which are today probably destroyed. Though it is full of useful information it has never been given much attention, or been used to try and locate sites on the ground. One part of that English summary of the report had always caught my eye. "At a distance of three hours to the south west of Kagizman there were the ruins of a fortified city whose walls were still visible in 1878. To the south of this site there was a fortress. Both the city and the fortress were associated with a legendary and otherwise unknown king called Handut. At two hours distance to the south of this place there was a chapel". This was almost the only site in the report to be described as a "city". And there was a good chance that something would remain: churches are easy to destroy – cities are more difficult! So, what is there three hours to the south-west of Kagizman? Nobody knows because nobody seems to have ever gone there to find out! Today Kagizman is a small town in Kars region. Look at a map and you find that in a valley to the east of it there is a river called "Kaput", a name that seems obviously to be a variation on Handut. And, apart from a village called Kuloglu at the base of the valley, it is empty of settlements. Puzzling, since if the valley had once contained a city then why was there nothing much there now? But if there was a city there, what city could it have been? Some 25 km north west of Kagizman is a settlement called Gechivan. Tunckaya is its official new name. Today it is just a small village but the massive walls that still encircle it prove it to have been far more important in the past. In medieval times it was called Kechror, and was a small city. The French art historian Jean-Michel Thierry spent about a week here in the late 1960s, surveying the site. His visit there is still remembered by the older villages. When his report was published in 1971, he included a history of the site, and tried to identify it using medieval Armenian accounts. The identification of Gechivan with the medieval city of Kechror was easy, but taking its history further back was more problematic. Thierry, after considering the probable alternatives, concluded that Kechror was, in earlier centuries, called Artagers. Artagers is a city mention by Classical geographers like Strabo and Ptolemy, and in the 360s it was the setting for a siege and massacre of its population by a Persian army. The 13th century Armenian historian Vardan mentions Kechror. In his "Historical Compilation" he writes that "in those same days Carak’ar was taken by robbers at the command of Gharach, the emir of Kech’ror, who sold it to Kizil Aslan for much gold. He settled there pernicious men, who did not desist from shedding blood by day or by night, even killing the Christians who had been plunged in profound gloom by famine and by the foul stench of those killed earlier. They slaughtered 5 notable monks with painful wounds inflicted by knifes in the form of a cross in a jest". He continues, later, to say that in the Armenian year 631 that same Gharach "who had seized Carak’ar" became terror stricken after destroying a holy relic and "suddenly abandoning his home, Kech’ror and Uzt’ik, and the whole valley of the Araxes, he went with his wife and children to Dvin". In his "Atlas" Vardan also writes "and the fortress of Kaput, which is called Artagereic, here is the city of Kechror and the monastery of Carak’ar dug inside the rock where the tomb of Xc’atur Vardapet Kec’arac’ is located…." It is clear from Vardan’s words that Artagers and Kechror cannot have been the same place, and so Thierry's identification is wrong. I suggest that Carak’ar is the unidentified cave monastery above Puruta village, about 2 hours walk to the south of Gechivan, and that the city of Artagers is actually Kaput / Handut. Thierry knew about Vardan’s writing, so why was he so set on Gechivan being the site of Artagers? Mainly, it seems, because he had seen a picture of Kaput Kale that showed it to be a small castle, too small to be a city site. But he never visited Kaput and, as the neglected 1878 report shows, the castle and the city are actually two different sites! However, the identification of Kaput as Artagers wouldn't be conclusive until I actually visited the site! In 2002 I was in Kagizman with Thorny. Kaput was obviously on our things to see list, though we never actually got there! Also in that 1878 report was a mention of the "renowned monastery of Vardher". We did go there, finding its ruins exactly where the report said it was, at the end of a wild valley so remote that we were certainly the first non-locals to ever visit the place. That valley was immediately to the east of the Kaput valley, and the truck driver who took us there had heard of Kaput, though he had never been there. Yes, he confirmed, he had been told that there was a castle there, and also a ruined city. But it was so far up the valley that he considered it was going to be difficult to visit - more difficult even than Vardher. Given that, and that we had already spent 4 days in Kagizman in a really basic hotel, and that we didn't want to stay longer in the town and attract unwanted attention from suspicious authorities, we decided to give Kaput a miss. However, In 2003 we returned to Kagizman, in those before-Rasputin days.
-
Tales from Lostlandia Where is Lostlandia? You might know it as "Western Armenia" - though you have to be in eastern Turkey to be there! But "Western Armenia" is a 20th century concept, just like "Turkish Armenia" was a 19th century one. We are in the 21st century, so maybe it’s time for a new name. I've been to so many Armenian sites in Eastern Turkey that I’ve started to loose count of how many. However, to my embarrassment, I have recorded very little of those visits beyond taking photographs. I want to start to make amends. If this sort of stuff is of interest to people here, then please give me some feedback. But if it bores you rigid, then also say so! Steve
-
'Fraid so. In your heart you know it. :( The hard question to answer (and to ask) is whether too much has been lost for the remainder to survive. Was 1915-21 a mortal wound? :( A depressing thought to end (or start) the day. I'm going to bed.
