Stormig
Members-
Posts
3,730 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Events
Gallery
Everything posted by Stormig
-
This thread is about the row over "sex and science," not some stick-figures' taste in Stepford mop-heads.
-
Junior Women's Water Polo World Championships
Stormig replied to nairi's topic in Sports and Recreation
That was your cousin, right? -
I'd prefer a horse anytime.
-
Solaris, I bid you welcome.
-
I don't believe I am a CAH girl even if it is implied that I am, even if I've been "accused of" having a male brain, displayed greater physical prowess than most of my friends, or never played with Barbie dolls. But, for the record, for all the sexist messages I got, I've always been different because I've said "Screw that" to what didn't suit me, not because I've had anything "innately male"... I don't owe any of my achievements to being anything male to any degree or nature - I owe it to my strong individualism - which is why I've been immune to all the messages and been at times reproved for it. Strongly recommended to members of the same sex.
-
Mouse, if Quebecer cannot ignore you, it is for the same reason he can't ignore genocide denialists and engages with them, down to the pettiest site or forum - he always has to counter the BS no matter how hard he tries not to. That is in fact something I admire about him, because I always put the ease and comfort of my mind first and walk away from discussing matters with some scum. As for differences between the sexes, nobody denies that, but that is called "the genders' being different, not being the same" - it is not about equality. "Equality of sexes" does not exist in the domain of science. It exists in law which aims to regulate human interactions and relationships. I did not bang out the skull of my lecturer when he was discussing the factors that determine the performance of users with a certain user interface in my machine-information systems course, where gender was cited alongside age and others. To say the sexes are unequal does implicate that one should be "more than" and the other "less than." It does now with two genders as it would if there were three or more genders. What people like myself don't like is that the influence of social conditioning is integrated with that of our inborn differences. Social conditioning makes Stepford wives and it also makes contrasexuals. Why is it that the former have to be cherished as "natural, nice, motherly females" some jerks can't find pedestals high enough to place them on while fecal matter oozes out of their mouths 24/7, whilst the latter are looked down on? And that is the whole point of people like you - you set out with an agenda, starting out with the "we are different." Everyone knows that, boy. What do you want? A pat on the back? If cognitive experiments are carried out, it is for research, not for some jerks' chest-thumping and back-patting. So what is the whole point of the hours of writing you've just spent on this thread - to pass judgement under the guise of "discussing science" and "carrying out logic"? Puh-lease. If you're so good at it, just go back and do a science major for the sake of knowing a little more jargon, if you stand a chance against the establishment with that attitude, boo hoo. I suppose people who emit oral diarrhoea for the sake of "going against the grain" are not equal to those who are smarter in the way they handle their time and efforts while working on their degrees. Oh geez, what did I just say?
-
Yes, forget about opportunities for the Saudi women, they're such lazy bums and such lousy drivers!
-
And I'll express my appreciation by ordering a monument to you next to his... Then again maybe an approximation other than "next to"...
-
I suppose some people wouldn't mind that teens run around bare-foot as long as there come the babies - maybe in their eyes the U.S. needs soldiers.
-
Most of my current colleagues are ladies, and we tick like clockwork. And, no, I don't work for a women's magazine. Either way, the minority that males are consider themselves lucky. Point is, men try to look "cool" and maybe they are more outgoing indeed - but at the end of the day they'll have irreconcilable differences with whoever and would rather die than admit it. Pride. What can I say. Just because some men have problems with ladies doesn't mean ladies are confrontational, ya know. Of course, it depends on the professionalism - but that's another issue.
-
No, I haven't. I have been too busy observing what goes on inside the men's room.
-
This is today's - http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/artic...-2005Jan29.html Raise Your Hand If You're A Woman in Science . . . By Virginia Valian Sunday, January 30, 2005; Page B01 For the past two weeks, my e-mail in-box has overflowed with messages from women -- and some men -- about the hypotheses recently offered by Harvard President Lawrence H. Summers to explain the dearth of women in the academic sciences. One woman wrote, "It is not surprising that people are angry when they see such full-blown contemptuous arrogance." Others were shocked at his apparent insensitivity: Had he no concern for the female students and faculty in math and science at Harvard or other academic institutions? That's an important question. Although we can't do anything about Summers's method of calling for more research into whether women and men have innate differences when it comes to mathematics and science (he told an economics conference on Jan. 14 that he was trying to be provocative), we can address the resulting controversy. There is a wealth of data about men and women in science, about cognitive sex differences, about the effects of expectations on people's behavior, and about unintended misjudgments of women and men. Summers is not alone in his lack of awareness of the compelling evidence of the power of small differences in how we treat boys and girls, men and women. Yet those differences, I would argue, provide a better hypothesis than innate sex differences to explain the gap between the numbers of men and women in academic jobs in the sciences. Nor is Summers alone in being unaware of the large set of experiments showing that well-intentioned people, intelligent people, people who believe in a meritocracy -- people, in short, just like many successful college presidents -- consistently underrate women's abilities and overrate men's. The finding that emerges from the research, in experiment after experiment, is that bias is a problem not because it is deliberate, but because it is the outcome of assumptions of which we are not consciously aware. Take, for example, a study published last year by New York University professor Madeline Heilman and her colleagues. The researchers asked people to rate individual men and women who were described as holding the position of assistant vice president in an aircraft company. The evaluators' job was to rate how competent and likable the employees were. They were given background information about the person, the job and the company. In half the cases, the employee was described as about to have a performance review (his or her competence was thus unknown); in the other half, the person was described as having been a stellar performer. When the evaluators had received no information about how well the assistant VP was doing in the job, they rated the man as more competent than the woman, and rated them as equally likable. When the background information made clear that the person was extremely competent, evaluators rated the man and woman as equally competent. But both men and women rated the highly competent woman as much less likable than her male counterpart, and considerably more hostile. Thus, in evaluating a woman in a male-dominated field, both male and female observers see her as less competent than a similarly described man unless there is clear information that she is a top performer. And in that case, they see her as less likable than a comparable man. The result of the experiment by Heilman and colleagues is typical of other research: Both men and women give men the benefit of the competence doubt. Why do we do this? Because we're like Summers: We have conceptions -- what psychologists call "gender schemas" -- of what it means to be male or female. We tend to see males as capable of independent action, as doing things for a reason and as getting down to the business at hand. We tend to see females as nurturing, communal and expressive. So which person, man or woman, seems a better fit for the job of assistant VP in an aircraft company? One guess. You can expect similar results in other male-dominated fields -- such as the sciences. Although an abundance of research of this sort exists, it has not become part of our common understanding and thus has not yet redressed the imbalances between men and women in professional life. With that in mind, it's useful to look at the three challenges that Summers presented in his speech to men and women who think elite institutions need to move faster to increase the number of women on their faculties. His comments, as reported by those who heard them, highlight some of the most common and enduring misconceptions. Summers claimed, echoing the neoclassical economics view, that discrimination is too costly to institutions to last. Over the long haul -- perhaps a very long haul -- discrimination will wither away, this line of thinking goes. Here's the rub: Harvard has a $20 billion endowment. Thus Harvard -- and other rich schools -- can afford to neglect a lot of female and minority talent and have shown a willingness to do so. The problems women experience in getting promotion and tenure are exacerbated at high-prestige institutions, as is shown by "From Scarcity to Visibility," a book that examines gender differences in the sciences. The deep pockets of elite schools allow them to buy the services of a lot of very talented white men. They may be paying too much for those men, but they can afford it. Meanwhile, people at institutions with heavy teaching responsibilities, few resources and insufficient staff have neither the time nor the money to perform the scholarly research they were trained for and that might win them jobs at more prestigious institutions. Women are overrepresented at such underfunded institutions, where they cannot reach their full potential. So when Summers looks around, he will mistakenly think that he isn't missing anything: Where, he will say, are all those super-productive women that I'm supposedly not hiring? And he's right, in a way. Those potential stars are performing beneath their abilities -- just like their white male counterparts who aren't at elite schools. What society is losing out on isn't immediately apparent. Another point often raised is that women don't put in the hours, and Summers followed that line, too, when he suggested that women don't want to work 80-hour weeks. The implication was that women wouldn't wind up at, or stay at, a place like Harvard. The first assumption is that 80-hour workweeks are a necessary condition for intellectual creativity and excellence, for either men or women. That assumption has very little data going for it. The second assumption is that women who do put in 80-hour weeks receive the same rewards as men. That assumption has a lot of data going against it, as we have seen. By far the most provocative discussion inspired by Summers's comments is whether women may be innately inferior to men in math. Women do score lower, on average, than men on the standardized math tests that are part of the SAT and GRE (Graduate Record Examination). We already know, from research by sociologists Yu Xie of the University of Michigan and Kimberlee Shauman of the University of California (who were examining the reasons that women do -- and don't -- leave science), that the differences on math tests do not account for the gender gap in who chooses to major in science. The gender gap persists even when you take test scores into account. So in a sense the question is moot. We also know that the differences within each sex are far larger than the average difference between the sexes. And we know that sex differences in math are smaller than cross-national differences. One study, comparing the United States, Taiwan and Japan, found that Japanese girls in grammar school scored almost twice as high on certain tests as American boys and almost always scored distinctly higher. Maybe Asians are innately better at math. If so, following Summers's reasoning, Harvard should be preferentially hiring Asian women over American men. (We don't know what's behind the large cross-national differences -- although education is key -- and, as Americans, we're a little reluctant to think we're inferior.) In the meantime, we don't cultivate women who are strong in math. A study of seventh- and eighth-graders in the top 1 percent of math performers shows that the girls do not improve their scores over a four-year period to the same extent that boys do; nor do girls in that top pool continue in math and science at the same rate as boys. We cultivate and nurture mathematically inclined boys. And children -- like adults -- have a tendency to fulfill expectations. We expect boys to excel at math and treat them accordingly. Shouldn't we do the same for girls? There is one cognitive ability that appears to be linked to sex differences in hormones. It's called mental rotation: the ability to look at a picture of a three-dimensional block figure and imagine it rotated in space. Males are much better than females at this task (although, with practice, someone of either sex can improve), and that result appears to be related to testosterone level. Girls who have experienced excess androgen in utero show higher mental rotation scores than normal girls. That's the kind of evidence we need to demonstrate a hormonal connection. We don't have that evidence for math or other cognitive differences. Does mental rotation ability matter? Maybe for a couple of scientific fields, but on balance, differences in math abilities seem better accounted for by differences in what we expect of women and how we treat them. The National Science Foundation has recognized that the nation loses out if colleges and universities squander the talents of women faculty members. And if women are going to thrive in math and science, academia has to change. To speed that change, the NSF has awarded ADVANCE Institutional Transformation Awards to 19 schools, of which Hunter College, where I teach, is one. And there are already results from this ambitious new program: These schools are hiring more women, improving their promotion and tenure policies, and doing more to ensure that women have the resources to do their best work. Summers now says he was wrong to have spoken in a way that has sent an unintended signal of discouragement to talented women. He also has pledged $25 million to promote the hiring of women and minorities at Harvard. That message would have been a welcome addition to his comments at the Jan. 14 conference. The most important message, though, is that if we raise expectations of women in science -- and give them the resources they need -- they will make it to the top. Author's e-mail: gender.tutorial@hunter.cuny.edu Virginia Valian is a professor of psychology and linguistics at Hunter College and the CUNY Graduate Center in New York and the author of "Why So Slow? The Advancement of Women" (M.I.T. Press). © 2005 The Washington Post Company
-
I think AINA's review of Leitzinger is an over-reaction. I see nothing Assyrians should be upset about aside from a sentence like "Nowadays the Assyrian Christians of Northern Iraq declare they are Kurds." This may or may not be true and while I wouldn't know I wouldn't be surprised if they were to maintain a low profile among the Kurds of Northern Iraq. This could have been elaborated on. And Leitzinger didn't at all imply that Kurdish sentiments were farce - quite the contrary. This can be demonstrated here: And there do exist Christian Kurds, or have - Bibles in the Kurdish language, written with the Armenian alphabet, have been reputed to exist. If anything, AINA's response is demeaning of Kurds where Leitzinger's wasn't - all this talk of "coveting Assyrian women" and how many children a typical Kurdish family can have - give me a break.
-
Don't they pretty much all get desperate the older they get? Case in point - Sean Connery.
-
Arpa, very interesting article - I'd say almost tour-de-force. Still, though, I have a few questions. Why? What does that mean? Were they born or revived? What is being referred to here? Is this NKR being mentioned? I got such a laugh out of the following. Not to mention how the loser pledged allegiance to Turkey, "I love Turkey, I want to serve my country" to a camera first thing on his flight out of Kenya, and not to mention how supporters still regard him with reverence even today, instead of branding him a traitor outright! Romanticised - how true!
-
All this talk of intelligence and what makes another more intelligent - male vs. female, lefty vs. righty... I do stand by what I said, though - and it's not a scientifically established fact, just my own observation on "brightness"... That said, and although not related to science, I found these two interesting: I honestly didn't like it that it started out with "it is logical that"... However, the next is even more interesting. ("Journal of Men's Health"??? )
-
I liked "Shall We Dance?" with Richard Gere and Jennifer Lopez. Made me wanna try dancing again - and not start with the tango but more fun stuff. I went to watch it with a male friend - and we came out of the movie theatre dancing. I didn't like the crying demure on Jennifer Lopez's face - she had it on for most of the movie and it was cheesy. The part where she described the rumba to Gere was hot, tho. Did I mention he looks great in a suit?
-
Sevig, poignant as was meant to be. Actually, I’ve been anticipating the release of the Chronicles of Narnia films for sometime, so I’ve been recalling things a lot recently, and in the last book there was a sentence where the king or the unicorn said to the other, “We have lived too long,” to see what was coming about. I’m not talking doomsday here like they were. However, yes, the gutwrench I feel makes me wish I knew about less. With regard to organ donors, aren't we all aware of whole pig hearts being transplanted to humans? Or was that yet at inception stage? I'm not sure. I'm more worried about the sort of crap that can come out of the labs of a state like China. It’s one of the first cases, if not the first, to be cited in that article. Countries of the West can exercise some form of auto-control, with success to whatever extent - that one can be contested. However, not so with a country like China. This is the same state that conducts nuclear experiments in the Taklamakan desert with no concern for the environment or health of the resident minorities, engages in numerous human rights abuses in Tibet, shoves off communities for humongous gorge dams, inflates the population with the drive of one leader and then punishes the second child of couples with the decrees of another - whatever the leaders deem fit for the moment - most of it under-reported for us. I did not miss the Tiananmen Square Incidents - for there you touch upon not just the brutality of the administration for squishing protesting civilians with tanks but also civilians burning policemen alive and throwing them off bridges - next to not reported in the rest of the world, in incidence with the reputed American finger in those incidents. We out here are upset to see two people fighting in the streets while passers-by walk away and seldom intervene to break them up, with older people shaking their heads and murmuring, “What has become of this world?” Now compare that with what I heard someone tell they saw on a visit to China - two men going at their blows at each other, in the street, while passers-by stop and watch with smiles on their faces, like they're watching a cock or dog fight, which is disgusting enough in itself, while blood and teeth fly all over the place. What I'm trying to get at is, there ought to be an understanding of morals, ethics, quite different from ours out there, in ways that would defy much of our reasoning, even way down in the grassroots. Perhaps the most demonstrative example of this was when a few years ago they were copying software with no understanding or regard to copyrights and contracts and there was a whole uproar because it was so systemic and also because Bill Gates was upset. And, for all their animosity, I understand that the Japanese are much like the Chinese in those respects, too – Sevig, maybe you could share what you saw about that with us if anything corresponds. This is the same administration paranoid enough about its interests to fear archaeology in the desert and decapitate blond, blue-eyed mummies – National Geographic channel – and there seems to be next to no concern among the people themselves, as long as they can have their personal liberties, get plastic surgery done to widen their eyes, follow world trends in music and adapt, and have pre-marital relationships, going against the grain of their parents who were raised as nice communist asexuals. Too much change, too many concessions in some areas, while the core still isn’t healthy. Now imagine how they'd react to any figment of meddling in their labs. It's not like you can sanction them for carrying out nuclear activities or something. OK, so China is far away. But, for the life of me, if someone so much as unleashed a half-human creature frothing in the mouth in my neighbourhood, I’d go after them for giving me that scare in the first place. That, of course, assuming that such organisms can live, let alone be functional for “purposes”... On the whole, I’m not strictly against testing on animals, but, like it says in the article, it is possible to carry out simulations on computers. Both methods have their advantages and disadvantages, I’m led to believe – but I don’t really feel well about some of this engineered stuff. Just how much of it is necessary, to what extent, and after what point?
-
We have lived too long.
-
I can't comment on the severity of global warming or the Skeptical stuff at the moment. Hopefully later. However, I do have to admit that hearing the term "environmentalist" makes my skin crawl. I'm not talking about environmentalist as in the context of professional, moral environmental scientists... Mostly the "whistle-blowers," campaigners, those types. I'm familiar with some strains, local and/or connected to a greater circle, and they piss me off immensely as they rely on dooms-day speak to stir hysteria and become the centre of attention - without even going near any alternatives, suggestions. Very few mention their sterility. All that said, I'm all for cutting down on whatever need be to stop aiding global warming, among others. It may indeed be a natural trend as some argue. However, that doesn't give carte blanche for exacerbation.
-
Message: 2 Date: Mon, 24 Jan 2005 19:52:35 +0400 From: Armenian Patriarchate of Istanbul Subject: Armenian Patriarchate of Constantinople takes legal action to keep Melkonian Institute open PRESS RELEASE ARMENIAN PATRIARCHATE TR-34480 Kumkapi, Istanbul Tel: +90 (212) 517-0970 Fax: +90 (212) 516-4833 Divan@ArmenianPatriarchate.org ARMENIAN PATRIARCHATE TAKES LEGAL ACTION TO KEEP MELKONIAN INSTITUTE OPEN CONTACT: RAFFI ZINZALIAN 951-453-9917 On behalf of Melkonian alumni, around the world, the Patriarch of the Armenian Patriarchate of Turkey, Mesrob Mutafyan, as the original trustee of the Melkonian gift, filed a lawsuit on January 13, 2005, with the Superior Court of the State of California, against The Armenian General Benevolent Union seeking to continue the Institute as the premier Armenian educational facility in the world and enforce the terms of the Garabed Melkonian Trust. The suit will be prosecuted by MacCarley & Rosen, PLC of Los Angeles, California. Devoted alumni from around the world have banded together to oppose the closing of their beloved Melkonian Educational Institute, a treasure of Armenian culture and education in Nicosia, Cyprus. Using the proceeds of a large financial gift from Garabed Melkonian, a benefactor, the Armenian Patriarch of Constantinople, Zaven Der Yeghyayan, in 1923 established the Melkonian Educational Institute in Cyprus. It has nurtured three generations of Armenian teachers, educators, lawyers, doctors, poets, scientists, and leaders. Its location in Cyprus puts it at the crossroads of the Armenian culture-between the Armenia homeland and the millions of Armenians who have immigrated to Europe and the America's. In 1925, the Armenian Patriarch of Constantinople with Garabed Melkonian's concurrence thereafter conveyed the entire gift, including the Melkonian Educational Institute, in trust to the Armenian General Benevolent Union, with the express direction and expectation that the AGBU would maintain the Institute in Cyprus and continue to educate Armenian youth long into the future. The Melkonian School now educates over 200 students from throughout the world every year at its 40 acre campus in Nicosia. The AGBU has recently announced that the Melkonian Institute will be closed at the end of the 2005 school year. Melkonian graduates from around the world have united in vigorous opposition to any effort to sell off the School and to do injustice to Garabed Melkonian's vision and foresight. So far, individual calls to AGBU to retain the school have gone unanswered.
-
Cartoon Madness By Bruce Kluger, AlterNet. Posted January 26, 2005. Christian conservatives classically over-reached when they launched their amphibious assault on SpongeBob SquarePants – and harpooned themselves squarely in the foot. Spongebob gay?! As a spokesman for Nickelodeon commented: "It's a sponge, for crying out loud. He has no sexuality." It was the perfect gesture at the perfect time. On March 11, 2002 – six months after the world changed forever – the Disney Channel, Nickelodeon and PBS stations across the country simulcast a three-minute, 11-second music video in which more than 100 beloved children's characters – from Kermit the Frog and Winnie the Pooh to Barney and SpongeBob SquarePants – came together to perform a decidedly animated version of the '70s hit song "We Are Family." No fanfare preceded the broadcast, no money was made from it. Rather, the event – an unprecedented collaboration among broadcast giants and cartoon-and-felt TV stars – was intended solely as a message of healing in the wake of 9/11. The men behind the project – producers Nile Rodgers and Christopher Cerf – were clearly well-suited to their task. Rodgers, the renowned music impresario and co-founder of the group Chic, had written the disco anthem 22 years earlier for Sister Sledge; and Cerf (son of legendary Random House founder Bennett Cerf) had racked up a shelf full of Emmys for his work on Sesame Street and the popular literacy-preparedness program, Between the Lions." In other words, these were guys who clearly knew a thing or two about children, music and the magic of humanity. So positive was the feedback from the broadcast that the project instantly became the cornerstone of Rodgers' We Are Family Foundation, a non-profit organization that promotes diversity, understanding and multiculturalism. In March, a revised version of the video will resurface when it is sent to 61,000 U.S. elementary schools as part of a campaign designed to demonstrate to children "the importance of togetherness," while keeping an eye out for those who are "victims of intolerance." Message to the We Are Family Foundation: Consider yourself the latest victim. Last week, Christian conservatives launched an attack on the video, specifically targeting SpongeBob Sqaurepants, Nickelodeon's bright yellow superstar who for six years has captivated kids (and grownups) from his modest pineapple digs under the sea. The amphibious assault on Bob was led by Rev. James Dobson, founding blowhard of the über-conservative Focus on the Family organization. In what can only be described as an outright effort to become a cartoon himself, Dobson chose inaugural week to publicly finger the happy, hapless Sponge as the ringleader in what he deems a "pro-homosexual" agenda within our popular culture. What fueled Dobson's preposterous broadside is the fact that the We Are Family Foundation has posted a "tolerance pledge" on its web site that makes reference to respecting a person's "sexual identity" (along with his or her beliefs, culture and race). This clearly doesn't sit well with the Reverend, who insists that such an inclusion "crosses a moral line" – especially, it seems, in a music video that flaunts interspecies, puppet-cartoon miscegenation. "We see the video as an insidious means by which the organization is manipulating and potentially brainwashing kids," Dobson's press rep told a slack-jawed media last week. "It's a classic bait and switch." Quicker than you can say, I can't believe they're going after a cartoon sponge, Dobson's cronies in the holier-than-thou contingent weighed in on the underwater turbulence. "Tolerance" and "diversity" are part of a "coded language that is regularly used by the homosexual community," said a spokesman from the reliably over-caffeinated Family Research Council; while Donald Wildmon, chairman of the American Family Association and reigning Chicken Little of moral depravity, warned parents everywhere to be on the lookout for the sinful video making its way into their kids' classrooms. Short of a perverse aversion to seafood, why on earth would these men carry such an ample supply of venom for the Spongester? Perhaps it's because SpongeBob occasionally holds hands with Patrick, his starfish buddy, or that the show itself has reportedly become something of a fad among gay adults (sort of like an aquatic Judy Garland). Or maybe it's simply because the moral crusaders – buoyed by the turnout of the evangelical vote in November, and interpreting that as a mandate to go on the attack – have finally lost their minds. (As a dumbfounded spokesman for Nickelodeon aptly commented: "It's a sponge, for crying out loud. He has no sexuality.") Over the weekend, I called Rodgers at his home in New England to ask him about about the firestorm surrounding his project. He was holed up from the blizzard outdoors, while fielding nonstop calls from a fascinated national media. Genetically incapable of succumbing to negativity or hot-headed retaliation (the guy is genuinely sunnier than SpongeBob), Rodgers finally did admit to a certain sense of frustration over the brouhaha. "The only thing that gets me mad," he admitted, "is when someone has the chutzpah or audacity to speak on behalf of my organization – to make up their own interpretation of our efforts and then present those opinions as fact. "As much as I appreciate the support we're getting from all over," he added, "I think the one thing that's been missing from all the coverage is a discussion of the video itself, and how all of these organizations joined forces to create a spirit of unity. Naturally, kids don't understand – or even care about – all the behind-the-scenes work it took to get giant entertainment corporations to pull together like this. But they will see Barney and Kermit and, yes, SpongeBob, on the same screen together, and they'll immediately understand the message: that even though we're different, we're really all the same." When the dust – rather, seaweed – finally settled on last week's silly debacle, a few salient facts bubbled to the surface of the brine. As it turns out, the whackos who originally led the attack on the We Are Family Foundation had logged onto the wrong web site in their search for ammunition. Rather than boot up the Foundation's site – www.wearefamilyfoundation.org – they'd mistakenly gone to the home page of the similarly named We Are Family organization (www.waf.org), which is, indeed, a gay and lesbian resource site. But instead of fessing up to messing up – especially now that the media was running with (and laughing at) the story – the resourceful Christians doubled back onto the Foundation's site, found the tolerance pledge, and had the smoking sponge they needed. Never mind the fact that the pledge is a wholly separate entity on the site, and won't be part of the music video campaign. Those are just little details. And if there's one thing the Dobsons and Wildmons of the world hate, it's details. The only good thing to come of SpongeGate, of course, is that, in classic style, Dobson and company over-reached, and in the process of chumming for anti-gay outrage among Americans, wound up sinking their own dinghy. It's a small victory for the good guys, but a pretty darn sweet one just the same. Meanwhile, I can't help but wonder to myself what SpongeBob himself might say about the Bible-thumping band of bullies who briefly had him on their sonar. Good guy that he is, he'd probably rather dry up and float away than say anything negative. Mr. Krabs, however – Bob's cranky boss and proprietor of the Krusty Krab – might have this comment: "I smell the smelly smell of something that smells smelly." Bruce Kluger writes for National Public Radio, and is on the Board of Contributors for USA Today. http://www.alternet.org/mediaculture/21084/ http://www.alternet.org/images/managed/Story%20Image_thumb_spongebob.gif
-
More than 500 prisoners are still held at Guantanamo Bay. Picture: PA printer friendly email article After more than 1,000 days in jail, Guantanamo four fly back to Britain JAMES KIRKUP POLITICAL CORRESPONDENT Key points • Final group of British detainees return home from Guantanamo Bay • None of four was ever charged - despite nearly three years of detention • US may be sued for compensation Key quote "It is inhumane and degrading treatment. They have all been locked up for three years, and two have been in solitary confinement for most of that time. I have represented my clients for the best part of three years. But tonight is the first time I will get to meet and talk to them - unfortunately it will be in a police station." - Lawyer Louise Christian Story in full THE last four Britons held without trial in the United States prison camp at Guantanamo Bay flew home yesterday, a move that civil rights groups said raises the pressure on the UK government to release terror suspects jailed arbitrarily in this country. The freed men were still at a high-security police station in central London last night, but all are likely to walk free within days. Three London men - Feroz Abbasi, from Croydon; Martin Mubanga, from Wembley; and Richard Belmar, from St John’s Wood - and Moazzam Begg, from Birmingham, have each spent more than 1,000 days in the custody of the US or its allies. None has been charged with a criminal offence or been allowed to consult a lawyer during the detention. After landing at an RAF airbase to the west of London at about 5pm, the four were driven to the high-security Paddington Green police station in central London for questioning by anti-terrorism officers. There is every prospect that they will walk free, perhaps as early as today. The Metropolitan Police is understood to have concluded there is no evidence to warrant charges against any of the four, even though the US authorities held them in the Cuban camp for more than three years on suspicion of terrorism. It’s time that the US and UK governments ended policies relying on detention without trial and torture once and for all - Shami Chakrabarti, Liberty Five other British citizens released from Guantanamo Bay last year were, likewise, questioned and released on their return to the country. The UK government was tight-lipped about yesterday’s releases, but the Pentagon issued a statement saying Britain had "assured the US government that the detainees will not pose a continuing security threat to the US or its allies". Despite lengthy and, at times, tortuous negotiations between Britain and the US, the decisive factor in the men’s release was almost certainly not pressure from London but a growing acceptance in Washington that Guantanamo Bay has become a largely useless international embarrassment. Citizens of several other nations have been released recently and there is speculation that the whole facility could be wound up amid suggestions that interrogations there have yielded little useful intelligence. Until yesterday, the four Britons were among some 545 prisoners from 42 countries still held at Guantanamo Bay, most of them captured in Afghanistan and Pakistan in the wake of the attacks on New York and Washington on 11 September, 2001, and the war against the Taleban that followed. To date, 207 detainees have left the camp - 146 have been freed and 61 transferred to the custody of other governments. Abbasi, 24, was reportedly arrested by US forces in northern Afghanistan in December 2001. Belmar, 25, and Begg, 37, were said to have been arrested in Pakistan in February 2002, while Mubanga, 32, was detained in Zambia. Begg and Abbasi have been kept in solitary confinement for much of their time in Cuba, raising fears about their mental health. They were reportedly held in Camp Echo, a "prison within a prison", where they were denied the recreational facilities, joint prayer sessions and limited association with other inmates allowed to other detainees. Their return home came as an RAF C-17 transport plane touched down at RAF Northolt, having carried the four men with what officials called a "basic level of comfort." Doctors and British police officers had accompanied them on their flight. As the flight landed, Begg’s father, Azmat Begg, told BBC Radio "it is a nice thing I am watching ... I am a little bit nervous and emotional". Belmar’s sister, Jeanette, said she feared he would never be able to return to a normal life. "If he wants to start his life again, he will have that behind him - ‘Richard Belmar, Guantanamo Bay prisoner’," she said. British lawyers for the four are now considering legal action against the US to claim compensation for their ordeal. Louise Christian, one of the lawyers representing the men, criticised the British authorities for detaining the four on the their return to this country. "It is inhumane and degrading treatment," she said. "They have all been locked up for three years, and two have been in solitary confinement for most of that time. "I have represented my clients for the best part of three years. But tonight is the first time I will get to meet and talk to them - unfortunately it will be in a police station." Even as the four UK citizens were returning to this country, campaigners were stepping up their demands for the British government to end the detention without trial of 12 foreign nationals held at a London jail. The men, most of them from North Africa, are being held at Belmarsh, where several are said to have suffered similar mental harm as those released from Guantanamo. The 12 have been detained under the Terrorism Act, although the Law Lords ruled last month that their imprisonment without trial is illegal. So far, ministers have refused to act on that ruling, although the legislation allowing the detentions must be renewed by parliament in March. Civil liberties groups said the release of the four Britons should usher in the end of the terror laws that permit the Belmarsh detentions. "After three years, it’s time that the US and UK governments ended policies relying on detention without trial and torture once and for all," said Shami Chakrabarti, the director of Liberty. Her warning echoed a call earlier this week from the Law Society of England and Wales. Edward Nally, the society’s president, said that "indefinite imprisonment without charge or trial is totally unacceptable" and insisted that ministers must stop ignoring the Law Lords’ ruling. Delivery formats for "Scotsman.com News" [more info] http://news.scotsman.com/index.cfm?id=96112005
-
Amerikanskis of the 21st century "bring civilisation to the desert"... US occupation damages ancient sites at Babylon Imperialism and cultural vandalism in Iraq By Harvey Thompson 26 January 2005 Use this version to print | Send this link by email | Email the author US-led occupation forces in Iraq have inflicted widespread damage and severe contamination to the remains of the ancient city of Babylon, according to a British Museum-commissioned report released this month. Ignoring protests by archaeologists, US and Polish forces have used the world-renowned site as a military depot for the past two years. Dr John Curtis, curator of the British Museum’s Ancient Near East Department, found “substantial damage” at the site during an investigative visit to Babylon last month. An authority on Iraq’s many archaeological sites, Curtis has worked as an archaeologist in Iraq for decades, personally directing many excavations. US forces established the military camp at Babylon city—some 50 miles (80km) south of Baghdad—in April 2003, and damage was already visible when Curtis first visited part of the site in June of that year. The Pentagon contracted Kellogg, Brown and Root—a subsidiary of the Halliburton corporation, where US vice-president, Richard Cheney was chief executive officer before joining the Bush administration—to develop and maintain the site, which grew to a 150-hectare camp, housing 2,000 soldiers. The base was officially handed over to Polish forces in September 2003. Commenting on the decision to site the military base in Babylon, the British Museum report said, “This is tantamount to establishing a military camp around the Great Pyramid in Egypt or around Stonehenge in Britain.” Curtis returned to Iraq following the US-led invasion, when the British Museum led an international effort to assess the damage and losses resulting from the looting of the national museum in Baghdad. He returned last month at the invitation of the Iraqi authorities and inspected Babylon with a team of Iraqi archaeologists. However, he was still not able to inspect the entire site, as part of it is still fenced off and mined. Curtis therefore warns that his report “should not be seen as exhaustive, but is indicative of the types of damage caused.” The 14-page British Museum report, compiled during a site visit in December, includes maps and lists numerous examples of visible damage. The report details: * Damage to the dragons decorating the Ishtar Gate “caused ... by a person or persons trying to remove a decorated brick.” The report details 10 separate areas of damage to the molded brick reliefs. * Broken bricks inscribed with the name of Nebuchadnezzar lying in spoil heaps. At the “Warsaw Gate” two 20-metre long trenches have been dug here. “In the piles of spoil alongside the trenches there are many fragments of brick, some with inscriptions of Nebuchadnezzar,” the report says. One brick clearly has an inscription that reads: “Nebuchadnezzar, King of Babylon, who provides for Esagila and Ezadila, the eldest son of Nabopolassar, King of Babylon, am I.” * Original brick surface of the great processional route through the gate crushed by military vehicles. Two areas of sixth century BC brick pavement, part of the processional street, are exposed in this area. “In both cases the bricks are badly broken. This is thought to be the result of a heavy vehicle or vehicles driving over them. If this is so, it is likely that the bricks still covered by earth are similarly damaged.” * Fuel seeping from tanks into archaeological layers. * Acres of the site leveled, covered with imported gravel—which Curtis said would be impossible to remove without causing further damage—and sprayed with chemicals that are also seeping into the unexcavated buried deposits. * Thousands of tonnes of archaeological material used to fill sandbags and mesh crates. At one point, outside the base entrance nicknamed the “Reno Gate,” is a 200-metre stretch of road, lined with the mesh baskets “that have clearly been filled with deposits from the Babylon site, containing shards, bones, etc.” And equally damaging, when that practice stopped, thousands more tonnes of material imported from outside the site, contaminating it for archaeologists forever. * Trenches dug into the ziggurat, one of the distinctive stepped pyramids or Babylonian monuments that probably gave rise to the legend of the Tower of Babel. “Much pottery and many fragments of brick with cuneiform inscriptions of Nebuchadnezzar were observed in the bank of spoil” next to the trench. Other observations include: an old car park vastly expanded to make a helicopter landing zone and parking lot, all flattened and graveled; old tracks covered in new stones, now deeply rutted from heavy vehicles; large areas scooped out to a depth of two metres to fill the sand bags; and metal baskets and earth mounded up to protect six fuel depots, which also show evidence of leakage. The report also suggests that the most serious damage may be invisible. The contamination and disturbance of areas that have never been excavated may mean that many of Babylon’s secrets, including the site of the hanging gardens, will never be resolved. In concluding the report, Curtis says, “A full-scale international investigation should be launched into the damage done to the archaeological site of Babylon during its occupation by coalition forces.” Curtis has said it was not possible for him to determine when the damage took place and which forces did it but the chronology of the findings strongly suggest that the most of it occurred under the aegis of the US military. Although the coalition authorities have now formally handed over the base, a US military spokesman, Lieutenant Colonel Steven Boylan, recently told the BBC that the base, which now has around 6,000 troops under Polish command, is needed to “further defeat terrorists and insurgents.” Archaeological community outraged The damage has outraged the world archaeological community. Mike Pitts, editor of British Archaeology, wrote; “What were they thinking? In a war acknowledged to be more about politics and culture than territory, surely the significance of Babylon was not missed? Babylon the capital city of Hammurabi, of Nebuchadnezzar, of the hanging gardens described by Herodotus; Babylon the military powerhouse that ravaged its neighbours in the sixth and fifth centuries BC, yet also developed astronomy, science and art to extraordinary levels. Surely no one in the West was so ignorant at least not to ask: should we not be concerned? “...Turning the pages of Curtis’s report I see case after case where the document that would tell this story has been ripped apart. An area 50m by 200m close to the ancient Ninmah temple was flattened for a helipad, graveled and treated with petroleum to control the dust. All of these—leveling, introduction of foreign materials and contamination—are potentially destructive of archaeological remains, as are the many cuttings and trenches detailed, the heavy vehicle wheel ruts, the earthmoving and the fuel seepages. And this list—the report’s killer phrase—‘should not be seen as exhaustive, but ... indicative.’” Many prominent British archaeologists have an extensive knowledge of Iraq’s 10,000 archaeological sites. They catalogued the previous looting and destruction of Iraq’s antiquities under the very nose of indifferent US troops (See: “The looting of Baghdad’s museum and library—US government implicated in planned theft of Iraqi artistic treasures”). They also witnessed the destruction of the historic mosques of Fallujah last November. Thus, they summed up their reaction to the conduct of the US-led forces in Babylon as one of “anger, but not surprise.” Writing in the Guardian January 17, Dr Mike Heyworth, director of the Council for British Archaeology, said: “The extensive cultural vandalism of archaeological sites in Iraq by US-led forces is deeply depressing, but it comes as no surprise. Archaeological organisations on both sides of the Atlantic were warning British and American governments about these issues for months in advance of the conflict, and we have repeated our concerns many times since.” Prof. Geoffrey Wainwright, chairman of Wessex Archaeology, writing in the same issue, said: “We should be angry but not surprised at the destruction of Babylon. Despite the requirements of The Hague convention, aggressors throughout history have targeted the cultural treasures of occupied territories in order to undermine their opponents’ national esteem and sense of cultural identity. Nebuchadnezzar created a world wonder, which, 2,600 years later, is the heritage icon for the Iraqi state—past and future. It is also part of a precious global heritage, which belongs to us all. “We should feel outrage and contempt for the perpetrators whose actions have diminished our common inheritance. At the very least there should now be a proper inventory of the damage to Iraq’s heritage, conducted by an international coalition of concerned nations.” Tim Schadla Hall, reader in public archaeology at the Institute of Archaeology at University College London, commented, “In this case we see an international conflict in which the US has failed to take into account the requirements of the Hague convention ... to protect major archaeological sites—just another convention it seems happy to ignore.” Lord Redesdale, an archaeologist and head of the all-party parliamentary archaeological group, said: “Outrage is hardly the word, this is just dreadful. These are world sites. Not only is what the American forces are doing damaging the archaeology of Iraq, it’s actually damaging the cultural heritage of the whole world.” Dr Francis Deblauwe, an independent Mesopotamian archaeologist based in Kansas City, Missouri, who runs the 2003 Iraq War & Archaeology web site, dismissed Pentagon claims that it “worked with” local archaeologists on the construction of the base. “How on earth all this was allowed to happen, long after the fiasco with the National Museum in Baghdad, is beyond my comprehension,” said Deblauwe. “Any civil affairs officer worth his/her salt should have known immediately that leveling whole areas of an ancient archaeological site such as Babylon is just not done.” He went on to suggest the real relations between archaeologists and the US military: “My guess is that their protests were summarily brushed aside once the wheels of the military machine came into motion. It seems the infrastructure necessary for modern hi-tech warfare was installed and provided for without much—if any—regard for the exceptionally sensitive and unique setting. Furthermore, the constant traffic of heavy trucks and machinery wreaks havoc on the archaeological deposits right underneath the surface. “Due to security concerns, Iraqi experts were shut out, especially the people from the State Board of Antiquities and Heritage (SBAH), whom the coalition military probably saw as Ba’athist holdovers.” By-product of a predatory war The irreparable damage done to the ancient sites of Babylon is a criminal act whose historical precedent is to be found in the Nazis’ looting of art treasures and destruction of famous monuments throughout Europe during World War II. The decision to base a military depot in one of the most important archaeological sites in the world can only have been issued from a deeply reactionary and reckless power that is utterly hostile to the cultural achievements of mankind. The damage done to Babylon has seriously impaired the prospect of further understanding an ancient civilisation of world importance, and has curtailed the ability of future generations to study and wonder at the historic sites. Despite attempts to pass off the vandalism of the sites as the folly of individual troops, this level of cultural and social philistinism has definite political roots. It is the logical by-product of a predatory war and occupation launched by subterfuge, which had as its main goal the seizure of Iraq’s oil resources. In the process, the Iraqi people have been subjugated to military rule and the country’s historical and artistic heritage looted or destroyed—with the complicity or tacit approval of the US military. In a cruel historical irony that will not be missed by those concerned with the fate of ancient Babylon, the Bush administration, a criminal political elite that purports to be waging war in defence of the values of ‘civilisation,’ is destroying important remnants of the origins of Western civilisation itself. http://www.wsws.org/articles/2005/jan2005/arch-j26.shtml
