Jump to content

Hell Is Full Of Well Intentioned People...


Boghos

Recommended Posts

Growing up in what would be considered a very liberal family, being educated at very liberal schools and colleges meant that certain basic tenets of what is called liberal views would not be easily challenged. However as time went by and having taken participaited in student politics, having marched for democracy and other worthy causes in Brazil and abroad, I realized by my late teens that there was as much self serving politics in so-called liberal circles as in so-called conservative ones. As such by college time I was engaged in writing satyrical articles on the childish liberals and their slogan shouting voluntarism and publishing them in the daily student newspaper. Controversy arose quite quickly, previously unknown people were congratulating me, at the same time I lost a few friends. Such is college life...

 

As I went on and deeper in the study of Economics and Political Science, it became quite clear that the traditional left members and its many methamophosis over time and space had a common and troubling denominator: they saw themselves as morally superior to common mortals. I will not go into the reasons for such, but suffices to say that it is a convenient steam valve for a lot of people, often well intentioned and sometimes intelectually lazy.

 

But time and again we have seen that such fight for ideas that are very vague and hardly practical, often detrimental for society as a whole attract well intentioned people. This is especially clear in the way sexuality is dealt with in America. Why should anybody wear a "Proud to be gay" t-shirt ? Isn´t that just attracting contempt ? or is it a need to affirm something that wouldn´t otherwise qualify for "pride" were it not a result of the opposite feeling ? what is there to be proud of ? or ashamed of ? what should I care what goes on in people´s bedrooms ? or wherever ? My contention, skipping many lines of an already long and boring text, is that there should be no special gay rights, or rights for immigrants or left handed one eyed card sharks...and that affirmative action is anything but that...Populism, just one of the ugliest faces of left and rightwing politics is represented in these kind of initiatives that in my view completely contradict and even work against any sort of rational approach to these and other controversial issues.

 

Of, course this is as valid for a number of ways Armenians approach the dearest subjects at hand.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

OK fine...and I understand you completely...but perhaps you need more exposure to the American (religeous based or at least cowtowing to) conservatives and their utter rediculousness (and dangerousness) about most things - to at least better appreciate the left (as perhaps the lesser of two evils)...
Link to comment
Share on other sites

that there should be no special gay rights, or rights for immigrants or left handed one eyed card sharks...and that affirmative action is anything but that...Populism, just one of the ugliest faces of left and rightwing politics is represented in these kind of initiatives that in my view completely contradict and even work against any sort of rational approach to these and other controversial issues.

Boghos

It is obvious that you know very little about the reality of US. The immigrants that pick strawberries and vegetables for slave wages need rights! Such as medical benefits among many others. These people are the reason that American produce is considerably cheaper then other developed countries. Most Americans rip the benefits of inexpensive produce but are reluctant to respect and appreciate the workers who labored it.

Affirmative action is justifiable considering black slaves practically build this country on their backs in cotton and sugar fields. Lets not forget that discrimination was totally real until civil rights movement and still present.

I am neither a liberal nor a conservative however your characterization of this issue is misguided.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I think what Boghos is saying is that both liberals and coservatives are selfish. It shouldn't be a surprise knowing the selfish nature of politics and most politicians. But of course Armat is also right regarding the immigrants' rights. It's just that (most) politicians don't do it out of altruistic reasons but out of self-interest. In this case liberals are better positioned to promote the cause and later on rip the benefits.

 

P.S. Thoth you are right sometimes religious conservatives can be really ridiculous and even sick. Politics corrupts religion when religious people are in politics.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Just wanted to add that if you were a Black American male lawyer trying to catch a cab in New York City and ignored repeatedly because of your color skin then it is not a right wing or left wing intellectual mambo jumbo but plain racism and that is not acceptable in this day and age. For thousands of people racism, discrimination is beyond politics but intricate part of the fabric in this society and lot of well meaning people (mostly liberals) try hard to change that hence by default becomes political. Obviously in democracy the only way to change the reality is through politics…
Link to comment
Share on other sites

For thousands of people racism, discrimination is beyond politics but intricate part of the fabric in this society and lot of well meaning people (mostly liberals) try hard to change that hence by default becomes political. Obviously in democracy the only way to change the reality is through politics…

Armat, yes you can't avoid politics, government, authorities, etc. in order to make big changes. But there is really no need to be a politician or official to make good things. Was Mother Theresa a politician? She never felt the need to be in politics in order to help. There are so many ways to help and being a politician should be the last thing, unless one has ambitions or needs to be glorified, etc. And these politicians when they do a small good thing they will of course exaggerate and keep saying it until the end of their lifes. That's just disgusting...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Affirmative action?

it's like saying "ok, rasism is bad. but unfortunately we are animals and can't control ourselves to avoid rasism. so, let's make it a law. at least we'll be afriad of the law and stop practicing rasism."

Link to comment
Share on other sites

OK fine...and I understand you completely...but perhaps you need more exposure to the American (religeous based or at least cowtowing to) conservatives and their utter rediculousness (and dangerousness) about most things - to at least better appreciate the left (as perhaps the lesser of two evils)...

Oh, but I have. I used to read National Review, follow the thoughts (as in reading them not necessarily agreeing with) Buckley, Buchanan, and a number of other luminaries of the conservative movement. I have as much sympathy for the religious right, as I have for tree kissing atheists that proclaim that they have the solution for world problems, that they are peace loving egalitarians and the like. What is really dangerous is letting the state grow into this monstruous octopus that becomes an endless source of corruption and misallocation of resources. The state as the entity that should be the most powerful is a concept shared by right and left in its worst manifestations.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I think what Boghos is saying is that both liberals and coservatives are selfish. It shouldn't be a surprise knowing the selfish nature of politics and most politicians. But of course Armat is also right regarding the immigrants' rights. It's just that (most) politicians don't do it out of altruistic reasons but out of self-interest. In this case liberals are better positioned to promote the cause and later on rip the benefits.

 

P.S. Thoth you are right sometimes religious conservatives can be really ridiculous and even sick. Politics corrupts religion when religious people are in politics.

Hello Sasun, I am not just saying that every politician is "selfish". I am saying that good intentions ae not enough and they often mask other questions and lead to a bad soltuion for "problems". Affirmative action is a very good example: of course blacks are "behind", of course they were brought to America involuntarily, of course they were enslaved, of course they were and are discriminated against, so with the stroke of a pen you bring them up to pair ? Isn´t this a populist and simplistic "solution" that just breeds contempt ? Isn´t it a reverse discrimination exercise ? should you tell a hardworking white boy, maybe your son, that he is not to be accepted because a black kid, whose ancestors blah, blah, will be in his place, in spite of being less qualified ? you think America will be in a better shape if you act like that ? if you do your little "contribution" ?

 

Don´t people realize that these problems are much deeper ? That they cannot be dealt with with apparently humane legistlation that ends up increasing the problem. That for example the disproportionately large US black carcerary population has roots in the 60s disintegration of the black family ?

 

Don´t you see how the first Armenians that came to America were discriminated against and still managed to have very succesful lives ? Their kids went on to attend college and became succesful professionals and entrepreneurs.

 

Religion and politics don´t mix ? Of course they do. They are not mutually incompatible. Religion is just an expression of moral values. It is an intrinsic part of politics, you can´t get rid of it. Of course there is the separation of "religion" and "state" which has nothing to do with religion, but everything to do with curtailing a given "church's" power. We for example, as Armenians, have not for the most part been able to separate religion from state in our minds...so there you go.

 

My point is that the aim is to reduce as much as possible interference with the natural laws of competition and what Keynes called "animal instincts". Politicians are noise in the system, they should be there, of course, but it is when you succumb to populsm and apparent short term gratification that things start to unravel.

Edited by Boghos
Link to comment
Share on other sites

My point is that the aim is to reduce as much as possible interference with the natural laws of competition and what Keynes called "animal instincts". Politicians are noise in the system, they should be there, of course, but it is when you succumb to populsm and apparent short term gratification that things start to unravel.

Boghos

 

 

On the other extreme spectrum we have almost pure Darwinistic “natural laws of competition” in Armenia and because of lack of respect for laws or none existing laws we got an environment which breeds corruption and counter growth and investments. Most businesses establish in the environment where stability and respect for laws are present.

This I am sure may not come as a shock to you that everything we do is self interest motivated even Sasun’s idea of Mother Theresa including. Politicians are necessary. In the ideal world utopian society we may not them however the examples you mention such as affirmative action can be easily changed if enough people don’t want them. That is democracy!

I hope my comments are not to be taken personally.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Armat, precisely. We are more in agreement than it seemed. The stable environment you call for appears to be similar to mine, I am not defending utopian societies and such, but stable rules and their enforcement for me means simple rules and enforcement. Twisting it renders it unrecognizable, a confusing web of specific interests that hinder development.

 

I also believe that we can always rectify mistakes, and democracy is in part about that, in my view. But that is no exactly the issue at hand. Rather that well intentioned so-called idealists often bring about worse results than the status quo. Democracy is about debating and measuring up alternative ways of dealing with issues, political correctness is a form of populism maskaraded as a moral deed.

 

The issues in Armenia go far beyond the rule of law and the like. But isn´t it interesting how even a corrupt state with little regard to the rule of law has little criminality in spite of the absence of an efficient police force ? Why criminality is a much more serious issue in Ca. among Armenians than in Armenia proper ?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The immigrants that pick strawberries and vegetables for slave wages need rights! Such as medical benefits among many others. These people are the reason that American produce is considerably cheaper then other developed countries. Most Americans rip the benefits of inexpensive produce but are reluctant to respect and appreciate the workers who labored it.

Armat,

 

I think you have dropped the keyword from your argument, which is "illegal” immigrants.

 

We all are immigrants in this country and, by in large, play by the rules or at least pretend to do so.

 

Why instead of standing up for the rights of illegal immigrants, and thus violating twice the laws of the land, not to legalize their status or to expend the perimeters of immigration?

 

Wouldn't it be better to legally migrate to the country people who, as you claim, are that critical for the local economies?

 

I think this goes to the heart of the problem that was earlier discussed - with all good impressions some people are creating more problems then attempting to provide acceptable solutions to them.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Boghos

It is obvious that you know very little about the reality of US...Affirmative action is justifiable considering black slaves practically build this country on their backs in cotton and sugar fields. Lets not forget that discrimination was totally real until civil rights movement and still present.

I am neither a liberal nor a conservative however your characterization of this issue is misguided.

I did not answer this part because it is factually wrong but I´ll have a go. The US was not built on the back of slave labour. Before you jump into conclusions, let me say that I studied US economic history from a Marxist perspective, which I think is at least an interesting one, so don´t accuse me of this or that. Stick to the facts and not wishful thinking.

 

Second point is that even if the US was built on the back of slave labour, which again it was not, what logical relationship is there between that and affirmative action ? It seems so obviously right to "compensate" the descendents of slaves, right ? But it isn´t. Following this sort of reasoning would mean that the descendents of coal miners in England should be compensated for their ancestors appaling work conditions, or that a Chinese Canadian should be compensated for his or that discriminatory treatment in the early 20th century and the list is near endless.

 

Affirmative action is not "compensation", it is a misguided policy designed to bring blacks and hispanics closer to white standards. But of course not only it doesn´t work but it increases the size of the problem, it creates problems where previously they did no exist. Doesn´t affirmative action increase the likelihood of a given black student, gifted black student, being perceived as favoured by the system ? Shouldn´t a poor white kid from the rust belt be entitled to the same "discrimination" given that his father´s steel mill no longer exists ? or how about the son of a North Korean immigrant, shouldn ´t he also be entitled to a place ahead of everybody else given that his family lived under the most attrocious oppression ? so, who isn´t entitled to some sort of "benevolence" ? If everybody is, than nobody is...so nobody should...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Curing the disease with another disease might work in homeopathic but not in politics.

Trying to overcome the negative affects of racist thinking in the society by imposing special rules for unprivileged ones just creates more tensions and double standards. If we agree that all men are equal then why should we treat some groups exclusively or with preferences?

B)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Religion and politics don´t mix ? Of course they do. They are not mutually incompatible. Religion is just an expression of moral values. It is an intrinsic part of politics, you can´t get rid of it. Of course there is the separation of "religion" and "state" which has nothing to do with religion, but everything to do with curtailing a given "church's" power. We for example, as Armenians, have not for the most part been able to separate religion from state in our minds...so there you go.

Hi Boghos. OK, I see your point more clearly now. But your view on religion and politics being mixable is a bit puzzling. I do agree wholeheartedly that politicians should have morality. Religion in a certain way can bring morality into politics. But is religion really the only way someone could be moral? A lot of people are not religious but are more moral than certain catholic priests, for example. I am a big admirer of religions but when it comes to politics I don't see any reason why religion should transcend spiritual matters and mix with politics. Also, in a country like the US one could ask rightfully what religion should it be - there are several contradictory religions around.

I am not sure in what way you think that religion and politics can go together. If you say that religious people would make great politicians I agree - a truely religious person has no greed, no ego, no personal ambitions, no cunning, no lying, therefore he/she would make a great politician. But anything more than that simply would not work. For example, if they tried to apply biblical law, or sheriat, or talmud - obviously that would be a really bad thing.

I think if the society is pious then its democratically elected leaders will also be pious and moral. So perhaps in this way religion and politics can mix indirectly with good results. As to Armenians keeping the "state" and religion together in their minds, that maybe true for Diasporans whereas "state" is the organizational structure, but in Armenia most people don't care or think about the church or religion.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Politicians are necessary.

Politicians are a dime a dozen, they are inevitable. What is really necessary is good, moral politicians. Such politicians are badly needed and rare.

 

This I am sure may not come as a shock to you that everything we do is self interest motivated even Sasun’s idea of Mother Theresa including.

 

Come on Armat, don't be so skeptical :) Enlightened people like Mother Theresa are not many but they do exist. What possible self-interest can you see in Mother Theresa (other than seeking a place in heaven :) )

Edited by Sasun
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Boghos

Racism was institutionalized until civil rights movement so blacks cannot be compared with other ethnic groups.

“Illegal” immigrants are actually called migrant workers and US agricultural companies knowingly allow them to come and work for two three dollars hour. Those workers are entitled to certain benefits.

Since you did mention immigrants and not “illegal” then my argument is more then valid since most of us began our lives here as immigrants. In the eighties I am not ashamed that we did receive welfare benefits for six mouths, which allowed enough time to readjust our lives in the US. My father soon started to work, and the rest is history.

The reason that I am uncomfortable with your Argument was how general and black and white you placed your examples.

I actually feel sympathetic to tree hugging liberals who do want to protect and raise the issue of saving old growth forests and lobby against clear cutting techniques often used by logging companies.

Do I advocate bombing those companies out? Hell no! What I am trying to express and at times not so eloquently that often in life things are grayer with different shades then black and white.

I can easily recognize that car safety issues ( seat belts, air bags), building codes, privation of dumping wastes in rivers and lakes, gun control- were mostly achieved by special groups that hinder growth or hinder natural instinct as you phrased it. My examples are only to illustrate that under your definition of Populism lays multiple issues, which cannot be approached in swiping manner.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hi Boghos. OK, I see your point more clearly now. But your view on religion and politics being mixable is a bit puzzling. I do agree wholeheartedly that politicians should have morality. Religion in a certain way can bring morality into politics. But is religion really the only way someone could be moral? A lot of people are not religious but are more moral than certain catholic priests, for example. I am a big admirer of religions but when it comes to politics I don't see any reason why religion should transcend spiritual matters and mix with politics. Also, in a country like the US one could ask rightfully what religion should it be - there are several contradictory religions around.

I am not sure in what way you think that religion and politics can go together. If you say that religious people would make great politicians I agree - a truely religious person has no greed, no ego, no personal ambitions, no cunning, no lying, therefore he/she would make a great politician. But anything more than that simply would not work. For example, if they tried to apply biblical law, or sheriat, or talmud - obviously that would be a really bad thing.

I think if the society is pious then its democratically elected leaders will also be pious and moral. So perhaps in this way religion and politics can mix indirectly with good results. As to Armenians keeping the "state" and religion together in their minds, that maybe true for Diasporans whereas "state" is the organizational structure, but in Armenia most people don't care or think about the church or religion.

Couple of things as it is late here: I think you are mixing "being moral" with "morals". When I say that religion and politics are connected through the morality implicit in religion I simply mean that in the sense that Kennedy was raised in a catholic family attended school with catholic values. Religion cannot be dissociated from most individuals. I am not making any value judgement on tat, just that it is inevitable and that there are varying degrees of hw it manifest itself; mandatory praying might be a practical extreme, legalized abortion another.

 

In Armenia the state does everything it can to avoid the growth of religions beside the Armenian Apostolic Church. It is called the "Mother Church", it is a "national church".

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Boghos

Racism was institutionalized until civil rights movement so blacks cannot be compared with other ethnic groups.

“Illegal” immigrants are actually called migrant workers and US agricultural companies knowingly allow them to come and work for two three dollars hour. Those workers are entitled to certain benefits.

Since you did mention immigrants and not “illegal” then my argument is more then valid since most of us began our lives here as immigrants. In the eighties I am not ashamed that we did receive welfare benefits for six mouths, which allowed enough time to readjust our lives in the US. My father soon started to work, and the rest is history.

The reason that I am uncomfortable with your Argument was how general and black and white you placed your examples.

I actually feel sympathetic to tree hugging liberals who do want to protect and raise the issue of saving old growth forests and lobby against clear cutting techniques often used by logging companies.

Do I advocate bombing those companies out? Hell no! What I am trying to express and at times not so eloquently that often in life things are grayer with different shades then black and white.

I can easily recognize that car safety issues ( seat belts, air bags), building codes, privation of dumping wastes in rivers and lakes, gun control- were mostly achieved by special groups that hinder growth or hinder natural instinct as you phrased it. My examples are only to illustrate that under your definition of Populism lays multiple issues, which cannot be approached in swiping manner.

Blacks can be compared to any other ethnic group if we look at problems going forward. What you are doing is creating a hierarchy of past injustices that have to be "compensated". You are missing my point entirely.

 

You can be sympahetic to whomever you want, that is beside the point. My thesis is that good intentions often translate into bad policy and the examples abound, I pass no judgement on the situation of any particular group. It is an useless exercise and the root of bad policy decisions as you act from a guily complex rther than a rational basis. Fallacy of composition at work.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

In Armenia the state does everything it can to avoid the growth of religions beside the Armenian Apostolic Church. It is called the "Mother Church", it is a "national church".

Yes, but people are not really religious, most of them view the church as just another national instition, and they may or maynot appreciate it even as an istitution. Perhaps some are proud of it, being the first Christian nation. But I am under the impression that in all this there are no religious feelings (maybe a little).

 

 

I think I understand what you mean for Kennedy's religious upbringing. This is one example of what I meant religion indirectly having a good influence on politics. On the other hand, he was not known as a deeply religious leader, and his catholic beliefs didn't strike out in any way, at least no more than any given catholic\ politician of that time.

 

P.S. I meant morality, not morals.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...