Jump to content

Art of gambling over masses


Kaan

Recommended Posts

A quotation from the article below:

 

"It appears so to you, no doubt; but we Armenians have determined to be free, Europe listened to the Bulgarian horrors and made Bulgaria free. She will listen to our cry when it goes up in the shrieks and blood of millions of women and children...We are desperate. We shall do it."

 

What we understand: Some Armenians living in Europe (the diaspora of that time) made the plans for the circumstances of a civil war for their political ambitions. It is obvious that the great tragedy was foreseen, they hoped to be the leaders of the free and great Armenia after the shrieks and blood of millions of women and children and they were working for the tragedy.

 

Similarity with today: Some Armenians (the diaspora of this time) tell Armenia to fight and make war forever, which make Armenia unsafer, poorer and emptier; which means: Armenians can only rule their country when they are not there, since they don't want to be in the bloodshed they want Armenia to be in, they (diaspora) want a cheap victory over their nation's misery and then to come to their motherland as victorious heros (!). They like gambling, and when they lose gambling with others' money, the diaspora wants the loss they have foreseen and caused back crying with the terms "civilization, humanity, democracy..."

 

 

 

FROM THE DIPLOMACY OF IMPERIALISM,

WILLIAM L. LANGER, NEW YORK (ALFRED A.KNOPF) 1960,

p.157-160

 

The record of Armenian revolutionary activities against the Ottoman Empire in the last two decades of the 19th century is dealt with in detail in the work of the Harvard University diplomatic historian, William Langer. Langer traces the manner by which the Armenian revolutionaries sought to incite European intervention on behalf of their cause. Specifically, by massacring innocent Muslim villagers, they hoped to provoke counter-violence which would then serve as a pretext for European intervention.

 

Langer writes:

"Europeans in Turkey have agreed that the immediate aim of the agitators was to incite disorder, bring about inhuman reprisals, and so provoke the intervention of the powers. For that reason, it was said that, they operated by preference in areas where the Armenians were in hopelessly minority, so that reprisals would be certain. One of the revolutionaries told Dr. Hamlin, the founder of Robert College, that Henchak bands would:

 

"watch their opportunity to kill Turks and Kurds, set fire to their villages, and then make their escape into the mountains. The enraged Moslems will then rise, and fall upon the defenseless Armenians and slaughter them with such barbarity that Russia will enter in the name of humanity and Christian civilization and take possession."

 

When the horrified missionary denounced the scheme as atrocious and infernal beyond anything ever known, he received this reply:

 

"It appears so to you, no doubt; but we Armenians have determined to be free. Europe listened to Bulgarian horrors and made bulgaria free. She will listen to our cry when it goes up in the shrieks and blood of millions of women and children..We are desperate. We shall do it."

 

* And so the revolutionaries began to get what they wanted - reprisals. It mattered not to them that perfectly innocent people were being made to suffer for the realization of a program drawn up by a group in Geneva or Athens, a group which had never been given any mandate whatever by the Armenian community.

 

* Hogarth tells of Armenians in the provinces who said they wished the patriots would leave them alone. But these people were not consulted by others for the sacrifice; their lives were the price to be paid for the realization of the fantastic national-socialist state of the fanatics."

 

***

Source: William L. Langer, The Diplomacy of Imperialism, New York (Alfred A. Knopf), pp.157-160

 

"The Hentchakian Revolutionary party was, in 1890, invited to join the Armenian Revolutionary Federation, and did so, but the association of the two did not last long. Nazarbek was evidently not an easy person to get on with and preferred to work on his own. At first he had trouble in finding followers, but his new collaborators worked hard, Khan-Azad, for example went to Constantinople in July 1889 and began to spread propaganda. He consulted with Khrimian, but found the old man doubtful:"You are crazy," said the old patriot. "The Armenians are a very small nation, and how much blood will have to be shed." He could not see how anything substantial could be done without European help. But Khan-Azad was not discouraged. he went on to Tiflis, where he had no better luck. It was only in Trebizond that he found any real enthusiasm. There he established the central committee of the party, and from that centre agents were sent out who organized revolutionary cells in Erzerum, Kharput, Smyrna, Aleppo and many other places. Nazarbek himself stayed discreetly in Geneva, but in a volume of stories published later he has given us vivid pictures of the agitators visiting the peasants, "talking the night through with them, speaking with them of their sufferings, unceasingly, impatiently, preaching the gospel of an eye for an eye, a tooth for a tooth, rousing their curshed spirits with high resolves and mighty aspirations.

 

The ambassadors at Constantinople were not slow in following the development of this agitation. From 1888 onward the English representative reported the presence of revolutionaries and the seizure of seditious literature. Revolutionary placards were being posted in the cities and there were not a few cases of the blackmailing of wealthy Armenians, who were forced to contribute to the cause. Europeans in Turkey were agreed that the immediate aim of the agitators was to incite disorder, bring about inhuman reprisals, and so provoke the intervention of the powers. For that reason, it was said, they operated by preference in areas where the Armenians were in a hopeless minority, so that reprisals would be certain. One of the revolutionaries told

 

Dr. Hamlin, the founder of Robert College, that the Henchak bands would watch their opportunity to kill Turks and Kurds, set fire to their villages, and then make their escape into the mountains. The enraged Moslems will then rise, and fall upon the defenseless Armenians and slaughter them with such barbarity that Russia will enter in the name of humanity and Christian civilization and take possession."

 

When the horrified missionary denounced the scheme as atrocious and infernal beyond anything ever known, he received this reply:

 

"It appears so to you, no doubt; but we Armenians have determined to be free, Europe listened to the Bulgarian horrors and made Bulgaria free. She will listen to our cry when it goes up in the shrieks and blood of millions of women and children...We are deperate. We shall do it."

 

Serious trouble began in 1890, when there were disturbances and some bloodshed at Erzerum. The outbreak had not been premeditated or planned, but the Hentchak hoped to capitalize it. To encourage interest it arranged to stage a great demonstration in Constantinople to impress both the Turkish and the European governments. The affair was carefully planned and the minimum demands of the revolutionaries (civil liberties) were sent in advance to the foreign ambassadors. A proclamation was read in Armenian Church at Kum-Kapu, in which the Armenians were told in so many words: "You must be your own self-governing master."

 

Even this demonstration had no favorable results. During the following months the efforts of the leaders seem to have gone into negotiations for an agreement with other revolutionary groups. There were long conferences at Athens, and in December 1891 the Hentchak officially joined the Oriental Federation of Macedonian, Albanian, Cretan and Greek revolutionists. The newspaper was transferred to Athens, where it remained until the end of 1894, at which time the Armenian organization moved to London. In the interval propaganda was being carried on in Armenia and efforts were being made to induce the Kurds to join forces with the insurgents. Agents were sent also to America, where branches were established in Boston, Worcester and other cities. Khan-Azad reports that he raised in America no less than $10,000 to support the cause.

 

When the Gladstone cabinet came into power in the summer of 1892 the hopes of the Armenians ran high, for was not the Grand Old Man the savior of the oppressed? As a matter of fact the Liberal Government began almost at once to send sharp notes to the Porte. The Anglo-Armenian Committee and the Evangelical Aliiance made the most of the situation and raised the hue and cry of religious persecution. But English influence had sunk so low at Constantinople that no attention was paid to the protests from London. The Turkish government probably realized even then the Russian government, just as hostile to the Hentchakian aspirations as the Turkish, would stand behind it. In 1890 the Russian officials had co-operated with the Turkish in breaking up an Armenian raiding party organized in the Caucasus. Many writers have taken the stand that English intervention only made matters worse. "The Turk begins to repress because we sympathize" wrote David Hogarth; "and we sympathize the more because he represses, and so the vicious circle revolves". England "is more responsible for the cold-blooded murders which have come near exterminating the Armenians than all other nations put together" remarked an American traveller.

 

It requires no very vivid imagination to picture the reaction of the Turks to the agitation of the revolutionists. They had constantly in mind, if not the revolt of the Greeks, at least the insurrection in Bulgaria and the disastrous intervention of Russia and the powers. Whether Abdul Hamid deserves the black reputation that has been pinned to him is a matter for debate. If he was "the bloody assassin" and the "red Sultan" to most people, he was the hard-working conscientious, much harassed but personally charming ruler to others. Those who have spoken for him have pointed out that the Sultan felt his Empire threatened by the Armenians who he knew or at least believed, were in league with the Young Turks, the Greeks, Macedonians, etc. They believe that Abdul Hamid was the victim of what we moderns call a persecution complex. He was terrified, and for that reason surrounded himself not only with high walls, but with all sorts of dubious characters, especially spies and delators who justified their existence by bringing ever more alarming reports.

 

So much at least cannot be denied: that the revolutionists planned a great conflagration and that they gave the Sultan and his ministers ample fright. One of their proclamations read:

 

"The times are most critical and pregnant with ominous events. The cup is full. Prepare for the inevitable. Organize, arm, -arm with anything. If one place revolts or shows resistance, do the same in your locality. Spread the fight for liberation. yes, in truth, it is better to live as a free man for a day, for an hour, and to die fighting, than to live a life of slavery for generations, nay for centuries."

 

In the summer of 1894 the Revolutionary Committee wrote a letter to the Grand Vizier warning him that there would be a general rising in the Empire if the "very just demands of the Armenian people" were not met. No one could blame the government for anticipating a tremendous upheaval and for taking precautions. Probably to counteract the efforts made to bring the Kurds into the movement, the Sultan had, in 1891, organized the tribesmen in the famous Hamidie regiments, which were modelled on the Russian cossack brigades and were supposedly meant to act as a frontier defense force. In 1877 and 1878, however, the Kurd troops had been more trouble than they were worth, it may therefore be assumed that the purpose of the new organizations was to satisfy the chief and keep them from joining forces with the Armenian revolutionaries. In fact they could and were, under the new system, used against the Armenians. Beginning in 1892, the Hamidie regiments, sometimes supported by regular troops, began to raid the Armenian settlements, burnign the houses, destroying the crop and cutting down the inhabitants.

 

And so the revolutionaries began to get what they wanted - reprisals. It mattered not to them that perfectly innocent people were being made to suffer for the realization of a program drawn up by a group in Geneva or Athens, a group which had never been given any mandate whatever by the Armenian community. So far as one can make out the Hentchak agitators were ardently supported by the lower-class Armenians in Constantinople, with whose help they forced the election of the Patriot Ismirlian as patriarch in 1894. But the upper classes appear to have been opposed to the whole program; indeed, they were victimized themselves by threatening letters and by blackmail into the financing of a scheme which they regarded as disastrous. As for the peasantry in the provinces, it is perfectly obvious that they did not know what it was all about. Isabella Bishop, who travelled through the country in 1891, makes the positive statement "that the Armenian peasant is as destitude of political aspirations as he is ignorant of political grievances...not a single occasion did I hear a wish expressed for political or administrative reform, or for Armenian independence." Hogarth tells of Armenians in the provinces who said they wished the patriots would leave them alone. But these people were not consulted. Whether they liked it or not, they were marked out by others for the sacrifice; their lives were the price to be paid for the

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I just discovered this material. Tried to read it, but after getting less than half way through, I couldn't continue - I found it boring and found my eyes simply running through the page without reading.

 

Maybe Kaan may help me/us to understand what is the conversation here about by making a couple of comments of his own and conveying the message of this material in few sentences and making clear what was the message that he was trying to deliver if any?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

quote:
Originally posted by MJ:

I just discovered this material. Tried to read it, but after getting less than half way through, I couldn't continue - I found it boring and found my eyes simply running through the page without reading.


Thanks MJ! I really thought it was just me. I couldn't make heads or tails out of it. Don't know about others, but I find that the
quote:
"quote"
format using the [ quote ] and [ /quote ] tags, to be extremely helpful in such cases.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

If I understood correctly, this is what Kaan was trying to say him/herself:

 

quote:

Some Armenians (the diaspora of this time) tell Armenia to fight and make war forever, which make Armenia unsafer, poorer and emptier; which means: Armenians can only rule their country when they are not there, since they don't want to be in the bloodshed they want Armenia to be in, they (diaspora) want a cheap victory over their nation's misery and then to come to their motherland as victorious heros (!). They like gambling, and when they lose gambling with others' money, the diaspora wants the loss they have foreseen and caused back crying with the terms "civilization, humanity, democracy..."


... which makes sense I guess since it starts off by "some Armenians" ... I am sure some armenians in the diaspora are telling all those things. But if you mean ALL diasporans, then obviously I don't agree since I am not telling anyone anything like that ... and I am part of the Diaspora (I think).

 

[ September 28, 2002, 06:57 PM: Message edited by: Sip ]

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thanks for the explanations, Sip. But I am still in the darkeness. The entire material above was by Langer. I would like to know what Kaan is trying to say here...

 

Is this supposed to be some kind of confession, another "explanation and justification," or am I to understand that this is supposed to manifest "Kaan dropping a bomb," and instead of talking, by now we all are supposed to be "dead?"

Link to comment
Share on other sites

It reads to me like bits and pieces of actual good info - but pushed together withought a thought as to what it was/is concluding or of making any real point. Of course my last sentance may be an example of the same...anyway that bottle of wine I just finished off was pretty damn good...
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Very easy for you to open a bottle of wine today isn't it Thoth? ... I only have the TOP scoring team to worry about in the league ... your opponent seems like he is going to be a pushover more or less ... as of now, his kicker and Running back are on BYE

 

But I gotta get a win on Blue Thunder ... I have made several riskey moves this week in the hopes of scoring BIG... it could backfire but I am hoping for the best.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

quote:
Originally posted by MJ:

I just discovered this material. Tried to read it, but after getting less than half way through, I couldn't continue - I found it boring and found my eyes simply running through the page without reading.

 

Maybe Kaan may help me/us to understand what is the conversation here about by making a couple of comments of his own and conveying the message of this material in few sentences and making clear what was the message that he was trying to deliver if any?


Welcome to the Twilight-Zone !

 

Or

 

Was it the Raki? Notice how the post comes to a sudden end !

Link to comment
Share on other sites

this is the gist of the article as far as i can understand:

 

1. the hinchaks wanted independence from the ottoman empire and since armenian forces were not sufficient for it, they deemed european intervention on behalf of the armenians was necessary.

 

2. to get european intervention, european interest had to be aroused, and for this they had to do what the balkan christians had done: commit atrocities against the local muslims, and the ottomans would "pay back with interest added", which would cause the outraged christian europeans to intervene on their behalf to throw off the muslim turkish yoke. it had worked in the balkans, why wouldn't it work in armenia?

 

3. they then set out to implement the plan.

 

kaan's (implied) conclusions: the armenians provoked the turks to attack, and hence are responsible for what happened to them.

 

my conclusions:

 

1. the hinchaks were a savage bunch who cared as much for armenian lives as for turkish lives.

 

2. the hinchaks predicted correctly that if they behaved like animals, the ottoman government would behave like an animal, too.

 

3. the ottoman government of the time failed to observe the distinction between a terrorist group with no legitimacy and hence given responsibility towards anyone and a legitimate state with a given responsibility toward its subjects.

 

my question to kaan:

 

1. the pkk has been doing for 15 years what the hinchaks did then. it has now been crushed without a million innocent kurds dead (total death toll, turk and kurd, military and civilian: 29,000). could the same not be done then?

 

2. would pkk actions, in your opinion, have justified the total eradication of the kurdish race from anatolia (this is what happened to the armenians)? if not, why?

 

3. how does this apply back to the armenian situation?

 

thanks.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

This whole Huchnack thing is far overplayed. Obviously their methods were despicable - but besides some killings and making a good excuse for the CUP racists - any actual impact of their activites was quite minimal. It should be acknoledged certainly (but for what it was). I find it funny though that many Turks who are somewhat more informed on the Genocide seem to want to keep coming back to these activities of (a very few) Armenian gangs as legitimate justification for Turkish anger, fear and reprisal - (but what of the even more numourous Muslim ones who preyed on innocent citizens during this period?). The facts are that these activities were basicaly inconsiquential - but provided a convinient excuzse - then and now.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I just saw this thread...

 

Ali you just demonstrated with your post here, that whatever nonsense could be posted, you will understand something from it, that will support your biased view.

 

Only appologists uses Langer, as well only appologists hide the compleat title of his work.

 

The work IS "Diplomacy of Imperialism 1890-1902" The work TALK about "Diplomacy of Imperialism 1890-1902"

 

The Armenian question is covered from 1890 to 1902, nor the bring anything about the new government system, nor the first World War, he just write few lines of it, in a massive work.

 

Langer was an appologist, justifying the crime against the Armenians, telling that Russians were as well doing the same with the Jews, like if it could justify the massacres...

 

Here is how he conclude his appologist chapter.

 

"After all, if the Turks were massacring the Armenians, so were the Russians massacring the Jews. If the Turks oppressed the Armenians, did not the Russians oppress them too? One might sympathize with these people, but one could not start a great European conflagration for their sake, and everyone understood that a reopening of the Turkish question might very well result in such a conflagration."

 

[ October 05, 2002, 08:58 AM: Message edited by: Domino ]

Link to comment
Share on other sites

quote:
Originally posted by Domino:

The work IS "Diplomacy of Imperialism 1890-1902" The work TALK about "Diplomacy of Imperialism 1890-1902"


This is an interesting observation and a very typical one, I think. The entire conceptual framework of Turkish (also Jewish, and whomever else) denialism is based on the presentation of things out of their actual context, and is built on very shaky foundations. That is, if it is addressed at us.

 

Let’s do a couple of simple exercises.

 

It would be stupid to claim that Turkish Ideological and Power Centers are this stupid. They are not. But what this attest to is that they use this trick as a device for the "tranquilization" of their own nation, since such materials, or better to say such presentations, are oriented at their internal audience, which probably is stupider than the above-mentioned structures.

 

This also leads to an enforced understanding that Turkish Ideological and Power Centers are afraid only of their own people and their primary driver is the reluctance to implement Human Right's reforms in Turkey. The Armenian Question is the best kept secret of Turkish Power Structures, it is their most hideous crime, and it is their Achilles Heal. Understood!

 

If one wants to see any changes in the Turkish "doctrine" towards Armenia(ns), one has to opt for Human Right's reform in Turkey.

 

However, this is a very risky proposition - in the process of an attempt to implement such reform, there are two realistic outcomes:

 

1. Human Right's Reform supporters will take over and the problems between Armenians and Turks would be resolved - and I would like to build on an earlier declaration of Boghos, here, but would like to go one step further, claiming that not only the problems between Armenians and Turks are simple, but also their solutions are trivial - there has to be just rational thinking on the subject. But can there be rational thinking on the subject?

 

2. Human Right's reform supporters would lose, which is not unrealistic to assume, and not only they will fail, but the secularist orientation of Turkey may change - Turkey is really poor country with nothing but misery for its own people and its neighbors - all neighbors – this is a consequence of their past and present imperialism. Under the known poverty, the best chances may belong to the supporters of Islamic Regime, for example. But then, “Armenians? What Armenians?”

 

Given the second outcome, which is a very serious possibility, maybe Turkey's current Regime is the least of two evils?

 

But then, we are back where we started...

 

One thing is clear, though: Turkey's further disintegration promises tremendous misery to its neighbors, especially Armenians... Is Armenia, for example, prepared to experience another decade (maybe more) of turmoil due to the collapse of a yet another Empire in its proximity with unpredictable consequences?

 

See how controversial things may get?

 

Two last comments:

 

1. As far as Armenian Revolutionaries are concerned, hope they enjoy their tenure in Hell;

 

2. As far as the initial material of this thread is concerned (Kaan's material) - keep it for internal use in Turkey - it may work.

 

P.S. The moral of my story is, under any circumstances other than the continuation of Status Quo, current Turkish regime loses. But, again, they will lose one or another way. It is just a matter of time, and delaying it may make the agony of death more torturous. But this is more cotnroversal, isn't it?

 

[ October 06, 2002, 09:29 AM: Message edited by: MJ ]

Link to comment
Share on other sites

quote:
Originally posted by Kaan:

 

"It appears so to you, no doubt; but we Armenians have determined to be free, Europe listened to the Bulgarian horrors and made Bulgaria free. She will listen to our cry when it goes up in the shrieks and blood of millions of women and children...We are desperate. We shall do it."


The foundation of the entire article is based on this statement. But is it actualy true, was the main reason Bulgaria got its independence from Ottoman Turkey because of the outrage certain European counries felt on hearing of the Turkish attrocities committed there?

 

I'd say it is patently false - Bulgarian independence resulted from the 1877-78 war between Turkey and Russia. The attrocities the Turks commited to some extent worked in Bulgaria's favour in the peace treaty, but it took a larger war involving Russia for the circumstances that (as a side issue) allowed Bulgarian independence to occur.

 

Thus, there is no logic behind ANY belief that prompting the Turks to commit attrocities would lead to Armenian independence. That is not to say some could believe it would - but the numbers who could believe such an obviously flawed theory would be very small, too small to make any impact. Ali - a "European intervention on behalf of the Armenians" is not the same as having a war fought by one or more European power against Turkey and about Armenians. There was no realistic possibility of such a war. Intervention, in this context, means diplomatic intervention.

 

Like Thoth said, "this whole Huchnack thing is far overplayed". Overplayed by the Turkish state who have found a ready made excuse to turn genocide into just an overly heavyhanded security operation. Overplayed by nationalistic Armenians who seem to need to boast about the martial spirit amongst Ottoman Armenians (which was, in reality, almost non existant).

Link to comment
Share on other sites

quote:
Originally posted by THOTH:

This whole Huchnack thing is far overplayed. Obviously their methods were despicable - but besides some killings and making a good excuse for the CUP racists - any actual impact of their activites was quite minimal. It should be acknoledged certainly (but for what it was). I find it funny though that many Turks who are somewhat more informed on the Genocide seem to want to keep coming back to these activities of (a very few) Armenian gangs as legitimate justification for Turkish anger, fear and reprisal - (but what of the even more numourous Muslim ones who preyed on innocent citizens during this period?). The facts are that these activities were basicaly inconsiquential - but provided a convinient excuzse - then and now.


thoth,

 

i agree with the hunchak thing being overplayed by turkey - though to what extent we may disagree with. the thing is those who had such designs on the armenians needed a justification for it and they got it. my questions - which kaan didn't answer - were 1) whether the murder of an entire nation - which it was - was "justifiable" or "necessary" on the grounds of the actions of some savage gangs and the perceived threat they presented, and 2) if it were - as he seems to imply - then why wasn't the same tactic employed against the pkk which admittedly has been a far more serious threat to turkey than the hunchaks had ever been.

 

these questions still await explanation.

 

meanwhile, even though the hunchak thing is overblown it certainly was there. both sides have to own up to what is theirs and armenians shouldn't worry (and turks shouldn't hope) that this would change the genocide into something else. it wouldn't.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

mj,

 

brilliant points. no disagreements, just developments.

 

1. human rights tend to go hand in hand with increased material wealth and fair distribution of it coupled with an increased level of education. here are a few numbers:

 

i) over three quarters of turks have never read a book.

 

ii) over two thirds have never studied beyond primary school (which was until recently 5 yeas in turkey).

 

iii) more than half have no hobbies, no interests, no occupation beyond professional work. in a soccer-crazy country, 48% of the population has never been to a contest.

 

iv) turkey's population has doubled in thirty years from 35 m to 70 m, whereas newspaper circulation stayed the same or even declined, at 3-4 m/day.

 

v) over 82% of the young population would leave the country if the opportunity arose.

 

v) over 80% live at or below subsistence level.

 

vi) average turkish life expectancy is 62 years (male) and 67 years (female) respectively.

 

anyone making comments on turkish statesmen, intellectuals, politicians soldiers, activists etc. should bear in mind that this is the raw material that they are working with.

 

there have been several discussions in this forum where the priorities of some members regarding morality have clashed with my priorities regarding practicality. i hope this will serve as an eye-opener to illustrate the nature of our terrain here.

 

regarding the scenarios:

 

1. if the current secular nationalist regime collapses, it would be replaced by a religious one almost without a doubt. this is not because the turks are fanatical but because they are predominantly rural. rural people tend to be religious all over the world. such a regime would offer approximately the same prospects as the taliban, the mullahs in iran, or the saudis.

 

2. if the imminent war in iraq results in the country's dismemberment and the emergence of a kurdish state (which seems most likely) turkey can either 1) get into yet another war and you can say goodbye to peace and stability in the region, 2) attempt to reform itself quickly to msake itself attractive to its kurds to prevent them from wanting to go over (low chance), 3) disintegrate (high probability).

 

if turkey disintegrates 1) your much-cherished historic armenia will largely stay in kurdish hands, and 2) you will very probably share no border with us but one with kurds.

 

since any emerging kurdistan will be unlikely to have any hopes of joining anything like the eu and the western interest there will soon after vanish, that country would slip into decay and turn into yet another middle eastern failure (do not forget that the kurds, unlike you, do not boast a well-qualified, capable population that can stand on its own feet, like the jews or you. these guys are basically nomads.). the main reason why turkey, despite its many shortcomings, is - let's face it - a lot better than iran, iraq, syria, saudi arabia etc. is because turkey has aspirations to get somewhere better and more civilised, whereas these other countries obviously don't. i am afraid that a kurdistan would be far more likely to join them in the club than a smaller, healthier turkey that would emerge from such a split.

 

if i were an armenian i would probably still prefer turkey to stay in one piece and change internally than it to disintegrate, leaving me together with very, very strange bedfellows.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Mr. Urguplu,

The smugness and self-assuredness of your post animated me to reply, against my better judgement. Your post is densely packed with fallacies and traps.

 

quote:
Originally posted by aurguplu:

1. human rights tend to go hand in hand with increased material wealth and fair distribution of it coupled with an increased level of education.


Mr. Urguplu does not even bother with posing it as a "chicken or egg" question (albeit false; the direction of causality is quite clear, and is opposite of the direction Mr. Urguplu wishes it were). He displays the wishful thinking of all cultural imperialists: you can bribe your way out of injustice and cultural rot. Not so easy, Mr. Urguplu, not so easy. Material wealth injected into a population does little to further human rights; witness Saudi Arabia for a glaring example. Even the relatively civilized and quite wealthy Singapore still has to endure a heavy-handed, authoritarian regime form many years after the enrichment of the population. On the other hand, high-quality human capital and culture almost invariably lifts a country from its temporary poverty. I cannot think of any country that remained in poverty despite having a high human-development index. Even if we assume that lots-o-money magically created respect for human rights, is that how we want to go about achieving those rights? Is that how you want to achieve enlightenment? Only if you want to build your newly rich and "oh-so-enlightened" society on the bones of the people and civilizations you crushed, to whom you may one day be willing to pay lip service from the safe distance of a century or two. I am touched. The practicality of your thoughts send shivers down my spine.

 

quote:

i) over three quarters of turks have never read a book.

 

ii) over two thirds have never studied beyond primary school (which was until recently 5 yeas in turkey).


You must mean books that are not mandated by the school. Otherwise the two statements don't make sense together. The reason why people get turned off books is the idiotic school system in Turkey, churning out people who can solve math problems like there is no tomorrow, and yet stumble at the sight of a problem requiring analytical thinking. Surprise? Not really, it reflects what the government wants in its population.

 

quote:
iii) more than half have no hobbies, no interests, no occupation beyond professional work.
The rich do, and the poor are too poor to have such niceties. So what?

 

quote:
in a soccer-crazy country, 48% of the population has never been to a contest.
The relevance of soccer game attendance is only by virtue of highlighting your misguided desire to bandy about statistics. When you are not quoting silly, out-of-context quotes, that is.

 

quote:
iv) turkey's population has doubled in thirty years from 35 m to 70 m, whereas newspaper circulation stayed the same or even declined, at 3-4 m/day.
Considering the quality of journalism in Turkey, a total circulation of zero would in fact be a huge improvement. At least they wouldn't be doing any more harm to the already stupefied population.

 

quote:

v) over 82% of the young population would leave the country if the opportunity arose.


That's nice. That must mean, among other more direct implications, that they are not rabid nationalists ready to topple the government at the first sign of its enlightenment.

 

quote:
v) over 80% live at or below subsistence level.
Concerning that problem, send your complaints to the address of the state apparatus, whose mentality you are doggedly defending, your completely false professd self-image notwithstanding.

 

quote:

vi) average turkish life expectancy is 62 years (male) and 67 years (female) respectively.


See my reply above.

 

quote:
anyone making comments on turkish statesmen, intellectuals, politicians soldiers, activists etc. should bear in mind that this is the raw material that they are working with.
Thanks for your patronizing suggestion. May I suggest to the giver of the advice to think about why the raw material is in the shape it is? Hint: it is not for lack of riches.

 

quote:
there have been several discussions in this forum where the priorities of some members regarding morality have clashed with my priorities regarding practicality. i hope this will serve as an eye-opener to illustrate the nature of our terrain here.
Mr. Urguplu apparently lacks the decency to address some individuals individually. Especially ones that expose his "system" of thought for what it exactly is. Well then. As an anonymous bloke, let me repeat what has previously fell off Mr. Urguplu's teflon-coated neurons: Without a moral basis, and logical self-consistency, there is no such thing as practicality. Without such foundations, there is only ultimatums and realpolitik, which you are trying to sugar-coat as some sort of pragmatic enlightenment. If you actually believe the poor excuse for an argument coming out of your keyboard, I can only pity you as a casualty of the Turkish educational system, which effectively lobotomizes the analytical thinking abilities of its captive audience.

 

I will not address the rest of your self-serving and irrelevant mental debris. Happy slumber.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

quote:
Originally posted by MJ:

This also leads to an enforced understanding that Turkish Ideological and Power Centers are afraid only of their own people and their primary driver is the reluctance to implement Human Right's reforms in Turkey. The Armenian Question is the best kept secret of Turkish Power Structures, it is their most hideous crime, and it is their Achilles Heal. Understood!

 

If one wants to see any changes in the Turkish "doctrine" towards Armenia(ns), one has to opt for Human Right's reform in Turkey.

 

However, this is a very risky proposition - in the process of an attempt to implement such reform, there are two realistic outcomes:

 

1. Human Right's Reform supporters will take over and the problems between Armenians and Turks would be resolved - and I would like to build on an earlier declaration of Boghos, here, but would like to go one step further, claiming that not only the problems between Armenians and Turks are simple, but also their solutions are trivial - there has to be just rational thinking on the subject. But can there be rational thinking on the subject?

 

2. Human Right's reform supporters would lose, which is not unrealistic to assume, and not only they will fail, but the secularist orientation of Turkey may change - Turkey is really poor country with nothing but misery for its own people and its neighbors - all neighbors – this is a consequence of their past and present imperialism. Under the known poverty, the best chances may belong to the supporters of Islamic Regime, for example. But then, “Armenians? What Armenians?”

 

Given the second outcome, which is a very serious possibility, maybe Turkey's current Regime is the least of two evils?

 

But then, we are back where we started...

 


Dear MJ,

Unfortunately I am entering yet another period during which I should refrain from spending much time here. I just wanted to say that I wish you had thought more thoroughly on the subject before you wrote this.

TB

 

quote:
1. As far as Armenian Revolutionaries are concerned, hope they enjoy their tenure in Hell;
P.S. "Armenian revolutionaries" was an almost deterministic outcome of the circumstances. It is unreasonable to expect a complete absence of violent expression of national aspirations at a time of prolonged and worsening oppression. It is irrelevant. It is like saying, "Only if you didn't scream when he was raping you. Then he got really mad." It is irrelevant not only because the scream was as impotent as the "revolutionaries", but also because it is not the actual cause of anything, by virtue of being an inevitable consequence of events and conditions preceding it.

 

[ October 07, 2002, 03:59 PM: Message edited by: Twilight Bark ]

Link to comment
Share on other sites

quote:
Originally posted by Twilight Bark:

quote:
Originally posted by MJ:

This also leads to an enforced understanding that Turkish Ideological and Power Centers are afraid only of their own people and their primary driver is the reluctance to implement Human Right's reforms in Turkey. The Armenian Question is the best kept secret of Turkish Power Structures, it is their most hideous crime, and it is their Achilles Heal. Understood!

 

If one wants to see any changes in the Turkish "doctrine" towards Armenia(ns), one has to opt for Human Right's reform in Turkey.

 

However, this is a very risky proposition - in the process of an attempt to implement such reform, there are two realistic outcomes:

 

1. Human Right's Reform supporters will take over and the problems between Armenians and Turks would be resolved - and I would like to build on an earlier declaration of Boghos, here, but would like to go one step further, claiming that not only the problems between Armenians and Turks are simple, but also their solutions are trivial - there has to be just rational thinking on the subject. But can there be rational thinking on the subject?

 

2. Human Right's reform supporters would lose, which is not unrealistic to assume, and not only they will fail, but the secularist orientation of Turkey may change - Turkey is really poor country with nothing but misery for its own people and its neighbors - all neighbors – this is a consequence of their past and present imperialism. Under the known poverty, the best chances may belong to the supporters of Islamic Regime, for example. But then, “Armenians? What Armenians?”

 

Given the second outcome, which is a very serious possibility, maybe Turkey's current Regime is the least of two evils?

 

But then, we are back where we started...

 


Dear MJ,

Unfortunately I am entering yet another period during which I should refrain from spending much time here. I just wanted to say that I wish you had thought more thoroughly on the subject before you wrote this.

TB

 

quote:
1. As far as Armenian Revolutionaries are concerned, hope they enjoy their tenure in Hell;
P.S. "Armenian revolutionaries" was an almost deterministic outcome of the circumstances. It is unreasonable to expect a complete absence of violent expression of national aspirations at a time of prolonged and worsening oppression. It is irrelevant. It is like saying, "Only if you didn't scream when he was raping you. Then he got really mad." It is irrelevant not only because the scream was as impotent as the "revolutionaries", but also because it is not the actual cause of anything, by virtue of being an inevitable consequence of events and conditions preceding it.
Dear TB,

 

Maybe then you should have refrained from your comment above, too? Because, after all, what you where saying above?

 

On the subject of violence... if I have made an impression of a pacifist on you, then it is a misperception. Otherwise, I have only attempted to contemplate on the subject of the clarity of the relevant agenda.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

quote:
Originally posted by MJ:

Dear TB,

 

Maybe then you should have refrained from your comment above, too? Because, after all, what you where saying above?


You would think that, wouldn't you?

But it so happens that I think I have thought sufficiently deeply about the subject. It is not a logical inconsistency to wish to see the same in the opinions expressed by others.

 

quote:
On the subject of violence... if I have made an impression of a pacifist on you, then it is a misperception.
No you haven't. And if I gave you the impression that you gave me the impression of being a pacifist, that is a misperception.

 

quote:
Otherwise, I have only attempted to contemplate on the subject of the clarity of the relevant agenda.
On which I wished you had spent more time contemplating.

 

Best,

TB

 

[ October 07, 2002, 04:21 PM: Message edited by: Twilight Bark ]

Link to comment
Share on other sites

quote:
Originally posted by Twilight Bark:

quote:
Originally posted by MJ:

Dear TB,

 

Maybe then you should have refrained from your comment above, too? Because, after all, what you where saying above?


You would think that, wouldn't you?

But it so happens that I think I have thought sufficiently deeply about the subject. It is not a logical inconsistency to wish to see the same in the opinions expressed by others.

 

quote:
On the subject of violence... if I have made an impression of a pacifist on you, then it is a misperception.
No you haven't. And if I gave you the impression that you gave me the impression of being a pacifist, that is a misperception.

 

quote:
Otherwise, I have only attempted to contemplate on the subject of the clarity of the relevant agenda.
On which I wished you had spent more time contemplating.

 

Best,

TB


But it is not fair, isn't it? You are reluctant to contemplate due to your time limitation, meanwhile ask me to contemplate furhter, while warning me that if you had time, you would have "shot" me.

 

Thank you for the waring, however.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

quote:
Originally posted by bellthecat:

quote:
Originally posted by Kaan:

 

"It appears so to you, no doubt; but we Armenians have determined to be free, Europe listened to the Bulgarian horrors and made Bulgaria free. She will listen to our cry when it goes up in the shrieks and blood of millions of women and children...We are desperate. We shall do it."


The foundation of the entire article is based on this statement. But is it actualy true, was the main reason Bulgaria got its independence from Ottoman Turkey because of the outrage certain European counries felt on hearing of the Turkish attrocities committed there?

 

I'd say it is patently false - Bulgarian independence resulted from the 1877-78 war between Turkey and Russia. The attrocities the Turks commited to some extent worked in Bulgaria's favour in the peace treaty, but it took a larger war involving Russia for the circumstances that (as a side issue) allowed Bulgarian independence to occur.

 

Thus, there is no logic behind ANY belief that prompting the Turks to commit attrocities would lead to Armenian independence. That is not to say some could believe it would - but the numbers who could believe such an obviously flawed theory would be very small, too small to make any impact. Ali - a "European intervention on behalf of the Armenians" is not the same as having a war fought by one or more European power against Turkey and about Armenians. There was no realistic possibility of such a war. Intervention, in this context, means diplomatic intervention.

 

Like Thoth said, "this whole Huchnack thing is far overplayed". Overplayed by the Turkish state who have found a ready made excuse to turn genocide into just an overly heavyhanded security operation. Overplayed by nationalistic Armenians who seem to need to boast about the martial spirit amongst Ottoman Armenians (which was, in reality, almost non existant).


I don't hate to admit, Steve, that I stand 100% behind your reply.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...