gamavor Posted November 9, 2006 Report Share Posted November 9, 2006 THE EU SHOULD BE PLAYING IRAN AND RUSSIA OFF AGAINST EACH OTHER Julian Evans Eurasian Home Analytical Resource, Russia Nov 8 2006 The European Union is increasingly anxious about being over-reliant on gas imports from Russia. The Kremlin, it is clear, intends to wield its huge oil and gas reserves as its main bargaining chip in foreign relations. The EU is concerned that its authoritarian neighbour to the east has it "over a barrel", as one British MP put it. Or, as the Daily Telegraph recently bewailed "The Russian bear could punch our lights out!" If the EU is serious about reducing its dependency on Russian gas, then it needs to look quickly at Russia's biggest gas rival - Iran. Iran is the second-biggest source of gas in the world. It has 18% of the world's gas supplies, compared to Russia's 25%, but experts believe over 60% of Iran's reserves are still undeveloped. The EU should be doing everything it can to foster competition between these two countries in the energy sphere. It should be striving to strike bilateral deals for Iranian gas, offering financial support for Iran's planned pipelines to India and Pakistan and other projects, and generally standing four-square with Iran over its global energy expansion. The argument the EU should make to Iran (and to America) is that the country is fighting last century's war by struggling to become a nuclear power. If Iran really wants to become a great power again, it should argue, it should seek to develop its energy markets and make the rest of the world - the US included - reliant on it. Energy, not nuclear missiles, is the new weapon of the twenty-first century great power. The sooner Iran lets go of its outdated ambitions to be a nuclear super-power, the quicker it can become a modern energy super-power. Iran should resist an energy alliance with Russia, the EU should argue, because Russia will always be in the driving seat. Gazprom only ever takes a controlling stake in projects, and it will involve itself in Iranian projects precisely with the object of protecting itself from Iranian competition and stymieing the development of Iran's gas resources. If Iran wants to develop its resources quickly, it should look to a more efficient and technologically developed partner, such as Total, OMV or Statoil. Western banks can bring far more capital to support Iranian energy projects than Russian banks ever could. But we are not seeing this energy alliance with Iran happen. Instead, we are seeing the EU once again outmanoeuvred by Gazprom, because Gazprom thinks two moves ahead, and the EU merely reacts, usually with panic and indignation. This weekend, Gazprom bought a controlling stake in its joint venture with Armenia, ArmRosGas, which controls Armenia's domestic gas distribution network and a soon-to-be-completed gas pipeline with Iran. That pipeline could have helped free both Armenia and Georgia from dependence on Russian gas, and also have been a conduit for Iranian gas into western Europe. But the Armenians, unwooed by the EU, sold the controlling stake to their Russian masters for $119 million. The same week that this deal was being signed in Moscow with Armenia's president, the petroleum minister of India, Murli Deorla, was also in town. He announced yesterday that India had agreed to let Gazprom join a planned pipeline from Iran to India and Pakistan. He said: "Russia will join the Iran pipeline. I spoke to Pakistan minister for petroleum and natural resources Amanullah Khan Jadoon (on Russian participation) on Tuesday and will be speaking to the Iranian minister later". So on the two most important new projects bringing Iranian gas to the outside world, Gazprom is involved, and possibly even in control. A good weekend's work, fellows. These appear to be the first decisive steps in a Kremlin initiative to forge an energy alliance with Iran. Also last week, Valery Yazev, head of the Duma energy committee and Gazprom's top lobbyist in the Duma, called for the creation of a gas cartel involving CIS countries, and including Iran, to counter the 'cartel' of European consumers. The plan was prompted, he said, by the refusal of France and Germany to be played off against the rest of Europe by president Putin, who offered Germany the chance to be a hub for Russian supplies to the rest of Europe when he visited Germany in September. Merkel refused, sensible lady. Alexander Medvedev, deputy chairman of Gazprom, yesterday told me that he viewed participation with Iran as "very profitable. We hope to use the joint venture to become involved in extraction and development [of Iranian gas], and possibly help supply gas through the joint venture to Western Europe, as well as Pakistan and India". So Russia is already a few steps ahead of the EU in this game. An energy alliance with Iran would tie up around 45% of the world's gas supplies. However, the game is not over yet. Luckily for us, the US and UK governments thought slightly ahead in the early 1990s, and secured both the BTC and Shah Deniz pipelines, which will bring oil and gas from Azerbaijan and Kazakhstan to Europe, without going through Russia. There is also a plan, now being put on the front-burner by the EU, to build a new Nabucco pipeline from the Caspian region to Austria, with OMV the main backer of the project. Gazprom has also asked to be involved in the project. Of course - as soon as the Kremlin signs the European Energy Charter. The project is intended to take Azeri gas, but should also take Iranian gas too. Am I being naïve, arguing for EU participation with Iran, for its support for Iran's gas industry, which will only enrich this dangerous and authoritarian country? Firstly, the lure of Iran becoming a global energy super-power might possibly be sufficient to persuade it away from its path of becoming a nuclear power, one of many all over the Middle East. It would never be a dominant nuclear power, but it could be a dominant gas power, one of the most powerful in the world. Secondly, when it comes to energy supplies, it's not a question of whether to work with illiberal authoritarian regimes or not. It's a question of trying to balance one authoritarian regime against another, so you're not too dependent on any one. Every energy power in the world, with the exception of Norway, is illiberal and authoritarian. Dick Cheney, for all his evilness, at least realizes this, and worked earlier than any EU bureaucrat to diversify CIS countries away from Moscow's control. We should be doing the same with Iran, though unfortunately the US seems to have decided on an altogether more direct method for securing Iranian energy supplies - and it is their belligerent rhetoric, and the EU's typically slow and confused energy policy, that is helping drive Iran and Russia together. Julian Evans, a British freelance journalist based in Moscow. November 8, 2006 http://www.eurasianhome.org/xml/t/opinion....ion&pid=558 --Boundary_(ID_IEsLAhhdop8tftogAcInsg)-- ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Very amateurish writing and understanding of energy policies, but I decided to repost it because it touches upon issues that needs to be discussed. The opinion expressed above is not different from the mainstream policy making thinking in the West. EU and USA complain that Russia "plays" with her natural resources. This is ridiculous. Of course Russia has every right to decide how to "play" with her assets. The West constantly brags about how bad Russia is how authoritarian the regime in Kremlin is but in the same time they want cheap gas and oil. I do believe that Iranians are smart enough to develop their nuclear program not to fell victim of Western "democracy" and that is what irritates the Americans and the British. I think Iran's nuclear program is the best guarantee that Europe WILL NOT be deprived of gas and oil sources and that the price of this precious commodity will remain stable despite the benevolent and noble intentions of BP, Exxon, Shell, etc.. to dictate and manipulate the prices. This is what irritates the British and American oil companies. The other well known fact that irritates them is that Iran and Russia can diversify the route of the oil flow to go directly into the heart of Europe, rather than being shipped via Turkish and other friendly to the Brits, Jews and Americans ports thus leaving them without real control over the traded amounts of oil and gas. What also irritates them is that by investing huge dollar amount into pipeline that circumvents Armenia, they were trapped twice. Firstly, the pipeline is not more secure by the simple fact that it goes around Armenia, and second the oil reserves of Azerbaijan will be gone in 2-3 years. Now with the introduction of Iran-Armenia pipeline with Gazprom in the project, the Brits should think about how to recognize the Armenian genocide. They know that French and German oil companies as well as other European powers will be welcomed to the Iran-Russia projects while Americans and Brits will be isolated and excluded maybe for good. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
zurderer Posted November 9, 2006 Report Share Posted November 9, 2006 and second the oil reserves of Azerbaijan will be gone in 2-3 years. any proof ? or Link? Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
gamavor Posted November 9, 2006 Author Report Share Posted November 9, 2006 http://www.infoplease.com/ipa/A0779169.html plus there will be "heat" season comming soon to Azerbaidjan from Kazakhstan and Turkmenistan. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
zurderer Posted November 9, 2006 Report Share Posted November 9, 2006 I did not see that azeri oil will finish 2-3 year. I think If It was reality, they would not build pipeline at Turkey. Heat season maybe beneficial or harmfull about azeris(so armenians.), but I can say, azeris have good allies.(USA, EU, Turkey.), but well Russia and iran is powerful too. Lets hope, USA attack iran, so Russia becomes alone. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
gamavor Posted November 9, 2006 Author Report Share Posted November 9, 2006 If USA attacks Iran, Turkey will be gone. Azeris have no friends in EU. They have interests. If you divide the proven oil reserves of Azveristan onto daily exploration amounts the oil in Azerbaijan will be gone in 2 years. If Iran is attacked, Baku-Jeihan is also gone with the wind. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
zurderer Posted November 9, 2006 Report Share Posted November 9, 2006 If USA attacks Iran, Turkey will be gone. correlation? Azeris have no friends in EU. They have interests. Interest is best friend.States becomes allies because of their interests. If you divide the proven oil reserves of Azveristan onto daily exploration amounts the oil in Azerbaijan will be gone in 2 years. understood, so azeris did what they can do. Do you realy think usa let other states to have her oil? If Iran is attacked, Baku-Jeihan is also gone with the wind. correlation? Politically we will not be harmed If a war happen between USA and Iran. Economically It is another issue. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
gamavor Posted November 9, 2006 Author Report Share Posted November 9, 2006 You will be harmed very sensibly because the type of the weapons that gone be used and the climatic conditions of the region. There is a trend of winds blowing East-West. Iranian leadership already warned USA that if they are being attacked they will blow up 'your' pipe. In case of military conflict between Iran and USA, Kurds will attack Turkey from within and out. I won’t be surprised if the Russians jump in because they have vital interests in South Caucasus. Russian submarines will block your Black Sea ports. If the conflict escalates Armenia and Greece will jump in too. You get the picture... Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
zurderer Posted November 9, 2006 Report Share Posted November 9, 2006 You will be harmed very sensibly because the type of the weapons that gone be used and the climatic conditions of the region. There is a trend of winds blowing East-West. Errr, I still did not understand much, I dont think usa will bomb border of turkey, and I dont think iran will bomb Turkey.. Iranian leadership already warned USA that if they are being attacked they will blow up 'your' pipe. Baku-Ceyhan? Be serious, do you realy think Iran want Turkey enemity? I think not. Specially not when she is surrounded by enemy usa states. In case of military conflict between Iran and USA, Kurds will attack Turkey from within and out. Giving too much importance to PKK, also still could not see correlation. I won’t be surprised if the Russians jump in because they have vital interests in South Caucasus. Be serious, Russia could not even protect serbia. Russian submarines will block your Black Sea ports. why? what is problem between russia and us? By the way, I dont realy think If a war happen, It is russia who blockade Turkey. Most probably It would be turkey who blocade russia. If the conflict escalates Armenia and Greece will jump in too. You get the picture... Most probably not, armenia is tiny and wont a problem for Turkey. Greece would attack turkey? are we talking about a new balkan war? Absolutely not. War would be between usa and iran. I dont think noone will try to interfere this war. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
gamavor Posted November 9, 2006 Author Report Share Posted November 9, 2006 Wake UP! It is 2006. Tiny Armenia may have big stick Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Takoush Posted November 9, 2006 Report Share Posted November 9, 2006 Gams jan; gentaneein megne ays chorin. Hoqit yev sirdet mi hadsener ays anasounin hamar. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
gamavor Posted November 9, 2006 Author Report Share Posted November 9, 2006 Hosum enk eli... Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
zurderer Posted November 10, 2006 Report Share Posted November 10, 2006 Wake UP! It is 2006. Tiny Armenia may have big stick Like israel? I can accept possibility of powerful armenia, but now It is powerless. You are economically bad situation, your people are lefting their country. Militaritically, You are no much for Turkey. You cannot give even any resistance. So sorry I think, in a short time. Tiny armenia is not a danger for Turkey. In reality, armenia is in a war for her survival. Becoming landlocked, surrounded with enemy states, and having a mafia goverment, poor and decreasing population. Sorry I cannot see a big stick there. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.