Rubo
Members-
Posts
385 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Never
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Events
Gallery
Everything posted by Rubo
-
Nairi jan I wrote it.
-
Mosjan I am a big fan of "System" and these young Armenians are doing great service to everyone.Kudos to SOD members. Weems of this world Human life is full of decisions, including significant choices about what to believe. Although everyone prefers to believe what is true, we often disagree with each other about what that is in particular instances. It may be that some of our most fundamental convictions in life are acquired by haphazard means rather than by the use of reason, but we all recognize that our beliefs about ourselves and the world often hang together in important ways. If I believe that whales are mammals and that all mammals are fish, then it would also make sense for me to believe that whales are fish. Even someone who (rightly!) disagreed with my understanding of biological taxonomy could appreciate the consistent, reasonable way in which I used my mistaken beliefs as the foundation upon which to establish a new one. On the other hand, if I decide to believe that Hamlet was Danish because I believe that Hamlet was a character in a play by Shaw and that some Danes are Shavian characters, then even someone who shares my belief in the result could point out that I haven't actually provided good reasons for accepting its truth. I needed to expand on some basic fundamentals of logic Fact is not a fact unless proven by logical evidence and the source of the evidence must be unbiased. For example Flat earth society members believe that the earth is flat therefore there is a definite edge when one can fall. The first proposition is highly subjective and based on believe system and devoid of any scientific argument therefore the conclusion is false. Genocide revisionists always based their propositions and “facts” on dubious sources and come to subjective conclusions. Just because a book is written by a revisionists it does not mean anything unless he or she back up with verifiable facts. Subjective arguments are not valid unless those arguments fall into category of logic. Weems arguments are laughable and have no logic. The guy is making thousand of dollars by making Turks feel good about themselves. By the way words like” facts about Armenian Genocide” which are so prevalent in Azeri and Turkish sites are meaningless scribbles without serious scholarly research. The fact is not a fact unless proven!
-
Dusts settle down on dry dessert road Corpses lying on top of each other Twisted bones, broken ribs scattered around the sand Turkish faces indifferent cold Sly grins coming out their minaret moustaches He just killed the doctor who saved his wife How thankful, how ironic… R.
-
What bothers me the most about the attack is Sharon’s shameful declaration of the attack as the “our biggest success” Incidentally the known war criminal Sharon indirectly responsible of killing thousands of innocent lives in Lebanon and Beirut refugee comps got away from prosecution in Belgian court. The main witness to testify against him got blown to pieces in Beirut days before court appearance-The circumstances of these happening points directly to Musad and Sharon. Sharon “We have no interest to hurt innocent civilians and are always sorry about civilians that are hurt but this action, according to me, is one of our biggest successes," Sharon said, "and of course obliges us to be on full state of alertness. "Civilian victims· Leila Safira, 40· Iman Shehade, 15· Mona Hweiti, 30· Sobhi Hweiti, 4· Mohammed Hweiti, 3· Mohammed Shawwa, 40· Ahmed Shawwa, 3· Iman Matar, 27· Daria Matar, 5· Mohammed Matar, 4· Aiman Matar, 18 months· Dunia Matar, 2 months· Alaa Matar, 11
-
Dear Hagarag,talking about Israel or any other country which mingles quote: in Armenian issues are fine considering Israel’s present land confiscation attempts and Denial policy and Jewish lobby efforts in Washington against Armenians. Your lap sided views are not of a person who cares about Armenia or Armenians but in fact you are acting like a syringe needle for the surgeon. Needless to say when the Turks were massacring Armenians, we had our ignorant priests who brainwashed our people to surrender to Turks in the hope of being saved but were ultimately butchered and now you are that priest trying to disparage, discourage and prevent Armenians from uniting and recognizing our adversaries and overcoming them.
-
Hagarag please do not read the space between the lines.The article is about Israel and nothing compares with I S R A E l:rolleyes:
-
Well said Nairi! It is time to organize and mobilize our goals and resources and stop blaming everything on Armenians.
-
Thanks Mosjan for the post,I had the pleasure to listen Djivan in concert and loved every minute.
-
Uri Avnery wrote for Global Peace Alliance Israel: ‘mad cow’ or simply maddened? Israel is the only state in the world that has a population of 200 percent. And that’s a fact. Public opinion polls show that it has two simultaneous majorities. One is peace-loving, the other supports extreme nationalism. At the present time, it looks like this: In every public opinion poll there is a large majority that supports the prime minister, Ariel Sharon. Sharon wants, of course, to enlarge the settlements, intensify the war against the Palestinians, eliminate their leader, Yasser Arafat, postpone a permanent solution and refuse any peace negotiations until unattainable conditions are met. Anyone who supports him must be a radical right-winger. But the very same public opinion polls also show that a majority agrees to withdraw from (almost) all the Occupied Territories, dismantle (almost) all settlements and accept the establishment of a Palestinian state in return for peace. How is this possible? Can a state have a population of more than 100 percent? If so, Israel is a very special country. This curious situation did not come about yesterday. It started long ago. I remember public opinion polls of more than 20 years ago, which also revealed two majorities. The first majority supported the idea of expelling all Arabs from the country west of the Jordan River. The second one supported a withdrawal from the West Bank and the Gaza Strip. Together with those who were against both proposals, this totaled 200 percent. Statisticians and sociologists examined, researched, shook their collective heads, shrugged their shoulders, raised both hands and thought: a crazy people. Doesn’t know what it wants. Mixed up. Schizophrenic. Suffering from a split personality. But the people were not mad at all. The professors just did not know how to read the polls. What the public tried to say was: If it were possible to drive out all the Arabs, that would be wonderful. If it’s impossible, let’s get the hell out of there. Why? For a simple reason: The one thing that unifies almost all Jewish Israelis is the wish to live in a state where there are only Jews. If we could achieve such a state in all the country between the Mediterranean and the Jordan River, OK. If not, let’s leave the Occupied Territories. Not “land for peace,” but “withdrawal for the sake of safeguarding a homogeneous Jewish state.” This is the majority opinion, and there is, indeed, only one majority. Some call this “racist.” Some call it “nationalist.” Some say that this is “apartheid.” But this attitude is rooted in the fact that for thousands of years, Jews have lived as a religious-ethnic community dispersed throughout the world and often suffered cruel persecution, especially in the Christian world. They have developed a ghetto mentality. They want to live among themselves, separated from others, surrounded by a high fence. Zionism wanted to achieve this by establishing a state where Jews would live together without Gentiles. Even the presence of a considerable minority the Arab citizens in Israel creates severe mental stress. For most Israelis, the ideal situation would be a state without a single non-Jewish citizen. The presence of foreign workers does not bother anybody; it is temporary, and they are devoid of any rights. Lately this aspiration has found new expression in an idea which is becoming quite popular: to transfer the Arab-Israeli villages adjoining the West Bank, together with their inhabitants, to the future Palestinian state, which means giving up territory so that Israel will have less non-Jewish citizens. This is quite unusual. The French, for example, have shed rivers of blood in order to keep Alsace, whose people are of German descent. India is ready to wage a nuclear war in order to keep Kashmir, which is populated by Muslims. For other nations, territory is more important than a homogeneous population, geography precedes demography. Israelis, too, like territory but demography is by far more important to them. One example: After the 1956 war, during which Israel conquered the Sinai and the Gaza Strip, David Ben-Gurion was compelled to give up the Sinai. At the time there was a clamor from right and left to annex the Gaza Strip. Ben-Gurion refused because he did not want to increase the number of Arab citizens by hundreds of thousands at any price. (The idea of an eternal military occupation, which allows the occupier to abstain from conferring citizenship on the occupied population, was not yet invented.) Today, too, there is only one majority in Israel. Most Israelis are ready to pay the price demanded for peace. So why do they support Sharon, who represents the opposite? For one simple reason: They have been brought to believe that “we have no partner.” There is unanimity from Avigdor Liberman and Effy Eitam on the right to Haim Ramon and Yossi Sarid on the “left” that “there is no partner.” And since there is no partner for peace, let’s support Sharon, who knows (or so it seems) how to wage war. The aim of this brainwashing is precisely to make it possible to keep the Occupied Territories and drive the Palestinians out. The real criminal in this story is Ehud Barak. In order to hide his monumental failure as a peacemaker, he created the legend that “we offered them everything and they rejected everything.” This historic lie is the connecting link between the two seemingly contradictory results of the polls: The majority is ready to pay the price of peace but does not believe that peace is possible. So they support Sharon. There is no riddle here. Israel is not a mad cow. It is, at most, a maddened cow. Uri Avnery, founder of Gush Shalom, an Israeli peace group, wrote this commentary for the Global Peace Alliance
-
I advise Armenians to do exactly what jews would have done if those comments were made against them-give him letter protest Hell so next time he won't mistake us for silent Mexicans! I advocate active protest measures against peole who are actively work against us.Kudos to ANCA and I am proud memeber myself.
-
Naivety of some Armenians about politics is becoming a sad footnote in our turbulent history. After monitoring Zionist tactics of silencing legitimate criticism about Israel or Armenian Genocide denial I am left hugely disappointed that so called patriotic Armenians are playing sitting ducks or shall I say people who forgot the meaning of fighting back. Raffee one of my favorite writers even wrote a whole book about Armenian subservient mentality in Iran in 19 century. It is ironic that even discussing anything Jewish related our red flags go up. One should ask a legitimate question why is that? Why is that Jewish groups can harass journalists, politicians, professors and deny the Armenian Genocide and get away with it without outrage and at best muted response. We cannot criticize without the red flags going up. The writing on the red flags is boldly printed “anti-Semitism” The credit is due to decades of vigilant work by Jews to program American public with convenient defense tactic even our Armenian friends are effected. They would not touch anything that has Jewish shtick. Bravo, feel proud that you as Armenian are hopelessly fell victim to the propaganda. Jews groups can spit on our history but we cannot say anything! Jews can monopolize holocaust but we should be happy with “alleged” so called genocide. Zionists can squash any opposition but we hopelessly play to their tune of “ant-Semitism” Enough said. How long must we take it on the chin! Regards Rubo
-
who dares to criticise Israel ?? Robert Fisk: I am being vilified for telling the truth about Palestinians 'The abuse being directed at anyone who dares to criticise Israel is reaching McCarthyite proportions' But the degree of abuse and outright threats now being directed at anyone - academic, analyst, reporter - who dares to criticise Israel (or dares to tell the truth about the Palestinian uprising) is fast reaching McCarthyite proportions. Take Edward Said, the brilliant Palestinian academic who is a professor at Columbia University. He has been facing unprecedented abuse from the Zionist Organisation of America, which last year demanded that he be fired from the Modern Language Association and which now demands on an almost daily basis his dismissal from his professorship at Columbia - solely because he points out, with clinical ferocity and painful accuracy, the historical tragedy of Palestinian dispossession, the brutality of Israel's continued occupation and the bankruptcy of the Oslo "peace" agreement. Columbia University has issued an unprecedented public defence of Said and "the fundamental values of a great university", quoting John Stuart Mill and adding that to give way to the Jewish lobby's demand would be "a threat to us all and to academic freedom". Too true. Noam Chomsky - himself Jewish - is one of the most profound philosophers of our age, but his scathing reviews of the Israeli occupation and America's blind, unquestioning support for Israel now earn him ever more ruthless abuse. In the United States, he wrote recently, a whole population is kept in ignorance of the facts because "the economic and and military programmes (of Israel) rely crucially on US support, which is domestically unpopular and would be far more so if its purposes were known." Ignorance of the Middle East is now so firmly adhered to in the US that only a few tiny newspapers report anything other than Israel's point of view. You won't find Chomsky in The New York Times. It was put very well by Charlie Reese in a recent issue of the Orlando Sentinel - note the boondocks location - when he wrote that "Palestinians won't get their independence until Americans get theirs". But the attempt to force the media to obey Israel's rules is now international. We must say that Israel is under siege by Palestinians (rather than occupying Palestinian land), that Palestinians are responsible for the violence (even though Palestinians are the principal victims), that Arafat turned down a good deal at Camp David (though he was offered just over 60 per cent of his land, not 94 per cent), and that Palestinians indulge in child sacrifice (rather than question why the Israeli troops have shot so many Palestinian children). Israeli ambassadors and Israel's lobbyists have never been such frequent visitors to European newspaper offices, to complain about reports or reporters, sometimes in a quite disgraceful manner. The Johannesburg Star - a sister paper of The Independent which carries my own Middle East reports - was confronted by one pro-Israeli group this year which claimed that I was in some way assisting the right-wing historian David Irving - someone I have never met and never wish to meet. They subsequently withdrew their allegation. Then an odd thing happened in Ireland - at a prize-giving ceremony in memory of a Belfast journalist. Mark Sofer, Israel's ambassador in Dublin, had been invited to talk about reporting in conflict zones to journalism students under the auspices of Co-operation Ireland, a charitable movement dedicated to North-South relations. But at one point he chose to use the opportunity to attack my own reporting of the Middle East, to suggest that it should not be read or believed. Mr Sofer is, of course, entitled to his views - but not to air his prejudices in a charitable forum without allowing a right of reply. The charity has since announced that it "totally dissociates itself" from the ambassador's remarks. So it should. And yet it goes on. In South Africa, in Europe, in Australia - I still treasure the five pages of abuse in an Australian lobby group's magazine headlined "The Ignoble Scribe" and accusing me of a "stupor of self-deception". Oddly, you can now learn more from the Israeli press than the American media. The brutality of Israeli soldiers is fully covered in Ha'aretz, which also reports on the large number of US negotiators who are Jewish. Four years ago, a former Israeli soldier described in an Israeli newspaper how his men had looted a village in southern Lebanon; when the piece was reprinted in The New York Times, the looting episode was censored out of the text. So here's just one final question. If Arab ambassadors and lobbyists behaved like their Israeli opposite numbers, would we listen to them? Would we respect them? Would we run for cover and print only one side of the story? Would we hell.
-
ISRAEL SAID TO SEIZE ARMENIAN PATRIARCHATE LAND NEAR BETHLEH
Rubo replied to MosJan's topic in † Armenian Apostolic Church
Things I do not understand about some Armenians. When we get really screwed on all fronts by Jews we got nothing but pale retrospective self blaming lame excuses but when it comes to scoring a point with fellow Armenians we waste no effort to squish him down. Isn’t this classic subservient slave mentality we are so used to seeing? Would the Jews stand passively and watch Armenian originations deny the Holocaust? No shit! They won’t stand passively. I can just imagine Newspaper headlines “Armenians are denying the Holocaust “ The harassing phone calls etc. Mr.Hagarag Robert Fisk, journalist from independent had a death threat on his life from a Zionist for covering Middle East objectively! The Zionist tactic of suppressing the real facts in Middle East is well documented. Armenians should intensify their efforts in showing their displeasure to those Jewish organizations that actively deny the AG and pursue distractive policies against Armenia. No real Armenian should stay idle and let our interests squashed down without a political fight. I strongly advocate massive demonstrations against the Jewish organizations in Washington next time around AG issue comes around with the same results. I have pride my friends. I care less what few brave less brainwashed self-blaming “Armenians” think. We should not fall into that sticking trap of Anti-Semitism BS. Injustice is injustice regardless whose chosen people are the culprits. -
Dear H. I am sorry I did not mean to ignore you.Your points are volid points! if they admit they have rabiz in them then who am I to argue?
-
Mosjan as everything in life music becomes the mirror to who we really are. If the rabiz demand is big which it is then should I not feel down that the Turkofied Armenians are winning and diluting our music to second rate Turkish mambo jumbo. I went to numerous weddings and by far Harut P. and Nersik gave great dancing numbers without wailing like Turkish mullahs. I am bet of a purist as you can tell. I observe the biginnigs of the disintegration of our culture to second-rate derivative Middle Eastern BS. Armenians are unique people. They are neither middle eastern nor Europeans but somewhere in the middle and precisely of this that our songs and melodies are truly unique. Unfortunately Diaspora Armenians as well as homlanders just simply put Armenian words to Greek, Arabic or Turkish music and call it Armenian. It simply repaginates me. If I want to listen Greek, Arabic or Turkish music I will listen the originals, why would I listen second-rate imitations? Have you seen any Turkish singers trying to sound Armenian? Could you not agree that our subservient people are just acting out the residues of Ottoman legacy?
-
ISRAEL SAID TO SEIZE ARMENIAN PATRIARCHATE LAND NEAR BETHLEH
Rubo replied to MosJan's topic in † Armenian Apostolic Church
Hagarag>Again you are relating the present circumstances instead of asking how we got to this point of no return. Rubo> I do not see the situation as no point of return. Your question of how we got into present situation is a valid one, which the answer any logical person can conclude does depend on not just Yerevan but Tel Aviv as well. Mr. Hagarag how do you know if Ter Petrosian and Kocharian administastion did not make an attempts to forge closer ties with Israel but basically rejected by Israel based on latter’s close ties with our arch adversary Turkey and Azerbaijan. During Azerbaijan conflict Israel did provide logistical support and food rations and military hardware via Turkey to Azerbaijan. You also avoiding once again Israeli, Jewish lobby efforts in Washington to deny the AG and other issues as well!!!!!!! Could you please bring me an example when Armenia since independence lobbied against Israel or denied Holocaust? So how is Armenia anti Israel just because she chooses to forge friendly relations with other nations? Hagarag>If Ankara can hold its close ties to Israel while forging ties to Teheran and the Palestinians, why can't Yerevan build closer ties to Israel? Rubo>Israel does not need Armenia as much as Turkey and Israel will not upset its relations with Turkey to do so! Again it is not all depended on Yerevan! Hagarag>Must a local Armenian Bishop be the only one to try to build ties with the Jews? Until our Church hierarchy is cleansed of anti--Jewish sentiments our situation in Israel will continue to deteriorate. Rhetorical comment without substance, Yerevan is on constant contact with Israel and you should be careful of raising the classical Jewish defense tactic of Anti-Semitism. When Jerusalem Armenians get trashed by Hasidic Jews I hoped you also wrote a protest comment in Jewish forums or you also blamed the Armenians. -
ISRAEL SAID TO SEIZE ARMENIAN PATRIARCHATE LAND NEAR BETHLEH
Rubo replied to MosJan's topic in † Armenian Apostolic Church
Dear Hagarag, your reasoning of blaming Armenians based on Yerevan’s ideological stance is severely hollow. Armenia did not supply Palestinians with weapons, Israelis have supplied to Turkey! Armenians did not lobby against Jewish interests in Washington but Israelis have lobbied against Armenian interests repeatedly!!!Which you seem to minimize. So based on your reasoning we should go ahead and deny the Holocaust, confiscate Jewish properties anywhere in the world and say well we were justified since Jews asked for it. Furthermore you do not seem to know the extent of the issue with our church property problems in Israel so I will give you the info. ARMENIAN PATRIARCHATE OF JERUSALEM P.O.Box 14235 Jerusalem, israel 91141 Contact: Fr. Pakrad Bourdjekian Tel: 9722-626-4866; FAX: 6264862 E-Mail: armre@netvision.net.il NOTE: The following is the Armenian Patriarchate's detailed official statement about the situation concerning the Patriarchate's property at Baron Der (Bethlehem) Armenian Patriarchate's View On The Baron Der Issue The property of Baron Der is so named after a renowned and saintly Armenian Patriarch, Grigor Baron Der (1560-1645), who used it as a retreat for devotion and hermitage. According to historical documents, the said Patriarch lived there, and since then the place was used by Armenian clergy for worship, reclusion, and meditation. Located north of Aida camp - Bethlehem and south of Tantour, Baron Der consists of approximately 143 dunums of archaeological land with ancient caves and tombs, as well as hundreds-of-years-old olive trees (1600 trees) in the vicinity. Within the property, in the south, stands a monastic building, which serves as residence for Armenian monks who officiate in the Nativity Church of Bethlehem. Armenian monks from Jerusalem also go there for their annual retreat and spiritual training. The Baron Der matter began long before the issuing of a military order by the State of Israel through its Chief Commander for the West Bank, General Itshaq Eitan, and the Head of the Israeli Ministry of Defense, General Amos Yaron, to construct a security fence separating the Palestinian areas from Jerusalem. The incursion of the IDF into the said property during mid-2001 can be considered a preliminary step toward the construction of the security fence, which the Ministry of Defense is aiming to execute. THE ISSUE 1. During the first week of May 2001 the IDF, without notifying the Armenian Patriarchate, broke into the convent of Baron Der with the excuse of security reasons. Upon the Patriarchate's complaint, the Ministry of Defense issued a 6-month seizure order of the property, on the 16th of May 2001. The IDF not only took possession of the said property, but also did not show respect towards the monastic building, thereby destroying and causing enormous interior and exterior damages to the convent and to the property as well. Because of the siege imposed on the Bethlehem area, the Patriarchate had to suffer in silence, hoping the encirclement would end, and then deal with the issue. The Patriarchate enumerated the IDF-caused damages and sent to them to the Ministry of Defense together with a letter of complaint on the 14th of September 2001. 2. On the 27th of August 2001, during the incursion into the region of Beith Jala, the IDF destroyed the wall enclosing the Baron Der convent and trampled down the ancient olive trees under its tanks. In preliminary preparation, the tanks opened the security road, which today the Ministry of Defense aims to convert into a separation wall and a security road between the West Bank and Israel. Armenian monks from Bethlehem went there immediately to request that the IDF leave the property and deal with the compensation of the extensive damages they had caused thereto. This request was left without a response. The Armenian Patriarchate's architect visited the property and enumerated the damages, estimated at approximately 77,000 USD. Through its attorney, the Patriarchate issued a letter of complaint, together with the request for compensation on the 14th of September 2001. 3. Receiving no reply from the Ministry of Defense with regard to the damages caused by the IDF during their incursion into the Beith Jala and Bethlehem areas, on the 27th of November 2001, the Armenian Patriarchate appealed in writing to the Italian Consul General, to the Special Representative of the United Nations Development Programme, and to the Minister of Public Works of the Palestinian Authority in Ramallah, for the restorative renovations of the said damages. 4. On the 20th of December 2001, the IDF responded to the Armenian Patriarchate's letter of complaint, denying the intrusion of the IDF into the Patriarchate's property, and asserting that, in their view, the IDF had never entered the said property and had not caused any of the damages stated in the Patriarchate's letter of complaint. The IDF further added that if the Patriarchate had any kind of dissatisfaction, it could write to the committee of insurance and lawsuits of the Ministry of Defense. 5. On the 14th of January 2002, the Armenian Patriarchate received a letter from the Ministry of Defense, stating that they were considering the issue based on the Patriarchate's letter of complaint, dated the 14th of September 2001. 6. On the 25th of March 2002, the Armenian Patriarchate sent a letter requesting an appropriate response by the Ministry of Defense. This was never answered. 7. On the 21st of April 2002, The IDF paved a military road, starting from main road of Gilo and passing through the Baron Der property, thereby dividing said property into two useless plots and reaching the main road to Bethlehem. When paving the road, the IDF destroyed the tombs and the antiquities and uprooted many of the hundreds-of-years-old olive trees. The representative from the Armenian Patriarchate, Fr. Pakrad, went to Baron Der and met with the Ministry of Defense advisor and IDF representative, Commander Amitai Levi, who stated that the road is only for temporary use, and as soon as the situation in the region calms down, they would restore the area as it had been before. They also requested that the Patriarchate allow them to lease the Baron Der convent as their headquarters, which the Patriarchate refused. They further promised to put this request in writing, which they never did. The Patriarchate convened an immediate Synod meeting regarding this matter. 8. Until the 23rd of May 2002, the Armenian Patriarchate persistently contacted Commander Amitai Levi, asking for the terms of their request in writing, but to no avail. The Patriarchate issued a new letter of complaint to the Ministry of Defense on the 23rd of May 2002, stating the following: a. Recently the IDF opened a road of 1000 meters in length within the Armenian Patriarchate's property called Baron Der, and this without the consent and the knowledge of the Patriarchate. The IDF is aiming to construct a separation wall, which can cause enormous damages to the sacred property. b. During the meetings of the Armenian Patriarchate's representatives with the Ministry of Defense, it was suggested and agreed that the wall to be constructed shall be the existing wall, separating the Baron Der property from Aida refugee camp. c. The Armenian Patriarchate requested the Ministry of Defense give the necessary orders to the IDF to act accordingly so as not to cause any further damages to the Patriarchate and to its property. 9. On the 19th of June 2002, The Ministry of Defense and the IDF invited the representatives of the Greek and Armenian Patriarchates to meet at the site of the conflict and discuss the issue. During that meeting, Fr. Pakrad objected to the plan and repeatedly demanded that the road be moved to the existing wall separating the Baron Der property from Aida refugee camp. 10. As a result to the requests, the representative of the IDF and Ministry of Defense, Shmuel Hamburger, on the 23rd of June 2002, delivered to the Armenian Patriarchate a military order of laying hand on the Baron Der property. This order was issued a long time after the opening of the military road within said property, thereby dividing it into two useless plots, contrary to the Patriarchate's consistent objections. The order was issued by the State of Israel through its Chief Commander for the West Bank, General Itshaq Eitan, and the Head of the Israeli Ministry of Defense, General Amos Yaron, in order to construct a security fence separating the Palestinian areas from Jerusalem. The area is located north of Aida refugee camp - Bethlehem, and south of Tantour. 11. On the 25th of June 2002, for the second time, the Armenian Patriarchate ordered its architect to prepare a project for the reconstruction of the wall demolished by the IDF. The Bill of Quantities for this project was estimated at 311,757 USD. 12. On the 26th of June 2002, upon the invitation of the Ministry of Defense, the Armenian Patriarchate's attorney, Advocate Mazen Qupty, and representatives from the Patriarchate went to Tel Aviv to meet with the representatives of the Ministry of Defense and the IDF. During the meeting, the Ministry of Defense representative, Mr. Shlomo Alon, stated that they are ready to reduce the width of the road from 50 meters to 27 meters, but they are not willing to move the road to the existing wall separating Baron Der property from Aida refugee camp for security reasons. He stated that the road that the Defense Ministry is planning to construct should become like the frontier between Jordan and Israel. He also added that the Ministry of Defense is interested in leasing the existing convent as their headquarters. The Patriarchate representatives rejected such a proposal and requested a reconsideration of this plan, for which purpose a Synod meeting was convened. 13. On the 10th of July 2002, a meeting was convened at the Armenian Patriarchate's Real Estate Office between the Patriarchate's representatives, Advocate Mazen Qupty, and the representatives of the Ministry of Defense and IDF, headed by Mr. Shlomo Alon. The Patriarchate's request to move the security fence and the road to the existing wall separating the Baron Der property from Aida refugee camp was not granted. 14. Having reached an impasse, on the 14th of July 2002, the Armenian Patriarchate, through Advocate Mazen Qupty, issued a file of appeal regarding its objections to the Ministry of Defense's plan to build a security fence running through the Baron Der property and delivered said file of appeal to the Appeal Court in Tel Aviv. 15. The issue was taken up by the worldwide media. Articles were published concerning the said issue, sometimes misrepresenting the geographical location of the said property. Local newspapers discussed the fact that the holy site of Rachel's Tomb, which is not far from the Baron Der property, was not taken within the security fence. Clarifications on the Baron Der Question: 16. The Baron Der property is a sacred and archaeological site within the region. Ever since 2001, Armenian monks have been unable to go on their annual retreats there because of the current situation within the region. 17. The letter of clarification from the Embassy of Israel in Tbilisi to the Foreign Ministry of Armenia, stating that the IDF temporarily seized 27 meters wide and 300-400 meters long agricultural land is not correct. The Ministry of Defense has stated that the security fence is intended to be a separation wall between the West Bank and Israel. Thus, the security fence will divide the sacred property into two useless plots. Conclusion: Despite all the efforts of the Armenian Patriarchate to avoid any such conflicts, and despite all the correspondence of the Patriarchate to reach a better understanding for a fair agreement on the issue, the Patriarchate's requests were not granted and its letters were not answered. The Armenian Patriarchate has no other alternative than, on the one hand, to turn to the local and international media, and on the other hand, to appeal to the High Court of Justice against such a plan. Prepared by Fr. Pakrad Bourjekian On the 20th of July 2002 Armenian Patriarchate Real Estates Office Jerusalem Email: armre@netvision.net.il -
ISRAEL SAID TO SEIZE ARMENIAN PATRIARCHATE LAND NEAR BETHLEH
Rubo replied to MosJan's topic in † Armenian Apostolic Church
Hagarag>So, if we claim to be "one" with the Palestinians, we will be treated as the Palestinians are treated. Dear Hagarag, your analysis is fundamentally flawed. Armenian concerns are not equitable with Palestinian issues although they intersect at times. Jewish lobbing against Armenian interests has nothing to do with Palestinians and everything to do with Israeli ally Turkey. Please do not confuse the issue, incidentally why are you quiet about Israeli attempts to confiscate Armenian lands? -
Dear Mosjan,You asked what other Armenian music I listen to ,so here we go. Armenian pop. Ruben Haghverdian,early Harut Papughjian, Nune, Nersik Ispirian, Havanes Badalian( his got some great fast tempo hyerenasirakan songs) etc. Classical and Traditional Komitas, Aram Khachadurian ( I got outstanding recording in flute piano concerto by my Serbian friend Nikola Radan) Allan Hovaness, Arno Babajanian, Richard Hagopian( perhaps finest oud player out there)Ensemble Akounk, Ensemble Saoun ( heart warming Armenian music) Ensemble Hay folk, Grigor Arakelian,Tagharan Armenian Sacred Music of the 5th-13th Centuries, Armenian women’s choral music etc. I loath Rabiz singers.Their severe distorted music is simply Turkish music with Armenian words.When listening to Sasun and Mush Armenian music one is being overwhelmed by its purity of sound and this despite of living amongst ottomans for six hundred years. Listening Rabiz reminds me of Islamic tradition of mosque singers when the tonality goes up and down with a wailing sounds. Unfortunately the reason Rabiz are popular in Armenia is that lot of Armenians are just Ottomanized Armenians and the music they hear sound close to their heart. This does upset me. Our musical pundits all in the name of patriotism are achieving what the Ottoman sword could not have achieved! Regards to all
-
Dear H, I rather skip political correctness and get down dirty! Aram Assaderian is just plain opportunistic mediocre singer who simply sings Turkish music but in Armenian. Total rabiz. If you think he sings Armenian music then you might need to refresh your repertoire. Closest Armenian pop musician comes to mind is Nune. I was in a wedding in LA and you guessed it Aram was the singer and I can tell you that what noises he made did not sound pleasant and I was not alone in this regard. Needless to say I was relived when finally I had to leave the wedding. The sad part is that our people encourage mediocre singers as true Artists hence the real Artists suffer since the field is occupied by bunch of Vodka shish kebob singers who are more interested in making a buck then care about the content of their frogy croaks! Regards Rubo
-
Hi Acc.I am glad you are ok.You did learn an important lesson "never trust an idiot". I came close to die twice in auto accidents and somehow survived but I became fearless. I ride Suzuki sportmotorcycle as a passion and I face death on daily bases. Somehow overcoming difficult life threatening sports does make you feel totally alive, I am thinking racers, mountain climbers etc. So on the bright side you may have conquered your fear of death. Regards Rubo
-
Dear Sip, you wrote “And everytime I hear chants of "We Armenains Hate All Turks" I get even more depressed ... well, I don't hate all turks ... so am I not an Armenian then?” Being Armenian is not synonymous with hating Turks. I do not hate Turks in general but I do react negatively to AG deniers. I am sure you guys already had plenty discussions of what it means being an Armenian so I will pass this subject. My general sentiment was that even though I consciously do not hate any groups in particular however when dealing with the past, I have a difficulty overcoming the AG. Perhaps you may be right if I do spend time in Turkey, it may change my outlook about lot of things. I am glad that we had an opportunity to meet electronically at least. One reason why I like forums like this is that we can learn from each other’s experiences. Take care
-
Barev Hayerin! I feel like drinking nice cold Armenian beer right now. Yep, this feels great! Yeah, I feel like celebrating, our adversaries are just crumbling on their own without any involvement from our side. EU over human rights, Alievs weird kigdom transvering to his son are kicking Azerbaijan in the ass. Turkey’s financial ruin just makes things sweeter! So I can say more but you get my drift… This beer is truly awesome! Kenatsner bolorit.
-
Sip I was talking about a TV program about Turkey. I guess you are lucky that you can dissociate the Armenian experience in Turkey and enjoy the little Touristy activities. I am by profession an Artist and having immersed myself in Armenian Genocide resulted in creation of paintings, which were extremely hard on me. I was there metaphorically and lived the horror of it all and since then, I am trying to find answers that satisfy me. Every time I read a newspaper report or watch a TV programs on Turks, I become biased since I expect them to also talk about the Armenian experience as well and negating this does affect me negatively. Denial can also be accomplished by intentional omission. The pluck in front of Ani entrance says absolutely nothing about Armenians even though Armenians built it, and it had over one thousand Armenian architectural gems. I know I would be upset, if I were traveling in Turkey and found all kinds of historical omissions and distortions. I know I will be one annoying Tourist when my Turkish guide resort to say Sinan was a Turk, I would stick my neck out and correct” excuse me sir but he was an Armenian” and see him get pissed and so on. God bless you guys and together we will overcome and build a prosperous healthy Armenia.
-
Seriously Accelerated, how did you decided on Accelerated! I mean where are you rushing to? I have been pretty fare when comes to Turks in general since I am not a racist and do not support people as such, but I am also product of my own brand of brainwashing.I can't take the Armenian genocide out of me which means I can not take the Turks out of me either. I am forever a part of this. I can forgive the Turks but only if they also show sincere remorse.Every time any Turk denies the AG, I can't help but feel negatively towards that perticular person hence the cycle...
