Boghos
Members-
Posts
1,746 -
Joined
-
Last visited
-
Days Won
4
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Events
Gallery
Everything posted by Boghos
-
Was there any chance that establishing relations with Turkey wouldn't be conditional on resolving the Karabagh question? I really doubt it and expressed such concept previously. Most articles against the protocols state that Armenia is giving up everything and getting nothing in return. I fail to see the evidence of such hysterical claims. Were the Armenian authorities to answer every single typical nationalist Turkish statement they would do nothing but that. Mind you, I am no supporter of the current government to put it mildly. I think and have said so several times that they are a disgrace, but that doesn't mean that dealing with Turkey and Azerbaijan is not desirable. It is. I remain convinced that good thing will come out of these protocols. One is mistaken in the belief that these negotiations were done between Sargsyan and the Turks but I will rest here and wait for the facts to unfold. The other mistake is to believe that the current status of Karabagh and the relations with Turkey make any sense. They don't. We cannot play 3 monkeys here.
-
The interview with Davitoglou is interesting but what he says is totally predictable, no? As expected Armeno-turco relations are conditional on settling the Karabagh issue. Are there better alternatives to the one being currently pursued?
-
As far as I know Madagascar was considered as a destination for the Jewish diaspora but not by them but by European powers. I have never heard of Vancouver as a possibility. Actually I am not aware of any such plans for Armenians (ie purchasing land for a new "homeland") only for the Jews.
-
We should devote many years to Gomidas (Vartabed or not).
-
One of my favourite XX century composers...Camrgo Guarnieri, after Villa Lobos the best Brazilian composer.
-
Zareh, Gabi Gomide as it existed in Soviet times had obvious limitations but did accomplish a few things that should be respected. There was a sense of purpose. The current incarnation should be renamed State Committee for Travel to the Diaspora. Just another meaningless bureaucratic entity that promises a lot and doesn't deliver one thing. In my book that is called lying.
-
It is so common to see Armenian politicians inventing facts that is no longer funny. The most tragicomic fact in what concerns the diaspora was the reinvention of the State Committee for Relations with Diaspora with Madam Hakobyan at the helm.
-
Gentlemen, ladies, I strongly suggest you read the various articles on Hetq.am about Armenoturco relations.
-
The Freemasons? The doenme? The Vulcans? The Simpsons?
-
That's exactly what I think as well. I hope the Armenia leadership understands that and can use it for the country's benefit. I have seen many arguments for not opening the borders, none whatsoever show Armenia losing. Armenia is a real country not a troupe singing Bank Ottoman day and night. As you mention Armenian is a small country, these are usually the free riders in international relations. It is a matter of record and it makes total sense. In playing along we have many ways we can benefit. Or we can be the Albania pre-1989.
-
Rizkallah Jorge, that's how they spell his name here was a major benefactor of the Armenian Church, you can also find his name in a building not so far from here. What I find most interesting about the Marash book is how usually precise the information is. I cannot find (not that I looked ) such a comprehensive book on an Armenian city anywhere. Some of the founding members of the Sao Paulo Chapter were very close relatives but as you can see none from my direct family. Do note that Bilezikians = protestant, Bilezikjians = Apostolic.
-
Excellent find. I was in Tartous last year, during Eid. One of my best friends from Aleppo is coming here next February. Unfortunately he is not from Marash .
-
Yes. Now that the protocols are signed we can hear more noise coming from Turkey whereas the Armenians and Armenia seem to have understood very quickly that they were signed and that there is nothing to be done about it. Turkey is acting as it is because it needs to do it, not because it really has a choice. They'll make all kinds of apparently contradictory statements but in the end parliament should ractify them. The reason is simple: this whole protocols business is just a politically convoluted way of getting done what has been agreed upon: establishing diplomatic relations with Armenia and opening the border. Armenia did not and does not have a choice: it will establish relations with Turkey and since it never closed the border, it will just wait until the Turks open their door. I cannot find any argument whatsoever to say that if things happens as I expect that Armenia will be harmed. Now as to Karabagh (Arpa jan: that's how they call themselves, let's not mirror the whole Turkey-turkey-Turkiye nonsense): I think it is highly unlikely that a solution to Karabagh was not discussed and agreed upon. Time will tell if that is true and what it is. Turkey gains considerable legitimacy having direct relations with Armenia and may even be an important part of the whole process.
-
Agreed. Opening the diplomatic relations are a symptom. A positive one for us.
-
One thousand times sorry I had overlookd this thread completely...I'll be back...
-
http://www.time.com/time/world/article/0,8...1903175,00.html apologies if it has been posted already
-
Armenia and Turkey will likely sign the protocols for the establishment of diplomatic relations that will lead to opening the borders. In the diaspora there has been tremendous dissatisfaction with the protocols, witness the manifestations in various cities during Sargsyan visits. But the diaspora unsurprisingly misses the point. Signing of the protocols and opening the borders may be one of the very few meaningful acts by an Armenian politician ever since Armenia became independent that is not of a self serving nature. It can easily be argued that such undertaking is not a result of Armenia or Turkey's initiatives or desires. Actually I am inclined to think that were it left to either of these countries the normalization of relations would take a long time to take place if ever. I confess that I am not very much interested on what motivated Turkey to agree to move forward and even state that Karabagh is not conditional to establishing relations with Armenia. I do think however that Turkey always be a wolf in sheep's cloth. But that would be the case with closed borders as well and in fact there is nothing new in it. Hence taking a very simplistic approach to this issue I think only two things matter: what Armenia is to gain and what will it cost. What Turkey will gain seems to be clear: US and European goodwill that was in great part lost by its reduced importance after the end of the Cold War and its stance in Irak. This goodwill may show itself in various forms but none that I can see detrimental to the interests of Armenia. For Armenia the economic gains are obvious: the country already imports hundreds of millions of dollars in goods from Turkey that go through Georgia, this thankfully will no longer be the case. Goods will be cheaper and we won't have to rely on the least reliable of neighbours. Also most likely there will be a larger amount of goods and potentially services being offered. Yes, Armenia having remained closed and with such a small and inefficient market for several reasons, probably cannot compete with Turkey on say textiles and candy manufacture. But neither can Georgia, Russia, or any European country. These are realities that we have to face and deal with it instead of sticking our heads into a hole, and a very expensive hole at that. I would be one of the last ones to brag about Armenia's capabilities and potential, I would be more inclined to think about the terrible effects of the brain drain and the monopolies that profit unduly from the little wealth that most Armenian citizens have at their disposal. Not because I am a pessimist but rather because I know how difficult it is and it will be to develop under the current circumstances. But we have no choice. We can't wait until a given set of undefined auspicious conditions allow us to be in better standing with the neighbors. Things just don't happen that way. Opening the borders is a major positive economically and hopefully politically as well. Now the cost. The fact is that Armenia had very little in terms of bargaining power with Turkey. Its leverage is probably more a result of Turkey's ambitions in other arenas and the US desire to have Turkey as a stabilizing factor in an otherwise very unstable region. Good relations with Armenia are thus easily accomplished as Turkey does not have to give anything up. But what does Armenia pay for that? Almost nothing. Or who is to believe that Genocide recognition on the part of Turkey was ever in the agenda? or giving up inexistent territorial claims? or any other fantasies that the diaspora entertains but have virtually no relation with what can be achieved now? The diaspora and particularly its most recalcitrant interest groups are behaving according to a script that is not new or unexpected. But who is to say that this behavior is also in the best interest of the Republic of Armenia? Armenia has to move forward. I am not saying that there is not some bad taste left after reading the protocols. But that's just one contract that can be rewritten when possible and necessary. Not an excuse to remain paralyzed while the country is in an unreasonable situation.
-
[ 2009/10/08 | 17:41 ] region Turkey’s Supreme Court of Appeals on Wednesday cleared the way for compensation claims to be made against Nobel laureate author Orhan Pamuk for telling a Swiss magazine in 2005 that “30,000 Kurds and 1 million Armenians were killed on this soil.” A court in İstanbul had earlier rejected compensation claims made by Pakize Alp Akbaba, the head of an association of mothers of slain Turkish soldiers, and lawyer Kemal Kerinçsiz, both of whom are under arrest for membership in Ergenekon, a clandestine organization allegedly involved in illegal activities. In May, the Supreme Court of Appeals overturned the local court ruling upon an appeal by plaintiffs and ordered a new trial. The İstanbul court reheard the suit and rejected the case once again. However, the Supreme Court of Appeals reversed the judgment after the plaintiffs submitted another appeal Supreme Court of Appeals judges also refused Pamuk’s request for a revision of the decision. Pamuk said in his request that the court should consider the consequences if every Turkish citizen had the right to sue him.
-
http://cgi.ebay.com/USSR-Armenia-FC-Ararat...4#ht_547wt_1167
-
The original price was 20 roubles. Soccer balls were expensive in the USSR...
-
Before reading the obituary of Mikhalkov in The Economist I was not aware that an Armenians had been involved with the Soviet Anthem. Not sure that the entry in Wiki is completely correct. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gabriel_El-Registan
-
Armenia & Turkey agree to establish diplomatic talks
Boghos replied to Em's topic in Republic of Armenia
It may very well be. In spite of the fact that the trilateral relations Armenia-Azerbaijan-Turkey are of limited importance and interest for those outside the region there is pressure from the United States to establish diplomatic relations and reopen the border. However unlike the pathetic announcements of important breakthroughs made before April 24th, we now have something a bit more concrete: on one side Armenia has reaffirmed what it has been saying for quite some time, that it is willing to establish diplomatic relations with Turkey without any preconditions. However the communique apparently tries to resurrect the historical commission that had been proposed by Turkey, essentially to determine whether the Armenian Genocide took place (2...Implement a dialogue on the historical dimension with the aim to restore mutual confidence between the two nations, including an impartial and scientific examination of the historical records and archives to define existing problems and formulate recommendations;). 1. accepting this clause is an incredible and humiliating loss to the Armenian side, perhaps a moral loss more than anything else (interestingly enough Switzerland recognizes the Genocide in spite of a few recalcitrant deniers in government), but a loss nevertheless. It does make the whole thing a much easier sell to the Turkish public and government but it also indicates how the balance of power works in this case. 2. such dialogue, commission or whatever else might be imagined will never take place. I doubt Turkey has any interest in that and Armenia should not play such games. 3. in spite of everything, opening the border and establishing diplomatic relationships is not just desirable but unavoidable, we can debate the circumstances but not its need. Some have argued that Turkey's admittance to the EU would be in the best interest of Armenia, I agree even though I don't think it will happen in my lifetime (I am 40 and expect to live a long time: thanks for the cognac, Azat!) but in order for EU talks to have a chance of progress Turkey's relationship with all is neighbours have to improve. Economic benefits are beyond discussion. Yes, it is better to go through Turkey than Georgia! 4. all in all, the best outcome for Armenia is to open the borders and have the Turks build an embassy in Yerevan, all the rest is the usual fluff that has no bearing in realpolitik. -
Chapter 1 Electoral behaviour or any other form of choice: Armenians vote with their feet, if they don't like what they see and have the means, they move. Chapter 2 Armenian atittude to people in power (not saying that there were other options) Yes, ***** yes, vizir yes, sir Yes, comrade Yes, baron nakhakar and yes to all mafiosi (the Russians prefer oligarch...) Chapter 3 The best WWII quote on Armenians: " One Armenian is better than a hundred German soldiers One hundred Armenians are not a match to one German soldier. "
-
Oh, poor Ara, I think he would qualify as a tragicomedian rather than a comedian. Having read most of what he wrote over decades, my conclusion is that if he condensed all his opinions in 1/50 of the space he used, he might have been a stronger voice. He is at heart a provocateur but if he wanted to be a real dissident he should have moved to Armenia. Michael Arlen's oft repeated words about the Armenians may very well apply to him.
-
Shushi had around 20 000 inhabitants. They had to be the most sophisticated people on Earth if the mentioned stats are to be justified. Somehow I find that unlikely.
