Jump to content

elovna

Members
  • Posts

    287
  • Joined

  • Last visited

    Never

Everything posted by elovna

  1. quote:Originally posted by nairi:They're playing it carefully with the Turks seen the amount of Turks in GroenLinks. (Keep in mind that most left-wing Turks become extreme-right-wing when it comes to the Armenian cause) Here it is! So GroenLinks would not only lose a lot of Turkish members/votes but also have to deal with a very angry ennemy.
  2. quote:Originally posted by nairi: quote:Originally posted by Aghtchik: Also, if the ignoring of the Dutch political parties regarding this issue is due to feared loss of Turkish votes Who said this? Do you have any concrete info? I'm interested. I did. That is... 'thinking outloud'... b.t.w. I said "IF", because I read, I believe it was in Alert (online), that France tried to get Armenian votes with the recognition, so immediately I thought: "Oh, this definitally wouldn't work in Holland. Too many Turkish votes to lose." So no one but myself and I were wondering about it. It's something that I personally wouldn't rule out. Would you?? If this is too far fetched, please convince me that it's not a possibility. I know that GroenLinks has quite a few Turkish votes. I don't know about the SP. I have voted GroenLinks for years and I may decide to run over to the SP one day. But those are the parties from which I would expect more support than what they've given sofar, not because they sympathize because they are Christians or because they have Armenian friends or relations, but because they will always try to do what is humanly right and just (at least that is what I would like to keep on believing) [ June 12, 2002, 03:36 PM: Message edited by: Aghtchik ]
  3. According to my boyfriend I have the most beautiful wrinkles in the world! I wouldn't want to spoil this with a face-lift.
  4. quote:Originally posted by nairi:Elly jan, please reread the ealier letter by April 24 Committee sent to Assen City Hall posted by Rouben on page 1 of this forum. I'm not here to agree or disagree with people who are more experienced than me. I merely came to provide information. You guys do whatever you want with it. Lieve Nairi. Thanks very much for posting the info. Don't feel obliged to comment on my thinking outloud. I didn't mean to say that Van Dijke is asking the wrong questions. I am just posting what goes through my mind regarding what I read without wanting to offend anyone and I welcome any (polite:)) comment on what I think is 'my' logic reasoning. I am not a law expert, not a historian or a politician. This is all new territory for me and like I said: "I don't know everything." But I want to learn and understand. The mentioned letter, the way I see it, goes past what according to the City was a legitimate reason for the police to interfear during the demonstration, namely the agreements that were made. I am not saying that the Armenians don't have a point. But it's a bit strange to first agree to certain 'requests' and then complain when things go wrong after agreements were not lived by. So for me it is more interesting to know HOW the agreements came to life. Was there pressure of any sort used.... THERE you would have a conflict regarding the Law Public Manifestations (see my previous posting)... at least that's what I think, but I am not a lawyer. Can someone help me out here? Maybe usutsich jan...? So, concluding, I would say that the april 24 committy used an unfortunate way of handling this specific matter. By the way...I have started this topic because the freedom of speech in The Netherlands was questioned on the Forum. I want to understand what happened and what is going on. I am a Dutch citizen and the least I can expect from my government(s) is to act according our Law(s). If in this matter they indeed are violating the right to freedom of speech, then this should come to surface and be made public. And of course it should be set straight. Also, if the ignoring of the Dutch political parties regarding this issue is due to feared loss of Turkish votes, then also that should come out in the open. This matter needs Dutch support, if only, to start with, from a small group of which some experts like for example a prominent Dutch historian. The issue should be publically discussed. So, maybe you can answer this question Nairi: what does the current Dutch support consist of, other than Van Dijkes (party)? Private message: what do I do to make it possible? Click on 'Profile' and make sure that you enable the option that will allow other members to send you messages. Maybe another way is for you to send me a private message (one of the options on top of my postings). I expect to be able to reply in that case.
  5. quote:Originally posted by nairi:6. Do you share the opinion that at this named demonstration there were no problems with public security, which would make intervention by the police necessary? Is there reason to assume that freedom of speech and the regulations of the Law on Public Manifestations were unjustly breached? They AGREED to not use certain words, unfortunately. That is what makes the interfearing of the police legitimate, or do I see it wrong? Isn't it more interesting to know HOW the agreements were made? Did the committy have a choice? THAT is what I would like to know. Was there any pressure used? Like: "If you don't agree to our terms, then we will not allow the demonstration to take place." Because in THAT case the City will have violated our Law Public Manifestations: In our Law Public Manifestations (Wet Openbare Manifestaties) which gives authority to local governments to set rules and regulations regarding the right to demonstrate, to be exact in paragraph 5.3, it says that a rule, limitation or prohibition cannot be related to the content of what is to be practiced or to the thoughts or feelings that are to be made public. [ June 11, 2002, 04:58 PM: Message edited by: Aghtchik ]
  6. By the way, Nairi. I would like to send you a private message. Can you make that possible?
  7. Back to the topic please. I believe it was about the bed. Actually, I find this a very interesting subject. So I would like to hold an enquete.... What do you make in the bed? How do you make it in the bed? How many times does the making in the bed take place? Is making the bed bad for what you make in the bed? How bad are you in bed?
  8. quote:Originally posted by Harut: quote:Originally posted by Aghtchik:I hoped that those spaces would be overlooked. B.t.w. Harut. Is there a better way to make the codes visible, like a special code that will hold them? just use code: [ CODE ] [ /CODE ]as i'm doing right now. just overlook the spaces for the code. code inside code is not overlooked i guess. Is there a special code that will hold the "[ code ]....[ /code ] ? (Please overlook the spaces in the code )
  9. quote:Originally posted by nairi: 3. Op welke gronden kon worden gelast dat deze woorden moesten worden geschapt? 4. Was er naar uw mening grond voor het genoemde optreden van de politie bij deze demonstratie? Ik denk toch dat men zich zal beroepen op de gemaakte 'afspraken'. Men mag verwachten dat afspraken worden nagekomen. Het was beter geweest wanneer deze afspraken niet gemaakt zouden zijn. Het is niet voor niets dat het zo gespeeld wordt. Men had niets af kunnen dwingen in dit verband (als ik de wetten - ik ben al vergeten welke - goed heb begrepen). Nu is het volgens mij gewoon zo dat de politie op mag treden wanneer men zich niet aan de afspraken blijkt te houden. Ergens is dat ook logisch. I don't have time now to post this also in English. Will do that in the morning.Thanks Nairi.
  10. quote:Originally posted by Aghtchik:This should not be happening here!!! ... or anywhere else of course.
  11. quote:Originally posted by Aghtchik: quote:Originally posted by nairi: [qb]Elly jan, ever thought of translating Dutch articles/letters about Armenians into English for groong. No, let me do that now. I don't have anything now, but as soon as I do I'll send it. I usually find time to do it myself, but sometimes it's too many (long) articles at the same time and a helping hand would be great. Thanks. Actually I meant: "Let me do the thinking now" But, OK , contact me when you need help and we will see what I can do. About the celebrations last year. I was invited to come to Yerevan, but I was kind of ill most of last year, so a lot of things unfortunately passed by me. I remember reading of the exhibition. Couldn't go myself. A terrible shame that it was not a succes. By the way, I didn't know that Van Dijke has Armenians in his family. But see what I meant with the interest of people. I started to care because of my Armenian relationship. Let me remind you of the "miniminority". About the ChristenUnie as the only party who cares as for now. I agree that the CDA seems a logical next step if you see the religion as a common factor. Well, of course I understand that it is also a matter of what contacts you have, but I think that the common factor should be that we are all humans. And we have moral obligations towards our fellow humans/people. There is 'right' and 'wrong' no matter what world or national politics are involved. The fact that other political parties ignore the issue, doesn't have anything to do with religion, or the lack of it. It has to do with the political situation and climate in and outside of Holland. THAT is very wrong in my opinion. I know that recognition of the genocide may have great consequences in the end that goes far beyond the recognition of the facts of the past alone. Still, that should not be reason to denie or not acknowledge the fact that it happened, simply because it is wrong to do so. quote:The Turkish lobby is VERY powerful and dangerous. Pls don't underestimate it. I assume with "dangerous", you mean REALLY dangerous up to life threatening even. Well, you won't see me poste my address here. So we should give in to that type of pressures? I don't think so. I am not stupid. I know what a minimum of 387.000 Turks can do. But maybe I AM stubborn. I am getting angry at this very moment about this situation. Imagine. My husband-to-be even reminded me of 'certain dangers' that I should not underestimate... to me, but also to my family. I am not a hero, but should I let myself be intimidated by some foreign forces in my own country? I would like to ask every Dutch citizen that question. This should not be happening here!!! About "The Armenian Exhibition" idea.... I think that I have something totally different in mind. I am thinking of something of a very popular nature. Thinking of: - a couple of good musicians willing to participate; folk (duduk), chamber music, jazz combo. - people who can bring in some theatre, dance stuff, maybe we can find or 'train' a bodypainter - some who can give lectures - some to give chess simuls - connections with (not yet established) artists in Yerevan who's works will be exhibited (and sold) - transportation means from Yerevan to Holland. - a transportable documentation center - a big tent (because we are making an outdoor happening and in Holland there is a good chance that it will rain) - photo exhibit - some transportable equipment, like bar, kitchen - some sound equipment, floor or podium (after rain the grass outside can become pretty swampy here ) - transportation for the exhibition - some people who will want to take care of setting and building the stuff up - Subsidy for this NON-PROFIT project. The program could be partially flexible for practical reasons. --------- Rouben, I just read your posting. This summer you can't count me in. I am far to busy for the time being. I was more thinking of next year. Besides. Summer has already started. Where do you want to get money from this quick? To get subsidy requires a detailed project plan and you need to apply and wait for the outcome. This thing isn't going to be solved in 'no time' anyway. So why the hurry? About bringing in famous Armenians... That's interesting for Armenians, not for Dutch, unless it's Cher, Charles Aznavour or System of a Down. Also I am not thinking of an agressive pro-recognition campaign. Just a friendly popular type of cultural happening. The genocide should not be the main subject. It will be part of course, how could it not be. But that way I think it's easier to get past the Turks. And if the authorities want to interfear and 'mess' with the truth that is being displayed, they should take the whole exhibition to court, or rather the organising foundation... for instance HAI2C.
  12. My posting somehow got in 3 times. So I deleted this one. [ June 11, 2002, 04:02 AM: Message edited by: Aghtchik ]
  13. My posting somehow got in 3 times. So I deleted this one. [ June 11, 2002, 04:01 AM: Message edited by: Aghtchik ]
  14. I hoped that those spaces would be overlooked. B.t.w. Harut. Is there a better way to make the codes visible, like a special code that will hold them?
  15. quote:Originally posted by nairi: I guess it didn't come out right. Maybe one of you can teach me how reply works. When you reply with quote you should keep an eye on the stuff between "[..]". The [ QB ]will give your text a certain lay-out (in this case for quotes). This lay-out will end with [ /QB ]. So everything in between will have that lay-out. After the [ /QB ] you can type your comments that will automatically be displayed in standard lay-out. You can put "[ QB ].........[ /QB ]" anywhere you like to highlight text (quotes). Just don't forget that what has a beginning should also have an end somewhere. This also goes for: [ quote ]....[ /quote ] (adds lines at beginning and end and adds "quote:" on top) or [ b ]...[ /b ] (makes fat text) You can even center words or phrases with [ center ]....[ /center ] or make them fat as well with [ center ][ b ]....[ /b ][ /center ] You can use the preview button before you post to see if the lay-out is ok. If it shows any irregularities you mostlikely forgot to put and end [/..] somewhere.
  16. Nairi said: "Hardly any attention was payed, even though it was the 1700th anniversary of Christianity in Armenia" Most of the Dutch are not religious anymore. Religion is out. Churches are being sold to sometimes even be turned into supermarkets or other types of businesses. If you want to celebrate the existance of christianity (in Holland) you will attract a very small group, like those who will vote for Van Dijke's ChristenUnie. (They only have 1 member left in the parliament now I believe.)
  17. quote:Originally posted by nairi: Elly jan, ever thought of translating Dutch articles/letters about Armenians into English for groong. No, let me do that now. Btw, your idea of an Armenia exhibit sounds very interesting, but a little unpractical I would say. A) try to get past the Turkish lobby, Try to attract ignorant SBS6 watching Dutch people. The Dutch people who are not ignorant usually already know about Armenians and the Genocide. Would you not agree? No, I don't agree. Take me for example. I don't consider myself ignorant. But I just don't know everything. (smilie face) I am interested in many things but history and politics were never my favourite subject. Before I met my Armenian prince a couple of years ago I only knew that Armenia had been part of the USSR (somewhere near Turkmenistan ) and I had heard some beautiful choir music by Armenian women. It is through my 'Armenian relationship' that I got interested. But when I look around here, I seem to be the only one. The interest isn't there. And why is that? Because we don't run into them, we don't meet them, we don't become friends. We see Turks everywhere. In the next town (85.000 inhabitants), 10 minutes from where I live there are 20.000 Turks. Where are those 5000 Armenians? I am not sure but I think most of them will be living in "De randstad" (the area around Rotterdam, Amsterdam, The Hague) and of course Assen, Almelo. But Holland is more than De Randstad. I only met one Armenian in Holland sofar . We Dutch talk a lot about our ethnic minorities, but the Armenian one is more like a miniminority. (smilie face) I guess what I'm trying to say is that last year an Armenian tried and failed. Most people who came to see the exhibitions were people who already knew something about Armenians. The small remaining minority came because they're regular exhibit goers, but even among those most already knew something about Armenians. Where was that exhibit? I am not talking of touring the main cities. I am talking about touring everywhere EXCEPT the main cities. You could take the season from spring until autumn, so you could visit 6 towns in one year, not too small, not too big. With a population of 30.000-40.000 you can reach many people who are interested in music, art, different cultures, or just to spend their sunday afternoon in a nice way. The ones who come for the music, will walk through the exhibition while the musicians have a break, so in the meanwhile they (the audience ) will see the pictures, the photographs, and they will want to take a closer look and put on their glasses to be able to read the text that describes what is going on in those pictures. They will see the genocide of course and they will remember it when sooner or later the recognition issue comes up in the parliament. And the media? Hardly any attention was payed, even though it was the 1700th anniversary of Christianity in Armenia and some of the artefacts on show would never come back to Holland again. Too bad that it didn't work. But I wasn't even thinking about involving media. I was just thinking about showing people about Armenia and the Armenians in an entertaining way so for everyone there would be something of interest if only to sit and have a drink while listening to the duduk and watch other people walk by. The local media won't be a problem. That would be standard procedure. This is not to reach headlines, it's to raise the interest of the people, to awaken their feelings for something old that is new to them. Sorry for being so pessimistic, but what more can you expect from a perennially thwarted, oppressed minority? :)Thanks for the effort though; it's greatly appreciated and who knows, you might be able to make it work. Let me cheer you up then. It's not even THAT difficult. You just have to find a bunch of enthusiastic people who will want to put some work in it. BUT, I am not saying (yet) that I will actually do this project, ok? Thanks for updating us on the newest developments regarding the genocide and Dutch politics. I am going to give that some thought now.
  18. Ok Sip, let me shine a little light over your bed problem There are many different people around. Some like their beds ready made, some like to make their beds ready. Did it occur to you that your sheets maybe need some daily fresh air? There can be an awful lot going on between them you know.
  19. By the way, I think there are other, nicer ways to reach the public. I have an idea... The Armenian Exhibition a lively presentation of past, present and future An Armenian (1-day; sunday?) exhibition that will tour through The Netherlands. It should be informative as well as entertaining. It should have art (straight from Armenia), live music, dance, lecture(s), movie(s)/video(s), food, history, the Armenian language, maybe chess (the young Levon Aronian who currently lives in Germany can be invited to give a simul ) etc. I think it should be possible to get subsidy for it even. It's only an idea, but a good one I think. Eventhough I don't have much time right now to put into it, I would like to explore the possibilities. For one I would need to find Armenians willing to participate/help of course. In order to apply for subsidy there would have to be a detailed plan on paper to present the project by. I would appreciate feedback regarding this.
  20. Thank you for your concern Toth. I appreciate it. But J I know MJ. If he was being cynical, he was not aiming for me. J In fact I think he was teasing me a little. I know perfectly well that recognition of a genocide normally doesn't pop up on a City's agenda. It was Assens 'bad luck' that one of their citizens was an Armenian who decided to put up a monument (nothing more) and that many Turks got very angry over it. So the City had to deal with it and as far as I know it didn’t really reach the parliaments agenda. The (local) government tried to not make it into a genocide recognition issue. According to the book it was about rules and regulations and agreements. It was unfortunate to 'agree' to the requests. If no agreements would have been made they could not have stopped a demonstration without violating the Law. Then I think you would have had a case to go for. With the complicated political situation I was of course referring to the different interests in this case, namely of Russia, USA, Europe the moslim world and god knows who else. I am only recently learning about all of this, since I have found a teacher who can explain it very nicely to me. (thanks usutsich jan! ) I read about the economic consequences that France had to deal with because of recognition. So I don't think that the City of Assen will want to cause something like that for the Netherlands. I read that for France it was supposed to be an election trick. In the Netherlands a trick like that would have the opposite effect because part of the 387.000 Turks will also vote. I wonder if a small country like The Netherlands can just go and decide all by themselves to recognize this genocide, just because it is the ‘right’ thing to do. Oh... that election trick of France. Belgium has also recognized the genocide. Does anyone know how many Armenians live in Belgium (and how many Turks?). If this is about votes… About the genocide industry. MJ knows that if that exists, it’s not my department, nor my responsability. So, i don’t take any offense in that or in anything else he said. About “keeping the memory alive”, I think MJ has a point there, if he means keeping it alive for the Armenians. But what you Armenians often forget is that for instance we Dutch don’t hear of the genocide in our history classes. I did not pay much attention in those classes, because I had other things on my mind. J But I am sure that if such a story would have been part of the lessons, I would have remembered. Seriously, there are only very few Dutch people who know what happened there. So I think MJ is right, you don’t need to remind the Armenians, but you do need to inform the ignorant. All this political stuff, actually, it’s not really my hobby. And although I am beginning to see now how complex it all is, I would like to restrict myself to the human aspects that are involved. For me, no matter how many votes will be lost, the facts and the truth should not be wiped under the carpet. I don’t understand how, after the Jewish holocaust, the Armenian genocide can still be denied, no matter what political interests are involved.
  21. Uit Trouw, Misschien wel de beste internetkrant van Nederland www.trouw.nl Een taboe op de helling Armeniërs, Erdal Balci 2001-02-09 Bijna een eeuw lang durfde vrijwel niemand in Turkije met een woord te reppen over de Armeense kwestie. Niemand wilde weten wat er in 1915 was gebeurd tussen de Turken en de Armeniers. Hoeveel Armeniërs werden omgebracht. Het onderwerp was taboe: geen boeken, geen onderwijs en geen discussies over de gedwongen exodus van destijds. Maar langzamerhand wordt het taboe heel voorzichtig doorbroken. Vroeger, zo'n negentig jaar geleden, leefde er een nog een volk in het Turkse deel van Klein-Azië, zeker twee miljoen Armeniërs waren over heel Anatolië verspreid. Ze vormden overal een minderheid, met uitzondering van de provincie Van. Het was een ontwikkeld volk, dat aan landbouw en handel deed. Hun muziek en hun tradities leken op die van de Turken en de Koerden, waarmee ze samenleefden in de bergachtige gebieden. Alleen, er was één groot verschil: de Armeniërs waren christenen. Nu negentig jaar later sta ik op het Taksimplein in Istanboel. Het is de enige Turkse stad, waar nog Armeniërs leven. In de steden, dorpen en bergen van Anatolië is het Armeense volk verdwenen. Op het plein is een shoarmazaak, met als eigenaar een Armeniër. Hij vertelt over zijn verleden: ,,Mijn ouders hebben in Kayseri gewoond. Na de dood van Atatürk is de druk op onze familie zo verhoogd, dat we daar wel weg moesten. In 1952 zijn we naar Istanboel gekomen. Hier hebben we nooit meer last gehad. Een groot deel van mijn familie woont in het buitenland. We hebben nog goede contacten.'' In Istanboel wonen tegenwoordig zo'n zestigduizend Armeniërs. De eigenaar van de shoarmazaak doet niet veel anders dan zijn broodjes verkopen. De zaken gaan goed. Zijn kinderen hebben met het geld van pa in het buitenland gestudeerd en hebben nu goede banen. De man wil niet praten over het lot dat zijn volk ten deel viel tijdens de Eerste Wereldoorlog. ,,Het is allemaal zo lang geleden. We moeten naar de toekomst kijken'', zegt hij. De shoarmazaakeigenaar, die nadrukkelijk niet met zijn naam in de krant wil komen, wil het verleden vergeten. De Armeniërs in het Westen doen dat niet. Ze lobbyen voortdurend om de westerse parlementen zo ver te krijgen, dat ze de 'genocide', gepleegd door de Turken op de Armeniërs, als wet aannemen. In Frankrijk is dat gelukt. De Turken worden telkens razend als het woord 'genocide' valt en dreigen de parlementen, die geneigd zijn om de volkerenmoord te erkennen met allerlei maatregelen. Daardoor komt de kwestie steeds weer op de agenda, hoe graag de shoarmazaakeigenaar het verleden zou willen begraven. Wat is er gebeurd in de Eerste Wereldoorlog, waar de kleinkinderen van die Armeniërs nog altijd van wakker liggen? De officiële lezing van de Turkse kant luidt als volgt: ,Eeuwenlang hebben de Armeniërs in vrede geleefd in het Osmaanse Rijk (de voorloper van de Turkse Republiek). Ze namen zelfs actief deel aan het bestuur van het Rijk. Maar naarmate het Rijk zwakker werd en grond verloor, begonnen ook de Armeniërs actief te werken aan een onafhankelijke staat. Armeense bendes vielen Turkse dorpen aan en vermoordden de boeren. Toen de Eerste Wereldoorlog uitbrak, viel Rusland Turkije binnen. De Russische Armeniërs vochten actief mee tegen de Turken. De Turkse Armeniërs voelden zich meer verwant met de christelijke Russen. Ze begonnen dan ook een bedreiging te vormen voor het Turkse leger. Hierop organiseerde de regering een exodus van de Armeniërs naar het zuiden. Onderweg vielen veel slachtoffers. Niet vanwege de Turkse regering, maar omdat de Koerdische veldheren niet onder controle konden worden gehouden. En natuurlijk ook door de slechte omstandigheden onderweg.' Het Armeense verhaal luidt anders: 'Alles begon met de opkomst van de nationalistische beweging 'Jonge Turken'. Ze richtten de partij Eenheid en Vooruitgang op en kwamen door de zwakte van de sultan snel aan de macht. De leiders van deze partij zagen in dat het rijk constant grond verloor. De enige kans van overleven was om in een kleiner land te leven met een bevolking die homogeen is. De Eerste Wereldoorlog werd dan ook als een perfect excuus gebruikt om het land te zuiveren van de Armeense minderheid. Alle Armeniërs werden stelselmatig onderworpen aan een exodus. Onderweg werden ze koelbloedig vermoord door de militairen en de Koerden. Aan het hoofd van de genocide stond generaal Talat, die voortdurend bevelen gaf aan zijn onderdanen dat ze geen genade moesten hebben met de Armeniërs. Van een miljoen Armeniërs, die aan de exodus waren onderworpen hebben uiteindelijk zo'n vijftigduizend het gehaald. De Armeniërs in Istanboel hebben de genocide wel overleefd, omdat buitenlandse afgezanten en journalisten in Istanboel waren gestationeerd.' ,,Ik ben nog nooit naar Oost-Turkije gegaan, waar mijn voorouders hebben geleefd en waar ze zijn verbannen'', zegt Devrim, een 27-jarige jarige gitarist, die in bekende café's in Istanboel speelt. ,,Tijdens de verbanning hebben de meeste Armeniërs braaf alle instructies van de militairen opgevolgd. Tegen hen werd gezegd dat ze hun bezittingen binnen een dag in ossenwagens moesten doen, de volgende dag zouden ze vertrekken. Mijn opa vertrouwde het allemaal niet. Hij verliet stiekem het dorp en dook onder bij een Alawietische familie in een ander dorp. Hij was de enige in de familie, die niet vertrok naar de woestijnen in het zuiden. Hij was ook de enige die in leven is gebleven.'' Devrim zelf zegt dat hij er langzamerhand genoeg van heeft dat de Armeense kwestie telkens weer opduikt. ,,Het is wel makkelijk voor de Armeniërs in het buitenland om de kwestie warm te houden. Maar hier in Turkije moeten wij met de Turken samenleven. Ik ben hier nooit gediscrimineerd vanwege mijn achtergrond. En ik wil dat graag zo houden. Mijn Turkse vrienden zien me als Devrim en niet als Devrim, de Armeniër. Okay, het was wel tragisch wat er 85 jaar geleden gebeurde, maar het is wel 85 jaar geleden gebeurd'', zegt hij. Hij treedt die avond op met zijn groep in een café in Beyoglu, de uitgaanswijk van Istanboel. Normaal spelen de jongens popmuziek. Maar er is een volkslied, waar niemand om heen kan de laatste maanden. Devrim speelt het dan ook: 'Op de markt van Erzurum (een oosterse stad met vroeger een grote Armeense bevolking) loopt het meisje uit de bergen. Ik weet dat ze jou mij niet zullen gunnen. Ik wou dat ik dood was, het meisje uit de bergen...' Devrim zingt de hit eerst in het Turks, daarna in de originele vorm, in het Armeens. Het geluid van de fluit is hartverscheurend. Hoewel Devrim niet wil dat de Armeense zaak telkens ter sprake komt, gebeurt dat in Turkije de laatste dertig jaar wel voortdurend. Eerst kwamen de Armeniërs in het nieuws met aanslagen van de Armeense terreurbeweging Asala op Turkse diplomaten. Daarna werden de Armeniërs stof van gesprek tijdens de oorlog tussen Armenië en Azerbeidzjan, twee Sovjet-republieken, die na de opheffing van de Sovjet-Unie in oorlog raakten om de Armeense enclave Nagorno Karabach. De Turken spraken ook over Armeniërs als het ging om de Koerdische beweging PKK. Volgens sommige Turkse nationalisten steunden de Armeniërs de PKK. En dan was daar de publicatie drie jaar geleden van het 'Armeense taboe' van de hand van de Franse onderzoeker Yves Ternon. Het werd direct uit de schappen van de winkels gehaald na een vonnis van de rechtbank. De rechtzaak bij een hogere rechter duurde ongeveer drie jaar. Uiteindelijk mocht het boek toch worden uitgegeven. In het vonnis stond dat de Armeense minderheid te klein is om een bedreiging te vormen voor de eenheid van de Turkse staat. Enkele dagen geleden nog deed een discussieprogramma veel stof opwaaien. Twee Turkse historici en een rechtse parlementariër waren uitgenodigd. Ze vertelden het gebruikelijke verhaal. Maar tot ieders verbazing belde de programmamaker ook Taner Akcam, een Turkse onderzoeker die vanwege zijn mening over de Armeense kwestie naar de Verenigde Staten is gevlucht. De discussie was zeer verhit, de gemoederen liepen hoog op. Zo hoog dat de doorgaans zo kalme Taner Akcam op een gegeven moment door de telefoon schreeuwde: ,,De PKK heeft mensen vermoord. Moeten we daarom alle Koerden uitroeien?'' De vrouw van wijlen president Özal belde woedend op. ,,Hoe kunnen jullie deze man aan het woord laten. Ik vraag jullie om onmiddelijk de afkomst van deze man uit te zoeken. Ik kan niet geloven dat deze Akcam een Turk is.'' Een dag later publiceerde Hurriyet, de krant met de grootste oplage in Turkije, een brief van een lezer die schreef dat het nu eindelijk eens tijd werd om generaal Talat, de man die verantwoordelijk wordt geacht voor de gebeurtenissen in 1915, als een Pol Pot of Stalin te beschouwen. Net als Devrim stoort ook Hrant Dink (47) zich aan het feit dat de Armeniërs zo negatief in het nieuws komen. Hij is hoofdredacteur van het Armeense weekblad Agos. Het blad verschijnt in het Turks en het Armeens. Het heeft een oplage van zevenduizend. Hrant Dink (47) moet niet zoveel hebben van de wetsvoorstellen over de genocide op Armeniërs in de westerse landen: ,,Ik twijfel ernstig aan de houding van de westerlingen. Ze schuiven de schuld constant in de schoenen van Turkije. We horen geen woord over hún aandeel in de gebeurtenissen in 1915. De Engelsen, de Fransen, de Italianen, de Russen en de Amerikanen waren druk bezig met de verwezenlijking van hun imperialistische idealen. Het lot van de Armeniërs kon hen niks schelen. Ze hadden alleen oog voor het verbreden van hun invloedssfeer.'' Voor Dink is het veel belangrijker om de Turkse publieke opinie te beinvloeden. ,,Het aannemen van wetten in honderd parlementen is voor mij minder belangrijk dan de empathie, het medegevoel van een Turkse burger. Vroeger kon je helemaal niet praten over 1915. Nu beginnen journalisten mondjesmaat te schrijven dat we eens in de Osmaanse archieven moeten kijken. Het proces komt traag op gang, net als de democratisering van Turkije. Maar ik geloof dat we ook dit taboe zullen doorbreken. Turkije moet ook beseffen wat die exodus het land heeft gekost. Het Armeense volk was het meest ontwikkelde volk in Turkije. Ze woonden er drieduizend jaar. Ze hadden universiteiten opgericht en gaven les in zeven buitenlandse talen. Ze hadden een goed ontwikkelde muziek, enzovoorts. Als er nu vijf miljoen Armeniërs in Turkije waren, dan zat Turkije allang in de Europese Unie'', zegt Dink. De hoofdredacteur begint steeds bozer te worden, begint bijna te schreeuwen: ,,Of ik teleurgesteld ben in Turkse links. Nou en of. Ik ben duizend procent teleurgesteld. Je kunt me niet één gedicht noemen van onze beroemde linkse dichters naar aanleiding van het Armeense drama.'' Die avond ga ik naar het huis van Devrim. Een oude tante is op bezoek. Op de televisie gaat het zoals gewoonlijk de laatste tijd over de Armeense kwestie. Een Turkse deskundige vertelt hoe volgens hem de 'tweehonderdduizend Armeniërs om het leven zijn gekomen in 1915. Devrims tante ontsteekt in woede. ,,Wat'', schreeuwt ze. ,,Het waren er wel drie miljoen. Mijn vader heeft het me allemaal verteld.'' Als ze even later weer tot bedaren is gekomen, zegt ze tegen Devrim dat hij niet overal moet vertellen dat hij een Armeniër is. Aan de muur hangt een afbeelding van Jezus.
  22. Gitem, Rouben jan. No prob. I am not doing much anyway . Also, I don't have any illusions that it will change anything about the huge complicated political situation that this matter seems to be part of. "...to wait for a favourable moment...". This raises the question: "Will there ever be a favourable moment?". So that question I have now mailed mr. Van Leemput.
  23. http://members.brabant.chello.nl/~e.martens2/pics/1953.jpg http://members.brabant.chello.nl/~e.martens2/pics/all41_14all.jpg [ June 07, 2002, 01:06 AM: Message edited by: Aghtchik ]
  24. SP's next reply... Dutch Beste , U beider boodschappen zijn goed doorgekomen en goed begrepen. Ik ken (het werk van) Taner Aksam (een beetje) en deel zijn analyse. Voor de SP geldt dat we een gunstig moment moeten afwachten om op een verstandige manier de hele problematiek van de Turkse geschiedenis op een praktische op de toekomstgerichte manier aan te kaarten. Met vriendelijke groeten Guido van Leemput English Dear , Both your messages came through ok and were understood well. I know (the work of) Taner Akcam (a little) and share his analysis. For the SP goes that we have to wait for a favourable moment to bring up the whole problem of the Turkish history in a practical way that is aiming to the future. With friendly greetings, Guido van Leemput. [ June 07, 2002, 02:50 PM: Message edited by: Aghtchik ]
  25. My next e-mail to the SP.... English Dear SP co-worker, Thanks for your quick reply. As you probably know the Armenian people, due to the, most mildly put, 'unfortunate' circumstances of the past, were spread all over the world. De genocide that took place on the Armenian people around the years 1910-1915 by the Ottoman empire has put an enormous stamp on the lives of the survivors and the victims children, of whom the greater part now lives in the Armenian diaspora. Can you imagine how it is like to, in a country where you sought shelter, not have the right to commemorate your ancestors in a suitable way?... how it is like to have to fight for being allowed to place a monument with a truthful inscription?... how it is like to be 'friendly requested' to not tell the truth because it may harm the 'good' relation of The Netherlands with Turky? An Armenian is practically born with a trauma and denial of the terrible holocaust makes it impossible to get over the pain. That these people now, almost a century later, in a country like The Netherlands cannot publically speak the truth, talking about humanity, I find inhumane and as a Dutch person I feel ashamed that today something like this is happening here. Of course you know that I am talking about the Armenian monument in Assent that in the meanwhile, after a lot of trouble, finally was erected for the purpose of yearly commemoration on april 24 of the Armenian victims of the genocide of 1910-1915 in the Ottoman empire. The government was smart I must say regarding article 7 of the Constitution. The same goes for the Law Public Manifestations regarding the demonstration that was organised to be held in Assen on april 24. The City of Assen, probably under pressure of the government, back then 'requested' to the Armenians to not use the word "genocide" in the inscription and now recently again to not use the words "Turks" or "Turkey" on any of the banners during the demonstration. The Armenians were nice enough to agree to this request. And after some "unagreed" words did pop up, that needed to be taken down in request of the police, the City could just nicely refer to 'agreements' that were not lived by. And rightfully, of course. But if this is what our 'freedom of speech' means I think we can go and pack our bags. ( ) The Armenian question is a delicate matter, yes. But, as the Turkish historian Taner Akcam says: "Turkey can never become a democracy if it does not clear it's history. We have to face the violence. The Turks of today are not guilty, but we carry a responsability.", in this context I want to add:"Where are we with our wonderful words, if we let us be intimidated this way?" Isn't it about time for The Netherlands to take an official stand regarding the events in the Ottoman empire around 1910-1915, so that the Armenians will get the right to grieve and deal with it? This sad subject is on the minds of the approximate 5000 Armenians in The Netherlands on a daily basis. The fact that about 387.000 Turks are getting mad over it should not be reason to keep on hiding the subject. In the Netherlands we give shelter to Kurds who today are experiencing about the same as the Armenians in the same area 90 years ago. There is no point in being silent and waiting. Hitler, before he started to exterminate the Jewish people, said: "After all, who remembers the Armenians." ..... It will be clear to you that I feel that this matter urgently needs to be discussed, in the parliament, the media, etcetera. And to the SP the request to start with it. With friendly greetings, . [ June 07, 2002, 02:48 PM: Message edited by: Aghtchik ]
×
×
  • Create New...