Jump to content

zurderer

Members
  • Posts

    401
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by zurderer

  1. That is why us(Turks) dont believe you. You are giving some truth and than lying. You firstly talk about 200 years of ethnic cleansing of Western Armenia, and did not proof it. Than talking about 25-30 million. What was the armenian population at 1915, and what is now. what is growth rate of armenian population, what is asimilation rate of armenian community. Calculate this, than talk about 25-30 million.It is absurd, you think accepting genocide also mean accepting all of your lies. I have enough english, but I am not faking. I just write quick and dont control much what I write. No need to consiperacy teories. what can I achieve at a forum less than 100 people attended. It is realy an interesting approach. This guy accept genocide, this guy have enough english, this guy is intelligent. So Ignore him. I am not following Turko-Armenian relations, I am following my country politics. Absurd, what proof have you for this claim? Trabzon have no kurds, and what would be my gain to pretend a Turk. hearing truth(I did not lie.) is irritate and anger people. Anyway If irritating is so much bad, You should stop to irritiate and anger Turks with genocide claims. My lovely friend,as QueBecer said, I accept and believe Armenian Genocide happened(With or without intent). So I dont know what type of record I need to talk? I am agree with you about genocide thing.(Not all BS produced by your people.) are you deaf? I said one millions time that I did not say you should forget, Infact I did not say you should forgive too. I just said,your culture is a culture of masosists(inheriting their ancestor sufference is armenian thing.), and It is racist.(As I said before, Just find a third people,let them read armenian forums, and ask him If armenians were racist or not.) Infact I wont call this as culture, but religion. Satan vs Angel. It is absurd, you can blame, attack, swear us, our culture, our people, but you never accept any type of discussion about your own culture. Also That you part is boring, personal accusation is unnecesary.You are talking about an collective crime(If saying you means Turks.) That is exactly what young Turks did, collectively accused and punished Armenians. But well, After all I said before, Your armenian culture is racist.(I hope Yerevan wont be angry, because armenians always accuse as racism, so I am not doing something that not happened to me.)
  2. Well cruelty of ottomans was not only aimed armenians but everyone who rebelled them. This is a new accusation, and unreal one. Ottomans had not an ethnic politics and most probably ottomans killed more turks than armenians.(It was turks who rebelled at anatolia a lot times.) I think there were more than one maps, ottomans have no problem calling lands with the name of people. They used ermenistan, kurdistan, lazistan, or gurcistan. Ethnic cleansing. Then they should not.I dont need any cattle. where did I say forget? but your ancestor sufference is realy, your sufference is not. one part of my family fleed form balkans, I didnot like this reality. Infact I accuse bulgarian goverment for it to, but neither I hate bulgarians, nor I suffer from it. It was sufference of my ancestors. There is a lot nation genocided, killed, but It is only armenians who inherited their ancestor sufference.
  3. I am not comparing them, I just gave asala as an example.(example of not justify a crime , but to understand reason.). Please spare me with more bullshit. It is becoming realy realy boring. Are you fighting with yourself? Also what is relation between Ataturk and armenian genocide? It happened at 1915, and Ataturk has no power neither to stop nor order it..
  4. So we have both Turkish and armenian stupidy. Should we decide which is more stupid. Kurds or other non-turks had their own ideas, and It is not complately same with you. weird, your ancestors were suffered, but It is you who hate Turks. I am sure, dont knowing history(Acording to you) is not a worse crime than genocide itself. So your nation is becoming more and more hateful than your ancestors. So why do you think we should have some sypmaty against you. Because you hate us. It is interesting also like always you accuse turks for your hate too. I am begining to think, you armenians have an other religion than christianity, and your satans are Turks. I didnot say such thing. Who is you? If It is ROA, I am sure Turkey wont give even one stone to ROA. (And I am totally against it.) If It is people who want they land,You should follow your campaing to take your lands back. It is totally acceptable wish. so your angels were your ancestors. They did not do any crime. Of course, It is turks who attacked patisah and killed some people, and armenians were loyal to Ottomans. It is absurd, you are talking like almost a turkish nationalist. They are terrorist they killed us, and we fought back. Bla bla, always same terane. Public support? were they living at democracy? how can you know there was public support? If there was public support, you can say this for armenians too. Infact armenians were supported Young Turks.(More than Turks.) So armenians supported their genocide too. Bullshit. dont built a history from your ass. By the way, If you can show me any proof(And You couldnot show any proof until now.) about intent of destroying all armenians, I may accept this. But please dont tell me again, 1.500.000 million people died, armenians exiled ext ext. This is result, not intent. That moron named talat, reasoned 70.000 Turkish soldier to die(because they have not winter cloths.) Can we say, he intended to kill all of them? By the way, why are you so interested with intent of Talat? Indeed, but most of your people take side at this. Why? Because they have knowledge about it? or because of France. So becoming denier is not only Turkish tradition. So you said excatly what I said. I dont justify genocide, but I can understand what pushed them to this. who should be punished? Me? Turkey? As I said you before, sufference, punishment, innocence(in armenian situation.), and guilt(In Turkish situation) dont pass next generations. You are talking about fasism of Turks, find a third person, and let them to read your forums. Than as him, Are we racist or not?
  5. Ridicule Turkish words? I am sure Turkish words are crying for what are you doing.
  6. so armenians are immune to craps? Infact I totally think different except some sensible guys(phantom, ext), most of forum armenains are talking without much sense. I said I am Turk, I dont know why It is much important. I am maybe an asimilated greek, or bulgarian. (Absolutely not kurd.), so will this change anything? do you talk people with acording to their nation? so why did not you listen him? If he is such a good guy, why dont you follow his way? I dont know why do you blame people, because of their lack of history knowledge? I dont think this is not a real accusation, after all noone know about murdered turks too.(Including you.) If It is a crime, so you are a criminal. I think you(Armenians) are repeating yourself, I said I accept ethnic cleansing, genocide(with intent or not.) I also dont think following past enemity will reason for a better future.Accepting genocide(Formally) wont change anything. Specially If this acceptance happened with force of out side. As I asked before, what is practical benefit of accepting genocide for armenians? do armenians are not capable of killing? Infact french army had armenians soldiers, or armenians attacked patisah of ottomans. So absolutely armenians killed people too. Do it justify genocide? No It doesnot, but denying murdered turks make you like these armenian killers.(I know you remember these words from somewhere.) I am not justifying their crimes, I am just understanding reason of crimes. I am sure you will also understand reason of Asala crimes.(And I hope you wont justify that crimes.) do you know what, I think pain of your people dont comes from Turks, but most of your own culture. It is not only your people who is genocided, butchered or killed, but It is only your people who still feel that pain. I can accept Turks genocided armenians, but I cannot accept we are still reason for your pain. It is you who built this masosist culture. Again you are trying to enforce me, some guilt that is not done by me. How do you sleep at night? with knowing what the hell happened withing your world? some? I think It is more than some. My friend, I read some armenian forums, I saw how armenians are proud of hating from Turks. So dont tell me some. when I have great sypmaty for your ancestors(I said before, I had power or chance, I will fight against genocide), I have zero sypmaty for your people(now). why do you think? I did not say It never happened, I said If It is genocide, so what happened algerians too, but It is interesting It is armenians who did ignored it. Yes It is a fasist slogan, A lot Turks still say it, but I dont see anyone of them want to kill all armenians. why did he accept this? If Reason was same with france, He is not hero but a trader of sufference.
  7. Indeed bad answer, why do you think EU is own you some dept? Because they just watched genocide of armenians? So they did for all type of genocide.(Infact how can a genocide happen, If someone try to stop it.) Like what? I generally said my ideas(thoughs), I did not played with any facts.
  8. Realy but you still did not show me how did you inherit sufference of your ancestor. Anyway I will show you how you are trying to sell your ancestors sufference. Lets remember what Sarkosky(so Devecian) want erdogan for stoping new law.(how can they dare to argue about this holy law. ) 1- Turkey should open borders to ROA.This is most disgusting wish I ever saw, we are talking about a genocide, how can you bargain genocide with some trade. Indeed this is nothing than selling sufference. You want trade with Turkey, and you use your ancestors sufference for forcing Turkey to trade. This trade issue is absolutely no relation with armenian genocide. 2- Turkey should abolish 301. Well this is an acceptable term except, you cannot show someone way, when you are doing absolutely what he is doing. 3- committee which discuss armenian genocide, should not only consist historians but also politicians. I dont know what can politicians add a historic discussion. why they want politicians? because historians will not see genocide as politic tool. Or maybe they fear, they can show any proof for armenian genocide? hmmm. Sorry as I said before(and thank Turkey have same idea with me.), dont sell your ancestors sufference, because we will not buy it.
  9. how did you effected from this death? do you think we should punish someone who have a murderer grandfather? or do you think we should give someone who lost his grandfather. Sorry as I said before, It is not you who exiled, It is not you who is killed, injustice did not happened to you. You cannot inherit sufference of your grandfathers.It is stupidy.
  10. so who tried to kill Patisah? turks and kurds? They tried to protect their country against all people, It is not important If they are turk or not, and armenians are not obedient. I am sure you will say majority of armenians have no relation with politics, but this is true for Turks too. So It is not a good defence. What more do you want in your brain to call a racist a racist? More than 2+ million Armenians were killed Maybe you should give some proof instead of words. even armenians talk about 1.5 million, now you are talking more than 2 million. So how many armenians survived after 1914? and how many eastern anatolia armenians we have now? I am sure more than 3-4 million(a conservative guess) armenian dont not comes from 500.000 surviver. by the way, how many armenian is asimilated? It is sad you are not living in real world. French goverment is not supporting this law. (weird?) And this law is not voted because of armenian genocide, and armenians sufference, but armenian votes.(Even French newspaper talk about this.) So what you gain is a political gain, and Infact I am not sure at long run It will benefit armenians. Just guess, what will happen If some people goes to jail because of this law. Anyway, Instead of thinking about your ancestors, you should began to think yourself. You are not living in real world. Infact you are wrong, a lot armenian survived in Turkey also, and It has no relation with armenian race. Converted armenians also survived. Nazis dont give any chance to jews, they chased and killed them even out of their land. why? Even I accept your ideas about armenian genocide, why should Turkey admit truth and the facts? why should we enarm armenians? Because you like us much? why should I give weapon to my enemy?(and absolute you are.) As I said before, I care for your ancestors, They deserve something(justice, unfortunately they did not get justice), You deserve absolutely nothing. Why should I care for some people who hate my people? If It is necassary to lie, I will continue to lie for my nation. Infact isnt diplomacy means lie for nation. Personally I am not guilty, and you are not murdered, so I own you nothing. My ancestors were guilty, and your ancestors were murdered. It is between them, dont try to sell your ancestor sufference(not your sufference, you did not suffer because of genocide), because I wont buy it. Yeah genocide is discovered by Turks. I will say them, what you will say to algerians. I said, intent is a vague word. You cannot say their aim was to kill all armenians, they were not racist like germans. It is not anti-armenian campaign.(Young turks killed every type of people, Turkish, kurdish, greek,arab ext ext., They were absolute cruel, but not racist.) But armenians, and others died. I said, even He did not intent to kill all armenians, absolute he genocided armenians. Sorry I wont accept an idea just because you say this. You cannot read talat intent, nor I. Indeed so world now knows, France is supported a law because of armenian votes. exactly,Infact armenian genocide fight is always political, but until now world never saw political face of discussion. Now They see it. true,but after all french motivation is also political.(Armenian votes.) I am turk. (Maybe an asimilated son of some greek ancestor, but absolute Turk.) So now you can swear me.
  11. Infact I believe genocide is a big massacre. This intent thing is absolute bullshit. If Intent is only important point, There was only one genocide.(Jewish one) they are killed because they are jews. It was not important where there live, how much loyalty they have against state, ext. It is not same for armenians, sorry again you are shoting your foot. So maybe I should began to think refuse armenian genocide. As I said before, Intent is a vague world.You cannot see intent of anyone.
  12. Indeed, and most probably It will never become a law.(Infact If It becomes laws, It would be better. Just think what will happen If france jail some Turkish citizens for this.) But this voting, made Armenian genocide problem as another politic problem. When It comes to politics, a lot country will choose Turkey over Armenia. EU will also choose Turkey.Infact EU is a double-edged sword, It may help armenians, or It may help Turkey.(With comdemning laws about Armenian Genocide.) indeed. But BBC also say this. The French governing Union for a Popular Movement (UMP) did not back the bill, but gave its deputies a free vote. It passed by 106 votes to 19, after most deputies left the chamber in protest against what critics say is an attempt to attract votes of the some 500,000 people of Armenian descent in presidential elections next year. It also says, Armenian genocide law passed because of armenian minority, not because of genocide itself.(So It is a france inner political issue, not a moral problem.) Lets hope, France will jail some people because of this law(If It realy happens.) I am sure both some armenians and turks like this.
  13. Infact you are calculating wrong, dont you read newspapers. Now EU is talking like Turkey. History should be discussed by historians not politicians. Weird, the ones who want Turkey in EU will help Turkey to bury armenian genocide. This time it is armenains who shot their foot.
  14. You can same for ittihatist too. Infact They were not racist people. They tought to protect Turkey, They should dismiss others. Their aim was not to kill, but to protect their country. So Ittihatist killed for land, I dont know If this is better or worse than killing for money.(What france did.) Aim was not armenians but land, armenians were hindarence. I dont claim that there was not armenian genocide.I just dont think accepting armenian genocide is beneficial for us. It is interesting that you are so stupid, you did not understand I just used your words, and It is sad, You have no idea about meaning of sarcasm. Infact It looks like you commented about yourself realy fine. You are helpless. Next time think about what are you saying. Of now should I care for your personal problems? It is you who say an algerian who lost his father should be greateful to france. So It is sad, you have no capacity to understand what you are saying. intent of young turks was not to kill armenians but to protect their land. Infact at first, They had pro-minority ideas, but with balkan wars, This ideas changed to nationalist one. So racist young turk was not a reality. So their intent was to take armenian lands, france intent is to take algerian moneys. Intent is realy a vague word. You cannot say young turk aim was to kill armenians(like nazi germany.) They did not actively followed armenians, and They did not kill and exile all armenians.(some armenians were spared.) Your intent? I think you are more racist than young Turks. Anyway, It looks like It is you who dont care about innocent life algerian lost, and It is you who cannot see wrong doings. It is interesting you have to much common thing with racist Turks. are you a sufist? But you wont become very supprised because there is some armenians left at istanbul. Happy to see you again angry child. Infact what you said is almost true.(Almost.) It is true, we did it.(intent is not much important) and It is true, a new genocide is possible too. But It is also true, armenians have hate capacity as much(even more) as us. You can do genocide too, but you had no power, and lets hope you wont have power. It is also true, Our way will meet at future too.(Maybe 100 year later maybe 1000.), so why should I help armenians? because my ancestors were murderers, I wont let my children to be murdered. It is interesting what you armenians only show is hate(also you are proud of that hate.), and you talk about humanity. Sorry but I dont think we will eat that dolma. By the way, It is interesting when you are accusing turks with becoming deniers, now you becomed deniers. If I had power to stop genocide, I will do it, but for you(haters, deniers), I will not even move my finger.(Except at forums.) did you like your medicine child? "If" is realy a big word for history. It was not Turks who won wars, It is armenians who lost war. If there were not Turks, you will lost an other war.(again araps, persians, russian,greeks etc.) Turks is not reason for your bad situation. It was your nation(and their inability to cope with other people) which reasoned this.
  15. The Convention (in article 2) defines genocide as "any of the following acts committed with intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnic, racial or religious group, as such:" (a) Killing members of the group; ( Causing serious bodily or mental harm to members of the group; © Deliberately inflicting on the group conditions of life calculated to bring about its physical destruction in whole or in part; (?) (d) Imposing measures intended to prevent births within the group; (e) Forcibly transferring children of the group to another group. Easy If this massacre happen to armenian people, It is genocide. If some people(who help armenians) make massacre It is massacre. I am critisizing my own country, dont you think I have this right? I dont like it. After Israel did to lebanons, Some Turks begin to cry, attack northern iraq. After France stupid law(For you It is sacred law), Some people decided to apply a law about algeria genocide, and now same stupid begin to say exile illegal armenians. (Like how russia did.) I dont think we have argument about this. Do we? Indeed, noone argued this.
  16. You can put a law and deport people. There were slavery laws too. Legal doesnot mean right, law does not mean justice. They just have some contact. Indeed. But you should be grateful to Turks too. If there were not Turks, You would be still live in poorness and stone age at eastern anatolia. but now you are living most advanced countries of world.(France, Usa.) No need to thanks.We dont deserve it like french. Acording to generally accepted meaning of genocide, what happened at algeria was genocide. I think you missunderstood me, even at historically Turks are not worse or better than Europeans. Every body have their bad and good past. By the way, isnt ottomans better than byzantium? I am talking about ideas some people mentioned in Turkey.Like accepting algeria genocide(Using people suffer for politic.), and exiling unlegally armenian immigrants.(this is what russia did.) It is ironically some people think, If someone make a crime, we have right to make that crime too. Well maybe you should say some of them. Still DTP(PKK legal party) get less than 50% vote of kurds. Infact Turkish parties(AKP, even MHP) rules some of kurdish cities.(Van, Iğdır,ext.) wrong that person is saying we should exile illegal armenian migrants, because they are armenians. As I said before, It is sad that moron only takes bad part of world.(Russia.) And It is also sad, He is talking about illegal immigrants(Not only armenians), and do nothing for this. This is between france and Turkey and has no relation with poor armenian workers. I dont like because these illegal migrants will suffer, but I think germany has absolutely that right. It is interesting when It comes to genocide, you accept they represent ottomans(Turks). If Ittihadist have no right to instore any speacial law, they have absolutely no right to represent Turkish people too. So maybe you should stop to claim that Turks genocided you.
  17. Infact They were legally deported. There was a law about deportion.
  18. These are mentioned by some people(not goverment.) It is disgusting, we are learning this type of things from russia or france. That 70.000 armenians(And other people) should be deported because they are illegally at Turkey, not because They are armenian. That glass house thing is dont work. how can turkey protect that illegal immigrants. It is other countries right to sent them back.
  19. I agree with you but depending on france, or russia is not a smart move. Ottomans did not conquered Europe, because they are stupid. Well You were right, but you are not right. A lot thing changed with USA attack to iraq. Relationship between Iran,Syria and Turkey is improved. Update yourself. is this necessary? I didnot refused genocide. So I dont know what are you talking about. did not take that part serious. Were you serious child? Sorry but we will survive at asia minor, most probably longer than armenians or greeks.(Not forever) By the way, Natives of anatolia are monkeys. dont you call turk as monkey?
  20. Bulgaria? We have no problem. Syria,Iran We are fine with them.(Thanks to USA, She is also our ally) Georgia, azeris. We are fine with them too.. Greece, armenia. We have bad relation with them. We have a lot allies at balkain, middle east, and central asia. Our relation with russia and Europea is improving. So we are not living a bad situation. Agree, I am just trying to say, They didnot enlarged their land because of their goverments, but because of ottomans. Infact They built states before ottomans or selcuks too. I afraid much. Yeah That was young turks solution for armenians too. You are not a heavy thinker, are you? Anyway sent all of them to us. Turkey. Infact that type of exiles will improve Turkey demographic position.We need more people. Sent all of them to Turkey. we have not any chess champion, but we have larger land than a chess table.
  21. we are not over humanity. Do you? Infact I think turks care more than enough what other think. why are armenians so wild when It comes to denial? do you realy care that all people should know your ancestors were murdered? I agree about politicians and people thing. are you an internet-psychologist? International politics are not much different than chess, so If you are good at chess, you will have better position now. Kurds are totally different issue, They never ruled themself, and their land is never joined with each other. Their position is not better than armenians. Maybe I am wrong, but I remember ROA said, our problems should be discussed within our goverments. I see that genocide claim as problem. Maybe ROA does not. It is true, our history is not objective. Yours? Abolition of slaver is changed future not past. So this is totally out of equation. Jewish holocaust is another animal but that is not a good example. One mistake dont make other mistakes right. can we prove some medical fact with laws? Sorry science of law and science of history is totally different. History can effect and change law, but laws cannot change or effect history. True Erdogan is responsible from 301, but Erdogan, Gül or others protected Armenian conference. (I should add reason is EU) They did not know some moron nationalist lawyers will attack others with such way. That cyprus issue is totally another topic, and cant see any relation. I think Turkey own something to armenians, but own totally nothing to greeks. Turkey didnot do any thing worse than greeks did. Acording to EU report there is no more orginized torture. Uh, what about BERNARD LEWIS? and other historians? Are they turkish politician too. If Turkish denial is a political act, maybe accepting armenian accusation is also politic act. So maybe we should ban it.(Remember It is not banned in Turkey) And you know who is using fake hitler quotes.do armenians never lie? Well no country will ever willingly admit genocides. Secondly If I am surrounded by enemies, I will become sorry because of my country, not because of another countries action. Anyway what will you gain with turkish acception? except political gains.
  22. I think roa said, We should discuss armenian genocide accusation between goverments(ROA and Turkish goverment), It should not be discussed by historians. I dont see any moral point to discuss genocide between two state. do you? By the way, I am talking about turkish and armenian goverment, not turkish people or armenian people. Most of Turkish people believe, There were not armenian genocide. So It is a moral issue for turks too. If they dont believe genocide, why should they accuse their ancestors with such crime? I didnot know, Turkish goverment tried to make law at other states, that say there is not armenian genocide. You cannot prove a historical fact with laws. Laws are generally related with politics. Be sure Erdogan have no relation with these prosecutions. He is an undemocratic moron, but have no relation with these. Ah I also remember some laws that punished who say that armenian genocide not happened or an historian which is punished because he refused armenian genocide. It is interesting you complain about turkish democracy. It is, both side lied others, used propoganda, and attacked each other with political means. I am still talking about turkish goverment. As I said you before, Turks generally think that armenian genocide is an unjust accusation. Ottoman empire? are we talking about 1915 or all life cycle of ottoman empire? Sometimes It is good sometimes it is bad. It looks like you are only looking for bad time of ottoman empires. is this ethical? If you were realy good chess players, dont you think You would have a better situation? You only have a landlocked country that surrounded by enemy nations, and you are loosing your population.
  23. chess for us? Not only for us but for you too. I said it is a politic conflict, not humanistic conflict.(of course talking about states, people are different matter.)
  24. we have not. (We test virginity too but not with apple way) Red Apple means most desired thing at Turkey.It is an utiopia. Acording to some turks, It was istanbul, than viyana, now It is turan.(I am sure you know what is turan)
×
×
  • Create New...