Jump to content

wh00t

Members
  • Posts

    522
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by wh00t

  1. in 1994 I visited the monastery of Narek, near Van, and found a Cross-stone of the tenth century, which I photographed-when I returned in 1997 the Kurdish villagers told me the police had come soon after my visit and destroyed it. - James R. Russell, August 9, 2001 New York Times letter to the editor
  2. quote:Originally posted by LithiumC4: I totally agree with Malayan about writing e-mail and urging the Dutch server to halt websites which mitigate this catastrophic event. Ignoring the issue is a NO NO! I didn't suggest we should ignore the issue, I suggested we ignore the denial. However, Rouben has succeeded admirably, and should be commended for his efforts.
  3. quote: Originally posted by bellthecat: People in glass houses shouldn't throw stones! /cgi-bin/forum/ultim...ic&f=4&t=000084 You take anything the Turkish media says as gospel? [ August 07, 2001: Message edited by: wh00t ]
  4. You are of course 100% correct. The official Jewish record on the recognition of the Armenian Genocide is the most shameful form of hypocrisy you will ever stumble upon. The irony that the people who suffered the largest genocide (pure form) of modern history would later lead the effort to deny the Armenian holocaust could leave anyone speechless.
  5. quote:Originally posted by Kazza: BTW off the subject for a while, what about that civil war in Afghanistan? It's been going on and on for years, and nobody gave it the slightest attention!!! The media gave Afghanistan plenty of attention when it destroyed that huge Buddha monument (and others), while Turkey destroys our precious city of Ani (under the guise of "restoration").
  6. gamavor, that Tsmer Papik / Gakhant Baba thing was just a joke and something I found amusing when looking through a Western/Eastern Armenian dictionary.
  7. I'm Bolsahye and I can't understand you people! It's not Tsmer Papik, it's Gakhant Baba! GAKHANT BABA! Anyway, all of the Armenian posts, or most of them, are in Eastern Armenian. No Bolsetsis or possibly from Gibros here? I have heard that Western Armenian will die before Eastern.. makes sense.
  8. Rouben, I'll write a letter.. but, will it do any good? There's no law in Holland recognizing the Genocide, to my knowledge. You know, on second thought it might be best not to act at all. If the webmaster sees that Armenians are actually listening to what he is saying and taking the time to try and shut him down, maybe he will feel motivated by it and this will in turn encourage his activities. I think ignoring the denial is the best thing the Armenians can do. By confronting it, the issue becomes more of a "subject under discussion" than simply "a historical fact". And that's what the Turks want, isn't it?
  9. Harut Sassounian is the man. Does anyone else look forward to reading his columns in the California Courier Online every Tuesday? His commentary is always right on the mark and he is feared by the Turks. The pen is mightier than the sword, so it seems. Check out his latest, which perfectly expresses why the "reconciliation commision" must be stopped: In an earlier column, I expressed the concern that while the recently formed Turkish-Armenian Reconciliation Commission may have had the intention of starting a dialogue with the Turks, it could end up inadvertently pitting the Armenians against each other. I had specifically expressed the fear that the formation of this commission would sour relations between the Armenian Assembly and the Armenian National Committee and disrupt their joint lobbying efforts in Washington. Van Krikorian, the Assembly's Chairman of the Board Directors, is one of the four Armenian members of this commission. Furthermore, the Assembly issued a statement supporting the commission, while the ANC's parent body, the ARF, strongly condemned its establishment. I also expressed the concern that this controversy could force the ARF to reconsider its support for Pres. Kocharian's legislative agenda in the Armenian Parliament. A presidential spokesman said last week that while the President was aware of the discussions leading to the commission's formation, he had no hand in its creation. The ARF, on the other had, expressed its displeasure at reports that Foreign Minister Vartan Oskanian had more than just a passing knowledge about the establishment of the commission. In order to clear the atmosphere of unhealthy mutual recriminations, I had suggested that the leaders of the Armenian Assembly and the ANC get together as soon as possible in Washington to see if they can come up with a common position on the critical issue of dealing with the Turks. Mr. Alexander Arzoumanian, the former foreign minister of Armenia and a member of this commission, in an interview published in Armenia last week, dismissed my concerns by describing them as "very inflammatory statements." He asserted that the Assembly and the ANC always had the best of relations and that there was no reason for concern. He boldly predicted that neither the Diaspora nor the people of Armenia would be split over this issue. Mr. Arzoumanian's comments indicate that despite his former high office and his current chairmanship of the Armenian National Movement, he has no clue whatsoever about developments in either Armenia or the Diaspora. Those who have worked with him in the past attest that he was also clueless about Armenian and international issues alike when he served as Ambassador to the United Nations and as Foreign Minister. It does not appear that his learning curve has improved very much despite his years of on the job training. This gentleman's ignorance of the issues is particularly alarming since, as Foreign Minister, he had been conducting negotiations with Turkish and Azeri officials about Karabagh and other issues of critical importance to Armenia. It is very disconcerting that he is now selected to be one of the four Armenians to sit across the table from highly experienced Turks to discuss sensitive Armenian issues. The organizers of the commission could not have made a better choice to discredit their own initiative. For the elucidation of Mr. Arzoumanian and others, I regret to report that the fears that I had expressed in my earlier column have materialized much sooner than anticipated. Last week, the two Armenian lobbying organizations in Washington were in disagreement over the mechanism and timing of introducing a new genocide resolution in the House of Representatives. While such differences of opinion have occurred in the past, the creation of the "Turkish-Armenian Reconciliation Commission" does cause the raising of unnecessary and unfair questions since one of the groups has been involved in a confidential "dialogue with the Turks." To dispel such suspicions, the leadership of the Armenian Assembly may now have to take a more aggressive approach in its long-standing efforts to secure the affirmation of the Armenian Genocide. There were similar disputes in Armenia also, last week. A high-ranking ARF delegation met with Foreign Minister Oskanian and issued a strongly-worded statement urging him to clarify the government's stand vis-a vis the commission. It was obvious that the ARF was not satisfied with the Minister's explanations. Coincidentally, the ARF faction in the Parliament, in a rare occurrence, voted against a key bill--the privatization of the electricity distribution network--that Pres. Kocharian desperately wanted to be adopted. The above examples indicate that the "Turkish-Armenian Reconciliation Commission" has had a disruptive effect on intra-Armenian solidarity in both Washington and Yerevan. The Turks have already accomplished their objective! Before Armenian interests are further damaged by the addition of two more Armenians to the commission and holding its next meeting in Istanbul, I suggest that Pres. Kocharian immediately invite the Armenian members of the commission and representatives of major Armenian organizations to a consultative meeting in Yerevan. The four Armenian members have to realize that, despite their individual status, they are not negotiating on a personal matter. Rightly or wrongly, they will be viewed by the Turks and others, as the representatives of all Armenians. Hence, they carry the heavy burden of responsibility in front of the entire Armenian nation.
  10. Tata is great.. Although he has an obsession with "sirounik akhchigneri"
  11. Harut, think of it this way: There are 8,000 Turks living in Turkey and 2,000 living elsewhere. There are 1,000 Armenians living in Armenia and 2,000 living elsewhere. Although the number of people living in the Turkish diaspora is greater, a greater percentage of Armenians live in the Diaspora (66% Armenians vs. 25% Turks). [ July 28, 2001: Message edited by: wh00t ]
  12. 2nd perhaps "per capita" behinds the Jews.. I'm guessing of course.
  13. quote:Originally posted by Thorny Rose: So, really, this "ignore them until, wee wee wee" is just arrogance and nothing else. Arrogance? Please explain. Why should Armenians give importance to what revisionist Turks think about our genocide? (Did that come out right? I'm directly translating from the Armenian 'garevorutyun gudankor'). When all else has failed, it is time to shut the Turks out and the rest will flow naturally towards Armenian interests. It is the best policy Armenians could hope for at this point. [ July 23, 2001: Message edited by: wh00t ]
  14. Then would you be willing to engaged with them in a normal human manner, now? Or would you be still willing to insult and alienate them? Previous posts by me in this thread explicitly praise Taner Akcam and others like him. Do you mind if Turkey recognizes before the US does? No. Or if the US and Canada recognize it, do you feel it is a reason for Turkey to recognize it? If yes, why? US and Canadian recognition would promote sympathy towards the Armenians, and build up the pressure on Turkey to recognize the Genocide. It will open doors for Armenian claims for compensation, monetary and otherwise. It may not be a direct reason for Turkey to recognize it, but it could be a consequence of it. But it didn’t pass, right? Had you read the text of the H. Res. 596? If not, you can find it in our Forum. It wasn't given an oppurtunity to pass. I have read H. Res. 596, both pre- and post- amendend versions. But if we are not a powerful voice, as you assert, why would any powerful party rush to our “rescue?” We have a good lobby. Congressmen have to please the Armenians in their districts. We discussed this already. I don’t think it is desperate. It has other alternatives – maybe not as sexy looking, but nevertheless, other alternatives are available to Turkey. It is desperate. Turkey hopes the EU will bring much-needed foreign investment and employment in the country. In fact it has. Only we, from the position of not understanding the rules of the game, may make such assertions. Turkey has known perfectly the rules of the game throughout its existence, it has played by the rules, and that’s why it has always emerged victorious. If commiting cultural genocide against the Kurds, leading a militarist and oppressionist government, destroying ancient monuments, committing genocide against the Armenians and Greeks, threatening other nations with violence and severe repercussions when it doesn't get its way, ignoring prisoners who are dying on hunger strike by the day, ignoring farmers who are going broke in the east, and on and on and on... if you consider that playing by the rules, then what can I tell you. How much do you think they care about the Western standards of Human Rights? They better start caring if they want into the EU. I hope that you are never in position to make strategic decisions which such assessment. A nice touch. Relax and smile. Likewise yourself. [ July 23, 2001: Message edited by: wh00t ]
  15. How about those Turks who accept that the Genocide has taken place, and feel sorry for it? I don't have anything to change their minds about. Recognition by Turkey or the rest of the world? Recognition by the rest of the world, and then Turkey. In that order. Understandably, Turkey will never acknowledge the Genocide without a reason to do so. Then how do you expect and for the sake of what the US to recognize more importantly, to condemn the Genocide? Why is this such a shock? H. Res. 596 was easily going to pass last year. We have a good lobby in the USA, but that alone doesn't make the Armenians extremely powerful. Don’t you think that you contradict yourself? Nope. We alone don't have a powerful voice. We need outside help. Somehow I don’t see Turkey being isolated, but the opposite – every major power from Russia to the US rushes to do business with Turkey. This is true. But it doesn't mean Turkey doesn't desperately want to join the EU - she does. And as much as you may be surprised, Turkey’s acceptance in the EU is in the best interest of Armenia. The acceptance would obligate Turkey to “play by the rules," it would provide Armenia with increased national security guarantees, would probably force Turkey to lift Armenia’s blockade, and would open a new venue for the recognition of the Genocide, itself. Turkey has never played by the rules, so it's not surprising to see many Armenians skeptical about any such change as a result of anything. But hey, you could be right. The situation between the nations is bound to ameliorate if Turkey is accepted.. but that isn't saying much - the situation can't get much worse at this point. It has in fact hardened Turkey’s position. With a hardened position, Turkey further isolates itself from Western standards of human rights, and again they lose.. while Armenians gain nothing and lose nothing. You are not alone, at all. In fact, you represent the majority, but as Soren Kierkegaard claims, “Truth always rests with the minority, and the minority is always stronger than the majority, because the minority is generally formed by those who really have an opinion, while the strength of a majority is illusory, formed by the gangs who have no opinion-and who, therefore, in the next instant (when it is evident that the minority is the stronger) assume its opinion . . . while Truth again reverts to a new minority.” Ouff!
  16. Then how do you know that their mind is set? We're not talking about buying a pair of shoes that one can think twice about in a second. This is a serious, sensitive subject for both parties. To any Turks, Azeri, etc. who ardently proclaims that there was no Genocide, I will not attempt to pick their brain to prove that they feel that way, nor is it worth it for me to spend my time and effort to try and change their minds. I definitely thing that the issue of the Armenian Genocide may be resolved only jointly with the Turks, and I wouldn’t give a damn about the entire worlds’ recognition of the Genocide. Others are not going to resolve our problems. On the contrary, in my opinion recognition is the one and probably only key to solving this dispute in a way that does not conflict with the interests of the Armenian people. We are a small people, our influence is limited. (Granted, we have a great lobby in the USA.) Turkey laughs at our claims, and I don't blame them. Who are the Armenians, anyway? In their eyes, an insignificant people trying to destroy their national honor by accusing them of something as horrific as Genocide. We don't have a major voice. The world's superpowers do. We need them to exert pressure upon Turkey, because we can't. If the EU upholds the Armenian Genocide prerequisite, for whatever political reason, Turkey will not budge and will just sit even further isolated than it is at present. A few more "the world is out to get us" editorials with appear in Milliyet. Have the Armenians won anything by the Turkey not being able to join the EU? No. Has Turkey lost anything by it? Yes. It's just a matter of how deep in isolation it goes and how much losses must they cut before they start to look at things from a different perspective. This may not be the universal Armenian standpoint, but I know that I am not alone with these opinions.
  17. quote:Originally posted by MJ: How do you know that? Have you tried it? Have I tried to change the minds of people with fixed mindsets against Armenian Genocide recognition? No. For me, it is a tedious and ultimately futile journey to embark upon, but that's just my view. You seem to have a different take on it, and all I can do is praise you for it. I don't want you to call me a spreader of misinformation, but from what I have been reading, it *SEEMS* that you share Thorny Rose's view that we need to cooperate with Turkey when it comes to the Armenian Genocide. Based on these views, raising awareness among the Turks, as you suggest it, is necessary. However, as you can tell, I can't relate with the Turkish cooperation bit. I do not entirely disagree with Turko-Armenian dialogue, but I feel we have tried that already, and it has failed, and we cannot get much good out of it. The current reconciliation commission is a mistake; on this point, I'm with the ARF. Therefore, simply to ignore is the next best policy. With such a policy, I am more motivated to spread awareness among the rest of the world, who are more impressionable because they have been exposed to no information about the Genocide in the past, rather the Turks, who, through no fault of their own have been fed lies for their entire lives. I will not try to do anything for them, it's not worth my time and effort.
  18. quote:Originally posted by MJ: If you can on your way also put some effort to raise the awareness of the Turks from an 11% of their population to a 55%, you would accomplish much more significant results. I am not about to set upon changing the minds of people with fixed beliefs about the subject at hand. If you are interested in raising Turkish awareness, more power to you, and I hope you are successful. If you feel this will help the Armenian cause, you should do it yourself, rather than trying to change my course of actions. quote I disagree. The Israelis have been playing this card for decades with admirable results. quote Refer to my response to your first suggestion. I would like to say "inzi khelk mi dar," but it's a bit harsher than I would like it to be .
  19. quote:Originally posted by Thorny Rose: There are other alternatives, not too far-fetched You don't seem to realize that we're running out of options, Duke! Why aren't you leading some big Armenian-Turkish friendship program with these revolutionary "alternatives" that nobody else has thought of? quote: I disagree. I believe that, at worst, a certain portion of the population can accept Armenians. You disagree? You think that Turks who have spent their entire lives believing and holding true to their hearts that it is one big "Armenian lie" can all of a sudden change their minds if foreign and local parliaments say so? Are Turks that easy to manipulate? I'll tell you, if the world told me today, right now, that there was no Armenian Genocide, I wouldn't change my opinion. Same goes for the other end of the spectrum with the Turks. quote: I believe that there is no tangible result to be attained if you isolate Turkey. We will see. At this point, unless there is some major, sudden, drastic change, it seems as though any solution acceptable to the Armenians will come at the cost of the isolation of Turkey. And I won't lose any sleep over it.
  20. quote:Originally posted by MJ: This is an example of what I have asserted many times in the past – many Armenians prefer the problem to the solution. They would rather have Turks not recognize the Genocide If this is what you think about my stance on the issue, MJ, then I think you misread me. Under no circumstances do I ever prefer revisionism to coming to terms with past atrocities. This is my stance on the Armenian Genocide, and other examples as well, such as the Japanese denial of the rape of Nanking. However, to acheive these desired ends (ie. acknowledgment of the Genocide), I refuse to be a bystander and perpetuate the status quo. If convincing the world that there was a Genocide (by the way, MJ, do you even believe there was a Genocide?) means exposing the past barbarisms of the Turks and their ancestors, then that's what I will do. If the Turks do not want this image that is projected upon them in the West, they should take the initiative to incite change, rather than perpetuate the image by, for example, threatening other nations and unions with repercussions and violence when they don't get their way.
  21. quote:Originally posted by Thorny Rose: It is you guys who have to quit the "Turks this, Turks that" BS in order to allow them to touch reality, in a way. Oh! I am so sorry.. it is the Armenians' fault that the Turks aren't able to grasp reality! How silly of me, I should have known that. On top of charges that we committed genocide against the Turks and that we are responsible for the anti-Turkey mindset in the West, you can throw this one upon us as well. quote I would rather have worldwide recognition of the Armenian Genocide with a Turkey full of Armenophobes than simply a Turkey (and its diaspora) full of Armenophobes WITHOUT worldwide recognition (the status quo). In essence, most Turks will not change their opinion about the subject (ie. there was no Genocide, it was one big organized Armenian lie), regardless of what legislation is passed by foreign assemblies. So, by saying that there's no value in worldwide recognition because Turks bear hatred against the Armenians, then what you are really saying is that there is no value if world parliaments recognize the Genocide at all. I do not concur. [ July 23, 2001: Message edited by: wh00t ]
  22. quote:Originally posted by Thorny Rose: Does your mommy wipe your arse after s'hit-break and baby-powder it up, too? Thorny, for someone trying to lecture me on being politically correct, was that really necessary? (/me smells hypocrisy in the air.)
  23. quote:Originally posted by gamavor: Whoot, The best approach is to ignore (the Turks) until the time (probably after several centuries when their evolution hopefully would be completed) when they will realize that defending defenseless cause is waist of time and emotions. Gamavor! I could kiss you if you were standing here.. you are absolutely right! The absolute best policy the Armenians can take up at this point is to IGNORE, IGNORE, IGNORE the denial. While the Turks are whining and droning on in the background about it, the Armenians are taking initiative and getting the Genocide recognized in France, Italy, and so on (and soon Canada.. come on O beautiful nation of mine, you can do it!) The Armenians didn't even consider what the Turks were up to. As the world acknowledges what happened, one nation at a time, Turkey is going to feel even more isolated than it does now, and THEN will they look into the mirror and reflect upon how lost their cause really is. No joke "reconciliation groups" will do.. the ball is in the Armenians' court. Turkey does not want to admit to the crimes of their ancestors? Fine. We'll keep our initiative anyway. quote People like Taner Akcam give me hope, but I know that he is simply "sick" in a world of brainwashed Turks (a la "This Perfect Day" by Ira Einhorn). You are right. [ July 23, 2001: Message edited by: wh00t ]
×
×
  • Create New...