Jump to content

Siamanto

Members
  • Posts

    668
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Siamanto

  1. I remember and I'll have to agree with Anonymouse that But I will briefly comment on the following: It is true that the Renaissance was a revival and gave an impetus to both Arts and Sciences, but it is not true that "Arts and sciences did not have the chance to develop before rigid religious dogmata were effectively challenged." In fact, many "enluminures" and Music of the "Dark Ages" seem to be more "contemporary" than Renaissance Art. I'll try to find better sites. For now, check the following - I've seen much better ones, they seem to be poorly scanned: http://www.bnf.fr/enluminures/manuscrits/aman1/i3_0001.htm (Click on picture to enlarge it.) Also, check the following site (you'll have to look around!) http://witcombe.sbc.edu/ARTHmedieval.html#general Claims about Muslims - or others - having "invented" or "discovered" this or that is not new! It's never clear what is meant and is - for the most part - anecdotal. We've heard it many many times before! In any case, asking for clarifications is the best way to understand someone, specially when the other person is from a different background! I can't learn from "one-sentence statements." I can only learn from explanations.
  2. First of all, thank you for the references: at least, now there's something to talk about! That may be a very simplistic and superficial assessment! A "more developed" Military Philosophy/Technology is neither a necessary nor a sufficient condition to successfully invade and conquer other lands. It makes it more likely, it only facilitates! The following are some of the main reasons why Muslims succeeded in their conquests: 1- Islam succeeded in uniting the disparate nomadic tribes - in Arabia and Central Asia - and channeled all available forces towards a unique - sacred - goal. The Muslim Philosophy was based on the idea of conquest i.e. "aslim, taslam!" Islam gave nomads an Identity, a Goal, a new life, a revival! 2- Europeans had internal issues and were in a decadent phase and had less motivation/drive to conquer. In fact, the Crusades proved that when motivated and united they could challenge the Muslims. 3- The open space - i.e. the Arabian deserts and Central Asian steppes - acted as "Highways" - interconnecting continents - that helped them in their initial conquests. Later, they were organized and mighty enough to go deeper into Europe, but they seldom conquered Highlands using military operations. In other words, they managed to conquer because of the enemy's inability to be motivated enough to fight! In other words, they excelled in terrain where developed military technology is less required. Of course, I'm not saying that they had no Military or Administrative Genie. I'm saying: "let's not exaggerate!" Those references, at best, indicate that some Muslim Individuals contributed to Science and Art. However, the question was about Muslims as a Collectivity : schools, trends etc. A Muslim Individual contributing to European Science, Art and Philosophy cannot represent the Muslim Collectivity. Last, but not least, most of it seems to be anecdotal and unfounded. I've known Indians who claim to have discovered the same. Most importantly, it does show how Muslims were "more developed" than Europeans! The following is a short list of URLs covering European Medieval Arts & Sciences: http://members.aol.com/McNelis/medsci_index.html#Math http://witcombe.sbc.edu/ARTHmedieval.html For a more exhaustive list: http://www.hmml.org/20040210_Archive/resou.../medi_links.htm
  3. Invading and conquering another country is a sign of being "more developed!" How did I miss that? So barbarians are "more developed!" Vikings were "more developed!" Mongols were "more developed!" I hope that you are joking! Can you provide the facts and let us know what they have developed in "algebra and geometry" to qualify them as "more developed." It's easy and gratuitous to make statements! That is a sign of being "more developed!" I really would like to understand your concept of "developed Nation/Culture." Of course! Spreading Chinese gunpowder and paper is a definite sign of being "more developed!" Really! Can you name where and how the Greeco-Roman heritage has been "preserved" by Muslims? Did they extensively translate? If yes, what happened to those translations? That would have helped us in better understanding Greek philosophers and thinkers! Last, but not least, where did you "learn?" that "Europe has lost the Greeco-Roman heritage." What is your understanding of "dark ages?" I would like to see examples of this "more creative arts!" Please see replies above! Also, can you please provide references and explain why and how their banking system was "more developed?" The same about sciences. It's too easy to make statements!
  4. How Muslims were "more developed than Europe?" Would you care to give some examples? Thanks!
  5. THE ARMENIAN CULTURE IS PURPOSEFULLY DESTROYED IN GEORGIA A1+ 14-02-2005 Because of the state indifference the Javaxq cultural centers are in danger, says the agency «A-Info». If at the end of the 19th century the famous Armenian theatres of Axalqalaq and Axaltsxa were still operating, during the Soviet reign they were closed turning into self-operating groups. After the collapse of the Soviet Union these groups too ceased to exist. For a long time no Armenian plays have been staged in Javaxq. Groups from abroad do not come here either. This year the Armenian National Dramatic Theater intends to go to Axalqalaq but the financial problem has not yet been solved. The museums are also in very sad condition. There are 4 museums in Axalqalaq and Ninotsminda, two of which �~@~S the Axalqalaq provinciological museum and the house museum of Vahan Teryan in Gandza, are popular in the cultural society. If the house museum of Vahan Teryan has recently been reconstructed, the building of the Axalqalaq provinciological museum is in danger of being deconstructed. Besides, because of the indifference of the authorities, unique exhibits are disappearing from museums. The same happens with the libraries. The doors are closed, but the books become less. --Boundary_(ID_oVpv6PT83uJezPg9EkPdnA)-- http://groong.usc.edu/news/msg103083.html
  6. Armenia-Iran energy cooperation suits USA, agency says Mediamax news agency, Yerevan 14 Feb 05 Excerpt from report in English by Armenian news agency Mediamax on 14 February headlined "Armenia between Iran and the United States" The Armenian defence minister and secretary of the Security Council under the Armenian president, Serzh Sarkisyan, paid an official visit to Iran last week. [Passage omitted: details of Sarkisyan's visit] The Armenian defence minister's visit to Teheran took place right at the time when clouds began gathering over Iran. Despite the fact that the United States has not lately displayed any signs of discontent over the expanding Armenian-Iranian political, economic and energy cooperation, it should not be ruled out that the situation may change in case the pressure on Iran increases. [Passage omitted: USA imposed sanctions on Armenian company in 2002 for delivering chemical substances to Iran; details of plans to build Armenia-Iran gas pipeline] Washington, naturally, has never supported the Iran-Armenia gas pipeline project. In March 2002, the US ambassador to Armenia, John Ordway, said that the United States was not against ordinary economic relations between Armenia and Iran. "However, the USA is preoccupied with the fact that Iran supports terrorism and purchases weapons of mass destruction... As Armenia is one of Iran's closest neighbours, I expect these issues should give concern to Armenia as well," the American diplomat said. Nevertheless, over the past years the United States has made no statement against the construction of an Iran-Armenia gas pipeline. However paradoxical it may seem, we dare suppose that the construction of an Iran-Armenia gas pipeline is, in a sense, advantageous to the United States, which has begun open expansion in the South Caucasus, since the realization of this project will make Yerevan less dependent on Moscow, and, therefore, more compliant in issues concerning the promotion of relations with Washington. [Passage omitted: quotes from Armenian foreign minister's statement made in September 2004] Although a war against Iran is highly unlikely, it is obvious that the United States will increase its pressure on Teheran. This, of course, gives concern to Yerevan, which should not waste time and should work out several scenarios (optimistic, pessimistic and very pessimistic) of behaviour and wait to see how far the confrontation between the United States and Iran will go. For instance, if the rift widens, Armenia will have to be more persistent with the United States in the issue of opening the Armenian-Turkish border as an alternative to Iranian communication routes. But if US-Iranian relations warm up a little (this is, unfortunately, very unlikely), Armenia may try to assume the role of a bridge between the sides which can launch a policy of "small steps". In any case, the time has come when Armenia, which is already overloaded with numerous commitments to the powers often pursuing opposite strategic aims in the region, has to conduct a much more cautious policy. Any mistake, which is considered to be minor in the short term, can have serious consequences in the long run. http://groong.usc.edu/news/msg103077.html
  7. Pan Armenian Network, Armenia Feb 13 2005 "GASPROM" FEARS TO LOSE ARMENIA The management of the Russian gas monopolist finds it necessary to be involved in the construction of Iran � Armenia gas pipeline not to lose control of the situation. Negotiations between "Gasprom" and Turkmenian government can have a negative impact on the price policy of the Russian gas monopolist. Official Ashgabat has refused to sell gas to "Gasprom" for the same price as before and the new prices offered by Turkmenistan were not convenient for Russians. The failure of this deal will decrease the income of "Gasprom" in 2005. It is believed that the State will not allow "Gasprom" to solve its problems at the cost of local consumers. Analysts suppose that the problem will be solved by means of increasing export prices. It should be reminded that the head of "Armrosgasprom" company recently confirmed that if "Gasprom" again reviews its price policy, the rise in prices will be inevitable in Armenia. /PanARMENIAN.Net/ Turkmenistan sold gas to "Gasprom" for 44 dollars per 1000 cubic meters. "Gasprom" resold the gas for 55-77 dollars covering the costs for transit through the territory of Kazakhstan. It is quite possible that at times "Gasprom" supplied Armenia with the same Turkmenian gas which we could purchase without mediators as it was done early 90s. Conditions offered by Turkmenbashi were much more favorable than those currently dictated by "Gasprom". The Russian monopolist has forced out not only foreign exporters but also Russian "Itera". Turkmenistan will be very glad to supply gas directly to Armenia but it is impossible due to communication problems. Ashgabat seeks for alternative means of export and they evidently mean that since firstly they looked quite confident in negotiations with Russians and secondly they are going to increase their gas production by 20 percents. Turkmenistan still has only one alternative to the western route of gas transportation. That is the gas pipeline to Iran. In 2004 about five milliard cubic meters of gas were supplied through this pipeline but the diameter allows to pump one half as much again. Turkmenistan sells gas to Iran for 42 dollars, that is to say a quarter less than the price that Russians offer to their strategic partner � Armenia. For today the only way of supplying Turkmenian gas to Armenia is the northern route passing through Russia. But this situation can change after the construction of Iran � Armenia gas pipeline. The management of "Gasprom" cannot help worrying about this perspective. The emergence of an alternative to Russian gas in the region is menacing not only for the commercial interests of "Gasprom" but also the political interest of Moscow. During the recent discussion held in the upper chamber of the Russian parliament the deputy president of "Gasprom" joint stock company Alexander Ryazanov called the authorities to sanction the participation of "Gasprom" in the construction of Iran � Armenia gas pipeline since it is the only way the keep control of the situation. "If we do not take part in the construction of Iran � Armenia gas pipeline no one knows where that gas will go", Ryazanov said. According to him the Armenian � Iranian project can compete with the "Blue stream" project on which "Gasprom" sets high hopes. At the same time Ryazanov did not ignore Armenian market which "Gasprom" can lose. But Mr. Ryazanov anyway did not state his main worry. It is known that the Russian gas monopolist is extremely worried about the possible perspective of Iranian gas pipeline extension to Ukraine through Georgia and Black Sea. The emergence of a competitor in the European gas market may have extremely undesirable consequences for "Gasprom". It is notable that yet not long ago the management of "Gasprom" showed great caution in talking about the possibility of joining the construction of Iran � Armenia gas pipeline. In July, 2004 the same Alexander Ryazanov announced in Yerevan that the payback terms of the project are above the norms accepted by "Gasprom". "Gasprom" prefers short-term investments but the conflict between commercial and political interests are always solved in favor of political interests. As it seems the political decision has already been made since the second figure in the company confidently speaks about the necessity of joining the project. It should be noted that the technical-economical justification of the investments was finished long ago so in case of the final approval of the idea by Kremlin the involvement of "Gasprom" in the project will take just a few weeks. Maybe the only thing that can prevent that is the possible intensification of the conflict between Iran and the United States. Artyom Yerkanyan --Boundary_(ID_xOiZedHCxWEa2Cx+aNeEvg)-- http://groong.usc.edu/news/msg103024.html
  8. State Magazine (U.S. Dept. of State) Feb 2005 page 11-15 P O S T O F T H E M O N T H By Kimberly Hargan YEREVAN U.S. Helps Land of Noah's Ark Steer Toward Future Armenia is a young country in an ancient land. The Republic of Armenia has been independent in its present form only since the dissolution of the Soviet Union in December 1991. But the earliest mention of the region dates to the 13th century B.C., in Assyrian descriptions of the kingdom of Urartu, which was succeeded by the kingdom of Armenia in the 6th century B.C. The biblical book of Genesis refers to Noah's landing on Mt. Ararat, visible directly to the south of the capital, Yerevan. (As a result of the shifting sands of history, Mt. Ararat, located near the center of the ancient Armenian kingdom, is now just across the border in Turkey.) Archaeological evidence indicates there were settlements in the area of Yerevan from the 6th to the 3rd millennium B.C. The name Yerevan derives from a fortress settlement, Erebuni, established in 783 B.C. The ruins of Erebuni can still be seen on a hilltop in the city. In 301 A.D., King Trdat (Tiridates) III was converted to Christianity by St. Gregory the Illuminator and decreed that his kingdom would follow suit, making Armenia Armenia the world's first Christian nation. Around 400, Bishop Mesrop Mashtots devised an alphabet for the Armenian language for his translation of the Bible. The resulting literary and religious traditions have remained at the core of Armenian identity. Current U.S. involvement in Armenia got started in 1988 with relief efforts following a terrible earthquake. After independence, the country lost most of its Soviet industrial base and economic connections. It also faced the closure of its borders to the east (with Azerbaijan) and west (withTurkey) as a result of the conflict in Nagorno-Artsax. In those years, most buildings were without central heating or electricity, so trees were cut down and a spiderweb of overhead electrical lines grew as Armenians borrowed electricity where they could find it. While the first years of U.S. assistance concentrated on humanitarian needs, it's now aimed at development. Armenia was once considered the Silicon Valley of the Soviet Union, providing advanced avionics for Soviet aircraft and supercomputers. Literacy is nearly 100 percent, reflecting the high priority placed on education. But the Armenian economy collapsed. Recent annual growth rates from 8 to 12 percent a year should allow the gross domestic product this year to return to its 1991 level. A unique factor in the U.S.-Armenian relationship is the Armenian-American diaspora, which consists of several generations of Armenians who fled from troubles in this corner of the world and now call the United States home. Earlier immigrants settled around Fresno, Calif.; Boston and Detroit. Many of the post-Soviet immigrants have created a Little Armenia in Glendale, Calif., a suburb of Los Angeles. With their penchant for business, they have adapted well to life in America, including politics. They lobby Congress enthusiastically on behalf of their homeland. So the embassy works not only with audiences in Armenia, but with an American "constituency" with considerable interest in U.S. policy and actions in Armenia. The U.S. Mission focuses on improving regional security and stability, fostering the development of democratic institutions and encouraging broad-based and sustainable economic growth. State's non-proliferation and border security program office helps prevent the movement of materials for weapons of mass destruction. The Bureau of International Narcotics and Law Enforcement Affairs works with Armenian authorities to combat transportation of narcotics, money laundering and trafficking in persons. The U.S. Agency for International Development works on democracy and social reform, public health, economic restructuring and energy. The Department of Defense handles military-to-military relations and some humanitarian assistance. The Department of Agriculture has introduced an American-style extension service and created a marketing assistance program. Treasury assists and trains government officials in modern methods of budgeting and financial control. More than 90 Peace Corps volunteers teach English, advise small and medium enterprises, and develop environmental awareness. A new chancery overlooking Lake Yerevan, with a beautiful view of Mt. Ararat, is being completed. There is no clearer demonstration of U.S. long-term commitment than this state-of-theart facility. " The staff required to manage all these programs has grown tremendously over the last decade. The embassy building, the former Communist Youth League headquarters, is overcrowded. Located on a major thoroughfare, it doesn't meet current security or earthquake safety standards, crucial in this seismically active zone. A new chancery overlooking Lake Yerevan, with a beautiful view of Mt. Ararat, is being completed. The move is scheduled for early April. There is no clearer demonstration of U.S. long-term commitment than this state-of-the-art facility. Yerevan continues to be a hardship posting. Public buildings are often minimally heated during winter, if at all. Visitors to schools and offices will see students or staff bundled up in thick coats, scarves and hats. Most imports come overland through Georgia or Iran, which makes for short supplies, high prices and some petty corruption. International flights to Yerevan involve long layovers and latenight arrivals. In spite of these difficulties, an assignment to Armenia can be rewarding. The people are warm and hospitable, often inviting foreigners to join them in family celebrations. The culture is rich. Traditional music and dance flourish even in the face of competition from MTV and other sources of global influences. You can hunt for paintings, sculptures and handwoven carpets in open-air markets. Classical music, opera, ballet and jazz all thrive. As the economy improves, restaurants, cafes and clubs in Yerevan expand. The mountainous countryside is spectacular and churches,monasteries and other monuments from prehistoric times onward are sprinkled throughout the country. In a country the size of Maryland, with a population of around three and a quarter million, it's easy to see changes and meet the people who benefit directly from U.S. programs. Armenians at all levels eagerly look to the United States for support in moving from their Soviet past into the community of modern democratic nations. � The author is the public affairs officer in Yerevan. AT A G L A N C E SOURCE: CIA World Factbook 2004 Country name: Armenia Capital: Yerevan Government: Republic Independence: September 21, 1991 (from the Soviet Union) Population: 3.2 million Languages: Armenian and Russian Total area: 29,000 square kilometers Approximate size: Slightly smaller than Maryland Currency: Dram (AMD) Per capita income: $3,500 Unemployment rate: 20% Export commodities: Diamonds, minerals, food products and energy Export partners: Belgium (18.2%), United Kingdom (16.8%) and Israel (15.7%) Literacy rate: 98.6% --Boundary_(ID_9jxECNXiKVf1ZOj4oN49cg)-- http://groong.usc.edu/news/msg103126.html
  9. Reading the many replies, it seems that most agree on the following: 1- The question is very interesting and challenging 2- I don't have enough time to consider it in all its details and attempt a comprehensive answer I'm pleased to say that I agree so far! Personally, I see - at least - two different questions: 1- How a Collectivity evolves i.e. the process in itself 2- Why different Collectivities evolve 2.1 In different directions? (the direction of the process) 2.2 At different paces ? (the speed of the process) I prefer to distinguish the two questions above! 1- How a Collectivity evolves? Disclaimer: in what follows "evolve/develop" simply denotes change, movement. It has no positive nor negative connotations! I will simply state - without discussing, for lack of time - the following: 1.1 Individuals and Collectivities evolve at different paces i.e. their dynamics have different frequencies. 1.2 Individuals evolve/change at a faster pace i.e. Individuals evolve/change with a higher frequency - i.e. more often. 1.3 The dynamics of a Collectivity represents the "average sum" of the dynamics of its member s i.e. the Individuals. That explains the relative stability of a Collectivity and it's higher resistance to change. 1.4 The Collectivity evolves/changes - i.e. the "average sum" changes - due to the - above average - excess of the dynamics of certain Individuals. Only "excessive" dynamics of Individuals can change the dynamics of a Collectivity. 1.5 In order to "average down" - i.e. integrate - the dynamics of Individuals, Collectivities "channel" - or shape - the dynamics of Individuals according to well established and "understandable/recognizable/intelligible" concepts. 1.6 Collectivities, like Individuals, age; but, at a slower pace. From infancy to adolescence, then adulthood, then... In other words, Individuals may be the engine of the dynamics/Evolution, but Collectivities represent the direction, the structure, the limits and the supporting foundations. The relative stability of a Collectivity is the foundation of Memory and "directional" History. Creativity is a characteristic of Individuals! etc. etc. 2- Why different Collectivities evolve 2.1 In different directions? 2.2 At different paces ? Each case may be different! Each case can only be the result of many different - and sometimes/somehow conflicting - factors! Of course, some of factors being independent of the "process of evolution" per se! There are many factors. Some are - among many others: 1- Technological advances favors and facilitates exploration and conquests 2- "Younger" Civilizations are somehow "barbarian!" 3- ... Can you please remind us when Muslims had a "more advanced civilizations than the Europe[a]ns?" Thanks! I agree that it is based on Increments of Individual Creations, but I agree with Solaris that the foundation is not in Christianity. For instance, consider the "portiques" in Ancient Greece i.e. the cynics, the stoics etc.- I don't know the English word! A legitimate question! That is exactly why I used the word "evolution" to denote simply movement or change.
  10. nairi, What's the magic word? Abracadabra! Et voila! Saturday 15 January 2005 Turkije's crime (Turkey's crime) By René Diekstra , I want gladly, ' ' Talaat, said that you move the American life insurance societies to send us a complete list of already their Armenian polishouders. They are practically all dead now and there are no more heirs collect the money. For this reason it expires all to the state. The government is now the beneficiary. Wants that to do?' ' That was me too much and I lost my itself control. ,,U will not get such a list of me, ' ' I said, stood up and left. This passage comes from the book which published the American ambassador in Turkey, Henry Morgenthau, in 1918, briefly after he had returned to the United States. She refers to one of the most terrible atrocities from the previous century, in verschrikking to in fact only compare with the eradication of the Jews by the Nazi's. But there is an important difference. Whereas the nation which is responsible for the Jewish holocaust, has assumed Germany, for that the responsibility entirely, the nation which is responsible for those other has, the Armenian holocaust, namely do Turkey, up to on the day of today refused the same. That calls a painful question. Couple had so far always refused wants sit that Germany by its committed eradication of the Jews to admit, we then with that country in a European community? The question couples is its answers. How can we can make it then, as it to have meanwhile already decided, to concern and talk with Turkey accession? The answer sounds, fears I that but moral considerations say, essential values, subordinate has been made to political, economic and soldier-military-strategic interests. That happens more often. But it is particularly sour that this squandering of moral values has happened correctly under the chairmanship of our own minister-president, who posts itself as large waarden-en-normen a voorvechter. Morals had seen he, on behalf of the EU, of Turkey must require that she would recognise its responsibility for the genocide on the armeniërs, openly before überhaupt of conversations concerning accession talk could be. Apparently we have not progressed on this point in the previous century on. Because directly after the first world war found one worldwide that Turkey could not come, getuige the responses to a highest event remarkable in several respects on 15 March 1921. in the hardening mount street at Charlottenburg at Berlin, assassinate an Armenian student, Teilirian called, the former Turkish statesman Talaat *****, the same where Morgenthau had it in the quoted passage concerning. The assassin is seized by a raging mob, to bloedens beaten and to the police force handed over. On 2 June of that year the process starts against the dader. In this it is unambiguously determined that Teilirian have nevertheless brought, traumatised indeed heavily, but with intentionally rade, its victim for living. The next day already the Berlin court pronounces sentence: Teilirian are clearred. By the complete world a sigh of reduction and the feeling goes which the right has triumphed. For Teilirian themselves the pronouncement means nothing less than a personal transfiguration. Of upset, anxious, everything and everyone suspiciously being changes he in a person who trusts in the world, in the future and in itself gets. Its victim had been during the first world war minister of home affairs of the Turkish realm. On its command the question of the there living armeniërs ' had been solved '. In 1915, the Turkish armeniërs were deprived of their property, from their places of residence chased off and in most of the cases in a bestial manner massacred or by means of uithongering, verwaarlozing or torment for living brought. Nobody weet exactly how much it have been, but certain it is that at least 600,000 and 1.5 million armeniërs has possibly even perished. At of the slachtpartijen 16 person whose birthday it is Teilirian with geweerkolf had then fallen down. Doodgewaand one had later thrown the heavily mutilated lijk of its brother on top of him. For two days Teilirian under the body of its brother lay without move itself daring. In that time he innumerable grind to the wanhoopskreten of its sisters would have had listen who were violated always in the most repugnant manner and in pieces were finally chopped. As only survivor of its large family the boy roamed years by perzië and Turkey, until he returned at slotte in its birth city. Of the original 20,000 armeniërs were there still scarcely thirty live. On a night, this way told he the court, its mother had come revenge itself in a dream at him and him had ordered on the assassins. The acquittal of Teilirian is the first and so far only time that to a victim of the Armenian holocaust right has been done. Votes against accession of Turkey sometimes the only other manner is able appear ensure that it does not remain at that one time. ------- Saturday 29 January 2005 To auschwitz by means of Istanbul (To auschwitz by means of Istanbul) By René Diekstra There are still people, who have to euvele courage deny that the nazi's millions have assassinated Jews in concentratie-kampen. That proved to be these yielded again, note bene in Germany, where was commemorated that 60 years suffered the concentration camp auschwitz was delivered. The dead meter of that camp is on 1,500,000 continues stand. The German government and the major part of the German people are ashamed themselves immensely for those under them, which denies this reality rockly-hard. ' Negationisten ' they are called. With negationisten the modern, democratic and right-minded duitser wants nothing do has. And that is also the only appropriate response. But how differently the situation is with respect to another atrocity of nearly the same scope as auschwitz, of which this year also a ' jubilee ' takes place. Assassinated on 24 April 1915 in some Turkish cities thousands Armenian politicians, priests and intellectuals were taken up, partly directly and partly deported. It was the start signal for the eradication of the largest part of the Armenian population in the Turkish realm. Of the two millions there live armeniërs see through by it according to prominent historians certain 1,200,000 in concentratie-kampen, met end slachtpartijen or uithongering. Dubious Recently I on this attention have asked for this Turkish auschwitz. Reason was the decision of the EU with Turkey start conversations concerning accession. From humanitarian and moral point of view an extremely dubious decision. Consecutive Turkish governments, current included, have always denied the mass assassination on the armeniërs and also the largest part of the Turkish population does that. This Turkish ' negationisme ' are just as terrible as the German negationisme. In my opinion the EU the point of view would have had take that concerning accession to the Union be talked cannot, before Turkey recognises its debt and responsibility in these openly. I have the conscience. My Article in this newspaper had hardly appeared or it rained e-mails, nearly all with, to I can make up, shippers with Turkish names. The contents of the most of it lie there not for. One makes me or the most violent reproaches or starts ordinary grof scold. A short flower reading. ' this is such an attack on Islam, because you are Christian and the armeniërs also ', ' you does not have lie, no mass assassination has taken place ', ' it is grof scandal that you your column in the newspaper for spreading this type anti-Turkse nonsense abused '. Moreover also veiled threats, which I will not repeat here. Also the newspaper had pay for it. ' grof scandal, which them such a politically-policy-political-propagandist Article has placed '. I do not will reflect of it provisionally from that these responses the conception of the majority of in the Netherlands live people of Turkish source. But they reflect unfortunately the official Turkish point of view. Important Unfortunately, because in the 20 years that I keep myself with the subject busy, me has become clear that it a point of view is against the facts in. Also the parliaments of several European countries, such as France in 2001, and since December 2004 also the Netherlands, have been meanwhile persuaded of atrocious truth of the Turkish auschwitz. It concerns an important question. This way important that it would be even correct if we would use in the Netherlands the pleasing referendum concerning the European constitution by means of ' no ' clear to make that no conversations with Turkey to be possible take place before them its negationisme give up. I leave, beside what I rather has written, reasons still two for that call. During the first world war Turkey chose the side of Germany and German diplomats were informed precise of the way in which the Turkish minister of home affairs, Talaat *****, the eradication of [ the Hitler Armeniers by means of a special for that established organisation let carry out. Intention reason that the genocide on the Armeniers with that model has has been stood which on Jews. More strongly still, Hitler themselves were which is in 1939, briefly for the bloody attack on Poland, legerbevelhebbers as follows clear made that Germany of the world opinion nothing to fear had. ' Wer nor, ' this way said to redet heute he, ' von of the Vernichtung of the Armenier?' The Nazi's had contributed actively to that dumbness himself, for example by booking concerning the Armenian eradication to prohibit (a situation which exists in Turkey de facto still). Also anderzins played Germany in these a dubious role. Talaat ***** were condemned because of its role in the Armenian genocide after the war by a Turkish court at contumacy for the dead, but got political asylum in Germany. Moreover, the Turks themselves that condemnation never have seriously taken. It had been especially meant as a knee inflection to the allied victors, such as becomes clear from the following. In Istanbul a mausoleum for Talaat has been set up and doorheen Turkey still streets and squares have been named after to him. Differently said, also by means of Istanbul you can end up in auschwitz.
  11. Siamanto

    Toilet Humor

    My experience says: " Depending on how good she looks, some other guy is sick and tired of putting up with her." By the way, is the following a "criticism" - "criticism" may not be the right/best word - of men or women? "No matter how bad she looks, some other guy is sick and tired of putting up with her. "
  12. Siamanto

    Spring Fashions

    Instead of picturing yourself in the corner, consider being the center of attention! A different perspective! Thanks! (Note: in what follows, I'm basing my appreciation mainly on Fall Collections. It's more difficult to be creative with Spring Collections.) 1 Kai Milla I did not enough free pictures of her work; so I can't express an opinion! 2 Oscar de la Renta I agree that he's an accomplished, creative and daring professional. Overall, I liked the Fall 2005 Collection. http://www.newyorkmetro.com/fashion/fashio...ardelarenta.htm What I don't like in him is of subjective nature i.e. taste. I don't like: - use of "paillettes" (those shiny little things!) - detailed "arabesque!" embroidery - laces - shiny fabrics - American style gowns - but I like the gowns with "curtain fabric!" The ones with flowers painted Overall, I like the choice of fabrics and colors. -Valentino I found his work a bit mediocre: both Women and Men Collections. For instance, check the Fall 2003 Collection at http://www.newyorkmetro.com/fashion/fashio...s/valentino.htm - Yohji Yamamoto Dod not care much for his Women Collection - with the exception of one or two black ones. I prefer his Men Collection. Personally, I would consider wearing some of his Men Collection. http://men.style.com/fashion/collections/F...ete/thumb/YYMEN Overall, I enjoy his contemporary minimalist taste! - Vera Wang I prefer her work to Oscar de la Renta's. I enjoy the minimalism, the simple cuts and the mixture and nature of the colors she uses! Please allow me to sound prejudiced and say: "after all, she's of Chinese background and de la Renta Latino!" Fall 2005 Collection at http://www.newyorkmetro.com/fashion/fashio...os/verawang.htm I also like more creative fashion Collections where the designer dares to "paint and sculpt!" Check Galliano's 2004 Fall Collection at http://www.newyorkmetro.com/fashion/fashio...s/johngalliano/ and http://fashionfile.com/designers/JohnGalliano.html Needless to say that this is not everyday wear, but Haute Couture. I'll try to find some old Lacroix. The best I could find is Fall 2002 Collection. http://fashionfile.com/designers/ChristianLacroix.html Can you please elaborate? Thanks! What you think of the following? - Avetisian Syuzi - Dudukchian Inga - Manukian Yulia - Sharbatyan Arthur - Stepanyan Margarita We already agreed that the fact that they're Armenian is not a sufficient reason to praise their work. However, you should not be harsher on them only because you are proud of your ancestry and would like to see them shine! Personally, I view the works displayed at fashion.am as prototypes; they are not finished works! Like any other prototype, they are poorly manufactured, they are not polished, they are poorly presented and "packaged." They are simply proof of concept, and I am impressed by some of the concepts! It will take some time, exposure, maturity and funds before they will be able to export their work. On the bright side, the most valuable element in a creation is the vision, the inspiration, the dream; the rest is only a matter of time, effort and money!
  13. Siamanto

    Spring Fashions

    I agree with you! However, I would appreciated if you could elaborate and explain what makes them "mediocre?" The choice of fabrics, the choice/mix of colors, the cuts, the style, the workmanship etc. etc? Can you please provide a list of fashion designers that you appreciate? Thanks! As a reference, I have provided - repeated below - a list of non-Armenian designers that I appreciate. - Galliano - Christian Lacroix - JP Gaultier - Issey Miyake - Junko Shimada I have also provided a list - repeated below - of Armenian designers that I find talented: - Avetisian Syuzi - Dudukchian Inga - Manukian Yulia - Sharbatyan Arthur - Stepanyan Margarita I'm looking forward for your list! Let's compare! For the record: I don't think you mocked the Armenian designers. I did not use the words in reference to your criticism! Please provide names/references. Thanks! I believe that most - if not all - members of this forum would agree with you!
  14. nairi, Did you notice that Western Armenians did an excellent job in remembering children songs, yet had no - or almost no - contribution in this thread? Why is it so? Is it because we have been deprived from our Lands - still infested by *urks - and had to settle in big cities, away from animals? PS. I am auto censoring "*urk" because it is an unpleasant word, with evil and immoral connotations!
  15. The truth is that, like it or not, such "scientific" "irrefutable" "discoveries", no matter now false, are quick to find high-ranking supporters, contributing to that very "gender stereotyping" and "discrimination". We don't even need to go far to find out how such thinking affects the treatment of women: During Dr Summers's presidency, the proportion of tenured jobs offered to women has fallen from 36 per cent to 13 per cent. Last year, only four of 32 tenured job openings were offered to women. style_images/master/snapback.png I believe that I've already answered that question! Do false claims and unsound ideas find echo and support in The Neocon Society? They do! Can you "objectively" debate with a Pro-War Neocon? I sincerely doubt the usefulness? etc. etc.
  16. No I'm not "making it seem like it's women who started writing about intelligence..." What exactly gave you that idea? Not everything is about opposing men and women! Personally, I don't have much time for that! It was about the claim of having an "objective" debate. No, I'm trying to turn this around. I'm simply saying that there can no "objective" debate about this issue, only pseudo-scientific! Last but not least, each camp probably thinks having done a good job! Good luck! I just don't want to get into this "men vs women" competition! I don't see things from that angle!
  17. That's it! I would probably agree less with myself if I read it carefully! I did not base my choice of Sharon Stone on Basic Instinct! I understand what you may have in mind, but she has - or portrays - a strong character and she's still feminine! Also, it's good to have diversity!
  18. Siamanto

    Spring Fashions

    This uneducated and untrained fool rather listen to Aznavour any day over Harut and P. Diddy and rather see people in their Armani outfits. You trained and educated keep listening to Paul and Harut and wear my rug as a suit and claim to be in fashion. style_images/master/snapback.png For the record: "High Quality Music" meant Classical musicians such as Zimmerman, Stockhausen and Cage. I don't know Harut and Paul and did not have in mind P. Diddy! PS. Again, it was not about you!
  19. Personally, I think that it is impossible to "objectively" debate the "existence" or "non-existence" of God! Similarly, I think that it is impossible to debate this subject "objectively" and I don't encourage pseudo-scientism. Intelligence is such a complex concept with many connotations and forms. Can biological differences explain the out performance of certain in some areas and their under performance in others? To some degree! Can physical, biological "handicaps" can be overcome with the help of determination, will and perseverance? Yes! Are the biological differences such that they cannot be easily overcome? Apparently not! Do biological differences always favor - or disadvantage - only one of the genders? I don't think so! Is it important that all individuals perform "equally" in all domains? I don't think so! etc. etc. I don't understand why it matters what a certain "scientist" thinks - or not - about your capabilities? Are you going to change the perception of yourself and the belief in your capabilities , if tomorrow a "scientific" "irrefutable" "discovery" "proves/indicates" that women are less "intelligent" than men? I hope not! Many scientists, sociologists, psychologists have published "irrefutable," "objective" - yet false - proofs/results in the past! Also, often "scientific" results simply record facts as they are - or seem to be - today i.e. the results of many thousands of years of male domination - at least, in certain domains! Any observation would be naturally "altered." Personally, what annoys me most in the generation of old fashioned feminists is the fact that they measure the professional performance, social standing, role and worthiness of women using values and indicators that were invented, developed and refined by males during the last several thousands of years. They evaluate and interpret the degree/nature of emancipation of a woman according to the values of a Society established and "incorporated" by males. For instance, why should "intelligence" be what the existing Society understands as such? There are many forms of intelligence! It is possible for a woman to have an strong individuality and remain feminine: Fiona Apple, Sharon Stone, Drew Barrymore and Fanny Ardant, to name a few! It's more about a culturo-socio-political struggle than an "objective" debate! What matters is that individuals - men or women - are given the same chances and opportunities to achieve their dream!
  20. Siamanto

    Spring Fashions

    For the record: My original reply ended as follows: What about the "French" kiss? (I did not know there was another way of kissing! )
  21. Siamanto

    Spring Fashions

    Azat, Who are Harut and Paul? Are you talking to imaginary people? By the way, it was not about you! Also, apparently it is OK to look down on and mock what designers create in Armenia, but it's not OK to point out the narrow minded arrogance of a person! PS. By the way, I did not know that listening to P. Diddy was fashionable! Thanks!
  22. Siamanto

    Spring Fashions

    I wouldn't be so sure! Compare the colors/motifs in Parajanov and the sense of "collage" to some of the works. Harder to compare Sarian and Minas, but I agree with Armen's comments!
  23. Siamanto

    Spring Fashions

    Yes! The untrained and uneducated eyes may be overwhelmed! Similarly, the untrained and uneducated ears hear street noise in some High Quality Music! It's never late to refine and educate our senses and learn to appreciate! Yes, there's a vast Universe beyond the narrowness of our perceptions!
  24. Siamanto

    Spring Fashions

    Thank you for the clarification! For the record, Hugo Boss is not "Haute Couture" while most of what is presented on fashion.am is! Hard to compare! Thank you for the clarification!
  25. Siamanto

    Spring Fashions

    OK! Only the statue? How about "French???" fries? (That the French consider Belgian!) How about "French???" dressing? (That no French have heard of?) I agree!
×
×
  • Create New...