Jump to content

Armen

Members
  • Posts

    3,439
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Armen

  1. Yes, I remember that joke Gams However I don't agree that it was a "Qaj Nazar" situation. Soviet league had teams like Dinamo Kiev, Zenith and Dinamo Tbilisi playing agaist Ararat, which were impossible to defeat without a team effort.
  2. Armen

    Empires

    Ironically, Churchill's and Roosevelt's lives were saved by a couple of Armenian KGB agents (Gevork and Goar Vartanyan) during Tehran conference in 1943. Yuri Kuznets writes about this in his recent book "Teheran-43 or Operation Long Jump". http://www.fas.org/irp/world/russia/teheran43.html Actually, in Soviet movie of 70s Tehran-43 has Charles Aznavour and another french singer (don't know the English spelling for her name) performing "Une Vie Damour". Alain Delon is also in the cast.
  3. Armen

    SEVAN!!!

    Among other criteria's to evaluate our government's national security policy is its program on Sevan. Sevan and Ararat valley are ecologically connected. If something happens to Sevan the valley will change its ecology and Armenia's main food supply base will vanish.
  4. Gamavor, how do you explain Ararat-73 then? Note: I agree with your statement.
  5. Armen

    SEVAN!!!

    http://www.hetq.am/eng/ecology/0409-sevan.html A critical moment for Lake Sevan [september 8, 2004] The six-meter increase in the water level is not based on science Lake Sevan was once a reservoir of water fit for drinking, according to physical, chemical, and biological indices. But today, as a result of the intensive exploitation of the lake over the years, its ecological system has been disturbed, with falling water level and resultant swamping bringing about qualitative changes, and the state of its native fish life, the most sensitive index of the health of the lake, has changed. There used to be three kinds of fish native to Sevan – ishkhan (trout), koghak (carp) and beghlu (barbus). Beghlu is a species peculiar to Lake Sevan . It has never had any economic significance, much less so today. The quantity of Koghak has decreased catastrophically as well, to the point where scientists plan to declare it an endangered species. Of the four types of Ishkhan, two used to spawn in the lake, and two in the rivers. Two of these have disappeared, since their spawning grounds have vanished as the water level has fallen, and the other two are on the verge of extinction. Today only two kinds of fish of industrial significance remain in Sevan – Sig (whitefish) and lake sazan . Four years ago a project to restore Lake Gilli , in the southeast of the Sevan basin, was launched, and it was expected to play a vital role in saving the Sevan eco-system. Lake Gilli had dried up as a result of the drop in Sevan's water level. Since then, 110 kinds of birds have disappeared from the basin, and the republic as a whole has been deprived of 35 kinds of birds. The Gilli project failed, and it is not clear yet what the fate of a second project, recently started with an impressive initial investment of $1 million, will be. The most striking evidence of the government's mishandling of the Sevan problem is the complete absence of purifying stations on the lake. But even if they were in operation, they would have trouble preventing the damage to Sevan caused by agriculture. Irrigation is not the only problem. The inability of villagers to utilize fertilizers correctly contributes to the free flow of nitrates and phosphates into the lake, the majority of which come from industrial and household wastewater. Twice in the past, a decision was made to build in a purification station in Gavar. Both times, the decisions were reversed and new enterprises were built. Delays in putting the Vorotan River-Arpa River hydro-system into operation have played a role as well. It has come to light through the 2002 annual report of the Ministry of Ecology that although 1.4 billion drams (about $2.7 million) was allocated for the construction of a tunnel, no work was carried out. There is another factor threatening the stability of the level of Sevan which is beyond human control, the negative impact of evaporation on the water level over the past few years. The volume of water lost through evaporation has been greater than the volume of water flowing into the lake. And although there has been heavy rainfall in the last two years, scientists predict that in connection with global warming, evaporation will increase in the future. Some even hold the pessimistic view that no matter what is done, the lake will eventually evaporate completely. But at least this year, unprecedentedly abundant rains have helped revive the beautiful mountainous lake. Today, Sevan seems to be waking up, its dead green color gradually turning healthy and vivid. It is expected that when the Vorotan - Arpa hydro-system goes into operation, 165 million cubic meters of water will flow into Sevan each year. This will be a miracle cure for the lake, now at death's door. The Law on Sevan stipulates that the level of the lake must rise by six meters. Compared to 2000-2001, the water level has already gone up one meter and seventeen centimeters. But a real battle has begun between ecologists and the government over goals for the lake. Scientists say that emphasizing the six-meter mark not only is unfounded scientifically, but also might have very dangerous consequences for the lake. The chairman of the NGO For Sustainable Human Development , Karine Danielyan, explains, “The ecological system of the lake will become healthier if the lake water returns to its level in the nineteen-sixties, i.e. 1,908.5 meters, when the processes of decline had not yet begun and the lake was in its natural, balanced state. That's the only way that the water quality will improve, the flora and fauna will revive, and it will become possible to talk about saving Sevan.” “This six meters won't do anything for the lake,” says the deputy-director of the Institute of Hydro-ecology and Pisciculture of the Academy of Science , Bartugh Gabrielyan. “Maybe it will hold up the swamping process, but it will not improve the water quality, and Sevan's most important problem is water quality. People were talking about six meters at a time when the lake's water level had fallen by eighteen meters. Since then the water level has kept falling, up to twenty to twenty-two meters, but now the same figure is being mentioned again. ” Minister of Ecology Vardan Aivazyan says that the figure of six meters appeared as a result of a study by experts from the World Bank. The real story is somewhat different. At one time, the Institute of Hydrology of the Academy of Science of Armenia , together with institutes in Moscow and Rostov ( Russia ), developed a mathematical model to find out what would happen in the lake after the water level increased, and what level would be necessary to return the water quality to its previous grade. The mark of six meters was found as a result of applying this model. Accepting these dated findings, without taking the trouble to do new research or ask the opinion of local scientists regarding the current situation, international experts merely reiterated the six-meter mark. The fact that the ecological system of the lake has changed for the worse, with new problems raising their heads, has been completely ignored. The reason that the government doesn't want to consider raising the level of the lake by more than six meters may simply be that a rising water level will become a real threat to dozens of lakeside vacation houses owned by the nouveaux riches with positions and connections. Waves are lapping at the walls of Gagik Tsarukyan's lakeside “cottage”, and dozens of other buildings are already under water. So today, stubborn attempts are being made to reduce even the six-meter mark. The marzpet (governor) of Gegharkiunik, Stepan Barsegyan, says he receives unofficial instructions that the water level should not go up by more than four meters. The director of Sevan National Park , Gagik Martirosyan, employs doubtful arguments to suggest that an increase of even by one meter would be enough for Sevan. This could mean that the quantity of water entering the lake will be controlled, in order to protect the owners of lakeside buildings. There are 350-400 structures along the coast today, owned by both individuals and organizations, the majority of them illegal. The government will not compensate the owners of illegal constructions if they go under water. But the government will have problems with the landlords whose houses were built with permits from town-planning authorities. These landlords are understandably furious, since none of the local officials or ministers dropped a hint about the water level increase as they handed out these permits. But the strange thing is that construction work is still going on all around the lake, even though local officials now warn builders that their projects might one day be under water. The fifteen to twenty hectares of lakeside forests that have been planted over the last fourteen years will be absorbed into the lake as well, a sad but unavoidable loss. Today for the first time in years, there is a real possibility that the lake will be saved. The Vorotan - Arpa hydro-system, the twenty-eight rivers that flow into the lake, and the reconstruction of the Yeghvard Reservoir all hold real promise for Sevan. The unprecedentedly heavy precipitation of the last few years was an unexpected gift. Some ecologists believe that even without the hydro-systems Sevan may come back from the brink of death. If, of course, its salvation is not sacrificed to the interests of the oligarchs. It's a critical time for Lake Sevan once again. The general public has been deprived of information about what has been going on around Sevan. It has been deprived of the right to participate in deliberations over the fate of the lake that plays such an important role in the life of generations to come. Perhaps this is because both our government and our society are lacking in environmental awareness. People sit by silently, uninformed, as their rights and interests are threatened. Karine Danielyan
  6. http://komitasquartet.mdp.am/eng/index.html This was in the links of the web-site. Check out the story of Komits Quartet. Very interesting.
  7. From Iravinq Weekly: A revlutionary situation as described by Lenin: "When the 'lower classes' do not want to live in the old way and the 'upper classes' cannot carry on in the old way". A revolutionary situation with Armenian characteristics: "The authorities doesn't want a change, the opposition cannot make a change and the people get a good beating".
  8. Armat, what do you think about the article above? Check out who the author is. Edit: second sentence
  9. http://www.cacianalyst.org/view_article.php?articleid=2658 CENTRAL ASIA - CAUCASUS ANALYST Wednesday / September 08, 2004 RUMSFELD AND THE CAUCASUS: AMERICA’S DEEPENING INVOLVEMENT IN THE SOUTH CAUCASUS CONFLICTS Stephen Blank Even without terrorism, there would be more than enough reason to fear that the South Caucasus might erupt in violent conflict and endanger the interests of all those powers who have significant interests there. Turkey seeks to internationalize the peacekeeping contingents now operating in the South Caucasus and Russian observers fear that NATO is gearing up to intervene in the Georgian-South Ossetian crisis. Recently, the man in the middle of Washington’s watchful solicitude for American interests has been Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld. In meetings in Washington with Georgian President Mikhail Saakashvili and in Baku with President Ilham Aliyev, Rumsfeld has sought to reinforce and secure Washington's position and interests in the South Caucasus. BACKGROUND: U.S. interests in the South Caucasus include thanking both Georgia and Azerbaijan, the only Muslim country with forces in Iraq, for their support of the U.S. invasion there. But much more is at stake than expressions of gratitude. Rumsfeld clearly aims to strengthen the U.S. military programs to train and equip the Georgian Army, which evidently were extended owing to his conversations with Saakashvili, and to defend Azerbaijan’s coastline. These programs provide the basis for future bilateral or multilateral cooperation of these armies with the U.S. military or with NATO. They are also the centerpiece of any hope for reform of Georgia’s defense structures, a prerequisite for realizing the regime’s great goal of inclusion in NATO. Rumsfeld’s discussions with Saakashvili undoubtedly worked out the modalities of continuing this program and ensuring its funding. Rumsfeld and his colleagues at the State Department also evidently were instrumental in persuading Georgia to resume work on the Baku-Ceyhan pipeline, which had been stopped due to environmental concerns. Work was only resumed after high-ranking State Department officials personally vouched for its environmental security and steps were taken to allay Georgian concerns. But it is also possible that the threat of the suspension of the pipeline’s construction was used to induce the United States to support Georgia’s position in the dispute with Russia over South Ossetia. Undoubtedly this crisis also lay at the center of Rumsfeld's discussions. While Colin Powell called for mediation of the crisis, both Tbilisi and Moscow regularly appear to be acting in ways that alternate provocation and moderation, and not always in well thought out ways. On both sides, there has been plenty of bellicose rhetoric, coupled with local acts of violence and covert Russian attempts at violence or support for separatists that were, as is almost always the case, found out, which only inflamed matters further. IMPLICATIONS: Georgia is already spending millions that it can ill afford on weapons. Whether this spending is for defense against Russian or Russian-supported forces or is intended to threaten separatists, it appears that only through Washington's facilitation of negotiation is a peaceful resolution possible. This fact underscores the centrality of the U.S. presence in the area to the preservation of peace and America’s beneficial impact upon the habitually tense Russo-Georgian relationship. But secretaries Rumsfeld and Powell’s intervention also underscores the need for Moscow and Tbilisi to avoid provocative and poorly conceived actions that may play well at home but lead to an irretrievable tragedy for all parties. And, in fact, we cannot count on either actor to avoid the temptation to score quick or cheap points that only escalate tensions further. Azerbaijan also presents problems for Washington, not least because of the stalemated war with Armenia over Nagorno-Artsax which shows no sign of coming closer to political resolution even as Aliyev’s government ratchets up the belligerent rhetoric and play to the large refugee population in Azerbaijan. Increasing numbers of people in Baku feel that despite all the help it has given Washington, America has not helped provide an answer to the problem. This view overlooks the fact that without a decent army of its own Azerbaijan cannot compel Armenia to yield, and goes hand in hand with the dangerous stimulation of belligerent rhetoric that the Aliyev government has fostered. But at the same time both Iran and Russia oppose extension of Baku’s military collaboration with Washington and if America cannot help Azerbaijan with Armenia, Aliyev may feel he has no choice but to turn to those two countries for help. After all, both also dispose of formidable means of inciting internal unrest inside Azerbaijan and have not shrunk from doing so in the past. That potential leverage is obviously another reason for Aliyev to harken to them rather than Washington. Certainly Iran has in the past tried not just to restrict and curtail America’s military presence but also to incite agitation for an Islamic regime there. Moscow has played at coups against the governments in Baku that have ruled since 1991, including that of Aliyev’s late father, Heydar Aliyev, and remains the nearest great power even if some analysts charge that a subterranean Irano-Russian rivalry is taking place and that Tehran believes that Russia is in long-term retreat. Undoubtedly Aliyev and his government seek the kind of assistance that Washington has given Georgia in defending its sovereignty against Russia as well as more tangible assistance against Armenia. But failing to get it, Aliyev has turned to Russia, China, and Pakistan for support. Islamabad has previously promised defense cooperation, i.e. arms sales and training for Azeri officers. China also provides such training and has improved its defense and energy profile in Azerbaijan by also buying into Azeri oil projects. Thus Rumsfeld apparently hurriedly included Azerbaijan in his itinerary of trips to Oman, Afghanistan, Russia, and Ukraine. Rumsfeld’s talks with Aliyev ostensibly revolved around issues of defense or security cooperation between Baku and Washington, which may also include a potential base for U.S. forces down the road. But there is good reason to believe that pressure is also building upon Washington to launch an initiative to unblock the frozen status quo regarding Nagorno-Artsax. Washington may be the only capital that has the means to launch such an initiative and the credibility to see it through, but that is by no means a foregone conclusion. Neither is the success of any American initiative to be taken for granted because there are so many factors and actors who might act individually or conspire to frustrate any American initiative. CONCLUSIONS: All signs of growing U.S. involvement as a critical actor and security manager for the area indicate the depth of America’s interests, and involvement in the South Caucasus and the fact that this involvement could lead to further entanglements, if not causes for estrangement, with Tehran, Moscow and other capitals. Now that Washington has become a legitimate security manager for the South Caucasus, if not the premier foreign player there, it must reckon with all the dimensions of this region’s security dilemmas and agendas. Nobody should think that these can be anything other than long-term and protracted responsibilities. Rumsfeld’s visit, not the first he made to this area, will probably not be the last made by him or by future Secretaries of Defense and State. Washington is in the Caucasus to stay, but it is not clear whether it can do better than all those who have tried in the past to master the region and who would gladly try to supplant it today. AUTHOR’S BIO: Professor Stephen Blank, Strategic Studies Institute, US Army War College, Carlisle Barracks, PA 17013. The views expressed here do not represent those of the US Army, Defense Department, or the US Government.
  10. Dual Loyalties by Juan Cole ProgressiveTrail.org, OR Sept 10 2004 Many readers have written me to express concern about my safety and/or reputation since I have spoken out frankly on the horrible Likud policies of stealing Palestinian lands and brutalizing them with occupation. I'm not a babe in the woods, and I know very well that saying these things is taboo in American political culture. In fact, whenever anyone comes on a cable television news show and is anything but hostile to the Palestinians, he or she is made by the interviewer to denounce terrorism. It is an outrageous implication, and not the job of a news interviewer. But pro-Israeli speakers are never made to denounce land theft or state terror. I received a very weird phone call from a prominent Jewish-American investigative journalist the other night. He kept muttering about bias against Sharon and how the Israeli security wall is no different from the wall near the Rio Grande (which isn't true: did the US annex Mexican land to build that?) He kept hinting around that he thought I must have some link to some hate group, or to the Ford Foundation, which he coded as linked to "hate groups," which in turn seemed to signify for him Palestinians. It was all very conspiracy theorist oriented. I tried to have a straightforward conversation with him, but it was probably a mistake, since it seems fairly obvious he intends to do some sort of hatchet job. I finally had to end it when his paraphrases of what I said became more and more outrageous and inaccurate. Another journalist named Eli Lake has now begun coming after me, as many readers predicted, using innuendo to suggest that I am to the right of Pat Buchanan and that it is irresponsible of American media outlets to have me on television and radio. One of his charges is that I am accusing the Neoconservatives in the Pentagon of "dual loyalties." That is true, but not in the way Lake imagines. I believe that Doug Feith, for instance, has dual loyalties to the Israeli Likud Party and to the U.S. Republican Party. He thinks that their interests are completely congruent. And I also think that if he has to choose, he will put the interests of the Likud above the interests of the Republican Party. I don't think there is anything a priori wrong with Feith being so devoted to the Likud Party. That is his prerogative. But as an American, I don't want a person with those sentiments to serve as the number 3 man in the Pentagon. I frankly don't trust him to put America first. Political dual loyalties have nothing to do with any particular ethnicity. It is natural for Armenian Americans to have a special tie to Armenia, for Greek Americans to have a special tie to Greece, for Iraqi Americans to feel strongly about Iraq. For them to take pride in the achievements of their homeland is right an natural, and unexceptionable. There is no reason on the face of it to even bring up their ethnicity with regard to public service. But if a Syrian American is a strong devotee of the Baath Party, would you appoint him Undersecretary of Defense? The Likud Coalition in Israel does contest elections. But it isn't morally superior in most respects to the Syrian Baath. The Likud brutally occupies 3 million Palestinians (who don't get to vote for their occupier) and is aggressively taking over their land. That is, it treats at least 3 million people no better than and possibly worse than the Syrian Baath treats its 17 million. The Likud invaded Lebanon in 1982 and killed 18,000 or so people, 9,000 of them innocent civilians. This is, contrary to what Bernard Lewis keeps implying, just about equivalent morally to the Syrian Baath's crushing of the Islamists in Hama the same year, which killed an estimated 10,000. Many in the Likud coalition are commited to "transfer," or the ethnic cleansing of the Palestinians. At the least they want to keep Palestinians stateless and without basic human rights and dignity. The vast majority of Palestinians has never commited an act of violence, but Likud propaganda justifies their expropriation on the innuendo that they are all terrorists. Likud aggression is invisible in American media, and the way in which it provokes violence is off limits for discussion. So I don't see a big difference between having a fanatical Syrian American Baathist as the number three man in the Pentagon and having a fanatical Jewish American Likudnik. Lake wants to suggest that I am a racist, and that the implication of my argument is that there should be an ethnic litmus test for public office. There is no point in replying to such slurs. Anyone who tries to defend himself from charges of being a racist just looks silly. I simply think that we deserve to have American public servants who are centrally commited to the interests of the United States, rather than to the interests of a foreign political party. So my position implies a political litmus test for high public office. And, of course there is such a litmus test. Why bother to have Congress confirm or reject appointees otherwise? Of course, Lake's salvo is only the first of what will be a campaign to vilify me and misrepresent my views, and to ensure as far as possible that I am silenced. So, why do I do it? It is September 11. It is obvious to me that what September 11 really represented was a dragooning of the United States into internal Middle East political conflicts. Israel's aggressive policies in the West Bank and Gaza have poisoned the political atmosphere in the Middle East (and increasingly in the Muslim world) for the United States. It is ridiculous to suggest that radical Islamists don't care about the Palestine issue. Now, if it were a matter of Israel's simple existence causing trouble for the U.S., then I would say, "Too bad! We stand with our friends, and won't allow you to harm Israel." But if it is Israeli expansionism and aggression that is causing trouble for the United States, then my response would be to put pressure on Israel to get used to its 1949 borders, which are its only legal ones. Unless the Israeli Palestinian issue is resolved, there will be more September 11s on US soil. So they should resolve it already. And, it is resolvable. If there were a Palestinian state with leaders who would certify that they are happy with Israel, then 99% of Muslims would accept that. It can't be resolved as long as the Likud Party has an aggressive colonialist agenda. It cannot be resolved as long as the United States government is afraid to say "boo" to Ariel Sharon. The taboo erected against saying what I have been saying is a way of ensuring that the Likud gets its way without American interference, even if it means America suffers from the fall-out of Likud aggression. In addition, what the Likud government is doing is ethically wrong. It has put hundreds of thousands of colonists into the West Bank, stealing land, water and resources from the Palestinians there. It has made the Palestinians' lives miserable with a dense network of checkpoints, highways, and other barriers to ordinary commerce and movement. And what possible claim could the Likud have on the West Bank of the Jordan? The original Zionist colonizers put almost no settlers there. It was not the part of Palestine that the United Nations awarded Israel in the partition plan. The United Nations Charter, to which Israel is a signatory, forbids the acquisition of territory by warfare, so the mere fact that the West Bank was conquered in 1967 gives Israel no rights in it. Sharon and other Likudniks keep demanding that the Arabs "recognize" Israel's "birthright" to the Holy Land. This language is bizarre. First of all, "peoples" don't have "birthrights" to "land." There are no peoples in the 19th century racist sense, and there is no link between Land und Volk the way the Likud imagines. Israel should be recognized because its people deserve to live like everyone else, not because of any superstitious and frankly racist "birthright." (Population geneticists have shown that the entire human population becomes related over 50 generations, so Isaac and the other Patriarchs are by now the common ancestors of us all. If the birthright is genetic, then it is in everyone by now. If it is based on halakhah or Jewish law, well that didn't exist in Isaac's time. Abraham probably wasn't even really a monotheist in the contemporary sense of the term.) You can't break down taboos unless you challenge them. Of course, there is the danger that if you challenge them, you will be attacked, and destroyed politically or marginalized. Perhaps it is even likely. But our country is in dire danger from the conflicts in the Middle East. If I had been a younger man (I am 51) I would have gone to fight al-Qaeda in Afghanistan. The very least I can do is to speak out about the dangers, and urge solutions of the problems generating the terrorism. What good is freedom of speech if we don't use it?
  11. Brilliant solution Gamavor ! Actually, Ishkhan Zakarian has some Gypsy roots...(kiddin') Yes, and I am Armenian
  12. Shiner, it is already a week that you're approaching the same theme from different angles. Your question basically is: "Is being Armenian worth it?" or "What are some advantages and disadvantages of being an Armenian?".
  13. Well Poland pays more trubute than Armenia. And they began paying long ago. So they are already leutenants in this business. If we pay orderly we may receieve our rank in the nearest future.
  14. Armat, the whole world is on its knees paying trubute to the empire. Why should Armenia be different? I join Sasun's whishes!
  15. Sorry Stormy if I understood it wrong. But whose opinion is it? Can't quite get it...
  16. Shiner I was clearly being sarcastic in my mentioning of a terrorist act My point is that we should find something marektable on global scale to become renowned. Armenia cannot supply something on global scale at present. Moreover you need to be present in all aspects of business life to be constantly remembered. Like if you have only 1 sport star everyone will talk about your country only when that star is performing. They'll forget it the next day. However if you have a sport star, you pruduce a nice car (like Ferrary), you produce some exotic food (like sushi) or you supply prostitutes (like Natasha) they remember you.
  17. Shiner if Armenia had a great composer or writer nowadays none of your friends and associates would have heard of him anyway. Because people in general in present days do not care for such things anymore. It better to have a basketball player in NBA or to do something very bad on global scale (like a big terrorist act). In later's case you and your country would become famous (=marketable) in a metter of seconds because CNN makes money on that.
  18. So what is your BIG point here Shiner. That all this is outrageous? Or that something should be done?
  19. The Chechens' American friends The Washington neocons' commitment to the war on terror evaporates in Chechnya, whose cause they have made their own John Laughland Wednesday September 8, 2004 The Guardian An enormous head of steam has built up behind the view that President Putin is somehow the main culprit in the grisly events in North Ossetia. Soundbites and headlines such as "Grief turns to anger", "Harsh words for government", and "Criticism mounting against Putin" have abounded, while TV and radio correspondents in Beslan have been pressed on air to say that the people there blame Moscow as much as the terrorists. There have been numerous editorials encouraging us to understand - to quote the Sunday Times - the "underlying causes" of Chechen terrorism (usually Russian authoritarianism), while the widespread use of the word "rebels" to describe people who shoot children shows a surprising indulgence in the face of extreme brutality. On closer inspection, it turns out that this so-called "mounting criticism" is in fact being driven by a specific group in the Russian political spectrum - and by its American supporters. The leading Russian critics of Putin's handling of the Beslan crisis are the pro-US politicians Boris Nemtsov and Vladimir Ryzhkov - men associated with the extreme neoliberal market reforms which so devastated the Russian economy under the west's beloved Boris Yeltsin - and the Carnegie Endowment's Moscow Centre. Funded by its New York head office, this influential thinktank - which operates in tandem with the military-political Rand Corporation, for instance in producing policy papers on Russia's role in helping the US restructure the "Greater Middle East" - has been quoted repeatedly in recent days blaming Putin for the Chechen atrocities. The centre has also been assiduous over recent months in arguing against Moscow's claims that there is a link between the Chechens and al-Qaida. These people peddle essentially the same line as that expressed by Chechen leaders themselves, such as Ahmed Zakaev, the London exile who wrote in these pages yesterday. Other prominent figures who use the Chechen rebellion as a stick with which to beat Putin include Boris Berezovsky, the Russian oligarch who, like Zakaev, was granted political asylum in this country, although the Russian authorities want him on numerous charges. Moscow has often accused Berezovsky of funding Chechen rebels in the past. By the same token, the BBC and other media sources are putting it about that Russian TV played down the Beslan crisis, while only western channels reported live, the implication being that Putin's Russia remains a highly controlled police state. But this view of the Russian media is precisely the opposite of the impression I gained while watching both CNN and Russian TV over the past week: the Russian channels had far better information and images from Beslan than their western competitors. This harshness towards Putin is perhaps explained by the fact that, in the US, the leading group which pleads the Chechen cause is the American Committee for Peace in Chechnya (ACPC). The list of the self-styled "distinguished Americans" who are its members is a rollcall of the most prominent neoconservatives who so enthusastically support the "war on terror". They include Richard Perle, the notorious Pentagon adviser; Elliott Abrams of Iran-Contra fame; Kenneth Adelman, the former US ambassador to the UN who egged on the invasion of Iraq by predicting it would be "a cakewalk"; Midge Decter, biographer of Donald Rumsfeld and a director of the rightwing Heritage Foundation; Frank Gaffney of the militarist Centre for Security Policy; Bruce Jackson, former US military intelligence officer and one-time vice-president of Lockheed Martin, now president of the US Committee on Nato; Michael Ledeen of the American Enterprise Institute, a former admirer of Italian fascism and now a leading proponent of regime change in Iran; and R James Woolsey, the former CIA director who is one of the leading cheerleaders behind George Bush's plans to re-model the Muslim world along pro-US lines. The ACPC heavily promotes the idea that the Chechen rebellion shows the undemocratic nature of Putin's Russia, and cultivates support for the Chechen cause by emphasising the seriousness of human rights violations in the tiny Caucasian republic. It compares the Chechen crisis to those other fashionable "Muslim" causes, Bosnia and Kosovo - implying that only international intervention in the Caucasus can stabilise the situation there. In August, the ACPC welcomed the award of political asylum in the US, and a US-government funded grant, to Ilyas Akhmadov, foreign minister in the opposition Chechen government, and a man Moscow describes as a terrorist. Coming from both political parties, the ACPC members represent the backbone of the US foreign policy establishment, and their views are indeed those of the US administration. Although the White House issued a condemnation of the Beslan hostage-takers, its official view remains that the Chechen conflict must be solved politically. According to ACPC member Charles Fairbanks of Johns Hopkins University, US pressure will now increase on Moscow to achieve a political, rather than military, solution - in other words to negotiate with terrorists, a policy the US resolutely rejects elsewhere. Allegations are even being made in Russia that the west itself is somehow behind the Chechen rebellion, and that the purpose of such support is to weaken Russia, and to drive her out of the Caucasus. The fact that the Chechens are believed to use as a base the Pankisi gorge in neighbouring Georgia - a country which aspires to join Nato, has an extremely pro-American government, and where the US already has a significant military presence - only encourages such speculation. Putin himself even seemed to lend credence to the idea in his interview with foreign journalists on Monday. Proof of any such western involvement would be difficult to obtain, but is it any wonder Russians are asking themselves such questions when the same people in Washington who demand the deployment of overwhelming military force against the US's so-called terrorist enemies also insist that Russia capitulate to hers?
  20. The reason I side with Russian government in this situation is that I know exactly why did Bolsheviks prevent the collapse of the Russian empire in 1917 (that would actually create a healthy Russian and an independent Chechnia among others) and why they want its collapse at present.
  21. There is a more correct example of that: USA in Middle East for Israel and oil. However, you forget that Russians liberated Georgia (which Georgians now forget). You also forget that Osetians and Abkhazians are pro-Russian in this situation. Degestanies are not at all anti-Russian. Does this make it "only-Armenia" Stormy? Actually, I find very difficult to understand this position of yours. So if it was to chose among Armenians and Chechens, whome would you chose?
  22. Didn't know that. Considering this, we may as well state that Swiss watch prodution has been moved to Armenia.
  23. Well, don't the ones who play these games know exactly who's with whome agaist whome?
  24. OK Sasun, it's started to develop. Beslan events and our depolyment came about the same time... ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Eurasianet Organization Sept 5 2004 ARMENIAN MILITARY GEARS UP FOR IRAQ DEPLOYMENT Armen Zakarian and Emil Danielyan: 9/05/04 A EurasiaNet Partner Post from RFE/RL Armenia will send a team of military officials to Iraq in September that will prepare for the deployment of a small Armenian army contingent in the war-torn country by the end of the year, a senior official said September 3. Deputy Defense Minister Artur Aghabekian told RFE/RL that the delegation comprising commanders of the Armenian army's special peace-keeping battalion and U.S.-funded demining center will "take a close look at the location where our contingent will be stationed and ascertain on the spot the tasks which it will perform." "We expect that after the completion of all formalities the Armenian contingent will leave for Iraq at the end of the autumn or at the beginning of the winter to start carrying out its mission," he said, confirming that it will be made up of U.S.-trained sappers, doctors and a company of military truck drivers. The chief of the army staff, Colonel-General Mikael Harutiunian, said earlier that a total of about 50 Armenian servicemen will be sent to Iraq. Aghabekian revealed that the non-combat military personnel will be based in the central southern region of the country administered by a Polish-led multinational force. He said Defense Minister Serzh Sarkisian will pass a relevant official note to his Polish counterpart during President Robert Kocharian's visit to Warsaw which begins on Sunday. The Polish government, which has 2,500 troops on the ground, is facing strong domestic opposition to the military presence in Iraq and is gradually scaling it back. In August Polish troops handed over some of the zone they control to U.S. forces, including the restive province of Najaf. More such handovers are expected next year. Unlike NATO member Poland, Armenia did not back the U.S. invasion of Iraq last year. Nonetheless, it decided in principle to join the U.S.-led occupation force there shortly after the overthrow of Saddam Hussein's regime. Official Yerevan has said it is undaunted by continuing unrest in the embattled country where deadly bombings and hostage taking are a common occurrence. Over the past year Iraqi insurgents have kidnapped scores of foreign nationals in a bid to force their countries to withdraw troops from Iraq or stop other forms of cooperation with the Americans. At least 25 of them have already been killed by their captors. Among the victims are three Turkish truck drivers whose bodies were found on Thursday. Seven other truck drivers from India, Kenya and Egypt were set free recently after their Kuwaiti employers paid a $500,000 ransom to the hostage-takers. The planned Armenian deployment could also put at greater risk the lives of thousands of ethnic Armenians living in Iraq. Like other Iraqi Christians, they have been regarded as another potential target of the Islamist-led insurgency since August's wave of bomb attacks on churches in Baghdad and Mosul. An Armenian Catholic church in Baghdad was among five Christian worship sites hit by the coordinated bombings that left 11 people dead. The dispatch of the servicemen to Iraq will mark Armenia's second military mission abroad. Thirty-three Armenian soldiers and officers began the first such mission last February when they joined the NATO-led peace-keeping force in the breakaway Serbian province of Kosovo. Aghabekian said they will return home and be replaced by another platoon of the Armenian peace-keeping battalion in the coming days.
×
×
  • Create New...