Jump to content

Twilight Bark

Members
  • Posts

    1,010
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Twilight Bark

  1. quote:Originally posted by aurguplu: twilight bark, they can't do it long enough to make it look ancient and irrelevant, because turkey wants to get into the eu to complete its integration with the west. since the recognition of the genocide is a prerequisite for that, they are going to recognise it if they want to get into the eu. otherwise, goodbye eu. It is the societal evolution that would lead to the recognition that is the prerequisite, and not the recognition per se. If one can magically make that evolution happen without the consequent recognition of the genocide, Turkey could still enter EU. What EU is afraid of is a populous and unreformed, unenlightened Turkey entering the EU, and having a big say in what goes on. Not to mention the lack of economic development that results from the absence of such an evolution. And if I put on my detached observer hat now, I sincerely want Turkey to achieve that societal evolution and enter the EU, independent of any other issue. This is on a purely humanitarian basis. Finally, I think a true "recognition" would involve a lot more than a sterile apology. One cannot absolve oneself from commiting genocide by simply saying "Yeah, I did it. Sorry.". Insistence on a simple apology and maybe "token reparations" would indicate that the desired intellectal and moral maturity has not been achieved yet.
  2. quote:Originally posted by aurguplu: 2. it is not true that there is not a shred of evidence that the armenians and other indo-europeans came from europe into anatolia: i) since the languages are indo-european, and so by definition originating in eastern europe-southern russia (if the current theories are correct and gamkrelidze and ivanov wrong) they must have come into anatolia from there! the question is whether they came through the caucasus (not europe) or across the bosporus/dardanelles (europe). now the hittites are thought to have taken the eastern route, and there is some archaeological evidence (sword types, etc.) supporting an intrusion of a warlike caste into anatolia about 2000 bc. the armenians, on the other hand, are very likely to have been the offspring of the "sea peoples" which had included, amongst others, the phrygians. now the problem of course is the very divergent nature of the armenian language (especially phonetics and phonology), which makes a precise location within indo-european difficult. it was once thought to be a satem language, but then the centum-satem division was seen to be of little significance, some parallels with greek were found, and also with the thracian tongues. to the best of my understanding these point to an eastern-european origin. also, the phrygians were called muski by the hittites, and there are two regions, one in turkey (mysia) and one in northern greece (moesia) bearing the same name. the word phrygian comes from bryg, which meant brigand (and yes, you have guessed correctly, the two words are cognate). i understand the georgians call the armenians sa-mekhi (or was it sa-mkhetti?), and linguists see a remnant of muski in this. so it is quite possible after all, that the armenians might have come from eastern europe. the language definitely has, and you need people to speak it for a language to have come from somewhere. Dear Ali, I am aware of the "evidence" you are describing. Using the indo-europeanness of Armenian to conclude that its speakers must have come from Europe is circular; the indo-european speakers of Europe may have equally probably come from somewhere outside Europe. There is no doubt that all of the newcomers, including the Phrygians eventually melted into the Armenians, as well as the "greeks" to varying degrees. The question is, does the arrival of the Phrygians or their cousins signal the arrival of the Armenians or just another component in their mosaic, and the genesis of the Armenian nation as a coherent entity predates that event. There is good evidence that a coherently defined "Hay" nation existed before the arrival of the Thracian tribes. As for the names, what other groups named or misnamed Armenians is secondary to what they called themselves. Surely, you don't think that Turks are Tajiks, do you? I will not comment on the other names (of which I knew about, but never attached much significance) you mentioned, other than the possibility that they represent later additions to the Armenian mosaic. It probably goes like this: A group migrates in, settles at the periphery of the Armenian-populated region, the neighboring groups come into contact with the new group, the new group gradually assimilates into the Armenian identity but the neighboring groups keep calling them with their original name. When they meet the rest of their "compatriots" (who are now the larger umbrella of Armenians), they will naturally refer to the whole thing by the name of the tribe they have dealt with before. As for the Hittites and Luwians, connecting this or that site, or the path of an unknown warlike incursion with them is completely arbitrary. There is simply not enough information to make these linkages. It may make a good story, but it is just that: a good story. Regards, Twilight Bark P.S. Thank you for the well-informed and thoughtful discussion you are offering. [ November 16, 2001: Message edited by: Twilight Bark ]
  3. quote:Originally posted by aurguplu: i thought i had stated earlier that 1) the action of garabed doesn't justify the murder of varjabed, and that 2) the secret clique within the young turk organisation had the idea of getting rid of the armenians altogether, so if there weren't a cause, they were probably going to create one. I appreciate your enlightened views on the subject. And I wish to iron out some of the details in which the devil lies. now some literature on the subject, not all written or sponsored by turks or pro-turks says that the armenian revolutionaries knew in advance that the young turks wanted to get rid of the armenians (it probably didn't take prophetic skill to realise that at the time) and attempted to use it in their fight for independence. their blueprint for this was what had transpired in the balkans, especially greece: the greeks had started to stage revolts (helped by the europeans) and massacred muslims, the turks massacred them in retaliation, and european public opinion, which was ignorant of the muslim massacres, was infuriated at the sight of poor greeks massacred by the barbarian turks. this gave the western states the public support they needed to come up with a moral cause to wage war against the ottoman empire, the ultimate aim of which was to "throw the turks bag and baggage out of europe (gladstone)" and get hold of the oil-rich arab provinces and the holy land. the europeans did genuinely care about the greeks to a certain extent by dint of classical antiquity, but that was not the main source of motivation. it was material gain. nevertheless, it did give the greeks enough support to freethemselves of turkish yoke, and gave a precedent to all other christian subjects of the empire. . . . the process of the dismantling of the ottoman empire was well underway when armenian revolutionary activity had started. the armenian revolutionaries thought, quite logically in fact, that if they had succeeded in provoking turks to retaliatory measures by instigating armenian rebellions, the west would step in to stop the bloodshed and they would get their freedom just as the greeks and balkan slavs did. Yes, it is common knowledge that the Armenian "revolutionaries" imagined that they could use the same strategy. However, both their numbers and the extent of their actions were pathetic compared with the carnage that the Balkan revolutions involved. Again, to expect that no one among a horribly oppressed minority would resort to such things would be disingenuously naive. So, the question is not whether there were any Armenians aspiring for independence and freedom. The question is whether their actions, or their mere potential for action posed any actual threat to the Ottoman Empire. The answer is no. They were outmanned and outgunned by a big margin even with the Ottoman Empire at its weakest. they rebelled, and attcaked the empire from behind at its weakest hour, and the "retaliation" they got in return was far more severe than what all other christian subjects who had previously rebelled got because 1) it was wartime, and the ottomans were fully aware that they were on their death throes, and 2) by then, pretty much the whole of the empire save anatolia was gone: if they lost that too, not only the empire, but the nation with it, would go extinct. so they resorted to the ultimate atrocity of getting rid of the armenians altogether. and the west just watched by. Here the the spin of the argument is indistinguishable from an apologist one. The few eastern provinces where Armenians could conceivably mount a credible rebellion were by no means necessary for the Turkish nation's survival. Think about it, is Eastern Anatolia an important part of the Turkish economy? No. Does it have any vital supply routes for Turkey? No. The Turkish nation would survive just fine without resorting to genocide. The Young Turk government was smart enough to know what was actually vital for a viable nation. Their motivation was not national survival. An independent Armenia might have taken a bite out of Eastern Anatolia, but nothing remotely close to "if Anatolia went too ...". the process was aided by the pan-turkic ideals of the young turks, but one must ask the question how much it would differ if they weren't pan-turkic: everyone realised that not only the empire, but the very existence of the turkish nation was at stake (with the non-turkish provinces gone, and all balkan muslims heading for anatolia, it was pretty obvious that the ottoman identity as such was a thing of the past). i doubt a non-panturkist government would have handled the issue all that differently, for pan- dreams aside, it was a visible fact that the empire was collapsing along first religious, and then ethnic lines. so even if the young turks did have pan-turkist dreams, one should probably set not that much store to them: pan or not, it was clear that the new state to emerge out of the ashes of the ottoman empire was going to have to be ethnically homogenous to be able to survive as a viable entity. Ah. Here lies one of the prime reasons for the liquidation of Armenians. They were an inconvenient group separating Turkey from Azerbaijan and Central Asia. We know how they solved this "inconvenience". Pan-Turkism had a central role in it. we have to examine the issue in cold blood if we are going to understand the whys and hows of it, for the planners had done so. Indeed.
  4. quote:Originally posted by aurguplu: bilge umar is a law professor from izmir, and although a gifted and informed amateur, to the best of my knowledge he is not a professional historian or archaeologist. i gather he speaks greek and latin, but as for his competence in the other languages of ancient anatolia, i don't know. so i would be careful when using him as a source on ancient anatolian history. Precisely. And that is why he is free to be more objective about it, or at least to explore away from the dogmas of the "profession". I know academia well enough. Many times, it is professional suicide to diverge from the "fundamental" assumptions (e.g. indo-european came from Europe. It is pure conjecture, just like any other hypothesis. There is nothing self-evident about it; the homeland is simply not known; period). So, I do not regard an informed "amateur" as "below" the "professionals" when it comes to history and linguistics. For example, in linguistics, things sometimes get so out of hand that people stop seeing obvious connections because they do not conform to some self-perpetuating, self-accentuating "rules".
  5. quote:Originally posted by Harut: no more stories for us?? Dear Harut, I'll try to fabricate one. Give me some time.
  6. quote:Originally posted by aurguplu: as for the armenians, the language certainly is indo-european, and probably belongs to a dialect cluster that might have included phrygian and the ancient thracian tongues, including probably that of alexander of macedon. there are also curious connections with greek. but the phonology of the language changed out of all recognition when it came in contact with the caucasian languages. since i don't know armenian, i cannot say anything about the extent of the influence of urartu or other caucasian languages on it, but it must be significant. so the ultimate european origins of the armenians appear to be a historical fact. of course, all this would have to be rewritten if the recent theory by gamkrelidze and ivanov regarding the origin of indo-european is correct: they place it in the caucasus, and maintain that all indo-european languages spread from there, as did farming. from a purely linguistic point of view this theory poses more problems than it solves. but it is a very interesting argument. if you know more about it i would be glad to hear. All I can say is that there is not a shred of evidence that the people forming the nucleus of the Armenian nation came from Europe. I am not really saying that they didn't; just that there is no evidence to that effect. On the contrary, the statelet where it all started (i.e. Hayasa) existed before the arrival of Phrygians. The indo-europeans were certainly in Anatolia before that time. As for the "arrival" of the "indo-europeans" (Hittites and Luwians), again there is really no evidence that they came from Europe. The archaeological "evidence" is non-existent, other than the wishful thinking reflecting the biases of individual historians/archaeologists. I admit that this is not concrete evidence, but Bilge Umar's explanations for place names in Anatolia involves Luwian (rather than Hurrian) most of the time. One would expect the place names to reflect the "native" culture much more extensively. So, in the absence of concrete evidence to the contrary it is more rational to reject fictional migration hypotheses.
  7. quote:Originally posted by aurguplu: dear twilight bark, the karaman bey you are referring to was karamanoğlu mehmet bey, who issued that order in 1277. to the best of my knowledge that order was issued not to assimilate greeks or armenians, but to stop turks themselves using persian (turks had a very unnerving habit of switching to persian for administration, and arabic for religious purposes). if you can find any reference to the scope of this ban, and the allegation that the penalty for speaking tongues other than turkish was cutting off the tongue, i would be glad. if it were an effort at cultural assimilation, then why did they allow the christians remain christian? after all, these days it was religion and not ethnicity that affected one's allegiance. As I said, it was a foggy recollection, and I don't have resources at hand. However, a web search came up with one secondary source (http://www.alevibektasi.com/ali_aktas.htm) that goes one sentence further than the usual, truncated "Bundan sonra; devlet dairelerinde, evlerde, sokaklarda Türkçe’den başka bir dil kullanılmayacaktır.", and adds "Aksi hareket edenler idam olunacaktır". Translated it says: "From now on, in state offices, in households, on the streets, no language other than Turkish shall be used. Those who do not comply will be executed." This isn't quite the same as cutting of the tongue, but would usually be regarded as harsher I suppose. Depends on whether you prefer living without a tongue over death Anyway, I didn't bring it up to "allege" anything or "embarass"; I just remembered something about that and was curious. As for its purpose, I think it's pretty obvious that the aim of the ferman was to hasten the assimilation of the population into a Turkish identity. Granted, it was unusual for the times. As you point out, religion was regarded as the most important factor defining identity. But not for the Karamanoglu Mehmet Bey apparently. [ November 15, 2001: Message edited by: Twilight Bark ]
  8. quote:Originally posted by aurguplu: "For instance, the most ancient Greek historians speak of striking similarities between the inhabitants of Cappadocia, Phrygia, and Armenia, in their language and customs, so much so that the Armenians and Phrygians were sometimes said to be the same people. So the Armenians were spoken of by some ancient writers as a colony of the Phrygians; and the Cappadocians as a colony of the Armenians. The different languages of the three, on account of their striking resemblance, have been called different dialects of a common language." we (the cappadocians) spoke dialects of hittite and luwian, both of which are very close to one another. the languages of lycia, lydia, and adanawa (present-day adana) were also very close. phrygian was spoken further north, and was written as a liturgical dead language until the third century a.d. you find phrygian tomb inscriptions in many places in central anatolia but not to the best of my knowledge in cappadocia (cappadocia is a very clearly defined area, and quite easily defended thanks to the fairy chimneys). Dear Ali Suat, I agree with you about the survival of Anatolian languages in pockets of Anatolia. As for the "greeks" (almost all "greeks" of Anatolia need to be put in quotation marks, as you would agree) of Karaman, was it the "bey" of Karaman that ordered the non-Turkish speaking population to switch to Turkish or else (I think the penalty was cutting of the tongue, although I am not sure)? I honestly don't remember. I think there used to be a "Day of Language" in Turkey that celebrated the day the order was issued. Is it still celebrated? As for the Armenian-Phrygian connection, I have never seen any evidence other than the all-too-often unreliable Greek historians. After all, they also claimed that Phrygian was the oldest language in the world; a laughable claim. The Hittite client kingdom of Hayasa existed before the arrival of the Phrygians, and the Armenian historical tradition (oral or otherwise) has no traces or implications tying Armenians with the Phrygians. The Phrygian/Balkan connection hypothesis was picked and lovingly parroted by Armenian "historians" who were very eager to associate Armenians with European origins. The whole "connection" is rather baseless. [ November 14, 2001: Message edited by: Twilight Bark ]
  9. quote:Originally posted by hagarag: we Armenians must stop talking out of two sides of our mouths, glorifying the revolutionaries, yet discounting their part in the terror that befell us. Eventually an Armenian nation would have formed, irregardless. We were more advaced than the Kurds and had a better geo-political deck dealt to us. The revolutionaries timing was very poor. They were very naive. The "revolutionaries" simply reacted to the endless oppression, at a time when the empire was becoming both weaker and more brutal simultaneously. It is against human nature to have a total of zero people saying "I am not taking this anymore!" out of a population of 2.1 million Armenians. Were these hotheads naive? Yes. Did they underestimate the depth of apathy and passivism (probably justified, but we will never really know) among Armenians? Absolutely. Could we expect that no one among an oppressed people would act the way they did, however foolish it may have been? Absolutely not. Now, that would be naive. The few Armenians who couldn't take it anymore were used as a (very) thin cover for a premeditated slaughter whose cause had nothing to do with any threat that the "revolutionaries" may have posed.
  10. quote:Originally posted by aurguplu: everybody knows the armenians were killed. no turkish official, loose-lipped or otherwise, can make people unlearn what they know. they are merely trying to buy time. they can't do it forever. you can fool all people for some time, you can fool some people all the time, but you can't fool all the people all the time. cheers, They don't need to do it forever. Just long enough to make the whole matter "ancient" enough to look irrelevant. And they don't need to fool everybody all of the time either. They just need to fool their own population. Complicity of the "intelligentsia" is not that hard to accomplish, since their superficial interests coincide. They don't need to fool anyone outside, but merely intimidate their allies into silence. And Turkey has been brilliant at all counts. Those among Armenians who like to believe that Turks are stupid, ignorant simpletons are only enjoying the bliss of ignorance themselves. On a more positive note, I am absolutely sure that the whole anatolia-caucasus region would become an exceptionally successful economic and intellectual powerhouse once its debilitating diseases inherited from the past have been cured. The human capital in the region is among the best in the world.
  11. quote:Originally posted by aurguplu: as for the "deformation" of kamurj to karmuj, it is called "metathesis" in linguistics: this is the phenomenon of medial (in the middle of the word) consonants changing places and is very common in many languages. for instance, the turkish word for "earth" is "toprak", but in azeri and eastern anatolian it becomes "torpah". The "metathesis" in Turkish is more likely to occur among "native speakers" when those speakers are almost entirely assimilated natives. And of course, the formation of the Turkish nation involved a lot of assimilation, so the local deformations are not surprising. In their origins, Armenians are also a mixed a bag. However, lacking true political power for almost their entire existence, there was not a great level of enthusiasm by other ethnic groups to assimilate into Armenians, especially in the last couple of millenia. So I am still somewhat skeptical of such "mispronunciations" explaining away Armenian words. Of course, the divergent pronunciation may date from the beginnings of the amalgamation of the Armenian nation.
  12. quote:Originally posted by hagarag: Ali, The Armenians were not "lambs" even to those among the Armenians they did not agree with. Some great Armenian patriots were falsely accused by other Armenian factions of being Benedict Arnolds. Feeding multitudes of the poor, Armenian, Turk and Kurd alike at no cost to them and paying the oppressive taxes of thousands of Armenians is disregarded. As I have said before, there can be no peace between our peoples until there is TOTAL truth on both sides. The programing must be reversed and the propaganda must cease. So what would be the percentage of Armenians who were wolves to Armenians and/or Turks alike? Please give an estimate. Any estimate, reflecting your intuition on the matter.
  13. quote:Originally posted by aurguplu: dear tb, o.k. i know, and have said before, that 1) the rebellious armenians did not cosntitute the majority, 2) you do not kill innocent armenian civilians because some armenian rebelled and killed turks. you go and nail that armenian and that one alone. 3) the young turks appear to have had the idea of getting rid of the armenians anyway, so the armenian rebellions only served as a pretext. so much i hope we agree in. now the rebellions: a letter by boghos noubar *****, the armenian representative at the paris? conference after ww1, which has been posted somewhere in this forum several times (once by me) states that armenians had joined the enemies of the ottomans in quite substantial numbers (way more than a few thousand) since the beginning of the war. there is also abundant literature, by the armenians and non-armenians alike, on the terrorist activities of armenian factions from the last decades of the 19th century. although it is probably true that the absolute majority had sided with the ottomans, it is equally true that a numerically significant minority had sided with the russians and the french (the boghos noubar letter gives a figure of at least 40,000 if i remember correctly. by the way, it was timuçin who posted it, then i re-copied it from there and posted it somewhere else, went back to look for it to post it here, it isn't there. can anyone tell me where it is, please?) so while turks have to learn to live with the fact that what transpired was a genocide, the armenians also have to learn to live with the fact that they were "not little lambs", as one british statesman of the period had put it. we both have to revise our perceptions of the past. cheers, Dear Ali, I know that you have accomplished a lot in the way of freeing yourself from most of the silly state indoctrination. And I assure you that I have a reasonably objective view of Armenians and Turks. So I know that not every Armenian was a "lamb". But an incredibly high percentage of them were exactly that. Clueless peasants who couldn't figure out what hit them until it was too late. Saying "majority of Armenians were not rebels" is quite misleading, although it may not have been intended to be consciously. Even in full mobilization of a community, the "majority" (i.e. greater than 50%) of the members would not be "rebels" or "soldiers". So acknowledging that "yeah, the majority of them were not rebels" is an information-free statement. The point is, the number of Ottoman Armenians who took up arms (or even were theoretically likely to) were absolutely tiny. Of the able-bodied Armenian men, probably not more than a few percent were involved in any activity that could be construed as "hostile". And where rebellion and resistance occurred, it was usually the result of too much oppression. Any other ethnic group would have rebelled in full force long before. Now "objectivity" does not demand that we ignore the facts so we look reasonable to less-informed outsiders. It was an unreasonable time, and the facts and behaviors of that time look absurd today. But that is how it was. Not all Armenians were lambs waiting to be slaugtered. But a vast, vast majority of them were exactly that. Let's get that straight and out in the open. It would be good education for Armenian chauvinists who like to fantasize that Armenians mounted a credible resistance like any "reasonable" group would. I am not necessarily saying that mounting a resistance would do any good, but they didn't in the vast majority of cases. Cheers and regards, TB
  14. quote:Originally posted by Arpa: The same way akanj has become ankaj, aryoudz turns to ayroudz and karvan (caravan) has in Turkish become kevran. Or have you heard of kapert v karpet to mean carpet? How about Kharberd into Harput sand Sebastia into Sivas? Or even Kesaria to Kayseri, not to mention Constantinopolis to Istanbul. Although your suggestion is reasonable, one also has to be careful about using such deformations because they occur almost always as a result of mispronunciation by non-native speakers (i.e. typically the invaders of the place). So deforming an Armenian word by Armenians would be suspect. However, if garmuj was the name used by the Turks or the Turkish authorities, and it stuck after a while and begun to be used by Armenians as well, that would not violate the "native speakers don't deform" principle (not that it is set in stone).
  15. quote:Originally posted by hagarag: TB, I am sure that if I met you, or even MJ, face to face that we could come to an understanding. We may even develop a comraderie of sorts. I wonder if the reason you folks question my motivations or history is because it is so divergent from your own. Without the influences of the Armenian Church or the community one develops different perceptions, despite the parental influences. Yes, I agree with what you said, including the end. However, I have not been "influenced" by the church or the "community". The church's role in my family's life has always been laughably small. As for "community", I have not been immersed in the "community" for quite some time, although I would like it if I had the chance. I am as far away from being a "ghetto dweller" as one can possibly get. My affection for things Armenian has nothing to do with pride, jingoism, or hostility to "others". I view Armenians as my extended family, and define my emotional attachment in the same way. I have no interest in belonging to a synthetic "nation" based on ideology or indoctrination. Oh, one more thing: I have a total lack of interest in any Republican-Democrat rivalries, or Armenian political rivalries for that matter. This should help you in placing me in your cultural landscape.
  16. Twilight Bark

    Paulicians

    quote:Originally posted by Arpa:
  17. quote:Originally posted by Harut: zankhul is supposed to be an Armenian word? then what would the verb be for it? zankhel? I know. It's an obscure word. But it's there; in the dictionary. Maybe an enterprising Armenian discovered the coal deposits, and used a doubly obscure name to refer to it so that the deposits remain "hidden" until he established a mining business. Or maybe zankhul used to be a more commonly used word. I wonder ...
  18. Twilight Bark

    Paulicians

    quote:Originally posted by MJ: P.S. Isn’t it interesting that the two examples brought in above regarding the “ldzord kirer” are “Bavghikian” and “Yerusaghem?” Could you give some other examples? I am curious. Can I pitch in? Gallia <--> Kaghia The tendency to turn "ll" to "gh" apparently goes back to the times when the Armenian language diverged from other indo-europen languages. The word "kaghak" (city) probably comes from the word for wall (the first towns were surrounded with a wall, and the wall really was the point of the town), as the w<-->k transformation is well known.
  19. Zankhul-dag Zankhul = hidden dag = under
  20. quote:Originally posted by hagarag: The point that I was making was about the extreme xenophobia of the leaders of the Young Turks. This was so extreme that they would exterminate ALL Armenians even those with whom they were dealing day to day in affairs of the state. Dear hagarag, There was no "phobia" involved on the part of the executioners, xeno- or otherwise. They were not afraid of Armenians. Armenians were unassimilable into the planned homogenous Turkish nation they wanted to synthesize, and had to be eliminated. As simple as that. There was no amount of loyalty (however undeserved) that could save an Armenian. This is the reason, by the way, why Armenian and Jewish genocides are entirely comparable, and of similar nature. Propagandists use a lot of positive-sounding "fluff" to deliver the "real" message buried among the "oh-so-true" statements. That is why I zero in on those "real" messages, and disregard the rest, as they are either really irrelevant for the propagandist or small "sacrifices" in the broader chess game being played. So, I urge you to read between the lines a bit more vigorously before swallowing a whole paragraph or two hook, line and sinkers. As for your personal history or motivations. I sincerely want to believe that you have a pure heart, and are an honest person. That will be my starting point from now on, and I hope that you will do the same favor to me. Regards, Twilight Bark
  21. quote:Originally posted by hagarag: TB, It is your utter vilification of A/B, without reference to any of his positive influences, which has induced me to pigeonhole you. I really don't know what your behavior is induced by. Pigeonhole and stereotype all you want; facts are immune to that sort of thing. Instead of going ballistic over my seeing through Baliozian's pathetic facade, please analyze (i.e. don't just state as a dictum) where I was inaccurate when I criticized his writings in a specific case. I said several times that most of what he writes is accurate enough; it's the silly untruths he regularly slips in intentionally that appalls me. When he does that he denigrates the truisms in his writings to the level of camouflage for advancing his personal vendetta against his equally silly adversaries within the Armenian "establishment" (of which I am definitely not a part, nor do I want to be). Read a little bit, and you'll realize that he often equates the whole Armenian nation with lowest forms of life, and refuses to see any positive qualities in Armenian character. If you view yourself as a Baliozian groupie, and refuse to contemplate that he is awfully wrong too often, please state it clearly; so I won't have to reply to you again. In any case, why are we talking about him again?
  22. quote:Originally posted by hagarag: TB, You mischaracterize my comments as usual. I understand that very few Armenians were involved in "revolutionary" activity. The point that I was making was about the extreme xenophobia of the leaders of the Young Turks. This was so extreme that they would exterminate ALL Armenians even those with whom they were dealing day to day in affairs of the state. As for the equitable settlement of Armenian claims, this is not a view that is not shared by most Armenians and is agreed to by a limited number of present-day Turkish officials. I am very familiar with your kind TB. You will sell a fellow Armenian down the river if their political or religious philosophies do not coincide with your own. You will plot with your fellow ideologues to bring down a fellow Armenian. Your ideology is more important than your Armenianess. For example the slavish way the AAA buckles under to every Bush command. Rove says "jump" and Hovnanian replies "how high." FYI, I know the Hovnanians very well and respect them for their success and their good deeds. I just feel that they are so blinded by their loyalty to Bush and Rove that they can not see the forest through the trees. Hagarag, Please do not go down that path. If you think I mischaracterized you comments, use the tools of logic and clear language to rebut my impression. The impression given by your earlier statements stands, whether there is factual basis for it or not. As for my "kind", apparently you know absolutely nothing about "my kind", so why not just give up? I try to analyze statements made by other as logically as possible. What is said may not reflect what was intended, but being a psychic is not one of my specialties; I go with what is actually uttered. If you try to understand me by pigeonholing me into a category that you are familiar with, it will be a futile activity. Let's stay as cordial and logical as we are capable of. TB
  23. quote:Originally posted by aurguplu: the armenians had rebelled, and the rebellion was most brutally put down; and then, seen as a threat to the existence of the state, they were all but annihilated. though barbaric and atrocious, it does not really compare to the holocaust Dear Ali, As reasonable and enlightened you may be in many respects, you are utterly wrong in this characterization. The Armenian "revolutionaries" were few in number, and had never amounted to any real threat. The sporadic "noises" from the provinces were the result of the appalling treatment Armenians endured despite their surreal degree of passivism. The vast majority of Ottoman Armenians were apolitical. Of all the ethnic groups that had the "potential" to rebel, Armenians were probably the most pathetic one, and the ruling party certainly was wily enough to know it. In fact, that knowledge gave them the audacity to carry out the "deed". Best Regards, Twilight Bark [ November 13, 2001: Message edited by: Twilight Bark ]
  24. quote:Originally posted by hagarag: It is the families of those Armenians falsely accused by Armenians of being traitors to the Armenian cause by working closely with the Ottomans who feel that there was absolutely no justifcation for their executions and the confiscation of their properties. It has been documented that a high Ottoman official in prison for war crimes personally agreed that my family members were never involved in any revolutionary activity, that they were executed solely because they refused to renounce their religion. A fair and equitable resolution of the events of that general era should include that which was foisted upon the Balkan Turks. Hagarag, You seem to imply that your family was exceptional in its non-involvement in "revolutionary" activities. The vast majority of Ottoman Armenians of that era fall into that category. Although I really do not want to think it, you seem to say "My family have served the Empire so well, and so much more than other Armenians. Oh, please, give me back my inheritance. I could use the money" at the expense of implied mischaracterization of the utterly apolitical nature of most Armenians in the Ottoman Empire when the Genocide took place.
  25. quote:Originally posted by Kazza: Your'e right. It's like Freddie Mercury-I saw on another forum that he was an azeri! I thought it was only rumour or wishful thinking at first, then I was looking at his bio on the TV. At his funeral it only showed his family breifly, and they were in traditional Azeri dress. I thought he was a Parsi from India, and that his family had emigrated to another British colony in Africa before ending up in Britain. I am interested in knowing the real story. Twilight Bark P.S. Sorry for continuing the off-topic sidetrack
×
×
  • Create New...