Jump to content

bellthecat

Banned
  • Posts

    1,641
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by bellthecat

  1. PS, don't worry Filiz - I didn't dig too deeply into the "embarrassing stuff" (and I'm sure you are a fine bunch of grapes, be you unreachable or not ) Steve
  2. Thank's Thorny There is a copy of Nogales's book in a library near to me - I'll try and photocopy some of it sometime and then "ocr" it. I have not read all of the book, the Van section is interesting, but the earlier chapter, dealing with Adilcevas, Acht'amar, and his journey across lake Van is genuinely horrifying. I think he says that Enver ***** was trying to have him assasinated because of what he had seen (which included telegraph messages ordering the massacres) - but that might just be a boast, (or a way of avoiding an Armenian assasin - like I said, his involvement is a little bit ambiguous for comfort). Steve
  3. bellthecat

    Coffee

    Coffee: "Although they be destitute of Taverns, yet they have their coffa-houses, which something resemble them. There sit they chatting most of the day, and sippe of a drink called coffa, in little china dishes, as hot as they can suffer it, black as soot and tasting not much unlike it" from "A description of Constantinople in 1610" by George Sandys.
  4. If I had a book to hand giving the figures, why would I be asking here I agree about McCarthy and his figures - they should not be taked at face value (and, yes, Armenian sources should also not be automaticaly trusted). However, I think a big (and fairly modern by early 20th century standards) place like Kayseri would have accurate population statistics somewhere. Steve
  5. Thank's Taguhi, that was really helpful, I can tidy up the English. The bit about the explosions is all true - when one went off, I was inside the Tigran Honentz church, and I ran out of the building because it started to shake, with dust falling from the ceiling. Steve
  6. bellthecat

    Coffee

    quote:Originally posted by Kazza: Hi people- I'm back. AND did you miss me? Well anyway, I'd like to ask you a question about Turkish coffee. or is it greek, or armenian cofee? This is the thing, SO many people like to argue to call it different things, or as I call it- just middle eastern coffee. What I'd call it is probably on the list of banned words - it is horrible stuff. But, yes I did miss you! Steve
  7. Dear Filiz I was reading one of your postings on the Middle East Forum http://network54.com/Hide/Forum/message?fo...ageid=988952656 In particular the following paragraph: "In addition to that, I also read a biography on a Venezuelan soldier who served in the Ottoman army during WWI. The author of this biography relates in one part how this Venezuelan-Ottoman army officer was disturbed by “what he thought was massacres of the Christian population” (this is the way the author puts it; this means that the author, while compiling his work, came across this in one of the autobiographies of our Venezuelan and, instead of ignoring it, interpreted it himself, trying to downplay the story related – as if it could have been anything other than massacre)." I have read the original book, it is called "4 years beneath the Crescent" by Rafael de Nogales. Is the "biography" you mentioned a Turkish book? I'd be interested in knowing more about its contents, and how they can explain away the clearly witnessed massacres that Nogales describes. The Nogales book is important because it is one of the few sources that describe events as they happened from the Turkish side, (although he is always careful to make out that he did not participate in any actual killing of Armenian civilians, and could do nothing to stop such killing - I think the former may be true, the latter is probably not). Steve PS, I want to say how intelligent and clearly expressed I am finding your writing to be. Your English is amazingly good, (and I don't just mean grammar - I recognised the reference to Aesops "fox and the grapes"!)
  8. quote:Originally posted by Tornado: dear steve I know that Aersakh is karabagh, and I can immagine that there live kurds and Azeri's, may be assyrian too. but I think it's impossible to find Turks there. Well, there are probably none there now! Actually, when I said Turks, I was thinking of Azeris, as in Azeri Turks, but I think that you are correct in saying that most of the non-Armenians in Artsakh / NK were actually Kurds (although I believe most spoke Azeri Turkish). Steve
  9. quote:Originally posted by Garo: Steve I don't remember the exact names of the villages now. I'll just name 2 of them - Grecira and Jagarlu. I'm not sure about the spelling though. As far as I know Grecira is still a village and you can find it on the map but Jagarlu now is a part of Batman. The name of the person who got killed is Geurie Shmoni (not sure about the correct spelling). He was from Gamishli, Syria. [ May 27, 2001: Message edited by: Garo ] Thanks Garo. When did it happen? If he was, say, a Jew trying to reclain property in Poland, and was killed as a result of it, you can be sure the whole world would have known of it. This would be partly because people know about the history behind such an incident, but partly also because you can be certain detailed and accurate facts about the incident would be available to everyone. Steve
  10. quote:Originally posted by circassian: Some other MHP supporters disagree with those who say armenians have no chance of return & reparation. Do they? For reparation, there has to have been something to be "repaired" and something that "broke" it - i.e: the genocide, and I don't really see the MHP admitting that happened! Although paying damages to individual Armenians in theory does not need to have political ramifications like genocide recognition, in practice it probably will. But it was just the right of Armenians in Turkey to expect to live normally that I was referring to - not to have bombs thrown in churches, graveyards vandalised, community property confiscated, receive violent threats by phone just because their name ends in "ian", etc. MHP politicians and others may not be openly hostile and encourage such actions - but they do not need to be, they have supporters to do the dirty work. And it seems that Paul Bunyan ia arguing for the same treatment to be inflicted on Turks or Kurds in Artsakh! Steve Oh - thanks for the kind words, Tornado.
  11. You are a chauvanistic thug. If fascists like you ever get to positions of power, Artsak will not survive the decade. (Remember, people like you did get to be in positions of power in Armenia in 1919 - and began to kick out or oppress non-Armenians - and thus gave Kemalist Turkey the excuse to invade and annex Kars and Igdir). Any study of the history of Artsakh will show that it has had a substantial non-Armenian population for centuries. It is unimportant how they got that land, when considering their modern descendents legal rights. All the international bodies demand that the return of displaced persons should be the end result of a permanent NK peace treaty. You have no right to block any such return, or force their permanent removal. You remind me of some MHP fascist saying that Armenians can have no place in Turkey - same words, same black heart. Steve
  12. PS; I meant to add that these villages are all to the south-east of Sivas. If Tuzhisar is amongst them, then you might be interested to know that it still has a rather nice Armenian church in it. Steve
  13. quote:Originally posted by edwardk: Now what you described about a man reclaiming his parental rights. Why did the Turkish government lead him into this situation in the first place may I ask?? Sure they knew the local villagers would kill him. Did you really believe a Turk will ever pay compensation to any of his victims?/ Are you that stupid?? Wake up man! I think you are the stupid one, making comments like this. Anyone who knows anything about Kurds will know that they don't need outside encouragement to do their killing. You seem to be chriticising Turkey because it recognised this person's ownership claim, but presumably you would also be chriticising Turkey if it had not... where is your logic!! Garo - perhaps you should give us some hard facts to back up your story about this man being killed by kurds - I'm not suggesting it didn't happen, but I wish sometimes that these and similar stories would rise above the status of heresay. Steve
  14. Help - does anyone know what was the size of the pre-1915 Armenian population of the city of Kayseri (also known as Caeserea) in central Turkey? Steve
  15. I think you should ask yourself some moral questions first. Where has this land come from? If it former soviet state owned land, then it was probably confiscated without compensation from its original owners. If it was privately owned land abandoned by its owners, be they Armenian or Azeri, then it is still morally and legally their property. Your words remind me of a documentary on Cyprus I saw once, In a part of it were some awfull English people who had bought up all of a formerly Greek village in northern Cyprus, and conveted it to holiday homes. They did not have the tinyest concern about what had happened to the previous owners - I hope that one day they find themselves kicked out on their arse, without a penny of compensation. Steve
  16. quote:Originally posted by levonyeshilian: Domino, Mesrob ,at least, can be like Greek Patriarch.He chooses to stay silent.I don't think he's afraid of any threads.He,and maybe 95 percent Armenians ''''living with Armenian identity'''are living in Istanbul,not little Anatolian towns. I think that is the most important question. Why does he not say something like "I will only comment of religious matters", if he really thinks only historians can comment on Armenian genocide matters? I have since seen a report on the background to the event where he made his comments. (I was actually intending to visit Rumkale last summer, but lots of journalists in the area were being arrested over the reporting of the the Birecik Dam, and I decided it was not safe to go). Here is the report: ISTANBUL, 18 May 2001 ("Lraper" Church Bulletin) -- PATRIARCH VISITS ANCIENT SPIRITUAL CENTRE IN HROMCLA His Beatitude Mesrob II, Armenian Patriarch of Istanbul and All Turkey, paid a second visit to Rumkale, where a boat donated by the Patriarchate to the village of Kasaba was inaugurated. Last July, the Patriarch had led an expedition to the region to discover the location of the ancient castle of Rumkale (Hromcla or Hromgla), on the very spot where the river Euphrates and Merzimen meet. It is located about an hour's drive north of the city of Gaziantep (Aintab). The purpose of last year's visit was to see whether Hromcla would be submerged in the Birecik Dam, which was being built at the time and has since been completed (*). While visiting the area, the Patriarch noticed that children were crossing the Merzimen River on dangerous makeshift rafts -- large pieces of wood laid on rubber automobile tires. He decided to give the chieftainship (mukhtariyet) of the Kasaba village a boat for safer crossing across the river. The Patriarchate purchased a second-hand boat in good condition from the seaside village of Arsuz, near Iskenderun (Alexandrette), in the province of Hatay (Antioch). It was then checked for safety, re-painted and renamed "Sevgi" ("love" in Turkish), and then sent to the Kasaba village on May 15. Patriarch Mesrob flew to Gaziantep on May 17, accompanied by the Revd. Archpriest Muron Ayvazyan (Patriarchal Religious Council member), Mr. Vazgen Barin (Deputy Mayor of the Sisli District of Istanbul) and Sub-deacon Vagarsag Seropyan ("Lraper" staff member). At the airport, Mr Shemseddin Can Kahya, Director of the Tourism Bureau of Gaziantep, and the executive members of the local Lions Club and representatives of tourist agencies greeted the Armenian Church delegation. The group then set off towards Hromcla by a bus, provided by the Arsan travel agency in Gaziantep. About 30 kilometres later, the bus stopped at the centre square of the Yavuzeli County, where the mayor of Yavuzeli, Mr Ali Sakar, greeted His Beatitude with flowers and accompanied them on the journey ahead. The Patriarch and his entourage arrived at the Kasaba Village (formerly called Kalekoy) and were greeted at the village entrance by the village Chief (the Mukhtar), the Imam and the members of the Elders' Council. Many villagers, men and women, came forward to greet the Patriarch and wish him welcome. A white pavilion tent was prepared in the village square for the reception, where the guests were offered cold "taan" (yoghurt drink, ayran) and local pistachios. The Mukhtar, Mr Mahmut Yazgan, formally greeted all the guests, wished them welcome to Kasaba and Rumkale, and recounted the hardships that the villagers were facing after the rising waters of the Birecik Dam had swallowed up, among others, the old Kasaba village as well. Now they had to build everything anew. They needed running water, new electric power lines, a sewage system, and similar utilities. Mr Yazgan thanked His Beatitude for making the effort to visit the site, which will help highlight the needs of the village. The Mayor of Yavuzeli, Mr Ali Sakar, followed with his short welcome speech and expressed hope that Rumkale would receive the attention it deserves following His Beatitude's visits. In his remarks, Patriarch Mesrob greeted the people with the Lord's peace and said that he is touched by the warm hospitality that he has received for the second time in the Kasaba village. He explained that purpose of his second visit was to deliver the boat to the village for safer access to the other bank of the Merzimen Spring and the River Euphrates. Patriarch Mesrob said he senses a special feeling at this site, the moral presence of the great Saint Nerses the Graceful, who served the Armenian people as Patriarch from his headquarters in Hromcla (**) in the 12th century. "He was a great man of God, with strong faith and deep love. Saint Nersess had a special gift for reconciling and peace making between different peoples. It is his moral presence, and also the place where his remains were committed, which make this site holy and special for pilgrims," added the Patriarchate. In its three-thousand year history, Hromcla had been ruled by the Assyrians, the Armenians, the Romans, the Parthians, the Byzantines, the Arabs, the Crusaders, the Memlukes, the Seljuks and the Turks. However, the most famous person whose name is associated with Hromcla is Saint Nersess. "The literature that he created, his poems, hymns, epistles and other works have been widely circulated to this day, not only in Armenian, but also in many foreign languages. Anatolia and Thrace are full of places of special interest for the believers, tourists, students of history and culture, and recreationists. However, it is important how people present these sites to the visitors and pilgrims. The number one prerequisite is the hospitality, and the Kasaba village is blessed with that gift," said the Patriarch. He then wished them well and success in their endeavours to rebuild their village and invoked God's blessings upon them. His Beatitude also prayed for the repose of the souls of the 34 passengers who had lost their lives in a tragic plane crash the day before in Malatya. Inauguration of Sevgi Immediately afterwards, the villagers and the guests, headed by the Patriarch, gathered on the northern bank of the Merzimen Spring where an inauguration ceremony was held. The "Sevgi" was lowered into the water, a 12-passenger boat, painted in dazzling white, with an adequate engine and propeller. The villagers were thankful for the donation of the Patriarchate. The Patriarch wished them well and safety, and embarked the boat along with the members of his delegation, the Kasaba Mukhtar, and the Mayor of Yavuzeli. Three smaller boats were brought from nearby villages on the Euphrates to carry the rest of the visitors. Half an hour later, lunch was served on the southern bank of the Merzimen, amidst a beautiful orchard of lovely pomegranate and tall white-berry trees. Oriental rugs covered the picnic area, on which all guests lined up cross-legged to enjoy the local dishes and khorovadz (kebab) that the villagers had prepared. At around 14:00 hours, the group began a climb up the Hromcla mound, approaching the forts via the western gate on which Armenian and Arabic scripts were barely noticeable. The Classical Armenian text began, "By the mercy of God... John...," but the rest was illegible. A steep climb took the visitors to the top of the mound where the ruins of an Armenian Church remained, built on the tomb of Saint Nersess the Graceful. The Patriarch discussed the current condition of the ruins with the Tourism Bureau chief and suggested that a scientific excavation was necessary in order to clear the narthex of the ancient church of the rubble that had fallen in. Another Armenian inscription was spotted on the southern wall of the bema, which was clearly dated 1600. The most moving moment of the visit was marked by the Patriarch's singing of a hymn in Classical Armenian, written by St Nersess in Hromcla: "Love is your name Jesus! Touch with your love my heart, which has become like stone. Because of your sorrow and mercy, grant newness to my life." Under the scorching sun, a mild breeze came to cool the faces of all present who listened to the ancient hymn in profound awe. Descending towards the inner plain opposite the Eastern gate of Hromcla, the pilgrims faced a pleasant surprise. The Arsan Travel Agency and the Tugcan Hotel in Gaziantep had joined efforts to hold a reception, offering some eighty people champagne, refreshments, seasonal fruits and mixed roasted nuts. Ms Ayse Nur Arun, the president of the Arsan Travel Agency, presented the Patriarch with a beautiful plaque ornate with mother-of-pearl. The Patriarch left Hromcla through the Eastern gate, and made a 45-minute tour of nearby villages, which had succumbed to the waters of the Birecik Dam on the banks of the River Euphrates. Returning to Kasaba village, he presented the village school with 120 children's books, a complete set of encyclopaedia and 30 schoolbags, which were gratefully received. He then said farewell to the Village Mukhtar, the Yavuzeli Mayor and the villagers and promised to visit them again. His Beatitude was then escorted to the Gaziantep airport and arrived at the VIP lounge, half an hour before the 19:30 flight back to Istanbul. Before he left for the plane, the Patriarch commended the Arsan travel agency for their excellent organization skills.
  17. It would be really helpful if someone who speaks Turkish (Levonyeshilian/ThornyRose?) could possibly translate the following newspaper article into English. It deals with the quarry the Armenians have set up directly opposite the ruins of Ani. http://www.hurriyetim.com.tr/hur/turk/01/0...rkiye/03tur.htm http://www.hurriyetim.com.tr/hur/turk/01/0...rkiye/03tur.htm
  18. He really cannot keep his mouth shut, can he? Armenian patriarch rejects so-called genocide Turkish Daily News 19 May, 2001 Mesrob II, the Patriarch of the Turkish Armenians, said that terminology should not be used for defining the events which took place in the past between the Turks and the Armenians, stating that he could not say that either a genocide or a massacre took place. "However, I can say that too many painful events occurred. Now there are those who were affected by this and who have to live with the pain and trauma of those events," Mesrob II said. Patriarch Mesrob II, visited Gaziantep to give a small boat as a present to the inhabitants of the Kasaba village close to Rumkale, who moved to the area as it will not be affected by the rise in the water level before the construction of the Birecik Dam. The Armenian Patriarch asked that the issue not be seen as a matter of hatred and offered the starting of the dialogue process.
  19. bellthecat

    Basque

    quote:Originally posted by Thorny Rose: Methinks you might remember me from Armenia-Diaspora Forum... It was the screen name "Thorny Rose" that caught my eye. I was wondering if you had made it up - or got it from somewhere else, as I think it may have also been the pen name or alias of a 19th century writer (but I can't remember for certain). Steve
  20. Levon, is it OK if I can I take up your "if u ever need a translation" offer? It is a report on Ani in an on-line article in the Hurriyet newspaper. http://www.hurriyetim.com.tr/hur/turk/01/0...rkiye/03tur.htm Thanks, Steve
  21. bellthecat

    Basque

    I think the alleged connection between Basque and Armenian comes from Nikolai Marr's linguistic theories from the 1920s and 30s - only the connection wasn't with Armenian, but with Abkazian / Georgian / Uruatian, etc. (see my link to a page on Marr in the famous Armenians section) Steve PS, Thorny Rose, the term "Caucasian" as an ethnic category for white Americans is only used in North America - nowhere else in the English speaking world is it used (abused?)thus. But where does the name "Thorny Rose" come from - I have heard it somewhere before, but forget where. Steve
  22. bellthecat

    Ararat

    quote:Originally posted by Azat: Who is she Mike? His wife. But why the surprise - she is in just about everything he has made; saves money I suppose (or at least keeps it in the family!) because it can't be for her stilted acting ability. Steve
  23. quote:Originally posted by MJ: As to the German Forgottenhisname, I should say, LOL, I meant I have Forgotten his name. Would make a great name for a comic character, perhaps refine it to Herr Vorgotteniznam.
  24. quote:Originally posted by Kazza: BTW, Steve- I was impressed by your website...must have taken an lot of work. Also , did you just see the eurovision contest? It was on a second ago. Do you know who won? Estonioa - and it was absolutley crap! Still,Eurovision is not renowned for it's music. Thanks for the praise - can't get too much of it! meeeoww. You're a bit younger than me (I think ) and probably look at the Eurovision song contest as just a cliched bit of silly old tat, but for anyone who grew up in the early 70s it is synonymous with the idea of the EEC (and later the EU) and of a "European culture". That's why I can find nothing ironic in its unmitigated ghastliness. OK, a lot of people don't realise its true meaning any more (a bit like the nursery rhyme "ring-a-ring-a-roses"). But think of what it really represents and you will never watch it again! Er, back to the subject - the question is a lot to do with what people mean by "invented". Saying that something is possible is not "inventing" it - so a statement that it was "realized as early as 1904 that color television was possible" has nothing to do with invention. You cannot patent an abstract idea, only a product. Similarly, improving on something previously invented is not inventing it - so saying "A fairly refined color television system was introduced in New York City in 1940 by the Hungarian-born American inventor Peter Goldmark" is again nothing to do with actual "invention" in its purest sense. That is more like innovation, I think. Steve
×
×
  • Create New...