-
Posts
1,641 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Events
Gallery
Everything posted by bellthecat
-
quote:Originally posted by gamavor: As a crime against humanity it was officially recognized by both The Senate and The French Parliament. The legal consequences of this recognition are that whoever, whenever dares to deny the fact of Genocide perpetrated against Armenians must face the Justice system. What legal consequences? As I just said this so-called "law" is actually a statement of belief - a public statement that the French senate (and, by implication, the French state) accepts that the Armenian genocide happened. It is an abomination for you to suggest that just because a legislative body says that something is true (or is not true) then a person who disagrees with that legislative's statement should be treated like a criminal. The French parliament has a long history of making unjustifiable statements, from the time of Dreyfus right to the present. It is about time you saw beyond partisan politics and recognised what sort of road you are advocating going down. Steve
-
If the French Senate had rejected the Law Recognising the Armenian Genocide, would Turkey have been able to close French sites alleging the genocide actually happened? You silence opponents by the strength of your facts and arguments. You do not censor them. And you do not encourage the French to ignore EC human rights legislation. Steve
-
Two more sites: http://jinx.sistm.unsw.edu.au/~greenlft/19.../386/386p25.htm http://markov.utstat.toronto.edu/fulford/CIA.html (and for the above site, check out some of the other articles by Robert Fulford - amusing stuff!) Steve
-
Strange - the end of the article on the website I quoted seems to have been cut. It should read: Ms. Stonor Saunders describes how the C.I.A. cleverly skimmed hundreds of millions of dollars from the Marshall Plan to finance its activities, funneling the money through fake philanthropies it created or real ones like the Ford Foundation. "We couldn't spend it all," Gilbert Greenway, a former C.I.A. agent, recalled. "There were no limits, and nobody had to account for it. It was amazing." When some of the C.I.A.'s activities were exposed in the late 1960's, many artists and intellectuals claimed ignorance. But Ms. Stonor Saunders makes a strong case that several people, including the philosopher Isaiah Berlin and the poet Stephen Spender, who was co-editor of Encounter, knew about the C.I.A.'s role. "She has made it very difficult now to deny that some of these things happened," said Norman Birnbaum, a professor at the Georgetown University Law School who was a university professor in Europe in the 1950's and early 1960's. "And she has placed a lot of people living and dead in embarrassing situations." Still unresolved is what impact the campaign had and whether it was worth it. Some of the participants, like Arthur M. Schlesinger Jr., who was in the O.S.S. and knew about some of the C.I.A.'s cultural activities, argue that the agency's role was benign, even necessary. Compared with the coups the C.I.A. sponsored in Guatemala, Iran and elsewhere, he said, its support of the arts was some of its best work. "It enabled people to publish what they already believed," he added. "It didn't change anyone's course of action or thought." But Diana Josselson, whose husband, Michael, ran the Congress for Cultural Freedom, told Ms. Stonor Saunders that there were real human costs among those around the world who innocently cooperated with the agency's front organizations only to be tarred with a C.I.A. affiliation when the truth came out. The author and other critics argue that by using government money covertly to promote such American ideals as democracy and freedom of expression, the agency ultimately stepped on its own message. "Obviously it was an error, and a rather serious error, to allow intellectuals to be subsidized by the government," said Alan Brinkley, a history professor at Columbia University. "And when it was revealed, it did undermine their credibility seriously." March 18, 2000 in the New York Times
-
quote:Originally posted by MJ: Steve, I have no intention of engaging in name calling. I am just recalling the communist propaganda on Abstract Art that I have grown up hearing about. That is true. From an American, calling someone a communist is perhaps far worse than just "name calling". Well I have not grown up with Communist propaganda, or anti-Communist propaganda. quote Homework: http://seattlep-i.nwsource.com/national/cia18.shtml quote See today's homework assignment. I will have to have a look at the book mentioned in the above article. I first learned of the CIA's close involvment in Abstract art in a TV documentary I saw about 5 years ago. quote: First of all, Abstract Art,..... Ho, hum, yes I can read an art history book as well, remember, all this started when I pointed out your ambiguous use of the term "abstract"! quote: Just grow up, man. I am just puzzled at the extremes that you through yourself at, lately. I want to just believe that your latest series of declarations are just a temporary manifestation of some mid-age crisis, which perhaps most of us go through at some time. ...sounds a bit like personal insults again. You might look back on what I wrote that prompted your replies, it had a winking smiley face next to it. It was not meant to be deadly serious. Steve
-
The celts in relation to the history of the caucasus.
bellthecat replied to Kazza's topic in History
quote:Originally posted by gamavor: I would suggest to Bellthecat to write a letter to the Webmaster of the above-mentioned webpage with an explanation why he thinks that the webpage is "utter garbage". A pointless thing for me to do, it is not a site with academic pretensions. For this sort of site, every fact should be treated with suspicion, ALL the dates and events could have be made up since there is not a single book or magazine source reference given anywhere on any of the pages. And in his bibliography there seem to be only two books listed, namely : "Hubert, Henri, THE RISE OF THE CELTS, Biblo and Tannen, New York, 1966" and "Powell, T.G.E., THE CELTS, Frederick Praeger, New York, 1966". I have heard of neither book before, and would you believe someone on the basis of them having read just two books on a subject? This is the sort of site that gives internet research a bad name. Steve NB: I am refering only to the "Celtic" part of the site - I have no knowledge of how accurate the "Texas" part of it is. You should be in a better (geographical ) position to judge that, gamavor. -
quote:Originally posted by MJ: However, singling out of the US is what I resent even more. When witnessing such singling out, and taking things out of the context, I get an impression of some other motives behind them, or at least unbalanced hyperventilation. MJ, this seems to be your standard response to ANY criticisim about American policy! You casually dismiss the legitimate points raised, and then start to get personal by attacking the motives, intellect or sanity of the person making those points. I just love your justification of state censorship and the re-writing of embarassing history by classifying it as a "procedural issue". The next time Turkey does the same thing, what moral basis will you have to argue against it.
-
quote:Originally posted by MJ: What a Communist nonsense, Steve... Your primitivism increasingly puzzles me, I should confess. MJ, I suggest you do some research before resorting to name-calling. It is a well known fact that the CIA covertly sponsored many American Abstract artists during the 1960s and 70s, and that it secretly financed tours and exhibitions of those artists in Europe, especially eastern Europe. At the time, none of that was known publicly, and was only revealed during the early 1990s when various freedom of information bills became law in the US. What was never adequately revealed was what hidden motives the CIA had for such a bizarre practice. Steve
-
And would you believe it - the paramilitary group America financed was called the "Gestapu". U.S. Gov't Recalls Indonesia Book By PETE YOST .c The Associated Press WASHINGTON (AP) - In a diplomatic damage-control mission, the government is recalling all copies of a State Department history book from hundreds of libraries because it details the U.S. role in Indonesia's deadly purge of communists in the 1960s. The anti-communist campaign helped topple the country's founding president, Sukarno. His daughter, Megawati Sukarnoputri, became the nation's new leader this week. A State Department cable contained in the book spells out a U.S. plan to funnel tens of thousands of dollars to a group that targeted the Indonesian Communist Party, known as the PKI, for destruction. The book quotes a message from the embassy to the State Department as saying that an embassy-prepared list of communist leaders ``is apparently being used by Indonesian security authorities who seem to lack even the simplest overt information on PKI leadership.'' The embassy admitted in an April 15, 1966 message to Washington that ``we frankly do not know whether the real figure'' of communists who have been killed ``is closer to 100,000 or 1,000,000 but believe it wiser to err on the side of the lower estimates, especially when questioned by the press.'' The State Department blamed the Government Printing Office for releasing the book without prior approval from State, but the GPO said it had gotten clearance from State in April. ``We did not inadvertently release this history,'' said GPO spokesman Andrew Sherman, adding that the office was contacted by the State Department only within the last two weeks. ``Every now and then an agency will say, 'there is a problem with a document, can you pull it back?' That's what we have been in the process of doing over the last several days - talking to the State Department and finding a way to ask the libraries to take those books off the shelves,'' Sherman said. The book is ``Foreign Relations of the United States 1964-68, Volume XXVII, Indonesia, Malaysia-Singapore, Philippines.'' The National Security Archive, a private group that collects and publishes declassified government documents, said the CIA had tried to suppress the account of U.S. involvement in the anti-communist campaign. The group on Friday posted the disputed volume on Indonesia on its Web site: http://www.nsarchive.org. The text of a four-page CIA memo from then-Far East Division Chief William Colby was excluded from the volume. But there is plenty of detail that remains about the Gestapu, the brutal civilian group that succeeded in suppressing the PKI. ``This is to confirm my earlier concurrence that we provide Malik with fifty million rupiahs requested by him for the activities of the Kap-Gestapu movement,'' says a Dec. 2, 1965 document from the American ambassador in Indonesia to William P. Bundy, assistant secretary of state for East Asian and Pacific affairs from 1964 to 1969. ``The chances of detection or subsequent revelation of our support in this instance are as minimal as any black bag operation can be,'' the document concludes. The memo identifies Malik as ``one of the key civilians'' in Gestapu and says that ``our endorsement of his present role'' will promote good relations between him and the Indonesian military. Of the Gestapu, the ambassador's document said, ``This army-inspired but civilian-staffed action group is still carrying burden of current repressive efforts targeted against the PKI.'' ``This month, before the internal process of deciding when to release the volume was completed, we learned that the Government Printing Office had begun distributing copies,'' said a State Department official, speaking on condition of anonymity. ``At that point, we asked the Government Printing Office not to sell any more copies because the process was not yet complete and no release date set.''
-
Sorry, this bit should have been highlighted. A separate State Department volume covering U.S. activities in Greece, Cyprus and Turkey in the mid-1960s "is still locked up in GPO warehouses," the institute said.
-
It is not only Turkey that refuses to admit to past crimes, and bans/destroys books that reveal those crimes. The paper shredders are probably being oiled as you read this! (NB: on British news sources, the figure is 1 million dead, not the 100,000 stated in this news report). US withholds book detailing 1960s Indonesia role WASHINGTON (Reuters) - The Bush administration has halted the distribution of a book about U.S. diplomatic and intelligence activities in Indonesia during the chaotic years of 1965 and 1966, a State Department official said Saturday. The book reportedly states that the U.S. Embassy in Indonesia provided Indonesian security forces with a list of top leaders of the PKI, the Communist Party opposition at the time. The book, a copy of which is available on the Internet, also suggests the U.S. information contributed to the killing of more than 100,000 PKI members at the hands of Indonesian security forces. The flap over the book came the week President Abdurrahman Wahid was ousted by Indonesia's national assembly and replaced by Megawati Sukarnoputri, the 54-year-old daughter of Indonesia's founding president, Sukarno, who was overthrown in the mid-1960s revolt. Wahid, a frail 60-year-old Muslim cleric who has had two strokes and is nearly blind, arrived in Baltimore Friday for a medical checkup. A copy of the book has been obtained by the National Security Archive, a nonprofit research institute operated out of George Washington University in Washington. The institute is a repository for documents that have been declassified by the government. The book has been posted on the institute's Web site, www.nsarchive.org. A State Department official, who asked not to be identified, said the agency earlier this year "began the process of arranging" release of the book to the public. He added that the Government Printing Office mistakenly began distributing copies of the book before an "internal process" of review was completed by the State Department. The official said he did not know how many copies of the Indonesia history book had been sold or when the government might resume sales. According to the National Security Archive, the State Department book states that on Dec. 2, 1965, U.S. Ambassador Marshall Green "endorsed a 50 million rupiah covert payment to the Kap-Gestapu movement leading the repression." The Dec. 30, 1965 response by the CIA to the State Department was withheld, the institute said. A separate State Department volume covering U.S. activities in Greece, Cyprus and Turkey in the mid-1960s "is still locked up in GPO warehouses," the institute said. The two books are part of a 350-volume series of foreign relations books published by the State Department. According to the State Department, the books are intended to present "the official documentary historical record of major U.S. foreign policy decisions and significant diplomatic activity." Among the volumes released in recent decades were historical records of the October 1962 Cuban Missile Crisis, Arab-Israeli conflicts in the mid-1960s and Vietnam in 1966.
-
The celts in relation to the history of the caucasus.
bellthecat replied to Kazza's topic in History
quote:Originally posted by gamavor: http://users.ev1.net/~gpmoran/CeltChron1.htm On this web page, those who are interested can find lots of info about the origins of the Celts. Pity the poor student who comes upon this site and actually believes all the stuff on it! Most of what it says about events before around 1300AD is utter garbage. Steve -
Yet another for the list? America's refusal to sign the treaty against biological weapons is another in a long line of treaties and international standards that America now seems to think it can violate, tear up, or simply ignore. (Anti-Ballistic Missile treaty, treaties to ban land mines and nuclear weapons tests, proposals for an international criminal court, UN proposals to ban use of the death penalty, treaty to restrict small-arms trafficking, Kyoto climate accord, .....)
-
quote:Originally posted by MJ: Steve, But I love Abstract Art. Because it was supported by the CIA (and similar agents of American Imperialisim )in the 1950s and 60s? Kazza, have you seen the films in a cinema - if not what's your excuse! Over the last year there were two different festivals of Armenian culture that showed the films in London. Steve
-
The celts in relation to the history of the caucasus.
bellthecat replied to Kazza's topic in History
quote:Originally posted by Thorny Rose: Steve, those inscriptions were written after escaping half a century of subjugation by the Chinese. Turkish history books describe that period as a brief moment in time when Turkic sovereignty of any form did not exist. I don't see any difference in nature between that and, say, Saroyan's defying all powers to erase Armenians off the face of the earth. Does it matter that much that one is a politician and he talks of the sky and the earth? It has nothing to do with "master-race" or whatever. That concept never existed until the ninteenth century, and, if it did, it was entertained for the greater part by the Ottoman romantics - and it is said that these started with the Hungarians, who, only out of coincidence, realized they weren't even eligible for Turanism, being Finno-Ugric peoples. The two people who ever believed in it are known - the Germans and the Japanese, respective in their own spheres. The original Turkic peoples were not racist. Personally, I have always disliked Saroyan's statement (or rather the pominence it is given) - but it was made in the context of a nation having actually SURVIVED an attempt to exterminate it - Turkey never went through that sort of experience. It is the lack of any connection to the land that I find disturbing in those Turkish inscriptions. Most other nations seem to have a very close affinity with the geography of the lands they developed in - but those Turkish inscriptions have an uncomfortable emphasis on the "nation" and on that "nation" having no boundaries or natural limits or fixed lands - that is what I was refering to when I talked (not very clearly I admit) about a "master race" - I did not mean some crude 20th century Fascism. In Turkey today, I see a near univeral contempt for the land. I mean "Land" in an abstract way (aarg, MJ, now I am using the word ). The Natural World. Maybe it is because they are not that land's original inhabitants, or maybe it is due to the original homeland of the Turks being a limitless steppe without strong geographical features or permanent settlements, or maybe I am making something out of nothing. Celtic Britain, however, had an extremely close connection to and affinty with the land in which they lived. We can see that most clearly in the so-called "nature poetry" of early Celtic Ireland and Scotland - a form of poetry umparalleled in any other part of Europe, and that seems disconcertingly modern to our eyes. Steve -
quote:Originally posted by Harut: as far as the #s go, in what place is Armenian Diaspora in the world? 2nd?????? certainly more like 200th, or maybe more like 1000th, or 2000th!
-
quote:Originally posted by MJ: My usage of the word "Abstract" here has had nothing to do with the category of Abstract Art, but rather with the philosophical meaning of the word "Abstract." And in that sense, what you described in your passage indicates exactly the movie belonging to the [philosophical] "Abstract" category. Yes, I see. I was just objecting to the use of (small "a") "abstract" because lot of people (myself included) dislike Abstract art, and to use the word abstract to describe Parajanov's films might put such people off from ever looking at them. (But "Abstract" is not just used as a description for paintings - it is also used as a style of film making, theatre presentation, etc). Has anyone ever seen the music video that used a lot of clips from his films - apart from probably breaking just about every copyright law in the book, it completely overloaded your eyes and brain with visual images.
-
The celts in relation to the history of the caucasus.
bellthecat replied to Kazza's topic in History
Re: Orkhon inscriptions, a while ago I found a website that listed a lot of the inscriptions - but I cannot now find it! There is another website, www.turcoman.btinternet.co.uk that has an article on the inscriptions. I don't know the exact page url. One of the inscriptions reads "If the sky above did not collapse and if the earth below did not give way, Oh Turk people, who would be able to destroy your state and your institutions." which could be a motto from early Republican Turkey! Steve -
I got one as well, a couple of dats ago, with the message "I hope you can help me with this file that I sent" I sent it to delete, without even thinking. NEVER open an e-mail attachment unless the sender describes in detail what it contains, and even then it is best to contact the sender to confirm the contents. Steve PS the attached file was named FI.xls.com and was 274k in size.
-
I need help and 'ting (Filiz you might be able to do somethi
bellthecat replied to Kazza's topic in Help
quote:Originally posted by Aghmug: I use that too, Steve. It's great. I keep waiting for them to say, "Sorry, free time is over, time to pay up!" but they haven't and it's been over a year. Its almost over - 8mb maximum storage and only one web page, from September, I think. Steve -
quote:Originally posted by Paul bunyan: Does anyone know if theres a Lake Salvadi in Armenia near the border with the stolen region of Nakichevan? Thanks There is a mountain called Salvadi, on the border. I don't have a large scale map, but maybe the lake is near the mountain.
-
quote:Originally posted by MJ: Yes, Mike. It is a highly publicised movie - a pretty abstract one. It is not really at all "abstract" if you understand the references and know something about Caucasian art. Abstract art is non-representational in that it is something which makes no identifiable reference to the visible world. Parajanov's films are probably the exact opposite of that. I regret never having been able to see any of his films on a cinema screen, but only on TV. Steve
-
The celts in relation to the history of the caucasus.
bellthecat replied to Kazza's topic in History
quote:Originally posted by Paul bunyan: BELLtheCAT, is that so, you mean in spite of all the evidence such as the tomb of the Keltic King Tut, discovered in germany back in the 1970s the facts are incorrect. what is your documentation? What facts do you mean? I think you may be confusing cultural influences with ethnicity. Cultural influences spread much faster than population movements, and as far a Britain and Ireland are concerned there were no large scale population movements, just an adobtion of cultural ideas from the rest of Europe. And when "celtic" europe was extinguished as a result of the Roman invasions it was in the British isles that Celtic art evolved into its most advanced form. Its peoples, though, were the descendents from the earliest inhabitants of the islands, and did not come via a "celtic invasion" or push out earlier peoples. -
The celts in relation to the history of the caucasus.
bellthecat replied to Kazza's topic in History
quote:Originally posted by Paul bunyan: The Celts from the Greek "celtoi" were thought to have originally settled in what is today dagestan. from there they made there way to the Balkans, Germany, and finally, to england, Ireland, Scotland, Wales, and Portugal. they certainly got around. That's 19th century pseudo-history, Paul. It is now accepted that until the invasions of the Angles and Saxons the peoples of Britain and Ireland were essentially the same people that always had lived there. No mass imigrations by "Celts". Steve -
The celts in relation to the history of the caucasus.
bellthecat replied to Kazza's topic in History
But looks are very different from influences, Kazza. Its a big leap from the first to the second, and there is no actual evidence to support that leap. Thorny, have you ever actually read what those Orkhon Valley inscriptions are supposed to say. If you have, I hope you found them as unpleasant as I did. Anyone who thinks that the Turkish opinion of themselves as some sort of "master-race" is of a recent origin should think again. Steve
