Jump to content

bellthecat

Banned
  • Posts

    1,641
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by bellthecat

  1. There were no "Christian" Hemshinli - there were only Hemshinli who were Muslim in public, but who retained some Christian customs and beliefs in private. Any pre-1915 Christians who lived in the Hemshin valleys (such as in the village of Elevit) were Armenians who called themselves Armenians.
  2. You are galloping into the realms of fantasy now! At the most, 15,000 Hemshinli live in their two original valleys and in the neighbouring towns on the Black sea. Probably ten times that number now live in the major towns of Western Turkey. I'm not sure how many still live in the villages around Adapazar - a few thousand at most, I'd guess. I don't know if anyone has investigated when and why they migrated into the Adapazar region. It must have been with the permission of the Ottoman Empire, anyway - which means that they must have been openly Muslim by that time or they probably wouldn't have been allowed to come. However, they were still acknowledged as being Armenian by the local Armenian population.
  3. Not Armenian - it is Georgian: Dortkilise monastery near Yusufeli (near as in a 3.5 hour walk from it).
  4. bellthecat

    Mac Or Ibm

    If an electronic component works to start with, then generally it will continue to work for ever. So there is no such thing as a cheap component. Only someone selling overpriced and unwanted additional extended guarantee/repair warranty will tell you otherwise! A "you get what you pay for" comment might be valid for mechanical devices or componets that have moving parts, such as keyboards or mice, or hard disks, but for everything else there is no such thing as poor quality. There is only correctly priced and over-priced. Macs belong to the latter category.
  5. Hmmm... but Hagopn, you seem to have broken quite a few of those rules so far! About your comment on alleged "anti-Armenian propaganda" from Germany - all the serious early 20th century academic work on Armenian culture and art originated in Germany - by people such as such as Bachmann, or Strzygowski. And, several generations earlier, it was a German, Shultz, who was responsible for the "discovery" of Urartu, and who paid for that discovery with his life. Also, it appears to me that you are the one who is assuming parallels with the modern era. Tell me, what do you think an Armenian from 500bc actually was? In what regions did he live? and in what regions did he not live? And did he consider himself to be an Armenian? And in what way do you consider that 500bc Armenian (or, for that matter, a 700bc Urartian) to be related to an modern Armenian? About my use of the word "obscure". I'm in no position to take a trip to northern Iran to view such and such cuniform inscription, or spend large amounts of money to build up a library of very hard to locate books, or (even if I had) I couldn't suddenly be able to read Russian or Armenian. Nor do I live near one of the few libraries in the world that would have such works. If you are fortunate enough to be able to do all that then good for you, but for most of the rest of us it will all remain "obscure" until you start to put something down beyond sloganising. At the very least, start to put dates against the authors you are citing. I doubt that much that has been written about Urartu that is more than 30 years old can contain anything substantially accurate - simply because the field was not well explored. Have any of the people you have cited made use of material found during the many recent excavations in Turkey, all of which would count as primary evidence?
  6. And it might also be worthwile thinking about why this fact is not given greater emphasis in literature about the Armenian genocide. Why Turks have not made more of it is obvious, but why the silence form Armenians? Surely it must be because Armenians have been making just as much propaganda out of the Armenian genocide as Turkey has. But for Armenians, since 1918 it has been all about getting back (or making a moral claim to) territory in eastern Turkey. So it is irrelevant for them that most of the Armenians killed or deported during the genocide did not live in eastern Turkey.
  7. Yep , maybe they all rushed into Georgia's parliament building because everyone in Georgia thinks that they should be president.
  8. What on earth do you mean by this? There are no Hemshinli in Cilicia. Nor are there (outside of the major cities) any Hemshinli anywhere else in Turkey except in and around their homeland in north-eastern Turkey, and in certain villages around Sakarya (Adapazar). And I'd think that they number in total a couple of 100,000 at most.
  9. bellthecat

    Noteworthy

    And it has been a long time since Frederick Forsyth has been a literary figure! Look at him now - a sad, old, has-been reduced to writing imaginary letters to the president. I thought only pre-teen American schoolkids wrote "Dear Mr President" letters!
  10. So there are vested interests at work trying to say there is no direct ethnic or cultural connection between Urartu and early Armenia Well, doh! - tell us something we don't all already know! Equally, there are vested interests trying to say that there is. And neither group uses anything that approaches a proper historical analysis. But you are still not telling us anything specific ... Edit: clean up done/ Sasun
  11. What a creep you are - I suggest you change your moniker to something more honest then "friend" - at least "nasty" is honest in that regard. Vet of over 30 years eh - so how many "gooks" (such as innocent Vietnamese women and children) did you murder? I bet you wish you were in the Israeli army now - it would be just like the old times for you.
  12. bellthecat

    Confidence

    A bit like Hitler then, aren't you? I wonder how many millions have died over the ages as a result of people with "confidence". What the world needs is for us all to have a lot less "confidence" and a lot more thoughtful self doubt.
  13. A genocide denialist bot should be easy to make - though maybe it exists already and is called Mr Nasty.
  14. I've just told you why, and what the message was!
  15. JF - you know very well that Jews not like you will consider YOU to be the abberation. "Flagrant liberal Jews" like you have sat back for decades and allowed Zionist fanatics to rule the roost - so don't go crying foul now that most of the world is tarring Jews like you and Jews like them with the same brush. And you must also know very well that the majority of card-carrying neocons are Jewish.
  16. Or if you say it more politely "You are not that clever, are you?" she replies "Surprisingly, you're not the first person to tell me that. I'll take it into account, Steve. " Why are you worth 100 dollars a month? "I am sorry, I don't like to brag, but I would rather leave you to see yourself the impact of BOTizen." Can you brag, please? "I'm not really sure, Steve. It isn't in my current function list." I can get a real woman for 100 dollars! "Is this suppose to be a complement? Well, I am afraid I am not real. I am an Automated Interactive Intelligent Agent. "
  17. bellthecat

    Noteworthy

    So you are back doing your old "hairy chested tub thumping" routine, eh, Martin?
  18. The point Arpa is making is that it is being turned into a piece of Jewish / Zionist propaganda by the use of phrases like "Jewish synagogues". No doubt the news reports of the explosions were sandwiched between appropriate (for Jews and neo-conservatives) other news reports. It probably went something like this. Start with a report of your brave American "heroes" in action in Iraq, then comes the report on Istanbul events in order to suggest to the viewer that this sort of thing is why America invaded Iraq, then move to a report on Palestine with all the usual Israeli bias, suggesting to the viewer that all palestinians are terrorists like those who planted the bombs in Istanbul. But, Thoth you know all about such wag the dog media manipulation of facts. It's your job, isn't it? But you and America's halcyon fool-some-of-the-people-all-of-the-time days are coming to an end.
  19. Long ago (according to Plato, anyway) humans had two heads and four arms and four legs, and there were no such things as men or women. But these humans were so perfect that they made the gods angry, and so they were all split down the middle, making two humans, male and female. So now everyone unconciously goes around searching for their missing half to make themselves complete again. And when we find our other half - that is what we call love. Steve
  20. Mutafyan is at it again. The tolerance <_< and peaceful days <_< <_< of the Ottoman Empire era will be revived in Turkey TurkishDaily News Nov 8, 2003 ISTANBUL - The Patriarch of the Turkish Armenian Orthodox Church, Mesrob Mutafyan, stated that Ramadan is a month of love and tolerance and added, "The tolerance and peaceful days of the Ottoman Empire era will be revived in Turkey." Mutafyan participated in an official reopening ceremony of the Ferikoy Surp Vartanans Armenian Church whose restoration expenditures were funded by the Sisli Municipality. After saying prays in the renovated church, Mutafyan said the tolerance and peace among Turkish citizens began to be revived 10 years ago. "Ten years ago, the followers of the same religion did not invite each other during the Iftar meal. Now the followers of different religions gather to celebrate their sacred days and festivals," said Mutafyan and added that they have been celebrating Ramadan with Muslims. Stating that all monotheistic religions have fasting rituals, Mutafyan continued, "The common characteristics of the monotheist religions are seen by all people. The fasting and alms are common features of all three religions. The restoration of the Ferikoy Church by Sisli Municipality is a good example of the cooperation between the monotheist religions, said the patriarch. Mutafyan added that the tolerance and dialogue process initiated by the Turkish Religious Affairs Directorate was supported by nongovernmental organizations. The Armenian Patriarch referred to the Inter-Religious Dialogue Conference in Tarsus 10 years ago as a great contribution to the restoration of dialogue and friendship between the different religious communities in Turkey.
  21. bellthecat

    Intelligence

    And then there is the phallic thing - big nose, big penis, (don't know whether it is true - though probably some US university has acres of research papers on the subject ) - so believers of that, if female, would maybe want to find a male partner with a big nose, but the man wouldn't want to have a female partner with a big nose!
  22. It's a recent thing, Stormy. In the past it was the men who wore the big wigs and impractical clothes and massive amounts of makeup. Or the armour that was impossible to walk or even fight in! But I don't think they did it to impress women, they did it to impress their fellow males
  23. Are you not maybe thinking of slob, or slobbo? Yob in Britain is just as nasty as the dictionary definition - in the nastyness scale it's not as bad a thug, not as good as a ned. Why should it be different in Australia? Steve
  24. bellthecat

    Intelligence

    First, define intelligence. Well, whatever it is, it is something that happens inside one's brain - and since parents with big noses tend to have children with even bigger noses, it might be the same with brains.
  25. That is just silly - almost as silly as the theory (now conveniently abandoned?) that they were emigrants who came from Ani after the city's fall to the Turks. The Byzantine empire had no authority in these regions, so could not have "settled" anyone there. Do not confuse real history with nationalist fantasy.
×
×
  • Create New...