Jump to content

bellthecat

Banned
  • Posts

    1,641
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by bellthecat

  1. Please - who do you think you are kidding! This book is just the latest example of a long line of Zionist propaganda. I wonder if words like "if you want to be respected you have to use force with muslims" were endlessly whispered in Bush's ear, or does his propensity towards casual violence come naturally? Did "Balkan Christians with independence and armies" like the Serbs avoid genocide. Hardly! In terms of percentage of population Serbia lost more people per head of population in WW1 than any other nation except Armenia. And in WW2 Serbia lost more people per head of population than any other nation. After all that it's a wonder there were any Serbs left in Kossovo to be exterminated in 1998. And who did all that killing - apart from Albanians who were Muslim in name only, it was Catholic Croats and Austrians and Protestant Germans. Steve
  2. Sorry, Domino, I didn't save the pictures. It was in Italian. Didn't someone say a while ago that this Arkun was buying stuff on behalf of a museum? So in that sense he is just buying to collect rather than to read!
  3. And in what way do you think you personally "make it a better place" while continuing to take Uncle Sam's paycheck in return for doing whatever deeds are asked of you?
  4. bellthecat

    Graphic Artist

    That drawing is not mine - I got it from here, don't know which page exactly. http://iatp.irex.am/resource/artcult/taraz/1eng.html But I have some similar drawings of my own, of the same reliefs. I'll see what they look like when I scan them. I'll scan them when I find them! Steve
  5. There was a copy on sale on ebay about 18 months ago - Authors name was Gorrini, it was a two volume book, in Italian, paperback cover I think, from the 1930s I think. Sold for something big - probably that darned arkun@usa.com got it, (may his fat wallet rot in his pocket and turn his genitals blue. )
  6. Well, [erhaps piggywiggy means that 99% of Turks were not concious that a genocide was being committed - and maybe even perhaps 90% of those doing the killing were not aware of the intended end result. Whether that is true or not I don't know. But if it were true then either you all must accept that "Turkey" as an entity, and "Turks" as a race, did not commit genocide. Or you must accept that there are a lot more unadmitted and far more recent genocides - such as that which America commited in Kosovo, and (for that matter) what Armenia committed in Nagorno Karabagh.
  7. bellthecat

    Graphic Artist

    How about something like this (from Aghtamar) http://iatp.irex.am/resource/artcult/taraz/takhtak18_2.gif
  8. There is a book by the Italian consul at Trebizond in 1915, in which he gives his memories of the events. I wonder what it has to say about it?
  9. Text from it reads: The ANI map, as I noted in my review, reproduces many of the errors and ambiguities in the original work. A specific issue that I use as an example—and I could have chosen others—is whether several thousand Armenians were drowned in the Black Sea during the Armenian Genocide of 1915. I argue that while there were rumors of such mass drownings in 1915, the stories were soon dismissed by contemporaries such as James Bryce, who had originally engaged the mass drowning theory. I also cite a dissertation on the manifestation of the Armenian Genocide at Trebizond, by Kevork Suakjian, who uses American consular records and does not support the mass-drownings thesis. Instead he gives a detailed chronology of deportations (see my review). Rouben Adalian, on the other hand, insists that the ANI map was carefully produced and argues that the United States consul at Trebizond, Oscar Heizer, and the encyclopedia of the Armenian Question (Yerevan, 1996) support his position on mass drownings. He categorically rejects my suggestion that the ANI map was simply lifted from the 1920 work without adequate checks of the actual data. As Suakjian demonstrated in his thesis, Oscar Heizer accounted for the disappearance of the vast majority of Armenians from Trebizond through mass deportations, while many Armenian children were kept in orphanages and farmed out to Muslim families. While Heizer noted that there were cases where some Armenians were taken to sea in caïques (rowboats) and probably drowned, he did not report any mass drownings as the Khanzadian and ANI maps suggest. Drowning was uncharacteristic of the fate of Armenians in Trebizond.
  10. Here is that armenainforum article. it is an adobe acrobat file. http://www.gomidas.org/forum/af8-adal.pdf
  11. Did you mean "not much" or "so much"? There was some stuff about the scale of these methods of killing on an online article I saw about that ANI reprinting of the 1920s "routes of deportations" map. I think it was on armenianforum maggazine. I'll try and find it.
  12. Unless America has an open door to all immigrants then surely the reason for lying is simply to deceive immigration officials - invent the usual fake stories about political persecution. Certainly, that is the case in Europe - though few dare say such a thing in public in Europe - saying such things will get you arrested for racism if you are an ordinary member of the public, or assasinated if you are a politician.
  13. Actually, Domino, the accuracy of these drownings stories have been questioned. Not that they didn't occur at all, but that their scale has been vastly exagerated. Most of the Trebizond Armenians who died, died in the same way as their compatriots elsewhere - the usual "deportations" ending in massacres. Steve
  14. bellthecat

    Two Extremes

    Of course, why would us Aquarians bother wanting to control any of those lesser, non-Aquarian, mortals
  15. bellthecat

    Graphic Artist

    Domino, it looks like a plucked chicken!
  16. "Language like biological species diverge with time," Gray said. I wonder. Maybe language is more like a virus. I tend to agree with Marr in his view that language belongs to the "superstructure" of a society. I.E., that it is a superficial and replaceable part of society, that a specific language is no more physically a part of one race of humans, than say, the latest ringtone is physically part of your mobile phone. Nairi - you seem to know about such things. What is the current status of Marr in the world of linguistics? http://www.virtualani.freeserve.co.uk/marr/index.htm
  17. And what makes you assume that all those people, all the way to Sochi and beyond, who all speak the same dialect all came from just two little valleys in north-eastern Turkey? You may be relying on Armenian linguists. I'm relying on common sense. What you are believing doesn't sound realistic. I don't know what you mean in point 2
  18. I think you are thinking to much about thoughts about thinking
  19. Why? Are you sure this is biological? Maybe it is lifestyle - men generally have to work physically harder, and tend to do more damage to themselves through smoking, drinking, violence, etc, and tend to get killed off a lot in wars that happen every few generations! If it were all to do with nature then you would think that men should live longer than women since post-menopausal woman have, in an evolutionary sense, no reason to still be alive because they are just a waste of resources.
  20. But, unfortunately for us men, that "truly little thing" is attached to a woman - a creature that is so complex that it is impossible to ever understand .
  21. Ho hum... that's a new one! So you are saying that one lot of people called another lot of people by a particular name because they spoke like yet another lot of people. How did the native populations of Abkhazia know what the Hemshin dialect sounded like? Do you know what a Breton dialect sounds like, or a Provence dialect, or a Langedoc dialect. I bet you don't - to you they will all just be French! What makes the Abkhazi any different, what gave them such a skill in linguistics? I think you are cherry-picking your facts in order to fit then into a pre-existing concept. Until I hear a better explanation I will stick to my asumption that "Hamshenahayer" is used in Abkhazia in the same broad way that "Laz" is used in Turkey. Also, the Black Sea region of Turkey is the most economically developed in Turkey after of the greater Istanbul region. And it has been like that since the 1930s and the advent of commercial tea production. It is a very wealthy area. For this reason, there has been little out migration except to Istanbul and areas near to Istanbul. The same was true in late Ottoman times - but then it was because population movement was restricted by the state. (The Adapazar Hemshinli are an exception, of course, since those settlements are very old.)
  22. No Hagopn - it is you who do not know what you are talking about! Unlike you, I have been to the areas in question, and explored them in depth. Stop talking nonsence about there being Hemshinli in Adana or Mersin - there may be a few hundred but not more than that. And stop your similar nonsence about "economic stagnation". They are leaving the villages for the same reason that villages throughout Europe get depopulated - life is easier in the cities. They are leaving because there is NOT economic stagnation. I was fortunate to have spoken to the probably last living Armenian who lived in pre-1915 Adapazar, near to the Hemshinli villages there. He confirmed that they were all Muslim, but were still recognised as Armenian by the local Christian Armenains.
  23. I also know that (hence my stress that I was refering only to Turkey) - but I also don't know much more. Though I do not think they migrated from the current Hemshin valleys, which were completely Muslim by the 19th century. Perhaps they originated from the separate community of Hemshinli who live in the hills to the east of Borcka. Nor does the fact that Armenians living along black sea are called hamshenahayer mean that they actually came from Hamshen. In Turkey, in popular language, anyone from the Black sea is called "Laz" but 90 percent are actually not Laz. So maybe "hamshenahayer" simply refers to any Armenian who migrated from north-eastern Turkey to Abkhazia. But I don't know for certain.
  24. There can't be "Christian Hemshinli" since, by definition, a Hemshinli is a Muslim Armenian. If a Hemshinli was a Christian then he would be an Armenian. (I'm obviously talking about the pre-1915 situation here). Any Christian Hemshinli that exist today would be Christian purely as a result of individual personal conversion - and not as a result of any direct cultural or ethnic influences. Where (in Turkey, I have only ever been talking about Turkey) do the Christian Hemshinli that you speak of live? If a valley system can only physically support 6000 to 10000 people then not even Soviet propaganda is going to make it support 100 times that amount. Even allowing for a century or more of economic migration, (and those migrants doing a hell of a lot of breeding and all their descendants still retaining a Hemshin ethnic identity) a figure of 1.5 million is more than fantastical - it is laughable. The 5 million figure for the Laz is also crazy. What on earth was the Russian purpose in producing such inflated figures? Modern Turkish population figures are accurate - but I don't think they record minorities like Laz or Hemshinli. The Hemshinli didn't migrate from Caucasia - they have been living where they are living now for at least 1000 years. The Laz did migrate from the Caucasus, but that was a long time ago (can't remember exactly right now - 800 years ago?). Some Hemshinli from Turkey migrated TO the Caucasus during the end of the 19th century, for economic reasons.
  25. ...and the adult population (up in the valleys) would have been about the same size as the present day. Well, maybe that would have been true until 10 or 15 years ago - there has been a lot of recent depopulation due to people moving to the cities. My 15,000 figure came from Turkish books - so that too is probably less now, since population statistics are always out of date. Actually, given the physical size of the settlements, I think maybe 6,000 to 8,000 is a better estimate for those still living in their original homeland.
×
×
  • Create New...