Jump to content

bellthecat

Banned
  • Posts

    1,641
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by bellthecat

  1. Uzungöl. Go there? - no thanks! Full of cretin tourists, both foreign and Turk, on their daytrips from Trabzon; that mosque sitting by the lakeside like an ugly cancer spot; litter everywhere. The worst thing about uglyness is when you look upon uglyness and know that it was one beautiful.
  2. I'm in a picture posting mood, so I was going to post some old photos of the place, from the 19th century. But where has the "file attachments" option gone?
  3. And the last. "Starving, dying children. Erivan."
  4. And yet another. The caption seems to say "Biscuit distribution entering Armenia".
  5. I spotted these on ebay a few months ago. Slides of Howard Heinz's journey to Armenia (in 1920?). Though Teresa Heinz, wife of Kerry, doesn't have a direct connection since she married into the Heinz family (her first husband, John Heinz, died in a plane crash).
  6. Oh, there is a house in Mimarsinan that is described as "Mimar Sinan's House" in a booklet published by the Kayseri tourist bureau. But I couldn't locate the house when I was there. Couldn't have been his actual house anyway since it looked like a house from the 19th century!
  7. Could have been something for April 1st! Conscript armies have had their day. But I've found it amusing that some American reporters refer to the US army as a "volunteer army". I don't thing any soldier actually volunteered to go to Iraq, and I don't thing anyone who didn't want to go to Iraq could volunteer to go somewhere else instead! They are a professional army with career soldiers, not a volunteer army.
  8. Hmm ...anyone think that part of the problem with Armenia is that independence came too easily, and too suddenly, after the collapse of the Soviet Union?
  9. You have gone far past the starting stages of tyranny when that sort of thing happens. It all sounds very sad, after all - democracy and justice shouldn't be that hard to get right in a small country, where everyone knows everyone else, and where there are no troublesome minorities or influential outside powers. Ah well, it's their country, let them sort it out.
  10. If the AGBU does not have the legal rights to dispose of the school then what is the problem? Who is going to buy the property if the legal status of the ownership is in dispute? Why is the "Deed of Assignment" in French? Does that mean it does not come under Cypriot law (since Cyprus was part of the British empire in the 1920s). There was a school near where I live which the local government closed recently (amid much local oposition - but they closed it anyway). The petty politicians were all licking their lips at the prospect of spending the money they would get from the sale of the building and the grounds. Then someone discovered that they did not actually own the land, and that it had been gifted by a landowner over 150 years ago on the condidtion that a school was built on it. And if the school was removed for any reason then the ownership reverted to the descendents of the original landowner (who happened to be a local farmer). A very happy local farmer - since he is now able to reclaim property worth about a million pounds!
  11. Sinan was born in a small town a little to the southeast of Kayseri, that is now called Mimarsinan in his honour. I've been there - it's built right on the top of a small hill. You can look down from it and see the entire Kayseri plain (with the sprawling suburbs of Kayseri now almost reaching to the base of the hill). To the left is Talas (which before 1915 had a mixed Greek, Turkish, and Armenian population) and to the right was the well known Armenian settlement of Efkere. During Sinan's time the town is known to have been mostly Armenian - so there is a good probability that he also was Armenian. Also, I've read that there are petitions to the Sultan that have survived and that bear Sinan's name and the names of Armenians in Kayseri, which also suggests he was Armenian (since why else would he be acting on the behalf of those Armenians). These might be the petitions that Arpa mentioned. Why were the Armenians going to be exiled? I don't believe that there are any Armenians still living in Kayseri. True, you can sometimes meet with Turks who say there are some (mostly along the lines of "yes, I once had neighbours who were Armenian"), but in reality they are as extinct as (and, to those Turks, are as exotic as) the dodo. Edited - no threats please, Steve Steve
  12. Haha - funny Though easter bunny was originally an Easter hare. Wimpy rabbits might rap, but hares would rock.
  13. bellthecat

    Atheism

    Your analogy is about a meaningless as the black cat in a coalcellar analogy. He can infer/deny/believe whatever he damned well wants - but that doesn't mean that what he infers/denies/believes is in anyway true. Same for you.
  14. bellthecat

    Atheism

    No it doesn't. Music is either good or is not good - and it exists in that state without the listener. and the listener hasn't much to do with it (in Western music that is the case, anyway - music in non western cultures is, in terms of theory, little more advanced than a monkey banging two sticks together). I.e. music has to follow certain predetermined natural (not human) laws: melody, harmony, proportion, etc. Just like all the creatures on this planet, and the very planets themselves. Steve
  15. bellthecat

    Atheism

    Mreow - did I miss a catfight?
  16. bellthecat

    Atheism

    Religious sentiment makes for an observable fantasy, not an observable reality. True, most religion has at its core a desire to explain the unexplained. But that very rarely make for an explanation grounded in observation and almost never makes for one grounded in reality. When I said "observation" I mean scientific observation, looking at something without preconceptions. For example, I doubt that a soft-brained individual who believes in Noah and the Flood would ever consider properly looking at the distribution of dinosaur bones in layers of strata since he would assume they all came about as a result of deaths due to the Flood. That sort of religious outlook is about as valid as an "observation" as the ancient greeks believing that mushrooms were the seed of the Gods because they observed that they seemed to appear from nowhere. Steve
  17. Nothing more than that which I mentioned. But I also mentioned having to try and not to show too much curiosity about things, and I was not able to do things like make a sketch plan of the ruins for the same reason.
  18. bellthecat

    Atheism

    Evolution is grounded in observation, mousey, and whatever Popper did or did not say about deductivism, i'd be surprised if he said that the starting point had to be anything other than good observational procedures. So evolution is not a belief like religion, since most beliefs are not grounded in any form of observation.
  19. Really - useless at what? What do you think should have been done? What punishment do you think is appropriate for genocide? If you steal a million dollars you don't expect to get just a few years in prison, or obtaining wealth from crime will be seen to be more successful than ordinary work. If you kill someone with intent then your life is either removed from your society for a long period of time, or removed permanently. So, follow that thought, and the only punishment for genocide is for those that commit it to have genocide inflicted on themselves. Would you, or anyone, have the guts to do that? In Rwanda, the Hutu murderers when they fled the scene of their crimes could have been left to starve to death in their hundreds and thousands. Insted they were protected and fed by the UN and other NGOs. And then they were encouraged to return to the country where they commited that genocide, and thus profit from it. So genocide works. But it isn't punishment, or education, that will stop genocide. I'll tell you why. These days someone will murder someone else maybe because they want the contents of their wallet, or because they are walking in the wrong neighbourhood, or even just because they don't like their face. These days almost no nation values their ethnicity and culture enough to go as far as starting a war to protect or expand on its territory. They all value money and consumer goods more.
  20. Well, actually it is spelt "Handut" because that is how I have spelt it, and how the English translation of the 1878 report spelt it! The "h" is pronounced in a rough, hard way, like "kh". I doubt that it has ever been written down in any Turkish book.
  21. Until you had mentioned it I had assumed that Handut was a male mame! (Maybe the English translation of the 1878 report made a mistake and mistranslated "queen" as "king"). But if it is it named after Khandout Khatoun then it is probably just called that in the same way that many fortified sites in Britain are associated with King Arthur. i.e. There wouldn't have been a real historical connection, but just the locals deciding on a legendery figure to associate with, and give meaning to, the otherwise unknown history of an old and abandoned place. But the name Kaput is interesting - I'm not actually sure that it is a corruption of the name Handut, if Handut is a real name as you suggest. Is the castle named after the river and valley, or is the the river and valley named after the castle? Kaput is similar to the Armenian word for "blue", isn't it? Which could describe the river. But if the castle's name actually comes from the Turkish word for cloak, which describes the castle's wall, then why is that name being used by Armenians as far back as the 13th century? Steve
×
×
  • Create New...