-
Posts
1,641 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Events
Gallery
Everything posted by bellthecat
-
So that's yet another "organ" we have to consult: as well as "heart feelings" and "head feelings", we've now got "gut feelings" :) (And then there is also that fourth "player" that vava mentioned!)
-
Apprehension, and maybe fear, would perhaps be more useful emotions for any American now to feel when travelling outside of America. Keep the shame and embarassment for within America.
-
Naw, follow your heart, if heart = emotions, and brain = cold calculating analysis. Love will never get anywhere if it is based on the latter.
-
Yes, sorry. And "regret" is both softer and less antagonistic - it is something that one feels on ones own accord, and is not, like shame, something that is forced upon someone.
-
Yes, that's possible, especially since he was a sort of hermit, living in a cave. The article about the monastery is by J. M. Thierry, in Revue des Études Arméniennes, Volume XI – 1975. He doen't give any explanation for the origin of the name, which is strange. And thats is why I had thought that it might be derived from the name of the saint, whose first name is also not given except as "Etienne". About the saint. The following isn't completely translated. Footnote 45 Saint Étienne, the son of Ter Housik of Artamet, acquired a widespread reputation for healing both during his life and after his death. His legendary biography is well known: his father, a priest named Housik, on returning from a journey, was informed that his wife had been captured by Infidels. After patient research, he found her in Tabriz, a slave of Bibi Hatun, the wife of an emir. This woman, who was a Christian in secret, agreed to free the poor wretch only on the condition that if, on their reunion, a son was born, the couple would promise him to the ecclesiastical state and that his first Mass was told his intention. (don't understand what that bit means in French! - steve). Actually, the spouses quickly had a son who, when young, went again to the convent of Argelan and was ordained as a priest. At his first Mass, as he got ready to receive communion, he had a terrifying vision. Before him stretched a sea of blood and, in the middle of the heavy waves, Bibi Hatun struggled and called for help. He finished the holy sacrifice in a great anxiety and refused to say the Mass henceforth because he was not able to, he affirmed, bear to see the view of this bloody sea. He still led an edifying life of asceticism and work, almost always in Argelan, except for a stay of 12 years in Erernavank (cf. infra) at the time of Moslem incursions into the region of Berkri. He died in Argelan in 1251 and was buried there (cf. "The Synaxaire of Ter Israel", trans. G. Bayan, PO, volume XVIII, p. 173-178; ADCHARIAN, Dictionary, op. cit., volume IV, p. 620-621).
-
Yes, it means "Apostle", doesn't it?
-
Now that I have translated the article I see that Argelan seems to be not the name of the person, but the place. But "Etienne" is not a personal name that would be used in Armenia would it? Unless the writer has converted "Stephanos" to "Etienne". Zenophobic French! Les couvents d'Argelan et de Saint-Étienne, fils de Ter Housik (Argelanivank' et Ter Huskan ordi vank') Le couvent supérieur ou d'Argelan se trouve au milieu d'un vaste alpage à environ 2100 m d'altitude; le couvent inférieur où Saint-Étienne est situe en contrebas, à 1950 m d'altitude, juste au pied de la falaise qui ceinture, à mi-hauteur, la montagne. On s'y rend assez facilement de Berkri en traversant à gué le Bendimahi çay et en s'élevant vivement sur les pentes rocheuses et herbeuses de l'Aksürek dag. On parvient en une heure au couvent inférieur et il faut encore presqu'autant pour atteindre le couvent supérieur. Le couvent a été maintes fois visité, mais seul Ostanikian en a donné une description passable. L'histoire des deux couvents est inséparable et ils furent, du reste, organiquement fusionnés. La date de fondation du couvent supérieur n'est pas connue, mais elle est certainement antérieure au XIIIe siècle, puisque saint Étienne, fils de Ter Housik y vint résider dans la première moitié de ce siècle 45. Comme il avait coutume de se recueillir dans une grotte en contrebas, il fut ensevelli, lors de sa mort en cet endroit et une modeste chapelle y fut édifiée. À partir de ce moment, le couvent (constitué donc par l'actuel monastère d'Argelan et par une petite chapelle funéraire) prit indifféremment le nom d'Argelanivank ou de Ter Houskan ordi vank. On y venait en pèlerinage pour accéder au tombeau du saint qui avait la réputation d'opérer de nombreux miracles. And my translation The convents of Argelan and Saint Etienne, son of Ter Housik (Argelanivank' and Ter Huskan ordi vank') The upper convent, or convent of Argelan, is located in the middle of a broad pasture at an altitude of about 2100 metres. The lower convent, or convent of Saint-Etienne, is situated lower down, at an altitude of 1950 metres, just at the foot of the cliff that encircles, at mid-height, the mountain. It can be reached easily enough from Berkri by crossing a ford on the Bendimahi çay and then rising quickly up the rocky and grassy slopes of the Aksürek dag. One arrives in one hour at the lower convent, and it takes nearly that much again to reach the upper convent. The convent has been visited many times, but only Ostanikian has given us a reasonable description of it. The histories of the two convents are inseparable and they were, moreover, organically merged. The date of the foundation of the upper convent is not known, but it is certainly earlier than the 13th century, since St. Etienne, son of Ter Housik came to reside there in the first half of that century 45. As he had a custom to meditate within a cave below the convent, after his death he was buried in that place and a modest chapel was built there. From that moment, the convent (then comprising the present monastery of Argelan and the small funerary chapel) became known alternatively as Argelanivank and Ter Houskan ordi vank. People came there in pilgrimage to reach the saint's tomb, which had the reputation of performing many miracles.
-
Huh, Thoth, you're the last person I'd be expecting to be citing the meanings of the word shame. The word I want Turks to start using is not, and never will be, shame. The word I want to hear is REGRET. That is still a feeling that has some sincerity behind it. And regret has a greater "depth" in time. The regret would not just be a regret for things that happened almost 90 years ago, but a regret for a loss that Turks and Turkey (as well as Armenia and Armenians) can still feel today if it is properly explained what has been lost. And this, its ability to be contemporary and inclusive, means that it is both more valuable, and more genuine, and more acceptable. All unlike that snivelling fraud called "shame". Just change that word's pronounciation from an "A" as in cane to an "A" as in apple to reach its real meaning today: a sham.
-
Is Argelan a personal name in Armenian, in use either now or historically? And what does it mean, and what is its western equivalent? I've been reading a French article about an Armenian monastery dedicated to a St. Argelan. The article also gives it the name "St. Etienne", which I thought might be the French equivalent. But is it? The name "Etienne" means "crowned one" and is the French form for Steven (which I didn't know!). But I thought that Steven in Armenian was Stephanos or similar. Or is that just the Greek equivalent of Steven, and it is a name that just happens to be used in Armenia rather than being specifically Armenian. I.E. is "Argelan" the Armenian equivalent of Steven? Or is it from another language? Steve
-
Don't know if this should be here or in the "for Sip" thread. Washington Post May 8-9 2004 A Sorry State The Artlessness Of the Apology By Tony Judt We live in the age of the public apology. When a crisis occurs or a scandal is exposed, the first instinct of many public figures today is to erupt in a torrent of remorse. From Bill Clinton's 1992 apology to his wife for his sexual infidelities to the notorious 1998 Oprah Winfrey show where guests apologized to people they had "hurt," saying sorry has become all the rage. On the Oprah show experts even offered tips on how to apologize. "Don't be afraid to apologize," the incomparable Ms. Winfrey advised on her Web site. "Apologizing to your child doesn't mean you lose." President Bush could have used a few such tips this month. Faced with the evidence of serial abuse of Iraqi prisoners by U.S. soldiers, Bush condemned, decried and regretted; but he didn't apologize for a week. In a world where victims -- real or presumptive -- demand not merely justice but penitence, the president's reluctance became a political issue in its own right. For the second time this spring the Bush administration was caught up in the media's passion for public contrition. In late March the public commission investigating security lapses before 9/11 was transformed into a daytime soap opera. Would Condoleezza Rice follow Richard Clarke's cue and offer a telegenic "sorry" for letting it all happen? How would she "look" if she did offer an all-points apology? And -- of even greater media interest -- how would she look if she didn't? Rice is a mediocre national security adviser but a good tactician. By refusing to express remorse ("I don't think that there is anyone who is not sorry for the terrible loss that these families endured," she told Ed Bradley on "60 Minutes," but she added, "the best thing that we can do for the future of this country is to focus on those who did this to us."), she paid a small price in the congeniality stakes while keeping journalists' attention firmly diverted from anything that mattered. It was Rice's present sentiments, rather than her past actions, that held center stage. We used to pay attention to what public figures did and what they thought. Now all we really want to know is how they feel. And everyone, even the president, enthusiastically obliges. Public apologies used to be a very serious matter -- that's why they were so uncommon. In the past, when faced with bad news, politicians would do anything rather than confess. Typically, they dissimulated. Rather than tell you how they felt about something unpleasant for which they might be held accountable, they just issued denials: "It never happened." Later, when denial was no longer possible, they downplayed the matter: "All right, it happened, but it wasn't as bad as you say." And then, later still, when the scale of the crime or scandal was clear to all, they would concede that, "Well, yes, it happened and it was every bit as bad as you say. But it's all so long ago -- why dredge up the past?" That is still the response in cultures where the public confession of failure or misbehavior carries heavy social penalties. In Japan, the wartime mistreatment of Chinese and Koreans is still mired in semi-denial and official mis-memory. Turkish authorities -- and many Turks -- shift uncomfortably between exculpatory re-description and outright denial when confronted with the massacre of the Armenians. Australia's leaders no longer deny the near-genocide of the Aborigines, but it is such old news that they refuse to dwell on it. Even where international pressure has made official "regrets" and restitution unavoidable, as in the case of the Holocaust, heartfelt official remorse is rare -- the recent apology by President Alexander Kwasniewski for his countrymen's part in the destruction of their Jewish neighbors was all the more effective for being unprecedented in Poland. The public apology, in short, is not a universal political response to bad news. But in the United States, where virtually everyone (except the 43rd president) apologizes at the first opportunity, it has a very different resonance. This does seem to be a distinctively American development. True, Tony Blair also indulges in it, but then in his well-advertised religiosity and his propensity to wax moralistic, Blair is the most "American" prime minister in modern British history. He is also of an age with Bill Clinton, Al Gore, George W. Bush and other baby boomers molded by the pedagogical revolution of the '60s and the narcissistic preoccupations of the era. For this generation of political leaders -- and followers -- it has always been important to have the right sort of feelings and to display them copiously. Thus (according to his spokesman) President Bush -- hitherto seemingly immune to the sensibilities of his generation -- feels sorry for the "pain caused" by the publication of pictures and reports of American soldiers torturing Iraqis. In Bush's own words he feels "bad" about what happened, "sorry for the humiliation" of Iraqi prisoners. He might not say that he exactly "feels their pain" -- that is a more distinctively Clintonian sentiment -- but it is the same general idea: Saying "sorry" makes it better. The victim feels better and so does the perpetrator -- indeed, you score a triple: You are good, you do good and you feel good. The preferred use of sorry, however, is in the formulation "I'm sorry that such and such happened," distancing the speaker from any connection to the events, thereby relieving the speaker of any need for self-examination. But in any case, in its transition from private relations to public affairs, the apology encounters some intriguing paradoxes. In the first place, it is self-undermining. As anyone knows who has ever dealt with young children, saying "sorry" has a dual purpose: It concedes guilt and exculpates the perpetrator. "I said I'm sorry -- why are you still upset?" Thus President Bush undoubtedly hopes that by saying how sorry he feels that his army has disgraced itself he can speedily put the affair behind him. But in this he is surely mistaken. In our age of instant remorse the currency of penitence has been hyperinflated and has lost almost all its value. Most of those who heard the president expressing his regrets, above all the Arab and Muslim audience to which they were primarily directed, will have echoed the celebrated response of Mandy Rice-Davies at the height of the Christine Keeler affair in Swinging London, when Lord Astor denied under oath that he had been involved with her: "Well, he would say that, wouldn't he?" Moreover, while the president's regrets are doubtless heartfelt, his skeptical international audience is likely to reflect that he is no less "sorry" that the news leaked out. He may also come to rue the carefully qualified apologies offered by his subordinates: Maj. Gen. Geoffrey Miller, in charge of Abu Ghraib prison, first offered his apologies and then spent some time explaining that what he was referring to were the "illegal or unauthorized acts" of "a small number of soldiers." Brig. Gen. Mark Kimmitt, the U.S. army spokesman in Iraq, similarly qualified his expression of regrets -- "a small number of soldiers doing the wrong thing." Such grudging, formulaic repentance (alleged sodomy "with a chemical light and perhaps a broomstick" is now "the wrong thing"?) merely calls attention to its own inadequacy -- and invites charges of bad faith. So what is a democratic leader to do? If you apologize too soon it rings false -- particularly to foreign audiences unfamiliar with the American cult of contrition. But if you stay silent it suggests callous indifference or a coverup. The crimes in Abu Ghraib and elsewhere are not comparable to My Lai in Vietnam or other atrocities committed in the heat of battle by terrified GIs and inadequate officers. They were born of that arrant indifference to laws, regulations, rights and rules that has characterized this administration from the outset, and that was bound, sooner or later, to percolate down to the sergeants and mercenaries who do the dirty work. Thus Bush had no option but to acknowledge immediately that terrible things had been done in Iraq -- and he would be wise to make sure that he has been told and is telling the whole story. But a public expression of his pain and sorrow will no longer suffice. What is missing in the modern American cult of "sorry" is any sense of responsibility. Whether it concerns the incompetence of the security apparatus before 9/11, a misguided and failed imperial adventure, the mismanagement and degradation of the army, or the criminal behavior of Americans in Iraq, everyone feels "bad" and everyone expresses "regret." But until Defense Secretary Donald H. Rumsfeld testified on Friday, no one even hinted at feeling "responsible." According to Bush (interviewed on the U.S.-funded Al Hurra Arabic language television network), "We believe in transparency, because we're a free society. That's what free societies do. If there's a problem, they address those problems in a forthright, upfront manner." Except, of course, we don't. For in the very next sentence, Bush assures his interlocutor that "I've got confidence in the secretary of defense, and I've got confidence in the commanders on the ground . . . because they and our troops are doing great work on behalf of the Iraqi people." So the commanders are off the hook. Meanwhile the New York Times (on May 6) carries a touching little story about the confused and helpless GIs who actually did the torturing, claiming that they were following orders/ had no orders/ misunderstood those orders/ were themselves misunderstood/ suffered great stress at the time/ are suffering even greater stress now -- and so forth. Everyone is sorry "it" happened. But unless its leaders can get beyond that sanctimonious and self-serving response, the United States is in deep trouble. If Rumsfeld (who on Friday offered his "deepest apology"), Deputy Defense Secretary Paul D. Wolfowitz or Joint Chiefs Chairman Richard B. Myers were honorable men they would resign in shame. But they are not. If Bush were of presidential caliber he would have sacked them by now -- and taken full personal responsibility for their incompetence. But wherever the buck stops these days, it surely is not on the president's desk. Yet nothing short of such an old-fashioned assumption of duty can now retrieve America's standing in the community of nations. To the rest of the world Bush's apologies are mere exercises in damage control. The same president who spoke of leading God's crusade against Evil and who basked in the self-congratulatory aura of his invincible warriors will have difficulty convincing the rest of humanity that he really cares about a few brutalized Arabs. Given the president's simultaneous and reiterated insistence that neither he nor his staff have done anything wrong and that there is nothing to change in his policies or goals, who will take seriously such an apology, extracted in extremis? Like confessions obtained under torture, it is worthless. As recent events have shown, America under Bush can still debase and humiliate its enemies. But it has lost the respect of its friends -- and it is fast losing respect for itself. Now that is something to feel sorry about.
-
They were not "civilians" - the US government has refused to say what they were doing in Iraq, or why they were in the area where they were killed. I.e. they were probably undercover US agents, either military or cia, and were thus as legitimate a target as anyone in uniform.
-
What? I thought everyone from age 1 to 100 instinctively makes things like rings or aeroplanes or bells or stick-animals from their aluminium "tin-foil" chocolate wrappings. And how many corny films have the hero useing foil to complete an electrical circuit to diffuse the bomb and save the day. But I never did get the significance of the tin-foil animals in "Blade-Runner". Enlighten me anyone?
-
I suppose, in fairness to him, his words might not be being quoted exactly, or since English is not (I presume) his native language he might not be correctly saying what he is trying to express. But, if that is not the case, then I agree with you.
-
But foil is also cool because you can make pretty things out of it!
-
Yes, sorry, that's actually what I meant to say , and that the roast whatsit has a very high capacity for heat (i.e. energy) storage.
-
The notion of race was central to almost everything that happened in Turkey during the final years of the Ottoman Empire. At the empire began to go though its final decades Turkish intellectuals, both reputable and disreputable, were trying to work out exactly what it meant to be a "Turk" rather than a "Muslim" or an "Osmanli", and how that Turkishness could be encouraged to grow. Maybe a major failing of Armenians was not realising that they no longer lived in the Ottoman Empire - because it was dead in everything but name.
-
Domino - "interrogation" itself is ill-treatment. And is illegal under the Geneva convention since all any prisoner in wartime needs to give is his name.
-
Haha! You have just made my point. There is no such thing as "college initiations" in Britain or Europe, even after decades of Hollywood films showing it. It is a particular "feature" of North American culture, especially American. And while the desired end result of the abusers in colleges or prisons might be different, their ability to commit the abuse without any thought that it might be morally wrong is exactly the same.
-
Because aluminium is a very bad conductor of heat. And your roast chicken is not.
-
Though of course similar and far worse things did happen in prison camps run by the Japanese, or in camps for Russian prisoners, or in concentration camps. That is because they were all run on the ideological basis that those imprisoned were considered to be subhuman. Which will also be the reason for the abuses in the prisons in Iraq, and all the things that are going on there and the prisons in Afghanistan and Cuba.
-
You are wrong. During WW2 I don't recall anything like this happening in POW camps in Nazi Germany, or in Britain or Canada or America. The problem has not arisen because of war, the problem has arisen because of the culture that initiated that war. If there is something rotten at the heart of America's occupying forces in Iraq then it is because there is something rotten at the heart of the American Establishment.
-
Your words could have come from a typical Turkish about "the so-called Armenian genocide". The usual "it was war, people die during war, lots of other people died as well as Armenians, why are you constantly going on and on about it, it is just used as an excuse for ASALA terrorists, etc, etc".
-
Conflict Between Armenians And Ajarians In Georgia
bellthecat replied to MosJan's topic in International
About half are, or at least are nominally Muslim after 70 odd years of communism. They are mostly descended from Muslim Abkhazians who migrated south when Russia conquered Abkhazia and then found themselves back within the Russian empire after 1877. (This is probably an oversimplification, but everything is an oversimplification where it concerns ethnicity in the Caucasus!) -
Because it is so grovellingly pathetic that not only does it appear that he has some sort of personality problem, but it is so extreme that nobody in Turkey would wish to associate with such a person's statements. It is the attitudes of the current Turkish Establishment and their supporters that he should be ashamed of, because they are acting in the name of Turks today. But maybe he thinks it safer to be ashamed of long-dead individuals and organisations.
-
Wrong - this figure, and I've seen a lower figure elsewhere, is of civilian deaths that are not obviously justified (i.e. those killed were not behaving in any sort of a hostile way). Most were not in custody when killed (none were, if you believe Labour party spin). I'd guess the American figure, would be into the 1000s if you count those civilians killed as a result of indiscriminate US bombing and shooting in Falluja and elsewhere.
