Jump to content

gamavor

Members
  • Posts

    5,027
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    176

Everything posted by gamavor

  1. Nope! Read the second paragraph carefuly! I didn't want to circumcise too much the whole article.
  2. Eve, circumcision has never been practiced in Europe, except the Albion, if you of course consider them European! Even on the British Islands it was not very popular, - maybe only among certain Scottish merchants who were in close contact with the Jews. Again, this barbaric practice is foreign to our culture. It has never been part of the Armenian culture and will never be, because it is wrong. I can give you thousands of reasons, but if someone believes that humans were conceived in likeness of God, than who gives us the right to alter his beautiful invention? http://www.cirp.org/library/legal/ Circumcision: Legal issues This page indexes legal material relevant to the performance of male circumcision. Documents are indexed in chronological order of publication. Introduction The English-speaking nations share the English language, the common law, and male circumcision as part of their history and culture since the late 19th century. This page incorporates relevant legal reference material from the several English-speaking nations. Some definitions: A "botched" circumcision is one that is poorly done and has obvious unexpected results. "Wrongful circumcision" is circumcision done without valid informed consent. Botched circumcision and wrongful circumcision constitute malpractice. Prior to 1984, circumcision law was included under malpractice law: Doctors who "botched" circumcisions could only be sued for failing to adhere to the "standard of care."3,4,5 There were, however, a number of circumcision malpractice cases that succeeded on these grounds. Starting in 1984, academics began to apply general principles of health care law and medical ethics to examine the legality of male circumcision. Children are legally regarded as incompetent persons who are unable to give consent. These principles imply that circumcision of male children (or any other operation done under proxy consent), when unnecessary and performed for other than express therapeutic purposes, may not be legal regardless of the standard of care. There are no valid medical indications for male circumcision in the neonatal period; * therefore routine male neonatal circumcision constitutes a non-therapeutic procedure — and now the American Medical Association has identified male neonatal circumcision as a non-therapeutic procedure in its policy statement. All persons enjoy a general right to bodily integrity. This has been true from at least as far back as the time of Blackstone; it has been affirmed by the United States Supreme Court in Union Pacific Railway Company v. Botsford, 141 U.S. 250 (1891), and reaffirmed in Planned Parenthood v. Casey, 505 U.S. 833 (1992). Male neonatal non-therapeutic circumcision removes healthy functional tissue and is viewed by many as an infringement upon the right to bodily integrity. Somerville discussed the legal distinction between therapeutic and non-therapeutic procedures and between operations on competent and incompetent people in a 1980 paper. William E. Brigman used new medical evidence to argue that circumcision is child abuse, and discussed possible legal remedies.8 Recent medical articles have documented the actual injury of circumcision, making it possible for a knowledgable attorney to win damages for wrongful circumcision. Recent legal commentary in the several nations has pointed out numerous legal problems with the practice of circumcision of male children in general, even when done with parental consent and not botched. There is increasing concern that (forcible) child circumcision is a violation of numerous provisions of international human rights law.17,18,23 Legal writers in the several English-speaking nations have been expressing concern in law review articles.6,7,8,9,23,24,25,26,27 Interpreting the legal status of circumcision objectively is difficult, owing to the cultural background and long history of the practice. A 1961 New York case (Kalina vs General Hospital of the City of Syracuse (100 NYS2d 226, 18 A.D.2d 757 (1962)) classifies circumcision as an assault; furthermore, it finds that the assaulted child has a right of recovery.2,3,5 A 1980s California case questioned the power of parents in California to consent to surgical procedures (in this case male circumcision) which had no medical purpose.10 Exceptionally, California statute law allows parents to consent to surgical procedures "regardless of purpose." The right of parents in that state to consent to male circumcision was upheld by the appellate court on that narrow ground while ignoring other applicable law. The California Supreme Court refused to hear the appeal. Apparently, the courts were not yet ready to address the issue. A case on circumcision (Re "J") has been decided in the United Kingdom. The court determined that circumcision is not in the best interest of the child concerned. Lynn E. Lebit, in a 1992 article,11 stressed the need for courts to protect the rights of minors and other legally incompetent persons. The power of parental proxy consent is much more limited than that of adult personal consent. There has been a general trend in society and in the courts to accord more recognition to the rights of minors, rights that exist independently of their parents.11,14 It is not at all clear that parental consent to the removal of healthy functional tissue from the body of an incompetent minor child is valid: If parental proxy consent to non-therapeutic circumcision of minor children were to be found to be invalid or vitiated, then almost all circumcisions of minor children are wrongful circumcisions. The Law Reform Commission of Queensland (Australia) published a research paper on the lawfulness of male circumcision in 1993. 12 The paper cited the Australian High Court case of Secretary, Department of Health and Community Services v JWB and SMB (1992) 175 CLR 218 and concluded that male circumcision was unlawful; but failed to propose further action which would enforce the rights of children. Solicitor Christopher P. Price, M.A., prepared a significant brief for the Law Commission of England and Wales17. A condensed version was later published by the Bulletin of Medical Ethics.18 In 1997, Margaret A. Somerville, founder and director of the McGill Center for Medicine, Ethics and Law in Montréal, characterized male circumcision as "technically criminal assault" under the Canadian criminal code. Chessler published a major review of the circumcision issues in the Buffalo Law Review.24 Povenmire argues that any parental rights should be subordinated to the child's right to bodily integrity; a court order should be required before the forcible circumcision of a child is allowed.25 Smith of the Netherlands Institute of Human Rights has published a report on the human rights violations inherent in neonatal male circumcision.26 Two papers that were published in early 1999 are relevant, in that they challenge the validity of parental consent and the lawfulness of male neonatal circumcision as it is customarily performed in the United States and several other English-speaking nations.27,29: Price elaborated the distinctions between therapeutic and non-therapeutic procedures.29 Van Howe, Svoboda, Dwyer, and Price maintain that parents do not have the right to consent to the removal of healthy, functional tissue from a healthy child, and therefore, physicians who continue to perform circumcisions, not only are in violation of law, but undertake appreciable legal risks as all neonatal non-therapeutic circumcisions are unconsented injuries.27 The American Academy of Pediatrics, in a recent circumcision policy statement, declared circumcision to be non-essential to child health; male circumcision must now be viewed in an entirely different light legally from that of an essential and necessary procedure. Boyle, Svoboda, Price, and Turner argue that non-therapeutic circumcision of healthy boys is criminal assault, and that legal action is needed to protect boys from this kind of assault.33 The American Medical Association has issued a statement on neonatal circumcision in which it defines neonatal male circumcision as a non-therapeutic procedure Hodges reports on the legal protection given to the prepuce in the ancient world.37 Martin comments on changing standards regarding informed consent in cases of intersexed children. Her comments also appear to be applicable to informed consent for circumcision.38 As of this writing, however, no court in any jurisdiction (to our knowledge) has considered forcible involuntary male circumcision to fall under existing laws against assault. This means that, for the moment, the legality of male circumcision is in a gray area. This situation seems destined to change as lawyers who are interested in the welfare of children are increasingly concerned about the lack of resolution of the legal status of male child circumcision. Recently, an 18-year-old man brought a lawsuit in New York against the doctor who neonatally circumcised him and the hospital in which the circumcision was carried out. --George Hill State Medical Boards Persons who believe a medical doctor has been negligent, or otherwise has behaved improperly or in an unethical fashion in relation to the circumcision of male infants, may wish to file a suit against a medical doctor and/or a hospital, especially if a person has been seriously injured. If this is the case, one should consult appropriate knowledgeable legal counsel. If the complaint does not involve an actual injury, persons may wish to report the behavior to the appropriate medical licensing board for appropriate disciplinary action. The regulation of medical practice is a function of state government in the USA. The Federation of State Medical Boards, a federation of 69 member boards, maintains a website with a listing of the addresses of the various state medical boards. Doctors who behave in an unethical or unlawful fashion should be reported to the appropriate state board for disciplinary action. This is for the benefit of the medical profession and the protection of the public. These actions may also be the subject of litigation especially if the malpractice results in personal injury. One should consult appropriate knowledgable counsel. In the case of male circumcision, such actions as Provision of false medical information to the public solicitation for surgery promotion of unnecessary circumcision use of coercion to obtain consent failure to provide complete and accurate informed consent, failure to provide information on conservative alternatives to male circumcision including no circumcision, performance of circumcision without consent, failure to use appropriate analgesia, delegation of the practice of medicine to an unlicensed individual, and negligent performance of circumcision which results in a botched circumcision are examples of misbehavior which should be reported to the appropriate state board. Intact boys are frequently the subject of maltreatment by ill-trained physicians. Premature forcible retraction of the foreskin is injurious to the boy and is contraindicated. It is actionable malpractice. It should also be reported to the State Medical Board. Information for the United Kingdom The General Medical Council receives complaints and regulates the practice of medicine in the United Kingdom. Complaints should be sent to: General Medical Council 178-202 Great Portland Street LONDON W1N 6JE Tel 0171 580 7642 Fax 0171 915 3641 More here:http://www.cirp.org/library/disease/HIV/nicoll/ http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/europe/1572483.stm
  3. EVEN AS Mia Hamm, Kristine Lilly, Julie Foudy, and the rest of the US Women's National Soccer Team compete to defend their Woman's World Cup title tomorrow night in a semifinal match against Germany in Portland, Ore., there is a sense in which they have already lost. On Sept. 15, six days before the opening game of the 2003 World Cup, the Women's United Soccer Association announced that it was folding after three years of operation. The WUSA, conceived in the delirious aftermath of the 1999 World Cup's dramatic conclusion, when the United States defeated China on penalty kicks in front of 90,000 screaming fans in the Rose Bowl, was the first fully professional women's soccer league in this country. Because it included all of America's best players, plus many of the top international players, the WUSA instantly became the premier women's soccer league in the world. ADVERTISEMENT Yet after three years of declining ticket sales and television ratings, the league ownership determined that there was insufficient sponsorship interest to allow the league to become profitable in the foreseeable future, and so they scuttled operations. There simply was not enough revenue to justify sustaining the enterprise. The end of the WUSA is a tragedy. Let's start with the WUSA players participating in the World Cup; there is a sense, as I say, in which they have already lost. But this is not a loss of their own making. The players in the WUSA did everything they could to build the fledgling league into a viable entity. Endless promotional and public relations work. Charity work in their communities. They worked hard to serve as role models for young girls and as ambassadors of the sport. They took pay cuts. Consider that last act: They took pay cuts for the good of the league. In what other sport on the American landscape is it possible even to imagine star players taking pay cuts for the benefit of the larger good? This alone would have made preserving the WUSA a worthwhile endeavor, an antidote to the money-is-everything culture that has suffused American sports. I hope this answers your question!
  4. Dude, have you ever heard of freedom of consciousness and freedom of religious practices?
  5. gamavor

    New War?

    Let them try! Here is who they have to deal with! http://www.azator.gr/archive/2004/photos/zoravarjoutiun_5_12_8_04.jpg http://www.azator.gr/archive/2004/photos/zoravarjoutiun_2_12_8_04.jpg http://www.azator.gr/archive/2004/photos/zoravarjoutiun_1_12_8_04.jpg http://www.azator.gr/archive/2004/photos/Ohanian_Seyran_12_8_04.jpg http://www.azator.gr/archive/2004/photos/Ghougasian_Sarksian_12_8_04.jpg http://www.azator.gr/
  6. Well, I think they are good. Seriously. What I think is what I always hope for....namely, Armenians from Armenia and Russian Diaspora should set the tunes and not vice-verse. That should be the case not only when it comes to music but for many other things too. I think Armenians from Armenia are much more progressive (younger generation) than the Diaspora in general. I only wish to see the same in the ecnonomical sphere too. Diasporans except some in Europe, Argentina and few in Lebanon are ... This is according to my observations. Edited by Sasun
  7. I'm afraid that most of us are aware of all these facts, which one more time proves how pathetic Armenians are! Sorry, my friend your web page is far from being nice. It is full of mistakes and omissions and simply desperate. If anybody uses illiterate turks to show to the world how great 'WE' are than nothing good expects us. Your efforts are commendable, your performance sucks. Sorry once again.
  8. Amerikanski... do you remember the first time when I called you IDIOT! Well, just to let you know that nothing has changed since then...
  9. They sound freshly punkish! You can download here more: http://hetq.nm.ru/audio.html
  10. gamavor

    New War?

    Yes Skhara, I agree and the article is very interesting indeed. The Azeris hysteria is nothing but well orchestrated attempt from Washington to scare off Armenians (as if they don't know us! ). On the other hand, what is at stake is to sell out Russian interests in the region. If not anything else, Armenia is blessed with excellent diplomacy - Oskanian is doing outstanding job. Everything in life comes with a "little" price tag.
  11. WoW, this guy is the perfect American. As a side note, the destiny of Meshhetian Turks is one of great sorrow and cruelty of the Stalin regime. What is more interesting is that genetically they have very little in common with the turks. They are simply Islamized Georgians, who were outcasted from the Georgian society.
  12. gamavor

    New War?

    Highly unlikely! In case of resumed hostilities Azeris can only rely on American sponsored Talibans, Chechen terrorist, and Turkish military advisers. None of the great players in the region wants to get 'personal', because that would lead to unpleasant encounter with a hungry Bear. And as you know such meetings are not very pleasant. If Azeris made even one move that would be in our advantage - our dream can finally become true. From Caspian to Black and from Black to Meditereanean. Tigrani HAIK!
  13. Naircho, isn't spelling part of the grammar?
  14. Yeah Armen, Sex and Football are the two things that I cannot watch. I would rather participate!!! BTW, Domino I have an original solution to your problem. Check this out: http://hyeforum.com/index.php?showtopic=7067
  15. gamavor

    Impressions Of The Day

    Azat you are hired.....however Remember: Hippoglossus stenolepis (this is latin for Halibut ) white meet - white wine!!!
  16. For more detailed info read this: http://www.travelmag.co.uk/printer_611.shtml
  17. Chalga in Bulgaria, partly Macedonia and Yougoslavia. Kiochek is turkish but understandable everywhere I guess! Just a small sample: http://pop-folk-chalga-music.bulgariancds.com/ This one is Anti-Chalga: http://chalgafun.hit.bg/site/chalgafun.htm This is a Serbian site where you can find.....even Armenian music: http://www.dingdingdingding.com/dir/World/...metnost/Muzika/ Enjoy if you can!
  18. Most of them seem to be pre-historic, while others might be associated with ancient history. Anyway the site is very interesting and if somebody can provide more info I would appreciate it. Some of them have something very disturbing in common with the discussions that are going on here, - like this one: http://www.arminco.com/hayknet/a9.gif or, What is an Armenian: http://www.arminco.com/hayknet/43.gif http://www.arminco.com/hayknet/naskal.htm
  19. Can I summarize this topic with few words? Circumcised men are missing something that they can never have back. They are missing much more in terms of sensuality that they can never regain. I feel pity about them and I wish that parents who are going to subject their kids to this truly barbaric ritual should think twice. Circumcision is alien to our culture and civilization. Believe me, if it was something good we would have been among the first to implement it.
  20. Yes, they said they are going for the Olympics. Hmm...Btw they won first place at AGBU games which was piece of cake for them, there was barely any competition.
  21. http://www.armnoc.am/photo/27.jpg Albert Azarian - the legendary champion is leading the Armenian delegation. I just don't understand why is he so serious. PS: I haven't seen in the list of Armenian atlets the Badmington team. I met them in Albena and they said they are going to Greece too.
  22. Time and again, so-called rabiz as I said earlier is not only an Armenian phenomenon. Most of Eastern Europe is drowned with this crap under different names. Chalga, kiochek, rabiz...I'm telling you if you do not listen the words it is all the same everywhere. This is unfortunately the contemporary pop culture in these countries. It has the same effect as the Country to USA. I thing zurna and dhol are only few of the traditional Armenian instruments which are shared by our neighbours too. When talking about traditional Armenian music what comes to mind is Duduk, naturaly(btw, the very same Armeniazed Galatians in Western Armenian had in their folkloric arsenal bagpipes) and I think Gomidas rather influenced his teachers than vice-verse, since his presentation of the Armenian folkloric tunes to West Europeans was his treasure. In short, listen Bambir. You won't regret a second of their music.
×
×
  • Create New...