Jump to content

Sasun

Members
  • Posts

    5,522
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    2

Everything posted by Sasun

  1. I really don't know what you have in mind, but it doesn't matter. You are judging unspecified religions for not quite specific things, I find it hard to answer in any way. When your time comes you will be asked a question why you were judging, and if you are falsely accusing then it is a clear sin and you will have to have an answer for that. If by rest you mean inner peace then I agree. I will add that I find inner peace not only in Jesus Christ's path and teachings but also other paths and prophets. You better ask Ludwig, he said you have a list of wrongdoings or crimes by religious minorities (which you obviously don't have) and I wanted to see that list. I don't know the truth, I only know pieces and glimpses of it and I try to form my opinions on the everlasting truth to the best of my ability. It seems that we are in the same boat more or less, however I don't judge your religion, while you judge all religions except for yours.
  2. I really don't want to get into theological debates, I am perfectly fine with what you believe in, it is up to you. I can't say that I disagree entirely, but I disagree with you on several fundamental things. You say so, and I could use the same words and say you know, there are other prophets that are like Jesus Christ and they manifest the same thing as Jesus Christ did. So basically I disagree, Jesus Christ and his path is a sure way of salvation, but not the only way. Before Jesus Christ there were other paths which still exist and also lead to salvation. I will leave it at that, because obviously you don't believe in that, just do your best to achieve the truth. And just a reminder, it doesn't matter how well you know theologies, how often you go to a church, and how eagerly you practice religious ceremonies. If you fail to practice righeousness, tolerance and forgiveness nothing will bribe God to give you a favor.
  3. And what religion would that be? Again, I am talking about bona fide religions, not some obscure groups, please don't imply that I am defending wrong religions. The question here concerns the groups mentioned in the original article, none of which is about killing people. So can't I say that you are misinterpreting the Bible and my way of understanding is the original Christianity and not yours? Let me see that list. In my opinion your doctrines are far away from the Christ, therefore I don't think you know Christ and can tell what deviation could mean. However, I leave it entirely up to you, it is none of my business what doctrines you have. I tolerate your views and you. It is not me that is intolerant.
  4. Yes, definitely. Nothing prevents us to do the same as regards to others, in this particular case, you can say look this guy did this bad thing, I do not approve of it, it is evil, etc... but what is happening is religious minorities are not accepted as a normal part of a society, not because they did something wrong as a whole, but because of prejudice and bigotry. If some members of the path did something wrong factually then they can be blamed just like anyone else, but not their particular path of faith. For example, if some Catholic priests did wrong things then they get blamed individually, not the Catholic church as a whole. I did not say that Christ was cool with everything. He would teach and preach but also forgive those even who killed him. Whatever he did was for the good of the sinner, sometimes kind words will lead to repentance and sometimes criticism. This way of correction depends on the individual, it depends on what the individual said or did, but not what path he belongs to.
  5. If that's the case we don't really need someone like that with fragile committment to the Armenian cause. But he seems like as interested as before. I mean, whether or not he gets arrested in 2005 does not have any relations to a study of history. An integral person would stick to the subject.
  6. No, I do not think that practicing other religions or any other Christian paths is wrong, morally or legally. I have no complaints about other religions, I don't mind their existence in Armenia or elsewhere. My first response to you was precisely because you were judging other religious groups. You said: "and they foget the church founded by the Apostles of Christ, and they forget the faith of 1,5 million martyrs not to mention all the others throughout our history, and they rebel against our Church deceived by opportunist western cults. Lord have mercy. " You are accusing them of rebellion and deception, all on theological grounds. There is nothing factual in what you say, it is all a matter of having a different faith and theology. Imagine if somebody accused you of rebellion and deception because they conclude so from their adopted theology. Now put yourself in the shoes of a Jehovah's witness who thinks he is faithfully practicing his religion and has faith in God just like you do, then imagine somebody is accusing you of deception and rebellion. Faith can be manifested in many ways and many religions. I see no treason really in any sense. I don't know what you mean. Fine, intolerant people need our prayers. But the question here is that some followers of the Armenian Apostolic church are not quite tolerant of religious minorities in Armenia, instead of offering prayers they are offerring harsh criticism and accuse them of things that they have not actually committed. For example, Jehovah's witnesses and other minorities are accused of being foreign agents with a covert agenda against the interests of Armenians. It's a problem because it is a cause of sectarian conflicts and separation. But do you know the truth? Oftentimes the same thing is called by different names. Other religions see the truth in Christ but they call it a different name. Before Jesus the person was born truth existed and was exactly the same as it has always been. Therefore, truth can be found not only in the person of Jesus, but in the Christhood that he realized and revealed to the humanity. That same Christhood has been revealed by other prophets in other religions. Therefore, one can approach the truth by practicing paths other than Christianity. The differences are only superficial, in essence all true religions (excluding man made artificial religions) have the same truths. In other words, yes, truth cannot exist outside of Christ but it can exist in and be manifested by other Christ-like individuals. When Jesus was saying he is the only truth he was not speaking as a human being, Jesus the son of a carpenter, but as Christ - something omnipresent and universal not bound just to the body of Jesus.
  7. It's a good news. I am not too clear about the motives of the government - why raise a big noise and negative publicity if in the end they are going to release. Or could it be that this will create a positive publicity? What was there to gain?
  8. Such words are bound to create animosity and separation. These people need not ask anyone what religion to pick, it is their choice, not the choice of the country. So if you are for unity of the nation such attitude is actually countreproductive to unity. Now that there is an Armenian statehood it maybe time for the Armenian church to be a spiritual guide for Armenians rather than a governing/social institution - something unnecessary for the church in Armenia. What are you suggesting here? To not allow religious minorities to have liberty? The same could be said about Jehovah's Witnesses and other religious paths. They are not perfect as human institutions, and have significance for their followers. So let them be .
  9. I know that people have free will, I am not asking you that. My question is, do people have the right to practice whatever religion they like? Is that (morally) right to have a religion other than Christianity? You said something about treason to 1.5 million people and things like that. Excuse me, but that's quite unreasonable to accuse people of treason which has no connection at all. This is another thing that falls in the category of dogma, you have a certain belief - fine, have whatever belief you wish, but be kind and don't accuse people of treason where there is none. 6 million Jewish people died because of being Jewish, so does that mean now we have to practice Judaism in order not to be traitors? I don't think so. Each man picks his religion. Let it be your way of defining, however, I fail to see how you connect unselfish love with intolerance. I am not accusing you. You actually said "intolerant: i agree they need our prayers". So I am wondering what you were agreeing then. You are free to speak, but the problem is that you are seeing deception and lies in other religion's teachings. Correct me if I am wrong but it looks like if something does not correspond to your beliefs you call it deception. That does not sound right. A while back Christianity was new in Armenia, with the same attitude one could conclude that Apostles and Christian preachers were also deceiving. So can you tell me what are the lies and deceptions you are talking about? That's a matter of personal belief, freedom of religion allows one to have any belief, and one cannot conclude any deception or lie from whatever other religious folks would preach just from the content of the preaching. Do you think you have no dogmas?
  10. I think there is a big difference, abandonment does not mean intolerance. To make a simple example, suppose I like blue shirts and don't like red shirts. I wear blue shirts and don't wear red shirts (in other words I abandon red shirts). However, I am quite tolerant of people who wear red shirts. Tolerance of other religions does not mean you have to practice them, it only means you have to be tolerant to their presence, ideas, beliefs, practices, everything that a bona fide religion implies provided nobody gets hurt or otherwise negatively affected by such practices. And even if there are some negative tendencies in other religions, the tolerant way is to give a friendly and compassionate advice, much like Jesus Christ would dine with Pharisees and teach and advice them in a humble and friendly manner.
  11. When everyone knows God and is perfect.
  12. This contradicts to what you said above. If you truly believe people are free to choose then you shoul not have any problem Armenians having any religion and I would expect no complaint about other religious/spiritual paths. However, you called them deceptive cults. How do you know that God is extreme? And what do you mean love is extreme? So you agree that you are intolerant??? Well, what can I say? Only that I would suggest you to have some of the tolerance that Jesus Christ demonstrated through his life and crucificion. And if you think someone needs your prayers then by all means pray for them. Nobody can tell you must pray, or you must not pray. Many dogmas, such as claim that everyone must be a Christian or go to eternal hell, etc... I am not fearing love - in fact I don't see any love coming from dogmatic people and institutions But I would be fearing that someone would take extreme steps based on some dogma and mental beliefs. Jehova's witnesses have a lot of dogmas of their own, but at least they are not displaying extreme behavior towards others.
  13. Don't you think people have the right to choose their own church/religion/temple? Lord have mercy indeed to the fanatical, intolerant and dogmatic.
  14. Oh... thanks You Would you mind passing a message to Him - I need a temperture of 90s this weekend, need to go to the shore
  15. Thank you indeed. Nzhdeh was not only a military hero but also a very wise and spiritual man. We have Zangezur thanks to him alone. Without Zangezur it would be extremely difficult to have Armenia.
  16. One should try to be fair. Put saving the Armenian nation from destruction on one scale, and fighting with Nazis on another, and without any bias try to objectively determine what weighs more. Demonizing Nazis is the easiest thing to do, because everyone does that while there are no Nazis around to object or force you to say otherwise. Likewise, for a blind nationalist it is easy to justify his hero under any circumstances because of his emotional bias. On the other hand, it is usually hard to persuade that freedom fighters are not necessarily terrorists, that bombing a country is most likely wrong and unjustifiable, that even uncivilized people have the right of free choice, etc... All because of propaganada and prevailing trends of thinking which are often wrong. One should be careful not to flock with the crowd and instead hold his/her intellectual independence from prevailing mental trends such as mindless bashing and absolute demonization of Nazism, or flowing in a selfish nationalist current of downfall.
  17. Mamigon, correct me if I am wrong, but it seems to me that you are trying to portray Dro and Nzhdeh in predominantly negative colors, as if they were ordinary mindless nationalists who became enchanted in Nazism and became inhumane Nazi executioners. That's a very inaccurate assesment in my opinion. We should not be ashamed or embarassed with either Dro or Nzhdeh. That does not mean that we are approving Nazism. These 2 individuals have done so much for their fellow human beings that we should only be proud of them. Perhaps it was a misjudgement to be with the Nazis, but that does not annul all their previous acievements. It is clear from their lives and actions that they were not chauvinists and had no Nazi complexes, they were very generous human beings who would readily sacrifice their lives for the good of their nation. At least that part of their lives is unquestionable and free of any taboos, everyone knows about their heroism. Making partnership with Nazis also could be viewed as a personal sacrifice. Think about it, they didn't care about their persons, that they might be criticized or condemned because of being with the Nazis. Or they could be simply executed by the Nazis themselves. All they cared about was the survival of the Armenian nation. That is quite contrary to blind nationalism which was the case with the real Nazis, or with Talaat and other scum for that matter.
  18. I hope the Bush administration will not stir more trouble in the world than it has already done, in which case he can't be compared to Hitler. However, he has already earned the status of a warmonger. Even though he has not killed millions of people, he has killed tens of thousands and has caused distress to millions, and continues to do so... But that's not the main point. What a certain leader will say he is doing for his nation is not what matters. If they do it selfishly without regard to other nations than that's a crime. We just need to look objectively. How can one compare Dro to Stalin or Hitler? Did Dro murder anyone to take their lands or properties? No. Did Dro aggress against another country? No. Did Dro attack peaceful people? No. If Turkey invaded Armenia and Dro's contingency plan took place, would another nation suffer because Dro would try to halt the extinction of the Armenian nation. No, at least there was no indication that Dro planned to do anything else than defense. Unless you disagree with the answers I really don't know how Dro can be compared to Talaat or Hitler or Stalin. If that was the case then Stalin's Marshal Baghramian should also be compared to Stalin, etc.
  19. It is quite possible for us to come down to an age in history were Bush collaborators would be regarded politically unacceptable with similar implications as with Nazi collaborators. Times dictate certain behavior on part of leaders of nations. Whereas many nations collaborate opportunistically driven by selfish gain, some nations particularly small nations have no other choice. Such was the case for our nation when Dro collaborated with Nazis. He just wanted us to survive in case Turkey was to invade Armenia, and that is true even today when our president is forced to be a Bush collaborator (arguably, this may not be vital or even wise). So, I could not place Dro on the same scale as let's say Mussolini or Henri Petain.
  20. "Fool" is not the word to use with names like Dro or Nzhdeh. Their dedication to our nation and extremely invaluable contributions put them in a very high rank, even if they collaborated with the Nazis, again for the sake of the survival of the Armenian nation. They are not perfect, so what? One cannot work for their nation as defence leaders and not have to collaborate one way or another with Nazis or Commis or whoever... Their selfless contributions far outweigh their deficiencies.
  21. Thanks Edo jan. Che ha, inch amusnanal, qani der xelq ka gluxs inch gorts unem kamavor gnam kalanqi tak?
  22. Sasun

    Pet Peeves!

    I tried hard but could not find any pet peeve of mine.
  23. Thanks, but I don't have it just yet. In about 2 weeks God willing
×
×
  • Create New...