- What is the basis for your hope?
"This is the first government that in fact breaks with the kemalists, the followers of Kemal Atatürk, founder of modern Turkey, who radically enforced the separation of Church and State. Apart from the opposition, the current politicians have nothing to do with people who have the genocide on their conscience. Erdogan and Gül are ordinary Muslims. Their supporters originate from people who had then saved Armenians with danger for their own lives. This government has, as far as I know, no links with the mafia, the military elite, the secret service and the media industry."
Firstly, ironically, there are no parties that talk about “Kemalism” (whatever the heck that is, pun intended).
I don’t know how he can say “the current politicians have nothing to do with people who have the genocide on their conscience.” Where does he get his info from? How does he reach his conclusions? What does he mean, anyway? It is in one’s hands to have something on their conscience or not – like today’s Kurds know what happened (and not plenty did enough to save Armenians, rest assured) but don’t give a rat’s arse, hence they don’t have it on their conscience. Yet during the last election they about almost all (I mean that region) dropped the “pro-Kurdish” parties and voted for these guys – one of the only two parties to make it into parliament. Anyone noted that? So what does it mean to “have nothing to do with...”? Is he talking about grassroots? Party members? MP’s? Associates, affiliates? What? And what does it mean to have something to do with people that DO have the genocide on their conscience? What are the implications?
- You are now referring to the car accident in Susurluk in 1996.
"Yes. A high police force officer, a member of Parliament, a mafia boss and a beauty diva were involved. Then it became clear how the Turkish establishment is interwoven with criminal gangs. This government has nothing to do with that and has strong roots in a democratic tradition. Therefore, I do not think that there are still reasons to keep Turkey outside the EU in the long run, especially if Erdogan recognizes the genocide. Because I do not see another government doing it so soon. Moreover this will help Turkey enormously.”
The criminal gangs part (or lack of connections with) could be true but would be misleading. The current party has almost always been in the opposition, but that is not to say it is “less filthy.” The party in government at this time is “ruled” by an elite class of former members of the previous fundamentalist party, for the most part, with recruits from other right-wing, centre-right, etc., parties, which is what makes it marginally plausible that it be “moderate” (or should one say “diluted”). And who are these people from the other rightist parties, including the ultranationalist MHP (a.k.a. Grey Wolves now having to tame down to Grey Puppies)? Any chance that they be “pure”? And the fundamentalists have no democratic tradition but one of going around houses like Jehovah’s Witnesses, asking for votes for their party, PR exercises such as making member one Arab Christian and advertising him to the whole world, putting up illiterate washerwomen as candidates for MP’s when first confronted with the question why they didn’t have any of their own, and one of a very cunning organisation and coordination and devotion (I’ll hand them that much) so much so that when their parties are to be shut down and their properties confiscated by the state, everything down to the pen and paper on the desk is registered as someone’s private property, to turn up in the HQ of the next emerging party. Oh do I even need to mention photos of chairmen and Uzbek terrorist Tahir Yoldash? The current are in no way, shape, or form “better” or less corrupt than the previous in that now that they have complete control over everything, as the single ruling party, they are relishing in the delight of pushing limits and getting around obstacles, something they are really good at. I’d say more but that would be telling.
- In which respect?
"Erdogan is able to push the door open for a completely new future for Turkey and also for the Caucasus Region. He will not do that primarily to please the EU, but out of personal interest. Because in the long run I see a leading role for Turkey in the whole region. I consider Erdogan able to do so. With the recognition of the Armenian genocide Turkey also provides itself with the legitimacy to develop into a real regional power. Recognition is in the Turkish interest. Problems do not get solved by blurring or by denying them."
Euphemism.
- What stops Turkey then?
"Not Erdogan, because he is in fact pleading for renewal and emancipation. You still find the opponents in all parts of the state apparatus and in the current opposition party CHP. That party depicts Erdogan's party AKP as Muslim fundamentalist that tries to frustrate the reforms. CHP represents the tradition of the genocide committers, Young-Turks, who for more than eighty years had the power and up to 1950 sat in the government and owned the banks. Their ideas are also widespread under Turks in Europe. They still play the same game, but they are losing their influence."
I have yet to imagine a Muslim fundamentalist being able to accept the G-word more easily than a member of a leftist party – not to be come across often, the latter, but even less the former. And like the hell Kaiser would know about CHP or what have you. These parties change position as they like or see fit according to the call of the day, and, moreover, on the grassroots, I believe it more likely to come across an enlightened CHP than a levitating fundamentalist. Assigning CHP the role of genocide denier simply because of its originating point is gross simplification. It was the Nationalists (repeat, “nationalists”) that formed the state, yet the CHP evolved into a leftist party while the MHP, today’s “nationalists,” emerged independently. If CHP would be so close-minded, I wouldn’t want to know how much worse an MHP could be.
- This sounds like a revolution.
"This is exactly so. At this moment a lot is happening in Turkey and that is a delicate process. AKP finds its basis among the ordinary population in Eastern Turkey. It is striking that exactly this Muslim government releases the Kurdish human rights activist Leyla Zana. A kemalist government would never do that."
They are merely reaping the harvest of a process not started by them.
- New York Life recently reached a millions of dollars settlement with Armenian heirs because of unpaid policies.
"This can be compared to the Jewish credit balances. There are more financial institutions with genocide money, both abroad and in Turkey itself. With the Armenian properties state ventures were established that still exist today. The Turkish government must take the initiative to blow off the lid. Transparency in companies is, in this respect, a condition for economic and democratic development in that region. This matter should not be seen in terms of what it costs, but in terms of new chances. That will also make Turkey more attractive for foreign investors."
Yes, yes, wonderful connections.
Holding Islam responsible is indeed silly as the genocide was a phenomenon of that geography and not of Muslims as the ummah. Also deporting Muslims to Turkify a region is quite different from deporting Christians so they would perish. Whether the Kurds were deported for the same reasons (I’d like to know the time frames), I don’t know. It was nationalism that played the role there, although not on its own. It’s not so simple, for, as Domino so astutely put it, the genocide was not racist, although the denial is. I think at the end of the day it isn’t important which –ism did this or that, or why, but just that it happened.