DominO123 Posted July 22, 2003 Report Share Posted July 22, 2003 (edited) http://www.space.com/scienceastronomy/sun-...ars_030721.html Sun-like Stars More Likely to Harbor Planets By Robert Roy BrittSenior Science Writerposted: 04:45 pm ET21 July 2003 http://a52.g.akamaitech.net/f/52/827/1d/www.space.com/images/h_HD70642_planet_01.jpg Common stars like our Sun rich in heavy elements are more likely to harbor planets, according to a new study. The finding suggests extrasolar planets might be more common than thought, and it should help planet hunters pick their targets more effectively. Theorists had long said that planet formation would be more common around stars rich in "metals," which in astronomers' parlance means anything heavier than hydrogen and helium, the two most common elements in the universe. The new study confirms this beyond expectations. The survey of 754 relatively nearby stars showed that the more metal a star contains the more likely it is to harbor one or more planets. The results represent a stark shift in the percentage of metal-rich stars now said to be potential homes to orbiting worlds. "Astronomers have been saying that only 5 percent of stars have planets," said Debra Fischer, an astronomer at the University of California, Berkeley. "If you look at the metal-rich stars, 20 percent have planets. That's stunning." Elements are forged in stars. The first stars in the universe were made almost entirely hydrogen. Subsequent generations of stars contain more and heavier elements. Our Sun, at about 4.6 billion years old, is young compared to the universe, which is 13.7 billion years old. The Sun is fairly metal-rich. What does this have to do with planets? A star is born from a cloud of material -- hydrogen and other elements. Planets form from the leftovers. If the cloud is rich in heavy material -- metals and rock -- then it has more of the stuff that theorists think planets require to begin their development. "The metals are the seeds from which planets form," said Fischer's colleague, Jeff Valenti of the Space Telescope Science Institute. Very metal poor stars can form planets, however. One example, announced recently, involves what is presumed to be the oldest planet in the universe. It must have been born around one of the earliest stars -- a star with very little metal, a separate research team said. Almost all of the 121 known extrasolar planets have been found nearby and around stars similar to the Sun, though. Most are larger than Jupiter and made mostly of gas. But scientists suspect they might have rocky cores. At the least, metals are needed for the gas to properly organize into a planetary ball, theorists say. Stars abundant in heavy metals are five times more likely to have a planetary companion than metal-poor stars, Fischer said. The survey included 61 stars known to have planets and 693 that do not, though further investigation could show that some of these other stars do in fact harbor planets that are very far away from their host star and thus hard to detect. It is the first large-scale survey comparing stellar metalicity to planet formation. The results were presented Monday at a meeting of the International Astronomical Union meeting in Sydney, Australia. Stars like the Sun, a typical star in this part of the Milky Way, have a 5 to 10 percent chance of hosting planets, the analysis showed. Stars three times more metal-rich than the Sun have a 20 percent chance of hosting planets, while stars with only one-third the amount of solar metalicity have just a 3 percent chance. Fischer also is part of the world's most prolific planet-hunting team, lead by Geoffrey Marcy at UC Berkeley and Paul Butler of the Carnegie Institution of Washington. "These results tell us why some of the stars in our Milky Way galaxy have planets while others do not," Marcy said. "The heavy metals must clump together to form rocks which themselves clump into the solid cores of planets." Edited July 22, 2003 by Fadix Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Azat Posted July 22, 2003 Report Share Posted July 22, 2003 (IMG:http://antwrp.gsfc.nasa.gov/apod/image/030.../carina_hst.jpg) This picture is more interesting Domino. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
DominO123 Posted July 22, 2003 Author Report Share Posted July 22, 2003 Seing such forms remembers me one picture that Hubble took where people reported having seen the face of God. I wonder if I can still locate it. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
THOTH Posted July 22, 2003 Report Share Posted July 22, 2003 Interesting stuff...and as I have suspected... Have you been following this "oldest planet" thing? (12.7 billion years supposedly) - they are claiming such great detail about its origines & history & what not. I can't for the life of me figure how they can know all of this... Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
DominO123 Posted July 22, 2003 Author Report Share Posted July 22, 2003 (edited) The way they detect planets is to follow its stars movement. While the planet turns around its star, not only does the star attract the planet because of gravity, but as well the planet has an influence on its star. What astronomers usually do(there is two methods, I will explain the simplest one, and if you want a head bracking thing, I can explain the second one then), is to study the little(very little) movement of the star in itself. What they will see is that the star will move one side to the other, for example left and then right etc... while its planet is turning around it. More it influence the star, or the planet is bigger, or it is closer. Now there is a way to know which of those is true, and it is to study the period in which the star move to right lef, right left etc... more it does, more the planet is closer, because more the planet is closer to it star, more it turns faster around it. So by differenciating that speed and the importance of this star movement, they can calculate the size and the distance the planet is from its star. All those even without seing the planet. Now, how they can know if it is the oldest. There is ways, stars have their life evolution, they born, they live and they die, more a star is massive, and less they live, our sun is in the size of the most common stars, that is, the average size. This average sizes live from 8 to 15 billions of years... where 85-90 % of their life they passes on their natural activity, at the end, they change forms, they become usual a giant red, than when they are the size of ours, they will end up at the size of earth, compacted, if bigger they may end up in a supernova and finish their life as a neutron star. Now, from spectroscopic analysis they can know the composition of a star, the way it works is that electrons capt a level of energy from the photon, depending on the quantum state of the particule. In simple, is that each elements acts differently when light passes from it, and that depend on the Quantum states of the electrons, I think I will spare that to you, unless you want me to elaborate. OK, now from that, they can kow the elements that the star contain, less they contain heavy ellements, more you can be assured that they have been formed near the ages when the Universe has started(I am simplifying that, because it as well depend on the type of star, but lets say that we consider the type). Because at the begging there were only Hydrogen, then Helium formed, and the rest were build in the stars, the most heavy ellements were formed from giant stars, when there was a supernova. Now, they compare all those datas. First, the composition of the star from spectroscopic analysis, then they try to verify by studying the age of the star, for example, if from the datation of the star we found out that the age is of 5 billion, and that the composition of the star indicate it should have been build 10 billion of years ago, we have a problem. After studying its type, we can know how much it lives, for example if from its composition, it is 14 billion years old, and that that type of star can only live 10 billion, we again have a problem. Now, after that, we date the planet. A planet from its angle from its star tend to go closer or farer from it(our solar system sound equilibrated though), more old it is, more it become equilibrated in its movement, and more we can observe that from the movement of the star... and voila, after all those observations, we found out that finally this planet is the oldest. In order to tell that, we must be sure that it has been formed with the star, more bigger the planet is, and more it is certain it has been build with it, and more older the star is, more the age difference become insignificant. If you want to know why that, I can explain that as well. You just asked the kind of question I like. Edited July 22, 2003 by Fadix Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
THOTH Posted July 22, 2003 Report Share Posted July 22, 2003 LOL - well thank you Domino...actually I am aware of most of what you speak - this subject - and astronomy in general - have long been of interest to me (since before you were born - LOL - though no doubt you understand the actual science better then I... ). In fact I used to know many of the folks at Cal Tech/JPL who are very involved in this sort of thing. When I lived in LA I would get invited to bring my video equipment and hook up for planetary flybys, comets striking planets (think I missed shoemaker...though did see it on a friends very nice telescope...) etc (see - I can hang with all you geeks - LOL!)...and as a result I have hours of video - originally recorded real time - direct from NASA internal network & such (mostly boring as hell - but some of interest certainly). One of my best friends (works at JPL...) was also on the team (or worked with them or some such) that engineered the Hubble fix a few years back. And he's actually got to climb aboard the shuttle a few times to secure various experiments (great thrills...). Several of my friends got Doctorates at tech in planetary Sciences related fieilds (though no straight Astronmy that I can recall) - others were/are physicists (some having been students of the great/awesome R Feynman...) And of course I have a cousin whom I used to be close too who is really into this stuff...Anyway - so I'm into all this too - though with perhaps only a Scientific American level of technical undsderstanding ...and I understand how they "discover" (and characterize) planets (& think that it is reasonbly legit...)...but they seem to have gone into a great deal of detail on the history of thie "so-called" oldest planet...frankly - IMHO - beyond perhaps what is warrented by good science...seems to me a lot of guesswork...and perhaps a bit of sensationalism...donno really - why I was asking I guess (I read the article on the site BTW)...and you may have wondered why I am such a fan of Gregory Beneford...eh? There Sip - I did it again... Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
DominO123 Posted July 22, 2003 Author Report Share Posted July 22, 2003 LOL - well thank you Domino...actually I am aware of most of what you speak - this subject - and astronomy in general - have long been of interest to me (since before you were born - LOL - though no doubt you understand the actual science better then I... ). In fact I used to know many of the folks at Cal Tech/JPL who are very involved in this sort of thing. When I lived in LA I would get invited to bring my video equipment and hook up for planetary flybys, comets striking planets (think I missed shoemaker...though did see it on a friends very nice telescope...) etc (see - I can hang with all you geeks - LOL!)...and as a result I have hours of video - originally recorded real time - direct from NASA internal network & such (mostly boring as hell - but some of interest certainly). One of my best friends (works at JPL...) was also on the team (or worked with them or some such) that engineered the Hubble fix a few years back. And he's actually got to climb aboard the shuttle a few times to secure various experiments (great thrills...). Several of my friends got Doctorates at tech in planetary Sciences related fieilds (though no straight Astronmy that I can recall) - others were/are physicists (some having been students of the great/awesome R Feynman...) And of course I have a cousin whom I used to be close too who is really into this stuff...Anyway - so I'm into all this too - though with perhaps only a Scientific American level of technical undsderstanding ...and I understand how they "discover" (and characterize) planets (& think that it is reasonbly legit...)...but they seem to have gone into a great deal of detail on the history of thie "so-called" oldest planet...frankly - IMHO - beyond perhaps what is warrented by good science...seems to me a lot of guesswork...and perhaps a bit of sensationalism...donno really - why I was asking I guess (I read the article on the site BTW)...and you may have wondered why I am such a fan of Gregory Beneford...eh? There Sip - I did it again... Thoth, mesuring a planets ages is more acurate than mesuring its size, or even before being sure that there is really a planet there you can mesure the age of a hypothetical one. You just have to mesure its star age and try to verify it with other parametres. The precision would nearly as good as the age of its star, and calculating the age of a star is not new and has been proven to be pretty precise. Ah another thing, it is not that rare to have world known great scientists as teachers in Universities, more particularly when you have astronomy, astrophysic, planetary science courses. Here in Quebec, there is about 40 astronomers, some of them are known figures that are in charge of our observatory and are the ones first interviewed when Ufologists bring their trashes up. So when you take astronomy courses, it is very likely that you will have a scientist that has wrote books and are known. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.