Jump to content

Olive Branches From Ankara Raise Hopes And Challen


Azat

Recommended Posts

Eurasia Insight:

OLIVE BRANCHES FROM ANKARA RAISE HOPES AND CHALLENGES IN ARMENIA

Haroutiun Khachatrian: 6/24/03

 

 

Armenian leaders, after two disputed elections, are now divided over how to receive recent overtures from Turkey. One camp doubts that Armenia’s most powerful neighbor really intends to normalize relations. Another group has expressed concern that Turkey does want to end the status quo, potentially causing trouble between Yerevan and the worldwide Armenian community known as the Diaspora.

 

The dilemma materialized in May, when Armenian officials responded to reports that Abdullah Gul, Turkey’s foreign minister, had commented to the Turkish media about his government’s desire to achieve full relations with Armenia’s. Gul then met with his Armenian counterpart Vartan Oskanian in Madrid on June 4 and said that the two would address reconciliation “with renewed energy.”

 

This tone counters mistrust stemming from the breakdown of the Soviet Union in late 1991. Turkey and Armenia never established diplomatic relations, largely because Turkey strongly supported Azerbaijan in the war over Nagorno-Artsax. (Turks and Azeris have a long history of ethnic kinship.) In April 1993, Ankara blocked the Armenian-Turkish border in response to Nagorno-Artsax troops’ occupation of Azerbaijan’s Kelbajar region. Turkey lifted an air blockade a year later, implying that the blockade had damaged its own economy. But it never considered further normalization, unless Armenia first agreed to a “liberation of the Azeri territories.” Now, Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan seems interested in getting the border open, potentially as a precursor to full relations.

 

However, some Armenian politicians suspect that Gul’s statement serves a separate agenda. Turkey keenly wants to join the European Union, which means it wants to avoid any appearance of intransigence toward its neighbors. [For background, see the Eurasia Insight archives]. European nations are watching Turkey’s posture toward Armenia closely: Paris, in April, unveiled a monument to Komitas, the famous Armenian composer, who was a victim of the 1915 massacres of Armenians in Turkey. At the time, Gul asked French officials to avoid the term “genocide” in recalling the deaths, despite the fact that the French parliament had officially termed these events as “genocide” two years earlier. The Irish parliament on June 14 urged Turkey to “promote good neighborliness” with Armenia as part of a resolution praising Ankara’s progress toward European Union membership. Gul’s remarks reportedly contained no indication on Azerbaijan, implying that Ankara was seriously considering modifying its policy to suit European and American desires.

 

Given this possible ulterior motive, members of the Armenian Diaspora and some politicians balked at the idea of instant reconciliation. [For background on the Diaspora, see the Eurasia Insight archives]. Armen Rustamian, chairman of the parliamentary commission on foreign relations, has conditioned diplomatic ties on Turkish “neutrality” regarding Nagorno-Artsax and on recognition that the 1915 tragedy was an act of genocide. “The opening of borders does not yet mean the establishment of full-scale relations,” he told the Noyan-Tapan news agency on June 12. His suspicion spread far and wide: the liberal daily Azg ran a June 12 story rendering the Oskanian-Gul meeting an “illusion of progress.” And ethnic Armenians worldwide, by invoking the genocide issue, could make Gul’s overtures more likely to stall.

 

Turkey has always rejected the claim that its troops perpetrated genocide on Armenians. [For background, see the Eurasia Insight archives]. Now, a draft of a ceremonial bill awaits consideration by both houses of the US Congress. The document lists the "Armenian genocide" among those genocides worth commemorating by the United Nations, contradicting Turkey’s interpretation of history. The traditionalist Armenian Revolutionary Federation Dashnaktsutiun (ARF), which ruled the First Armenian Republic of 1918-20 and has won a role in Armenia’s new coalition government, has argued that Turkey’s current activities are simply “tricks” aimed at preventing this resolution. "They want to use ‘diplomacy’ to divert the issue,” Rustamian, a member of the party’s leadership, told Noyan Tapan. On the same basis, the Armenian National Committee of America, an organization affiliated with ARF, rejected a meeting with Ecvet Tezcan, a Turkish Foreign Ministry official, and called him a “genocide denier.”

 

With this issue unresolved, other issues have arisen. Gul reportedly tied normalization only to an absence of territorial claims from the Armenian side to Turkey. In reply, Oskanian expressed readiness to discuss normalization issues “without any preconditions.” The language led the Golos Armenii newspaper to urge Armenia to try revising the Moscow and Kars treaties of 1921, in which Turkey and the Bolshevik-led Russia forced Armenia to adopt its current borders with Turkey and Azerbaijan. This border arrangement keeps Nakhcivan as an Armenian exclave in Azerbaijan.

 

Rustamian has also called for reparations in addition to recognition, breaking with his own government’s official policy. President Robert Kocharian has held to the position that seeking genocide recognition need not entail a punitive component. This policy, while it appears flexible, could trigger tension between the president and the Diaspora, many of whose members trace their ancestry to the events of 1915.

 

The prospect of reconciliation is hard to gauge. Armenia treats the expected reopening of the Turkish border as a serious victory. The end of a transportation blockade would make Armenia more attractive to investors and could improve the trade balance by opening Turkey to imports of Armenian goods. But even this step could bring more political and economic complications, which would make full normalization even more elusive. Edvard Simoniants, a former minister of national security, says opening borders may greatly increase imports of Turkish goods, which now go through Georgia before reaching Armenian markets. This could suppress domestic production, especially in agriculture and light manufacturing. Second, after the Gyumri-Kars railroad link between the two countries is reopened, international mediators may increase pressure on Armenia to impose very serious concessions on the Nagorno-Artsax issue. [For background on the Nagorno-Artsax conflict, see the Eurasia Insight archives].

 

Finally, many worry that Armenia is politically too fragile and institutionally too immature to hold its own in normalized dealings with a nation of 67 million. Ties with Turkey could also mute Armenia’s alliance with its strategic partner, Russia. “For this reason, I think that Armenia should not hurry to fully normalize its relations with Turkey, and should prepare very carefully each step in this direction,” Simoniants says. Whatever happens between the two countries, it is likely to happen deliberately.

 

 

Editor’s Note: Haroutiun Khachatrian is a Yerevan-based writer specializing in economic and political affairs.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I would say let them go for it. Let Armenia have diplomatic relations with turkey. Let them open the border and let them have normal commerce. Let people travel, let them exchange cultural programs, let them learn about Armenian Genocide, let them bue Armenian goods.

 

Don't let them in Europe and block any efforts on their part to become more "Europeans". I know that that hurts. Don't buy turkish goods, don't listen to turkish music, don't eat turkish food, don't be polite with turks, don't help them abroad, if you meet a turk by accident spit in his face or at least blow his tires.

 

All of the above is called politics. Do you think Greeks or Serbs or Romanians or anybody else in the vicinities like the turks? Just play fair and intelligent.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

many worry that Armenia is politically too fragile and institutionally too immature to hold its own in normalized dealings with a nation of 67 million.

 

I don't understand, what is this supposed to mean? Did Armenia have a problem in dealing with China, a nation of 1 billion, for example, or India, Russia?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

many worry that Armenia is politically too fragile and institutionally too immature to hold its own in normalized dealings with a nation of 67 million.

 

I don't understand, what is this supposed to mean? Did Armenia have a problem in dealing with China, a nation of 1 billion, for example, or India, Russia?

In case you could not read between the lines ... it is a THREAT.

Remember when Ozal advocated sending a few "fire crackers" to Yerevan to remind the Armenians what happened in 1915.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Yes, I remember Ozal's rheotoric.

If a Turk said something like that I would think it's a threat. But this is an Armenian analyst talking about normal relationship between Armenia and Turkey.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

That is no "Olive Branch", it is a sabre disguised as one.

To see why and how read "Defnese and Offense".

We will know when a real "Olive Branch" is dsplayed, only when a complete map of Western Armenia is attached to the "branch", only then we will talk. Until then there is nothing to be said that has not been already said.

Is it an "Olive Branch" or a "White Flag"?

We will soon know.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

One thing i remember the son of turk ozal died from massive heart atack upon returning from azerbayjan

:rolleyes: :rolleyes: :rolleyes: :rolleyes: :rolleyes: :rolleyes:

sxalvum es barekam - sra n@maner@ chem mahanum / sranq satkum en shan n@man

 

yes anglereni jisht hamanun@ chem gtnum satkelu / knereq

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I would say let them go for it. Let Armenia have diplomatic relations with turkey. Let them open the border and let them have normal commerce. Let people travel, let them exchange cultural programs, let them learn about Armenian Genocide, let them bue Armenian goods.

 

Don't let them in Europe and block any efforts on their part to become more "Europeans". I know that that hurts. Don't buy turkish goods, don't listen to turkish music, don't eat turkish food, don't be polite with turks, don't help them abroad, if you meet a turk by accident spit in his face or at least blow his tires.

 

All of the above is called politics. Do you think Greeks or Serbs or Romanians or anybody else in the vicinities like the turks? Just play fair and intelligent.

All of the above is called politics / sorry but no / your wrong

 

least blow his tires - this is not acceptable !!! you cant blow his tires or his car - you can have it don by some qurds, this will be the correct and political way of doing...

 

now this is fair and intelligent.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

One thing i remember the son of turk ozal died from massive heart atack upon returning from azerbayjan 

:rolleyes:  :rolleyes:  :rolleyes:  :rolleyes:  :rolleyes:  :rolleyes:

sxalvum es barekam - sra n@maner@ chem mahanum / sranq satkum en shan n@man

 

yes anglereni jisht hamanun@ chem gtnum satkelu / knereq

Voronum es "croak"??? :mummy:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...