Jump to content

Residents of Hamshen


Ashot

Recommended Posts

Hemshinli: The Forgotten Black Sea Armenians

 

Bert Vaux

Harvard University

 

1. Introduction to the history, language, and culture of the Hemshinli

 

If asked to identify the inheritors of the Black Sea coast region once inhabited by the Pontic

Greeks and the Trabzon and Artvin Armenians, many would correctly identify the Laz in Turkey

and the Abkhaz and other Caucasian tribes in Georgia and southern Russia. However, few know

of the existence of one of the most widespread and populous groups in this area, which has a

population of as many as several hundred thousand worldwide. This group, the hemshinli or

residents of Hamshen, occupies a continuous area stretching from the Black Sea province of

Trabzon, Rize, anSamsun in north-central Turkey to southern Russia in the north. There are also

significant Hemshinli communities in the northwestern provinces of western Turkey, in various

cities in Central Asia, and amongst the guest workers in Germany.

One is immediately struck by two facts about the Hemshinli: they are originally

Armenian, and the Hemshinli in Turkey are Muslim.

The presence of these enigmatic Armenians in the Black Sea area raises many interesting

and difficult questions:

• Who exactly are the Hemshinli?

• When did they come into the area?

• Where did they come from?

• Why are they generally unknown to the outside world?

• What effect has Islamicization had on their language and culture?

In this paper I develop the beginnings of an answer to these questions, based on my fieldwork

with a number of young Hemshinli as well as some of their Christian counterparts in Abkhazia.

My primary Hemshinli informant is a young man in his twenties named "Cengiz", who was

born and raised in the village of Köprücü, located 5 kilometers from the Georgian border and

from the Black Sea coast in the Artvin province. On the other side of the border my main source

of information is a man of the same age named Avik Topchyan, whose family comes from the

town of Novyj Afon in Abkhazia.

 

1.1. Who are the Hemshinli?

 

There are three basic subgroups of Hemshinli:

• Western Hemshinli, who live in the Turkish province of Rize and dispersed elsewhere in

Turkey, speak Turkish, and are Sunni Muslim. (This group, which refers to itself as

hemshinli, is well-described in two books by Uwe Bläsing (1992, 1995) and in Benninghaus

1989.)

• Eastern Hemshinli, who live in the province of Artvin (with smaller numbers dispersed

elsewhere in Turkey, Central Asia, and Europe), speak a language called Homshetsma, and

are also Sunni. (This group, which refers to itself as either hemshinli or homshetsi, has been

studied by myself (1996, 2001), Marr (1925), Dumézil (1963, 1965, 1967, 1986),

Benninghaus (1989), and Vardanyan (1993).)

• Northern Hemshinli, the descendants of non-Islamicized Hemshinli formerly of the

provinces of Samsun, Ordu, Giresun, and Trabzon, who live in Georgia and Russia, speak

Homshetsma, and are Christian. (This is the group studied by Aça®yan 1947, Torlakyan

1986, Vardanyan 1993, and Kuznetsov 1995, 2001. They refer to themselves as homshentsi.)

 

The primary traditional occupations of the Turkish (i.e. western and eastern) Hemshinli are

cultivating tea and corn, animal husbandry, and beekeeping. The Homshetsma lexicon includes a

special term for ‘honey sickness’, a peculiar condition that afflicts unfortunates who have

consumed a special type of honey foudn in the eastern Black Sea region. Their folklore reflects

the daily concerns of the Hemshinli as well as the mountainous coastal milieu in which they

exist: it is replete with tales of protecting their fields from bears, wolves, wild men, ghosts, and

their Laz neighbors. According to Cengiz, until recent times traveling bards would congregate in

the village square to compete in composing songs dealing with local trees, mountains, and foods,

as well as more familiar topics such as wooing and lost love.

Their riddles encapsulate the world of life in a Black Sea village, as one can see in the

following examples elicited from Cengiz’s mother:

(1)

Q: galat me kak bade tevi

‘I threw a basket of dung against the wall’

A: onguç

‘ear’

(2)

Q: ma@ me hagvit caxke tei

‘I put a sieve full of egg on the roof’

A: asda@

‘star’

(3)

Q: gerta gerta iz çuni, yed ku ka açvi çuni

‘it goes and goes and has no footprint; it returns and has no eye’

A: ked

‘river’

(4)

Q: Àompu vaan haßnaj senduk

‘a locked lockbox on the road’

A: mazarlux

‘cemetery’

 

The first riddle, for example, reflects the Hemshinli tradition of using cow dung (kak or axp) to

fill in the cracks between stones in the temporary homes they erect during their summer stays in

summer camps (yayla) several days to the south. The other riddles display features that I will

touch on below.

 

Interestingly, the ethnicity of the Hemshinli is no longer easily determined by consulting

the Turkish Hemshinli. The Hemshinli in Turkey are Muslim, and are considered by many Turks

to be a variety of Laz (Benninghaus 1989:497). Younger Turkish Hemshinli apparently consider

themselves to be a Turkic tribe, an opinion shared in print in various Turkish publications by

older members of their community (Benninghaus 1989:486-7). Their personal names are

generally of Turkish origin, but many have nicknames of South Caucasian origin; some typical

Hemshinli nicknames and their Georgian counterparts are given in (5).

 

(5) Hemshinli names

Homshetsma - Çita - Boko - Çute - Xavula - Mapu - Dukßi - Gunti

Georgian - çita - boko - çute - ƒavila - mabu - tukhsi - gundia

 

The Hemshinli also share with the Laz their preference for the tulum, a sort of bagpipe, the

horon, a particular style of dance, and a certain amount of vocabulary, such as lazut ‘corn’,

digina ‘a device that children use to carry tea on their backs’, and so on.

However, though the Turkish Hemshinli often present themselves as Laz for

convenience, it is important to notice that they do not intermarry with the Laz (Benninghaus

1989:491; confirmed by Cengiz). Furthermore, they rarely know more than a few words of the

Laz language (Benninghaus 1989:491), and they do not refer to the Laz as Hemshinli, but rather

as megreli ‘Mingrelians’ (Benninghaus 1989:491) or Àon ‘Laz’, related to the Georgian name for

the Laz, ç’ani (cf. also Middle Armenian çen çen, Byzantine Greek tsánoi).

 

The Laz themselves refer to the western Hemshinli as ermeni ‘Armenian’ (Benninghaus

1989:131), suggesting their true origins. Interestingly, though Cengiz reports that the same term

ermeni is used by some of the young eastern Hemshinli to refer to drunkards, elder members of

this community in fact seem to be aware of their Armenian origins, but discourage discussion of

them.

The Armenian origin of the Hemshinli becomes clear when one examines Homshetsma,

the language spoken by the eastern and northern Hemshinli. As we will see later, though

Homshetsma contains many Turkish and Laz lexical items, genetically it is in fact closely related

to the western dialects of modern Armenian.

The Armenian heritage of the Hemshinli becomes even clearer when one considers the

northern Hemshinli, who acknowledge their Armenian roots, have Armenian names, belong to

the Armenian Apostolic Church, and do not employ Caucasian instruments such as the tulum. In

fact, some of the younger generation of northern Hemshinli are not even aware that they are of

Hamshen descent, and know only that they are Armenian and their ancestors came from

somewhere in Turkey5.

So far, then, we know that the Hemshinli are a western Armenian group, who are in the

process of assimilating to their Turkish and Caucasian environment. Our next question is where

they came from, and when.

Edited by Ashot
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1.2. Where did the Hemshinli come from, and when?

 

As one can guess from their name, the Hemshinli originally come from the region around the

town of Çaml¥hemßin (‘Piny Hamshen’) in the Rize province of northeastern Turkey. The

Armenian name of this area is Hamßên (Hamshen). In order to refer to a resident of Hamshen in

Homshetsma, one adds the Armenian provenance suffix -…i (-tsi). (The form Hemßinli is the

Turkish equivalent; it means literally '(resident) of Hemßin'.) Homshetsma furthermore changes a

to o before nasal consonants (m and n), as we already saw in the derivation of Àon ‘Laz’ from

tsan, and then deletes the -n-; the end result is the form homße…i homße…i mentioned earlier.

The name Hamshen itself appears to derive from an earlier form Hamamaßên

(Hamamashen), which means roughly ‘Hamam’s hamlet’. We have reason then to believe that

the Hemshinli moved to their current location under the guidance of a certain man by the name

of Hamam. But where did these original settlers come from? There is a tradition in Cengiz’s

village that the Hemshinli are the descendants of the offspring of a Turkish general and his

Armenian wife, who originally lived in the Van area and eventually migrated to Hamshen via

Kars and Ardahan. Various other local traditions are surveyed in Benninghaus’ excellent 1989

article on the Hemshinli: for example, certain Turkish nationalists have suggested that the

Hemshinli are the descendants of a Turkic tribe from Central Asia, or even neo-Akkadians.

In reality, it seems that the original inhabitants of Hamamashen migrated to the area

together with a certain prince Hamam Amatuni in the second half of the eighth century (Edwards

1988:404). Xachikyan (1969:118) suggests that these migrants came from Kotayk and

Aragatsotn in the province of Ayrarat, which accords well with the linguistic facts, as we will see

later. This initial migration may have been augmented by an influx of refugees from the fallen

kingdom of Ani in the second half of the eleventh century (Benninghaus 1989:482).

We can also get an idea of the historical movements of the Hemshinli from their

language. For example, the fact that all Hemshinli (both Christian and Muslim) have substantial

Turkish and Laz components in their lexicon, whereas only the northern Hemshinli have Russian

loans, suggests that the original Hemshinli lived in a Turkish-Laz milieu, and the northern group

later split off from this original homeland and established itself in an area of Russian dominance.

Similarly, the Homshetsma consonant system suggests that the community originally had close

ties with the Armenians who ended up in the area around the city of Akn on the Euphrates river,

and that both of these communities migrated from somewhere in the Ayrarat region. I’ll return to

this topic below.

 

1.3. The conversion

 

To summarize thus far, we know that we are dealing with a single original Christian community

centered around the city of Hamshen, which subsequently split into the three modern Hemshinli

communities: two Muslim and one Christian; two Turkish and one (ex-)Soviet. These facts raise

three interesting problems:

 

(i) How did the Hemshinli come to be distributed over such a large area after beginning with

such a restricted distribution?

 

(ii) Secondly, we know that it is highly unusual to come across Armenian-speaking Muslims.

Many Armenians over the centuries have converted to Islam, but this conversion generally

entails loss of the language and of Armenian identity within two generations. Conversely,

some members of neighboring ethnic groups have acquired the Armenian language, but

these minorities are typically Christian, such as the Assyrians, and they do not necessarily

assimilate into the larger Armenian polity. The question then is: what conditions have

enabled the Hemshinli to preserve their Armenian language and culture after converting to

Islam, and how have they been affected by this conversion?

 

(iii) Finally, how did the division between the Muslim and the Christian Hemshinli develop?

The answers to all three of these questions revolve around a single important event in the history

of the Hemshinli community, which has had profound and lasting effects on their culture,

identity, and language.

 

Beginning in about the sixteenth century, a large portion of the Hemshinli converted to

Islam. This trend assumed a significantly larger scale in the eighteenth century, and continued to

a lesser degree up to the beginning of the twentieth century. Those Hemshinli who converted to

Islam were allowed to remain in situ, and have essentially been left undisturbed since that time.

Those who refused to convert had in effect the choice of fleeing or taking their chances where

they were. The first wave of refugees fled westwards to Trabzon, Giresun, Samsun, and so on.

Their descendants successfully established new communities along the Black Sea coasts of

Georgia, Abkhazia, and Russia, and in the western Turkish provinces of Bolu and Sakarya in the

nineteenth and twentieth centuries. Some of the Hemshinli in western Turkey relocated to

Armenia after the First World War.

 

Throughout this sequence of conversions and emigration small pockets of Christian

Hemshinli survived in Turkey, until 1915. We have reason to believe that the eastern Hemshinli

in Cengiz’s area, isolated in the mountain fastnesses of northern Hopa subprovince, were among

the last to convert en masse, in the late seventeenth century. To the best of our knowledge,

though, there are currently no Christian Hemshinli left in Turkey.

We do not know when the eastern Hemshinli, the least studied of the various Hemshinli

subgroups, extended into the Hopa region and southern Georgia (Benninghaus 1989:482).

We do know, however, that the Hemshinli who had converted and then established themselves along

the Georgian coast fell victim to Stalin’s deportation of some 200,000 residents of Georgia’s

southern border to Kazakhstan and Uzbekistan in 1944. These Central Asian Hemshinli

communities remain distinct and alive up to the present day, and at least some members retain

Homshetsma (Robert Krikorian, personal communication; Kuznetsov 2001). It is interesting to

note that some members of the Central Asian Hemshinli community petitioned to relocate to

Armenia near the end of the Soviet period, and were refused on account of their religion (Robert

Krikorian, personal communication).

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Zartonq jan, I haven't finished the full article, the only reason why I didn't want this merged because the discussion of the Hamshetsa is very long, and this article by itself is very long as well... let me finish the full article then we can merge or do whatever we want... The one thing I was afraid of has already happened - the interruption of the full article!!!

 

I'll have to ask Yervand to remove posts 3-6 untill I finish the full article, then I will ask our Guderian to post the pictures back in here at the end!!!

 

Thank you, and if it's ok by you, please let Yervant know!!!

 

Thank you in advance!!!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1.3.1. The impact of Islamicization

 

Having accounted for the distribution of the various Hemshinli communities, I would now like to

consider the impact that the conversion to Islam had on the Turkish Hemshinli. In addressing this

problem I will draw primarily on my work with Cengiz, who belongs to the eastern Hemshinli

community.

 

The overall effect of the conversion among the eastern Hemshinli is quite striking:

though they essentially preserve their pre-Islamic language and culture intact--presumably

because they live in isolated mountain villages with few Turks around--both the language and

the culture have been almost completely stripped of their Christian elements. For example,

weddings are still performed in the traditional Armenian fashion, except that no priest is present.

Similarly, the native Armenian words for Christian terms such as ‘priest’, ‘cross’, ‘church’, and

so on have disappeared (though see the discussion of xaæuß below).

A striking example of this de-Christianization can be seen in a Hemshinli folktale that

Cengiz once recited for me, called ‘Temel’s Head’.

 

(8) Temel’s Head

 

Yiyek hadik enger caxutn ive kay¥@ enuß gerton. Tsaxutin keloxn ive kellin kay¥@e genin. Šad

barak gelli; hemi inçecnuß kuzin. Andi inçecnele erguse uuß Àompacove Àompan ißno@un meg

al na satarin kelxan Àompan inçecno@um gasa. Da@in onune temel gelli. Temele çvone Àedin

gaba gu, ‘yes hemi asdi inçecenim’ gasa. Andi engerdake Àompan kiçnun put genin martun

vuÀude go keloxe çgo. ‘Yahu,’ gasin, ‘asu keloxe gar ta çgar ta? Inç enik inç enik oç?’ Yuuc put

genin ‘yahu,’ gasin, ‘meg erta gasa genoçe harc enik balki genige kidena gu.’ Genoçe mode

gerton, ‘yahu,’ gasin, ‘ku martun keloxe vaan er ta vaan çer ta?’ Genign a gasa, ‘as akvan a,’

gasa, ‘kahvalti haz¥rlamiß i,’ gasa, ‘bat marte giav ta giav oç ta çkidim,’ gasa.

 

Three friends go up a mountain to make a boat. They climb up to the top of the mountain and

make the boat. [The mountain] is very steep; now they want to lower [the boat down the mountain].

Then to lower it, two go down by one path; the other says, ‘I’ll lower it down the

steeper path.’ The lad’s name is Temel. Temel ties a rope around his neck and says, ‘Now I’ll

lower it.’ Then the friends go down the path and see that there’s a man’s body, but there’s no

head. ‘Hey,’ they say, ‘did he have his head or not? What do we do, what don’t we do?’ They

look at each other and say, ‘Hey, let’s go ask his wife; maybe she knows.’ They go to the wife

and say, ‘Hey, does your husband have a head, or not?’ The wife says, ‘this morning he

prepared breakfast, but I don’t know if he ate it, or not.’

 

The story of Temel’s Head is a variant of a popular Christian Armenian folktale, ‘The

Priest’s Head’, of which one version from the Mush area in eastern Turkey involves two men

taking a priest to a cave to search for the missing day of the week, Friday. The story concludes as

follows:

 

(9) excerpt from ‘The Missing Friday’ (Russell 1987)

It was decided the priest should go [into the cave], so they lowered him down into the hole with

his feet sticking out the top. Time passed, and the priest made no sound. They pulled him out by

his feet and saw he had no head: the bear ate it.

‘Hey, son, the priest had his head on when we brought him here, didn’t he?’

‘Shucks, I didn’t look to see if it was there or not.’

‘This is pretty bad, son. We’d better go and ask his wife whether the priest had his head

on or not when he left the house this morning.’

So they went to her house.

‘Ma’am, would you tell us, did the Father have his head on or not when he left the house

today?’ asked the householder.

‘By my soul, I don’t know,’ replied the priest’s wife. ‘Now was it, or wasn’t it? But I do

recall, while he was eating yogurt it was dribbling down his beard.’

 

One can see that the essence of the story (including the nonsensical tone) of the Priest’s

Head is preserved in the Hemshinli version. However, the priest has been replaced with a secular

character, Temel, the standard hero of Black Sea tales, and the mildly anticlerical tone of the

original is completely absent. There is also interesting wordplay specific to Homshetsma: the

story clearly takes place on a mountain, but it makes no sense to build a boat on a mountain. It

does make sense, on the other hand, to build a boat in a forest, where wood is readily available;

this possibility is in fact alluded to in the tale's use of Homshetsma …axut (…axud), which

means both 'mountain' and 'forest'.

 

The essential point in the story of Temel's Head, though, is the way in which its Christian

elements have been stripped from the Hemshinli version, which is part of the general

dechristianization of the Hemshinli culture. Related to this dechristianization is the Hemshinli's

loss of Armenian identity. For example, the Hemshinli have completely lost the word hay

‘Armenian’ and its derivatives, such as hayerên ‘Armenian language’, using instead the terms

homße…i and homße…ma respectively. Similarly, as I mentioned earlier, the eastern Hemshinli

use the Turkish term for Armenians, ermeni, to refer to drunkards. One also finds amongst the

Turkish Hemshinli sentiments such as the following, which was expressed in a 1984 letter from

an eastern Hemshinli to Rüdiger Benninghaus: ‘the Armenians are terrorists, and therefore the

peaceful Hemshinli cannot be of Armenian descent’ (Benninghaus 1989:486). However, it

should be noted that in 1914 the entire population of Cengiz’s village fled to the mountains,

suggesting some awareness of their Armenian past.

 

Despite the general dechristianization of the Turkish Hemshinli language and culture, we

should note that there are in fact a few isolated remnants of their Christian past. For example, the

Turkish Hemshinli observe nor dai ‘New Year’ on the day of the Epiphany, in accordance with

the Christian Armenian practice. Bryer (1975:142) reports moreover that baptisms were

performed among the western Hemshinli as late as the turn of the twentieth century. Finally, in

late July the western Hemshinli celebrate at their yaylas a three-day festival called vartivor. This

is a survival of the Christian Armenian festival vardava®, the Feast of the Transfiguration, which

is generally celebrated August 6th (cf. Russell 1992).

 

The Hemshinli have also preserved a few isolated Christian items in their lexicon. For

example, unlike the Laz, who have replaced their original Caucasian word for ‘god’ with Turkish

tanr¥ (Dumézil 1937), the Hemshinli have preserved the original Armenian word astuac

astuac in the form asbac (aspaj), which shows up in expressions such as asbac xenta…na

Ïeziki aspaj xendacna kezigi ‘may god make you joyful’. The form aspaj is only attested

elsewhere in the dialect of Akn, which as we have already seen must have once been in closer

contact with the Hamshen Armenians. Xenda…na is the causative subjunctive of the verb xenduß,

which preserves the original meaning of the Classical Armenian verb xndal xndal ‘rejoice, be

joyful’, unlike standard modern Armenian, wherein this verb now means specifically ‘to laugh’.

One can also notice in this blessing the dative suffix -gi, which is only found in Homshetsma.

 

Another interesting remnant of the Hemshinli's Christian past is the verb xaæuß xaçuß,

which means ‘to nail an entrance shut with two boards’; in certain situations it can also have the

more generic meaning ‘to close’. Cengiz describes this verb as being based on the image of the

two boards nailed on top of one another in perpendicular fashion. This suggests that the verb is

derived from the Armenian noun xaæ ƒaæ ‘cross’, which has been lost in Cengiz’s dialect as part

of the general dechristianization of the lexicon.

 

So far we’ve seen that the conversion to Islam has resulted in a striking dechristianization

of the language and culture of the Turkish Hemshinli. However, as can be seen from the tale of

Temel's Head, the assimilation of the Hemshinli to their Turkish neighbors has had a more

general impact on their language and culture as well. The younger generation has assimilated

many of the basic characteristics of Turkish pronunciation, so that the @ ("ghad"), which in most

forms of Armenian is pronounced as a voiced uvular fricative @, is pronounced by the younger

Hemshinli in the same manner as Turkish @ (yumußak ge "soft g"), that is either as a barely

audible uvular approximant, or as nothing at all. The older Hemshinli, on the other hand, still

speak with what we can call an Armenian accent.

 

There has also been a massive influx of Turkish vocabulary, to a much greater extent

than we find in other Armenian dialects.

 

Homshetsma has also assimilated Turkish syntax to a degree not normally found in

Armenian dialects. For example, Homshetsma has developed an equivalent of Turkish -mi/

m¥/mu/mü, which serves as an indicator of yes-no questions. The use in this capacity of ta,

which originally meant ‘that, if, or’, corresponding to standard Armenian †ê.

This peculiar usage of Armenian †ê as a marker of yes-no questions also occurs in the nearby

Xotorjur dialect to the south, but otherwise is unattested in the Armenian-speaking world.

 

Turkish has also found its way into Homshetsma poetics. For example, the eastern

Hemshinli have a saying vur Ïeæi ßepe…u xeæi vur keçi ßebecu xeçi, literally ‘hit, goat, hit, so

that it falls down’, used to goad someone into action. The efficacy of this idiom crucially

depends on the linguistic tools available exclusively to the Hemshinli: living in a Turkishspeaking

milieu, they can play the Turkish verb vurmak ‘hit’ against its Homshetsma equivalent

ßebecnuß (which does not seem to be used in standard Armenian, though it is found in the

dialects of Van, Erevan, and Ghazax). Similarly, the Hemshinli can rhyme the Turkish word keçi

‘goat’ with the Homshetsma verb ƒeçuß ‘fall’, which again is rare in standard Armenian. Word

plays of this type are no longer possible among the northern Hemshinli and other Armenian

groups who do not speak Turkish.

 

 

Another interesting example of wordplay in this mixed Turkish-Armenian context is the

counting rhyme in following, which Cengiz’s mother used to teach him the numbers from one to ten:

 

meg, terone pe®g - one, a hoe outside

ergus, terone çapa - two, a hoe outside

yiyek, govu tek - three, a cow’s placenta

çors, jile nors - four, sparse corn sprouts

hink, terone di(n)g - five, a goatskin sack outside

vec, kenafin tec - six, smelly air in the outhouse

oxte, dolavin tuxte - seven, the sheet of paper in the cupboard

ute, terone tute - eight, the mulberry outside

ine, valan hine - nine, the old pants

dase, tarkin tase - ten, the bowl on the shelf

 

Notice here that whereas the middle word is often of Turkish origin, the rhyming couplet is

always drawn from the native Armenian word stock, with two exceptions, çapa and tas. The

former is particularly interesting, as it alone fails to rhyme with the number it accompanies. This

striking asymmetry suggests that the rhyme for ergus ‘2’ was originally some native Armenian

lexical item, which was subsequently replaced, perhaps when the meaning of the original

Armenian form was forgotten.

 

It is important to notice that the Hemshinli are not simply assimilating features of

standard Turkish language and culture, but rather of local Black Sea Turkish. Thus, for example,

the Turkish Hemshinli no longer employ the Christian Armenian month names, but they also do

not employ those found in standard Turkish. Month names such as kuçux guÀux ‘February’

and æurux çurux ‘July’ are clearly related not to the standard Turkish forms ßubat and temmuz,

but rather to the forms we find among the Turks of Çaykara to the southwest, küçük and çürük

respectively, and to those we find in Kars to the south, g'üÀük 'February' and Àürüg ay¥ 'August'.

Other months such as sifte güz ‘September’ and gaakeß ‘December’ are also of Turkish origin--

siftah güz in Turkish means ‘first autumn’ and gaakeß derives from kara k¥ß ‘black winter’ (cf.

Kars gara-g¥ß, Erzerum GarG¥ß)--but again do not correspond to the standard Turkish forms eylül

and aral¥k.

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1.4. Language

 

We’ve seen so far that the language and folklore of the Hemshinli have much to tell us about

their identity, their history, and their social and geographical context. I’d now like to present a

case study that demonstrates this point more forcefully, but in order to do so it is first necessary

to provide a general overview of the history and structure of the Homshetsma language.

 

A number of conditions have conspired to make Homshetsma one of the most divergent

and interesting varieties of Armenian. The Hemshinli moved from the original Armenian

homeland to an area of isolated mountain villages at a time when the Armenian language was

still relatively homogenous, and had not yet developed the incredible diversity that characterizes

the hundreds of modern Armenian dialects (Weitenberg 1983). Consequently, Homshetsma

preserves a number of important archaisms that were levelled elsewhere, and has also developed

a host of peculiar innovations not found in other varieties of Armenian. The fact that the

language is not written has entailed that Homshetsma has not undergone any influence from the

classical or literary dialects, which to the best of my knowledge makes it unique among the

Armenian dialects. Homshetsma therefore gives us our only glimpse of what Armenian in its socalled

‘pure’ form would look like, untainted by loanwords from Classical Armenian and not

stripped of the Turkish component of its lexicon.

 

A number of features distinguish Homshetsma from all other dialects of Armenian.

Whereas all other varieties of Armenian form the infinitive by adding to the verb stem the

suffixes -el, -il, -al, and so on, Homshetsma adds only the suffix -uß. Our tale for example

contains two infinitives, enuß ‘do’ and inçecnuß ‘lower’, corresponding to standard Western

Armenian ånel and iÀe…nel respectively. Homshetsma, like many western dialects, actually has

four classes of verbs according to the vowel they take in conjugation, but all of these select the -uß infinitive.

 

Adjarian (1911:189) plausibly relates the -uß suffix to the Turkish participial suffix -iß, as in al¥ßveriß

‘trade’, whereas Dumézil 1963 prefers to derive it from Persian.

 

Homshetsma is also unique in using the verb unnuß ‘have’ as an auxiliary: in northern

Homshetsma it is used to form the progressive tense, and in eastern Homshetsma it is used to

form the perfect tense, in a manner similar to Germanic and Romance languages.

 

Homshetsma is also unusual relative to other Armenian dialects in using the Middle

Armenian plural suffix -vi- as a singulative marker for paired body parts (the one possible

parallel is Zeytun). Other dialects use forms such as aævi and unÏvi, but these forms are

always plural in meaning -- ‘eyes’, ‘eyebrows’ -- whereas in Homshetsma they are singular, the

plural being formed by adding the regular plural suffix -niye.

 

Though the use of this particular suffix is unprecedented, the semantic development it reflects is

paralleled in standard Armenian, where the Classical Armenian plural suffix -Ï (-k) is employed

to mark the same paired body parts as well as certain other singular nouns.

 

Like most western Armenian dialects, Homshetsma employs the affix gu to mark the

present and imperfect tenses. The distribution of this affix is peculiar in Homshetsma, though: it

appears after polysyllabic consonant-initial verbs, and before vowel-initial and monosyllabic

verbs.

 

In terms of lexical material, Homshetsma possesses a host of words unparalleled

elsewhere in Armenian, such as the form hohol or xorxol, which means ‘owl’; the standard

Armenian form bu/pu is unknown to Hemshinli. Another isolated form of unknown origin is

galaß ‘wind’; again, Hemshinli have not heard the standard Armenian forms hov hov and Ïami

Ïami.

 

On a lighter note, Homshetsma seems to be unique amongst the Armenian dialects in

having a voiceless coarticulated dental and bilabial trill, which we find for example in the

expression used to call baby chickens, tBi ÀiÀi. This sound occurs as a regular phoneme in the

nearby Caucasian languages Ubykh and Kabardian, but does not appear to be phonemic in

Homshetsma. Homshetsma also differs from standard Armenian in pronouncing r as a retroflex

alveolar approximant, in the same fashion as speakers of standard American English. One also

hears this pronunciation among elderly Armenians born in Turkey.

 

Two other linguistic features that distinguish Homshetsma from all but one or two other

Armenian dialects are the change of a to o before nasals that I mentioned earlier, and the use of

the -o@ participle to form the future tense. The change of a to o before nasals is only paralleled in

the dialect of Akn, which as we have already seen is closely related to Homshetsma, and in the

dialect of Aslanbek in western Turkey. However, we happen to know that the Aslanbek

community was formed by immigrants from Akn and Hamshen. Interestingly, this particular

change is also attested in our earliest known Armenian manuscript, the Moscow gospel, which

was written by a scribe from Kars, just to the south of Hamshen, in 887, not long after Hemshinli

arrived in the area.

 

The basic verb is inçuß ‘descend’, from which we form a causative inçecnuß ‘cause to descend,

lower’. To make the future tense of this causative verb, one removes the infinitive suffix and

adds the participial suffix -o@, followed by forms of the auxiliary verb ‘be’. We know from other

forms of Armenian that -o@ was originally a present participle suffix, so that the entire form

originally meant something like ‘I am lowering’. The development of present progressive

formations of this type into future formations is amply attested in the world’s languages,

including English, which has forms such as ‘I’m going to the store tomorrow.’

 

Homshetsma also preserves a number of archaic features that have been lost in standard

Armenian. I have already mentioned the verb xenduß; another striking example involves the

formation of the past tense. Indo-European, the ancestor of Armenian, formed the imperfect

tense by prefixing an e- to the verb root; so, for example, the word for ‘he carried’ was *ebheret.

The expected outcome of this form in Armenian is eber, which is in fact what we find in the

Classical Armenian aorist. Standard Modern Armenian has entirely lost this e- augment, though,

so we now have forms like Standard Western bere… §ere…. Homshetsma, however, preserves the

augment; their form for 's/he brought' is êbi epi.

 

The relation in which Homshetsma stands to other Armenian dialects is somewhat complex.

Nevertheless, we can say that Homshetsma is clearly a Western Armenian dialect. For example,

it shows the voicing of original Armenian voiceless unaspirated stops that characterizes almost

all western dialects.

 

We also know that the original form of Homshetsma, before it split into the three modern groups,

contained a set of sounds known as voiced aspirates: {ph th kh ch çh} (bh dh gh jh Àh). These

sounds are preserved in the Christian dialect of Mala (in Trabzon), but have merged with the

original voiceless aspirates in Cengiz’s dialect (since voiceless stops are predictably aspirated in

Cengiz’s dialect, as in English, we do not write the aspiration).

 

These two properties of the Homshetsma consonant system, namely the voicing of original

voiceless unaspirated stops and the aspiration of original voiced stops, are consistent with the

historical evidence that the Hemshinli came from the Ayrarat region, since the local dialects of

Ayrarat share these properties (Markosyan 1989).

 

The variety of Homshetsma spoken by eastern Hemshinli has a number of interesting

innovations. The epenthetic vowel, which normally surfaces as schwa in other varieties of

Armenian, surfaces as e in eastern Homshetsma and as a before the sounds x and @.

The only other dialect of Armenian in which this change occurs is Tigranakert.

 

Eastern Homshetsma also shows a predilection for metathesizing stop + sonorant

clusters, particularly at the end of a word; so, for example, original taygr ‘husband’s brother’

becomes dark; original …amaÏ ‘dry’ gives the verb cokmecnuß ‘dry out’; original ßitak

‘straight’ gives the verb ßigduß ‘heal’; hawki† ‘egg’ becomes hagvit; nósr ‘sparse’ becomes

nors, which we saw in the counting rhyme; ak®ay ‘tooth’ becomes arga; and so on (26a). This

metathesis also applies to some loanwords: Turkish haber ‘news, narrative’ (originally from

Arabic) gives xarbuß ‘speak’; küfür ‘cursing’, also from Arabic, gives kerfuß ‘to curse’; and so

on.

 

In the domain of vocabulary, Homshetsma has undergone a variety of interesting semantic

changes. The word canr, which originally meant ‘heavy’, has become in Homshetsma the word

jond, which means only ‘pregnant’. pêtÏ, which in standard Armenian means ‘need’, in

Homshetsma means only ‘well, good’, as in inçbes es? bedk im ‘how are you? I’m good.’ The

original Armenian root ƒel-, which survives in the standard Armenian forms ƒelÏ ‘brains’ and

ƒelóÏ ‘clever(ly)’, is preserved in Homshetsma only in the form xelok, which means ‘quickly’.

 

With this linguistic background in hand, I’ll now present a case study demonstrating that

careful examination of a people’s language and folklore can reveal important facts about their

past.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...