Aratta-Kingdom Posted February 25, 2007 Report Share Posted February 25, 2007 Panorama.am 19:02 24/02/2007 SUMGAIT .... A TRAGEDY OR CONTINUATION OF GENOCIDE? Today a discussion was held on `Sumgait tragedy and its political consequences' at the initiative of student-youth organization of Social Democratic Hnchak party, `Sargis Tkhruni' in Yerevan. Youth and public organizations participated at the event. Larisa Alaverdyan, executive director of public organization `Against Legal Violation' mentioned in her speech that the events of 80s executed by Soviet Azerbaijan were the continuation of policy adopted by Osman Turkey in lat 19th century, namely, to execute the population which did not consider themselves as Osmans. `Sumgait is not a single act but the continuation of the policy which was accomplished in 1923,' Avalverdyan said. `We did not win a victory in Karabakh but protected our right for life on this planet,' Robert Melik-*****ev, refugee from Baku and chairman of human rights organization `Return Haik,' said. He believes we lost a lot in Azerbaijan, including Armenian land. He also believes that Sumgait, Baku, Kirovabad and Maraga are the continuation of Azerbaijani-Turkish politics. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
SanVal Posted February 25, 2007 Report Share Posted February 25, 2007 The purpose wasn't to get rid of the people who weren't Osmans. They didn't do anything to the Russians and the Jews, some of whom continue to live there. It appears that the Russian churches and cemetaries still stand there today. What happened during the pogroms in the republic was that they went door to door, after having obtained lists of residents with Armenian surnames (which, given the fact that there was nothing like white pages there at the time, must have been done through government offices). So, they were targeting Armenians, not non-Turks. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Aratta-Kingdom Posted February 26, 2007 Author Report Share Posted February 26, 2007 you are right salval, the azeris were targeting the armenians and thats an act of genocide. if they were to go after the russians and the jews, the soviet army which was in the city in those days, would have stop them. can you even for a secong think what could have happened to the azeris if they were to touch a single russian? right after the collapse of the soviet union, the azeris targeted all the others that they could not touch while under the moscow rule. just remember the story of gary gasparov. that being said, for the record i must say that the azeris were holding turkish flags in their hands and were calling themselves 'turks' in the early days of the war. once they realized after forming a union with turkey would mean to share the oil money, they put the turkish flags down. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Zartonk Posted February 26, 2007 Report Share Posted February 26, 2007 that being said, for the record i must say that the azeris were holding turkish flags in their hands and were calling themselves 'turks' in the early days of the war. once they realized after forming a union with turkey would mean to share the oil money, they put the turkish flags down. Interesting. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
SanVal Posted February 27, 2007 Report Share Posted February 27, 2007 you are right salval, the azeris were targeting the armenians and thats an act of genocide. if they were to go after the russians and the jews, the soviet army which was in the city in those days, would have stop them. can you even for a secong think what could have happened to the azeris if they were to touch a single russian? right after the collapse of the soviet union, the azeris targeted all the others that they could not touch while under the moscow rule. just remember the story of gary gasparov. that being said, for the record i must say that the azeris were holding turkish flags in their hands and were calling themselves 'turks' in the early days of the war. once they realized after forming a union with turkey would mean to share the oil money, they put the turkish flags down. Yes, that's true. It's also telling that the only democratically elected leader of the country since it gained independence was a man who considered himself a Turk. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
hosank Posted February 27, 2007 Report Share Posted February 27, 2007 well they make it easier for us.. they are all turks, no matter what border. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Aratta-Kingdom Posted February 27, 2007 Author Report Share Posted February 27, 2007 SanVal, Elchibey, was pan-turkist and also a mamber of grey worlves terrorist organization. Elchibey had the support of the azeri people because he promised to clean the turkish soil from those who were not osmans. The Aliyev family is not different, except for now they rather keep the azeri-turks in a dark so they can packet the oil money. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
MosJan Posted February 27, 2007 Report Share Posted February 27, 2007 http://www.untimely-thoughts.com/index.html?art=2212 Democracy and Human Rights ? Democracy and respect for human rights, just as for all the other liberal values, go together – this seems to be the accepted wisdom. A careful student of the spreading of democracy, however, can easily prove that this is a mere fallacy, an assumption that just does not square with facts. Notin the Soviet Union or Former Soviet Union, anyway. In the post-Stalinist period, the Soviet Union remained an extremely undemocratic, totalitarian country, an evil empire, to quote Ronald Reagan. Freedom of speech, zero. Freedom of political associations, ditto. Freedom of conscience, ditto. Freedom of travel, ditto. We all know the list of those iniquities. But, consider the ultimate human right – the right to live. When did this right enjoy greater respect – before or after the democratic revolution, the overthrow of communism, and the collapse of the “evil empire’? Don’t tell me; let me tell you. In May 1987 I paddled in a seven-foot-long kayak along the western coast of the Caspian, starting at Samur on the border between Dagestan and Azerbaijan and finishingin Sumgait. I traveled solo, spending the nights on the beach, sleeping in the kayak and feeling absolutely safe, though sometimes my sleep was disturbed by sturgeon poachers. In the daytime they were not averse to taking a pot shot at a strange boat apparently heading for their nets, but I had the sense to paddle straight for the shooters, to show them how tiny my ridiculous boat was, and how innocuous the solitary wanderer. They then remembered that a traveler is the Prophet’s gift to the faithful, and treated me accordingly. The trip was tough but great, and I promised myself to start next yearin Sumgait and continue southwards. Well, I never did, nor am I ever likely to do. Next year "Sumgait" became a word that dripped blood and inspired horror as it hit the world's papers and TV screens. At that time Azerbaijan and Armenia were already at each other’s throats over the disputed territory of Nagorny Karabakh, with Popular Fronts, the first shoots of democracy, so to speak, active on both sides.In February, Azeri mobs rampaged through the streets of Sumgait , killing, raping, maiming, beating up Armenians and plundering their homes. Horror stories quickly reached Moscow of pregnant women's bellies being ripped up, and similar atrocities. Some 30 people were reported dead, and 197 wounded and beaten up. TheAzeri police let the pogrom run its bloody course for three days, before unarmed federal troops were sent in – only to be attacked by mobs armed with knives and iron bars. There were more casualties, this time among the troops. Russians, mostly. And that is the whole thing in a nutshell. The lifting of totalitarian, imperial order, the rise of “democratic” Popular Fronts all over the outlying regions of the Soviet Union aroused the basest instinctsin the “demos” of those lands, varying only in the degree of bestiality. The nice phrase to describe those feelings was “aspirations of sovereignty.” In sordid fact, it was bestial nationalism; it was pure Nazism. If you did not belong to the “titular nation” or ethnic group, you had no human rights at all. Certainly not the ultimate human right, to live. Ask Meskhetian Turks. In 1989, just as the First Congress of People’s Deputies, then the highest achievement of democracy in the Soviet Union, was winding up, a murderous conflict erupted in the Fergana Valley in Uzbekistan between the local population and the Meskhetian Turks deported there during the Second World War. Sixty thousand of them had to be flown out of Uzbekistan, leaving behind about a hundred killed by the Uzbeks, and taking with them about a thousand injured. Their original homeland wasin Georgia, on the border with Turkey – but could they be brought back to Georgia, which was then staging mass rallies and hunger strikesin support of democracy? Even vague rumors of such a move nearly sparked violent protests among the local Georgian population. So the Turks had to be scattered over the vast, long-suffering MotherRussia, many of them in Krasnodar Territory. Here, they are not treated by the local Cossacks with exquisite courtesy, that is true, but pogroms? Killings? Not on your life. Still, their plight is laid at the door ofRussia, and there is a lot of noise about a hundred of them being resettled in the US. Not in their native Georgia, though. Their native Georgia is a beacon of democracy now; a democracy that stops short of permitting these people to go back to their ancestor’s land. It would be a good idea for Amnesty International to inquire into the matter, but somehow I feel certain it won’t. OK, Meskhetians are a small people. Now, what about the fate of millions of Russians and Russian speakers (who could belong to any of the 100 plus nationalities of the Soviet Union)in areas where those ethnic Popular Fronts were active? Was Amnesty International ever interested in those millions? I doubt it – yet their human rights were abused routinely and most horribly. Many lost their lives or were maimed during pogroms. Many more lost their jobs, their apartments, and all their property, as they fled for their lives from lands where their ancestors had often lived for generations. Still, all that wasin a good cause, the overthrow of communism and the destruction of the Soviet Union, so presumably Amnesty International had no business poking its nosein these laudable processes. Chechnya is the classic case, of course. In 1991 Ruslan Khasbulatov, a Chechen himself and at the time Yeltsin’s right-hand man (later mortal enemy), supported the “democratic” General Dudayev's coup against the local "partocrats"in the hope of creating a puppet – and produced a Frankenstein monster. The rape, plunder and murder of anyone passing through Chechen territory had begun alreadyin 1990, but with the coming of Dudayev it all became institutionalized. Dudayev’s first edict was on the right of every Chechen to carry arms, and an out-and-out ethnic cleansing was carried out immediately forthwith. Several hundred thousand non-Chechens – those, that is, who hadn’t been shot out of hand or hadn’t had their throats cut – scattered through the vastness ofRussia , their misery totally unrecorded by any Human Rights Watch or Amnesty International. Then came the long series of massive hostage takings and pillagingin adjacent Stavropolye by Chechen bands; the raid on Budyonnovsk in 1995, with Basayev’s gunmen shooting people in the street for fun, like partridges, then taking a thousand patients hostage in the town hospital and using women nearing childbirth as human shields – literally lifting them on windowsills and shooting at the troops between their legs; Raduyev’s raid on Pervomayskoye, with another bunch of hospital patients taken hostage and dozens dying; the 1999 attack on Dagestan, and the residential blocks blown upin Buynaksk, Moscow, Volgodonsk in the same year; the commuter trains blown up near Kislovodsk; the Dubrovka siege in Moscow in 2002; the later spate of bombings in Moscow; the Beslan school atrocity in September 2004. Not to mention little things like the slave markets and zindans, holes in the ground for keeping slaves in, in virtually every Chechen village; the beheadings of Russians, New Zealanders, or any other infidels who have no human rights at allin the eyes of these subhumans. Careful, Roy – the politically correct West is chary of calling them terrorists, even. No, they are merely “separatists,” or their own proud self-appellation, “mujaheddin.” Do we hear much about the human rights violations by these “separatists”? God forbid. Whenever human rights and Chechnya come upin Western discourse, it is always about the awful human rights record of the Kremlin, and of Russians generally, against those angelic Chechens. No doubt about it – human rights watchers are very selective in deciding what to watch and what to let go unnoticed. In the above, I touched only briefly on the human right to live and the way it fared in the transition to democracy. There is yet another big chapter in this odyssey – how the human right to a dignified life was trampled on in the course of the plunder that transition to a market economy turned out to be; how the lives of millions of people degenerated and were cut short by the privations which that process entailed. Again, do we hear much from the human rights watchers about these violations of the rights of millions? No, but we hear a great deal about the sufferings of one of those plunderers; the billions he had stolen clearly weigh more than the sufferings of millions on the peculiar scales used by our honest human rights watchers. And no wonder – democracy is at stake! Putin is backtracking on democracy! You know, lots of people here wish he backtracked some more. In America, that was called stepping on the corns of “the comparative few who seek to retain or to gain position or riches or both by some short cut which is harmful to the greater good.” The numbers ofRussia’s billionaires are growing alarmingly – which means that the plunder goes on. So if Putin is serious about backtracking in the FDR spirit, he ought to, for starters, do something about Russia’s tax system, which some people call the most barbarous and anti-social in Europe. Such a move would show that he really respects the right of human beings, his fellow-countrymen, to live in dignity, not squalor. And it would be approved by about 90 percent of Russia’s population. That’s democracy enough for me. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Aratta-Kingdom Posted February 28, 2007 Author Report Share Posted February 28, 2007 PROCESSION DEVOTED TO THE MEMORY OF VICTIMS OF ARMENIAN POGROMS IN SOUMGAIT TO BE HELD IN YEREVAN FEBRUARY 28 February 28 a procession devoted to the 19th anniversary of the Armenian pogroms in Soumgait will be held in Yerevan. The action has been initiated by ARF Dashnaktsutyun. According to the information DE FACTO got at the ARF Dashnaktsutyun Supreme Body’s Press Service, the procession’s participants would gather at the Sport and Concert Complex after K. Demirchyan. The participants will walk to the Memorial of the Armenian Genocide’s victims – Tsitsernakaberd, where they will lay flowers and wreaths, thus paying tribute to the memory of the victims of the Azeri cutthroats. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.