Jump to content

Harvard Row Over Sex And Science


Anileve

Recommended Posts

I would add, that from personal experience, I uncounter more dumb men than dumb women.

style_images/master/snapback.png

 

And I have encountered nearly as many dumb fellas as dumb gals, but in "my" dumb crowd there has been a clear tendency though: a rather big proportion of female dummies seemed to be aware of their modest abilities, keeping a relatively low profile (which makes them somewhat less dumb - and generally less harmful from the "public good" viewpoint), while the dumber the man, the more confident he seemed in his superior intelligence and abilities (hence the enormous damage caused by the activities of stupid men throughout the history?). Now if anyone has observed a similar pattern, can they explain me this particular phenomenon? Is this that very "inherent difference"?

Just kidding. :P

Edited by Solaris
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 335
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

I don't understand why it matters what a certain "scientist" thinks - or not - about your capabilities? Are you going to change the perception of yourself and the belief in your capabilities , if tomorrow a "scientific" "irrefutable" "discovery"  "proves/indicates" that women are less "intelligent" than men? I hope not!

Many scientists, sociologists, psychologists have published "irrefutable," "objective" - yet false - proofs/results in the past!

 

style_images/master/snapback.png

 

The truth is that, like it or not, such "scientific" "irrefutable" "discoveries", no matter now false, are quick to find high-ranking supporters, contributing to that very "gender stereotyping" and "discrimination". We don't even need to go far to find out how such thinking affects the treatment of women:

 

During Dr Summers's presidency, the proportion of tenured jobs offered to women has fallen from 36 per cent to 13 per cent. Last year, only four of 32 tenured job openings were offered to women.

Edited by Solaris
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I don't understand why it matters what a certain "scientist" thinks - or not - about your capabilities? Are you going to change the perception of yourself and the belief in your capabilities , if tomorrow a "scientific" "irrefutable" "discovery"  "proves/indicates" that women are less "intelligent" than men? I hope not!

Many scientists, sociologists, psychologists have published "irrefutable," "objective" - yet false - proofs/results in the past!

style_images/master/snapback.png

The truth is that, like it or not, such "scientific" "irrefutable" "discoveries", no matter now false, are quick to find high-ranking supporters, contributing to that very "gender stereotyping" and "discrimination". We don't even need to go far to find out how such thinking affects the treatment of women:

 

During Dr Summers's presidency, the proportion of tenured jobs offered to women has fallen from 36 per cent to 13 per cent. Last year, only four of 32 tenured job openings were offered to women.

style_images/master/snapback.png

 

 

I believe that I've already answered that question!

I think that it is impossible to debate this subject "objectively" and I don't encourage pseudo-scientism.  Intelligence is such a complex  concept with many connotations and forms.

.....

It's more about a culturo-socio-political struggle than an "objective" debate! What matters is that individuals - men or women - are given the same chances and opportunities to achieve their dream!

style_images/master/snapback.png

 

Do false claims and unsound ideas find echo and support in The Neocon Society? They do!

Can you "objectively" debate with a Pro-War Neocon? I sincerely doubt the usefulness?

etc. etc.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

It's actually terrific that Mouse agrees with him – we have come to a "common denominator" after all!  :partytime:

style_images/master/snapback.png

 

Let me clarify.

 

I did not say, that I was surprised that Mouse say he agree with him, what I said was that I don't understand how he agree with Siamanto.

 

Of course Mouse will claim agreeing, just to show that he has the situation under control. :) Because some of Siamantos points(not only just "points" but the most important ones) are in total conflict with Mouses ones, and the part where Siamano uses the words pseudo-scientific should have refreshed Mouses memory, from past exchanges we had, and the way he uses pseudo-science.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Let me clarify.

 

I did not say, that I was surprised that Mouse say he agree with him, what I said was that  I don't understand how he agree with Siamanto.

 

Of course Mouse will claim agreeing, just to show that he has the situation under control.  :)  Because some of Siamantos points(not only just "points" but the most important ones) are in total conflict with Mouses ones, and the part where Siamano uses the words pseudo-scientific should have refreshed Mouses memory, from past exchanges we had, and the way he uses pseudo-science.

style_images/master/snapback.png

 

Actually his points are not in conflict with mine. My arguments were based on extremes and I did elaborate several times on some of those points but of course they were ignored. Also, most of my agument was based on the notion of equality. Furthermore I said "for the most part". Now pay attention.

Edited by Anonymouse
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Could this difference be that men are more agressive and a bit more egoistic while women are more yielding and caring, even are considerate to the others' well-beings?

 

As I was writing my essay on the cultural symbolism of Ararat I started reading a lot about our history and culture again. I can't help but think that we as a nation, as a culture, are more kind, caring, and yes, yielding, than our neighboring countries. Maybe this is the reason that we still exist when all the great ancient civilizations are history, but also this is the reason that we, as a culture, have struggled so much, been tortured, always been held back... Now, more than ever, I can see a comparison between gender characteristics with that of nations and their cultural characteristics. I don't know if I make sense...

style_images/master/snapback.png

That's interesting. Likewise, I have this image of Serbs as being represented by a fair-skinned lady with coloured eyes, traditional dress, that sort of thing. Croats on the other hand immediately make me think of an Ustasha uniform - I have a difficult time drawing up a Croatian woman, even if the two (Serbs and Croats) are very close... Must be WWII in my head.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I disagree. It's the men that play chess in coffee-houses, not the women when paying their neighbours calls.

style_images/master/snapback.png

 

You have a very negative stereotype of women. There are MANY women in sports and chess is the one where they have been very active. It is not physical.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Back to the subject of this thread.

 

It is a question of brain plasticity. While men in general have a bigger brain, women brain density is higher, which mean that in a given region during the processing of information, there is more neurons available to process the data.

 

Density compensate. Einstein brain was smaller than the average man, while more dense. Which means that physically his brain was more similar to a women brain.

 

Research on brain plasticity show us that female are not less capable intellectually.

 

I have never denied there were differences between men and women, it would be foolish from my part to do that. Men do tend to have generally better visual-spacial scores, but this is more due to social conditioning than anything else.

 

A guy during his brain development, will tend to be more active, while the girl will sit and play with barbies, the boy will play with cars, trow them, run, wanting to go outside and play sport. As a result, the brain processing during his development will be concentrated with spacio-visual tasks and their solving. The interest as a kid, is social-genetic, but the brain capacity between genders is not genetic(nothing suggest they are). Thousands of years back, men had to hunt and get the meat. They had to play tricks on the pray to catch them, and then return safely.

 

Trough natural selection, this evolved as what I call “initial interest.” The boy and girl initially will have those different interests. I have observed little kids for long, and it generally work like this, while girls are generally passive, they listen more, and they are more careful at listening, while boys are more physical. What happen as a result is that in the early stage of brain wiring, the language skills are advantaged for the girls.

 

I am sure that I can test that. I think that girl and boy should NOT be raised the same way for optimal performances. I always believed that girls should be prevented from developing their language skills too early. And another part of the problem is society, and what is build as a toy for girls. Parents should buy toys for girls that will make them more active, a bicycle very early, games that will require spacio-visual skills, and the same time as being toys proper to girls. This way girls will perform more in visual-spacial but probably less in verbal. Or it is this, or it is changing the whole primary school way of teaching. The first years, girls and boys in different classes, with different programs.

 

Another thing, is the age related degeneration of the brain which is higher in man. Women have hormonal protection, this same protection, protect them against severe cases of schizophrenia. This is why for instance, there will be less women getting schizophrenia, and the average year when they get it is higher than male, and they are not affected as severely.

 

The brain neuron degeneration is marked in performance skills. Women will tend to preserve their IQ, contrary to men, and this is even observed as soon as the middle of her thirties.

 

I do think, that part of this is as well attributed to other things than brain degeneration. Since women tend to use more their white matter, and men their grey matter, the degeneration happens more in the grey matter early... this may as well explain why male are more influenced by the destruction of neurons due to age after their 20s.

 

There is ways to conditionate people to use more an area of the brain, different way of raising girls will do that. And this could even serve to treat psychiatric conditions. I have in mind a brain plasticity specialist, psychiatrist, that cured(not treated, but cured) obsessive compulsive patients by using the brains plastic capabilities.

 

I think, I am starting to go out of subject.

 

Well, in short, social conditioning is probably the most important factor explaining the subject of this thread... girls should be differently raised, we are not living in the era of the cave man, so the society should stop imposing this passive girl raising.

EDITED: I forgot to add, that in the regions where there is the highest density differences, such as the frontal lobe, women will tend to lose more neurons than men. And since the connections between emotions etc. in the brain are better define for women, this is why they will tend to get more problems associated to Serotonin neurotransmitters. So the protections they got over men, is “compensated” by this. I just referred to this, to prevent someone to jump up and answer something about this. Also, I forgot to add that once white matter start decreasing, it does faster than Grey matter... even though up until ages 40, white matter doesn't really decline contrary to Grey. As when, after women menoposes, and the hormone deficiency, the neuronal protection doesn't exist anymore.

style_images/master/snapback.png

Without going into details, I believe I had that ideal upbringing, except that, not playing with dolls, I played out adventures with fluffy animals and watched Transformers and the Adventures of Nils Holgersson as much as My Little Pony. :)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

You have a very negative stereotype of women. There are MANY women in sports and chess is the one where they have been very active. It is not physical.

style_images/master/snapback.png

Yeah, and for some reason most high school chess clubs consist mostly of boys. I must ask myself why. Mine may be a negative stereotype - but only because I wish more, not because I like looking down on members of the same sex. Social conditioning does exist even in the modern world and in secular countries - and the individualistic girls are called "tomboys"...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

...and the individualistic girls are called "tomboys"...

style_images/master/snapback.png

 

As far as I know, a tomboy is a girl who regularly partakes in physical activities like sports. And it is a term that seems to be obsolete, for the most part. The very rare times I hear that term it is used by a girl, often refering to herself. It does not seem to have a negative connotation anymore or a great frequency of use.

Edited by Arvestaked
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Yeah, and for some reason most high school chess clubs consist mostly of boys. I must ask myself why. Mine may be a negative stereotype - but only because I wish more, not because I like looking down on members of the same sex. Social conditioning does exist even in the modern world and in secular countries - and the individualistic girls are called "tomboys"...

style_images/master/snapback.png

 

In Armenia girls have always been in chess schools. Our female team is one of the strongest actually. The chess school in Yerevan is full of girls and they are never moked because usually the boys who attend chess schools are shy. I think it is rather the other way round.

 

I have not observed this situation with chess in other countries but I tend not to believe you.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

My experience in two-three countries has been otherwise.

style_images/master/snapback.png

 

I don't buy it. The same situation is in neighbouring Georgia. Their female team has always been stronger than the male team and has always been one of the leading teams in world championships. Same in Russia and especially in China. In is not socially conditioned.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I don't buy it. The same situation is in neighbouring Georgia. Their female team has always been stronger than the male team and has always been one of the leading teams in world championships. Same in Russia and especially in China. In is not socially conditioned.

style_images/master/snapback.png

 

Armen, what`s this continual cheap talk? And what`s your point? She made a comment about what she has observed in high school chess tournaments.

 

Will you buy if I say that I have observed the same here where I live as well?

 

That ex-communist countries are more open and interested to chess doesn`t mean it is the same elsewhere.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Armen, what`s this continual cheap talk? And what`s your point? She made a comment about what she has observed in high school chess tournaments.

 

Will you buy if I say that I have observed the same here where I live as well?

 

That ex-communist countries are more open and interested to chess doesn`t mean it is the same elsewhere.

style_images/master/snapback.png

 

My point is that men are much better in chess than women and not because of any social conditions but because the nature of our intelligence if different. It gives us more mental abilities in chess.

 

And it sounds like a total absurdity when you say than soviet countries where more open or interested in chess. All western countries have always participated and have been interested.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

My point is that men are much better in chess than women and not because of any social conditions but because the nature of our intelligence if different. It gives us more mental abilities in chess.

 

And it sounds like a total absurdity when you say than soviet countries where more open or interested in chess. All western countries have always participated and have been interested.

style_images/master/snapback.png

 

This has to do with brain visual-spatial abstract thinking processing... and this sort of logical thinking is influenced by early childhood conditioning. Since one of the major region of the brain involved, women have a higher brain density(15% from one Canadian study, and similar results with others)... which in terms of "brute power" seems to be very equivalent.

 

The differences here appears to be in the White matter vs Grey matter uses, and there are evidences that show that this is dictated during the first 10 years of a child, during brain wiring, and is a social conditioning.

 

A girl young, won`t like to play chess, less than a boy, it has to do with the initial interest... but when forced, this will modify her brain wiring and will make her more concentrated in those sort of abstract thinking.

 

Beethoven when young, his father was beating him and taking him from his hairs to force him to take his courses, but this helped his brain to be wired to form a genious in what he did.

 

As for chess, my friends comming from those countries likes prety much playing chess, and are all good at, but not my French Canadian friends. And from those immigrants have said, Chess was more widespread in their country of origine.

Edited by QueBeceR
Link to comment
Share on other sites

This has to do with brain visual-spatial abstract thinking processing... and this sort of logical thinking is influenced by early childhood conditioning. Since one of the major region of the brain involved, women have a higher brain density(15% from one Canadian study, and similar results with others)... which in terms of "brute power" seems to be very equivalent.

 

The differences here appears to be in the White matter vs Grey matter uses, and there are evidences that show that this is dictated during the first 10 years of a child, during brain wiring, and is a social conditioning.

 

A girl young, won`t like to play chess, less than a boy, it has to do with the initial interest... but when forced, this will modify her brain wiring and will make her more concentrated in those sort of abstract thinking.

 

Beethoven when young, his father was beating him and taking him from his hairs to force him to take his courses, but this helped his brain to be wired to form a genious in what he did.

 

As for chess, my friends comming from those countries likes prety much playing chess, and are all good at, but not my French Canadian friends. And from those immigrants have said, Chess was more widespread in their country of origine.

style_images/master/snapback.png

 

I think that the density you mention helps women in some cases and plays against them in others. And that's a clear evidense of our differense.

 

And the experience of soviet states with chess is a clear evidense.

 

I think the beating developed Beethoven's will and ego more than his brain.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I don't buy it. The same situation is in neighbouring Georgia. Their female team has always been stronger than the male team and has always been one of the leading teams in world championships. Same in Russia and especially in China. In is not socially conditioned.

style_images/master/snapback.png

Like Quebecer said, all those are ex-Communist countries, China still Communist. If you're going to hold the opportunities men and especially women are given in these types of countries with the others, whether it be school, sports, or others, then I really have nothing to say to you, especially with such "flippant" arguments about Beethoven's ego.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Like Quebecer said, all those are ex-Communist countries, China still Communist. If you're going to hold the opportunities men and especially women are given in these types of countries with the others, whether it be school, sports, or others, then I really have nothing to say to you, especially with such "flippant" arguments about Beethoven's ego.

style_images/master/snapback.png

 

You're out of arguments

 

BTW, Armen, what's your point if you iterate that the world's best female chess player ranks 150th and women's teams were better than the men's in Georgia? :rolleyes:

style_images/master/snapback.png

 

Georgian women play better when they play with women from other countries not when they play Georgian men's team.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Well, I do find it interesting that in games like chess men and women are separated in competitions. I understand this division in physical sports, where it would be obviously unfair to have women and men compete against each other, but chess? A mental sport?

 

Storms, I think the point is that in these (ex-)communist countries where women are given equal opportunities when it comes to chess, men still do better compared to women. I'm sure there are women who could beat Armen at chess with a snap of their fingers, but so far no woman has proven to beat the likes of Kramnik and Kasparov. Can you explain why?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...

×
×
  • Create New...