Jump to content

Harvard Row Over Sex And Science


Anileve

Recommended Posts

This is where Mouse gets his inspiration from. In fact many other prominent minds of the Austrian School of economics are slaves to this pompous and “disinformed” belief. Ironically they also admire Ayn Rand who happens to be an advocate of individualism and who is farm from a domesticated creature. Where is the prevailing male logic some of you boast about?

http://www.mises.org/econsense/ch1.asp

style_images/master/snapback.png

 

First of all, don't speak on where I get my inspiration(s) from as you do not know. Second of all, I had never ever seen that article before. I read it and I am curious as to what is your point? I do not see a contradiction in what the article wrote and an admiration for Ayn Rand. How about without making spurious statements you actually make the connections as opposed to unsubstantiated assertions. I know this forum is where the feminists are high and mighty and I know you are annoyed at some of my posts but at least be a bit more clear in what you're trying to say.

 

Can you perhaps name a few of the "many other prominent minds of the Austrian School of economics are slaves to this pompous and “disinformed” belief"? Murray Rothbard has also wrote the following:

 

I do not go so far as the extreme male "sexists" who contend that women should confine themselves to home and children, and that any search for alternative careers is unnatural. On the other hand, I do not see much more support for the opposite contention that domestic-type women are violating their natures. There is in this as in all matters a division of labor, and in a free market society every individual will enter those fields and areas of work which he or she finds most attractive. The proportion of working women is far higher than even twenty years ago, and that is fine; but it is still a minority of females, and that’s fine too. Who are you or I to tell anyone, male or female, what occupation he or she should enter?

 

I know this might sound scary to some of you but that above snippet is from Murry Rothbard's classic Against Women's Lib from The Individualist written in 1970. Have a look.

 

http://www.lewrockwell.com/rothbard/rothbard4.html

Edited by Anonymouse
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 335
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

I never suggested that anybody sought to gain directly from an argument. I never suggested I thought anyone needed a reason other than disagreement to argue. But since you mention it, there is always something to be gained by supporting the more accepted cause, especially if it has moral overtones.

 

People are harming themselves by convincing themselves that there is more to the subject than there actually is. I addressed that already. They are overly sensitive and ignorant. Saying Person A is probably smarter that Person B does not mean that Person B is not smart. This is obvious. And so is the fact that comparative generalizations between groups says nothing about a given individual in a given group and therefore is not cause for feeling personally attacked as such an individual. The fact that people get insulted only proves my point.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I think if we "weight" the contribution of male and famle intelligence to the overall development of humankind we will come to a conclusion that none of these two kinds of intelligence is replaceble.

 

If we take ANY example of human advansement in ANY spere and manage to dig deep into the real course of actions, actors involved, dicisions made, breakthroughs etc. (which is almost impossible) we will inevitably come to a conclusion that both kinds of intelligence are involved in almost any historical event this or that way.

 

I view the nature of male and famale intelligence different because that's what I have seen in my life. Even women with equal opportunities act differently, therefore they have a different kind of intelligence. To get a statistical evidence on the achievements is impossible. Intelligence generally deals with number of other charactaristics males and females have. E.g. women are more immune to long term emotional pain (and there are many other examples of this on boths sides and both positive or negative). All these characteristics must be taken into account when we discuss "intelligence" because cirmustances are always the environment where we act.

 

Where this difference comes from? Just the analysis of different physical and physiological processes in males and females will reveal that even if we have the same type of "intelligence" before say 12-13 it all changes after that. There are many unanswered questions that make this discussion very subjective. E.g. how come females start developing faster than males in there teens? No matter how much scientific evidence you find even on the micro-genetic level, you will never get to the source of the impulse on this particular process. If you don't know the answer to this question ALL other evodence is going to be only partial.

 

Why males have been dominant all this time is a theme of different discussion. Before that there was Matriarchal society and there was a reason for that. These processes change when the mission of that particular process in society is accomplished. The history of humankind is also a history of development of human consciousness. These kind of processes (like male domination this or that kind) develop human consciouness on certain level. E.g. after all these thousands of years, only at present humans are starting to grasp on the level of consciousness what is "male domination", why is it, how is it.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I know Dusken, our views are similar on certain points. There was a call to register an opinion...

style_images/master/snapback.png

How cute. Another male bond is formed. An addition to the secret brotherhood. How about a title for your fraternity: "Malelligence" Yes, I think it's quite suitable. I've made the necessary changes.

 

With time he [dusken] grew more angry and resentful towards women who displayed paramount characteristics of intelligence and strength. He turned his rage into a continuous set of monologues trashing women and their “inherent disabilities.” Fortunately to him, his fallacious claims were reinforced by an equally scarred someone by the alias of Anonymouse [and Armen]. Both later formed a covert brotherhood of cantankerous misogynists, secretly desiring the feel of a cold stiletto heel of an intelligent woman against their delicate post-teenage cheeks.
Edited by Anileve
Link to comment
Share on other sites

First of all, don't speak on where I get my inspiration(s) from as you do not know.

I can pretty much speak about what I please without the need to back it up with any factual claims or any consideration for your feelings regarding the issue. That is what you call an "opinion" after all. Isn't it what you practice?

 

Second of all, I had never ever seen that article before. I read it and I am curious as to what is your point? I do not see a contradiction in what the article wrote and an admiration for Ayn Rand. How about without making spurious statements you actually make the connections as opposed to unsubstantiated assertions.

Hmmmm....how about...NO?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

You are misusing the idea of Occam's Razor. It is actually funny that you mention it because it does more to support the position you are arguing against. That is why...

 

It is a possible explanation that holds no weight whatsoever and that was always my point. Possible explanation? So is the idea of variation in potential. So is the idea that this is all a dream. So what?

 

I am not unfamiliar with the basics of anthropology.

 

Explain to me? That is laughable. Domino made no plausible arguements. Half the time he was not even addressing my points and the other half was entirely illogical. It is easy to gain support of an audience when you hold popular ground, ignore someones responses, and reply with rhetoric and red herrings. Such a powerful legion you have!

 

"Oh no! Someone is skeptical about a socially accepted idea revolving around gender! He must be illinformed and just plain terrible! Tar and feather him." Seriously, that is my biggest problem: the fact that someone who holds a politically correct, popular belief is, by default, smarter and cooler than the ignorant skeptic who deserves to be attacked when there is not a preponderance of evidence to support either position. It is a narrow-minded "my team is better" mentality. Why is your team better? "Because it's my team!" Oh crap. Sorry. That makes sense. Summers is quite obviously a cornhole but nobody addressed his lack of tact or choice as a forum for expressing the idea, et cetera. They just made these comments to the effect of "How dare he question such a thing! What an idiot!"

style_images/master/snapback.png

 

And you told you were through with this topic… The "boring circus" seems to be addictive, huh?

 

Re the Occam Razor: no, it does not support your idea, if your idea is that of inherent genetic differences.

Our question is: what is the possible explanation of gender disparities in science? We have i) the gene hypothesis – in fact a speculative assumption, as opposed to ii) the uncontested evidence of consistent subjugation, gender stereotyping, discrimination and disparagement. ii), no matter what you say, does hold weight – we all know that it exists. One should have a rather creative imagination to consider the speculative assumption as a more plausible explanation than the one based on well-established facts.

 

The thing is that building your argument, you seem to be assuming the very thing that is being challenged. You a priori assume that those differences do exist, while you still need to substantiate them since they have been challenged. So you substantiate them by pointing to the under-representation of women – the very thing that needs to be explained (and which may in fact have other explanations, such as the host of factors having disadvantaged women). This is a very common vicious-cycle-like mistake. :msn-cry:

 

Re anthro: it doesn't look like you are familiar with its basics. But don't worry, I'm not going to quiz you – at least not here and not now. :P Nor am I going to tar and feather you - you may live, I am merciful! :P

Edited by Solaris
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Eve, you're getting political ...

 

If you disagree that there is a difference in the intelligence consider this.

 

Does the PMS influence decision making? What results does it produce over a lifetime?

 

Similarly, how does testasterone influence lifetime decision making?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Back to the topic and related... Like I mentioned, before someone in need of collecting their wits spoiled in, there's this thing about women in sports I'm itching to look into.

In one of the articles posted by Sulamita (much thanks, btw!), it said something to the effect of men and women's competition events being segregated because of this whole spatial cognition issue.

Some cave-men would drop in and say that men and women aren't equal in sports. :) I'd say that the concept of "equality" doesn't exist in the realm of sports any more than it does in scientific/medical terms. Cave-men would thank me and say men and women are hence unequal, but the crux is that the concept of "inequality" can't exist, either, if "equality" can't. :)

That's not the point, though - but, aside from brunt, I really don't see women in such a disadvantageous position. If anything, I enjoy watching women's tennis more than I do men's. There's more pizzaz in a match with Martina Hingis than with Pete Sampras - or was, and hopefully we shall see her back soon. And I've had a couple of guy friends agree with me on this, and I double-checked that it wasn't about the skirts. Tennis, after all, is one of those where the efficacy of strength is confined by the "point of diminishing return," even if not as much as with badminton, where on international levels you have mixed teams of one male and one female. Now why is that, and for one as intense as badminton?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Eve, you're getting political ...

 

If you disagree that there is a difference in the intelligence consider this.

 

Does the PMS influence decision making? What results does it produce over a lifetime?

 

Similarly, how does testasterone influence lifetime decision making?

style_images/master/snapback.png

Pray tell - just what is the long-lost link between intelligence and decision-making?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Pray tell - just what is the long-lost link between intelligence and decision-making?

style_images/master/snapback.png

 

I see you have difficulties with connections. How do you otherwise find out if a person is overall intelligent or not if not by his/her decisions making (problem solving, inventive capabilities etc)?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

And you told you were through with this topic… The "boring circus" seems to be addictive, huh?

 

It is difficult to resist attacking stupid comments. I will try harder.

 

Re the Occam Razor: no, it does not support your idea, if your idea is that of inherent genetic differences.

Our question is: what is the possible explanation of gender disparities in science? We have (a) the gene hypothesis – in fact a speculative assumption, as opposed to (B) the uncontested evidence of consistent subjugation, gender stereotyping, discrimination and disparagement. (B), no matter what you say, does hold weight – we all know that it exists. One should have a rather creative imagination to consider the speculative assumption as a more plausible explanation than the one based on well-established facts.

 

I think you confused yourself. The question is whether there are differences in abilities. Occam's Razor, as I am sure you know, has to do with chosing the simplest of two possibilities as an explanation. Though my point is not truly dependant on this idea, it is, as I suggested, more similar in spirit than is your point. This is because one can look throughout history, and show that men have a tendency to dominate (and I know you would not argue that because you bring up oppression.) By having something observable to show that men have consistently dominated is a support for a belief that it is a natural and inherent characteristic. It is not any more speculative than a "line of best fit." Your position is what is speculative because you are accepting the idea on faith. You mention "uncontested evidence of consistent subjugation, gender stereotyping, discrimination and disparagement." All of that is uncontested by me, as well. But this only shows that women were not given the opportunity to act according to their potential. It does not logically prove that the potential in question is equivalent to that of general male potential. As I said before, and I would hope that before attacking me you had actually read my posts, it is possible that women have the same intellectual potential as men but that possibility is not enough to warrant verbal aggression toward one who does not agree.

 

 

The thing is that building your argument, you seem to be assuming the very thing that is being challenged. You a priori assume that those differences do exist, while you still need to substantiate them since they have been challenged. So you substantiate them by pointing to the under-representation of women – the very thing that needs to be explained (and which may in fact have other explanations, such as the host of factors having disadvantaged women). This is a very common vicious-cycle-like mistake.  :msn-cry:

 

I am not assuming differences exist. I am deducing from observable historical things that even you accept as true. Has there consistently been differences in performance? Yes. It is safe to say, at that point, that the simplest explanation is that there is an inherent difference between the genders. Anything further is less simple. Should it be ruled out? No. But it should also be logical and should not be accepted on faith because some people are insulted. If you want to contest a line of best fit you need to have quite a precise formula that produces better results.

 

Re anthro: it doesn't look like you are familiar with its basics.

 

What are you basing this on, really?

Edited by dusken
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Decision-making is about evaluating alternatives and making a choice. Problem solving is about focusing on an issue and coming to a resolution. The two can be employed, one to the other, but otherwise can be mutually exclusive. Inventive capabilities have nothing to do with decision-making.

Moreover, to hold the sway in hormone levels in females "against" their intelligence is like taking into account a flu or a man's horniness according to whether he's getting any or not.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Decision-making is about evaluating alternatives and making a choice. Problem solving is about focusing on an issue and coming to a resolution. The two can be employed, one to the other, but otherwise can be mutually exclusive. Inventive capabilities have nothing to do with decision-making.

I did not mean the term "decision-making" as applied in professional policy analysis or evaluation. Any logical and mental move and, as a consequence, the action you take is a decision. If you invent something all your actions involved are decisions. If you come up with a solution it is a decision. We can name it "decision taking" if you want. The action of decision is present in all the situations mentioned.

Moreover, to hold the sway in hormone levels in females "against" their intelligence is like taking into account a flu or a man's horniness according to whether he's getting any or not.

style_images/master/snapback.png

You are not reading what I write. I did not say it is "aganist". I impyed that it changes the "decision" and nature of intelligence as an outcome. I can bring examples where the difference of famle intelligence because of hormons is positive rather than negative as compared to men. Flu is not a permanent condition. PMS and horniness are there for the greater part of life.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Eve, you're getting political ...

 

If you disagree that there is a difference in the intelligence consider this.

 

Does the PMS influence decision making? What results does it produce over a lifetime?

 

Similarly, how does testasterone influence lifetime decision making?

style_images/master/snapback.png

Armen, your views are very skewed. To answer your questions:

 

No. Definitely not life altering, I don't know anyone who blamed PMS for passing up on a scholarship to NYU or a lifetime opportunity to work at a job of their dreams and as a result spending the rest of their life begging in the streets....all because of PMS. It doesn't.

taking into account a flu or a man's horniness according to whether he's getting any or not.

:D

Link to comment
Share on other sites

You are not reading what I write. I did not say it is "aganist". I impyed that it changes the "decision" and nature of intelligence as an outcome. I can bring examples where the difference of famle intelligence because of hormons is positive rather than negative as compared to men. Flu is not a permanent condition. PMS and horniness are there for the greater part of life.

style_images/master/snapback.png

You mentioned PMS, and, if not only for its relation to "other times," PMS is considered by all as a negative. I needn't expand on why.

I gave the flu because it is more debilitating, for lack of better words.

PMS is not there for the greater part of life. It is part of the cycle and doesn't last half the month or anything. Taking a balanced diet, exercising, promoting overall health relieves symptoms, and the "Oh I am PMS-ing" - "She is PMS-ing" scene is a fact of bum city life only. For something as regular and expected as PMS, you might as well take into account certain regular attacks of persons suffering from one disease or deficiency for life. And Eve's words were right on.

Beware of a woman near a red button days before her menses.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

You mentioned PMS, and, if not only for its relation to "other times," PMS is considered by all as a negative. I needn't expand on why.

It is negative but it may have some positive consequences as far as psychology is concerned. It goes in cycles as you noticed and it may have a disciplinary effect. As much as I have seen women need comfort and they always secure it beforehand. This might develop a sense of alert on conscious level that may be used in other areas of life.

PMS is not there for the greater part of life. It is part of the cycle and doesn't last half the month or anything. Taking a balanced diet, exercising, promoting overall health relieves symptoms, and the "Oh I am PMS-ing" - "She is PMS-ing" scene is a fact of bum city life only. For something as regular and expected as PMS, you might as well take into account certain regular attacks of persons suffering from one disease or deficiency for life. And Eve's words were right on.

style_images/master/snapback.png

Haven't you seen how people who are attacked because of some disease or deficiency always develop a different thinking?

Edited by Armen
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I don't know anyone who blamed PMS for passing up on a scholarship to NYU or a lifetime opportunity to work at a job of their dreams and as a result spending the rest of their life begging in the streets....all because of PMS. It doesn't.

style_images/master/snapback.png

 

There are many people and things you don't know Eve. If you're not comfortable with the PMS thing consider another charasteristic that may develop a different thinking and intelligence: women's need to be wanted and its influence on their deicisions.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I never suggested that anybody sought to gain directly from an argument. I never suggested I thought anyone needed a reason other than disagreement to argue. But since you mention it, there is always something to be gained by supporting the more accepted cause, especially if it has moral overtones.

 

People are harming themselves by convincing themselves that there is more to the subject than there actually is. I addressed that already. They are overly sensitive and ignorant. Saying Person A is probably smarter that Person B does not mean that Person B is not smart. This is obvious. And so is the fact that comparative generalizations between groups says nothing about a given individual in a given group and therefore is not cause for feeling personally attacked as such an individual. The fact that people get insulted only proves my point.

style_images/master/snapback.png

 

First of all, my answer didn't concerned you; it was just an open statement nothing more.

 

Now, can you tell me what I will gain from my position? The only thing that will happen, is for me to waste time answering others, and give Mouse the occasion to spew his nonsensical crap.

Edited by QueBeceR
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I think you confused yourself. The question is whether there are differences in abilities. Occam's Razor, as I am sure you know, has to do with chosing the simplest of two possibilities as an explanation. Though my point is not truly dependant on this idea, it is, as I suggested, more similar in spirit than is your point. This is because one can look throughout history, and show that men have a tendency to dominate (and I know you would not argue that because you bring up oppression.) By having something observable to show that men have consistently dominated is a support for a belief that it is a natural and inherent characteristic. It is not any more speculative than a "line of best fit." Your position is what is speculative because you are accepting the idea on faith. You mention "uncontested evidence of consistent subjugation, gender stereotyping, discrimination and disparagement." All of that is uncontested by me, as well. But this only shows that women were not given the opportunity to act according to their potential. It does not logically prove that the potential in question is equivalent to that of general male potential. As I said before, and I would hope that before attacking me you had actually read my posts, it is possible that women have the same intellectual potential as men but that possibility is not enough to warrant verbal aggression toward one who does not agree.

 

What you are doing is using circular logic. Since I do believe you are intelligent enough to know what you did wrong here, I have to conclude that you did it on purposes. An “explanation” is part of the argumentation, and not the theses. But here you present a sub theses that contain an argument itself.

 

This is what you do:

 

The theses is supported by the sub theses, which is supported by an argument. Your theses is that men have more intellectual abilities than women. Your sub theses, which is used as argument to support it, is that there are more male historic figures... and your argument explaining this, is that men are more intelligent,(men have more abilities) and because of that there are more male historic figures in those concerned disciplines.

 

Now pay attention to what is in the parentheses. “Men have more abilities,” this is the argument for the observation about historic figures. This argument is as well the theses which is supported by the historic figure.

 

What you are doing is using circular logic. “Men are more intelligent because there are more males...” and “ there are more males... because men are more intelligent.”

 

Solaris point was logical, it contained your first theses, and divided the two arguments, yours and hers, those arguments were the explanation, and then, she applied the Occam's Razor. This is how Occam's Razor should be applied.

 

I am not assuming differences exist. I am deducing from observable historical things that even you accept as true. Has there consistently been differences in performance? Yes. It is safe to say, at that point, that the simplest explanation is that there is an inherent difference between the genders. Anything further is less simple. Should it be ruled out? No. But it should also be logical and should not be accepted on faith because some people are insulted. If you want to contest a line of best fit you need to have quite a precise formula that produces better results.

 

Again, you got that wrong, because you are using circular logic, while Solaris compares the two explanations, what you do is to present two interdependent claims, one being the argument of the other. Please stop doing that, you are starting to act like Mouse.

 

In short, that is what you are doing.

 

X is right, because of Y, Y is right because of X.

Edited by QueBeceR
Link to comment
Share on other sites

On average, women do better in certain verbal skills and men in spatial and mathematical skills.
style_images/master/snapback.png

 

Sorry, I haven't read much of what else has been written on this thread, except for scanning over bits and pieces, but I did want to comment on this.

 

Just today, I did a little test along with my fellow students (boys and girls) in which we got to hear four different spatial descriptions and were asked to draw them out. This was a verbal as well as a spatial skill test, obviously.

 

Everyone got the first assignment completely right (the easiest one). On the other hand, no one got the following descriptions entirely right, although girls were closer to the actual description than boys (as compared to the answers we got in the end).

 

Was this to do with verbal skills, in which women are better anyway, or with space in which men are supposed to be better? Either way, women scored higher on both skills.

 

As for PMS, I'll just give you this much: I hardly doubt that for most women this has a great impact on what they normally do. From personal experience, I know I only "suffer" from PMS, physically and/or psychologically, once every few months. Physically I feel a bit of pain, or feel like eating and drinking more than usual. Psychologically, I might feel a bit depressed or unable to concentrate well. This phase, in its worse form, usually lasts no more than two-three days. In other words: nothing to worry about.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

As for PMS, I'll just give you this much: I hardly doubt that for most women this has a great impact on what they normally do. From personal experience, I know I only "suffer" from PMS, physically and/or psychologically, once every few months. Physically I feel a bit of pain, or feel like eating and drinking more than usual. Psychologically, I might feel a bit depressed or unable to concentrate well. This phase, in its worse form, usually lasts no more than two-three days. In other words: nothing to worry about.

style_images/master/snapback.png

 

Do you forget about it after it is gone and do you make some arrangements in your daily surroundings some days prior to it? Or, don't know, some changes of schedule?

 

Is it making you more organized?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Why would I think about it after it's gone??

 

Armen I think someone already said: do you plan a flu, or other illness? And if it's okay for you to take a week off because of a flu once or twice a year, why is it not okay for a women to take a day off once every few months?

 

Or do you organize your migraines? If so, does that make you more organized?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...

×
×
  • Create New...