Sip, It has been my experience that the majority of the funerals I have been to fall into the 'tragic' category, more so than the 'lead a long, fruitful life, and now it's time' category. At least in my family. But IMO there's sadness in saying goodbye. Whether it's preventable or not. Many things are inevitable, but I personally cannot claim to be made of such steel that my emotions remain un-moved simply because something is natural, or preventable, or not. Yes, I have to live/die with it - but I do react to it. And yes, I agree that on some occasions in fact, a funeral can become a celebration of lives lived, as opposed to a sad event. My grandfather, after being orphaned during the AG, and subsequently struggling to educate himself, established a large family and was surrounded by his children, grand-children and great-grandchildren when he passed away. Yes, it was sad to see him go - but he had lived a full life - and we were happy his suffering was over.