Jump to content

Boghos

Members
  • Posts

    1,746
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    4

Everything posted by Boghos

  1. Marriage is a contract betwen two people, any combination of people. It should stop there. The state should recognize that and all the implications of what was a "traditional" marriage should apply to whatever other combinations. This is state-church separation. As to children, I must say that the idea of adoption by gay couples is not that attractive to me but since we have to make choices on a least worse basis sometimes, then I´ll go with Winston´s argument.
  2. Why complicate matters ? Stormig´s second to last post is to the point, I am sorry to say that I have to commend her just for having common sense. Moreover, a person doesn´t embody a government or even a whole people, a state, city, neigbhorhod or even the building he lives in (maybe the house, but only if he is single and deprived of pets or other living companions). Unless you subscribe to stereotypes, which of course would make you a living stereotype and proof perhaps that at least some stereotypes have a degree of truth in them. Armenians, as many other people are prone to stereotyping (typing in their stereos ? ) but focus on Turks, the source of infinite evil and sadism. I concede that my perspective on things finds a sadistic trait on Turks more pronounced than many other peoples. Historical circumstances have made them even worse. This, of course, is no justification for anything, for History has nothing to do with being right or wrong, just or unjust, so on, this exists on a true sense only at an individual level and does not scale up to larger levels. We have to recognize that there are important national characteristics of peoples and that is as far as it goes. You cannot be ashamed of something you did not choose to be or do, but perhaps you can be sorry or regret the treatment of reality. If a Turk came to me and said: "I am sorry for what we did to you", I would hope he finds a good shrink, for that is the expression of a misplaced guilt feeling. I much rather hear, as I did, that: "here is Boghos, from one of the peoples that constitutes our national heritage". It is not only true but it is more authentic. BUt people have different preferences on what they want to hear... Now, on this history of a popular feeling towards whatever issue, how hopeful can we be when millions of people buy products that will make them muscular, sexy, and provide them with an incredible memory among other miracles ? Should we expect that Turks as a whole feel ashamed for whatever reason ? Has any people in history felt truly ashamed of anything ? Not that I recall. Some have learned from the extremes that they can go to in terms of cruelty to others and have put barriers against their own perceived shortcomes. But those are a minority. But as I said countless times it is those with a severe guilt feeling that have the most to gain from acceptance. It has nothing to do with shame but with understanding where they came from.
  3. Hello TB, I see your point. But is there really any hope for that ? I think on an individual level you can understand certain unpleasant characteristics of your people, but how can "shame" permeate the national conscience when those feelings are those that also make others like "pride" and such, arise ?
  4. I think regret is more appropriate because first it is more authentic and second it at this point in time it makes more sense. Gult feelings, shame can only be attributed to those that comitted the crimes, not his descendents. But at the end of the day that is discussing, as we say, the sex of the angels.
  5. Personal issues aside (Steve, please...) I much prefer "regret". Shame sounds more politically correct but it is indeed too Spielbergeresque.
  6. I concur. This is an area in need of dire improvement. Most of the stuff has a 70s look. As for coins, there used to be a site for the Armenian Numismatic Society...
  7. After seeing a few pictures I understood what Cheney meant by welcoming Americans with "open arms".
  8. A small country such as Armenia has on a net basis a lot to gain from having an open economy. Of course there are some industries that will not survive but that means that these industries are being subsidized by the Armenian consumer. In other words, Armenians pay more for the privilege of having an Armenian made something. We need to be competitive, for that we need the lowest possible cost inputs. Armenia will never be an industrial powerhouse, one would have to be delirious to believe that. Our vocations is in light industry and services with some specialty extractive and agricultural products thrown in. Opening the borders has the same rationale as breaking up the telecom monopoly: cheaper and better services. Certainly in the beginning unemployment might even go up, but if we don´t believe we can compete, in the right places, then what is the point of all the arguments about our industriousness and otherwise above average entrepreneurial and inventive capacities ? Should we fear Turkey ? Should we fear their cheap cookies, cheap textiles and so on ? Of course not, as Stormig mentions they are already there, but are just more expensive given the cost of going through Georgia. Opening the border means growing up, accepting the reality of a competitive world AND profiting from it. Armenians move and have moved all over the world often starting from scratch, not even knowing the local language properly and the like. What kind of argument can be made for keeping the border closed ? None, unless our self assessment is 180 degrees wrong.
  9. Hello Knight, Have a great trip. Tatev is a place I particularly like and I am glad you´ll be visiting it. mx5, I have always defended that if an Armenian from the diaspora is really serious about Armenia and Armenians he should visit the country. Have a nice trip and good luck with your plans.
  10. I am not a big fan of turkey myself, but if you are ever in New York check out a place called Viand on Madison and 62nd if I remember properly. It is owned by some sleazy Greeks but they make an excellent turkey sandwich.
  11. A long time ago I told my grandfather that the dried figs he was eating were from Turkey, he said: "Sometimes a fig is just a fig".
  12. Apparenty she was not the only one : http://www.armenianow.com/2004/april23/new...ition/index.asp
  13. Boghos

    Sharagan

    http://www.armenianow.com/2004/april23/arts/singer/index.asp
  14. Boghos

    Dual Citizenship

    Birth right means that citizenship is given to someone who was born in that place. You were referring to blood right or jus sanguinus, that is according to your ascendency, Germany is probably the best known example of blood right, up to recebtky Turks that were born in German soil were not entitled to citizenship. An obvious case of birth right is the US.
  15. Boghos

    Sharagan

    No broblem, boss .
  16. Boghos

    Sharagan

    I have just listened to Anush and Inga Arshakyan singing Gomidas. I didn´t know them, very good.
  17. You mean diplomacy I suspect. I don´t think we are as bad at it as many portray it.
  18. *due to lack of time, unedited* This issue should never have been transformed into a battle of pessimists vs. optimists. I think this is in part a result of the difficulty that some of us have in accepting some tough facts that transcend desire, in other words to face reality in its most simple facets. I tend to resort to ironies and sarcasm in instances where I feel that a reasonable attempt to have a debate, failed. I concede that one may not achieve the best results by doing that but that on the other hand it becomes necessary when the sense of self importance and know it all populism takes charge, such as in the case of most of Pirate's writings. In any case the Pirate´s initial thesis seems to arise from the issue of sexual repression rather than anything else and this is what hould have been discussed instead in transforming it in a platform for his endless, boring and obviously narrow preaching. But he does write well, if in excess. I have said here and in other threads that I believe stongly that we´ll see an Armenian renaissance in coming years. I think that we are seeing pessimism both in the diaspora and in Armenia proper at its highest levels ever, at least in contemporary history. At the same time Armenians everywhere, in different ways react to this pessimism by planting seeds that will eventually grow and blossom. We tend to overlook positive change in these times of despair, this is the time to buy "Armenia", when nobody wants her. How many Armenians are optimistic on the future of the nation ? the government of the RoA ? diaspora leaders ? our parties ? and so on. Very few to none. But this is nothing new. Our last experience in self government is lost in centuries, we are learning to walk, and this learning experience involved already a number of traumatic events that have made it even more difficult, such as the Karabagh War, the blockades and so on. Even though Armenians are quick to vote with their feet out of economic, political or whatever reason, I believe I should say again that I have faith in the future of Armenia. We are too resilient to simply give up, I was watching once again the documentary about Stalinism in Armenia "Enemy of the People", for me that is a strong representation of some of the things that our people is about: persistence, honesty of purpose, sometimes even some extremely attractive naiveté . Look at how much has Armenia improved since indepedence, most people will say that I am out of my mind by saying this. But I believe that a country under the unfortunate circumstances of Armenia has done a good job, certainly much beyond what we would have liked but nevertheless and unqualified success, again, given the possibilities. Education has improved: nostalgics will refer to the Soviet period and point out how it was free, that people had a chance to go to Moscow for good advanced degrees, and so on, and that today we have corruption in admissions, it is expensive, etc all true but corruption was prevalent even before and we had only one verson of facts, today there is much more offered, there is AUA, Russian University, think tanks, scholarships and exchange programmes with universities around the world and so on. Armenian opened up very quickly to many ideas that already circulated but were nto open for debate, and all this in spite of the government. How many good hotels are there in Yerevan ? Evev with the apparently impossible task of having a national carrier from how many places an you fly into Yerevan ? Sure there is a myriad of problems: telecom is major impediment to low cost access to internet for example, public health is in very poor condition, unemployment is high. But isn´t it amazing that in a country with so many economic and social problems, war and sabotage there is very little domestic violence ? The most important source of violence is the government, and even that will not last forever. Hence the focus should be Armenia. That is our only sustenaible lighthouse, that´s where I would like to send my kids to spend summers, where I would consider buying another home, where our meaningful intelligentsia will assert itself. Not only a lighthouse but a safe harbor. In spite of all the atempts by internal or external leeches, we will eventually overcome.
  19. By Belge there is also the publication of Jenosid in 1995, the turkish version of "Genocide as a problem of national and international law". Translation by Yavuz Alogan.
  20. "I am half-armenian, half-french (not a strong partisan of mixed marriages though)." Now you may go and play with your toys. So long.
  21. It all comes to the fact that we have to rely more on our own capacity and not on the goodwill of others, governments sympathy for Armenia and Armenians is just an illusion as it has been shown time and again. Of course we have to be diplomatically skillful, but that is a different thing.
  22. You seem to be deprived of the most elementary analytic logic as your statement shows. The second paragraph contradicts the first... At the root of these contradictions might be the fact that in spite of being half-Armenian you are against mixed-marriages. Bravo ! It is not a matter of reasoning in what you call "limited categories" but rather that you do not have the knowledge to understand what I am saying. In any case, enough time has been wasted on you and your brother in arms.
  23. I am not quite clear on what is heroic willpower but suffices to say that emotions and rationality are not contradictory concepts. We should not go much beyond the end of the XIX century to observe how blind voluntarism led to more harm than good. Yervant Odian has a very good representation of this in "Comrade Panchoonie". Maybe heroic willpower is having a sticker in your car that says "Fedayner". Yes, I have seen it, with an Armenian flag in the background, unfortunately these revolutionaries which I am well acquainted with very much enjoy the empty symbolism involved in these actions but do very little in practical terms to help the cause of Armenianism. Their biographies are nothing but failure, with the exception of one Turkish flag burning here and there, grafitti and the like. Do you think Asala helped Armenia and Armenians, for example ? The anti-intellectual tradition is alien to Armenians, insofar as it doesn´t negate the inherent practicality that permeates our culture (even though it often doesn´t seem like it). Armenians tend to be good problem solvers, no wonder we have excellent engineers, doctors, chess players, mathematicians, physicists and so on. So appealing to some kind of primordial spirit is nothing but cheap populism. Armenians that subscribe to this sort of view have created a deep split in communities around the world, to the point that marrying a member of the "other camp" was considered almost a crime. Is that conceivable ? Is that acceptable ? Isn´t that an absolute contradiction ?
  24. I was also surprised about how easy it was. It worked the first time. But I am not a Sip or Azat , hence my reaction.
  25. Easiest way: download it through WAP and that´s it, I guess it also depends on your mobile. Or download it to your PC and then transfer it to your mobile.
×
×
  • Create New...