Cult theater and exits to hell notes about role-identity, conversion and rites of passage
Elitist social activities led by charismatic leaders who demean and often dread the surrounding reality are commonly called “cults.” However, cult activity takes many other forms that may not demean or dread the social environment. For example, the Society for Creative Anachronism includes a cult of fantasy and character roles assumed by members during Renaissance festivals and events. Outsiders are entertained, not threatened or demeaned, by such cult activity though some members may be obsessed with their roles. Movies and shows take on cult status when individuals attend repeatedly, often participating with ritualistic behaviors, dress or responses. In the broad sense cult activity is common within a wide variety of social and business groups. Stock market players focus on a cult of profits when they repeatedly trade shares for no other reason than monetary gain.
Cult behavior and obsession are often not far apart. Non-aligned spiritual seekers who dabble in many forms of religion and the occult often venerate the “path” itself as it leads to their primary cult object, the transpersonal Self. Cult ritual exists in clubs, churches or “orders” that have degrees or levels of initiation—Freemasonry, Latter Day Saints, Elks, Knights of Columbus. Cults are easiest to recognize when adherents dress, talk or behave differently. The cult label does not indicate levels of appropriate or abusive activity.
Cults attract negative attention when group activity is systematically harmful, irrational and/or illegal. The Flat Earth Society may be a socially benign cult, but it obsesses over an irrational belief. Breatharianism has around 5000 adherents worldwide—practitioners eat very little and believe that humans ultimately can live on air alone. In Australia in 1999, the leaders of a small breatharian cult were convicted of killing a disciple. Cock fighting represents a gaming cult that exists in illegal territory.
Many cults actually utilize theater and stage productions to influence members. Rudolf Steiner (died 1925), the founder of Anthroposophy, established an art form on stage called Eurythmy that has both didactic and ritual meanings. Sri Chinmoy, a controversial guru, since 1966 still stages musical performances featuring himself [clumsily in my experience] improvising with many instruments. The ICC and the Potters House Christian cults put on morality dramas as tools to teach and recruit. G. I. Gurdjieff (died 1949) created many forms of theater for his cult members, chiefly when the group lived or met at a commune in France: “The door to the Prieuré was guarded—you had to ring loudly to get in—and once in, the strange combination of monastery, labor camp, and Mad Hatter’s Tea-Party excluded the world beyond the institute’s walls; a world from which Gurdjieff’s Citroén arrived….like an intruder from reality” (Webb, 548).
Social groups that teach doctrine meant to radically separate members from family and the out-group are especially targeted by the many counter-cult organizations as “destructive.” Another feature of tightly organized counter-social groups is a totalist one. Such groups practice “idealogical totalism,” an expression coined by Robert J. Lifton (1961) in his studies on "brainwashing” in China. A common feature of totalist cults with their characteristic closed system is their “continuous theater” of rituals and roles that makes the “in-group” or members distinct from non-members. Lifton calls it “psychological closure”—a condition of perception that does not easily entertain conflicting information. If you are not “on stage” as a committed player, you’re not saved, enlightened, or in higher consciousness. Cults become most controversial when their theater is continuous with no way out without condemnation by the group, and their presentation is too bizarre or condescending for outsiders to appreciate or tolerate. A social system is “closed” when no authority figure outside the group management has value concerning questions of doctrine, behaviors or management.
Brainwashing or conversion
How a member assumes a role in a controversial theater is a process often with two names from two points of view: The in-group and supporters may call it conversion, but the out-group and critics may call it brainwashing. The reverse could also be true as “brainwashing,” coined by writer Edward Hunter in the mid-twentieth century, was derived from the Chinese concept hsi nao, properly translated as “thought reform.” Thought reform for the larger, sacred cause of the group agenda was (is) a good thing in Communist China. To convert means to transform or change—to change from one perspective, doctrine or religion to another. Brainwashing or thought reform implies a program or systematic manipulation of a recruit to replace out-group thoughts and behaviors with in-group ones. Conversion implies similar manipulations by the in-group, but it does not carry the pejorative baggage associated with brainwashing in modern, western culture. For the most part the general social reaction is tolerance toward conversion to, say, Catholicism, the Baptists or the Methodist Church, but is suspicion about conversion to controversial new religious movements—the “con” is emphasized as recruits are seen as being taken into the confidence of a spurious group. A common perception is that new recruits are brainwashed into joining controversial or fringe groups, whereas they convert to main line religions.
Stage Hypnosis and hidden agendas
Most of you reading this have experienced or seen a hypnotist perform on stage. Typically, the performer selects audience volunteers who pass certain tests. The hypnotist establishes rapport as an “authority figure,” and he or she is looking for compliance and suggestibility in any volunteer. Because it is entertainment, rapport is not difficult to establish--the hypnotist is hiding nothing despite the participants who may be ignorant about suggestibility. Recruiters for cults most often seek people with whom they can establish rapport and who they can entertain with stories about their own conversion, doctrine, leader or group. Recruiters from controversial groups, like Amway, tend to disguise their group until they are pressed or after initial indoctrination sessions about the “beneficial” nature of their agenda.
The hypnotist might do a general test for suggestibility, for example, by asking audience members to clasp their hands and fingers together above their heads. He will pace them all through a slow count, put them under what appears to be a mild trance, and suggest that their hands are now “locked” by an invisible force. He will then state that many of them will not be able to pull their hands apart at his command. Some will not be able to pull their hands apart. He wants those people up on stage because they have demonstrated suggestibility to his authority. If they come up on stage, they demonstrate compliance and “trust.” Now he can go on to direct the show. The hypnotist does not want skeptics, the insane or rebels on stage as they can ruin the act—the cult recruiters also screen out such non-compliant types.
By instinct and by imitation of how they were recruited, many cult recruiters inadvertently mimic the techniques of the stage hypnotist. After establishing rapport with someone the recruiter can expose a special interest of the recruit indicated through appearance or “costume,” a pamphlet, or merely talk. Engaging someone to assume a listening attitude is the same as inducing a mild trance, thus increasing suggestibility. Once engaged the recruiter will instinctively evaluate the new prospect and determine how much compliance the recruit is willing to give. They may meet again alone or the recruit may be quickly invited to a group meeting. At this stage, the new recruit has also established dependence on suggestions made by his recruiter who is now an authority figure for this interesting “news” or new path. Suggestions about performance [behaviors] may come quickly, such as: “Be careful not to talk about this to anyone not in our group—they may not understand and you need to know more so you do not misrepresent us, and we have been harassed by unenlightened people.” Thus, the suggestion that outsiders are unenlightened has been planted.
The performance aspect depends on how quickly the new member learns scripts (group jargon) and assumes roles (group rituals and behaviors). A stage hypnotist can induce instant performance because the expectations are not complex, life changing, or threatening. To briefly pretend to be a famous German chef after a hypnotist has relaxed your inhibitions is humorous; to assume a complete role in support of your salvation, a role that might include shunning your family and old way of life, is grave. The latter role demands elaborate absorption of new choreography and an ultimate doctrine. It may take months to learn. To perform properly a new recruit must emulate role models—many will take on the accent or language style of the leaders, for example. The role models generally savor the chance to teach what they have learned or assimilated. This teaching ritual offers power of authority and it reinforces conviction. It also enables the recruiter to imitate their hero, the guru or leader who choreographs and directs the cult theater.
Radical splits: Gnosticism revisited
Groups that create an impressive cosmology that devalues the physical world while exalting the “knowledge” (gnosis) of spiritual states recreate ancient gnosticism. Pratkanis and Aronson in the book Age of Propaganda wrote a chapter on “How to become a cult leader.” Step two of seven states that you must use a “granfalloon” technique that requires the creation of an in-group of followers and an out-group of the unredeemed: “If you want to be chosen, you must act like a chosen one” (p 243). Gnosticism thrived in many forms and cults from the first through the fourth centuries—most Gnostic myths extrapolated from the Christian Gospels. The Gnostic teachings veered from traditional Christianity that found good values in the created world—Gnostics preferred that the physical creation disappear altogether as it was a horrible mistake not created by the true or “alien” God. Cults that find little good in the world and society around them reflect Gnostic values. The hallmark of Gnosticism is a radical form of dualism that separates spirit from matter. This often has the effect of separating believers from family and social connections that value the material world more. A spate of new religious movements founded in the 20th century revived the radical dualism of Gnosticism in many forms.
Confusion with expectation enables manipulation
“How am I to perform” is a statement of confusion framed in a question. Every new recruit, like every new employee, goes through stages of confusion and dependence. The hypnotist’s subjects are also confused on purpose due to a high-paced delivery and quick changes in suggestions. The compliant subjects on stage are easier to manipulate if their expectations are aroused—and they are. They expect something weird to happen and they expect the hypnotist/guru to come up with the guidance as to what. Another way to look at this is through the eyes of a long suffering, battered woman—she got that way most likely because her expectation of love in a marriage was confused by attempting to perform for a husband who can be charming, but has an anger disorder. Battered women remain in abusive relationships due to confused dependence. Confused people have difficulties making clear decisions. Once a compliant subject has merged into the manipulative field of influence, it is difficult for the subject to exit on out-group terms—he or she no longer has psychological, and perhaps physical, control over the terms of exit, and exit could mean hell, more abuse, insanity or death.
Unlike the stage hypnotist or Broadway director, the cult guru offers no normal way out of his or her theater. The exit becomes an exit to hell, a return to insanity or a fallen world, or, a ticket to injury and death. The cult is now the only reality “worth” pursuing, and the world is divided between the saved and unsaved, the sacred and the profane, the enlightened and the ignorant. The tighter the script, the stronger the boundary between us and them, and the greater the degree of exclusivity [our leader is the only One], the more difficult it becomes for the believer to exit. The member’s only “choice” is to perform better. Healthy, socialized groups offer a wide latitude of self expression within their rules, offer a way to challenge and remove leaders when necessary, and do not condemn outsiders merely for not believing as they do. Groups or cults become destructive when exits are psychologically or spiritually barred for reasons that become corrupt when the member takes the time to see what is actually going on “back or off stage.”
Off stage reality: don’t look behind that curtain
Most new religious movements and cults fail because the leaders are immature or unstable authority figures who perpetuate grandiose self-myths and develop paranoid policies toward critics. These closed systems tend to collapse within a generation or two as leaders hoard power to change corrupt policies and hidden agendas. New devotees and old are constantly influenced to avoid dissent. Doubt and criticism of the teacher and doctrine demonstrates lack of faith, intelligence and spiritual advancement to the in-group. The typical devotee will proudly dismiss or justify any evidence of sexual, financial or legal indiscretion by leadership as misinterpretations or outright lies. They will blame “mid-managers” or new devotees who allegedly acted on their own. The ultimate copout is to claim that critics are not enlightened enough to grasp the ways of the leader.
In totalist groups, rarely does one act “on his own” volition. If you do not follow the script, you may become an outcast and lose all right to participate as a cast member in the “kingdom” on stage. Every feeling and thought is micro-managed and compared to teachings and group expectations in a totalist milieu. If a thought or feeling deviates from the script, the devotee learns to admonish himself. If the devotee expresses any doubt or deviance, the milieu will admonish him. Suggestions and vague hints are as powerful as commands in cult-theater. Mind control or policing one’s thoughts in the name of loyalty or “faith” can be more effective than an armed guard to keep oneself from exiting the theater stage.
In the wonderful fairy tale, The Wizard of Oz, we can find ample illustrations of theater processes that cults often mimic. Dorothy and her small dog, Toto, are swept away into a magical land after Dorothy suffers a blow to the head during a tornado. Dorothy experiences an altered state of consciousness, and her entire field of reference was altered—she is in a different world and wants to go “home.” But she also wants to save Toto from legal destruction—Toto represents her reasonable faith in what is right and wrong. In cults, the definition of home is altered. First, Dorothy must find the wizard [guru, leader] who has the power to direct her homeward. She is thrust into a world of forces, both good and evil. Many new cult recruits experience this internal tug-of-war during initiation stages between forces that would dissuade them from reaching a leader, especially one they need to obey if they are to get “home.”
The Oz tale ends with the backstage revelation that the Wizard is a mere man, a charlatan who manipulates his stage presence to maintain power over his flock. Toto, the force of reasonable faith, exposes the false god by pulling the curtain on him. The difference between this charlatan and the average deluded or unscrupulous cult leader is one of character—the Wizard wisely rewards his disciples after he is exposed. He leaves Oz under the committee rule of wisdom, charity and courage—Scarecrow, Tin Man and Lion. Demented and paranoid leaders control members by crudely devaluing challengers and defectors. The Wizard capitulated to his critics--real men who replaced his fake power with authentic values. The good witch, Glinda, at the end instructs Dorothy that she always had the power to go home—all she had to do was click her ruby slipper heals and repeat “There’s no place like home” three times. She has saved her faith [Toto] from wicked legalism—she feels safe to go home. Glinda represents free will aligned with true and healthy purpose. Similarly, many cult members will not dare leave the set until back stage experience and information [often from former members, sometimes from exit counselors or news articles] expose the true nature of their theater director and the underlying, corrupt message of their performance.
Rite of passage
According to Arnold van Gennep, who published Les rites de passage in 1908, significant transitions in the life-path and perception of any individual are often accompanied by “rites.” For example, rituals and ceremonies often accompany a young man or woman in transition into adulthood in traditional societies. These rites vary in technique from sympathetic and contagious to direct, indirect, positive, and negative (van Gannep, 14). Although members and new recruits argue for positive features in their transitions into a controversial cult, the negative features can easily undermine their claims when examined from ex-member testimony and investigative report. The value of controversial cult life, if any, for the former member comes from a keen awareness of a radical transition that changed them for life—converting to and later emerging from a controversial cult is an extraordinary rite of passage. The lessons can be unlike any available in other life transitions. Depending on their experience and character, people emerge from cults with varying degrees of insight into matters sacred and profane, and of effects in their body-mind worlds.
Although most people eventually exit, or dare to exit, from high-demand, controversial groups, not all of them like Dorothy in the Oz story are ready to “go home” with their lessons. Many linger in familiar fields of religious pursuit hoping to salvage some meaning from a corrupt experience. For example, many former Hare Krishna devotees pursue Bhakti (devotional) styles of Hinduism for some time, while others have found relevance in fundamentalist Christianity where the legalism and literalism repeat similar doctrinal approaches of the Hare Krishna sect. Ex-members of groups that emphasize vegetarian diets often hold on to their non-meat lifestyle for some time. It is not unusual for ex-members of puritanical groups to continue to uphold moral rules from their group experience, but some react by taking on behaviors forbidden by their cult. What they cannot retain is that special position on the cult stage as a committed actor in some cult leader’s grand scheme.
All the world is a stage
Life takes on deeper meaning during the most dramatic events or “rites of passage” in people lives. These events can be celebrations, comedies or tragedies. We tell and retell stories about these events—novels and plays are wrapped around such dramas. The Christian Gospel is a traditional example of high theater in print that continues to inspire over a billion people. The story of Jesus for them is the ultimate drama. People often find meaning and inspiration in theatrical presentations—they go because they get to feel a catharsis, be it in joy, sadness or fear, that is not available to them in an everyday experience. It should be easy to understand why so many cults thrive in the spiritual and self-improvement marketplace when you consider that many people enjoy being special and “on stage” despite the hardships of a non-stop show with high demands on the actors. Many ex-members are depressed just after exiting, partially because life is not as energized or directed or special as when they were cult bound. It can take time to regroup and take on a mundane role in a world that is not so exciting, at least not until the ex-member realizes the freedom to act in a less restricted, more responsible way.
References:
Lyman Frank Baum, The Wonderful Wizard of Oz
Giovanni Filoramo (1990) A History of Gnosticism
Gillian Harris, April 6, 2000. ‘Starvation guru given hostile reception.’ Dundee Courier,
Scotland, p. 9.
Robert J. Lifton (1961, 1997) Thought Reform and the Psychology of Totalism
Anthony Pratkanis and Elliot Aronson (1991) Age of Propaganda
Arnold van Gennep (1908, 1972) The Rites of Passage
James Webb (1987) The Harmonious Circle