Jump to content

tigranisbasileus

Banned
  • Posts

    137
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by tigranisbasileus

  1. Ara Baliozian says if I remember that you can name three greek philopsophers, french or german philisopher but try naming three armenian philosophers? Our high horse is called Hellenism and not greekdom, and its value is determined by odars...not ourselves! My conclusion is that subjectuvely you can love your culture but in the case where an armenian hooks up with an odar, let's say a greek or an italian: even if the child shall be brought up ideally 50% mix, representing both: because of positive reinforcement of these two odar cultures, objectively being more popular and easily identifiable, he'll identify more as a greek or italian more: i.e brand recognition. The only reason I agree with intermarrying for armenians is because you can't convince certain odars to bring up their children exclusively armenian: if you try and expose them to both, still one will dominate.... Cultural darwinism
  2. kathe fore pou diabazo tin graphein sas xaipomai.... ellhnas einai autos pou eixei labei ellhnikhn paideia... mpravo sas pou den fobosaste na milate...kai gi'auto eimaste o monos laos pou sas bohthame...giati h leksi filotimo den uparxei se alllh glossa kai gi'auto bohthisame tous smyrnoarmenides kai tous kon-poliotes...
  3. ] Dear Hyers, I fall into the category of an ODAR like you choose to call me, being in a serious relationship with a beautiful girl, which happens to be armenian. I just recently discovered the meaning of the word odar so I find it delightful to see it being tossed around so freely. First, I must state I have the utmost respect for the armenian culture. I believe it to be beautiful, just ilke my girlfriend. I know it must piss off some of you guys to see my girlfriend in love with me and vice-versa. Quite frankly : I believe it not to be your business. If everybody kept to their own, rather than criticize others choices we would be better. Secondly, i believe that the opinoins expressed here are not representative of all armenians. Everybody has a right to their opinions; it only becomes a problem when you impose your opinion on others or make them feel like shit for not agreeong with you. Thirdly, the odar debate is a valid one for the simple reason that this debate is also prevalen in other diaspora groups such aas italians greeks, arabs and jews. In the case of Italians and Greeks, I belive that I can speak being a person who has grown up with italians and of course being greek. We don't have so much the same preoccupation with the preservation of our ethinicity because popular culture advertizes it enough for us. When you opne a history book, you see that the egyptians, romans-italians and greeks and also arabs figure prominently. Identity isn't also a question of how you feel but how aothers perceive you. Unfortunately, armenian culture isn't as well known and I belive it is difficult to sell something which isn't as known: question of brand recongnition: example: It is easier to make someone drive a mercedes than a saab. saabs are great automobiles, yet the brand recognition isn't as good. Having studied the armenian culture and the diapora's attiude towards their culture, I belive a distinction should be made between positive cultural reinforcement and negative. Italians and Greeks have it easier because their cultural isnetity isn't based on fear. These two cultures base their pride on accomplishments and on thier respecitve contributions to western civilization. Per captipa, these two culture have contributed more in all spectres of life to modern western society that most have. It doesn't make them in any way better, just easier to feel an attachement to. Having seen mixed greek and italian couples, the children view themselves as being predominantly of these two cultures due to the fact that western civilization objectively values their contribution and hence makes it easy for those iwht these roots to feel proud. In the case of judaic and armenian cultures, what I have noticed is there is room for positive reinforcement yet for various reasons, a negative reinforcement based cultural identity is dominent amongst the diaspora. I attribute this to various factors: 1- geographical: the armenian nation has being a people in between various famous civilizations: persians, assyrians, babylians and greeks. It is difficult for a culture to grow and prosper when constantly in fear of being assmilated by these strong neighbors. 2- demographical: the dispora was traditionally spead of over various regions of Asia Minor. VEry often, armenians where not in a majority position in any of the major areas. 3- Historical: Armenia, a sovereign republic came to existence late in the game.circa 1991. If like Ialty and Greece, it would have been created in the 19th century it would be stronger today. 4- mass media: Momst even small nations have satellite tv channels which provide a mean for the diapsora to keep in touch with local events in the the homeland. Unfortunately because Armenians have been a diaspora people for a long time they don't see alink between the republic and themselves. 5- Education: Armenian language education is offered in various communities of the world. however, there is big rift between both dialects, which create a cultural rift and create a non uniform language. Mass media can correct this: it has done for hebrew (yiddish not spoken anymore) greek and italian. My point is that there are reasons why you cannot keep a culture based on negative reinforcement. The armenian diaspora for it to survive must adopt models which work: othewise you only create a pride based on guilt: got to marry and keep your culture out of guilt. I must say although that the judaic culture has been able to base its survial on keeping members strong by guilt. So maybe my logic is flawed. Yet, historically, they are the only people that have know adversity of such epic proportion: so it works, but only for them. Also, to their credit theiy have the organisational skills to make it work. I belive that communities around the world should even mimic their organisation. When I read blogs of people saying conversion to armenian, I smile. You must respect people for who they are. You are born a certain way. Out of love, a spouse might choose to let you dominate the cultural upbring of your children, but never think they can renounce who they are. Also armenians that choose to marry odars, like myslf are not traitors. I belive that these chldren from these unions shall be ambassadors of their armenian ancestory. The biggest damage that armenians have done is intermarrying. The best way to publisize the culture is by giving up some of the flock to odars to create bonds with other communities. When I fell on this forum I could not believe what I saw: armenians blasting odars. No man is an island and no culture is an island. Interraction is the key. Whetther this goes as far as intermarriage, well... this for you to decide. As a person of greek descent and dating and armenian girl, it bothers me that people who call themselves armenian, which we have helped, given them houses , citizenship, which in our poor country, we split our bread with, would see us as a threat to the survival or the ARMENIAN RACE. As a people, we shall always help armenians, because you are our brothers...and in the end, to bad if we take your women: because we respect them, and they come willingly....Love is the way...not guilt.... tigranes basileus
  4. Armenian race: or Aryan race? You earned what? p.s non puoi dire capish? รจ capisci! Ok every nation has a right to autodetermination and survival: on this I agree! Oh yeah how did you earn this??? We help armenians out of goodwill; not because we own anything to them or because they earned anything! Based on your theories of earning, how have you earned our help? We help because we want and not because we have to because we know if it wasn't for our history and the value other european odars place on it... we probably would be like.... you get the picture.... in the end...love is stronger than any race...than the armenian one...and maybe , maybe the greek one.... pari kisher
  5. Dear Hyers, I fall into the category of an ODAR like you choose to call me, being in a serious relationship with a beautiful girl, which happens to be armenian. I just recently discovered the meaning of the word odar so I find it delightful to see it being tossed around so freely. First, I must state I have the utmost respect for the armenian culture. I believe it to be beautiful, just ilke my girlfriend. I know it must piss off some of you guys to see my girlfriend in love with me and vice-versa. Quite frankly : I believe it not to be your business. If everybody kept to their own, rather than criticize others choices we would be better. Secondly, i believe that the opinoins expressed here are not representative of all armenians. Everybody has a right to their opinions; it only becomes a problem when you impose your opinion on others or make them feel like shit for not agreeong with you. Thirdly, the odar debate is a valid one for the simple reason that this debate is also prevalen in other diaspora groups such aas italians greeks, arabs and jews. In the case of Italians and Greeks, I belive that I can speak being a person who has grown up with italians and of course being greek. We don't have so much the same preoccupation with the preservation of our ethinicity because popular culture advertizes it enough for us. When you opne a history book, you see that the egyptians, romans-italians and greeks and also arabs figure prominently. Identity isn't also a question of how you feel but how aothers perceive you. Unfortunately, armenian culture isn't as well known and I belive it is difficult to sell something which isn't as known: question of brand recongnition: example: It is easier to make someone drive a mercedes than a saab. saabs are great automobiles, yet the brand recognition isn't as good. Having studied the armenian culture and the diapora's attiude towards their culture, I belive a distinction should be made between positive cultural reinforcement and negative. Italians and Greeks have it easier because their cultural isnetity isn't based on fear. These two cultures base their pride on accomplishments and on thier respecitve contributions to western civilization. Per captipa, these two culture have contributed more in all spectres of life to modern western society that most have. It doesn't make them in any way better, just easier to feel an attachement to. Having seen mixed greek and italian couples, the children view themselves as being predominantly of these two cultures due to the fact that western civilization objectively values their contribution and hence makes it easy for those iwht these roots to feel proud. In the case of judaic and armenian cultures, what I have noticed is there is room for positive reinforcement yet for various reasons, a negative reinforcement based cultural identity is dominent amongst the diaspora. I attribute this to various factors: 1- geographical: the armenian nation has being a people in between various famous civilizations: persians, assyrians, babylians and greeks. It is difficult for a culture to grow and prosper when constantly in fear of being assmilated by these strong neighbors. 2- demographical: the dispora was traditionally spead of over various regions of Asia Minor. VEry often, armenians where not in a majority position in any of the major areas. 3- Historical: Armenia, a sovereign republic came to existence late in the game.circa 1991. If like Ialty and Greece, it would have been created in the 19th century it would be stronger today. 4- mass media: Momst even small nations have satellite tv channels which provide a mean for the diapsora to keep in touch with local events in the the homeland. Unfortunately because Armenians have been a diaspora people for a long time they don't see alink between the republic and themselves. 5- Education: Armenian language education is offered in various communities of the world. however, there is big rift between both dialects, which create a cultural rift and create a non uniform language. Mass media can correct this: it has done for hebrew (yiddish not spoken anymore) greek and italian. My point is that there are reasons why you cannot keep a culture based on negative reinforcement. The armenian diaspora for it to survive must adopt models which work: othewise you only create a pride based on guilt: got to marry and keep your culture out of guilt. I must say although that the judaic culture has been able to base its survial on keeping members strong by guilt. So maybe my logic is flawed. Yet, historically, they are the only people that have know adversity of such epic proportion: so it works, but only for them. Also, to their credit theiy have the organisational skills to make it work. I belive that communities around the world should even mimic their organisation. When I read blogs of people saying conversion to armenian, I smile. You must respect people for who they are. You are born a certain way. Out of love, a spouse might choose to let you dominate the cultural upbring of your children, but never think they can renounce who they are. Also armenians that choose to marry odars, like myslf are not traitors. I belive that these chldren from these unions shall be ambassadors of their armenian ancestory. The biggest damage that armenians have done is intermarrying. The best way to publisize the culture is by giving up some of the flock to odars to create bonds with other communities. When I fell on this forum I could not believe what I saw: armenians blasting odars. No man is an island and no culture is an island. Interraction is the key. Whetther this goes as far as intermarriage, well... this for you to decide. As a person of greek descent and dating and armenian girl, it bothers me that people who call themselves armenian, which we have helped, given them houses , citizenship, which in our poor country, we split our bread with, would see us as a threat to the survival or the ARMENIAN RACE. As a people, we shall always help armenians, because you are our brothers...and in the end, to bad if we take your women: because we respect them, and they come willingly....Love is the way...not guilt.... tigranes basileus
×
×
  • Create New...